A Buddhist asks Sadhguru a Puzzling Question
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лип 2020
- A vipassana practitioner approaches Sadhguru with a question that he has been unable to find an answer for anywhere else. In his own inimitable style, Sadhguru demolishes the questioner, beseeching him to make an authentic effort to grow. #Vipassana
#Sadhguru
Yogi, mystic and visionary, Sadhguru is a spiritual master with a difference. An arresting blend of profundity and pragmatism, his life and work serves as a reminder that yoga is a contemporary science, vitally relevant to our times.
Sadhguru Exclusive (Register Now)
⚡ isha.co/ex-yt
Sadhguru App (Download)
📱onelink.to/sadhguru__app
Official Sadhguru Website
🌎 isha.sadhguru.org
Donate Towards Crafting A Conscious Planet
🙏 isha.sadhguru.org/sanghamitra
Offerings from Sadhguru in Challenging Times
🌼 isha.sadhguru.org/sadhana-sup...
Guided Yoga & Meditations by Sadhguru (Free Online)
🌼 isha.sadhguru.org/5-min-practices
🌼 isha.sadhguru.org/IshaKriya
Inner Engineering Online Program
50% off | FREE for COVID Warriors
🌼 isha.co/IEO-YT (Register Now)
Official Social Profiles of Sadhguru (Subscribe)
🌐 ua-cam.com/users/sadhguru?sub_conf...
🌐 / sadhguru
🌐 / sadhguru
🌐 / sadhgurujv
🌐 t.me/Sadhguru - Навчання та стиль
This guy asked a very valid question. Respectable.
Valid but useless
@@Ajay-pj2hv not useless. Questioning can never be useless.
but still he got the question. it wasn't answered.
@@majorgeneralrahul6298 if you think that, you haven't encountered enough questions
@@Ajay-pj2hv I agree, I haven't encountered enough questions. I am still learning. And so are you.
"The only real purpose of life is to explore it in its fullest depth and dimension."
--sadhguru
I appreciate your channel
@@wisdomofyogi1 nice collection of videos in ur channel. keep it up..
💚
@@gokukn2336 Thanks for your support to become part of Sadhguru's mission to touch 7 billion lives...
Wisdom of yogi life and life and just life alone just live a life.
Never seen a Guruji as intelligent as Sadhguru..full of knowledge, simplicity and humbleness.
Krishnamurti is about the same.
@@Ludifantjiddu was just a philosopher. He keeps talking and talking. Blah blah blah bark bark bark. All bark no bite.
The Buddha, who belongs to this world, preached the nature and truth of this world 🇱🇰
Thanks for these beautiful words
Agreed
but this world is unreal, ever changing always in flux as per buddha then how come he belongs to something which is not reality(world) buddha said i'm nothing then how come nothing belongs to something ?
@@sujal1943 not nothing it's emptiness
Especially in vipassana,practitioners are encouraged to know by experience.I was once curious about lot of thing's and went from teacher to teacher only to realize everything has to be known through experience.
may be that is what keeping shut and just doing means...bc when u just do, u move forward with wondering, stressing or contemplating much..u have no fear, no assumptions only work...hence making u faster in ur journey in achieving and through that process itself u keep learning faster from experience...life becomes easy and worth working for..i dont knw if m correct but that is my logical approach towards understanding this vipasana thing as i heard sadhguru talking about the basic rule of it
everything about yourself. not necessarily everything. e.g. you should not eat poison in order to know that it is poison by your own experience.
@@spdadventurer1754 sadhguru is wrong about Vipassana, its not shut up and do. Few Vipassana practitioner disagreed to it.
@@agnirelaxgaming i am vipassna practitioner too i was there for 11 days....sadhguru just said it wrong he did not meant ...he actually meant..that first you do somethinga nd explore it yourself...this is not a press conference
He must find his own answers. The only way to answer this is he himself. It's like asking what were I 2000 years ago but the question is how end up this karmic cycle if I had not karma at the point of my origin!
This can't be answered theoriticaly it can only be experienced. It is beyond. He is Simply asking who am I? Who was I? I am sorry that is what am looking for? _/\_
Brilliant. SG barely took even a moment for thought, and then launched into this comprehensive explanation that covered EVERYTHING implied by the question. The explanation appears to have been wholly created in his mind in an instant. It was well considered and well organized. A masterpiece of exposition executed on the spur of the moment. I suppose that is what happens after years of just doing it.
Indeed Richard! Just brilliant!
question was good.🙂
And don't forget the humor, which is of big value no matter how big the knowledge and the experience is: it's love for life expressed.
