A response to those who follow Mufti Menk blindly - Homosexuality and other issues
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 вер 2024
- If you are not gonna watch the video please don't comment. Attack the argument and bring your proof. Both brothers were grilled and both failed. May Allah guide them.
I'm addressing him in public because he addresses everyone and this interview of his was public.
I remember when Robert Mugabe ( ex president of Zimbabwe) laughed out loud in response to being banned from entering Europe. He said " how does that affect me? I have no relatives in Europe, it could only hurt if they could keep me away from Africa "
Rip Mugabe.
???
😂😂😂😂 that's a joke,
I love your energy👑🖤⚡
Respect for Gabriel Al Romaani for speaking the Truth
Majority of the lecturers are scared to speak out aganist Mufti Menk
A true believer never compromises when it comes to his deen.
And we are to learn the deen to acc. To manhaj Salaf.
Indeed well said
Absolutely correct
Respect For Gabriel Al Romaani for speaking the Truth
Majority of the Lecturers are scared to speak out aganist Mufti Menk
@Dark Horse Taliban were made with American.
I’ve just finished reading the Quran and I agree why you man.
One day I will accept Islam and take shahada. I’m not quite ready yet.
May Allah guide you
Let's go Brendon!
You can take your time bro May Allah make it easy for you and lead you to the Islam very soon. Ameen
You can take shahada in your heart for now if you're not ready to publically announce it. You just have to believe in your heart that there's no God but Allah, and Muhammad PBUH is His messenger.
Don't say one day I will do this and that; because that day may never come. You can perish from disease a natural disaster or a day to day calamity like an accident etc. Not saying that you should take shahada right now, but if even after reading quran and doing research you are still not convinced, perhaps something more is at play here.
Hello brother Brandon, I’m glad Allah has guided you, but if I were you-Id take my Shahadha immediately. You can take your time learning the religion, but try to revert to Islam immediately.
"And never will the Jews or the Christians approve of you until you follow their religion" (2:120)
So how do you apply this ayah to this topic?
Relax Maggie. No doubt I'd love it if the Muslim world became Christian, but if you're honest with yourself you would equally love it if the Christian world became Muslim. No need to be divisive sister.
@@santanav.4504 Well that's simply because we believe what is the Truth to us. This verse is simply telling us that we should not compromise our religion for the approval and happiness of other people.
@@themercifulguard3971 I have no issues with that. Either way, this is a debate among Muslims. I only responded because she referenced an ayah that mentioned Jews and Christians. And although I'm not Muslim, I love Mufti Menk.
True! Like people living around Hazrat Lut (A.S) didn't approved and accepted him (A.S) until he (A.S) separated from them.
..never be apologetic for what is in accordance with Quran..simple as it is..
Yeah, I learned a valuable lesson today Alhamdulillah
Dnt accept or oblige to wrong if its not permissible in ISLAAM
Mashallah may Allah guide you and guide me inshallah
@@abdinasirwato7656 you should say amin with a dua brother since your asking Allah for something its something like oh Allah answer. In Sha Allah is if Allah wills it like I go to the store if Allah wills it
Where in the Quran/Sunna does it teach us to publicly air broadcasting someone's faults? Sorry but Al-Romani all those who follow this course of action in publicly broadcasting are only following the dictates and protocols of western media practices. I challenge Al-Romani to make a 57 minute video about his only faults and then post it on social media.
I have been following Mufti Menk for the last 20 years. I've heard him quote from the Quran. He opposes homo sexuality clearly. He has inspired me to be a better person. May Allah continue blessing him with goodness.
Brother Gabriel, I think you should have contacted him directly to clarify instead of jumping on social media.
People will stand up to defend “popular personalities” but will not stand up and defend Islam. Such a shame.
illiteracy is on its peak
May ALLAH give us hidayah
100% true ☝🏽🤲🏽❤
@@hannah7346 Aameen ☝🏽🤲🏽❤
People need to stop broadcast others faults publicly without first broadcasting their own faults publicly.
@@Ibrahim-metahari1968 It is a must to expose those who share Islam not according to the sunnah. muft menk has a deobandi background. We don't mock or criticize anyone, we just expose and warn people just like the sahaba and tabe'een did.
Mufti menk was cancelled from Oxford and other universities for saying homosexuality is wrong. I have also heard him speak out against other sins like adultery, lying, waste, gambling, and intoxicants. I don’t think he is really guiding people down the wrong path. I have learned a lot of valuable things from him on how to approach touchy topics with a peaceful demeanor. That being said, no one is perfect. All imams and sheikhs and muftis are human. They are not angels and they are not prophets and they are not God sbt. None of them should be followed blindly. And you can still disagree with one or some statements said by a scholar or mufti or sheikh but still really gain knowledge on other topics. One doesn’t discount the other.
I agree, have never heard Mufti Menk say or do something that goes against the Quran & Sunnah. He teaches us in a very simple way, even made many non-muslims revert to Islam. So I don’t get what this guy here is on about tbh…..
Yeah but for people who are new or ignorant about Islam. This type of preacher is dangerous because they don't know what's wrong and right.
Okay, but you did see this one interview of Mufti Menk, which is problematic right? The statement brother Gabriel had problem with? Yes Mufti had preached many positive things in Islam and guided many people into Islam. Doesn't mean that people can't question or criticize him when he says things that contradictory to Islam
I completely agree. He has done more good than harm, and we should show the same level of mercy that we show on a non-Muslim to our Muslim brothers.
Very good cmnt Masha Allah 👍👍
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ! May Allah guide us and protect our religion . Ameen !!!
Hey Sister, I just want to.i let you know because I was recently made aware but, as women it is haram for us to post pictures on social media even in hijab. I'm not trying to push but, you can check Islamqa and there are other references. I how this is helpful.
Asalamu Alaikum.
Majority of women love mufti menk.
@@HMD1986- I like him. But I'm not subscribed.
@@HabrenOdinsdottir
I didn’t know him very good . Used to listen to him and did Subscribe. Step by step I knew him and unsubscribed him . He 24/7 talks about women right and pushing feminism among Muslims women. As daee your job is inviting people to توحید . Not just make feminist. Homosexuals. Christians . Jews . Atheist… happy. He is CELEBRITY DAEE
@@HMD1986- I will not speak bad of him for I don't not know but, again I am not subscribed any longer.
Being Muslim is about following the Quran and Sunnah and not about personalities...No one is perfect in this Duniya....READ QURAN EVERYDAY AND NEVER IGNORE YOUR FIVE DAILY PRAYERS 🇵🇸WORSHIP THE CREATOR ALLAH AND NOT HIS CREATION JESUS PBUH 🇵🇸ALLAH CREATED JESUS PBUH 🇵🇸
Assalaam alaykoem warhmatullaah
The only perfect One is The Only One and that is our Creator
I Respect Gabriel Al Romaani for speaking the Truth
Majority of the lecturers are scared to speak out aganist Mufti Menk
The only one we can follow blindness is out profeth mohammed sallalahu alayhu wa salaam
Allah says in the Quran: “0 you who believe! stand out firmly for Justice as witnesses to Allah-- Q u r a n 4 :1 3 5
We Don't even stand up to those preachers who contradict the Quran & Hadith 😠
We Don't even defend the Quran & Hadith 😠
We Do defend preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith -- Astaghfirullah 😠
@Pork eating crusader The Sad Truth ---> The Bible Exposes Christianity 🤦♂️🤣🤣🤣
🔻No one can see God ( 1 John 4:20 - John 5:37 )
( Which proves Jesus can't be God because people have seen him )
🔻For there is ➡️ one God ⬅️ and there is one mediator between God & Men, the ➡️ man ⬅️ Christ Jesus, ( 1 Timothy 2:5 )
( This proves Jesus isa man. not God )
🔻Jesus said, “Hear, o Israel : The Lord our God is one. ( Mark 12 : 29 - 31 )
( Jesus compared himself with the people by saying our God is one )
🔻Jesus said why do you call me good ? ”No one is good except God alone
( Luke 18 : 19 )
( This proves Jesus made it clear he is not good & only God is Good )
🔻The bible makes it clear God is not a man ( Numbers 23 : 19 )
( Why do the Christians say Jesus is God and human )
🔻Jesus, said, “Hear, o Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord Is 0ne ( Mark 12 : 29 - 31)
( Why do the Christians say Jesus & God are both Gods )
🔻Jesus said to the people I am ascending to my Father & your Father, to my God & your God.” ( John 2O : 17 )
( Jesus Compared himself with the people by saying my God and your God.”)
