Mufti Menk addresses controversy after iftar with Zionist rabbi in Dubai
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 сер 2024
- Islamic speaker and cleric Mufti Menk stoked controversy after attending an interfaith iftar in Dubai alongside Zionist rabbi Levi Duchman, who facilitated Israel’s presence in the UAE.
Menk later released a video response, saying he was misrepresented by “mischief makers”.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
![[UA] Team Vitality проти NAVI | IEM Cologne 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wttO1zVRTC0/mqdefault.jpg)
If my brother was oppressed by someone, i wont sit with them having a dinner knowing how my brother would feel about it. Why is that so hard to understand?
Man's surname is "Dušman" .In the Bosnian language its literally means THE ENEMY ..
To do this someone should have a self respect
@abc-mf8rr same meaning in urdu
Ask yourself, would our Prophet have done this while our fellow Muslims are going through what they're going through? Think about it.
Tell us, what did our Prophet did when Hamzah became a martyr?
Yes
@@Twofix Our Prophet didn't invite them to a party of course. stop defending him. Let him realize that was mistake.
@@riadulkabir2792 Mufti Menk didn't invite the rabbi to his party. He was seated next to a rabbi by the organizer. Stop being an ignorant in Ramadhan.
Which profit? The self proclaimed profit?
Instead of explaining why he was there, he just told us his feelings, what a shame...
He’s a dog nothing new. Money and fame. Religious value gone in a second
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't let try to tarnish his name. Please..
@@masterally6025With all due respect but muhammad is a lie bruh 🤧
@@masterally6025 I'm not tarnishing him, but we should forbid what is wrong and praise what is right. Allah knows best and will be the Judge to us all, may Allah guide us and forgive us, ameen.
Look up his account. He did explained it in the beginning why he was there at the first place.
Saying we are with Palestine isn't enough!! We should also practice it.
Guys the Jews were living in medina during the life of our prophet so what is wrong
@@camas9351 these are not Jews,these are Zionists. And they are totally different from Jews.
@@camas9351 He is prophet for whole human Kind. Never heard hadith where prophet had iftar or any food with people that plans to kill muslim or spent money to kill innocent muslims. You dare tell this to Palestinians they will give you best answer. Palestinians Brother and sister loosing their families houses and you talking about peace? Have you forgotten their pains blood deaths? You didn't looses a family member but Palestinians did you will never understand their pain. Do you think Allah blessed the iftar he shared with them while ummah were crying fighting for Life?
@@theend5876 brother/sister you are right 👍🏻 but sadly some muslim has no pain for another muslims😔 it sad to see muslim has forgotten sacrifices of Palestinians kids, family, money & properties 😔May Allah keep us among those who Feel pain of Muslim Ummah 🥲
Well said. Do not mislead the ummah. He doesn't know the Palestine people's hurt. It was more a talk show .
In his reply, all he did is condemn those who wrote the headlines... but he didn't actually explain WHY those headlines are false.
Exactly. He doesn't have any explanation sadly
he doesn't control the UAE group that sponsored this event- he was a guest and had no say in who would be there- now everything is being dumped on him
@@ahershey8523 he should have stood up and left...imagine sitting with enemy of Islam and those oppressing Muslims in palestine
Does he need to give an explanation to why it is false? He's an Islamic scholar for goodness sake. His job helps spread Islam even to the most difficult people and his insight is expected to be a bit better than the average Muslim. Just because a person hates Islam and Muslims doesn't mean you can't talk to them. How do you think the prophet dealt with the non Muslims who hated Islam in a way you can only imagine? Take Abu jahl for example, the prophet never gave up on him until Allah made it clear that he had no hope, the people of ta'if, even prophet Ibrahim A.S didn't give up on his father and people until his life was threatened and he was commanded by Allah to do hijra.
He is a Hypocrite end of the story.
We have no problem of him eating with a Jew or a Rabbi.
The problem here is that he sat down and ate with a Zionist.
We're not condemning the respected religion of Judaism that this man identifies with, but his political belief (Zionisim) that caused so much harm
Edit:-
This is a counter argument against those who'll claim antisemitism not a condemnation against the mufti
@@abdul-ur6vq says who? Go find out the agenda of zionism. Zionism and Judaism are two different things.
@@abdul-ur6vq So you admit that Islam is intolerant and discriminating? Shame on people who follow such a hostile ideology.
@@abdul-ur6vq Jews and Zionists are different. I have seen many Rabbis who protested against Israeli violence. Meanwhile a Zionists commands Israeli violence. So there's a pretty big difference. However, most of the Jews today are Zionists unfortunately.
@@friedrichrubinstein2346
Agreed. Such ideologies should be put down.
But it's not Islam. Islam says we should tolerate and respect one another and that we should find common grounds instead
Zionism and Judaism are separate. Zionism is a political belief backed by fanatics to justify robbing the native population of the Levant/Palestine (Jews/Christians/Druze/Muslims) of their property, livelihoods, sovereignty and rights. We can break our fast with anyone, although the recent politics of gulf states towards Israel puts into question their intentions. Not just recent above table actions today, but how long they’ve been cozy with the Zionist state oppressing Palestinians for nearly 74 years. Egypt, Jordan, Turkey, Gulf states all talk a tough game in public but have privately been undermining the Palestinians struggle for justice, sovereignty and equal rights for a long time.
''I am against oppressions but i will sit and enjoy food with oppressor''.
21st century cute scholar.
Or chicken of his wife😭🤣
Simp imam 😂
hypocritical fake scholar.