Just the fact that Sad Guru talks of demolishing the questioner reeks of arrogance!! People have genuine questions. If our so called guru is so enlightened, he would do well to answer as best as he can. Making fun of someone does not behove well for a guru. To me he's just a charlatan.
Centuries of Knowledge from Thousands of lifetimes
2:00 Spirituality,
2:39 Physical Chemistry
3:40 quantum physics
4:13 astrology,
5:54 biology (Theory of evolution)
7:06 spiritual (Karma)
7:35 psychology
You have attained enlightenment 🧘🏻👏🏼👏🏼
But no answer at last
@@defencenpolitics2719 u were not listening, that's y u didn't get the answer... Hello... wake up dude!!!
@@GenghisKhan3105 he didn't answered
@@GenghisKhan3105 why then rebirth?? If it's all about making from atoms.
Atoms are still existing don't tell ki ab they don't exist now new things started
I can 100% guarantee on the statement "DO IT DO IT DO IT, It will slowly transform you". A piece of evidence from my recent achievement. In the beginning, a task that seems very simple, I failed terribly but I did not stop trying. Rather than being worried about failures, I started to focus on the tiny improvements every day. After almost 15 days of continuous try, I successfully achieved it, and it's evolving to better quality every day since then.
For Dicent Divan. An important concept in Buddhism "NO BEGINNING OF LIFE." and "NO BEGINNING OF TIME"
Most people accept the idea of an infinite future without question. But I have always felt that he past must be infinite also.
@@robertcammack902 that's what i always get deep thoughts about ,
In science and dharma the beggining of life , and universes , and the big bang - theories have been made regarding them
But no mention of the beginning of time or is time infinite (no Start no end) has been made - not that i know of
I would really like to discuss it with someone , is there a community i can join
"Showing moon by finger" we should look at the moon not the finger. There are so many theories in religions and science about beginning of existence, those theory really doesnt matter to us because we are already here, existed in this universe. This discussion will be just to surprise each other so, the real question is how to liberate oneself? Not worrying about past future.
@@Sonamdikey1516 i understand what you're saying
But i have different curiosity
By " existence " scientists say that big bang is the start of universe and time,
But there has to something before big bang in order for big bang to occur
On other hand , time and space must've always been there and by always means there is no beginning / no start , and since there is no beginning then there is no end
This is very hard to comprehend by human mind
Foolish
I love watching Sadhguru laugh with his entire body! He always makes me smile.
One day you will see him in jail with Asaram bapu
@@vinayakparab6517 you're funny
He laughs and people claps, seriously? Don't be a sheep.
Nice, I saw it but didn't have words to say it. Laughing with full body it is (Y)
😀
One thing I have known from these five six years I have been blessed with sadhguru's presence is that, you never ever try to sound smart while asking a question. A question should only come out of pain of not knowing. If the question was structured to sound smart, you had it. Lol. I love him. He is the love of my life, I cant believe I said that to a 60+ bearded man! hahaha but thats the truth.
What happens if you try to be smart with sadhguru isn’t he supposedly absent of ego
I hear you, same here, love Sadhguru!
@@thejeweller1 The ego is the conscious mind, it comprises the thoughts, memories, and emotions a person is aware of.
@@sheevinopalpatino4782 if you don’t have those you don’t have to worry what people talk about you
@@thejeweller1 Brilliant... finally... someone...
Sadhguru didn't clearly answer the question.He just rounded the conversation.
Even I think so. But he did say that it is not relevant to seek why it happened.
@@saketsgh3966 but I suppose that is what is called spiritual awakening...you start asking such questions
@@kirandeshmne6165 yeah I know. Although, it’s a waste of time to ponder over such questions because they won’t help you understand what is the self or what you are - which is the most relevant question for spiritual seekers. I feel like the origin of birth question can be answered only when one breaks the cycle of life and death
@@saketsgh3966 I think the question would become irrelevant when one breaks the birth-death cycle, I mean it would be pointless if the question occurs then. So now would be a good time to ponder over that. One doesn't look at road map after one has arrived at the destination. It is good to be inquisitive about origins. till date studies are being conducted to understand the starting point of the universe which is the big bang and the preceding singularity.That is his spiritual journey, he is allowed to think for himself, have his own questions and find the answers for himself...we can't refute his questions saying that question was irrelevant or it was not worth answering
He asked a question which was an indecent way which is he said the Gurus at Vipassana Meditation could not answer. If Sadhguru answered, it will be looked up as a competition of Intellectual nature between the teachings in Vipasana and the methods of Sadhguru. Sadhguru has more experience than all of us and he answered it wisely. SOmeone who seeks such question genuinely, he overtime understands that the answers to such questions are not factual knowlege, but experiential knowledge. The way one finds such knowledge is personal and the answers are personal too.
