The Kulture Study: Dreamcatcher 'MAISON' MV REACTION & REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- Want to help keep the channel alive? Support us on patreon @ patreon.com/formoftherapy
Want to just make a one time donation? You can donate to the channel via PAYPAL: media@formoftherapy.com
Watch the original video here: • Dreamcatcher(드림캐쳐) 'MA...
For business & professional inquiries only:
media@formoftherapy.com
Follow us on social media @formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
#dreamcatcher #maison #드림캐쳐
The greenscreen MV was to go with the theme of the song. It was supposed to not waste any materials creating scenes, no waste, environmental free. They got their 1st and 2nd win with Maison! Thank you for the reaction!
I had not thought of that but that’s a good answer. Honestly it isn’t one of my favorite videos of theirs, but I can appreciate that thought process.
And then they dropped NFTs 😭😭🤪
@@xiaowayama4392 id rather have a good mv than fucking NFTs 😂
true it did very much help go with the saving the environment aspect of the songs concept but the MV could have been much better with all the effects and green screen quality. just looked cheap for a dreamcatcher MV. is def not there best work
@@gaara12363 fr
I'm so proud of Dreamcatcher that they won twice with Maison! 🥳
Now if only KARD could finally get a win when they comeback in the next year
@@jamesrawlins735 fighting! I can feel it coming!! It’s looking to be a great year
@@jamesrawlins735 can't wait for their comeback tbh i hope it'd be catchy and striking people's attention!
the "weirdness" of the mv is definitely noticeable, it's like one of those things where your brain knows something is a bit wrong but it can't pinpoint what. however! i don't rly care lol, it matched the vibe of the song and the mv was still very pretty
That "weird" thing you say you see but you don't know what it is. I don't know much about this but I think it's because when you use green screen and you plan to use scenarios like the ones in the MV then you have to be very careful about the light you put on people. The light and shadows in the girls must coincide with that scenario that is going to be created later. If that (and other issues) are not done well, it ends up looking weird, like out of place. That explains why the scenes that are white look better, because when there is a lot of white it seems that the light comes from everywhere so it is easier to manipulate the light, I guess.🤔 However, for me the scenes that look "weird" are very few, most of the MV looks good, my opinion. And it has scenes that are GORGEOUS 💖 Personally, whether I like a song or not doesn't depend on the MV. I'm not going to watch the MV every time I listen to the song hahaha
I replied to your comment before I finished PD's explanation 🤣 he explained perfectly 👌🏽
Usually they have really beautiful mvs like «Boca» and «Odd eye» or mvs who tell a story like «Good night» and «Chase me» so the mv for «Maison» was a bit disappointing. The CGI looked weird in some place like the devil creature Sua fighted. But there were points where it looked nice like the greek inspired area.
I honestly didn't like this MV at all, one of my least fav actually, but I'm in this journey for the music above all so I'm not really bothered by it in the slightest
This Is a reference why K-pop songs didn't need a super synth for te chorus, or a fast rap, or a dance break to be a good song.
Maison it's just a masterpiece and the album blow me away.
I’m absolutely OBSESSED with this comeback, it’s so different from what they’ve given us before but also the same Dreamcatcher sound. Congrats to the girls on getting their first with with Maison!
Dreamcatcher finally got their 1st and 2nd win on music shows with Maison 🥲
PD posted this on the 20th in Korean time, so it's been a month
I don’t need to repeat anything that’s said in the comments already about the greatness of the song itself. Can I just say THIS IS A ENVIRONMENTALIST ANTIPOLLUTION CLIMATE ENGAGING ROCK SONG LIKE???? MY HEART?????
The cgi for a reason. This new trilogy is about the environment. No real product waste
didn't they drop nfts after this 💀
@@p1ss.official they probably had no say regarding those, and its most likely their company/execs was behind that.
@@p1ss.official THEY WHAT
@@alienbanana129 yeah im not blaming them on the girls they most likely wouldn't want this
@@p1ss.official y'all act like they choose the concept and the nft things it all from the company kpop company now love nft also somnia don't like about that either we mass the company email and now dcc don't even mention and talk about that nft anymore somnia don't even involve w this and let them nft flop
I think the CG, as in the graphical elements, isn't necessarily bad; which is why it was difficult for me to pick out what didn't quite sit right with me. You voiced a lot of expertise in ways that I could "feel" but not express. I appreciate your production deep dives, because I think somehow it all registers with me even if I don't know /why/ it's good or bad.
It’s actually pronounced “MAY-ZON”, which is French for House/Home. Loved your reaction as always PD!