Why do judge him on his intention when you dont know what's in his heart.
@@salihmuhammad3902 this guy judged by what the so called mufti said and did
He said he is against oppression. And he also sat beside those who is one of the oppressor of our brothers and had party during iftaar
I have never heard mufti menk call Israel a terrorist, have you ?
Have you woken up for tahajjud brother? No?...does that make you a kaafir?
@@tm1541What are you going on about you clown ! What does your reply have to do with my statement on Mufti Menk !
Who said anything about kufr?? Don't beg the question. No one is calling anyone names here. The question is did he?... Taking up the public space is not an easy one. It comes with heavy duty responsibilities. Don't just do where it's easy. Be just and voice the truth without fear. @@tm1541
Mufti is Ruwejbida, fake scholar.
@@tm1541it's not relevant question.tahajad is your personal action.but other situations is relevant .we need unity .get it
It's painful to see mufti Menk sitting next to A rabbi who represents Isreal .
Our brothers and sisters are suffering in Palestine.What a shame!
The shame should be on you who think it's a shame. The prophet was bleeding profusely on the battlefield but when asked if to destroy the enemies of Islam in one moment by the angel, he said no. He still had hope and yes many of them later became Muslims. Umar R.A was an enemy of Islam also but he ended up becoming our khalifa. There's hope as long as there's life. The Muslims were told to fight the disbelievers until they gave up fighting the Muslims or even end up becoming Muslims. There were people who stopped fighting Muslims simply because they could no longer face them, not because they were convinced of Islam and they loved under the protection of Muslims for as long as they didn't wage war.
He only cares about money. Some idiots still believe in fake sheikhs who sold themselves to money and fame
Right 👍
@Chhatrapathi Aurangzeb Alamgirji maybe he is a bot. A lot of AI bots are roaming and putting out propaganda.
That rabbi is an ORTHODOX Jew Chief Rabbi of the UAE NOT a ‘Zionist chief’ for the ignorant misinformed clowns in the comment section.
He has no compassion for Gaza .. all this shows is that he only cares about filling his own stomach ! Absolutely disgusting
The guy is a dog. Money and fame made him lose his mind and his ahlak instantly . Mufti Menk is a agent who was put there to promote madkhali sect of Islam.
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes it "disgusting" ?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
Astagfirullah. Have you watched the full video uploaded by Mufti? Please do.
It’s an Iftar event by the Islamic Affairs. He was invited as a guest. He is just there to break his fast.
@@masterally6025 chill... I don't care if Mufti did ir Intentionally or not?? If he did he will be accountable for that on Judgement day...if he didn't he will be rewarded for his deeds. Its as simple as that.
The main thing to remember here don't follow any Mufti/Imam blindly
What a prodigious sellout, May Allah Ta’aala save us from munafiqun like him
As Muslims we are crying out for a true leader
Have patience my Brother. When the time comes, Allah SWT will equip a man from amongst us with the competence and he will rise as a Mahdi overnight.
Imran khan
@@thegambler808 You will reject him and hand him over to the Americans and the west willingly. You will reject every single leader until the end of time. I’ve seen it with my own eyes.
Don’t repeat the mistake of putting your faith in leaders
@@MuhammadAhmad-jv4vt Dude Imran Khan is a good man. He is nowhere near to be a leader. That dude was playboy in his early days. I take mufti over him all day
He can't be trusted.
Mufti Menk could you please talk on Palestinians oppression rather than enjoying iftar with enemies of Islam..
what about you what you done good to islam instead pointing a man who is 24 / 7 spreading Islam your comment is an recorded by Angels of Allah
Sellouts dont need to do any talks with us... Fake mufti
@@SajidAlSayed sheesh man tell him
What do you expect him to do fight him on TV so people view islam in a negative way
@@salimalkaabi9779 I wonder. I don't know what has become of Muslims these days
Yet he has the nerve to blame the media of reporting the truth but not apologizing for his wrong doings.
Everything has a price. He is just a businessman he knows exactly what he is doing he was paid to appear on behalf of the UAE Government for normalisation or whatever they call it.
May the ones with double faces continue to be exposed
I am a Muslim , and from my knowledge of Islam , we don't do injustice, we have to be just , many of us commenting don't know anything about Islamic ethics,
My mother is a Christian and she insults the holy prophet of Islam , and it hurts me more than seeing soldiers in masjid Al aqsar . now should I stop talking to my mum or kill her ?? Or should I try to preach to her , you see how senseless we have become?? You tell me 😡😡
AsSalamualeykum, brother, i want to advice you to replace these flags/banners of so-called Islamic states with the flag of real Islamic state - Afghanistan. JazakumuLlahu khair
@@radiation8174 you need to talk with your mother kindly, even if she is unfair. If she starts to insult Islam or messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, go away and let her be alone to calm down, then try to find good moments to talk with her, to help her with something halal (food cooking, washing, cleaning etc) and talk with her kindly, even if it's hard. I know it may not be easy but it is rule that Allah made for us.
@@radiation8174 copy paste
Yes the time has come for all rats to come out of their holes.
How can people be so hypocritical.? Are we to deny what we are seeing with our own eyes
When there money to be made. Everything else Ok
@@shahankhan8777Lmao
You say what is in your heart… 🙂
Ufti Menk is motivated by money and fame not Islam
££££££
He didn't even clarify why he was vibing with Zionists. All he did was give an emotional response.
He literally said he didn't know who that guy was
That's not really true. Watch his full response video he out out a few days ago.
You need to analyze his response video again. Clearly you missed the vital points.
