Kayla Tran Finally I find someone who has the same thought as me Since the first time I saw him, I just got surprised that he really looks like Jonghyun but what surprised me more is that not may people realized this Even in this cover, Taehyun got Jonghyun’s part WHAT A LIFE 😭
@@nikitanurazizah205 omggggg finally people who see it like me!!! Same when I first saw him I thought he resembled Jonghyun soooo much. Like he has something that looks like jonghyun im emo 😭
@@InfiniteTVXQ I get what you mean, but it isn't that they aren't acknowledging their skills, it's that they want to avoid boxing the boys in by assigning positions.
not even top 20... the least they could is sing live, but they are using LIVE AR (Live All Recorded) and it has very obviously been touched up in the studio, as evident from the mixing/pitch correction. I mean i understand they aren't a strong group vocally but they could try a bit harder...
@@triplej8666 "LOVE SCENARIO by Ikon" TXT .. search it u'll see that they're just lounging on their sofa while singing that song.. no backup voices whatsoever .. then tell me if they have no tune at all or they're voices are not superior 😂
[TRANS] 191227 WeVerse TXT Taehyun "Today I'm not posting a diary, I just came. Now that I think about it, this was this year's last performance. This year, a lot of things happened since our debut; it's fascinating how we've already completed a year. Around this time, I always ...would be watching the end-of-the-year shows while eating dinner with my family, but now I'm standing on that stage. Always, SHINee's 'Replay' that we showed today is a very special song to me. The song was what became my first hope that brought me into becoming a singer... ...and the feeling felt new. Honestly, performing covers is always pressuring, because the original song already existing is perfect as it is. This time, I was in charge of Jonghyun-sunbaenim's part and was contemplating a lot on how I would perform it. Also, I tried my best... ...to relay his feelings wholeheartedly by re-watching his videos while practicing. I also wanted to sing the song similarly, but I think it's not easy to replicate such a great singer's style and feeling. As soon as we finished today's performance, I think I spent a lot of time looking up reactions to it. Thankfully, many people watched it well, and I am happy. Also, everytime I perform on stage, for some reason, I felt the fluttering feeling and happiness along with the pressure I usually feel. I think it would be nice if MOAs could also feel the same emotions I feel whenever I'm on stage while they watched us today. Thank you for giving us a lot of support and attention this year, and in 2020, we'll return with a cooler, improved image. Everyone worked hard. Thank you"
The way Taehyun’s eyes sparkle. This song means so much to him and he’s living his dream whilst paying homage to the song and artist that inspired it. What a moment. Giving him Jonghyun’s part was an amazing idea. Well done to whoever made that decision
Taehyun wrote a letter for Taemin inside the eternity album and all of the members signed it and mc soobin is the one who gave it to taemin. SHINee's Replay is the reason why taehyun wants to become a singer. I cant take this anymore im crying so hard rn. They're the sweetes fanboys ever
@@1flash3571 That explains a lot. TXT felt fairly similar to Shinee in some songs and choreography, and I'm not even complaining. Shinee was and still is very unique and carries a unique sound. If txt were to become their successor, I wouldn't even be surprised nor disappointed. This is coming from a Shawol herself
@Zzandra kinda agree, they have equal dance and vocal skill, all of them are great. As in BTS they have RM & Jin lack in dance, RM & Suga lack in vocal.. TXT has more equal skill.. But.. BTS has much more producing and writing skill, even since their debut. That's it. BTS and TXT are perfect with their own ways.
As a Shawol I don’t typically enjoy SHINee covers because no one does their songs justice cause SHINee is just that good but TXT did a really great job! My fave replay cover for sure!
Well it does mean a lot for the guy who started the song, the one who sings Jonghyun's parts (blue and white varsity jacket). This song became his inspiration to be an artist and it's when he first heard this song that he began his journey. You can see it in his eyes that he really enjoys the performance and how much the song means to him. The other 4 did a great job but that one boy (Taehyun) was practically glowing.
As a shawol since the beginning, and thinking the first time I saw and heard Taehyun that he reminded me of Jonghyun on an extreme level. This is perfect and actually made me cry.
I'm a Shawol who has always felt that covers of Replay are generally "missing something." TXT's cover is the first time I've ever NOT thought that!! They did a fantastic job!
This song is what inspired TXT's Taehyun into wanting to become an idol. For this performance, he put a lot of effort studying their MV and stages and he tried to portay the original feelings and style of the song. He said nothing can beat the original SHINee performance or their singing, but he hoped people can appreciate this tribute. It's a very special song to Taehyun.
It's 2024 and I'm still here. They were still rookies here but they made ppl swoon over them. fast forward to tday.... tubas you've done well and you are amazing! Watch 41 winks special performance video and you'll see how much they have grown as artists.
I say thank you to that young man who sung Jonghyun's parts with such passion and soul. It really made my heart melt to hear him putting so much love into his parts. Truly wonderful. This quintet has helped add to the legacy of Replay by putting on a stage that had me engaged and wanting to see them do it without a shit camera job. TXT my hat's off to you
replay is the song that inspired him to become an idol 💕 it's wonderful to see that they truly understood the song and it's atmosphere, they seem like they enjoy it a lot.. they are truly talented and i am glad they gave this song justice! the best replay cover for me.. I really started crying when I heard it, shin5e
After Taehyun revealed that SHINee was the reason he wanted to be a singer, I think he's really happy he was able to give justice in covering his sunbae-nim's song. He's really happy for this opportunity. Years ago, he was just inspired by SHINee to be an artist. And now he's started his journey through SHINee. I'm happy to see positive feedbacks from Shawols. Thank you!
@@costarica9685 the first comment didn't even cited his name, how can you be so sure that they were talking about that. shinee has always been taehyun's favorite group and that's why they pointed his eyes were twinkling. but if you're talking about the reply, then i misunderstood
im going to say this again, this is another reason why txt is entitled as the monster rookies because no matter concept it will be, they will definitely kill it. how did they “im gonna be your oppa” last time and now to “noona you are very pretty” real quick. every cover they are making, they are killing it.
this has to be one of the most legendary and iconic cover to ever exists.. i mean wdym txt did this on their first year as rookies and they did amazingly well 🔥
Literally crying watching this. Shinee’s Replay is what got me into kpop in the first place it holds a special place in my heart. TXT did a wonderful job, and I agree Taehyun was the right choice to sing all Jonghyun’s parts. ❤
The only one i trust with jonghyuns lines is taehyun. That boy is something else. Im so excited to see where this road will take him. I really hope TXT (and shinee!) will be even more successful.
@@edddd__ i knew he liked their music, it was apparent through this beautiful, beautigil performance but I did not know he was a Shawol*.* what a perfect guy. And oh my god i have to look for that intervieewwwwwww♡♡♡
Whenever random kpop fans talk about 'TXT has no stage presence', I rewatched some of their performance videos. And still amazed me how I can enjoy all of them even when I'm already watched it a lot of time. They don't need fake swag, bold make up, and noisy songs to break the stage. The way they capture a lot of audience attention especially for non-fans, that's what I call stage presence.
Yes. They expect txt to be more into hiphop which is now too mainstream but nahh. I'm glad that they debuted in a more chill vibes which shows they are still teens and not the fake badass looks
I don’t watch group dance videos that often, but I keep rewatching them for TXT. They have so much passion and skill in their performance it amazes me.
My heart goes out for the one who covered Jonghyun’s part, his eyes lit up & reminded me of the passion & love I would see in Jonghyun 😭 thank you TXT for this cover. Honestly the best so far
He's Taehyun. Replay was the song that inspired him to be a singer so this cover was really important to him. He said he was nervous about doing Jonghyun's parts so he researched a lot to convey the emotions properly
Vatis The Skinny he’s the biggest shawol ever and he said when he saw the replay debut stage he wanted to become an idol :) he idolizes shinee so much and I love it
The fact that taehyun became a kpop idol because he was influenced by this song and performing it with his band mates this good is really amazing .. proud of my boys
Same happens with soobin😢they always show someone else when soobin or beomgyu r singing..like i noticed it often ..even these gets the most less line in their songs
Taehyun's eyes really looks like jonghyun.... I'm sorry for saying this. Jonghyun is my bias in shinee and when I'm looking at taehyun, he really have his eyes....
The world take jonghyun away from us but then the world give taehyun to us. Maybe they not the same, but taehyun remind me to jonghyun everyday. Thank you world
Thank you so much! I only checked Replay in April because Taehyun mentioned that he wanted to become an idol when he saw the song as a kid, and now I'm here loving so many songs of Shinee, they are truelly amazing and I like the members too.