Vipassana does not mean "No questions". Vipassana means "Special seeing/Insight" . Besides, Buddha's teachings are full of questions answer sessions with Laymen, Learned Men, Kings and Saints. Buddha spoke elaborately about Vipassana and answered all questions related to the practice.
It happened differently... Not like the way you are saying.
He didn't answer these kind of questions. Not to them who were practicing Vipassana atleast...
Life cannot be understood through words , because words are not accurate in life matter. I can tell someone how beautiful the flower is , but to really see how beautiful the flower is , one has to see by himself. Words can only deliver so much , and misleading as well. To understand life , we can only understand through ourselves.
@@Llucius1 couldnt agree more ...👌👌i feel the same
But sadhguru said buddha dint answer to the common masses while he was moving everyday..thats not the kings
@@spdadventurer1754 I mentioned Laymen as well. Not just the kings.
Budda was asked the same question.His answer was There is no beginning there is no end to this process of rebirth.He referred to the sand on the sea show.Can you count the number of sand particles on a beach.We have been born and died more times than that yet we do not know.He asked not to worry about the beginning or end.
No brother there has end but not beginning there has end because when we achieved enlightment that's end.
And Sadghuru gave the same answer. Blessings!!
In my ignorence i think shadyguru gave the same answer.
There are a countable amount of grains of sand. If there were infinitely many, the whole universe would be filled with grains of sand. The question remains unanswered and poses a serious problem
@@liquidoxygen819 what serious problem are you talking about?
"I pray that whoever reads this and is going through a difficult time, don't give up, good things are coming for you, you will achieve your dreams in this lifetime"
Thanks🙏
Speaking words of wisdom let it be let it be. -the Beatles.
And he loves you. Om Shanti
Thank you... 🙏🏼
Thank you, I wish the same for you
Idk how I came on your videos, but I'm very happy I did. I have a huge problem with life and it's so hard to let go. I find your wisdom relaxes my mind. Thank you for being you🙏
The voice and tone of the questioner, and the brilliant question itself shows he has attained a good level of spiritual development. All metaphysical questions cannot be answered in words. The Sadhguru's reply was evasive, and questioning the motive of the questioner was not expected from the wise man.
he did his best, he is not god. in my view correct answer is that everything is maya and it takes many births to realize it. karma is the path taken to realize it. if you take incorrect path, its bad karma, if you take right path its good karma.
@@yoppindia If that's his 'best', he probably should get down the pedestal.
even if I feel some kind of sadness, or maybe even disappointment, I can't disagree with you.
Yeah I thought it was a good question and I didn’t really like the answer from Sadhguru
There cannot be a perfect answer than this. Because you also need to accept that sadguru is also a human. So he can answer upto this extent only. That it's irrelevant. Nobody can answer it. Cause it's like we are a person made of salt went into sea which is like universal truth to understand and just became a part of it. We just can't return to tell it to others. That's the difference between intellectual and intelligents. Intelligent doesn't needs to proven to other until you know it.
It is very worthy question. Lot of ppl on spiritual path might have the same question. I respect Sadhguru...but here he passed his own judgement about the person who asked question and was kind of insulting in front of others present there.
I'm thinking the same
true. i never saw sadhguru insulting someone like this before and self praising himself that he is a straight forward nd genuine person... maybe he was high on something that day... 🤔 he was definitely rude in this video...
hope you find my Answer-comment to that question !!
He kinda hate Buddhism
Ok
The most Brriliantestttt question I have ever heard 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I don't think the question was brilliant or maybe it's over my head,I believe the question if in fact the question was a real 1 and not staged for this program or lecture was exactly as the guru stated one to try to make the Guru look foolish and not one of pure positive informational intent.
Sadhguru, Thank you for your unconditional love, patience, perseverance and teachings🙏
Sadhguru ‘s openness, vulnerability, and humor is endearing. Sadhguru reminds us not to waste time with unfathomable questions
And that I am not your monkey!
Just do it. Do what is existential in you.
Be 🐝peace 🕊and love 💚
I find it intriguing when ancient civilization talks about creation: Energies, vibrations ecc... And now science came to the fact that in fact atoms are just excitations in the quantum field..
And you had the dark Middle Ages which almost destroyed the entire ancient classical civilisation.
Yes indeed excitation has to be there or else there is no movement if there is no initial movement there is no creation.
How did the "excitations in the quantum field" get there?