He knew who he was @@unibawan3244
If you are with your brothers and sisters in Palestine, do not sit and share a meal with their oppressors. Instead of acknowledging your mistake then do not go on to defending it by putting the blame on others.
Funny how the Irish would have probably left that table, but our Islamic scholars sit and dine with them.
So true!! The Irish are Men of all Men. 👍🏼👍🏼
Love ❤️ from Yemen 🇾🇪
The rabbi came next to menk and not vice versa..
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus as I said the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
We don’t know muftis intentions tho he seems like a down to earth genuine person .
SOOO True 👍
I see this as a betrayal of our muslim brothers and sister in palestine. Putting our hands in the hands of the enemy? How can you ever be cool with that?
Just by attending this event and remaining silent indicates his approval of their actions whilst the Palestinians are being bombarded during their iftaar
ua-cam.com/video/Ng6jYuA2VIQ/v-deo.html
Watch Ali Dawah's video.
Mufti Menk didn't know that a pro Israeli rebbi would be there. And it's a gathering of all religious scholars. Even the Sikh guy was there.
@@omarfarique6304 yea, but I still don't know about shaking hands with the rabbi. I would at least not smile. But maybe im wrong.
@@hooman467 There is nothing wrong with shaking hands, smiling and talking with the enemies.
We have great individuals of our history they all did that such as Umar (Ra) and Hercules. Salauddin (Ra) and Richard the lionheart. Besides these 2 there are others as well.
He still isn't condemning the Israeli occupation. He must think we are muppets.
You are tryin to spread falsehood. He is not a world leader, and he is not responsibke for speaking out about every subject. He is better than millions like you.
Media has been screwing up your mind, i see.
@@duncan3998 Did media put him there with a Zionist Palestinian murderer? Have gheerah for the deen and understand what wala and bara is dunkin donuts
@@AbdisalamFarah391 where you from?
He is a media mufti paying homage to his paymasters, caught red-handed with no explanation or remorse.
No he isn’t Everyone makes mistakes and you don’t know the details of the circumstances so let’s not ..
Isn't this a great fitnah to sit together with Chief Rabbii that facilitating the existence of oppressor on your brother's land and working normalisation on it? Action speaks louder than words.
That rabbi is an Orthodox Jew Chief Rabbi of the UAE not a ‘Zionist chief’ for the ignorant misinformed clowns in the comment section.
Isn't it a great fitnah for u to say that it was "normalisation on it ?'..
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a Jew is fitnahh?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
it was an Interfaith iftar so he had no clue he was gonna be sitting with the rabbi
⚠️ *IMPORTANT PLS READ ALL* ⚠️
Anyone who writes bad things about Mufti in the comments is simply NOT a real Muslim anymore! He may have made a little mistake, but we're not even that perfect, so WORK on yourself! Only Allah alone what is in our hearts, so don't judge what you have no idea about, you are making Islam dirtier! We shouldn't develop hatred, but kindly convince ourselves that we all have flaws. So never judge, otherwise Allah will make you taste the same in the future! Our Prophet would not develop hatred but only make dua for that person! Now say: "I seek refuge from the accursed shaytan and his plans!"
For your information it was an iftar dinner organized by the Muslims not the Jews.
Moreover it was not only the jew fate that were present. So don't crucify mufti menk for being present at the dinner.
You can't stand with palestinians and sit for iftar with israelis at the same time
Why not? Is Islam so intolerant and discriminating?
@@friedrichrubinstein2346 isn't judaism suppose to be peaceful? Then what are these mini hitlers doing to Palestinians since 70yrs? You hope to hit us, and be greeted with flowers in return don't u
And you clearly don't have brains 💀@Hossain Abeer
@@friedrichrubinstein2346 what a foolish question??what do you think should we hug and kiss them ???
@@user-zv2no5og2e If you're not a bigot, yes. I'm also not hating Muslims just because 50 of the top terrorist groups in the world are Islamic fundamentalists.
If you cannot differentiate between _people_ and an _ideology_ then you're foolish.
Iftaar party while Masjid Al Aqsa is being destroyed!!
Only Allah knows his intentions, we can’t judge and say anything, may Allah Guide us to the right path Ameen
Excellent! I agree with you
Yes I Agree only Allah knows what's in the persons heart
💯 ❤️ 💯
@Anti-Degeneracy 🏳️🌈⃠ Salaam, please don't get me wrong as I mean no argument rather to try understand the wisdom. Some English police officers came to our local masjid couple of years ago, fasted the whole day and shared iftaar with us? Whether they were men of faith or not only my Allah knows what I do not. But it was surely a nice thing to see. They did this to see what it felt like to be a Muslim and what Ramadhan was all about (not just food but the fasting of the senses that Allah has bestowed us with and conduct of one's self) Allah knows best what the intention was of the sheikh and all who else that joined. If the people in my masjid were to judge the two English officers who shared iftaar with us imagine how they would have felt about Islam and Muslims? They may have reverted to Islam for all we know, and Only Allah knows best. Please correct me if I am wrong. Would this what happened in our masjid not be classed as an act of dawah, in turn making it an act of worship? If I am wrong please forgive me..
I agree with u
May allah guid us all
Menak is at the wrong side.... Sorry you are wrong very very wrong .
Keep out side at this metter .