Replay (Noona You're So Pretty) is such an amazingly legendary, well-deserved, well-known iconic song from one of the brightest K-pop groups that has ever existed, SHINee. TXT performed it well, following the flow of the original. Showcasing similar iconic-concept outfits to the choreography, yet giving their own unique vocals, personalities and charm of their own group with the song. Thank you so much for covering SHINee's Replay. I'm sure SHINee sunbae-nims feel absolutely proud.
@@seasawseasaw5823 I can say that one of the reasons is because MOA is not problematic. Also, the boys are versatile with their concepts. And have a nice personality, they are very respectful. And people can see their passion and talent immediately. They are not afraid of dancing GG songs too
Txt and their fandom as a whole is just very lovable in general. They're also very creative and versatile so they can pull off any concept we can think of. That's why I also love them sm
@@itsliterallyryangosling sorry but I dont think that he would be happy hearing that he is little someone. Anyway I hope you'll support him in the future too.
no offense but i think txt is one of the best groups out there in covering songs. the way they covered this made me totally nostalgic and how they covered bts's boy in luv too... i think they're a really great rookie group. y'all have to stop sleeping on them if you're still sleeping on them kkkk
*Taehyun started dreaming of being an idol after watching Shinee's "Replay"* And now he's up here performing this in front of thousands of people. The way their dreams are coming true one by one. *I know nobody's gonna replace Shinee but I see my five boys as them. Talented and hardworking angels. I am proud❤*
Ikr, at the beggining of the year, people started calling them bts or exo as all rounders, seventeen because of good dancers and what not. But Shinee is the group that reflects the most on them. Refreshing concept, five boys running towards their dream, good vocalist, good dancers. Nobody can replace Shinee but the world is always ready for little Shinee ❤
For people who want to know the member: 1. Blue jacket, Striped Tee: TAEHYUN 2. Black & blue jacket, Blue hair: YEONJUN 3. Black sweetshirt, Gray hair: BEOMGYU 4. Blue tee, Black shirt, Black hair: SOOBIN 5. Blue hoodie: HUENINGKAI TXT doesnt have any fix position, so all of them could Sing, Rap, and Dance well! (p.s. Replay is the song which made Taehyun want to be an idol) - Greetings from MOA for Shawol and everyone who enjoy this video!
Fyi Big Hit’s Bang Hyun Sik about SHINee: “As someone who produces singers, I would like to work with a group like SM’s SHINee. SHINee has not only live perfoming skills on stage but also a unique music worldview. Even though they are idols but they also don’t seem like idols Personally it’s a group I wanna work with at least once. It’s a group that shows H.O.T’s and god’s strengths. ... Look at how Ring Ding Dong became a hit for its music and dance through UA-cam.” He said this in 2010 in an interview.
As a Shawol I'm so happy right now, TXT did such a good job they reminded me of our boys' debut days. It's not everyday that shawols like a SHINee cover (the standard is way too high) but they gave the song justice and we like it! Way to go TXT!
Im not a fan of shinee, but i recently heard theyre new song dont call me, it was great. But i noticed that there were 4 members, taemin, key, onew and Minho. If you dont mind could you tell me what happened to jonghyun?🤔
The way TXT covers other groups is that they don't try to exactly be like them or copy them, but they perform it in their own style as if its their own song while at the same time they perform it to the standards of the original artist and try to give off the same nostalgic emotions the original artist gives. I don't know if that makes sense? But I personally feel like the way txt executes covers is genuinely the best I've ever seen. I've seen so many groups doing covers where they're trying to copy or be exactly like the original artist and it's just not that impressive? On top of all of that, txt is a very unique group with a unique sound and they very much resemble shinee. I have huge respect for them that they're actually doing something different and unique in this generation from most bgs and bringing in more diversity into the kpop industry. I feel like they're one of the only big company groups right now that's genuinely living up to their privilege and hype. Mad respect to txt, this performance was incredible and one that I'll never forget.
and even if they have their own style they still respect the owners of the song by not overdoing it. Many groups try to change the songs to fit their own vibe and ruin the original mood the song had. TXT perform the song with their own style but keeping the roots of the original version so it feels nostalgic, its fantastic
Honestly I’m not even a shawol but something about this just makes me so emotional. A lot of shawol in the comments were feeling very nostalgic and talked about how SHINee started out as young boys with dreams and that txt reminds them of that. I feel like years down the line MOA will watch this understand what they meant and feel the same thing.
Because of people showing their love in the comments section, I have learned the significance of this song for Shawol and the KPop community. I now have Replay in my regular rotation, and while I can never even imagine what it means for loyal Shawol, the song is now part of my journey. I'm glad TXT covered it, I'm thankful to exist in a time where a group called SHINee sang and performed it, and I'm thankful to Shawol who continue to show their love for SHINee and have shown their love for this cover
@@nominbilegt4420 ok, but that literally proves nothing. When it comes to SM, you can't even argue. We all know SM artists can sing extremely well live. So it means nothing, if they don't sing live for a few performances
The first group I’ve ever fully stanned was Shinee, most groups that cover their songs do good but never give of the same vibes that shinee had; Txt really did this song and performance justice, honestly everything was so on point that it almost felt that I could see Shinee on that stage - all 5 of them. Honestly brought tears to my eyes (call me extra).
Taehyun admittedly wrote on weverse after their performance that he had to really search shinee's performance of this to re-enact them as possible but he said that nothing can beat/ unmatched to the original. He really Respect shinee so much. This song is really special him , it made him who he is today. IT WAS THE FIRST SONG THAT MOTIVATED HIM TO BECOME AN IDOL 😭😭😭
Sorry to say, but their general vibe as a group is too cutesy to pull off this song. If you want to see a Replay cover done properly, check Astro's cover. (The one with 7M views)
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans as a 13yo shawol I think this one is the best of all Replay covers. It's been almost three years but I still come here once in a while. When I watched it for the first time I started crying mostly because of Taehyun's part. He took the best from the original performance and multiplied it by his own vision and talent, and the result is amazing. All of them did well, it's a great job, and no one has any right to say that they didn't do it properly. If you like Astro's cover more - it's your choice, but don't humiliate txt here, keep your negative thoughts for yourself and don't waste your time watching something you don't like. Have a nice day :)
I'm tearing over the fact that taehyun looks like about to cry during their entire performance huhu. You could see the passion in his eyes while singing. Our bois starting to get what they deserved through hardwork. Fighting moa's fighting txt!
TXT treated the song with utmost respect giving it the most Shinee vibe they could give. The outcome is a very honest and sincere performance making the audience feel the emotion of the song and the nostalgia it brings.
This song is very nostalgic, im shawol since senior high school, and now im 24 years old already. I never stan idol after stan shinee. But, im officially become moa since three months ago. So, when i see txt covering this song, i cant handle my tears 😭
@@Mimieiguess they did very well. Trust me. I followed shinee too since their debut. I am old too now and i am MOA rn. Trust me, they did very very well, idk very nostalgic, i was crying watching their cover
Taehyun has such a sparkle in his eyes while singing this song, he really does remind me of Jonghyun while singing this, and it’s hella emotional. No matter how many times I watch this I will never not have tears in my eyes 😭💙
I can see how much they give respect to the original ver since they did not change the original verse and have done honest with it.This is the best cover of replay so far.
I'm not a fan of any of this but I used to listen to SHINee's songs when I was younger, I'm 36 now and this boys remind me of them, strong nostalgic feeling. I see, this boys will have a big and bright future.
Thank you for saying so much good about the boys, it really means a lot since they have been getting a lot of hate about they didn't cover shinee songs well :)
When the song started playing, I started tearing up a bit (I've had a really hard time listening to SHINee and Jonghyun after his passing...) and as soon as Taehyun started singing, my heart just broke entirely at just how similar his voice sounded to Jonghyun's. He did amazing. And I'm glad he put in all the effort he did.
Taehyun looks like Leetuk to me, or a mix of Jonghyun and Leetuk. TXT Heuningkai and Taehyun have a look SM artists usually have. Even Beomgyu gives me SM vibes. BigHit put an incredibly talented group, highly recommend anyone to listen to their live performance of 20cm.
I love how they focused on precise dance like SHINee' s performance than added unnecessary cuteness. TXT and Astro's Replay covers are the only covers shawol approved
I found a tweet said that shawols rarely compliment the other groups that cover SHINee's song, and as a shawol i agree with that. But this is amazing. Thank you, TXT.