@@jeffreyluciana8711 you tell me 😂
Science didn't come about it now, India's had Anu and Parmanu since ancient times
If we all think about the beginning, there will be no beginning. Because if there is a beginning, we will still question about the time before that.
Right
Exactly! One can even question creation and the creator. What was there before and what created the creator.
For me... time is only part of the 3rd dimension that is limited by time and space, which are both part of the same. In the material/3D dimension we can perceive things little by little, second y second... But 4th dimensional things can be perceived by our mind from the future or past, they are seen at once in the 4th dimension where time doesn't exist and space doesn't make sense. When you say "the beginning" That's only part of 3rd dimension which have time. The beginning is the start of only the 3rd dimension, and is hard for our material brains to comprehend a dimension with no time.
Existence itself is timeless i think. Time was just implemented to measure and keep track. Existence is a constant timeless happening where there is no beginning or end; because there was something , or the void, happening “before” the beginning.
@@RedPill.Action Exactly. Imagine being a big consciousness that knows that it exist, but without matter. Knows everything and can do anything, and there's nothing to learn or do. Wouldn't you make a more limited dimension to live, observe yourself from different perspectives and evolve despite having everything?
I wish I could sit and have tea with this man. Such a presence. A couple hours to speak about your books and some topics I have studied myself would be such a gift. Your words flow like water, your mind is a wondrous waterfall :)
He doesn't drink tea I think,They don't do inyoxications
It is not necessary to have the desire for the company of a wise or enlightened person. You have all the peace and fulfilment within yourself .. more than you could ever get from a guru or spiritual master. Think for yourself.
I've been following Sadhguru for quite a long time, he has added so much value to my life. But this is the first time I'm not convinced by his answer.
"No teaching, no question. Just simple instruction. Get the instruction right. Just do it, do it, and do it. Slowly, it will transfer to you." I like these sentenses. Everytime listen to Sadhguru, I feel further understanding of life.
Same instructions were given to terrorist, just do it, do it, without asking the question, result is terrorist attack.
Cross checking of what you are doing is very important.i believe.
That sounds like a brain death existence.
@@atulpatil2289 Understaning what you are doing and having a good heart are important.
You teaching so accept questions too ....
@@atulpatil2289 same with soldiers.. Do it do it do it.. Result? Bombing in Iraq, Libya and afgjanistan
I went to vipasana, what Sadhguru said is absolutely true. Vipasana help you to realise with help of practice but it's really hard and takes huge willpower but it is transform you as a human.
Can you please tell me, that what vipasana is?
I wants to know about it, please.....
@@avikatrigun1764 Hi Avika, you can goto their website and search nearest vipasana center. Thankfully it was very near tome so i gave it a try. But I'll recommend to you. One must experience it in their lifetime.
@@mhvr8508 thank you....🙂🙏
Hare Krishna 🙂🙏
@@avikatrigun1764 hare krishna 🙏. Jai hanuman🕉️
He's so well spoken absolutely delightful
The mind is a beautiful servant, a dangerous master. Buddha
Exactly!
Absolutely right 👍👍👍💯💯💯🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
What is the Mind ?
@@patrickmonaghan9783 mind is not a single entity..it is comprised of many thoughts.
@@himathuhina4823 it depends on your perspective
Sadhguru I love your honest and directness. I was seeking an answer and found exactly what I needed to hear from one of your other videos. Since then I have been listening & watching your videos each day. I also am participating in your course. Thank you for all you offer the world.
But it was not perfect answer.
@@priyokantichakma2071 Is there one?
hope you find my Answer-comment to that question !!
what is the video you mention here..
@@priyokantichakma2071 ..answer is there...maybe others failed to understand ....let me make it simple...monkeys can't produce human beings..but we know humans are transformed from monkeys...this transformation is always happening and that's what sadguru said because of karma it's happening....this is what actually rebirth because of karma means....it doesn't mean ur first birth was a human being..u may started of as amoeba..about first birth...sadguru said even science says atoms can be created in vacuum by energy revebration....energy revebration is also a karma..
Thank you very much Guru Ji for talking about my Lord Buddha. May all blessings from the world of Buddhism empower you.
He is fond of Buddha . Just like most of the spiritual seekers on this planet .
Roots of Buddhism is connected to Sanatana Dharma. And we are Dharmic. So no Dharmic one will hesitate to talk about another Dharmic beliefs. ❤️
@@meenagondhali393 you always pay homage to your seniors and learn from it
"Those were good times for the gurus"... comedic genious
Because discipline has little ego.
Love this "put you into place" answer from Sadhguru.