Go to english class💀😂
@@user-ce7ez4cg6z go back to your mother
Oh wait your parentless
I don't trust him..eating one table with the enemy
@Caliph Apollo he should have known
@Caliph Apollo It's no time to defend the ones that stab us in the back ya khanzir
@Caliph Apollo preach! finally someone sensible lmao
@Caliph Apollo a “mufti” not knowing that sitting with Jews and Christians is wrong? It’s not like he was forced to go there, he could have refused but instead chose to sit with these evil people to try and bring “unity” with each other. It baffles me how people still make excuses for this sugar coating individual who waters down the religion. May Allah guide us.
@@abdul-ur6vq "is wrong" why? Why is it wrong? Is it haram?
Our brothers and sisters are dying and there you are having an iftar party. May Allah hold you accountable for it if you’re wrong. Shame on you, man! Seeing people of Palestine makes me cry and you’re having iftar party with the very people who are attacking muslims in Palestine, India and all around the world. SHAME ON YOU MUFTI, you’re definitely not a role model.
You are right brother
Munifiqhoon.. with beards.. calling themselves "muftis".. shame . Indeed we see through "fitnah" alhamdullilah
Mr menek you are wrong our brothers are killed from Israel's you are take iftar together thay are entering al aqsa mosqe and destroyed you are getting iftar with same people
We are unhappy
💯💯
If a religion does not teach you compassion and love, you must rethink... 🤔
@@london-vlog2981 fuck that kind of love and xompassion when the zionist are killing muslims on the day of ramadhan and he is eating iftar with that same zionists
@@london-vlog2981
Love and compassion with killers ?
@@london-vlog2981 aight I will come to steal ur house hope u will still love me after 👍👍
"We stand with our brothers and sisters in Palestine and with masjid Al Aqsa forever forever"
But
The question arises,
*HOW* ?
By celebrating iftar (breaking fast) with Zionist!
🥴
🤦
U think menk knew he was a Zionist. Even if he did know..
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
Hmm, he’s not the one who invited the zionist tho. He’s just a guest and as a guest you won’t know who all are going to be there.
He’s there to break his fast, not to normalize anything.
This war exposed all the hypocrites. You can say whatever you want but your deeds are clear.
You cannot break your fast in aqsa with palestanians but you will invite zionist over your place. How broad minded!!! Amazing. Salute!!!!
His explanation didn't at all sound convincing. May Allah guide him and all of us!
Allah the Exalted says "the arab is the worst in hypocrisy and disbelief"
Hey kiss u r the same women who showed support to bashar al Assad and here u r criticizing Mufti menk stfu already don't be d.khead
@@gems8167 he isnt even arab grow up kid
I totally agree. It was heavily diluted and indirect..
@@gems8167 Muhammed was arab
He didnt even say i didnt know a Zionist was there, or i regret what i did now.
Simply just attacking the people who criticized him. If this dinner was with taliban memembers he would not have attended. All the fanboy's defending him now would be like yeah hes right to not attend.
⚠️ *IMPORTANT PLS READ ALL* ⚠️
Anyone who writes bad things about Mufti in the comments is simply NOT a real Muslim anymore! He may have made a little mistake, but we're not even that perfect, so WORK on yourself! Only Allah alone what is in our hearts, so don't judge what you have no idea about, you are making Islam dirtier! We shouldn't develop hatred, but kindly convince ourselves that we all have flaws. So never judge, otherwise Allah will make you taste the same in the future! Our Prophet would not develop hatred but only make dua for that person! Now say: "I seek refuge from the accursed shaytan and his plans!"
Taliban dines with china and iran i dont know if its better
Mufti is proving that money can buy iman. He at least could have said, "I will not sit with the Rabbi."
How can u say that ?
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
@@masterally6025 ye watch your mufti eat next to zionist to which his state killed , rape children and genocide people . and please for the love of god stop with with imaginary argument if prophet muhamed was surrounded by his enemies etc.... that's why most people in islam believe in hadith more then in the quran itself . quote "media want to devide us" after the prophet people are divided then people started colonizing north african region in the name of islam
Don't say that he sold his iman. I understand many have been hurt by this, but when someone's been a quite show off already, then what do you expect? But don't question iman whatsoever.
I'm concerned for you. No hate towards you.
@@masterally6025 sitting with someone as friends who's hands are tainted with the blood of his brothers. Our rasul if were alive would have waged war against them.
@@BK-3112 ur prophet fooled u guys iman that iman this 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Here’s an example of hypocrisy.
" We stand with our brothers and sisters, but while we are doing that, we cosy up to those who slaughter them at al Aqsa". ~UAE
Having Ifthar with a Rabai is not a wrong Thing point is Ifthar with Israily zayanist rabai,Treter of palastienens state of UAE Allah may curse them.
Ameen
Ameen !
THAT'S THAT! We stand with our brothers & sisters in 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Absolutely, Allahu Akbar
🇵🇸✊🏼❤️
And brother Mufti. Allahu akbar
⚠️ *IMPORTANT PLS READ ALL* ⚠️
Anyone who writes bad things about Mufti in the comments is simply NOT a real Muslim anymore! He may have made a little mistake, but we're not even that perfect, so WORK on yourself! Only Allah alone what is in our hearts, so don't judge what you have no idea about, you are making Islam dirtier! We shouldn't develop hatred, but kindly convince ourselves that we all have flaws. So never judge, otherwise Allah will make you taste the same in the future! Our Prophet would not develop hatred but only make dua for that person! Now say: "I seek refuge from the accursed shaytan and his plans!"
Shut up he has brainwashed you not us
Ufti Menk is motivated by money and fame, not Islam
If he feels like he was in the wrong place, he would have said that in the video. You would confess that you didn’t know who that person was. And you would condemn it, rather then blame why it was over done
he was only a guest there- the UAE group that sponsored this is responsible- he had no say and now everything is being dumped on him
@@ahershey8523 He could always leave and refuse any photo op with the Rabbi. Just like George Galloway left when he was mislead to attend an event which turns out that it was a debate with Israeli students.