🔻But of that day and that hour knoweth no man, not the angels which are in heaven, neither the son, but the Father ( Mark 13:32 )
( The fact that Jesus does not know the future proves he is not God )
🔻Fellow Israelites, listen to this :Jesus of Nazareth ➡️ a man ⬅️ accredited by God to you by miracles, wonders and signs, which God did among you through him, as you yourselves know. ( Acts 2:22 )
( Christians it does not say Jesus of Nazareth was ➡️ a God ⬅️ accredited by God )
🔻Jesus cried out in a loud voice, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
( Matthew 27 : 46 )
( If Jesus is God why is he begging God to save him from getting killed by a Jew )
*I love this video:*
“The Prophets were sent to societies that were against them. The Prophets did not teach tolerance and acceptance. They taught that those people are wrong and they need to change.”
Beautiful quote.
Haq
100% fact in its context.
When it comes to rulings that are open to interpretation. Then Prophets taught tolerance.
Opposition to Laws That are established.. there is NO tolerance.
There is a balance.
Islam teaches the good and tolerance of good and rejecting bad. Balanced.
Atheism build no civilization. Feminism wants to break civilization by family. They came after central banks to switch from farm to debtors imprisonment.
My God! What a shame are people like you for our religion.
It's a lesson NOT to follow anyone blindly in field of religion Deen aqeedah
I only follow the Quran that’s about it. That’s the truth you need as soon as people start making their own ways and teachings making big $$$ that’s all a load of ***ap, they use Islam for their own needs.
We live in time of fitnah , may Allah guide us to the right path .
Ameen
Ameen
Ameen
Aamiin... ya... Robbal alamin...
Ameen. This is Fitnah .. Mashallah why are u not speaking to him.. DIRECTLY..WHAT HAPPENED TO BEING HUMBLE & PRIVATE WITH ISSUES . DONT LET THE KHUFAR SEE US GOING AGAINST EACH OTHER. IM IN THE USA 🇺🇸.. THIS LOOKS BAD FOR ALL ☪️ MUSLIMS..
I watched this after the alidawah video and now I understand what Mufti Menk is doing. Alhamdullilah, I am not a blind follower of Mufti Menk. At the end of the day, Prophet Muhammad (SAW) will always be our greatest role model. Baraakallahu feek!
ua-cam.com/channels/vBmEy8FCNtVwLm2RgbCBuw.html
Which video is this ..
What is he exactly doing?
lool your a blindfollower ahahhahahaha
@@safiullahnoori8675 I'm not a blind follower of Mufti Menk. Did you even read my comment?
When someone is misleading the ummah, especially when they are sitting on such a seat with influence, no matter who they are, we all have a responsibility to speak up against what they say. Alhamdulillah you have the courage to do it.
😂that's the wrong way to do it...we have hadab in our religion. First he has to do was to call him privately and have his views or thought on the concerned matter but he didn't do that but came out to stylishly bash. That's not acceptable way to correct. Peace!
@Tunde. I will not go to this extreme to call Mufti Menk misleading Ummah. He is not misleading Muslims. He is practicing "Live and let Live". He is following the prophet's command of moving with wisdom
@@tundeganiyu3319 first of all you have no clue if he messaged him privately first. second of all this is something mufti said in public and should be refuted in public to make it clear for everyone and for them to not deviate
@@ShowBizJunkie I don't think the last part is true akhi. Mufti Menk is good overall, but we need to be very careful of being to leinnat on the lgbt movement. I'm sure the Mufti is an excellent person, a great Muslim, and an inspiring speaker. I also have no doubt that his reason for being nice to the lgbt is to try to win them over. However, some people don't see it that way. They think then it's okay or something. I know that's not what the Mufti intends most likely, but it's what some people think.
@@rami5466 That's true
Nothing in this world is harder than speaking the truth. MashaAllah, brother Gab keeping it authentic and real. HafidhakaAllah
Agree
@@khoyrulalam8274 Agree
These videos cause nothing but confusion and miss understanding.
I would much prefer if u had a direct conversation with mufti menk rather than addressing it to the laymen
He literally addressed this issue in the video 46:26
Mufti Menk has clearly opposed homosexuals multiple times, you’re clearly just ranting.
And he also has shown sympathy towards them
One who wants to be blind, no one can show them way
I am born and raised in Denmark. This country is an extremely Islam-hating country, and their politicians and media are constantly picking on muslims. They literally made a hate-preacher list of so many common and neutral imams and ulamah on the basis of very minor and misunderstood comments from them. SubehanAllah. I remembered when they interviewed Mufti Menk. He was obviously caught off-guard and gave into his fear to protect his image for Western people. Very sad, he should have stood his ground as he could care less about these ignorant haters. May Allah protect and guide us.
"He was obviously caught off-guard and gave into his fear to protect his image for Western people. Very sad, he should have stood his ground as he could care less about these ignorant haters".= and exactly what did you do when faced with a similar situation?😉
Then your parents should have picked another country to migrate to. The imperialism thing doesnt make any sense. There are wealthy gulf nations you could go to
@@ottopotatum5775dont assume when you dont know his conditions
Hearing those interviews really pains my heart. Brother Gabriel, keep fighting the good fight and spearing the word of truth. May Allah preserve and protect you, and all of the unapologetic ad'iyaa Aameen.
I gotta admit that I’m binge watching brother Gabriel’s channel like a Netflix show so I’m a year late on this but it’s astonishing how indirect and hesitant they were with their answers. This is stuff they taught us in Islamic school in my early years. It’s clear cut. I don’t see what’s there to ponder about. I’m glad that we have someone speaking out on this. It’s like a breathe of fresh air and honestly it’s because of this channel I’ve been trying to get closer to the deen again. I’m religious but not really practising as I should be. May Allah guide us all.
I think I am starting to understand where your coming from. It's not that mufti is fully wrong, it's that his overtolerant peaceful way of teaching the deen forces him to blur the lines and let people walk all over him. Instead of giving straight direct answers they give apologetic neutral ones with parts of the deen cutout.
I never trusted that dude.
@@manoflegacy6738 so what you're saying it's okay to appease the non-believers by changing the religion to suit their desires? No way!
@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 I dont think mufti menk changed something in the religion, if so please provide some evidence
@@bluelightmoon777 sugarcoating the religion which he does and avoiding certain topics which he does are subtle signs of dishonesty. However my comment was in reference to Man of Legacy insinuations, not Mufti Menk per se. We have to remember a lot of Menk's followers are fanatics who like to put words in his mouth and misrepresent him, especially on social media posts.
@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 i get it we dont live in a fairy tale world where everything is peace and love its quite the opposite imo. So certain rules have to be followed for us muslims and some of these rules may sound harsh but they actually protect us no need to sugercoat things
I came here from the knitting video. I don't understand how knitting is considered feminine and I stand my ground about that, that video was absolutely unnecessary. However, you're absolutely right about him flip-flopping during that interview, he was trying to be clever by not saying "controversial" things. However, assuming that he's doing it for a visa is wrong, we have no right to assume that without any clear evidence. The first time I'm hearing Mufti Menk say things I disagree with. Thanks for the clear-up. God bless.
