What Makes Nightwish "Ghost Love Score" AWESOME? - 2013 Wacken - Dr. Marc - Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2019
- What Makes _ AWESOME? - from
Voice Teacher, Vocal Coach, Performance Coach, & Opera Stage Director Dr. Marc Reynolds reacts and teaches how to sing and perform like the top performers in the world and talk about what makes those performers the best!
Original Video: • NIGHTWISH - Ghost Love...
SIGN UP FOR A PRIVATE ONLINE LESSON!
mrperformingartsstudio.com
Send me a quick question or get your own reaction from me on Scaleabout.com:
www.scaleabout.com/Dr_MarcRey...
Help me to keep making videos like this:
/ drmarcreynolds
Don’t forget to download Amino and search my profile name, @DrMarcReynolds, to check out my Stories:
aminoapps.onelink.me/4eRt/DrM...
Follow me to see more of my Stories and support me!
Product and Book Recommendations :
mrperformingartsstudio.com/ho...
Social Media :
/ mrperformingartsstudio
This video is made in accordance with copyright as follows:
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use
What a wonderful breakdown of this performance. Better than any others I have seen, because you took everything into account. Thank you so much!
Totally agree, I was so looking forward to this reaction.
Ann, if you had to choose one of Floor's performances on Beste Zangers to request for Marc, which one would it be?
@@mykindamakeup That is tough. My favorite is Winner. But Phantom blew my mind. I don't know. I can't pick between the two....... :-)
Took the words right out of my mouth
Every performance she did on Beste Zangers was just so amazing. Each with their own type of emotion but each of those emotions was perfectly on point. Im so sad the show is over.
@@Grizzlox :-)
Well. I have watched numerous people reacting to this ... and yours was so .. well .. dang great!!
Thank you!
Her smiling is so warm. Whenever she performs she always makes you feel like her friend. Floor is amazing.
Thing is Floor Jansen is a beautiful person, independently of how she sings...
Check our Floor and Henk Poort do Phantom of the Opera from Beste Zangers 2019. Awesome
I would love to see your reaction on that one too !
The Beste Zangers Phantom Performance is SOOOO impressive ^_^
Yes, but you should watch it on the channel of Rebecca Vocal Athlete. It's a real killer.
@@zorrowv8045 Love Rebecca VA.
@@zorrowv8045 DO IT!!!!!!
Wow man I'm only in minute 13 but just have to react! You are a true revelation. Your enthousiasme is freaking contagious. The things you get from this are what we all feel and you put into words. "Love it" ;)
I have seen at least 50 GLS reactions but yours is truly unique in the greatest sense. Universal analysis would be your niche. Superb!
So glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for watching!
Hi, Dr. Marc Reynolds, I think you must see Floor Jansen and Henk Poort, Phantom of the Opera, Beste Zangers.
Yes he should! They play out their performance briljantly.
I never heard more words in one GLS-reaction. 😂
But everyone was worth to listen to, even if i did'nt understand all of them.
Again, well done.
Greetings from germany
Thank you for watching and for the kind comment!
yup, he talks way too much, AND at the wrong time every time.
I was there back in 2013 and I can tell only one thing...this was a dreamflight for one and a half hour...flying through the dreams of Tuomas (the keyboarder, main componist) and the voice of the decade...Floor Jansen.
The way you put your appreciation of the calm middle section to words... Serene.... Transcendent... fabulous!
Let me be honest. This is the first reaction video where I did not skip even a single commentary from a presenter. Not a single! It was as entertaining to listen to as the song itself. Thank you!
Dr. Marc has finally reacted to Nightwish, Ghost Love Score. That's a wrap for 2019. It can end now. Thanks.
Yep. Finally bucked up the courage to do this one. It ended up being really easy to respond to because there was so much great stuff going on.
@@DrMarcReynolds thank you very much. You did a great job, as usual.
About 82000 metal fans, patiently waiting till the band returns on stage :)
Quietly waiting at that.
@@Meinotchu Well, it's germany, so orderly and efficient ;)
Been listening to Nightwish for almost 20 years, and have never seen a breakdown of one of their compositions like this. Absolutely fantastic. Thanks you!
It's funny how he's one of the very few doing these reaction videos who actually realized that the pipes around Tuomas' keyboards are a prop and not an actual instrument xD
This was really great reaction, but oh man, that Floorgasm™ Interruptus pierced my heart ;) Now I need to listen to that final note at least 5 times again, without interruption.
See it was all part of the master plan to get you to listen to the original song more ;)
This was a Rollercoaster? Please react The Poet and the Pendulum from Wembley Show, thats a Rollercoaster! This Reaction is very professionell thank you!