He did say or imply that he didn't know who they were. He implied that he was just invited to iftar.
Let's not blame each other.. forgive him and move on..
Let's not let his 30 to 40 and more years of Dawah go.down the drain because of something like this
He is a guest.
Are people actually stupid? He didn't apologise, he didn't regret the situation.
He claims he didn't know who he was...even though he sat there talking to him. I'm sure he explained who he is. If not then he certianly knew afterwards! Yet still NO apology, and no regretting the situation.
In this whole video response, he did NOT mention the name of Israel once to condemn their actions. His stance was very soft and indirect and heavily dilluted - much like the responses of western media and malala - only after they're pressurised to comment
The whole video was blagging nonsense for 90% of the time. And his defense was literally in simple terms "dude why are you getting salty? It's just an iftar with some other religions" and "people with an agenda are trying to slander and take out of context..they have evil hearts"
HE REFUTED NOTHING!
He also stated "these groups/organisations have polticial agendas". Yes..their agenda is in line with pro-palestine and anti Israel agenda. Why does this give menk a stomach ache?
These youtube milk sheikhs and social media celebs need to be cancelled. They just jump on the liberal bandwagon trying to appease everyone, even when it contradicts religion.
Also the nations sponsoring them, most notably the zionist Arab League.
Who does he have to apologize to
Indeed, his explanation seemed very watered-down and vague…Allah knows best.
@@mohamedhamdan8087 well the Palestinians would be a good start..and the Muslims in general
@@ertugrulbae46 Generally the Palestinians are not asking for a apology just hate thinking they could dictate to the Muslims ppl with no understanding of our religion Islam and ppl
Exactly we are yet to see Mr menk openly refute and reject and speak against israeli occupation and the illegitimate state
At the end of the day it's his Intention behind his actions. And the intentions and the thoughts that goes through a man's heart is only known to Allah. What we see outward doesn't have to be his intention so let's not Judge too much.. its a test for him as well as a test for us. So let's be mindful of our words , Remember our words will stand against us or with us on the day of judgement. He is not obliged to ask forgiveness to anyone of us. He is not perfect. Neither are we.
What have we done for Palestinians ? Nothing so far. We are cursing and dissing the Jews left and right. That's all we have done.
Remember our beloved prophet Muhammad swallallahu alaihi wa sallim had shown kindness and had the best manners even to his Enemies...
The words once said can never be taken back and if those words hurts someone it's going to be worst.
May Allah guide us all. Aameen
We don't care about his intentions. We judge by what is apparent as Umar ibn alKhattaab رضي اللّٰه عنه has said in the past. Menk hasn't done this sort of thing for the first time. He's been doing it and he'll keep on doing it. If you follow him blindly, then may Allah guide you ukhti. This man has betrayed the trust of his followers. Let him knit his life away.
Cursing the zionists is quite a lot of work trust me. Had no one spoke out against them, the muslims wouldn't care about our Palestinian brothers except maybe a few. Don't underestimate the power of the voice.
If you think Rasoolullah صلى اللّٰه عليه وسلّم was like him, I suggest you learn the seerah and not from the likes of Menk or Omar Suleyman but from a scholar like sheikh Uthman. When Abu Jahl came to make fun of him, he picked abu Jahl up and told him, "Know that Allah's curse is upon you." He was not a chicken like the modern compassionate imams. He was a man. His companions were men. And we need to become men.
This may be a test for him. Or a punishment. Or Allah's plan to expose him. But it definitely is a test for us. Whether we follow him blindly like sheep or dissociate ourselves from this compassionate "imam".
I wonder if you catch your husband prostrating to the Hindu gods'
And rape your mom'
Lol would you reply the same: "At the end of the day it's his intention behind his actions. And the intentions and thoughts that goes through a man's heart"
@@safwanshahriar4108 very well said Safwan ,, was searching for this sort of comment
@@safwanshahriar4108 aslam alkum. it's okay brother/sister if u don't care about his intentions ALLAH SWT Cares .
And i don't want to talk any farther we ALL want justice and peace .. and Allah SWT pleasure. let's ask Allah swt for help and guidance..
We don't need to talk about others that much .. we don't have that much time. Let's Focus in our self more. After all we all want to achieve Allah swt pleasure
It quite hard to trust Anyone these days then.. let's just relay on Allah SWT
For guidance
May ALLAH SWT forgive us all ameen. Jazakallah khair
@@safwanshahriar4108👌👌
they denied you entry and you greet them may allah have mercy on us
What most people dont realize in the comment section is that the moment mufti menk associates himself with the UAE he already is DIRECTLY linked with Israel, I dont need to say more....
Can you elaborate?
ua-cam.com/video/Ng6jYuA2VIQ/v-deo.html
Exactly 👏🏼
Exactly.People think their saints for defending these acts.If Dajjaal comes they'll also defend him
Going to a country that's openly formalising its relationship with the zionest and also a country that's helped to bomb many yamani children and women is wrong to start with!
But in the end only Allah truly knows his intentions and inshaallah this is a lesson to anyone who goes to the UAE
Regardless of whether it’s misconstrued or not YOU SHOULD NOT HAVE SIT WITH THEM FOR ANY REASON WHATSOEVER!!!
When you were offered you could kindly denied and sit by someone else!