That's a very English pronunciation though, in French it should be closer to "meh-zon"😉
@@davidcosta5099 you're right except the n is silent for the french pronunciation😁
@@B.O.B_Sll exactly !
lol their pronounciation of it had me lol
@@sweehtie pd's or dc's ?
I'm a fan of Dreamcatcher when they are on actual set like Chase Me, Good NIght or the most recent BEcause. But I think Deja Vu would be the best example of great CG+Set. But clearly Maison wants to have big scale destruction, it make sense to go full CG.
It’s just that some scenes were absolutely incredibly made while others looked like they were copy and pasted over the background, and most of it was just lighting problems, but for a smaller company doing such a large scale project, I think they did pretty well.
Also another thing is that I feel like they were too scared to cover the member’s faces with shading i.e. Dami’s scene and Siyeon’s first scene. The direction of the lighting didn’t match the cgi so it made them look super out of place.
I'm a bit torn on the MV, as it's definitley not my favourite. I think because of the message of the song it would be really difficult to create a ruined world on such a huge scale without a green screen. I think maybe if they switched between green screen and then a real set for the choreo parts, but I don't know if the contrast would make it stand out more.
I think they only used greenscreen in order to prevent material waste. They did okay but they might have bitten more than they could chew😅 but the music is ofc as amazing as always
YEEES THAT'S WHAT I WAS WAITING FOR THE MOST. The song becomes better with every single listen and has cemented itself legendary simply for earning Dreamcatcher their first 2 wins with it!
Edit: 3:12 IF THIS ISN'T MY REACTION THEN IDK. Definitely my favourite part of the song, the way Yoo's voice kicks in after the grittier Dami section is goosebumps EVERY single time, + yes, that hair style deserves its own hall of fame.
Great seeing you here 😂😜
Been waiting for this reaction. This song really connected me finally with Dreamcatcher, I am a big rock fan and so it was weird to me that I was kind of dismissive of Dreamcatcher despite their trademark, rock sound. But after seeing this video, and even more, watching them get their first win live, I can finally say I am an Insomnia. So happy to be in this era of KPOP.
welcome to the club, I hope you enjoy the journey!
Try their Japanese tracks, they’re a lot more straightforwardly rock/metal and you might enjoy them! Don’t Light My Fire might be my favorite DC track.
@@strawberryinsomnia9188 Will do, thanks for the recommendation!
The way I see it, Dreamcatcher has always had fantastical, out of this world settings - it's actually a part of their appeal. I think even though we've seen them in so many different crazy places, like a mansion (Fly High), other dimensions (YOU AND I), wastelands (Scream), and cyberpunk facilities (Odd Eye), MAISON and the Apocalypse trilogy seemed to up this to the next level. It''s hard to set yourself in a blasted cityscape with fantasy elements without significant cost.
While I'm speculating, I think this is a combination of A)being constrained by perhaps not being able to travel to a place where there'd be more natural setpieces for an "apocalypse"/COVID-19 case surge B)saving a bit of cash/environment consciousness and C)wanting to experiment with something more. Dreamcatcher has always been an experimental group. I definitely saw some of the green-screen heavy usage this time around, but it didn't really bug me terribly much - if they were prioritizing safety, cash, and environment, doing it this way makes sense. And because Dreamcatcher has always been about a lot of unique concepts (this time around being divine/super-powered warrior-defenders of a apocalyptic planet in answer to peoples' prayers) I was able to more easily forgive any weird CGI off-putting - especially as the song is an absolute banger and the culmination of the evolution of their style.
In short, I don't mind this stuff so much so long as the song is good, the group is satisfied with the final outcome and the fandom as a whole is supportive of it, which, as we saw from it winning not once but twice, and selling the best out of all their albums yet (99k Hanteo right now), seems to be what is happening.
I cried as hard as the girls did when this brought their first win. Maison will always hold a special place for us.
DCC actually confirmed - the song IS a climate change song! Love the song, love the message -- as someone who's in no way a film expert, I agree 100% with what you were saying about the MV. when the MV started I was amazed at how good the CG background looked (with the camera angle on Jiu and Yoohyeon) but it did look obviously 2D to me in other scenes, particularly with Gahyeon and the portal scenes with Handong and Siyeon. So tldr, not my favorite music video from Dreamcatcher. I'm not opposed to CGI, but I usually prefer a combination of real sets and CG effects, like Dreamcatcher has done in the past. However, I do appreciate with how DCC is trying something new here, and I wouldn't mind if they stick to it - hopefully they can keep the criticism in mind if they do try it again next time.