@Sabir you should talk respectfully to your fellow Muslim. Especially in these times when the Muslim ummah is being attacked by the non Muslims (Palestine) be kind and patient with others even if you want to guide someone you must have proper manners.
females are better than males at knitting on average (not only knitting but also all the crafty works)... Wanna run a research about that?he considered knitting feminine from this ground...that doesn’t mean knitting is haram for males....but mufti menk's approach was to normalize the reversal of gender role or it least his fans interpreted it in that way....it wasn't about proving knitting feminine or masculine.... See the bigger picture
It's sad and dangerous that those individuals have a huge following whereas brothers like Gabriel who are on haqq relatively don't. This simply reflects on the condition of the entire Ummah.
“liars will be taken as truthful and truthful honest beings will be taken as liars” that’s a sign in the Hadith of qiyama
You claim to be true Muslim brotherhood ,why would you want to go in public for the heaters to laughing at and enjoying mucking about Islam .he is your brother in faith , this is bad to be in public saying things about people , their are other options to communicate with him privately , this is the last thing a Muslim should be doing in public our beloved prophet never do those things you disgrace some one in public . you claim to be knowledgable than others then do the right things, (The world is watching shame on you ,it is backbiting ) only Allah knows what you knows not let Almighty Allah be the judge . Everything happens for a reason so please stop do what you are doing please and thank you jazamukalakir.
Use one eye to see your own fault , and the other eye to see atum good of others , remember how much falt you have done and don't want any one to know . Mankind has no ability to judge others with out salide enquiry from the person in self .
@@bibiansoralli5934 if someone says something wrong in public as an Imam about the Deen, they MUST be corrected publicly. If you don’t agree with that statement, you are lacking in knowledge.
Do not compromise, brother Gabriel! May Allah reward you tremendously for standing up to preachers of falsehood and weakness.
Ameen
Ameen
Allah says in the Quran: “O you who believe! stand out firmly for ➡️ Justice ⬅️ as witnesses to Allah
( Quran 4 :135 )
We must ➡️ Stand up ⬅️ to those preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith.
Every person who defends those preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith will gain as much ➡️ Sin ⬅️ as those preachers.
We must only defend the Quran & Hadith.
Man is in loss, except for those who believe, do good deeds, urge 0ne another to the
➡️ truth ⬅️ ( 📖 Surah-Al-Asr )
The Sad thing is many of us are busy defending preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith ...Astaghfirullah
On zina the ruling and punishment applies by sharia law and legal system tell who is following in today’s world. Whatever sins Muslim do will be questioned on judgment day. Having said Muslim is supposed to be tolerant and not vigilante. In story of prophet lut,AS it was Allah who decided to punish not prophet lut. AS. Please get your facts straight
preech tolerance but dont preech acceptance do you understand the difference .... how do you prove someone is gay in a shariah court do you know?????
I see more boys who imitate girls and girls who imitate boys and I am shocked because I didn't realize how deep this problem is in the Muslim countries!
Feminism hates men, because men are structured thinkers and they are upholding the corrupt. Feminism was pro colonialism and lynching. They came after big banks to switch from farm to debt slavery. They are anti minority family as they are left. Islam is the balance. Avoid extremism of right and fake science on left. Quran is preserved and even modern science methods made by Muslims to be clear and transparent
This is a problem in the world..
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 the one that you talked about is more into third wave feminisim all the sjw.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Shiism is a false sect? What sect are you from? Before you start calling out Shiism as false I invite you to do research on Shiism and compare hadiths. More importantly do studying on your own sect and if you will find many holes in it. May الله سبحانه و تعالى guide us all to the straight path, the path of our beloved Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and his Ahlulbayt. آمين 🌹
@@Mazzie2022 I am Sunni flesh and blood by birth, yet I will not be ashamed to be a Shia.
Shias are great mantle holders of Islam.
Today, who are the defenders of the Noble Islam?
Look around. It is
The Noble Iran is.
Is a Suni more pure is spirit than a Shia?
Cut the separatism.
Only Allah decides who is rightous and let Allah decide.
No one is perfect, don't pay attention to mistakes he might make, he's always giving great advices, teaching great stuff! Grow up.
I love Mufti❤️ btw if he's made a mistake , message him, don't make a video out of it lol😃
Now that being really ignorant, what an ignorant thing you have said. Don't pay attention to the mistakes he makes, you know how he has mislead the Muslims. It you who need to grow up, the shaykh who's speaking here is not ignorant like you. When you don't know much about the Deen it better to keep quiet than writing what you wrote.
1000% your right
This guy making this video is like a 12 year old looking for validation or acknowledgement. He has to get his facts together. Its people like him that scares people away from Islam.
@@aslamfelton9794 scares people with Haqq, what a hypocrite you are. True Islam you don't have to sugar things to make people happy, or preach it the way you think it right. Say things in accordance the Qur'an And Sunnah. That why the Ummah is in such a state, it people like you and the so called Shayookh you'll follow. The Shayookh you'll follow instead of them bring up man true lions of Islam they bring up man with women characteristics. You'll should be ashamed to even call yourselves man the way you'll behave.
Thank you
Murad you said what
I was thinking
جزاك الله خير
Mufti Menk does address homosexuality i’ve seen him talk about it in lectures, and that’s it’s something we should not engage in or encourage. He even told about him confronting two gay man. It’s a little to extreme to say he’s an influence into people becoming homosexual just because he takes the softer approach which isn’t always the case mufti menk is firm when he needs to be. Allah SWT loves those who are soft and kind in nature so much so on the day of judgement they enter paradise no questioning. Being soft doesn’t mean you’re going to become homosexual. There’s a thing as being overall masculine where everything you do has to be showing you’re a men, which can lead to toxic masculinity. There’s needs to be a balance, if you’re a man your actions will speak for itself mufti menk does horse back riding and goes to the shooting range but he doesn’t focus on that because he knows who he is as a man he doesn’t need to prove it to anyone. It’s honestly not him it’s society people are normalizing homosexuality so much and pushing for it that kids today will say they’re gay just to be cool astaghfirullah. May Allah SWT protect us.
@@ridwanibrahimabdullahieeda3177 but he does address it directly i’ve heard him directly address the issue many times
I think this comment makes the most sense
@@rahmahdalhat8484 which comment?
@@jean-christdjelhiyahot4612 yours suprisingly
@@rahmahdalhat8484 oh ok, why is it surprising?
May Allah keep you sincere and steadfast and preserve you. Aameen.
Brother, there is a crossworshipper in america by the name marjorie taylor. I thought that it would help Muslims turning certain errors in the christian religion into mainstream arguments.
And it would help your cause against the lgbtq.
The crossworshippers claim that their god became a man. So my argument is, if they believe that their god transformed into a man in the 1st century, then how can they have any argument against the lgbtq? You are hitting two targets with the sane stone. And your Da'wah and argument will generate the Muslims to belittle lgbtq and humiliate the crossworshippers at the sane time.
The time for counter attack is here, not defending all the time.
The christian god and his male gender transformation is not only an argument against the crossworshippers, but a mainstream thinking of the Muslim youth to have in their minds whenever vile crossworshippers show up. And that will also instil in them to despise lgbtq.
Amiin.
@Black Roses Amiin
@Black Roses aameen. May Allah do the same for you.
You are absolutely 💯right bro I was one of his followers but not any more after I heard this its really a shame 😕
That’s the pure truth, i don’t care who he is as long as he doesn’t voice the truth.
what is wrong with a man knitting tho
@@bennaq788 I don’t see that as an big issue. That criticism specifically. But apologizing someone who insults our prophet just to show up tolerant in the public it’s fucking disgusting. Also not telling the truth what he thinks about Homosexuality. I was watching his videos till now, there are way better people giving knowledge about deen and they are not scared to voice any argument which is in the Quran and Sunnah.
@@agron4040 Can you recommend some good scholars/UA-camrs
@@caesta7168 There are many of them but most their speech it’s recorded from different Talebul ILM or whatsoever; Search for Shejk Feuzan, Ibn Baz, Uthaimin, rahimahullah. Their videos lead to other great schoolars.
