Does the Evolution Sound Better? SVS Ultra Evolution Bookshelf & SVS Ultra Bookshelf Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 103

  • @Zaba...
    @Zaba... 4 місяці тому +5

    I really like the balance of laid back vs details that the OG Ultra just gets right for me. My favorite speakers are time-acurate Meadowlarks so I'm tempted by the Evos, but honestly am not sure I'd enjoy what sounded like a less laid back speaker.

  • @DrNoahBoddy004
    @DrNoahBoddy004 4 місяці тому +4

    I c a n hear a difference… there’s a distinct, somewhat forward loudness in the mids on the Evo, that the Ultra doesn’t have. On a couple sections on tracks, they (SIGNAL TRACKED) almost Identically, it was amazing hearing that!
    Any audiophiles interested in Ultras should note that, THAT evolved difference can be duplicated by some VERY slight shelving on an Eq to approximate a nearly equal variant on the Evo and save a coupla bucks in the bargain! An excellent report, and thank you.🌹

  • @paulchristman5875
    @paulchristman5875 4 місяці тому +5

    Everything that you said in your review is exactly what I heard. I hope more people subscribe to your channel as I just did. Your reviews seem very trustworthy 💜

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  2 місяці тому

      Thank you, I truly appreciate that!

  • @calvincurry8496
    @calvincurry8496 5 місяців тому +10

    I really wish someone would do this comparison between the SVS Ultra tower and the SVS Ultra Evolution tower. All I'm seen is is reviews of the Titan and Pinnacle. None of the evo tower which I understand replaced the Ultra Evolution tower!!

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +2

      I hope someone does the comparison also.

    • @Brandonbuilt
      @Brandonbuilt 5 місяців тому

      +1 with that too! Evo Tower pricing was delayed in Canada for quite some time, so I am assuming product was too? But yes, too much emphasis on the Pinnacles and Titans right now. Canadian pricing is $8000 and $6000 a pair respectively for the Pinnacles and Titans which is a hard pill to swallow for most ht enthusiasts. Really looking forward to the Evo Towers and I really hope they test better than the disappointing Pinnacles did with Erin's Audio Corner recently.

    • @michaelburton5198
      @michaelburton5198 5 місяців тому

      ​@@SpecOfTechHey.. Will You Do A Speaker Comparison With Arendal 1723 Speakers VS The Svs New ( I Believe The Titan Speakers Of Svs?) Speakers????? Have You Gotten To Hear The New Tower Speakers Of Svs , I Should Ask First??? Thanks!

  • @bobslave7063
    @bobslave7063 Місяць тому +1

    Congrats SVS, these are definitely an evolution. Thanks for an amazing review!

  • @Jedi_Order81
    @Jedi_Order81 5 місяців тому +2

    Great review! Thanks for comparing the two. I received notification yesterday the Nano’s have just shipped 🤘🏻 So excited

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      No problem, glad you enjoyed it. Enjoy your Nano's!

  • @JeffAguilar68
    @JeffAguilar68 5 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for taking the time to talk about what you heard in the differences between the two. I am glad you had the equipment to make it easier to switch between the two. I upgraded from the Ultra bookshelf speakers to the Evolution Titan speakers but did not really take the time to A/B them like you did in your room. It really would not be a fair comparison going front he bookshelf speakers to a tower speaker. Even if I kept my subs on during the comparison, I simply get better lower extension with the towers and subs compared to bookshelves and subs. I agree that the soundstage seems higher, which I really enjoy pulling the soundstage a little higher into my screen. There is definitely more detail between the two lines of speakers too. Again, thank you for taking the time to explain what you heard.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому

      I'm glad you enjoyed the comparison. Enjoy your Titan's, I'm sure they sound amazing!

  • @wilfredohernandez2257
    @wilfredohernandez2257 5 місяців тому +1

    Nice review and demo. I can definitely hear the difference with the center image dropping when you switch to the ultras and the evolutions are more clear and image is spread out more.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      Thanks for the feedback!

  • @andycamacho1112
    @andycamacho1112 5 місяців тому +2

    Very good take and comparison of these two sets of bookshelf speakers. I usually don’t hear much difference when listening to comparisons through a set of headphones. But I have to say, I did notice quite a difference. Although both the Ultra and Evolution sound great, the Evolution speakers definitely have a broader wider dispersion sound than the Ultras. I did not notice much difference in the low end, but I can definitely hear the difference in the highs and mids of the Evolution. And trust me, although I know a little about sound, I am not an expert.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +2

      Thank you for the feedback. I'm glad that some of the differences are coming through on UA-cam. What you heard is just more pronounced in person. Thanks for watching!