Anyway thanks for the reaction PD! Can't wait to hear what you think about their full album, and glad to have you back. Hopefully you can get a ticket for their US tour...I did manage to get one but NY and LA sold out almost immediately.
oh yes, the combination of CGI and real sets could have been very good with the concept!
One of my favorite MV's in general ever cause to me personally it feels like a videogame and the song is amazing and they look STUNNING and it shows they really put money in this believing in MAISON and it payed off... MAISON will forever remaing untouchable and GodTier 🏆🏆
The dance sequence CGI surrounding part is made with XR technology...that's why the background seems wobbly coz it follows the camera movement in real time...
this whole album is keeping me full. i love dreamcatcher so much
When it came to the video and the consistency, it subconsciously had a small effect on me. I definately felt that some parts of the video felt off. But for someone who doesn't know much about this stuff, I just shrugged it off as mediocre green screen and cgi throughout the video. So it was interesting getting a breakdown, and having it explained why some parts felt off, and also that not all parts of it was like that.
Great video as always!
I feel like I'm in the rarity when I say I adored this on first listen. It's so special
Personally, when watching a video this grand, with large world created around them, I will not be bothered by details in the visual quality. Very few girl groups get to put out videos with a rich CGI background, something which must have cost a lot and is unaffordable for most, so I'm just happy to see one. On the other hand, if there are plenty simple rookie "mistakes" in an MV, or too many considering that a large budget should have ensured proper quality control, then of course it can be annoying.
When it comes to musical analysis, I'm intrigued by how groups build their tracks, but never bothered by how they choose to structure their tracks, or which part is called what according to music theory. To me music is supposed to be surprising. I don't care where verses, choruses, pre-choruses or bridges are, or if some of them are missing or replayed on a loop, as long as the final product as a whole is pleasant to listen to. I don't think less of a song if it isn't built according to some rules, if some part is not where it's "supposed" to be, or if a part is not easily identifiable as a specific section. In fact, I enjoy when song makers break the mould. Never really understood why pop music so rigidly restricts itself to one pretty defined formula.
The main thing that annoyed me with the editing and filming was literally just Dami’s scene. That is my favorite scene but it bugs me so much that all the computer screens are flashing but you don’t see the light affecting her at all. It’s one minor thing and it’s stupid to dwell on but I just wanted that scene to be perfect 😆
Dreamcatcher got their first win recently too!!
To answer your question, I definitely prefer practical sets and MVs more than green screen ones. I knew there was something that bothered me about this MV the 1st time I watched it but didn’t know what, so I’m glad you were able to point it out. I wish they filmed the entire MV in the style they did Jiu’s scene at the start!
The song is really good though! Loved the album and choreography too.
The same for me. The MV looked "off" to me, but I couldn't put my finger on it. This helps me make sense of it.
I agree with you 10000000%. They definitely "levelled up" in terms of the music, but I also wasn't a fan of the 100% green screen situation they had. I get what they were going for but I wish they actually had sets instead
I streamed this a lot when it first came out and had not listened to it since promotion stopped. Listening to it again now gave me chills. Especially Dami’s part. Sometimes it takes stepping away to really appreciate a song.
They drop MAISON with live band, amazing is perfection
i absolutely love dreamcatcher and really enjoy how theatrical their mv's are, but i prefer their sets much more. too much cg makes it hard for me to be fully immersed
I agree about the video. CGI was so noticeable that I kept imagining the group performing in a blank green room instead of wherever the video was trying to place them.
PD ur face while reacting to dreamcatcher is priceless we can tell you love the girls a lot
I definitely agree with the video being inconsistent but I am not too much bothered by it. The song is amazing and it is for sure one of the best girl group comebacks of the year.
This album is my favorite piece of work from them! Their solos are so great and full of so much personality. They all also wrote and I think composed their solo songs as well and they did an amazing job
I'm a huge DC fan and I do agree with all your points: The music itself was great but the MV was lacking. The group looks great but the green screen graphics were almost too distracting. I do like Dami's set and fits her vibe perfectly. But everything else seemed to distract in a negative way.
This song is an absolute banger!
Easily my favorite album of the year so far. And MAISON? It blows me away every time I listen to it.
You definitely have to check out the album, all the members make a solo song and it's incredible ✨🤍 (My favorite is Cherry by Jiu)
I would have never noticed those differences in the editing- but, for what it's worth, it's a lot of fun watching you explain things like that!