@@agron4040 jazakallah khair, thanks
I used to watch Mufti Menk back then cause he was more strong in his stance and great source for learning but nowadays he’s more focused on heart softeners or “feel good” speeches.
That’s great and all but I don’t gain knowledge, especially about controversial topics. He’s more of public speaker that aims to make his listeners feel better so I can’t just take him seriously.
If he’s beneficial to others, great but I want to learn and seek knowledge even if it’s painful to hear at first.
Precisely. And knowledge is extremely important, esp. in a time where you need to protect yourself from confusion from all angles.
Yes, I was his audience too. I watched a lot of his videos and I have learned a lot from him. But on the gay and lesbian issues, I disagree with him.
the Mufti never claimed to acquire knowledge from him. He always referred back to the quraan and the sunnah. Please don't be biased in your views. Aswk
@@MrAddyan he’s always promoted as an Islamic scholar and even has the title as Grand Mufti of Zimbabwe so please spare with YOUR biasness. Rather he admits it himself or not, he has mass influence and is known as a scholar.
I think I was fair in my judgement. I mentioned he has various strengths that I appreciated and also has weaknesses. His main one being that he tends to shy away from certain parts of Islam that are still important due to fear being labelled as “intolerant” as stated in Gabriel’s video.
He’s a great speaker no doubt, but he should stop bending so much to gain validation from westerners cause pushing this inclusivity would just make Muslims water down the deen and non-Muslims think that Islam is like any other religion and not as the ultimate truth.
@@anisahs2110 What do you mean by "he's always promoted"??? you realize he dedicated his life to the deen don't you?? He is separate from his "followers" and has ALWAYS said to follow the quraan and the sunnah above himself. Gaining validation??? from who?? the only validation we need is from Allah swt which he has said countless times. Gabriel justs looks frustated and tbh comes out a bit jealous because he doesn't approve of his way of daawah. He chose a wrong video to pick on Mufti and nowhere has the mufti ever said that homosexuality is allowed and I can challenge you to show me. If you think that speaking softly and politely is a way of "bending to westerners" then you need to check yourself. Have a nice day.
I am happy to see that at least one person have said against him. Nobody was concerned about his issues. People nowadays are feared to say truth about these influential person's. Jazakallahu khairon my brother, keep this honesty and truthfulness go on. May Allaah guide us all to the right path.
You have no idea how much I needed to hear this, as I am struggling with fear as well, from my non-Muslim parents and I have to admit, sometimes even the western society in some aspects.
Bismillah and make Hijra
Be patient brother and find and pray for a way.
Whatever happens
Live with the rules of islam and never quiet
Always remember Allah is with those who strive in His way. Just keep on being patient with the situation Allah has given you and be steadfast in Islam and Allah will make it easier for you Ameen. And even when we make mistakes, Allah is The Merciful, he promised us forgiveness when we repent.
Make immigration to Muslim country, brother.
If someone says something that is contrary to the Deen publicly, then he is obliged to come out and denounce his opinion publicly once he recognises his error. If he fails to do that then it is the responsibility of the ulama and all other Muslims who know the truth or correct ruling to come out publicly and declare what is right regarding the matter, so that people (the larger Muslim communities) would not be misled by the ignorant or selfish/personal ruling. So brother Romani you're doing the right thing. What I would wish to happen is to have a panel of islamic scholars (on UA-cam especially) who would be examining rulings/opinions of fellow scholars on aaqeedah and contemporary social issues affecting the Muslim ummah. And it would be best to invite and have discussions with the scholar who deviates from the Islamic ruling/law on issues. And this should be done professionally and intellectually without giving room for anyone to think or believe this is an attack on the other scholar. Pretty much like The behaviour Panel (I don't know if you're familiar with that UA-cam channel).
I wander why we can't even liberated our own brothers and sisters in the occupie land 🤦🏾♂️, she was asking them those questions expecting them to answer them as Muslims 🙈🙈🙈🙈shame......
Thank you brother for standing up for the young men who aren't always able to speak out. You are an inspiration for me, how much you strive to follow the example of Rasulallah (SAW). Allahumma barik.
Habibi simply detach yourself from these people and stand firm upon the Haqq with the understanding of the Salaf
Mashallah wallahi we should stay away from this fitna and stay upon the Haqq by the permission of Allah SWT and only speak or think of these matters when refuting and attacking these evil innovated ways of thinking , if only we knew the responsibility of a man when he has such a influence outhu billah may Allah SWT keep us firm of the Haqq ammen
He is fighting against it . That’s what they should do.
Mannnnnn, its so sad that we all (Ahlus Sunnah wal jamaaah) are not living near to each other. This would be such a strong Jamaah!
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmetullahi wa barakatuhu!
I'm not following ibn Abdul wahhab. Fuck him
@@DARTH-R3VAN good for us alhamdulillah, our jamaah is clean from such people like you
Very seriously, I never came across you and I don't know u but. This is my first time hearing from you, but for Mufty I have been following him years, I will say you are 100% right. Many of the preachers are trying to be politicians nowadays, propaganda to suit western world.
I feel your frustration brother, we as Muslim ummah needs to stand against these western ideologies with firmness, this is a sickening and disgusting era we live in. We bear the responsibility to clean this mess 🧹
Unfortunately a part of his followers are too attached to his personality, and someone criticizes the things he says, is immediately attacked by these fans. They behave like celebrity fans. The same happens when someone criticizes people like Yasir Qadhi. His followers immediately are offended and come to the one who criticizes them and start screaming and swearing. It appears the personality Mufti Menk is more important for them than what Quran or Sunnah says. But it should never shy a muslim away from continuing these critics
Right brother
ua-cam.com/video/Cj06lzXIEvk/v-deo.html
@Zeenįt Jay Nobody is denigrating him, he is being criticized, so stop acting emotional about it. NObody on earth is exempt from criticism, i told you earlier and i will continue to say that until you understand. And again, if somebody does something in public, it makes them a public figure, so they are open for criticism. If you dont want that, then don't come out into the public, unless you're sure you can't make mistakes. But if you do, then you're corrected. There's nothing wrong with being corrected, even if it's publicly. Besides that nobody is disrespectful towards mufti Menk, he is being criticized.
@Zeenįt Jay
What definition best describes you here? 😆
What Do I Do If I Find Out My Favorite Preacher Is Corrupt? The 5 Stages of Grief
It is very traumatic to find out that the person you've been listening to for years has changed or is now expressing increasingly deviant views.
If you recognize this deviance, consider yourself one of the fortunate ones. Most of the fans of the person won't even understand the problem because their entire source for learning Islam is the preacher himself. So these fans don't even have an objective measuring stick needed to know what is or isn't corruption. Their understanding of Islam completely depends on whatever the celebrity teaches. If he changes, they change.
I have gone through this trauma myself. People that I thought were upright scholars of deen that I loved and respected turned out to be unabashed sell outs. It wasn't one or two "off the cuff" remarks that made me realize this, but an extended pattern of behavior, associations, and private correspondence. When I talked with the preachers in question about these issues, rather than assuage the worry, they compounded it by doubling down, excusing their behavior, making ugly accusations against me, accusing me of disloyalty, etc.
What I have seen is that when fans of celebrity compassionate imams find out about corruption and deviance, they go through the 5 stages of grief.
Stage 1: Denial
The first thought is, "This is nothing." The fans don't want to hear anything bad about the preacher. So they ignore all the evidence and try to shield themselves from seeing anything incriminating so that they can maintain the pristine image of their beloved preacher. Sadly, many do not leave this stage, no matter how much evidence there is.
Stage 2: Anger
In this stage, the fan lashes out at anyone pointing out the corruption/deviance. It is very sad to see these individuals because you can hear it in their voice how tortured they are. They view the celebrity as a family member. Sometimes they love the preacher more than their own family members. But they also are confused and can sense that something is not right. This contradiction causes mental anguish and they release this frustration by lashing out at others and defending the preacher at all costs.