Sadhguru, Being Honest & Straightforward is not a handicap, you're fabulous the way you are!!!!
क्रोध, काम और बहिर्मुखी (extrovert) चिंतन को छोड़ कर.... अंतर्मुखी (Introverted) मनन से हीं स्वयं को पाया जा सकता है !
अजीत ओझा
Healing Touch Foundation
Karma is build even as an insect
@@skkaul1
But, before coming to exist as [any lifeform], we had no karma, and it would seem that we also had no desire. So, why did we become a lifeform in samsara?
@@1StepForwardToday very good question
@@1StepForwardToday cells + cells = 2 cells.
2 cells +1 cells =3 cells.
3 cells + 1 cells=4 cells. Now close your eyes. U see anything that is the answer of your question
15:35 “That question or the answer will not in any way add to your practice." Fully agree. That's why the Buddha also don't answer such questions.
Kumāra Bhikkhu So you know what questions the Buddha did not answer? Tell us where this is written down. Do not tell us your phantasies about the Buddha. He was enlightened, but this unwise guru demonstrates how far he is from enlightenment. Investigate your attitude, it may be painful, but bring you some insight. You know.
@@maluawho3732Budha once said as per the Pali texts, That I can teach in detail...it is those who understand that are hard to find
Since u are specific about where it is written and how to prove everything, this is another one.
In Pali texts, There is a beautiful Story, Which is very well preserved in Buddhist Texts..
Few students came to Buddha and said we are leaving ur teachings because you have not answered us whether there is life after death, Or if there is any other dimension/world of existence.
Budha replied - Did I ever say I will answer to these questions?
Student - No lord u didn't.
Budhha - why do you think that I never said I'll answer to any of these questions?
Because these are not the things that you need to know..Thing that you need to know is, how to deal with suffering.
Because at this very moment what makes u ask such questions is suffering.
Now u may Interpret it in different ways.
Anyways.
@@fc4rthworldfifaproclubs60 what if u want to ask a question not out of suffering, but out of curiosity or in order to gain more knowledge
@@phoenixj1299 how can a creature in existence actually and honestly answer the question of non-existence… even if it tries, it’s a fallacy…you can try theorise it… but will that be the truth? how can u prove that’s the truth? live by experience… seeking is not wrong but just ensure ure seeking is not hindering ur living because that becomes a suffering… at times knowledge (seeking) hinders understanding…. knowledge with/from experience comes understanding and then only true wisdom. and yet i can’t guarantee that i’m right.
@@maluawho3732 I agree with you that sadhguru is unwise, but I can confirm @kumara's statement, the buddha did once not respond when asked about the existence of god.
I love how Sadhguru has the wisdom to never chastise a question, but rather understand the perspective it comes from and give an explanation, often times which is simpler than you'd think.
he is not a guru. he is just a well payd babbler
What? Are you outta mind? He just mocked his question and never gave an answer. He bent and twisted the entire session around the question and his followers were laughing like a brainless herd.
@@jackeyniraula True
*I love the voice of a person who narrated the question*
Why don’t you go buy a ring then 💍
Ya about voice of the fellow who asked this question, lovely,heavy, charming, comprehensive,God bless
Not all questioners are trying to prove they are intelligent. Some might be genuinely asking that. Blaming these genuine people and calling them "fool" is not right.
I think the bigger point is that the question does not matter or stems from the wrong intention, even if it isn't to deceive the guru
Questions answering is a pool. And u cannot jump in that pool without knowing how to jump
@sri harsha, very true.
as to the origin or originator; a master will tell you the question is to put your mind in a hamster wheel. And in all your striving for an answer you will be right where you started.
SG didn't do what you say. This question precisely was not stemming from genuine pain,, but from the need to disqualify the master... It came from someone who THINKS he's been "practicing" vipassana, but still hasn't the faintest clue why questions might be the problem... But if the need to disqualify the master IS his "genuine pain", let it be, SG doesn't give a sh*...
The beauty of life is to perceive queries and to patiently hear the answers, which are coming, certainly , rt now, rt here, from within. One should be humble enough to accept. Thankyou very much my Dear Sadhguruji.
This is one of the best answers from Sadhguru I've heard. He explained things right from the subatomic level to biological life with such simplicity. So much to learn 🙏
yea it is awesome how is knowledge of science is backed by vedic practice and vica versa!
"energy can neither be created nor be destroyed" I guess this is a simpler answer to the boy's question😂
I can see so many sadhguru's in the comment area.
😂
You should learn from all of them... 😄😄... only vipasna 👍
:D
then it must be a good result for sadhguru, appreciation for sadhguru!