    • @bkrhino1
      @bkrhino1 5 місяців тому

      I run four (4) of the Ultra Bookshelves with Prime Pinnacles and dual SB-3000’s in a SVS 6.2 Music System. I stream via iHeart Radio or play custom CDs via the Onkyo DX-C390 Six Disc Changer. For the cost difference and my application, I am good. Good video for someone that does not have the Ultras already.

    • @bkrhino1
      @bkrhino1 5 місяців тому +1

      I run four (4) of the Ultra Bookshelves with Prime Pinnacles and dual SB16’s and a SB-4000 rearfill in a SVS 6.3Music System. I stream via iHeart Radio or play custom CDs via the Onkyo DX-C390 Six Disc Changer. For the cost difference and my application, I am good. Good video for someone that does not have the Ultras already.

  • @texasbuzzard4970
    @texasbuzzard4970 3 місяці тому +1

    would love to see this same video with the OG ultra towers vs the titans

  • @lbudt29
    @lbudt29 5 місяців тому +4

    I liked the Ultra better, more bass, and all the instruments blended better. Not harsh like the Evo.. I bypassed the evaluation, and went to the demo . The Evo was more detailed, but would need a sub and was harsh with some music. I see what you mean about the Ultras being backward in presence and the Evo more forward. I would buy the Evo with a sub, and some EQ. to soften some of that harshness with certain types of music.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      Everyone has their own preference, glad if you found it helpful.

    • @bearclaw5115
      @bearclaw5115 5 місяців тому

      Are you kidding? The Evo's had more bass for sure. Most audible difference to me.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому

      @@bearclaw5115 Keep in mind that the recorded demos aren't an entirely accurate depiction of what is heard in the room. We are at the mercy of what the mic picks up.

  • @arckanum332
    @arckanum332 5 місяців тому +3

    I know the price is a bit different between the 2 but how would Ultra Evolution compare to Noesis 110HT?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      The Neosis are more Neutral and can get much louder than the Evo's, but the Evo's would be better for music. Keep in mind the Neosis do not do any low bass. If you are pairing them with subwoofers, then I would lean towards the Neosis.

    • @arckanum332
      @arckanum332 5 місяців тому

      @@SpecOfTech I appreciate the comment. Thanks for taking the time.

    • @MrMichaelEsser
      @MrMichaelEsser 5 місяців тому

      ​@@SpecOfTechAnd would you say that the JTR Towers (for example the 212) ist much cleaner and seperated then the Evos?

  • @eyeshezzy
    @eyeshezzy 2 місяці тому

    cant wait for your PB 17 Ultra revolution subwoofer review

  • @fencerrandy
    @fencerrandy 3 місяці тому

    Enjoyed the recording comparisons. The Evos sound like a nice step forward for SVS.

  • @boricuanights
    @boricuanights 3 місяці тому

    @SpecOfTech I liked both speakers but I only can afford the regular Ultras. With that being said, what do you think about these kits that you can buy to "upgrade" the sound, such as ones that have better crossover parts, etc? If I can find some regular Ultras at a lower price, should I just grab 'em and forget about the Ultra Evolutions? Let me know what you think!

  • @add3406
    @add3406 3 місяці тому

    Considering the Evos for desktop speakers. Very near field (under 2ft). I'm sure there are more economic choices for such close range, but I'm really interested in tthese.

  • @andrewellett6383
    @andrewellett6383 5 місяців тому

    Great comparison video! I'm really hanging out for a comparison between the old ultra towers and the titan or pinnacle towers. Trying to work out if an upgrade is worth it

  • @vijjreddy
    @vijjreddy 4 місяці тому

    CAN YOU TELL ME - GERSHMAN ACOUSTICS AVANTE GARDE VS WILSON AUDIO SABRINA X - WHICH ONE YOU WOULD RECOMMEND, THE FIRST ONE IS MODERN, USES ALUMINUM TWEETERS AND WOOFERS, THE LATTER IS REALLY REALLY OLD FASHIONED LIKE LAST CENTURY STUFF, USES DOPED PAPER CONES.. FIRST ONE IS FORWARD AND FAST WHILE THE LATTER IS DEEP AND FULL

  • @nobody1194
    @nobody1194 4 місяці тому

    would you consider the speakers warm (laid back), neutral or bright sounding (shouty)?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      It isn't shouty. It's close to neutral, but it has a slight bump in the treble and bass regions.