Stage 3: Bargaining
Eventually the fans cannot deny that there is something off with the preacher. By now, multiple independent sources have brought up the same problems and the preacher himself has done nothing to satisfactorily address the issues, much less resolve them. Sometimes he might even double down. The fans start to bargain with themselves: "Well, there has to be an explanation. It must have been out of context, it was an innocent slip," etc. They tell themselves, "Ok, so maybe he did make a mistake. But so what? No one's perfect!" They bargain with themselves, "I'll just take the good and leave the bad. No problem."
Stage 4: Depression
This stage hits like a ton of bricks. The previous stages of coping could not stop the inevitable realization. Now they have reached full-on grief and it can be very ugly. For some, their Islam is threatened. They have so closely associated Islam with this preacher that they transfer feelings of betrayal to Islam itself or ulama and scholarship as a whole. Some fans, in their grief, make dramatic pronouncements like: "I will NEVER listen to another scholar again!" This stage can last for weeks or months.
Stage 5: Acceptance
If Allah wills, the now ex-fans reach a stage of maturity. They now understand that not every preacher today is trustworthy, to say the least, and some of them may have the external trappings of traditional Islam when in reality, they are nothing more than faux-traditionalist wolves. They have moved past blind fandom and start to distinguish between the feel-good fluff version of Islam taught by compassionate imams from the kind of Islam taught by traditional scholars for centuries. They may have scars, but the healing process is well underway.
An excellent example comes from the Sahabi Salman al-Farsi. He spent his early adulthood leaving the religion of fire-worship to become Christian. He would find a Christian scholar to study with, learn all that he could until the scholar would die and then he would move to study with the next scholar. In some cases, he found out that one of the Christian scholars he was studying with was corrupt, literally stealing from people. He didn't give up or say, "Well, we can only follow the dead!" He moved on and sought the truth. Eventually that led him to RasulAllah ﷺ and he became one of the greatest Companions, may Allah be pleased with them all.
Be like Salman. If one preacher burns you, there are many righteous scholars in our day and age who stick to the truth and don't sell out. Seek them out and Allah will guide you to Him bi idhnillah.
By: Daniel Haqiqatjou
@Zeenįt Jay as you may know in Islam we are to correct each other and grow together.
Muslims must not call another muslim a hater just because he is saying logical things about another muslim. May Allah guide us all.
Jazak Allah kheir, Brother Gabriel.
Of course. In Islam its obligated to help and correct each other and that's part of growing.
@Ali Chaudhry by following the clear Evidence back to Qur'an and Sunnah... thats how! don't stop at the imam, follow the entire evidence, even babies pick up langauges...
@Ali Chaudhry May Allah bless you my dear brother. have you read Sh. Albani's book Prophet's prayer intro on how all 4 mathhabs said if we miss a hadith go with that... beautiful, Muslims need to learn to unite by following just the basics of analytical thinking over laziness and culture. May Allah guide us!
@Joe Average are you a muslim??
Jibril said only the truth. Maybe you have no idea what shariaa is...maybe you are here with a fake account to insult instead of trying to understand Brother Gabriel's response. Anyway, May God guide you.
@@MonPrinCeCyCLoPe Amin.
Mufti Menk is a pious Muslim and human being. Anybody who speaks against him are just jealous of him. It’s all good and well saying I have nothing against mufti Menk then go out there way to make a video of him.
I assume you’re not muslim. You don’t change the religion of God. He’s in the wrong profession
The problem is fanboys and fan girls are being mislead. Warning against Deviants is permissible.
If the sahabah can get confused so much so that it lead to “the battle of Jamal” and “the battle of siffin” then who are we :/ these are tough times and the most important thing is UNITY. I gave this example just to say we are humans and mufti menk is a human too and we are nobody compared to the sahabahs. But it’s good that you pointed it. It would have been better if you talked to him directly idk just saying.
Exactly
you looking at it the wrong way. we supposed to learn from the past- what our predecessors went through- not using it as an excuse to not to do better.
I think these people have talked to them but what can mufti menk do, go back and retract his statement
Prophet Muhammad pbuh said: “Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or he is an oppressed one” and you implemented that and he pbuh also said: “ say the truth even if it is against your own self” and you implemented that too. May Allah increase you in reward and grant you jannah for this.
Your 1st Hadith isn't true.
It was the belief of the bedouins in the days of the jahiliah.
Quraan says to stand firmly against injustice even if it was your own family members doing this.
@@honouredsoul1405 it is a authentic hadith, but you didn’t get it. Let me show you the full image: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or he is an oppressed one. People asked, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! It is all right to help him if he is oppressed, but how should we help him if he is an oppressor?" The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "By preventing him from oppressing others."
@@Abdulbasit-uv4bi Yeah this is understandable.
I was confused by your previous comment.
Thank much for the clarification
@@honouredsoul1405 the pleasure is all mine
@@Abdulbasit-uv4bi You should have mentioned the full hadith at first place with context as many people just gonna read your first comment & move on with a confused mind.
I like Mufti Menk but I follow NO MAN blindly, except Muhammad (Sallallahu Alaihi WaSallam) and that isn't even blind following really, Allah has told me to follow him (Sallallahu Alaihi Wa Sallam) as an example!
Ma sha Allah may Allah keep us steadfast.
☝️🤲❤
@@AK-47ak12 Right on Brother.
@@AK-47ak12 You seem familiar... do we see each other somewhere else?
@@HabrenOdinsdottir probably leaving comments on Islamic channels videos lectures etc
Gabriel is one of few Islamic teachers, I hve the most respect for presenting the traditional islam without being ashamed of it and mincing matter like a punk that other compassionate imams r.
Spot on bro. Check out Daniel Haqiqatjou he is also doing great things regarding this matter. His channel is called muslim skeptic.
@@arifrafique1439 Danial is my inspiration.
Agree. They both have unapologetic approaches when it comes to their deen being attacked.
@@wanfahim3583 which country is this brother from n where 9s his school?
@Brown Boy BV Jazak Allahu Khayr!
JazakAllah Khairun Brother Gabriel. I completely agree with what you have said. May Allah bless you for all your efforts. We desperately need more people like you.
I just wanna tell you dear Gabriel. When you judge someone for any reason, you will be responsible for your judgment in front of God. And only God knows who is right and who is wrong.
Thank You Brother James for the reminder. I was going to curse Gabriel out. If it haven't been for the knowledge and wisdom that Brother Mufti Menk shared on UA-cam, I would have been depressed and probably committed suicide.
we judge by what is apparent not that which is hidden.
James Smith exactly why Gabriel made this video!!! He cares about his after life more than this life and popularity unlike some
Thats not true who is right and who is not the hadith and Quran have already mentioned
He is not judging him but telling him what the Quran and Sunnah says on those topics he was interviewed about…judging obviously will be ultimately done by Allahﷻ and only He knows each and everyone intention , what’s in their heart and no one will escape His judgment.
We need more Men like you.
Yesssss
True
No we don't mufti menk is a good speaker
This isn’t jealousy, it is sunnah to renounce words that transgress. This is the least you can do “Whosoever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart - and that is the weakest of faith.”Hadith 34, 40 Hadith an-Nawawi. So if any of you have an issue with him refuting Mufti Menk, then take your account to Allah because you’re arguing an Islamic protocol and you’re now transgressing the bounds of Islam. You’re waging war with Allah so be on your own!
Edit: I’ve seen some other d’aee make a video on brother Romani and it’s as expected people in the comments on that channel are going in on brother Romani, why? Because sticking with the haq looses you votes.
A lot of pseudo experts of Islam. Furthermore we are at a stage where ghirah of Islam sticking with the sunnah to some means you’re “mental and radical”. These are the times Allah has spoken of and it’s clear holding onto our deen is like holding onto hot coal
JazakAllah khayran brother for bringing this up. Homies sticking out for each other, nothing more than that. It's as if only one person is deserving of husn ad dhann.