Oh boy I have been waiting for your reaction!! This song had me in tears at first listen:’)
Despite how much I liked the mv, I don’t think it did the outro justice. The mv for the outro was really beautiful but the transition to the outro was somehow a little off and should’ve been more jarring. But overall this comeback was absolutely stunning!!
Also, SU A’s solo is insane! Can’t wait for a listening party🙌🏼
this is what I've been waiting for! continuously checked your channel for this Maison reaction
At first I was unsure how to feel about this comeback because I was honestly so surprised about the direction they went after BEcause. But I am now obsessed with the song (and the album). The outro of the song is one of the most epic outro in all kpop. As far as the MV, I understand why they went all CGI, but I do prefer the look of their simple physical sets like from Scream and BEcause.
I loved that you explain what was going on with this video. I thought it was odd but didn't know why, thank you PD! This song is definitely incredible
YESS!!! So proud of this group!! Thank u for your reaction 🧡🙌🏻
I was waiting for Dreamcatcher reaction!!
Love the insights on the music video PD, it broadened my horizons. Now I am gonna watch MVs using heavy CGIs from a new perspective.
Also, this song SLAPS so hard!!!
I got emotional first time I watched this MV and read the lyrics. I think it's awesome they're using their platform for important messages, like "Boca" and this song for example. They're not afraid to speak their minds!!
I was also a bit confused when I first watched the video and thought it had to do with them being in a videogame or something but loved the song. THEN I realized that the song is about saving the earth and then found out the video was made that way because it was supposed not to waste anything creating practical sets and they wanted it to be environmental free.
I'm flying over from England for the gigs in New York, Louisville KY and Chicago. My first ever DC gigs, I'm so excited.
I still can't process that i saw them perform maison live with my own eyes. The girls are fantastic and deserve so much more.
Entrancing is heaven
Maison really did step it up for Dreamcatcher! While their previous comebacks were slowly garnering the girls more success and recognition, Maison just really pushed through and gave Dreamcatcher their long awaited and very well deserved first and second wins 🥳 I hope that because of what Maison was able to do for the girls that they only get more successful from here because they really do deserve it for their ✨high quality✨music as well as the time, hard work and effort that goes into it. Thanks for the reaction and review, PD!
Loved this comeback! Can’t believe it’s already been almost a full month since their first win! Well deserved and long overdue!
My fave DC mvs are Odd Eye and Boca. I definitely prefer actual sets over green screen. But this one is still pretty to me, it feels like they popped out of a comic book or video game.
At first I was really disappointed with the music video, but now I actually really like it! I usually don't like green screen that much, but the reason why they did it is nice. Also, the world is distorted so it kinda fits.
PD always killing it! Keep up the great work!!
I am beside myself with joy, watching you whoa your way through your first watch. Love you PD!
It’s super interesting about the whole “level up” thing with this song cause I felt like they leveled up last comeback with because… super interesting that that feeling is so variety among fans… *variable not variety
The more I listen to this MAISON by Dreamcatcher, the more I fall in love with it. I can't get out of it ! ❤ Thanks.
Dreamcatcher are a great group. They always bring amazing things every comeback, surprising me a lot.
PD! Welcome back! Glad you enjoyed Maison! Please also check out Starlight by Dreamcatcher from the same album! The synth is to die for!
that threw me off too. Idk what it was at first but it hit me like "ow that is it" and I can't unsee it every time.
Waiting for the listening party of this epic album!, i'll suscribe to your patreon for sure to see it!
I didn’t like the song at first, but now after listening to it again I really love it!!
"Mayson - is amazing!" Thank you, pd. Thank you. Glad we agree 😌😌
*this song is such a special song for us somnias and dc itself, so much good news has come to dc ever since they start promotions from 1st ever music show win to the 2nd, a tour, a solo songs from every members etc. plus the live band version of this is FUEGO* 🔥
It’s just so epic, I’m so happy they r getting bigger
Great content as always PD! :D
I've always listened to DC only sometimes, but became a fan after this song. The message behind it is great too - save our planet!!
The MV was product by TAIWAN's CG team called AGEcreative ,so there may be some languague barriears or something else, as a Taiwan insomina, even the CG wasn't perfect enough, I still proud of them.
it feels so special that they won with one of their heavier rock songs instead of something that tips more into the mainstream.