It's understandable that Shawols are very critical when it comes to groups covering SHINee. But Shawols are the sweetest when someone found their soft spots💙
[TRANS] 191227 WeVerse TXT Taehyun "Today I'm not posting a diary, I just came. Now that I think about it, this was this year's last performance. This year, a lot of things happened since our debut; it's fascinating how we've already completed a year. Around this time, I always ...would be watching the end-of-the-year shows while eating dinner with my family, but now I'm standing on that stage. Always, SHINee's 'Replay' that we showed today is a very special song to me. The song was what became my first hope that brought me into becoming a singer... ...and the feeling felt new. Honestly, performing covers is always pressuring, because the original song already existing is perfect as it is. This time, I was in charge of Jonghyun-sunbaenim's part and was contemplating a lot on how I would perform it. Also, I tried my best... ...to relay his feelings wholeheartedly by re-watching his videos while practicing. I also wanted to sing the song similarly, but I think it's not easy to replicate such a great singer's style and feeling. As soon as we finished today's performance, I think I spent a lot of time looking up reactions to it. Thankfully, many people watched it well, and I am happy. Also, everytime I perform on stage, for some reason, I felt the fluttering feeling and happiness along with the pressure I usually feel. I think it would be nice if MOAs could also feel the same emotions I feel whenever I'm on stage while they watched us today. Thank you for giving us a lot of support and attention this year, and in 2020, we'll return with a cooler, improved image. Everyone worked hard. Thank you "
not a fan of them but their version of replay is the best one ive seen so far its well executed well performed from vocals to dancing reminds me of shinee’s debut stage even the vibes clothes colour code matches that guy who covered jounghyuns part did well
eternal moonlight omg really? no wonder!! honestly tho if i had to pick only one id still choose this cover over other covers and astros cover (my ult stan group im sorry 😭 ) idk how put it into words but like you can tell when hes singing jonghyuns part he really drew my attention now im not a singing instructor but his singing like everything i thought he was really good!! when i watched it for the first time ngl i kinda teared up cause it kinda reminded me of jonghyun and their stage 😭😭😭 but wow the whole group are talented singing harmonisation dancing 🤯👍🏻👍🏻 hahahhaa i only wrote a comment and left but didn’t expect to get this many likes but at least i now know his name is taehyun
Forever MOARMY this womans is old and too busy can only stan one at a time sry hahahha but i do listen to their songs time to time hahha although i still dont know other members tho as i havent looked it up yer hahahah!! when i eventually found and watched this cover months ago i teared up cause of his singing and just looking at the whole group reminded me so much of shinees debut stage 12 yrs ago 😭 but yes i agree they are soso talented!!!
@PoppinStarjunie This amazing song was their debut song????????????????? It sounds like a classic, absolutely timeless. That makes me just more sad. I feel so bad for shawols, I can't imagine
@@lonelyvalley is just that it's literally their title, even the host of the shows they guested called them that and I thought before that I am the only who thinks that because that's what I feel but I agree that big hit artist really lives in their motto in a different kind of way...
The choreo for this song is amazing. It would have been better if the cameraman focused a bit more on the choreo as a whole rather than the member singing or in the center.
So Taemin went to Mubank yesterday to perform 'Criminal'. On backstage interview, Soobin handed Taemin a TXT's Eternity signed album which has a handwritten letter from Taehyun. That's the sweetest thing I ever witnessed on a music show stre4ming. I always recognize that somehow TXT has SHINee's vibe on them. I'm so happy for babywol Taehyun, his admiration for SHINee is real and pure
Taehyun - Jonghyun Yeonjun - Taemin Beomgyu - Minho Kai - Onew Soobin - Key Taehyun did Jonghyun proud ❤️ SHINee isn’t the same without Jonghyun, and replay was one of the best songs they ever did together. We love you Jonghyun 😔✊
Now that I look back, it's really touching that Taehyun did Jonghyun's part since from their debut people have been saying he looks/resembles Jonghyun. And when Beomgyu was young, the aunties in his neighbourhood used to say he looks like Minho!
i’ve listened to txt’s album as a casual kpop listener but as a shawol of course i was drawn to this cover. i think halfway thru the song i realized it wasn’t actually shinee but txt performing, which is to say, they did an amazing job. i don’t know if this is a thing with other shawols but this song makes me extremely emotional (especially since his passing) and seeing the amount of respect and care the txt boys put into the performance brought so much joy to me. Don’t wanna just name an specific member because to me they all put something in the performance that reminded me so much of shinee (but definite kudos to the kid doing jjong’s part, his letter was also very lovely)... and so, now i’m very excited about what txt will bring to the table in 2020. Great job boys! Keep it up!
I’m not even a shawol. But I saw SHINee for years, I had like a care for them. And when jjong passed I cried a lot, I felt rlly sad. And replay for some reason started to make me wanna cry. I’m army, and i just started to follow txt, bc they’re cute, they’re unique. And this cover made me cry a little bit too. Not just bc of the song but bc Taehyun reminded me jjong so much and I kinda feel sad now, imagine how proud jjong would be watching this Cover. 🥺🥺
Exactly!!! I didn't know I needed this for real. I haven't been able to listen to 5HINee ever since, but I've sure been listening to TXT nonstop...and Taehyun looks like Jonghyun to me sometimes so yeah - this messed me up. How they gonna perform my favorite SHINee song like this mannnn
Txt covering replay was a dream that MOAS had and is finally here. They did so well, the best cover until now. Taehyun singing Jong's part and Yeonjun doing Taemin's dance made me so emotional.
Surf Wave yessss welcome to the fandom!!! These kids work so hard, I want them to gain fans, not totally from being bts’ brother group, but for being their own group and for their passion!
Just dropping by to hype Hueningkai who did great with his vocals runs and adlibs throughout the song. He did them so well that people didn't even know it was him doing most of the runs in the songs and of course not forgetting how his vocals which were soft but strong,smooth and were just on point. Hueningkai 4th generation legend vocalist, it boy and star.
ikr, he did so well. But tbh, the camerawork for this entire show was lacking. They didn't even show Beongyu's part, it was always zoomed out. They all did amazing tho!
Came here again since kmedia reported that this was 100% live, txt is pureeeeeee vocal kingsssss I’m so so so proud, literally they’re monster rookies in 2019
![[ENG/JPN] SHINee dancing to their song from debut to now in 2024 #SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cmI8g9-u3E0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG/JPN] SHINee dancing to their song from debut to now in 2024 #SHINEE](/img/tr.png)
![[ASTRO - Replay (SHINee)] Special Stage | M COUNTDOWN 161110 EP.500](/img/n.gif)
the way taehyun’s eyes LITERALLY sparkle🥺
He really reminds me of jonghyun...made me cry to be honest
Kayla Tran Finally I find someone who has the same thought as me
Since the first time I saw him, I just got surprised that he really looks like Jonghyun but what surprised me more is that not may people realized this
Even in this cover, Taehyun got Jonghyun’s part
WHAT A LIFE 😭
@@nikitanurazizah205 omggggg finally people who see it like me!!! Same when I first saw him I thought he resembled Jonghyun soooo much. Like he has something that looks like jonghyun im emo 😭
@@saranikolinacehic615 I knoow,he looks a lot like jonghyun,those eyes...They have the same energy
He does look like him, since the first time i saw him i thought of jonghyun.
they did everything right by giving jonghyun's parts to taehyun
and it makes more sense since his face and vocal range is similar to jonghyun
He is their best and most stable vocalist and that they refuse to give him the title kinda pisses me off.
They even look alike somehow
@@InfiniteTVXQ I get what you mean, but it isn't that they aren't acknowledging their skills, it's that they want to avoid boxing the boys in by assigning positions.
@@mochmn3170 I agree, especially his voice, feel like he has same color as jonghyun's voice :'
as a Shawol i have just one thing to say : THANK YOU TXT
As a moa i have just one thing to say too :
THANK YOU FOR APPRECIATING OUR BABIES 💙
thank you for appreciating txt!
@@chickennoodlesoop0320 They were truly amazing, we, shawols, are so thankful towards them and we support them 💙💎
@@ilmanmufiydhaagustadia_1346 MOAs thank you for everything too ❤💙
5hawol VIP ❤️🙏
still one of the best covers in kpop.
Its the best
not even top 20... the least they could is sing live, but they are using LIVE AR (Live All Recorded) and it has very obviously been touched up in the studio, as evident from the mixing/pitch correction. I mean i understand they aren't a strong group vocally but they could try a bit harder...
@@triplej8666 what are u even saying
@TripleJ dude they're under bighit they definitely sing live that's what they were trained to do
@@triplej8666 "LOVE SCENARIO by Ikon" TXT .. search it u'll see that they're just lounging on their sofa while singing that song.. no backup voices whatsoever .. then tell me if they have no tune at all or they're voices are not superior 😂
The fact that txt are rookies and Shinee debut with this song feels so nostalgic. Thank you TXT. As a shawol, I really miss Shinee
Another fact Taehyun decided to be an idol because of watching SHINee's replay! So this song is very special to him
I'm sure, Jonghyun would be happy and smile seeing this. Btw, Taehyun is very similar to Jonghyun
[TRANS] 191227 WeVerse TXT Taehyun
"Today I'm not posting a diary, I just came. Now that I think about it, this was this year's last performance. This year, a lot of things happened since our debut; it's fascinating how we've already completed a year. Around this time, I always ...would be watching the end-of-the-year shows while eating dinner with my family, but now I'm standing on that stage. Always, SHINee's 'Replay' that we showed today is a very special song to me. The song was what became my first hope that brought me into becoming a singer...