I agree 100%.
It's probably worth looking at the background of the song in this case, since the history of it with the longer standing band members means there are some apparently odd performance choices (specifically Marco and Emppu checking on Tuomas) which make sense in the context of the history the song narrates, but look odd to new eyes.
@@rog2224, that is very true. I'm glad you mentioned it.
It’s one of THE great live performances, period.
Truly epic performance!
Oh yeah! This song and performance disected into its tiniest bits and pieces. Awesome! I was glued to your lips. If you plan to do more Nightwish I'll surely be there to witness it.
Thank you!
I loved your last break-down of "The Islander" as well mate, although that song is a bit uncharacteristic for Nightwish. This song is what Nightwish is all about! Awesome!
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Yes very curious what you would have to say about that one!
Floor was recently on a Dutch reality show (Beste Zangers) with 6 other professional singers. Each week was focused on the music of/that inspired one of the singers. The show isn't a competition, which creates a friendly vibe. The final episode from this past weekend feaured duets.
A few must watch performances from the show:
Floor Jansen and Henk Poort - Phantom of the Opera
Emma Heesters - Strong
Henk Poort - Sound of Silence
I really loved her vilja lied... talk about a way to start a show... first performance first episode BAM! I was totally entertained :3
This was probably the most thoughtful and insightful reaction I’ve seen to this song. Excellent job!
Nightwish, Ghost Love Score is just the entrace door ... there is a lot, and I mean a truckload of amazing songs and performances to see.
The Nightwish Army is here.
3 minutes in and this is already my favorite reaction video. I love how you're able to break down what makes this performance so exciting and not just hit your audience with the "Yes, oh I like that. Oh is that a pipe organ?" You have just earned a sub from me :)
This is an awesome video ! Really makes you think how deliberate these performances are yet how natural they come across to the audience.
Oh yeah... nothing is improvised there. Everything is carefully planned.
I’ve always loved how theatrical she is, how expressive she is. This was a really complete analysis, well done!
First time see you so excited 😁 She worth it, the entire band also! Thank you
What a good reaction, I've seen a few from other voice coach pros but yours is the first that covers all aspect of NWs performance. To my mind the most important part of a NW show is the symbiotic relationship between the band and their audience, NW fans have a deep appreciation of Floors voice and all the others amazing talents and when we go to a gig we know we will go through an emotional wringer.
There is a feedback loop generated between band and fans, we support them through the emotional rawness of The Poet and The Pendulum, we laugh and smile through Alpenglow and we give and receive love every minute we are with them.
What Makes Dr. Marc Reynolds AWESOME?
-He is easy to understand, while being a total pro and a fun guy to listen to
And thank you for analysing Nightwish songs completely as it is these complex compositions by Tuomas Holopainen which make the band so special among with excellent musicians and technicians.
About the ending queue: It won't be a surprise that they did this a lot of times and it became a natural thing. This was a registration of their last concert of a world tour of 104 concerts. An amazing thing is that the singer jumped in half way the tour in the US to replace the former singer. She literally saved the tour that seemed doomed.
Floor had toured with them in her previous band, knew this song,
freestyled in soundchecks, the rest of the band loved it.
Floor might do it subtley different each time, some recent versions are even more exciting.
Love your break down, so many things to learn. Would love to see your break down on Poet and the Pendulum from their Wembley performance. Such a lot to take it and see, I recon you’d have a lot to say.
BUT to analyse Poet and Pendulum properly you NEED TO KNOW the backstory that goes along with it... it isn't just another Nightwish song... It's a song written in Tuomas darkest hours...
Now I'm really curious what you'd make of Nightwish's POET AND THE PENDULUM......please ;D
Loved, loved, loved your reaction and analysis. You not only put a lot of things in perspective, but you've also helped engage my brain to notice much more, which only makes me far more appreciative of the performance. Thank you for opening my mind and helping me to see. I eagerly look forward to further Nightwish reactions. Thanks again for the reaction. It was awesome :)
If you want a stage performance... I'd suggest Greatest Show on Earth live in Tampere 2015, It's a 24 minute long number, If you also include the outro at the end which is also composed by Toumas(Keyboard). That song allows all the bandmembers to be on stage Including their multi instrumentalist Troy Donockley(Flutes, pipes etc.).
Oh my God! You finally did it! After I asked you forever! Thank you! Can't wait to watch! Let's go!
Just wait until you see The Greatest Show On Earth (Live @ Tampere 2015). It's a 24 minute epic about life and evolution. Nightwish is a supreme storytelling band. We love them. Thanks for this awesome breakdown!