Well. Yes you can but. Eather way. Every action we do its reflect to others what we been tough on our religion. Result to maybe some case increase the negativity of Islam in media (cuz the yahud mostly control western media) its lose-lose situation. You sit with a zionist rabbi you get Fitnah from our side, you not sit with them they gonna attack you and Islam and more damaging.
Sitting close with the rabbi wouldnt make you suddenly support their agenda. But these days media tends to dramatize something
Iftar for normalisation while Al Aqsa is being stormed. Another wahabi western puppet in disguise. Shame on the Mufti.
He could've done but unfortunately he was there representing Islam. And doing that would send a message that Islam is all about hate. And that Muslims can't co exist. Btw for 60+ years Muslims have boycotted Israel. And what did we achieve?
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
He is a human you guys act like he is not a sinner too everyone is a sinner
I always had intution tht something is fishy about this Mufti menk
He proved it today
watch his danish radio interview too. He is a sellout
@Rjdiei Irkedk summun bukmun umyun fahum laa yarjioon
@Rjdiei Irkedk yeah yeah
We can see that
Full support and everlasting love to Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
From river to the see,
Israel will be free!!!!
@@levand3673
Well , this will be reported .
@@jmikhael5200 good luck to you then!
🤣🤣😍
ua-cam.com/video/oiIsbpoN4pU/v-deo.html
You mean Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Abu Dhar said, "I was with the Prophet ﷺ one day and I heard him saing: “There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal.”
It was then that I became afraid, so I said: 'Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He ﷺ said, “Misguided and astray scholars.”
Musnad Imam Ahmad, hadith - 21334 aur 21335. Shaykh Shu'ayb al Arna'ut graded it sahih li ghayri (authentic due to corroborating narrations) in his tahqiq of the Musnad Imam Ahmad.
May Allah send you to heaven for speaking the truth. Ameen
We are watching these misguided scholars going astray these days.
absolutely brother mufti menk is a fake scholar,he will be on dajjals side . Infact i think that he is also from jewish lineage like MBS
Mufti Menk spends decades working for the ummah and Islam. One mistake and he's done.Ya'll are crzay.
Jazak ALLAH ! Brother you revealed truth, thru this hadith. May ALLAH bless you and increase your knowledge.
Liar menki 😠😠😠
Do not accuse him of a liar. Allah has warned Muslims to not spread rumors, slander, talk ill of others, or make accusations on such matter. Leave it Allah and don’t call him a liar until it is apparent and obvious of what he’s done. Jazzakallah.
SubhanAllah, I stopped following him the day, I started following Quran and sunnah. Either you follow scholars or follow the Quran and sunnah.
I have never heard him say something against the Quran or Sunnah 🤷🏼♀️
Now stop. Muslim scholars have always been a backbone for conveying the message of Islam after tabayin.. we do need scholars for proper guidance in accordance with Quran and ahadith
Agreed I unscribed him
@@farizasafeer7734 ua-cam.com/video/QTqXhV4j6pw/v-deo.html
Is this wrong? If youve never heard him say something wrong that just means you're ignorant of the basics of islam.
This is not in accordance with Islam teaching. You have to speak truth
The devil has many disguises. I would stay clear of this one.
I didn't hear the reason why he was there or why he was sat next to that chap.
Mr Menk, your words and your actions dont correspond with each other, because your deeds are very different then what you try to make people believe
Menk is more tolerant than Islam allows? I thought Islam is the most tolerant religion in the world, as the media tells us.
In a nutshell he is a Hypocrite
@@sultan111111 Bro everything we write in the comments we will be held to account for on the day of judgement, to call someone a hypocrite simply from this puts you at risk of slandering the person, there's a reason why the scholars of Islam throughout history were hesitant to call a Muslim a hypocrite even if there were multiple pieces of evidence against them. It is always best to avoid the labeling,.
@@statixfall8799 He claims he supports the Palestinian cause then he sits down and have Ifar with a Zionist Rabbi, so what do you call his act after that ? Don't Tell me Dawaa 🤨
💯
No explanation can justify this act.
Simple as that and those who are trying to give explanation on behalf of Mufti, Pls dare giving the same explanation while standing in front of your Lord on the day of judgement.
Exactly. Mufti Menk should've been well aware he was attending an event that was normalizing firm relationships between the UAE and the Zionist Occupation. If he genuinely feels the Palestinians are the victims of the government being represented by that rabbi, he would've stayed clear of that dinner.
Prophets Mohammed neighbor was a Jew. Do you hold the same view for him too. Mufti Menk was not aware of Zionist being there as it was organized by Muslim organization. Blame UAE and that specific Muslim organization. UAE and Saudi Arabia leaders are hypocrites. If he would have walked out. People would then say Muslims are intolerant. don't be Naïve. This is opportunity for Dawah
R u even a muslim?
@@zackbem926 I don't know dear if I am Muslims as per your definition or not.
But surely I have to wait till the day of judgement to know if I was Muslims in this Dunya or not as per Allah(swt) definition. I need HIS(SWT) certification bro not yours hope I have cleared your doubt.
@@irfanahmed7847 bro fear Allah before giving such analogy.
And you yourself contradicted in the first 5 line.
Mufti Menk has been engaged with these problematic things for a while now. Whether it is him attending the nikah ceremony of the son of a pro establishment puppet in Kashmir and now this. Instead of apologizing he's constantly beating around the bush. This is what's one wouldn't expect from a scholar of his stature. Seems like he's become more of a celebrity lately.