  • @thecasualnoob8008
    @thecasualnoob8008 4 місяці тому

    I remember demoing the Ultra bookshelf vs My rp8000f in the only highend speaker retailer in my country. I almost went for the ultra, but for the price it wanst much of a choice because atm they both cost about the same and the rp8000f just beat it in practically every way. I did notice the Ultras were quite "rich" for their size. Wish i could snag a pair from the outlet sales, but import fees are too high, would be a killer desktop pair. I'll probably end up keeping my Klipsch for as long as I'm on this plane lol, they have a "live" sound to them.

  • @RJArrayCPA
    @RJArrayCPA 2 місяці тому

    How do you think these speakers would stack up against the all new Q series from KEF?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  2 місяці тому +1

      That's really hard for me to answer. I have not heard the Q series. If we are just comparing known preconceived assumptions about speakers. Then I would venture a guess that the KEF are more neutral than the SVS. Sorry, but that's all I can really guess without hearing them first.
      I do hope to get a pair of KEF Q Concerta Meta bookshelves in.

    • @RJArrayCPA
      @RJArrayCPA 2 місяці тому

      @@SpecOfTech Yeah from what I recall the Concerta bookshelves go for around $1,300/pair while the Q11 Towers go for $1,100/pair. Interesting that the bookshelves are higher price than the tower. Granted both are 3-way speakers. Just for kicks, go check out Arendal's new 1528 series line up, they look extremely intruiging!

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  2 місяці тому

      @@RJArrayCPA I think you may be comparing the per speaker price of the Q11 to the per pair price of the Concerto? At least in Canada, the Concerto's are $1799 per pair and the Q11's are $1499 Each speaker, $3000 per pair.
      I've been in touch with Arendal, and it looks like I should be able to get the 1528 towers in for review. Possibly in the new year.

    • @RJArrayCPA
      @RJArrayCPA 2 місяці тому

      ​@@SpecOfTechoh yeah you're correct, I misread. So in the US the Q11's are $2,200 a pair. And Concerto $1,300 a pair. But yeah, those new Arendal Towers are massive. $9,500 a pair in the US. I would consider the bookshelves or the bookshelves slim $4,500 and $3,500 USD respectively. I would look forward to your review on those, cheers 🍻

  • @eranoved6757
    @eranoved6757 4 місяці тому

    how do you think the evo compares to the revel m16?

  • @joshuad3
    @joshuad3 5 місяців тому

    good stuff, bro. i could hear the bass bump on the evos that svs claims. likewise, the evos seem a bit more forward than the ultras...if that's what you like. thanks for the work.

  • @dangoertz8030
    @dangoertz8030 2 місяці тому +1

    A little late to the party. I have owned the Ultras for a few years. Great for TV and movies but I found them a bit fatiguing with music. I tried the Evo's for a couple of months and ended up selling them a friend. I couldn't live with them...way too forward for my liking.
    Great review!

    • @libertalian_8415
      @libertalian_8415 28 днів тому

      Hello. Are Evos fatiguing for movies aswell ? I plan to use speakers as fronts for movies primarily, so which one would you recommend? Difference between them is around 250 dollars in my country. Thanks

    • @dangoertz8030
      @dangoertz8030 28 днів тому +1

      @ Not sure. For music they are. They might be better for TV and movies.

    • @libertalian_8415
      @libertalian_8415 28 днів тому

      @@dangoertz8030 I have ultra center and want to buy either of these for fronts...I see that there are also evo nano version. Don't have opportunity to listen to all of them. I was wondering which one is better and is it worth to add more for ultra evo vesion.

    • @libertalian_8415
      @libertalian_8415 28 днів тому

      @@dangoertz8030 Thank you

    • @jakanddax0
      @jakanddax0 22 дні тому

      That's good to know the evolution are too forward and more forward than the ultras. I'm surprised the ultras were too fatiguing for you since the dome design is much nicer for me after JBL 530s and a 520C. The highs for the JBLs were way harsher and were too quiet at lower volumes and built to harsh levels when increasing the input.
      Sorry to hear the ultras were too harsh. I listen to a lot of electronic music with synths and trap elements or thrashy guitar in metal, and I've found them to be a welcome relief after the JBLs. But, this helps make my mind up to probably not try and trade up for the evolution and appreciate the deal I got at the SVS outlet on the ultras.
      I'll forever be wary of horns going forward as far as fatigue.

  • @MrMichaelEsser
    @MrMichaelEsser 5 місяців тому

    Like always: great review 🤙

  • @davidross7255
    @davidross7255 5 місяців тому

    Thank you for this video, one question I had is how the evolution speakers perform with movies. The reason why I ask is because the ultras are $700 versus the evolutions are $1,200 and I would be using them for side surround speakers not front speakers, so is the sound from the evolution speakers $500 better than the ultras especially since there isn't a major difference as far as sound quality?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +2

      It really depends on your budget. The EVO are the better sounding, more detailed speaker. This will help in a home theater use case. If it were me, I would be buying the EVO's.