This is an amazing reaction and review. Really appreciated all the commentary on staging and the overall showmanship.
another great reaction! i've seen that video so many times and seen so many reaction videos to it and i still fall in love with floor all over again every time i watch her perform this song. it was really interesting to hear your insights into everything that went into the actual performance and not just her voice, which not many people have done. there were a lot of things that i think a lot of us didn't really register consciously, but just about everything you pointed out did have an effect on how engaged we were as an audience. i'd love to hear what you have to say about floor's more recent performance with henk poort, when they sang "the phantom of the opera" together on the dutch show, beste zangers.
Great analysis! Enjoyed your insights. To think Floor had only joined Nightwish 10 months earlier, on 48 hours notice, mid way through the American leg of a World Tour and she gives goes and gives this high quality performance! Astounding! Look forward to further analysis of other Nightwish live performances! Subscribed.
Well deserved like for this reaction and welcome to the Nightwish world of great sound, wonderful arrangements and extremely well invested time/energy
I really enjoyed this video. It was fascinating hearing you talk about all the aspects of the performance, the audio, the visual, the way she moved her body and why it worked in the moment.
Also, I would love to see a video reacting to a voice doing a healthy vibrato vs a wobble. I have trouble differentiating between those sometimes and I would love to get your take.
Thank you. I learned more in the last half an hour than I have in just about every other reaction to this song put together. No problem with the pausing, since I learned something new with every pause - that makes them worthwhile.
Thanks again.
Thank you for watching! Im glad you got something from it!
@@DrMarcReynolds And now I really, really, *really* want to know what you make of Poet and the Pendulum. Rollercoaster doesn't even come close.
The performance is remarkable...without exaggeration I've probably see this particular video many dozens of times and your ability to dissect the particulars of the piece, translating your observations into an increased appreciation for the listener is worth its weight...thank you, so much!
Thank you so much for this very detailed and in depth reaction. I love Nightwish, Floor and this song. And after watching your analysis I understand why, instead of just "feeling it". Personally I didn't mind the pauses at all, because you actually have information to share during the pauses (and I'm listening to the original almost daily anyway). Would love to see more Nightwish-Floor reactions from you. Thank you !
Such a technical yet easy to comprehend analysis - thank you!
Finished. Fantastic review. Thanks.
Now, you clearly liked this. This means you must watch Poet and the Pendulum live in Wembley 2016 asap! Can't wait for you to check that one. But: read the back story first of the conception of this work.
Great reaction 😁
Nightwish is my favourite band. For good reason, judging from this video. 😂 I want to recommend Romanticide (Wacken 2013), Song of Myself (Wacken 2013), The Poet and the Pendulum (15 minutes long) Live at Wembley 2015, Sleeping Sun (Tampere 2015) and The Greatest Show on Earth (Tampere 2015. Warning; it’s 21 minutes long. But worth it.)
mangalover0149 yours is a empty hope. Her growling
Love the new quality! I will check out all your vids from now on. Top level right here!
Nice, I'm glad you took my suggestion and reacted to this.iconic performance by one of the best bands and singers in any music genre, in the world!!! BTW, this genre is known a Symphonic Metal
Must admit : Would love to hear your reaction to "Yours is an empty hope"
Wow! What a nice analysis! This has to be the most interesting reaction I've watch so far. WELL DONE!! Keep doing your analysis, they are very clever and on point. I'm very glad that you enjoyed this performance. Greetings from Quebec Canada.
As others have mentioned, I enjoy watching/listening to different reactions and always appreciate different perspectives such as the one you provided throughout their performance. I look forward to watching for the new notification of 'cool stuff to learn' from you. Thanks!
Thanks. This was refreshing because you gave so much insight into the performance itself. Too many voice analyzes exist already :)
She knows what she's doing!! She is a vocal coach and she already did tons of masterclasses!!
The most in-depth, intelligent analysis of a piece of music I have ever heard. Outstanding! Thank you Marc!
This is the Most EPIC of Nightwish's Tracks!!! Still my Favourite Track Ever by a Long Way, but I have a lot of Favourites for Very Different Reasons. So glad you used the Wacken Version of this song, it is by far the best Version of the song!!! Although I do have a pet Love for the Tampere Version also. I Love your analytics of this song and in particular to Floor. She is such a Great Singer!!! I often ponder on whether or not Nightwish would still exist, without bagging Floor as Lead Singer. This was her first Big Stage Performance with the Band by the way!!! Which is another reason why I love this song so much!!! Emppu has such a Technique with his guitar, Love it!!! Fascinating!!! Tuomas (Synthesisers (and Founder of the Band)) is such a Composer!!! Love him too!!! Wait for it!!! Oh yes I love them all including Marco (Bass) and Troy (Pipes) LOL!!! Floor is Very A Dramatic Performer!!! Please react to some more of Nightwish's Track I'm interested for sure, maybe try The Poet and The Pendulum @ Wembley or even the Tampere Version of this song, because there is a mega pleasant surprise somewhere in that one. WOW!!!