...and the feeling felt new. Honestly, performing covers is always pressuring, because the original song already existing is perfect as it is. This time, I was in charge of Jonghyun-sunbaenim's part and was contemplating a lot on how I would perform it. Also, I tried my best...
...to relay his feelings wholeheartedly by re-watching his videos while practicing. I also wanted to sing the song similarly, but I think it's not easy to replicate such a great singer's style and feeling. As soon as we finished today's performance, I think I spent a lot of time looking up reactions to it. Thankfully, many people watched it well, and I am happy. Also, everytime I perform on stage, for some reason, I felt the fluttering feeling and happiness along with the pressure I usually feel. I think it would be nice if MOAs could also feel the same emotions I feel whenever I'm on stage while they watched us today. Thank you for giving us a lot of support and attention this year, and in 2020, we'll return with a cooler, improved image. Everyone worked hard. Thank you"
@@subdrama.labels9438 jonghyun is death
@@subdrama.labels9438 no he's another member from txt he only covered jonghyun's part in the song
shinee fans supporting TXT
thank youuuuuuuuuuu , I hope Shinee fans liked and got satisfied with TXT cover
Thank you 😭😭😭
Thank you from MoArmy 💜
Aww thanks ❤️ 😭
Thank u Shawols 😭
The way Taehyun’s eyes sparkle. This song means so much to him and he’s living his dream whilst paying homage to the song and artist that inspired it. What a moment.
Giving him Jonghyun’s part was an amazing idea. Well done to whoever made that decision
I think he was a shawol😂😂😂
@@lucyfilia5341 yes,l saw a news where he said he's a shawol and got inspiration from SHINee.
@@khelenadevisukham awww man that's cute😢😢
Zzandra ooft imagine calling someone a delulu for noticing someone’s love for a band. Get a hobby
@Zzandra wow you're so annoying
Taehyun’s eyes were sparkling ✨
Yes! All throughout the performance.
yeah
I am new can u tell me whos taehyun here?
@@sayedrouf6744 0:09 , 0:57 the one who sang first
@@bangtani7690 oh ok
Taehyun wrote a letter for Taemin inside the eternity album and all of the members signed it and mc soobin is the one who gave it to taemin. SHINee's Replay is the reason why taehyun wants to become a singer. I cant take this anymore im crying so hard rn. They're the sweetes fanboys ever
And the fact taehyun and jonghyun really look alike idk tho mybe it's just me
@@vansharry2164 yeh now that taehyun is blonde this cb he looks more like jonghyun
@@taehyunsbestie9153 watch everlastic shine live
There pink taehyun looks like our angel jonghyun entirely
@@Moa_deb IKR!!
Can someone please like this so it can stay in my Timeline Forever 💖 (♡ω♡ ) ~♪
Beomgyu : is singing
Cameraman : lets see what is the crowd doing
I'm not even a TXT stan and it's making me mad. They did him so dirty even in his solo part! They did Bangtan dirty as well, it's really sad.
I WAS SO MAD AT THAT 😡😡 I feel like Beomgyu is the most underrated member of txt now they covered Shawn mendes’ in my blood and he barely even sang 😭😭
It's not the cameraman's fault. Blame it on the editor
@@Studio_Rae its from live
yesss how can tho..he should be just recording them all the time bcause this is tooooooooooooooo limited cover😭😭😭i'm crying thooooo
Seeing the sparkle in Taehyun eyes when he sang jonghyun’s part brought a smile to my face he sang his part so good
😭😭😭😭
*i'm crying over the fact that they remind me of SHINee so much than any other groups that covered this song, especially Taehyun*
*ikr*
Yessss
Bang PD molded TXT from SHINee. He really liked SHINee and wanted to work with them when he was with SM.
FOR REAL I HAD GOOSEBUMPS ;-;
@@1flash3571 That explains a lot. TXT felt fairly similar to Shinee in some songs and choreography, and I'm not even complaining. Shinee was and still is very unique and carries a unique sound. If txt were to become their successor, I wouldn't even be surprised nor disappointed. This is coming from a Shawol herself
This is not just a rookie group, this is a high class group , this is rooqué
Your mind!💜
@@luzvieestrada2451 what do you mean??
@@lalthanmawiil3801 I guess he/she just made the word "rookie" spelled and pronounced with more class by being a difficult word *I assume* 😂😂
Kurage san AHAHAHAHA🤣🤣
BEOEKNXJAJANSM I CANTTSNSN
TXT just has it, to be honest. There's something about their aura that makes them stand out, just like their seniors. Monster rookies indeed.
I know right
kim sungeyon A lot of people say so but anyways stick to your opinion but don’t go around bashing people
Skyla_Rockysy a lot of people disagree.
@Zzandra kinda agree, they have equal dance and vocal skill, all of them are great. As in BTS they have RM & Jin lack in dance, RM & Suga lack in vocal.. TXT has more equal skill..
But.. BTS has much more producing and writing skill, even since their debut. That's it.
BTS and TXT are perfect with their own ways.
@Zzandra but if u compare Yeonjun to Jimin or Jhope. Nope. Jimin and Jhope still better
taehyun's voice with Jonghyun's part looks like a replay of the song since he's voice was similar to Jonghyun
Boy In Luv - Yeonjun’s audition
Replay - Taehyun’s inspiration
Edit: In My Blood - Kai’s favorite song
There is a pattern here 🤔
Don't tell me a theorie 🥴🥴
How about Beomi, Hyuka, and Soobin-ahh?
Ohhhh, interesting
Mata Hari Let us see on their future performances
Jungshook is Lifeu wait a minute can u tell me who is taehyun?
As a Shawol I don’t typically enjoy SHINee covers because no one does their songs justice cause SHINee is just that good but TXT did a really great job! My fave replay cover for sure!
Well it does mean a lot for the guy who started the song, the one who sings Jonghyun's parts (blue and white varsity jacket). This song became his inspiration to be an artist and it's when he first heard this song that he began his journey. You can see it in his eyes that he really enjoys the performance and how much the song means to him. The other 4 did a great job but that one boy (Taehyun) was practically glowing.
Thank you. SHINee is taehyun inspire also yeonjun have cover of Taemin song moves before debut too.
ASTRO AND TXT
You should watch astro's cover of replay!!
@@xins7931 TXT better than astro
i love how yeonjun tried to wink but closes both his eyes my baby
He tried 🤣
Now I just remembered the way Gavin Reed from the game Detroit: Become Human winks because whenever he tries to wink he just closes both eyes instead
i know righhtttt i love it too much
When??
mgta 1015 right at the beginning
As a shawol since the beginning, and thinking the first time I saw and heard Taehyun that he reminded me of Jonghyun on an extreme level. This is perfect and actually made me cry.
Oh yes...me too! He is like Jonghyun's younger brother!
I'm a Shawol who has always felt that covers of Replay are generally "missing something."
TXT's cover is the first time I've ever NOT thought that!! They did a fantastic job!
Thank you 😭~♡♡
This song is what inspired TXT's Taehyun into wanting to become an idol. For this performance, he put a lot of effort studying their MV and stages and he tried to portay the original feelings and style of the song. He said nothing can beat the original SHINee performance or their singing, but he hoped people can appreciate this tribute. It's a very special song to Taehyun.
Thankyouu sunbaenim🙇♂️♡
Thank you shawol sunbaenim😭😭😭
THANK YOU! ❤
They shine even with a terrible camera work...
*F* *A* *C* *T* *S*
M LC FACTS OMG YES
I agree
On a side note... OMG your pfp 🤣🤣🤣
@@scarlettearmy1200 I love it xd that was my face when I see the camerawork🙃🙃🙃
shine(e)
TxT said: we have 5 vocals, 5 rappers, 5 visuals, and 5 dance leaders.
Rapper no
But One And Only Leader Soobin
& 5 giants lmao
Periodt 😌💙😂
Kakashi Yes
It's 2024 and I'm still here. They were still rookies here but they made ppl swoon over them. fast forward to tday.... tubas you've done well and you are amazing! Watch 41 winks special performance video and you'll see how much they have grown as artists.