    • @davidross7255
      @davidross7255 5 місяців тому

      @@SpecOfTech thanks for your response. Seeing as how the surround speakers aren't constantly playing sound (in relation to the front speakers), if there were a massive sound difference between the two, I would be willing to pay the extra $500 but based on your review its a "little better" and more "evolved" speaker. I again thank you for your transparency and honesty of this review.

    • @sanonmars
      @sanonmars 5 місяців тому +1

      For surround I would save and use that money for sub or front unless I do not have any budget in mind.

    • @davidross7255
      @davidross7255 5 місяців тому

      @@sanonmars that's my plan, and since I won't have the ultra and evo speakers' side by side, my ears are going to adapt to the ultras. I will be using the extra $500 toward the purchase of the SVS ultra evolution center channel as I'm in the process of upgrading my home theater from a 7.1 to a 9.1.

  • @dodpr
    @dodpr 3 місяці тому

    Can I pair these with a SVS prime Center? I wonder if the tonality change a whole lot.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  3 місяці тому +1

      There was a noticeable sound improvement between the Ultra and Evo. I imagine the same would apply to the center channel. I think it may be noticeable if you paired these with the Prime center, but as long as it doesn't bug you, then by all means.

    • @dodpr
      @dodpr 3 місяці тому

      @@SpecOfTech Thank you for the reply.

  • @uzcateguipedromiguel
    @uzcateguipedromiguel 5 місяців тому

    Are those differences also noticeable with movies or just for music?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому

      Yes, they would be equally noticeable for movie soundtracks.

  • @SegundojPreciado
    @SegundojPreciado 5 місяців тому

    hi, i really like your videos, you are doing a great job. do you have plans to make review of ascendo speakers? since is a new brand and many people are telling are great speakers im interested on hear what you think about it

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      Thanks brother! I don't currently have any plans to review Ascendo, sorry.

  • @smonsterj
    @smonsterj 2 місяці тому

    I'd like to see a comparison with the ultra versus ultra evolution towers, centers, and PB16 versus the PB17

  • @djfirestormx
    @djfirestormx 4 місяці тому

    what sub is that with all those ports?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      Stay tuned on the channel. I have videos coming about 2 new beastly subwoofers.

  • @leatijoseph828
    @leatijoseph828 5 місяців тому

    Svs ultra center or evolution center which one best?

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      I have not heard them both, but given my experience with the bookshelves, the Evo center would perform better.

  • @rockyramayla3869
    @rockyramayla3869 3 місяці тому

    To me I’d like the sound of the Ultra cuz it’s fuller. As far as the sound stage

  • @jameskirk796
    @jameskirk796 5 місяців тому +1

    I have the Ultra B.S, and like them, but upgrading to the Evo B.S. soon. SVS is a great company to deal with. 👍Great comparison demo! 👍

    • @tcamm9812
      @tcamm9812 4 місяці тому

      you should really do an upgrade if your going to spend the money instead of a minor upgrade for the same speakers lol

  • @kozmiczian
    @kozmiczian 6 днів тому

    . . . you cannot hear slight differences using U-tube as a source. They compress the sound.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  6 днів тому +1

      I agree, the sound is compressed. But each speakers recording will be compressed equally. So the differences that were there, are still there, just not AS pronounced. You absolutely can hear differences if you listen with a resolving system or a good pair of headphones. Cheers.

  • @alwayspushing2031
    @alwayspushing2031 5 місяців тому

    Uh oh, you said it!! "Tonewinner" 😮😅😂😂😂 great review 🤘🏼🎼🔊

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому

      haha, thanks brother.

  • @chebrubin
    @chebrubin 5 місяців тому

    You really need to test there biggest towers bi amped.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      I'm working on getting a pair.

  • @colin2718
    @colin2718 4 місяці тому

    You could use a Switchbot Bot to press the A/B button with your phone instead of needing somebody else to switch

  • @psyphonyxaudio
    @psyphonyxaudio 5 місяців тому

    Good Video. Thanks

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      Glad you liked it, thanks.

    • @psyphonyxaudio
      @psyphonyxaudio 5 місяців тому

      @@SpecOfTech - I made another comment ..but I guess that was held or removed.. All good. I'm happy to see a quality comparison done.
      I need better mics =)

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +1

      @@psyphonyxaudio I don't see any other comments, not even in the "Held for Review" folder...weird. Now worries dude. Haha, yeah mics can surely make a difference. I did notice a big step up in spatial quality when I switched to the binaural mic, even after UA-cam compresses it.