The evidence is provided, but the intoxication with personalities is hard to get rid. Like a bad case of Stockholm syndrome.
INSULTING the prophet (pbuh) and being docile with that, and people have ZERO issues, and all the rage in the world for a brother who is calling it as it is. Appalling.
@@MechkanysT Barak’Allahu feek brother. I’m a sister though! No problem, as your message is the same. I agree and I’m just frustrated this is happening. I’m Sick of people watering down the deen to appease the west and suit their own agenda
I often watch this speakers corner (a place in London in a park where people talk openly about anything) they’ve now made it into a live UA-cam stream. This is where you see the true colours of even our ummah, there’s so called Muslims insulting the prophet PBUH and then denying that they meant harm. Then you have people on that stream who are also Muslim with NO ghirah playing ignorant and saying “oh they didn’t mean it like that”. Then we have the disbelievers saying all sorts on the same streams and Muslims befriending them and all for views. It’s a sick world. I remember I was on the live chats and saying “there’s a hadud punishment even after you repent for reviling the prophet PBUH, and even if you repent that capital punishment stands” the ridicule I got because people don’t know their deen or are happy for it to be slandered said I’m extreme and wrong. SubanAllah I brought daleel and yet they disbelieved in Allah’s verses
I pray i don't see my husband leaving Life to knit a sweater
@@earthynomad7160 with all due respect in my country men do knitting for a living and no woman has ever ever come out looking as those men/husbands as women. Let’s not take sides in this because wallahi Allah will reward us or punish us for our intentions and whatever we say/affirm wallahi we will be help accountable for it.
Qtn: should we now scrap this action out of the way of life of our Nabbi SAW just because the world is full of jahil?? Are we now trying to claim that the action was feminine yet the prophet did it. astaghfirullah.
So knitting is transgression?
Omar Suleiman, then Mufti Menk wallahi I don't know what to believe anymore. May Allah protect us from the Dajjal
What about Omar Suleiman brother? Recently got into his videos is there something I should be aware of?
@@thefin4lb0ss He promotes the LGBT movement and makes money from it
@@assileyacoub4829 really 😳 plz tag me on that video
@@gisorediana5489 ua-cam.com/video/YIySWut5uhk/v-deo.html
@@assileyacoub4829he does not!! Stop slandering brother. He was in the wrong place at the wrong time with the wrong people and made a video addressing the situation and apologized. Mufti menk has all the makings of a state sponsored shiekh. Made alot of money do so too
Brother with all due respect I would like to let u know that knitting is a major occupation in africa . It's not different from sewing. We make dresses from the knitting and knitting is never allocated to only women. Each one of us will be held accountable for our deeds lets busy ourselves with our shortcomings because our meeting with Allah will be individualized. May Allah keep us guided in Islam. Lets not busy ourselves with being judgmental of others!!!!
The brother is harbouring some resentment it seems. Please act like a MAN brother and not a BOY......
Yes, we will be held accountable of our own actions; however, what he said about homosexuality, democracy and other issues are all true.
We are all sinning and making mistakes knowingly or unknowingly, but at least he is spreading the right knowledge of Islam by making a video to educate the people without cowering. Not the same can be said about you and I, and may Allah accept it from him. May Allah guide us in these times of fitan.
Knitting is probably not the main issue amirite? I taught my kid knitting as a kid, it's actually good for the nerves. But I don't do it for a living. Maybe guys who knit for a living will be angry though, I can respect ur opinion. Peace
Knitting is actually a girly thing! If you look at the fashion designers now, they are mostly gays. From what he said about knitting is, why would Mufti Menk give example on a work such as knitting, why not give a masculine more manly example. And he is right. Because these small things add up to one day being gay attribute and suddenly one day boys will identify as woman or become gay. We as parents teach our boy children to be boys and bring up as man. Don't fall into the trap of thinking that ... everything can be done by both boy/girl. Boy's do have specific activities, girl have some. Why does society want to deny that??
@@artismypassion Agreed Sister 100% 🌺
So apologetic. Why Allie yourself to be interrogated like that. Just for a visa. You water down or disregard the Islamic teachings. Disgusting.
Islam is better and we should treat it like that against the corruption of the west they promote to bring us down.... how weak, May Allah guide us to Manhaj Salaf.
I stopped following mufti menk a long time ago, once I saw him making "heart sign" over some video chat, the level of cringe tripped me off.
Guantánamo Bay wasn’t a mistake if you get crossed by seeing a guy make heart
@@MrWiibetrollin Your wi[f]e's bo[y]friend would agree with me though.
Do people think once they say, “We believe,” that they will be left without being put to the test?
We certainly tested those before them. And ˹in this way˺ Allah will
clearly distinguish between those who are truthful and those who are
liars.
S29:V2-3
@Mufti Menk, for the sake of Allah, take this brother's advice seriously. He is telling the truth. So stand with him.
I really respect you for being so unapologetic and straight to the point .
Yeah look at your profile picture lol
I agree brother. We need to strengthen ourselves as Muslims. To be Masculine and strong as Allah intended. Jazak Allah Khair.
It’s good to see people express their opinions respectfully and say what they feel . That shows a healthy strong society
Thank you brother!! You have opened my eyes!!! Jazakallah
I don't understand....when has it become OK to judge another person on how he delivers his message. Everyone has their own style of preaching and you know there is a saying, you catch more flies with honey than vinegar.
Its not about "how" he delivers "the" message but its about what he delivers? I mean he is wrong over there cuz Quran and hadith clearly say that homosexuality is not allowed and prophet even clarified how we have to stand our grounds whether it be christians or jews. U look to be an intellectual brother, i hope you beat your ego and try to understand.
If you actually don’t understand what he just said, that is actually very simple and clear then it’s definitely your fault…
It’s shame brother that people stand up and defend personalities it shame these people don’t stand up for islam like this when the media or some government say something against islam or our beloved prophet Mohammed pbuh 🙏🙏 truth is always bitter pill to swallow May Allah bless you brother for standing your ground when something is wrong nowadays people who show them the mirror are short supply
So brother what are you trying to point out?
Speak the truth even if it is bitter.No one can aid you except Allah.
LGBTQ don't only insult the Prophet (PBUH) they insult ALL prophets including Isa (Jesus), Moses (Musa), Abraham (Ibrahim) and countless others. They are friends of no one but Iblis. I was looking to get married, and through family and relatives, I was introduced to a hafiza of the quran. When we were talking about the serious stuff, she said that she has LGBTQ friends and if our kids became LGBTQ, all she would do was tell them that she loved them!!!!! She did not believe me that the alphabet people had an agenda against us. She believed that she could reform them no matter how much they tried to lead her astray, made fun of her, said bad things about the prophet (PBUH) and his companions. I told her that a Prophet, Lut (PBUH) failed, where she was expecting to succeed!!! And mind you, these "friends" of hers, were making fun of her, sneering at her. How can muslims these days be so naive? Why do women think that they can turn the situation around no matter what? Why do the words Lost Cause not have any meaning to them? On certain things and certain people especially, we must give up. Did the Prophet (PBUH) also not give up on Abu Jahl and Abu Lahab? We must know how to cut our losses. Like wise we must know when to push and push and not give up.
Assalamu alaikum,
O brother you have done a great job. For me I will consider what you have done now has criticism. How many times have you commended him on his videos he has been doing I hope you don't fall into the category of those that used to search for someone's fault.
As a muslim you don't need to agree to everything someone is saying . Pick yours and then move on. If you have the opportunity to talk to the person one on one it would have been more okay not like this. It's like you are promoting hatred Among the muslim and giving the non muslims chances to insult our religion. About homosexuality, because of his disagreement with it that's why he was banned in some of the European countries. So brother this is just my piece of advice . Thanks.