May the 19th day of Ramadan be blessed to all Muslims❤🌏
@@duncan3998 They’re talking about the 19th day of Ramadan not May 19th
Nineteen: God’s Signature in Nature and Scripture by Edip Yuksel
I'm neutral here, but let me give you guys a warning from Quran since we still do not know Mufti Menk's true intention regarding this issue
Believers, avoid making too many assumptions- some assumptions are sinful- and do not spy on one another or speak ill of people behind their backs: would any of you like to eat the flesh of your dead brother? No, you would hate it. So be mindful of God: God is ever relenting, most merciful. (Al Hujurat : 12)
actions are fruits of intentions.
If his intention was not to sit with him he would've just stood and left them
@@maksud1551
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
Thanks .. that's a good reminder
please dont dont take quran quote out of context
So somehow according to you, we are backbiting someone who clearly went against Islam multiple times while he is supposed to be more knowledgeable than all of us?. Stop misquoted quran please
This is part of the UAE's agenda to normalise religions and "Adhere to humanism" before everything. Menk, we have been observing the shift in the UAE for many years now. We know what the Ummah is dealing with.
THE NEED OF THE HOUR IS TO SOLVE OUR DIFFERENCES WITH CHRISTIANS AND JEWS, HINDUS ARE ALREADY OUR ENEMY HOW WEE WILL DEAL WITH THEM
Even the holiday thing
Uae is on the right path but the same cannot be said for Palestine….
Agenda? I don't hate anyone but what's wrong with uae being secular and peaceful is treating every religion equally Is evil in Islam ?
@@randomhuman1754 the agenda here is to please the secular and liberal masters by pushing for the idea that all religions and ways of life are equal in value, and that they moreover all lead to heaven.
This is absolutely against the teachings of Islam. Islam is the objectively superior way of life and the one and only true faith. End of story. Any "Muslims" who say that Islam is not the only true religion are going against the teachings of Islam.
Islam is not a little "cute" ideology that can be put in the same basket as pagan ideologies.
As Muslims, we must oppose any attempts at secularising our masses. We don't care whether you love or hate Islam. We shall declare our firm faith until the last heart beat.
I lost all respect for this nation and Menk as well, I am not gonna call him Mufti because he doesn't fit the role. UAE and Saudi Arabia are not Islamic countries.
Going to rich people weddings where you know their earnings are haram don't look good either mufti sahib.
In all the world, his parents had to name him DUCHMAN😂
I stand with Palestine forever!
5 seconds later, proceeds to dine with their oppressors.
Everything aside I urge people to take dead people as their role models. As we can conclude their lives, their actions, where they stood. Living man can be Corrupted any time if he's will is weak. And we don't know about his true intentions except Allah.
Exactly actions speak louder than words
"Mufti Menk" is in PR business and he knew exactly who he will be meeting, sitting next to and will be photographed with, its not just random photographs taken by UAE Govt. funded media house ... all this has a message to convey.
I feel stabbed in the back again, I know the video is 1year old but now hurts even more due to all what’s happening during the last 6 months
They denied your entry and you are breaking fast with them stand against occupation 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
exactly 💯
I cannot believe mufti even sat with him! Is he pleasing is emirati masters!
Weak apology. It’s not even sincere. You can’t even say Israel.
Allah is the best planner & He never sleep ! He is watching us ! It's ok if UAE saudi arabia even the whole arab leaders ignore the suffering of Palestinians BECAUSE ALLAH IS ENOUGH FOR US & PALESTINIANS ! #FREEPALESTINE ❤🇰🇼☝️🤲
I boycotted him long ago.
My heart never liked him even though I am close to salafi philosophy.
SHAME On them
Lying mufti .... He was paid to be there and he knew full well who would be there and why . Typical money oriented mufti .
What he did was wrong and him to justify his actions instead of apologizing is even worse
He came to KASHMIR for a nikkah of collaborative elements; people who’ve been committing atrocities against Kashmiris since forever and reason cited was “he was unaware of the political details “. Oh come on. You sit and dine w the people who are wrecking havoc upon the ummah and then justify it. That’s sad!!
U r letting the media get into u.. that's what's actually SAD
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
Exactly.Muftis whom people claim have knowledge but always claim they weren't aware when they do things like this
The day of judgement is arriving soon keep patience
I would happily befriend any religious or nonreligious people but not Zionists. Never.
*🤣 Love how they apologize like they are sorry and were clueless about who they were sitting eating with..*
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
@@masterally6025 You are a Hypocrite and so is he, when it comes to Palestine 🇵🇸 there is no middle ground.
@@masterally6025 You are one of those part time Muslims who come and open your mouth when you have no clue who he met with. Move along.
@@masterally6025 zionist bot make a better copy pasta
@@masterally6025 🥱
So basically it's "Sorry but not sorry". He could leave or at least refuse to have photo ops with the Rabbi. Body language says it all. Is he compromised, who knows. Becoming glib ie misrepresented by the media explanation and then have the audacity to turn around and blame others. He could insists on the Sikh guy by his side too. His explanation is very unconvincing. I'm giving him the side-eye. Only caught due to video/photo online. Was he paid to attend? George Galloway left an event after he was misled to attend when he found out that it was a debate with Israeli students. It's on youtube.
The four Arab nations, Egypt, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Morocco attend NEGEV Summit in Israel holding hands and smiling. A picture is worth a thousand words. I'm sorry for the Palestinians who are cannon fodder. IF anyone is holding out for the four Arabic nations to help, one can always dream and pray.
He was just a guest for God sake... It's not like they were "Yo menk here is the invitation card, there is an Israeli coming, rabbi, Sikh etc"...