I say thank you to that young man who sung Jonghyun's parts with such passion and soul. It really made my heart melt to hear him putting so much love into his parts. Truly wonderful. This quintet has helped add to the legacy of Replay by putting on a stage that had me engaged and wanting to see them do it without a shit camera job. TXT my hat's off to you
The young man was taehyun and i hope you like their music💕
Taehyun is a shawol technically he's one of you guys so support them in the future plz
replay is the song that inspired him to become an idol 💕 it's wonderful to see that they truly understood the song and it's atmosphere, they seem like they enjoy it a lot.. they are truly talented and i am glad they gave this song justice! the best replay cover for me.. I really started crying when I heard it, shin5e
After Taehyun revealed that SHINee was the reason he wanted to be a singer, I think he's really happy he was able to give justice in covering his sunbae-nim's song. He's really happy for this opportunity. Years ago, he was just inspired by SHINee to be an artist. And now he's started his journey through SHINee. I'm happy to see positive feedbacks from Shawols. Thank you!
Taehyun has a really unique and powerful voice
The way Taehyun’s eyes twinkle as he sings his heart out. Bestie I’m gonna cry....
Also he is Shawol, and they giving Jonghyun line to Taehyun... Maybe this is reason why he's eye it's sparkling 😭
You dont have to cry everytime jonghyun's mentioned.
@@costarica9685 they werent saying that... bffr...
@@bordercarnival they literally wrote it..you can read English?
@@costarica9685 the first comment didn't even cited his name, how can you be so sure that they were talking about that. shinee has always been taehyun's favorite group and that's why they pointed his eyes were twinkling. but if you're talking about the reply, then i misunderstood
im going to say this again, this is another reason why txt is entitled as the monster rookies because no matter concept it will be, they will definitely kill it. how did they “im gonna be your oppa” last time and now to “noona you are very pretty” real quick. every cover they are making, they are killing it.
exactly!!!!!!!!!!!!
which shinne song is this?
And people still question why their rookies of the year smh
i agree.
ppl say ateez is better but tbh their cover on bwl is not so good.
btw txt live performance is better than bts(you can't deny it)
this has to be one of the most legendary and iconic cover to ever exists.. i mean wdym txt did this on their first year as rookies and they did amazingly well 🔥
Beomgyu is singing
Camera man : the crowd today looks good
Seriously though, the fancams that the fans recorded were better. Like I appreciate the cameramen but this was just....
ㅋㅋ ㅜㅜ
ikr, and the thing is I always notice them do this,, i really don't get it,, it's so unfair
I freaking hate it when they zoom out WAY too much especially with boemgyu like seriously?!
@Kookie _ or if it's live, I think it is the director
This comment section, this is what a real fandom should be, praising and respecting each others group..love it~
-Shawol
Love to too.have a great day. .Thankyou.lets continue to support eachother.
Love❤
Shawol is such a beautiful fandom
Shawols are great!!!
This is so true!
me who just remembered taehyun saying shinee's replay inspired him to become a singer 🥺🥺💕
flower child I felt a sense of accomplishment having been able to make the 199 likes to 200... 😁😁😁
Flower child and SeleneKlare Lee I feel a sense of accomplishment too. Being able to make this comment go from 345 likes to 346. 😌
both of you are so wholesome oh my goodness
x4
🥺🥺 and beach gave his BEST and did the ORIGINAL GROUP JUSTICE 😍😍😍
Literally crying watching this. Shinee’s Replay is what got me into kpop in the first place it holds a special place in my heart. TXT did a wonderful job, and I agree Taehyun was the right choice to sing all Jonghyun’s parts. ❤
The only one i trust with jonghyuns lines is taehyun. That boy is something else. Im so excited to see where this road will take him. I really hope TXT (and shinee!) will be even more successful.
Do you know that taehyun is a shawol ㅠㅠ he really love shinee. And last week on music bank he get to interview taemin and he was so so happyyyy
@@edddd__ i knew he liked their music, it was apparent through this beautiful, beautigil performance but I did not know he was a Shawol*.* what a perfect guy. And oh my god i have to look for that intervieewwwwwww♡♡♡
Taehyun is such a big fan of SHINee. Especially Taemin. He said that he looked up to Taemin a lot when he was a trainee ㅠㅠ
and now we had a Taehyun-Taemin selca😭💖
im now waitng for Tyun to have a selca with Key, Onew and Minho😭💖💖💖💖
I actually think Taehyun and Jonghyun kinda look alike, I think their smiles are very similar
Whenever random kpop fans talk about 'TXT has no stage presence', I rewatched some of their performance videos. And still amazed me how I can enjoy all of them even when I'm already watched it a lot of time. They don't need fake swag, bold make up, and noisy songs to break the stage.
The way they capture a lot of audience attention especially for non-fans, that's what I call stage presence.
Right😏
Yess 100%. I will screenshot this and read again when im feel bad or when my boys get hate.
Yes. They expect txt to be more into hiphop which is now too mainstream but nahh. I'm glad that they debuted in a more chill vibes which shows they are still teens and not the fake badass looks
Finally someone have said it, thank youuuuuuuuuu, we stan talents💚💙
I don’t watch group dance videos that often, but I keep rewatching them for TXT. They have so much passion and skill in their performance it amazes me.
My heart goes out for the one who covered Jonghyun’s part, his eyes lit up & reminded me of the passion & love I would see in Jonghyun 😭 thank you TXT for this cover. Honestly the best so far
Vatis The Skinny it’s Taehyun no offense he reminds me of him especially vocally
He's Taehyun. Replay was the song that inspired him to be a singer so this cover was really important to him. He said he was nervous about doing Jonghyun's parts so he researched a lot to convey the emotions properly
Your heat 😂
😭😭😭♥️
Vatis The Skinny he’s the biggest shawol ever and he said when he saw the replay debut stage he wanted to become an idol :) he idolizes shinee so much and I love it
The fact that taehyun became a kpop idol because he was influenced by this song and performing it with his band mates this good is really amazing .. proud of my boys
can we talk about beomgyu? he was killing it but the camera never caught him :(
Yeah, I hate them for treating Beomgyu like thatttt.
kfkm yess
He looks like minho here and he is channelling his energyy
Even in the Boy In Luv cover Gyu didn't have much camera time idk why they do this to him :((
Same happens with soobin😢they always show someone else when soobin or beomgyu r singing..like i noticed it often ..even these gets the most less line in their songs
Taehyun's eyes really looks like jonghyun.... I'm sorry for saying this. Jonghyun is my bias in shinee and when I'm looking at taehyun, he really have his eyes....
for me is his smile ;-;
I thought the same! Jonghyun is also my bias, this is freaking awesome!
They are both creakheats
Damn I miss our sunshine so much. More than the last few months/years
The world take jonghyun away from us but then the world give taehyun to us. Maybe they not the same, but taehyun remind me to jonghyun everyday. Thank you world
golden matnae istg yes jonghyun was my bias as well and I miss him so much, this is by far the best shinee cover ever
tbh i only clicked 'cause i saw shinee, and i was not expecting it to be THIS GOOD yall they deserve appreciation from more shawols
Thank you so much 🥺💜💜
Como Shawol y Moa, mi corazón está completamente feliz!.
Thank you so much! I only checked Replay in April because Taehyun mentioned that he wanted to become an idol when he saw the song as a kid, and now I'm here loving so many songs of Shinee, they are truelly amazing and I like the members too.
@@skarbuskreska welcome sister Shawol and Moa.
Replay (Noona You're So Pretty) is such an amazingly legendary, well-deserved, well-known iconic song from one of the brightest K-pop groups that has ever existed, SHINee. TXT performed it well, following the flow of the original. Showcasing similar iconic-concept outfits to the choreography, yet giving their own unique vocals, personalities and charm of their own group with the song. Thank you so much for covering SHINee's Replay. I'm sure SHINee sunbae-nims feel absolutely proud.
And well-respected!!
*am i the only one started crying when taehyun sang jonghyuns part of the first verse? He reminds me of jonghyun so much!! I miss jonghyun a lot :((*
We all miss him 😭❤️
Not you alone 😭❤
Me too 😭
Mee too😭❤
I can't even imagine how do you feel, but i send you a lot of love and hugs
Out of all 4th gen bgs TXT is the onyl one that is giving me SHINee vibes. Their vocals are insane. I love them so much
thank you sm! i've also noticed that a lot of gg stans like txt. like half of their fandom r literally gg stans.
@@aya-_-3045 really?
@@trishaflaviano3944 i cant say half of fandom but txt also known as gg,they hv many gg stan as a fan.that how i see..
@@seasawseasaw5823 I can say that one of the reasons is because MOA is not problematic.