I lost a frozen meat supply contract after I declined politely shaking hands with the female owner of a cafeteria. NEVER REGRET IT
Allah is the owner of everything, the sustainer, Allah will bless you in other ways. If you don't get this, you get another, besides, you may still loose it after disobeying Allah and be double loser. May Allah help us stand firm
May Allah grant you a better contract akhi
Totally agree with you dear brother, these men which such huge following need to be very very careful about what they preach and comment on. YQ has really crossed the line. I fear for him if he does not repent. I worry for our youth !
Allah SWT Reward you dear brother, keep doing as your doing please !!!!!!!
SubhanaAllah! May Allah protect us and our children.
May Allah bless those who submit to his will the most and decrease accordingly. You don’t wear hijab
Protect yourself by wearing a hijab
Try and practise wearing the Hijab sister. It's compulsory on you as a Muslim woman.
Ameen ☝️🤲❤
One method of protection is wearing hijab.
No sugar coating here brother thats what is needed Masha Allah. Keep it up bro.
He’s harsh but he’s telling the truth. Appreciate those who shoot straight to the point instead of beating around the bush
MashaAllah may ALLAH SWT protect and have mercy on us. You a brave muslim
Balanced approach to an important issue. First time to hear you. May Allaah increase you in knowledge, strengthen your resolve to speak the truth, especially when it is unpopular to do so, and keep you upon the straight and clear path.
One golden statement:"she isnt interested in what Islam says. She wants to know if you agree with what Islam says."
I agree with you 100 % brother. I don't know you but you are right. The mufti is a celebrity imam, he loves publicity. "if you live by the media you will die by the media"
tbh I really love Mufti Menk. And if somebody would say something against his Ahlak and character, I would stand up against this. But I am literally, and there is no doubt (after hearing and realizing, checking, and all of this stuff) after hearing this what was going on, Haha no there is no point in supporting his arguments of Mufti Menk.
Like I said I really appreciate him, but if he wants to represent Islam, he could do better. And I want to wake up and not follow a bunch of sheep, responding to a shepherd.
I don't have the energy, even to follow (blindly) the majority or scholars, who are I not even sure and the actions don't represent them to be scholors.
Ugh..wallahi.sad reality...
Serpil s, I will never run any brother or sister down and that is in keeping with the spirit of up holding the sunnah of not revealing the your fellow Muslims faults.
However, recently our sheikh had engaged in some activities that were not in good spirit. It will slowly surface when Allah wills...
I politely disagree Mufti Menk keeps it real and he doesn't care about being known. This guy here looks like he wants people to praise him like a God astaghfirallah. He's looking for celebrity and notoriety himself!! He needs to stop the Fitna
This guy looking at him you can tell he’s speaking the truth you can tell he isn’t radical nor liberal just pure Islam
Exactly
Brother Gabriel I to be honest felt that mufti menk felt trapped the whole time and didn’t know how to be diplomatic. We are all humans after all not angels and life in the west is crazy but if u personally talked to him it would have been more fruitful bcz sheikhs may also need reminders. Jazak Allah Khair
Mufti Menk has many followers,people look to him for advise..It appears he is Saudi backed (saudis have allied with the zionist jews),therefore he will not speak out against his saudi masters.If he does not want to speak out against saudi atrocities including the war in Yemen and
allowing hundreds of thousands of amerikan soldiers on Arab lands (The Prophet pbuh said there must not be another religion other than Islam on Arab soils)..Brother Menk please do not be selective in your lectures,address the current issues where lives are lost.If you do no have the courage to speak out say it openly and admit its cowardice and Allah swt will show mercy InshaAllah.We dont need knitting lessons when people are dying!
He is in a public position,if he is incapable or too scared to be truthful the n stop preaching or admit your a coward and dissapear into oblivion.Have the guts to be honest.Your more frightened of a news reporter than Allah swt..These guys are cowards.
اللهم يا مقلب القلوب ثبت قلوبنا على دينك
I listened to the full interview very carefully. Mufti said nothing wrong at all. Listen carefully to each of his sentences and words (ua-cam.com/video/v5xIfEQqjdA/v-deo.html). He actually beat the woman at her own game for those of understanding. The other canadian guy however, yes, I agree with you, that is total weakness.
Interviewer: Can a woman shake hands with a man ?
Mufti: Under certain cirscumstances, yes she can....
Interviewer: What's your personal teaching ?
Mufti: " If I have to, I will......
(If for example he is asked to shake a woman's hands in a certain circumstance where it is a matter of saving human life, he would...Makes perfect sense. If his mother asks him to shake her, his wife's hand, etc, he will...Notice it is not good muslim behavior not to shake a woman's hand in some circumstances. If your mother or wife demands you to shake her hand, what would Allah want ?. Remember he already said "Under certain circumstances...")
Interviewer: "If I visit you in Zimbabwe, will you shake my hand ?"
Mufti: "If you see my beard and extend your hand. Who knows ? I may shake it. I really don't know..it's the circumstance...i don't even know if you will come here....but argumentatively if you were to come here it' s ok."
(Careful here, he said he really does not know if he will shake her hand if she comes to Zimbabwe. Which makes perfect sense, imagine someone held a gun at Mufti's head or at the woman's head when she visits Zimbabwe and demanding that Mufti shakes her hand to save a life. Will he do it ? Yes. Mufti's answer is correct at all circumstances. Yes, he does not know. Only Allah knows what will happen. In fact Mufti even said that he does not even know if the woman will come to Zimbabwe. And that is the correct answer.
He is not saying it' s ok that he will shake her hand, but it's ok if she were to come there to Zimbabwe...)
About freedom of religion, yes Mufti is 100% right. Remember there is the verse: "No compulsion in religion..." In the Quran, Allah keeps reminding our prophet that his job is only to warn and spread the message, not to force anyone. That He will not be asked about the non believers.That they are not his responsibility. His job was only to warn.That perhaps it would sadden him if they do not believe, but they are not his responsibility and he will not be asked about them.
Mufti went on to say, in a subtle way, that Denmark, a country that pretends to be all about freedom, is not actually about freedom of speech: "are we not blocking freedom of speech.." meaning that the Danish are against freedom of speech if they are unwilling to accept someone disagreeing with their opinion on certain matters..."
Interviewer: "Do you believe in Democracy ? "
Mufti: "Democracy is ok". He did not say that he believes in it. He went on to say he votes in elections, meaning he has no problem with democracy but he never said he believes in democracy.
Mufti: " If I were to show you the evidence, you would say yes, this man believes that he should vote"... Here again Mufti avoids saying that he believes in democracy, but he says that he believes he should vote.
Interviewer: "Do you believe that pornography can lead to homosexuality ? "
Mufti: " Maybe it can...If pornographhy is ok in Denmark, and homosexuality is ok in Denmark, and bestiality is ok in Denmark, then what is wrong if pornography leads to homosexuality. Why are they getting angry at it ? Why are they getting angry at that statement ? It is freedom of speech to believe yes it does, or no it does not...." Mufti killed it.
Be careful of slandering people and making them say what they did not say. A mulim should always give the benefit of the doubt to his muslim brother and assume the best as we cannot read our brother’s hearts, only Allah can. So let's fear Allah. Putting Mufti alongside the other guy makes it seem as if Mufti is also guilty by association but when you take his words apart and listen to them carefully you realize all of his sentences are perfectly correct and there is a lot of hiqma in the way he answers the questions. Those of understanding, who can interpret correctly what they hear, and can also read between the lines will know what I am talking about.
And to the brother @Gabriel Al Romaani, Lut was a prophet sent on a mission to warn those people. Mufti is not a prophet and he was not sent to the homosexual nations to warn them. That comparison makes no sense. Even to the prophet Muhamad, pbuh, Allah keeps saying in the Quran, it was not his responsibility if they do not believe in the message. He will not be asked about the non believers. His job was only to warn and spread the message.
He is very kind and has very good knowledge. Most of all he doesn't bad mouth anyone
Who?