Come on ?
Don't let his 30 to 40 years of Dawah go to the drain like this ...
@@masterally6025 I have never read a more defeatist comment like this before.
@@muminhanifa3392 it's better to have good assumption..
U want to take it otherwise.. suit yourself
"Defeatiest comment"
Yeah that's why u can't reply to it..
@@masterally6025 God granted him a pair of feet and vocal cords. He could fully utilize it and his explanation is so lame, whatever, whatever. I don't know nor listen to him and from what little I've seen, it seems like he let the 'fame' get to his head, more like a celebrity and no humbleness. I'm entitled to my opinion. Is he a paid or unpaid guest? Who knows and I don't know how it works in the Arab world. Just like God gives everyone brain so don't follow a person blindly or put them on a pedastal just because someone is a leader/teacher to a point it's almost cultish.
They pray to God, but have dinner with the devil. Astagfirullah
“We stand with our brothers forever but eat bread with their oppressors, the same way with stand with our Prophet by honoring his grandson’s killers”
What we need right now is a leader who preaches and fights at the same time. Like the Sahabah and the likes of Salahuddin Al Ayoubi.
Those were men! Especially the Rashidun caliphates,truly strong leaders
It was about time he showed his true colours
Don't say that after all this year's.. Please...
If the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was surrounded by his enemies 24/7 what right do u have to come and say that Mufti menk sitting next to a rabbi makes him wrong?... I urge you not to fuel the argument.. I urge u not to let the media get into u...
They want to divide us..
Just forgive him, don't let all his 30 to 40 and more years of his Dawah go down the drain because of something like this...
He was there as a guest, it's not like they be like "yo menk here is the invitation list"..plus the rabbi came to him and not vice versa.. isn't this enough?
Menk approached people all the way from Asia to Africa.when no one did .
Come on.. don't try to tarnish his name.
@@masterally6025 even if rabbi approached him he could have left but he chose to stay.. Any muslim personality which is blooming on social media will eventually show it's true colours but the good ones will always be taken down by fb youtube etc
@@TERMINATOR-92 man, u think there rabbi would have said to menk "yo I am a rabbi, nice to meet u"... Come on..
@@masterally6025 i hope it Answers your (yo) type of questions ua-cam.com/users/shortsMOTCRxTYsz4?feature=share
*Why this Mufti Menk always go to rich people’s gatherings?*
*Muslims should avoid to participate this man’s gatherings even for his bayans*
Muslim shud stick to orthodox sunnism...the four traditional madhab in fiqh ,the ashari and maturidi in aqeedah and one of tareeqa of tassawuf...stay away from modern literalist salafis wahabi
Mufti "celeb" menk is more concerned about his image and subscribers than anything
Dining with the occupiers and claiming he supports the occupied land and its peoples rights..what a joke.
Disgusting and Shameful what a traitor
Shut up with your terrorist flag
What a Hypocrite !!
comments below against Mufti Menk are not fair. this is what has caused and continues to cause division in our ummah and why we are falling behind in the world. so much hate man. it's ramadan. stop thinking bad of others esp our Scholors
💯
It is becoming increasingly difficult to give this guy the benefit of the doubt.
This time whenever you go to Palestine take your friend the Rabbi and they won't deny you entry 😉
Shame on Menk...u sold ur Iman like Arab...lots of hate from bangladesh
What you except from whabism
Real question is why are they even allowed in Dubai?
Al Jazeera shame on you for that article.
Alright, the media misrepresented the photo and situation, then what's the real story then? what could it possible be ?
exactly what I was thinking, if they "misrepresented" don't tell us how hurt you are, represent it correctly, let it be seen as justifiable if thats what you think it is.
@@haythamabdel-qader6934 the way it unfolded into attacking aljazera got me saying "here we go again, UAE swallowed him"
Arabs betrayed Palestine, but one day we Pakistanis will come , be ready israel
Pakistan betrayed Chinese Muslims. Your government is also big sellouts
Why haven’t the pakistanis fought Israel 🇮🇱 yet?
@@arilayno-moses5332 because till now we had people in power who were touts of US, but things are changing now just be patient and get prepared....Justice may be delayed but it will definitely be served
@@asadabbasi3652 who exactly are you referring to as touts of the US?
what our ummat is going through..it's high time we need imam Mahdi and we 'll show them
⚠️ *IMPORTANT PLS READ ALL* ⚠️
Anyone who writes bad things about Mufti in the comments is simply NOT a real Muslim anymore! He may have made a little mistake, but we're not even that perfect, so WORK on yourself! Only Allah alone what is in our hearts, so don't judge what you have no idea about, you are making Islam dirtier! We shouldn't develop hatred, but kindly convince ourselves that we all have flaws. So never judge, otherwise Allah will make you taste the same in the future! Our Prophet would not develop hatred but only make dua for that person! Now say: "I seek refuge from the accursed shaytan and his plans!"
@@touchheart3629 yes of course we have no hatred for our brothers, but u can't say that we r not a real muslim if we talk about his mistake, yes noone is perfect but we can't simply ignore thing we have brain we know what is right and what is wrong so we will discuss among ourselves politely so that we may stand strong with Islam without any mistake, for non muslim we still r one, but that doesn't mea we can't discuss things amoung ourselves?, If we won't object then who will correct our brothers? Yes those who r angry and showing hatred are not doing the right thing of course but u can't we won't be muslim u can't say such big words with just by tongue without any hawala my brother
In 1973 war Saiful Azam did a brilliant job of hammering the Jewish fighter pilots.