Also, the boys are versatile with their concepts. And have a nice personality, they are very respectful. And people can see their passion and talent immediately. They are not afraid of dancing GG songs too
Txt and their fandom as a whole is just very lovable in general. They're also very creative and versatile so they can pull off any concept we can think of. That's why I also love them sm
Seriously no one could have done a better cover!! Did you hear Taehyun voice match Jonghyun...such beautiful!
Right! I thought he favored Jonghyun a bit too, like his appearance.
@@AlyshiaJackson He is literally little Jonghyun. He totally resembles Jonghyun and his voice is also like him
@@itsliterallyryangosling sorry but I dont think that he would be happy hearing that he is little someone. Anyway I hope you'll support him in the future too.
Check out astro they did great too
@@enzain7203 i already checked out astro ver before txt ver came out. But in my opinion, i still think txt did a greater cover and also tribute.
Taehyun - Jonghyun ❤
Huening Kai - Onew ❤
Soobin - Key ❤
Yeonjun - Taemin ❤
Beomgyu - Minho ❤
Is it just me who always felt that Taehyun looks just like Jonghyun and giving him his part was indeed the best thing that could happen.
FR I THOUGHT IM THE ONLY ONE WHO NOTICE THAT T______T
yes omg exactly what i was saying
YESSSS OMGGGGG 🥺
I cried when I heard Jim TT
Yesssss I also think so… I can see the resemblance in both visuals and voice🥺😍 I feel that TXT is just the younger version of SHINEE
no offense but i think txt is one of the best groups out there in covering songs. the way they covered this made me totally nostalgic and how they covered bts's boy in luv too... i think they're a really great rookie group. y'all have to stop sleeping on them if you're still sleeping on them kkkk
Yes, people shouldn't sleeping on them...their whole album is great n they're versatile gp.
*F A C T S*
They can perfectly perform the emotion; it’s amazing.
P R E A C H!!! 🙌
I know right even when they cover In my blood by Shawn Mendes it go me shock
*Taehyun started dreaming of being an idol after watching Shinee's "Replay"*
And now he's up here performing this in front of thousands of people. The way their dreams are coming true one by one.
*I know nobody's gonna replace Shinee but I see my five boys as them. Talented and hardworking angels. I am proud❤*
Agree they couldn't be shinee but for sometime they feeled like them ,I'm crying.... proud of txt
Ikr, at the beggining of the year, people started calling them bts or exo as all rounders, seventeen because of good dancers and what not.
But Shinee is the group that reflects the most on them. Refreshing concept, five boys running towards their dream, good vocalist, good dancers.
Nobody can replace Shinee but the world is always ready for little Shinee ❤
True😭🐿
Omg im in tears😭😭 thank you for such a kind words
Yes, you right and when i saw taehyun cover this song, i started remember Jonghyun😢
shinee x txtは最高なんよ
For people who want to know the member:
1. Blue jacket, Striped Tee: TAEHYUN
2. Black & blue jacket, Blue hair: YEONJUN
3. Black sweetshirt, Gray hair: BEOMGYU
4. Blue tee, Black shirt, Black hair: SOOBIN
5. Blue hoodie: HUENINGKAI
TXT doesnt have any fix position, so all of them could Sing, Rap, and Dance well!
(p.s. Replay is the song which made Taehyun want to be an idol)
- Greetings from MOA for Shawol and everyone who enjoy this video!
i just thinking...
what kind of human who don't know TxT in this world... wich part of world did he live in???
Fyi
Big Hit’s Bang Hyun Sik about SHINee: “As someone who produces singers, I would like to work with a group like SM’s SHINee. SHINee has not only live perfoming skills on stage but also a unique music worldview. Even though they are idols but they also don’t seem like idols Personally it’s a group I wanna work with at least once. It’s a group that shows H.O.T’s and god’s strengths. ... Look at how Ring Ding Dong became a hit for its music and dance through UA-cam.”
He said this in 2010 in an interview.
@@liyana_sadalee1662 TXT is still a new group and many people don't know them, especially individual member so please don't say anything like that
Who is the center in 1:20
@@caiocabral1228 Taehyun ♡
As a Shawol I'm so happy right now, TXT did such a good job they reminded me of our boys' debut days. It's not everyday that shawols like a SHINee cover (the standard is way too high) but they gave the song justice and we like it! Way to go TXT!
First of all thank you soo much for checking their cover!
Second of all thank you for appreciating TXT!
- From a MOA💙
namelessbae Thank you so much!
Thank you ~♡♡
Thank you so much 😢💜
namelessbae thank you 🙏
Taehyun is singing Jonghyun's part and he even looks like him... I'll cry
I thought i was the only one seeing the resemblance but apparently not!!.. :( he even sounds like him in some parts and i'm crying too!!!! :(((
@@goozieGab I thought that they look similar too
Im not a fan of shinee, but i recently heard theyre new song dont call me, it was great. But i noticed that there were 4 members, taemin, key, onew and Minho. If you dont mind could you tell me what happened to jonghyun?🤔
@@bananayo316 Jonghyun passed away December 2017
@@thehuman.glowstick Oh no... Thats sad 😢😢
The way TXT does justice to Shinee covers every time is just *chefs kiss*
The way TXT covers other groups is that they don't try to exactly be like them or copy them, but they perform it in their own style as if its their own song while at the same time they perform it to the standards of the original artist and try to give off the same nostalgic emotions the original artist gives. I don't know if that makes sense? But I personally feel like the way txt executes covers is genuinely the best I've ever seen. I've seen so many groups doing covers where they're trying to copy or be exactly like the original artist and it's just not that impressive? On top of all of that, txt is a very unique group with a unique sound and they very much resemble shinee. I have huge respect for them that they're actually doing something different and unique in this generation from most bgs and bringing in more diversity into the kpop industry. I feel like they're one of the only big company groups right now that's genuinely living up to their privilege and hype. Mad respect to txt, this performance was incredible and one that I'll never forget.
❤
and even if they have their own style they still respect the owners of the song by not overdoing it. Many groups try to change the songs to fit their own vibe and ruin the original mood the song had. TXT perform the song with their own style but keeping the roots of the original version so it feels nostalgic, its fantastic
Thank u so much for this comments!
@@lookatthat2438 THIS!!
I love this.. it gave me chills omg
This is probably the most wholesome and pure comment section under a kpop video, I’m so happy 😭💗💗💗
Omg same💛💙💛💙💛
Both fandoms are so sweet. Its beautiful
Annie the Army both fandoms are just vibing 🤙
Taehyun did jonghyun’s part perfect and I want to cry. Taehyun’s voice is a little similar to jonghyuns In this song. TXT did amazing
Michelle Hawkins I know he did amazing... I have seen the future of Kpop through them, I feel it...
Taehyun looks like jonghyun
Kusta he really does! Jonghyun was and still is my bias in shinee and when txt came out I fell for taehyun
there was no better time for them to have done this cover ❤️ I'm glad it exists
Honestly I’m not even a shawol but something about this just makes me so emotional. A lot of shawol in the comments were feeling very nostalgic and talked about how SHINee started out as young boys with dreams and that txt reminds them of that. I feel like years down the line MOA will watch this understand what they meant and feel the same thing.
i feel the same thing aaaaaaaa
Yessss omggg
Because of people showing their love in the comments section, I have learned the significance of this song for Shawol and the KPop community. I now have Replay in my regular rotation, and while I can never even imagine what it means for loyal Shawol, the song is now part of my journey. I'm glad TXT covered it, I'm thankful to exist in a time where a group called SHINee sang and performed it, and I'm thankful to Shawol who continue to show their love for SHINee and have shown their love for this cover
Same I started crying reading all these comments.
Sameee
I just knew the "Noona" would definitely come from Taehyun first.
Lol
Taehyun has a noona agenda 😂
Knowing that TXT is one of the few groups who actually sing live makes me even prouder. Thanks to PANN for showing the truth.
Ikr kingssssss
what happened?
@@rainbaew9891 op revealed who sings live and lip sync and txt and bts were singing live and almost most sm artists were lip syncing
@@nominbilegt4420 ok, but that literally proves nothing. When it comes to SM, you can't even argue. We all know SM artists can sing extremely well live. So it means nothing, if they don't sing live for a few performances
@@hoodiehoodie5328 i never said they cant sing why are u mad i was just stating facts that they lipsync
Still the best cover by a 4th gen even after years me thinks
Exactly 🔥🔥
The first group I’ve ever fully stanned was Shinee, most groups that cover their songs do good but never give of the same vibes that shinee had; Txt really did this song and performance justice, honestly everything was so on point that it almost felt that I could see Shinee on that stage - all 5 of them. Honestly brought tears to my eyes (call me extra).
you stan SHINee? social media please!