    • @psyphonyxaudio
      @psyphonyxaudio 5 місяців тому

      @SpecOfTech ... All good.
      Yup .. Sound demos online are a stretch even at its best.. but its better than nothing imo.

  • @bigasagaai7331
    @bigasagaai7331 5 місяців тому +1

    I have SVS Ultra and Ultra Centre. I really did not want to hear much of a difference, because as an ex sound recording mixer, I have a little OCD and I am worried about my pocket.
    The Evolutions are a little more pronounced in bass, clearer in the highs and upper mids, very focused and detailed which on some instruments may sound strident because they are so detailed.
    But the biggest difference is not the Evolutions being higher or bigger in sound, but they have great depth. The Ultras are a little 2D, and in sound mixing this is what was the holy grail- to get depth and separation, and a lot of 3effort is used using great mikes, pre amps and converters etc.
    Bugger, the Evolutions greater depth is very stark- and a bit depressing to me-oh well, may have to sell it to my wife saying we need to go white speakers to match the white Hamptons look in the house .....

  • @jamiesmith8307
    @jamiesmith8307 5 місяців тому

    You should've done a audio clip back to back with the legacies.It'd be good to hear the difference between the two.

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому

      I'd have every troll in the audio industry on here telling me why I shouldn't do that lol. But I get what your saying, it's interesting to see the difference between uber high end and the more affordable stuff.

  • @Jnegrin881
    @Jnegrin881 3 місяці тому +1

    Ultra sounds airier and definitely a wide soundstage (to me)

  • @peterandersson6762
    @peterandersson6762 3 місяці тому

    I think the old ones sound better on youtube.

  • @rcauthen324
    @rcauthen324 4 місяці тому

    It is really worth upgrading the Ultra to the Evo?

    • @tcamm9812
      @tcamm9812 4 місяці тому

      lol no, step up to a real upgrade.

  • @HiFiMods
    @HiFiMods 5 місяців тому +2

    Are these reviews for general public?
    Because if you don’t open up a speaker, show and talk about the crossover components it really is - only describing the speaker how the manufacturer intended it to sound, while trying to save on the internal components that the public doesn’t see.
    Meaning the reviewers know very little about speaker design and how their internal counterparts make the difference to the sound… Have you tried opening one up and thinking of what any of it means??
    I see/hear - here’s a new car that looks like this, sounds like this and drives like this, but nobody ever opens up the hood and tells us how it does that… 🤔

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  5 місяців тому +2

      I'm planning a teardown for another video. Most potential buyers only care about how it performs and sounds. But there are some that want to see the insides. So I will show it in a different video.

    • @HiFiMods
      @HiFiMods 5 місяців тому

      @@SpecOfTech Sounds great, I’ll look forward to it. But more interested in their center channel. I’m trying to build one that’s similar 😅👍 Thx!! I appreciate your response, even though I may have been a bit out of place 🙃🤷‍♂️😎

    • @tedkay5272
      @tedkay5272 5 місяців тому +1

      😂😂😂

    • @cgcarlos45
      @cgcarlos45 5 місяців тому

      G-R Research has broken down an SVS Ultra bookshelf and the crossover that is in it is crap. This is where the corners are cut with companies like SVS. Don't get me wrong I own some SVS speakers I wish I knew before I purchased what I know now.

    • @HiFiMods
      @HiFiMods 5 місяців тому

      @@cgcarlos45 They’re not SVS, they’re a HiVi 2.2A DIY kit from Amazon, but I’m sure they would beat everything on the market now (Dyn Audio drivers). I did do a crossover upgrade using GR and other’s techniques ... after getting a Umik-1 measuring mic. A bit involving, but very necessary IMHO!

  • @JCOTV
    @JCOTV 5 місяців тому

    Evo vs Klipsch

    • @SpecOfTech
      @SpecOfTech  4 місяці тому +1

      Evo vs Klispch RP 600M II, you mean?

    • @JCOTV
      @JCOTV 4 місяці тому

      @@SpecOfTech yeah 🤘

  • @Breakinlife007
    @Breakinlife007 4 місяці тому

    After SVS dropped the price of the prior ultra series at the end to dump stock they devalued the current owners that there is no reason now to sell them or trade them in... due to this bad business move i will never buy another svs product again.... they screwed their current customers.

    • @Blahmanwhysoserious
      @Blahmanwhysoserious 4 місяці тому +3

      Your old speakers are still good though…. Im sure the new ones are nice but worth replacing stuff you already have? Doubt it. I was interested in the new Ultra Elevations but for almost double the price? No thanks. I’ll spend my money on more room treatments and probably get better results.