@@HabrenOdinsdottir mufti menk
yes he doesn't have bad mouth neither your white master Gabriel al Romani
@@yasminenazarine1629 racist
I think Mufti Menk should be credited for trying to raise awareness in domestic violence issues. It has nothing to do with masculinity.
So to do that he had to be knitting?
Rainy Sounds for Sleeping Relaxing & Calm Down What’s wrong with knitting?!
I stopped listening to mufti after watching one of his videos..
Stranger Random stranger To think it’s a woman’s job is ridiculous!
@REMEMBER PALESTINE-UYGHURS-KASHMIR-SYRIA MYANMAR What is the big deal with his knitting? What did I miss?
Thank you for your wonderful discussion, yes these issues need to be addressed without us losing our honour/ principle which makes us firm in our beliefs.
I feel sad that you have had to defended yourself and state your principles which unfortunately are not shared by others.
This “GUY” , has a name. It’s sheikh Ismaiil Mufi Menk.
And he’s Awsome MashAllah.
Sometimes i like what he says. Doesnt mean that he is untouchable. So stop crying like a b*tch
@@rememberpalestine-uyghurs-2918 You should be more soft, why did you even use that kind of word to your brother/sister? The true Muslim is the one from whose tongue and hand the Muslims are safe...
@Abtahee abtahee Absolutely it is wrong to do those actions.
@Abtahee abtahee 100% agreed.
Menk won't benefit you on Yawm Al Qiyamah habibi
Feeding the algorithm so the truth reaches people, thanks to bro Saajid lipham
I never new him but saajid mentioned him that's why I'm here
السلام عليكم
If saajid vouches for someone, i will vouch for him
@@naeemmuhammad8216وعليكم السلام ورحمه الله وبركاته
we need our own media ...
This is brother Gabriel Al Romani..
Mufti menk present the “cute” version of islam which can be melted easily under pressure of western demands
I agree with this brother. We are not promoting the sunnah of masculinity in Islam and are rather do gimmicks to show softer image
In 3rd world countries toxic patriachy unjustly associated with Islam is pushing women to suicide and you say masculinity is being taken away.
If people like me and you can't do anything about it atleast we shouldn't belittle the one trying to make a genuine positive change.
Islam teaches the good and tolerance of good and rejecting bad. Balanced.
Atheism build no civilization. Feminism wants to break civilization by family. They came after central banks to switch from farm to debtors imprisonment.
@@honouredsoul1405 femenism has killed far more babies and aided in suicides and colonizations and slavery so what are you talking about?
@@honouredsoul1405 Feminism hates men, because men are structured thinkers and they are upholding the corrupt. Feminism was pro colonialism and lynching. They came after big banks to switch from farm to debt slavery. They are anti minority family as they are left. Islam is the balance. Avoid extremism of right and fake science on left. Quran is preserved and even modern science methods made by Muslims to be clear and transparent
@@honouredsoul1405 who is trying to make positive change?
Quran and sunnah upon the methodology of the Salaf. The religion of Allah is never watered down. جزاك الله خيرا brother this is needed man we are living in stranger times.
Asalam Alikum Br. Greetings from the Western Caribbean,I understand your frustration and actually agree with your points, I wonder if it might have been better to discuss directly with Mufti Menk rather than put this out in the public domain ?
I disagree with your methodology we don't need the enemies of our deen to see us in this state ,it is not productive at a time when we already have so many challenges as an ummah.
However ,you are absolutely correct ,these are without question forbidden lifestyles.
I believe Khalid Bin Waleed had a quote that goes: "May the eyes of cowards never sleep".
So if the person is a coward what's the point whether the eyes are open or closed?
@@babdullah5025 ‘May they never rest’
Subhan'Allah.And let's follow the Zeal of Hadhrat Khalid Bin Walid(RA) and not of flower throwers like Menk
Was it just a one liner or is there more to this quote
@@babdullah5025
Have you never read poetry?
Don't take words literally.
Don't be concrete in the way you think.
Hardly ever comment on videaos and never seen your videos before akhi but alhamdullilah may Allah swt reward you for this message I feel your pain and have been thinking exactly the same thing as what you are saying great job 👏
Norman Ali Khan,yasir qadi,hamza yusuf and now mufti menk.honestly these men have preached so much good,we kinda forget that they are human too....with struggles.shaytan is not an enemy to only ordinary people.take what is good from them and just make dua.people are so quick to point out someone's flaw
mashaAllah brother. You have shown great courage ❤️❤️. Thanks for helping us to be on right path
Brother tell him directly advise him about this issue and the effects please lets stand together don’t go against each other 🧐
This views should have been addressed between him and Mufti Menk.. I agree.. Its disrespectful in my opinion to address issues you have with another person on social network.. He notes it as a battle between him and Mufti Menk Subhanallah in his message above what has our Deen come too.. I have no other words.its sad.
Many people and other scholars have privately advised ismaeel Menk but he carries on being ignorant.
@@Bigbro123r5 I don’t think it is fair to say he keeps on being ignorant as this is the only interview I have ever seen that anyone talks about in a negative way which is understandable but he was under a lot of pressure you can see that and we all have weaknesses Mufti Menk is not perfect he is a human being. And except for this interview he has been consistently giving helpful dawah and I’ve never come across anything of his like this except for this so its unfair to say because someone makes a mistake you forget all the good he has done. We must be careful Allah likes those who are merciful to others. The other person addressed in the video I haven’t seen anything else of his so I will not speak about him. But we have to be fair try to strengthen our brothers and sisters weaknesses not expose them. May Allah guide us all.
@@Rosyrasul4654 there are many interviews in which ‘mufti’ menk was being ignorant in. He refuses to apologise for his mistakes and thinks he’s in the right.
@@Rosyrasul4654 he has made many mistakes, look them up. There was a video in which he was saying that a homosexualism is allowed in Islam and that he shakes hands with non mahram women.
WE LOVE YOU FOR THE SAKE OF ALLAH SHAYKH! May Allah (SWT) bless you for your guidance on these matters. Please never change or compromise our Deen which the Companions gave their blood for (may Allah be pleased with them all). Ameen.
This is what Islam says.... Stand up against evil... If you can...
Not to be the prophet of Tolerance
🤣
Thank you for speaking on this problem and calling out THE REAL ISSUES with these online personalities that water down the Deen...much respect bro...SALAMS.
You are a real Muslim, loyality should be to Allah and His prophet
I really like what this brother is bringing to our attentions. Watch the whole video before you go off on your opinion because I also had my biases because the title had some well known name in it. This is good. We have to wake up in these trying days. Jazakallah gheir brother Gabriel. Keep standing for Islam
May Allah keep us all sincere and strong in our Iman w Deen, ameen.
good job .... A person asked Imam Ahmed Is it better to pray and fast or expose the people of Beda ( the people who changed their religion) Imam Ahmed Said : If you pray and fast .. it is to benefit yourself .... and if you speak about the people of beda your efforts is to benefit the Muslims.
Jazakallah brother!
Keep alerting people, even if you have only one follower!
May Allah guide us!
Who are you man?!! How did I only know you now ,keep going brother!👍
If I understand you well you are not doubting these peoples faith or sincerity of purpose but you have an issue with their approach and simplicity in matters that are clear cut in Islam. Well! I think to do the correction you should be “TALKING TO” the scholars In question , not “TALKING AGAINST” them to the public.
Invest on pointing out the right thing yourself rather than pinpointing how others have failed to point out the right thing.
Carve a niche for your self with your own type and style of da’awah, or else you would always be perceived as been jealous.
And please stop making it sound like they are leading more people astray than showing them the right guidance, violence and hostility will not achieve what peace and gentility (with goal in mind )did not achieve.
Don't use emotions and Western thinking to judge others. Use proof with Quran and Sunnah.
May Allah bless you for being truthful ❤️
Amin, victory isnt with numbers, see Qur'an 9 : 25!