Y'all still stan SHINee and I thought everyone forgot them😭😭😭😭
Fatima Fathi girl you can never forget the kings🥺
i really want to like your comment but it already has 666 likes and i don’t want to ruin this 👉👈
@@babyshawol1764 No honey,we still remember them 🙂💖
Taehyun admittedly wrote on weverse after their performance that he had to really search shinee's performance of this to re-enact them as possible but he said that nothing can beat/ unmatched to the original. He really Respect shinee so much. This song is really special him , it made him who he is today. IT WAS THE FIRST SONG THAT MOTIVATED HIM TO BECOME AN IDOL 😭😭😭
wow king
Sorry to say, but their general vibe as a group is too cutesy to pull off this song. If you want to see a Replay cover done properly, check Astro's cover. (The one with 7M views)
@@StreamHypeBoyByNewJeans as a 13yo shawol I think this one is the best of all Replay covers. It's been almost three years but I still come here once in a while. When I watched it for the first time I started crying mostly because of Taehyun's part. He took the best from the original performance and multiplied it by his own vision and talent, and the result is amazing. All of them did well, it's a great job, and no one has any right to say that they didn't do it properly. If you like Astro's cover more - it's your choice, but don't humiliate txt here, keep your negative thoughts for yourself and don't waste your time watching something you don't like.
Have a nice day :)
King shi fr
Honestly bawling right now! The really did that!!! Taehyun pulled off our jonghyun so well :) I’m absolutely in love ❤😭😭
I'm tearing over the fact that taehyun looks like about to cry during their entire performance huhu. You could see the passion in his eyes while singing. Our bois starting to get what they deserved through hardwork. Fighting moa's fighting txt!
His sparkling eyes actually 1:25
Best cover of Replay EVER! What a wonderful tribute to Shinee!!
Not gonna lie something about this makes me wanna cry as a shawol, they did a really good job :)
Kate V. Thank you 🙏
Same..... it brings back memoriessㅠㅡㅠ
Your very right 😔👊
me too 😔
TXT treated the song with utmost respect giving it the most Shinee vibe they could give. The outcome is a very honest and sincere performance making the audience feel the emotion of the song and the nostalgia it brings.
This song is very nostalgic, im shawol since senior high school, and now im 24 years old already. I never stan idol after stan shinee. But, im officially become moa since three months ago. So, when i see txt covering this song, i cant handle my tears 😭
I'm not a fan of shinee but may i ask if they nailed it ? 😌
@@Mimieiguess they did very well. Trust me. I followed shinee too since their debut. I am old too now and i am MOA rn. Trust me, they did very very well, idk very nostalgic, i was crying watching their cover
Yess me too, im crying right now, i remember about 5hinee
@@Mimieiguess ofc, makes me turn back to replay era 😭
I'm not a shawol but thank you for stanning shinee and thank you for becoming a MOA
Taehyun has such a sparkle in his eyes while singing this song, he really does remind me of Jonghyun while singing this, and it’s hella emotional. No matter how many times I watch this I will never not have tears in my eyes 😭💙
I thought he was going to cry 😭
I was crying so badly!🥺....
I can see how much they give respect to the original ver since they did not change the original verse and have done honest with it.This is the best cover of replay so far.
what get me is how taehyun wrote a letter on weverse about how meaningful this performance and doing jonghyun’s part was to him 🥺 he’s really a shawol
I'm not a fan of any of this but I used to listen to SHINee's songs when I was younger, I'm 36 now and this boys remind me of them, strong nostalgic feeling. I see, this boys will have a big and bright future.
Me too!!! Haha They reminded me of shinee rookie days!
Hopefully!! Thanks for wishing the best for them!
Thank you for saying so much good about the boys, it really means a lot since they have been getting a lot of hate about they didn't cover shinee songs well :)
It sends chills how the fans of prince of k-pop say that, it's so beautiful I can feel collywobbles inside.
@@uzma648 Who and Where everyone seems to be impressed on every video?
Taehyun not only resembles Jonghyun with his voice but also his visuals.
little thingy it got me sentimental because I miss jongie and taehyun reminded me of him
I know right? The first time I heard his voice I thought it reminded me of someone else's and know that you mentioned it I can really see it!
When the song started playing, I started tearing up a bit (I've had a really hard time listening to SHINee and Jonghyun after his passing...) and as soon as Taehyun started singing, my heart just broke entirely at just how similar his voice sounded to Jonghyun's. He did amazing. And I'm glad he put in all the effort he did.
Taehyun looks like Leetuk to me, or a mix of Jonghyun and Leetuk. TXT Heuningkai and Taehyun have a look SM artists usually have. Even Beomgyu gives me SM vibes. BigHit put an incredibly talented group, highly recommend anyone to listen to their live performance of 20cm.
True :”)
That little vocal battle between Yeonjun, Taehyun and Huening is euphoric 👌🏽👌🏽✨
Jonghyun - Taehyun
Onew - Kai
Key - Soobin
Taemin - Yeonjun
Minho - Beomgyu
I'm sobbing
omg Minho is my bias and Key is my bias wrecker and Beomgyu is my bias and Soobin is my bias wrecker 😂
This is comment i looking for 😂 i was shawol since shinee's debut, i really love key. Now i know soobin ❤
Yeonjun (aka my bias) got taemin(also my bias)
@@Deeznutz4624 me too
I love how they focused on precise dance like SHINee' s performance than added unnecessary cuteness. TXT and Astro's Replay covers are the only covers shawol approved
I AGREE 100%
I found a tweet said that shawols rarely compliment the other groups that cover SHINee's song, and as a shawol i agree with that. But this is amazing. Thank you, TXT.
Thank you so much for appreciate it🌷🌷🌷
No need to thanks. They deserve to be appreciated ^^
THANK YOU!!!!!!!
Omg thank you 😭
It's understandable that Shawols are very critical when it comes to groups covering SHINee. But Shawols are the sweetest when someone found their soft spots💙
crying everytime I see Taehyun doing Jonghyun's lines, he looks so much like him
jonghyun would be smiling and giggling while flailing his hands like crazy for them :)
damnit joon this comment made me cry 😭💔
umh this comment make me cry a little bit... i miss him so much, I hope he’s happy and good now 💙
Dang you got me tearing up
Others were crying seeing your comment, but I'm smiling so wide because I really can imagine that
he's doing that wherever he is, i'm sure💜
[TRANS] 191227 WeVerse TXT Taehyun
"Today I'm not posting a diary, I just came. Now that I think about it, this was this year's last performance. This year, a lot of things happened since our debut; it's fascinating how we've already completed a year. Around this time, I always ...would be watching the end-of-the-year shows while eating dinner with my family, but now I'm standing on that stage. Always, SHINee's 'Replay' that we showed today is a very special song to me. The song was what became my first hope that brought me into becoming a singer...
...and the feeling felt new. Honestly, performing covers is always pressuring, because the original song already existing is perfect as it is. This time, I was in charge of Jonghyun-sunbaenim's part and was contemplating a lot on how I would perform it. Also, I tried my best...
...to relay his feelings wholeheartedly by re-watching his videos while practicing. I also wanted to sing the song similarly, but I think it's not easy to replicate such a great singer's style and feeling. As soon as we finished today's performance, I think I spent a lot of time looking up reactions to it. Thankfully, many people watched it well, and I am happy. Also, everytime I perform on stage, for some reason, I felt the fluttering feeling and happiness along with the pressure I usually feel. I think it would be nice if MOAs could also feel the same emotions I feel whenever I'm on stage while they watched us today. Thank you for giving us a lot of support and attention this year, and in 2020, we'll return with a cooler, improved image. Everyone worked hard. Thank you "
nooo, he is such a sweet boy, you did great baby
He is so sweet amd passionate about singing. He deserves the world
I'm sobbing
Oh no... he's so sweet and respectful :( He's such a mature young man. I love him so much and I wish him the best in life.
Oh my god he’s such a sweetheart, he did so well😭🖤
not a fan of them but their version of replay is the best one ive seen so far its well executed well performed from vocals to dancing reminds me of shinee’s debut stage even the vibes clothes colour code matches that guy who covered jounghyuns part did well
He's taehyun, a big shinee fan. Replay inspired him to be a singer
I would only say Stan TXT ( Tomorrow × Together ) .
They are a bunch of perfect guys in a group 💜💜💜
eternal moonlight omg really? no wonder!! honestly tho if i had to pick only one id still choose this cover over other covers and astros cover (my ult stan group im sorry 😭 ) idk how put it into words but like you can tell when hes singing jonghyuns part he really drew my attention now im not a singing instructor but his singing like everything i thought he was really good!! when i watched it for the first time ngl i kinda teared up cause it kinda reminded me of jonghyun and their stage 😭😭😭 but wow the whole group are talented singing harmonisation dancing 🤯👍🏻👍🏻 hahahhaa i only wrote a comment and left but didn’t expect to get this many likes but at least i now know his name is taehyun
Forever MOARMY this womans is old and too busy can only stan one at a time sry hahahha but i do listen to their songs time to time hahha although i still dont know other members tho as i havent looked it up yer hahahah!! when i eventually found and watched this cover months ago i teared up cause of his singing and just looking at the whole group reminded me so much of shinees debut stage 12 yrs ago 😭 but yes i agree they are soso talented!!!