@@mncconsultant3189 by reading his cmnt I think he actually doing vipashyna.
Buddha never said ' just do it '. He said, ' do it if u find it to be true by your own experiences'. 'Atta deep bhava' means be 'your own lamp'. This statement gives freedom to mind to ask and seek or self development or self study. The questioner should not have said that ' everyone said no one could ever answer it'
क्रोध, काम और बहिर्मुखी (extrovert) चिंतन को छोड़ कर.... अंतर्मुखी (Introverted) मनन से हीं स्वयं को पाया जा सकता है !
अजीत ओझा
Healing Touch Foundation
@@mncconsultant3189 chintan bahirmukhi ho ya antarmukhi, usme kitni gaharai hai yah chij main hai. Antarmukhi chintan nishchit hi shreshth hai bahirmukhi se kyuki shant man se kiya chintan bahut gahara hota hai.
It started... right now. In this very moment. We need to update our relationship with time in order to comprehend these deeper questions. This moment right NOW, contains the start, the middle & the end. ❤️🙏☀️
We appreciate u Sadhguruji for taking people for a ride .. May god bless all of us...
Vipasana means unbiased keen observation & not effected by experience.
Dear Guru Ji,
Greetings!!!
Without you, it could never be possible to understand science & spirituality all together!
Sadhguru I think it’s cosmically astounding that I watched a video a few minutes ago by the 5th kind which triggered a thought that maybe civilizations have existed on earth many times before and that this technological age of man might not be the first or last instance of the cycle of human life on earth and now here I am watching your video and you speak of 84 creations it makes me believe more firmly in universal consciousness thank you for continuing to spread the wisdom of the ancients 🙌🏻
I'm ignorant to this, but where does the number 84 come from?
Thank you and long life SadGuruji , you powerful word giving me positive energy every time, sincerely grateful
It's a "baap of all questions"
😄👍👍👍👍
@@sakusuzi9031 😊😊😊😊😌😌😌
What is a "baap" ? L W-X
@@lawrencewolfe-xavier5951 baap means father
@@thefire398 Which language?
I wish I had Sadhguru for my grandfather, so many fun stories...never get bored!
What's wrong with your own grandfather?
I love the way you are straight and honest. !!!
I'm a true Buddhist...I was very moved by Sadhguru's answer
a true Buddhist doesn't need to let others on the internet know they are Buddhists.
Sadguru is great. But I feel how
Buddha said just do Vipassana n don't ask without teaching. How funny. There r 84000 text in Buddhist teaching n philosophy.
Your answer is satisfactory to the question but it is totally wrong that it's easy for Buddha to tell people Do it n they do without a questions. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@mike8147 😂😂😂facts
@@mike8147true that’s not the goal but that doesn’t mean your not a true Buddhist if your genuinely trying in any walk of the process your a Buddhist, do they come out of the womb masters? They would say no
It was really a good question
@Santha so according to jagdish vasudev human Is created by some kind of energy so there is no God and if energy created the very first human then what is the role of karma or good or bad in the birth of a person and if god hadn't made human then who is lord shiva,vishnu and bhramha..
Making fun of a person who asked such a good question is not the quality of a SADHGURU..
@@praveenschauhan6519 well god isn't certainly a man or a women it's an energy they are described as man and women in the Vedas so that people could understand easily. And I asked the same question to my guru and he did replied that no one can answer this
The answer was so pathetic. He did not answer it. With no inheritance of mind, thought , form, karma how did he come to existence. He strategically avoided by going to less related areas.
@@dulanhasanthajayasooriya8284 I agree but the decent man also said that he tried asking several gurus and no one could answer it because no one knows about it
There is no begining point where you can say here i didnt exist and came to exist later since ignorance is not eliminated you are being born again and again no matter how far you go into past you will always be existing only when ignorance is eliminated you cease to exist and will nor appear anywhere again.
this is what buddha in pali suttas
i am surprised their are many questioners to sadhguru..and many of them asks very beautifully in a calm and kind way..
So wise, so great answers, thank you dear Sadhguru for your being ❤️🙏🏾🧚🏿♀️
Sadhguru Namaskaram🙏
Your honest and straight answers have enlightened us and I sincerely feel we are blessed under your kind direction…
A Big Thank you Sadhguru 🙏
We will get this answer when we Enlighten from negative emotions n every darkness ...
Thank You SADHGURU - An enlightened Master Unparalled, Unmatched and The Ultimate GURU of the times.