Please..Floor Jansen/Henk Poort...Phantom of the opera from Beste Zangers 2019....
Extra props for an overall excellent analysis, especially the hidden/subliminal points of the song and staging. P.S. I agree with you, she’s gorgeous!
This is my favorite reaction I've seen - and as a Nightwish fan, I've seen a lot! You wonderfully analyze Floor's vocal skill and performance, but beyond that, you bring in a perfect analysis of the whole band's performance, including light- and stage technicians! I loved this! Thank you!
I am not a performer in any way, but I learned a great deal watching this. You are clearly a very talented teacher. And I love your analysis and insights. I've been listening to this song for 15 years (it's one of my favorite Nightwish songs), but you've given me a new appreciation for it. Bravo, maestro.
exellent analysis, love how professional you are and respectfull of the efford and talent. Love to see more Nightwish in your channel
Wow. What a nice reaction. Makes me as much speechless like the song itself. Again: wow. I have seen many (maybe over 100) of reactions to this song (because it's so good) - but this was an experiance. Getting described with words what make me feel so much by this song makes me really thankfull. I'm hooked - and of Course it would be too much demanded to react to all of the Songs of this awesome concert at Wacken 2013 - but: if I had a wish for the next months, then please please please do the two other of the "big three" Nightwish Songs: "The Poet and the pendulum", live from their Wembley Show and of Course "The greatest Show on earth" live in Tampere. Oh my god - I would be so lucky (and I believe, many others too…) ✌👌
Thank you for this! What a detailed, informative reaction. More Nightwish please! Or LP - Lost on You, or really anything live from LP!
I'm so glad you finally got to cross this one off your list! You point out things that no other reactor mentions and it's so insightful, thank you. I'd love to see you react to Floor and Henk Poort singing The Phantom Of The Opera or any other song that Floor did on the show Beste Zangers, to be honest.
Nightwish had a huge stage but these performances were on a stage the size of a stamp so it's totally different.
Edit: if you want to watch more Nightwish then definitely watch Poet And The Pendulum. Takes my breath away every time.
Okay I have watched many many many (40+) reactions to this song in the last weeks and this is honestly my favorite one now!
I love how you notice all the details and not just see and connect it, but also appreciate it and have a little smile while analysing :) thank you so much for this!
I would love to see your reaction to Floor Jansen and Henk Poort singing The phantom of the opera!
Greetings and much love from germany!
thanks for this analysis - it's not just a reaction for me, it's a very deep analysis and by the way, it's the best video I've ever heard about this song.
You notice the professional who knows and understands what he is talking about. I like more of it - especially for Nightwish there is a lot of stuff that would be interesting.
Indeed : Floor is as smart as she sings well. So imagine how smart she is !
Finally someone can put into words what I feel everytime I listen to this song!!
Excellent analysis - that was really interesting. Thank you! I'm just amazed by Floor's stage presesence and how every move she makes seem so natural and graceful.
Excellent analysis. I've watched a lot of people react to this song and you really broke it down so even those of us who don't know much about music and production can understand and enjoy this awesome song in new ways. Thank you for this.
i love this reaction. I find that not many appreciate the nuances of how their songs are arranged, performed, and translated through theatrics.
please do a reaction on lea salonga i adore her performances
Dont ever interrupt ''Floorgasm''. That is a sin hehe. This is the most detailed reaction to this epic song. Very nice. Love it. Respect!
I love your descriptions. I learned so much.
Thank you for a wonderful analysis, the technical aspect of it all makes it even more beautiful!
I love how Floor near the end is enveloped in almost preternatural darkness, calling forth fire like a demigoddess with her voice and her fist.
Good to hear someone who was able to fully analyze everything about this song - not just excellent vocal performance and instrumental competence, but also an understanding as to why the songwriting is excellent, or how well all of the performers operate as a cohesive unit!
OMG! I was so excited to see that you reacted to this! Thanks for keeping it honest - a true first reaction. You have more to see from Floor, the singer.
Oh that's a great reaction! Interesting info all the way to the end, not many speak about that kind of details on stage.
Loved your breakdown! You should try 'Song of Myself' from the same concert. Marco the bass player sings alongside Floor and magic is made!
Awesome review. This performance was awesome indeed, one of the best live performance for sure.