Angel Alisa yes. he is only 18 y/o and he has great vocals. 4th gen main vocalist indeed. stan taehyun❤️
As a Shawol , I don't even have words to describe how I feel. But TXT did amazing. It was as if I was watching SHINee in their debut era
i'm happy cuz txt give a justice covering this song "replay" by shinee and many shawols are approving it.
Omg i laughing so hard to your profile picture 😂😂😂
EYO HITMAN BANG WHAT DO U THINK OF TXT'S PERFORMANCE 👁👄👁
Comments made me nostalgic
Ur dp made me😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ayoo! hitman bang introduces
Astro and TXT best covers of replay by SHINee
This type of music genre really fits their voices omfg, never heard this song but it sounds beautiful omg
One of those iconic kpop song. You could hear the scream when audience recognised the music.
I'm shocked that you havent heard it before, it's iconic for kpop
PoppinStarjunie omg that’s why i found the song familiar :0 freakin childhood man
@PoppinStarjunie This amazing song was their debut song????????????????? It sounds like a classic, absolutely timeless. That makes me just more sad. I feel so bad for shawols, I can't imagine
I kinda want them to cover perfect man or i like it. Maybe coffee too.
I think it might suit their voices.
That's why TXT's title is "the healing idols"
Alpha Grace 🥺🥺🥺
:(
Actually all artists under BigHit are called “healing idols” but yes I agree, txt really did justice to replay
reminds me of bighit's intro ''music & artist for healing'' the truest words
@@lonelyvalley is just that it's literally their title, even the host of the shows they guested called them that and I thought before that I am the only who thinks that because that's what I feel but I agree that big hit artist really lives in their motto in a different kind of way...
4 years later and I still wish for them to at least release a studio version of this for us to listen to TT
The fact that taehyun reminds me of jonghyun, this hurts but warms my heart at the same time 😭♥️
Eva Gomez just looking at taehyun u can see jonghyun😫
Michelle Hawkins and the fact that he’s singing jonghyuns lines😭 I miss shinee
Eva Gomez Finally I find people starting to recognize that Taehyun is similar to Jonghyun
oh thank god I thought it was just me
Eva Gomez 😭😭❤️
TXT: has five members
Cameraman: oh, I only know Yeonjun and Taehyun
The choreo for this song is amazing. It would have been better if the cameraman focused a bit more on the choreo as a whole rather than the member singing or in the center.
ig the cameraman has their own bias and bias wrecker haha ._.;;
@@suntae2501 actually kai has a lot of lines as well but they zoom out
It’s not the cameraman it’s the editor of the video the cameraman recorded and then the editor edits the video
@@chaewonlvr8405 thats true
As I Shawol who has SHINee as her Utt I can say that this is one of the, if not the, best Replay cover ever
Thank you so much for this! I love Shinee too but TXT is my Ult now and I'm just happy to get Shawol approval for these boys!
So Taemin went to Mubank yesterday to perform 'Criminal'. On backstage interview, Soobin handed Taemin a TXT's Eternity signed album which has a handwritten letter from Taehyun. That's the sweetest thing I ever witnessed on a music show stre4ming. I always recognize that somehow TXT has SHINee's vibe on them. I'm so happy for babywol Taehyun, his admiration for SHINee is real and pure
Since SHINee is Taehyun's inspiration, I became emotional and so I cried
@Hanamaru Stan true!😁
and now, taehyun met taemin aaaaa
_THIS IS WHY TXT DESERVES THE ROOKIE OF THE YEAR_
UP
No doubt
I absolutely agree, it really showed how talented they are
a lot of groups deserved roty they were all amazing
Taehyun - Jonghyun
Yeonjun - Taemin
Beomgyu - Minho
Kai - Onew
Soobin - Key
Taehyun did Jonghyun proud ❤️ SHINee isn’t the same without Jonghyun, and replay was one of the best songs they ever did together. We love you Jonghyun 😔✊
You're the comment I've been looking for
but shinee still has jonghyun shinee is still five
Now that I look back, it's really touching that Taehyun did Jonghyun's part since from their debut people have been saying he looks/resembles Jonghyun. And when Beomgyu was young, the aunties in his neighbourhood used to say he looks like Minho!
It bothers me that Taehyun was Jonghyun
@@lisbethguerraalbujar9464 why tf does it bother you??
1:25 his eyes 🥺 taehyun decided to be a idol after see taemin in replay we can see the respect and admiration in his eyes
i’ve listened to txt’s album as a casual kpop listener but as a shawol of course i was drawn to this cover. i think halfway thru the song i realized it wasn’t actually shinee but txt performing, which is to say, they did an amazing job. i don’t know if this is a thing with other shawols but this song makes me extremely emotional (especially since his passing) and seeing the amount of respect and care the txt boys put into the performance brought so much joy to me. Don’t wanna just name an specific member because to me they all put something in the performance that reminded me so much of shinee (but definite kudos to the kid doing jjong’s part, his letter was also very lovely)... and so, now i’m very excited about what txt will bring to the table in 2020.
Great job boys! Keep it up!
I’m not even a shawol. But I saw SHINee for years, I had like a care for them. And when jjong passed I cried a lot, I felt rlly sad. And replay for some reason started to make me wanna cry.
I’m army, and i just started to follow txt, bc they’re cute, they’re unique. And this cover made me cry a little bit too. Not just bc of the song but bc Taehyun reminded me jjong so much and I kinda feel sad now, imagine how proud jjong would be watching this Cover. 🥺🥺
Gu
I’m a shawol since Shinee’s debut.. watching TXT as a group of 5-members covering replay is so emotional
Exactly!!! I didn't know I needed this for real. I haven't been able to listen to 5HINee ever since, but I've sure been listening to TXT nonstop...and Taehyun looks like Jonghyun to me sometimes so yeah - this messed me up. How they gonna perform my favorite SHINee song like this mannnn
Ikr 😭, I also see Taehyun the same way as you.
@@suraangel6956 Taehyun really remind me of Jonghyun 😭
@@pikachusenpai2585 Yeah :( I tried not to notice it..
can’t believe they covered such an iconic song the taste really came through
YES 😄👌
When Taehyun started to belt out Jonghyun’s part, it’s so emotional because we missed him.
Txt covering replay was a dream that MOAS had and is finally here. They did so well, the best cover until now. Taehyun singing Jong's part and Yeonjun doing Taemin's dance made me so emotional.
I wasn't a TXT fan before but seeing them put their heart and soul into performing Shinee's legendary Replay makes me STAN them. ❤❤❤
This cover definitely made me noticed this young group. Hope all the best for them.
Welcome
Welcome to the MOA (Moments Of Alwaysness) fandom!!
WELCOME NEW MOA
Surf Wave yessss welcome to the fandom!!! These kids work so hard, I want them to gain fans, not totally from being bts’ brother group, but for being their own group and for their passion!
Just dropping by to hype Hueningkai who did great with his vocals runs and adlibs throughout the song. He did them so well that people didn't even know it was him doing most of the runs in the songs and of course not forgetting how his vocals which were soft but strong,smooth and were just on point.
Hueningkai 4th generation legend vocalist, it boy and star.
jo kim Kai’s vocal is no joke his harmonization is sooo good
😍😍😍😍 yas of course Hueningkaiii our one of the most promising artist in the future 🔥💖
i was about to comment that sis.
time stamps for hyuka's adlibs:
1:40
1:54-1:57
1:59
2:01
2:08
2:11
2:18
2:27
2:30
2:34
ikr, he did so well. But tbh, the camerawork for this entire show was lacking. They didn't even show Beongyu's part, it was always zoomed out. They all did amazing tho!
Thank you for answering my questions. I was tryna figure out who's doing onew's jonghyun's runs and adlibs. It was def same person.
honestly txt reminds me sm of shinee i had no idea this cover existed
Came here again since kmedia reported that this was 100% live, txt is pureeeeeee vocal kingsssss I’m so so so proud, literally they’re monster rookies in 2019
Ikr they are something else!!!!!!
100% live means there's no backup vocals? Wow
@@santaclaus8848 I think they had it, but also there's a bit of autotune going on, so it's a bit hard to catch it at 100%
@Albadr 7 hchcht
can you share the link? is it on pann?
Taehyun’s eyes are sparkling so bright, he looks so happy omgg he’s cute