Gratitude & Pranams
nobody is enlightened for it takes an action to be (enlightened discovers ones own shadow)there is Only nothing rest is ilusion (Maya) Structured so that we may enjoy the external energy of the Lord.
As to Why all this that is Lila , ( Just for fun) His Fun, and by extension Our Fun, this fun must involve learning however, and that is the only condition for rebirth.
He’s just a wise man, nothing special. Isn’t always right. You should never adore a guru more than necessary.
@@UKViking Guru is important not God. Guru is the one that opens and clears our path towards God.
@@montysharma8271 you find answers through life experience and meditation. Listening to guru makes you feel good and empties your wallet
@@UKViking True to certain extent but meditation is a long path full of distractions and illusions therefore Guru is needed to guide us which clear our path however it is very hard to find true elightened Guru.
Sadhguru still answered the question. He still took time and suggested the questioner to practice Vipassana and realize ones self. I think we are so fortunate to hear through a living Buddha.
Yes, yes!!! Just Do It!!! (I doubt Nike understood it on this level!) When thinking about things I have done that I did not understand previous to doing it, without any instruction, I realize that the act of doing it gave me an understanding that questions and answers could never have explained, and that could not possibly match the level of understanding I attained from "just doing it". Instructions given in words and pictures are not enough to give a proper understanding. This is why the ancient Egyptians used hieroglyphs - they are NOT a primitive form of language, but a "language" that represents what words and sentences cannot, and the great thing about hieroglyphs is that each time a person "reads" them, the MORE they get from them. Back in ancient times, a person learned more and more from the same hieroglyphs the older they got.
Giving instruction to someone who thinks they know everything takes many more hours to get them to the place where people who don't assume they know everything are already at.
I'm practicing Shoonya since 8 months. I have to tell you guys all my questions just burnt away.
Im in a different level of understanding now.
I didn't get sadhguru ans
Could you please elaborate for me then.....
@@praveen6710 its subtle answer
it will take time for u
@@anirbanbhattacharjee4188 smartass! thats just another way of saying you dont know! if thats not true then please elaborate as requested by @j . j . ..and enlighten us :) he/she asked a simple question, so stop giving answers like some enlightened guru, and share your understanding
How to do it? Pls tell me
@@vijayatman dont ask a question to some one else ask it to your own brain .......
Every word you utter syncs in me so easily! I seem to flow with your energy so smoothly that even without meeting you in person, I still feel so much connected with you❤
It's because you ate magic shrooms, isn't it?
Being straight and blunt makes you the greatest guru alive to begin with. Perhaps one of the greatest ever! Your honesty is awesome, your wisdom and knowledge are awesome and your willingness, no joy in sharing it, is awesome! People feel connected, you speak to each and every one in a hall of hundreds and no one feels left out or neglected. Whenever you sense the slightest barrier while teaching, you effortlessly (so it seems) find a different approach to make sure your words are clear and confuse no one. Your audiences are in awe of you, but it is joyful awe if that makes sense. You give people joy in their own existence; they matter.... and they leave with hope! Thank you, Sadhguru!
He really loves us. I see it in his eyes.🙏🙏
"We have enough religions to make us hate each other ; but not enough to make us love one another" !
That's what Jonathan Swift had said !
If you are an "eternal" being, why would you have a beginning?
The question asked by the young Buddhist indicates he knows little about his path. This point is covered in the suttas. Any knowledgeable teacher would know the answer. However, dwelling on this question is an impediment to awakening.
Contrary to Sadhguru, vipassana IS asking questions, but the right questions. Those are questions about your beliefs and comparing them to the Dhamma. Vipassana must be balanced by samatha.
It is normal to ask, "What was my origin?" But, it is not a helpful question if your intent is to awaken.
If the answer is in Suttas please answer.
If u can't tell how many times I'm reborn in earth with facts,just don't keep on saying that bcz in the garb of your so called knowledge u tell us to first reach that astute and then we will understand.
I think where u want us to reach is a state of manipulation so I can start bobbling my head and agree on each and every point.
I think everyone should be able to understand answers to any questions in this world which are related to your life.
Don't bring me Maths and tell me do u know the basis of Pythagoras theorem,that would be diverting from your question.
Tell me how many times have I taken Rebirth?
Just because someone has spend almost all of life into something which in appreciated In India and easily to mend Indian Crowd, doesn't mean he is right.
At the End he might have realized that there is nothing in God,but now that I have put lot of efforts and practices and voracious readings,I should use this to drive people and manipulate them and get the Feel of the King.