Brilliant.....best appreciation I have yet seen. Love them, thanks for sharing.
Cool reaction and analysis. Some points though: about the whole opera metal thing, most metal heads will happily listen to classical as it's pretty much metal pre electricity. But more seriously I think it's because we metal heads appreciate the different textures, complexity and technical skill the music requires of the musicians and the composer.
Floor pretty much crushes any musical piece put in front of her. I'm surprised you didn't mention how much she holds back her considerable power when appropriate (speaks to her skill as a singer). For example listen to where she's at power wise between the end and when it's just her, Marco (bassist, who also has a great voice by the way) and Jukka (drummer) nearer the beginning.
She's also a lot of fun to watch on stage (lucky enough to see them live shortly after Floor joined the band).
AWESOME!!! I was both a theater and choir geek in high school and I lost track of the number of concerts I was taken to from groups from the 1950s to present day. I love a performance that combines solid writing, musicianship, vocals, choreography, and overall production. Nightwish has it all in spades 😎
They’ll be on the road next year if you want to see them live 😉
Several here have suggested you react to The Poet and the Pendulum and I agree! I also think you should definitely check out Romanticide from Wembly (it’s short FYI), Shudder Before the Beautiful, and The Greatest Show on Earth 👍
Stepping away from Nightwish, I think Epica will probably blow your mind, especially Chasing the Dragon from their Respect show 😁
Thanks again and have a fantastic day!!!
Great performance! Its was a rich explanation of the work of art that Tuomas (keyboards and composer of 90% of NW músic) created. He is a genius. Of course, Floor and all the musicians are the best the world can give as well. All put together creates magic. There are too many Good songs to recommend but there are two that you will love most, The Greatest Show on Earth live in Tampere and the Poet and the Pendulum live at Wembley. In term of composing exceeds this one to me. The poet song requires you to know the back story to fully appreciate that masterpiece (choose a vídeo with Lyrics) congrats
Wow. I believe this is the most detailed but at the same time very entertaining and easy to watch reaction I have seen in You Tube. Respect, truly. That is what you could call a professional reacting. All those tiny nuances really give this song a larger than life perspective. Thank you from Finland :-)
I love how you break down every aspect of the performance, Looking forward to more, i think their song the greatest show on earth will amaze you!! Poet and the pendulum would also be good,
Awesome reaction and fantastic explanation of the skill in this performance. Thank you so much
Very unique perspective and analysis on a lot of performance aspects that usually aren't remarked upon. Loved this!
Hi dr. Reynolds! What a great way to look at this. I feel like I’ve just had a masterclass of a masterpiece - thank you!
I would love it if you would also check out the song Floor Jansen sang with mr. Henk Poort (who played the Phantom in The Netherlands in the nineties and was a favorite of Andrew Loyd Webber). They sang The Phantom of the opera. And they did it amazingly!! 🌷🌷🌷its from the show Beste Zangers 2019.
Dude! You need more likes and subs. Done both. Brilliant breakdown. Less than 20,000 views is a crime.
Working on it! Every like and subscribe is appreciated! Thanks for watching!!!
Love how you faded out her voice at the pinnacle in the end. Love it.
Great analysis - well done and some great insights :)
A wonderful reaction and analysis. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you so much.
Damn this is one hell of an analysis. Easily one of the best "reactions" on here.
We've seen people break this down vocally before but the added insight to song structure and the overall performance and production made this super interesting to watch. Definitely going to subscribe!
Awesome job, Marc!
Very informative.
Suggesting Storytime from this same show.
Thank-you!
Great analysis. And I wasn't bothered too much by your choice of moments to pause... your only faux-pas in that area was muting out the volume of her final notes at the end :)
Wow, what an incredibly detailed analysis, so nice to see, thank u for posting! So appreciate this! This allows fans to share in how much work and experience there is here. It’s not a case of just talent. These people have put in the work. 👍
When you’ve witnessed a work of art that makes you feel something incredible, and you want someone to tell you everything you don’t know about it. 😆
You've made a fantastic video. Wow, your reaction was so insightful. Thank you so much.
great reaction! this is my favorite song from my favorite band. subscribed!
This band is trully amazing,every part of members
Floor is really talent singer
I always like fact that nightwish knows how to make a show
I have to catch one of their concert in europe if i have chance
Thank you for this in-depth breakdown. I like how you brought all aspects from lighting and costuming down to vocal posture and movement into consideration of what makes this piece work. While Floor and the guys of Nightwish are undoubtedly talented, there is a ton of work done to bring these performances to this level. I'd love to hear your analysis of Floor and Henk Poort's recent Phantom of the Opera video.