I don't usually comment on the videos I watch on this channel, but I really felt the need to because of how passionate you were about how this M/V was shot haha
When I first watched this, I wasn't a fan of the visuals in certain parts of the M/V as well, and I wasn't quite sure either. I really enjoyed certain parts at the beginning and then some parts felt awkward or out of place. Your observations explained my feelings perfectly because there were parts that felt dynamic and naturally beautiful, whereas other parts were clearly aesthetically beautiful, but "flat". I personally usually prefer more natural and dynamic, but I think doing green screen and CGI are fine if it really fits the song and story they're going with. However, I don't enjoy it as much when there's a clear discrepancy when both techniques are incorporated.
This is the first Dreamcatcher title song I fell in love with. It conveys the message perfectly and is very well constructed (but it still feels organic?) It's a nice release. 100% understand the 1st win. Congrats Dreamcatcher & Insomnia!
I was waiting for this reaction for so long and i clicked this video maybe i never before. They did such a great job as always and won 2 award with dope Maison. I don't know why but i feel like everyone has to know those golden people out there. Their concept is my biggest weakness, i admit.
I felt the same as you about the MV and i like the song. I wish them more success
I didn't notice any of the things you said about CG while watching the video, but I never pay attention to that so that's on me, so I don't mind. I wished you commented more on the topic of the song, that was my favourite part!
Please, PLEASE for the love of everything above and beyond do a listening party for this album, itvs god level!!
Thank you for new insight and explanation about camera thing on this video PD
For me, it's kinda an aesthetic to not have like super convincing green screen but still a clean one. It's like knowing they're in the studio with all the location.
This song makes me so sad when I read the lyrics, we need to fight for our earth:(
They probably shot the video with an idea of the CGI, and tried to make it work. Probably came down to time and the fact that nobody goes back to reshoot something in most KPOP videos (24-48 hours and done). Overall I think it works for the video, and I would say it is very good for a first try for a full green screen video from the Dreamcatcher team (they have been making amazing videos for not being one of the big three).
thank you for the insight PD! wouldn’t have even noticed about the lighting and shadows etc in the MV hahah
I mean, Dreamcatcher's company is pretty small so i'm quite happy they are putting this much effort, this complex cgi is prob expensive and difficult to do so I can see their efforts here. Also I feel like it being all cgi contributes to the values of the song about being more eco and caring for the environment
PD i was waiting for your reaction for almost a month. Thanks a lot dude. Your reactions are emotional, true , to the point and unbiased. Thanks again 🙏
Thank you so much for the explanations. Something was bothering me from the mv, and you pinpointed it. The song is so amazing so I'm very happy they got their first win with it!!!
I watched so much Corridor Crew that when you said "you know what they got right on the green screen?" I immediately said THE LIGHTING 😂😂😂
It's been 84 years, finally 😍🥰
YESSS i was waiting for PD to react to this 🙌🏼
From a visual perspective, I did notice a few things you mentioned: The distant cg Yoohyeon at the start, the almost shadowless Siyeon at the start, the flat yellow Handong in front of the portal scene, and the flat white scene with the 7 members at the end. Doesn't bother me per se, but it did catch me off guard and you can't unsee it. Because DC has done a ton of CG work before, but never once, like you mentioned, there's that much noticeable visual inconsistency.
I do personally love the more practical or even live sets (like Everglow - First), you can still ad tons of CGI to it. Pure (or a lot of) greenscreen feels a little odd to be, almost a lifeless perhaps, it's just not the same.
Dreamcatcher will be invited to perform at Primavera Sound in Spain, June, Europe's largest music festival, and the concert tour of various U.S. cities is scheduled in July. Among them, I am going to see Dreamcatcher's New York concert !
Never really noticed until you mentioned it and yeah i can see it. It doesn’t really bother me but i can see how it could be from a producing pov. The song is a bop! Great reaction as usual~
Stan DC
Finally! I have been waiting for this reaction. Prepare to be mind blown with the album!
Love your reaction :) I would love to see a album listening Party for this album, especially the Solos
I've been waiting for this for weeks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm glad they won twice with this comeback~~ They truly deserved it :)
I 100% felt that it was off to when I first watched it, you're not alone. Thank you for sharing your knowledge, it was nice to learn WHY it felt off haha. Like you said, they had a few really awesome shots that are just a step above what we're used to when it comes to DC mvs so it made the quality of the video just feel all over the place. Still an amazing comeback and an amazing album.
woouuu....wouuuu!!!! through out the reaction 🤯.!!!
its dreamcatcher!!
Usually I like the dance practice or dance-focused videos over the MVs for K-POP groups...in this case, the "Play Your Color" version of Maison is fantastic and that's usually what I watch.
This is the reaction I was waiting for. Thank you pd
pd you won't believe how good this album is 😭😭 can't wait for the listening party