Questions are questions and if you dont have answers u insult them
@@yaaallah2448 🤔👍
@@yaaallah2448 👌👌👌
Buddhism is inherently flawed tbh
@@realeyesrealisereallies97 No, it isnt. Atleast, I havent found one Single Flaw yet, so if you could bring forth any examples of wrong Statements I'd be suprised.
I like the "good" blunt(ness) of Sadhguru b'cos he knows exactly when one needs or deserves it! Not a handicap at all, it is a quality of a genius. "Straight" to untangle the complications of nowadays society, is of profound direction for those seeking the truth in oneself. Not a handicap also. So honest that Sadhguru doesn't waste nobody's time. Thank you.
Dear Sadhguru, from now onwards i am a honour follower of urs, ur every answer to a question is a godly one as well as the scientific theories implies to the answers. Great one!!🙏🙏🙏🙏
“To handle yourself, use your head; to handle others, use your heart.”
― Eleanor Roosevelt
Beautiful quote
heart is just a pumping organ. a brain is the organ which decides how to handle...
„The most beautiful moments in life are moments when you are expressing your joy, not when you are seeking it.“
Sadhguru 💚
Yes, you are too straight n blunt and you r owsm sadguru ji🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
What a simple way of explaining...
🙏🙏🙏
Question was just like who came first
The egg or the chicken
It was the chicken chicken didn't lay eggs before they evolved to laying eggs. It was the evolutionary process. From Dinosaurs Birds came then chicken then eggs it was an Evolutionary process. You can google this Birds are living form of Dinosaur era flying Dinosaur's survived and evolved into birds to survive. I am not saying i know everything but to my knowledge and understanding chicken came first just like babies didn't came first it was the human form that evolved first.
@@kappa633 you haven't gotten anywhere...
Its the egg that came first
@@nikhilaenugula8148 so the egg just popped out of nowhere genuis. All makes complete sense now
@@vvv2k12 google it you will be knowing read about life forms on earth
He always said be joyful in the "I don't knows of life" - This question BOTH can and can't be answered is the point. Even if it could be answered definitively, it is of no consequence to your growth as a human being and the wellness of others around you. These questions are meant for you to feel like you "know all the answers" psychologically to please your intellect only because most people are unwilling to do the actual work Yoga requires.
Feels like he gave a glimpse of the true knowledge he has and everyone went like he didn't answer the question...
SadhGuru you always make me smile even at my hardest part of my day. Love you guruji.
“You have power over your mind - not outside events. Realize this, and you will find strength.”
― Marcus Aurelius
no that's not what we think, wonderful thing about u is being honest and straight forward ⏩
It was a great question....so profound that the audience went quiet for a moment and then started applauding. I think the answer can be found in a video by Mr. Hans Wilhem called "Spirit, soul and human being". Here he explains that we were all pure, selflessly loving spirit beings residing in heaven world but due to our desire or karma, for e.g. thinking of being equal to God or selfishness, we fell to a lower realm and were called fallen souls. The tendency of any being is to return to home, so to expedite our return to heaven world the fallen souls are given opportunity to reduce their karmic burden through human body. The soul cant suffer so can't get rid of karmic burden. But if it enters human body, then it can reduce karmic burden through suffering so that its return to heaven world is expedited. It makes sense too, because when one himself suffers he easily empathizes with sufferings of others and tries to help them. Many of the NGOs or individuals who strive to help the society have themselves, or their loved one, suffered. So by helping others they can reduce their karmic burden.
Beautiful way of telling. Thank you.
To the person who asked the question: You asked a question Lord Buddha has preached us not to ask. We have been born innumerable times that it is very difficult to find the beginning of our being. So Lord Buddha asked us to try to understand reality of life and attain Nirwana. When you do attain Nirwana, you will realize that you do not need the answers to these questions anymore. And karma is a deep subject matter that we lay people do not understand completely. Only and Only a Buddha is able to explain the complete process of Karma.
If wish to know how a life come to being, Lord Buddha has explained starting of the life in Indaka Suthra
Read Agganna Suthra. You will find the answer to the question how the world came to be.
I disagree that a certain question can't be asked. That's what the other religions mandated from their followers, everything stop with God.
It is said that the day when you are borned, the day of conception, are not your birthday. You are there already. Keep practice meditation and mindfulness, right actions, rightthoughts, etc, obtain nirvana...your question will be self explanatory!
@@ratanaun2960 Well my friend, agree with you with the part you said keep practising. May you attain Nibbana.
hope you find my Answer-comment to that question !!
Amali mapa, with most respect i am asking this, how can you say only Buddha can answer that ?
Ok
Sadguru you are too modest : being straight forward, thou it's hurts many, and being honest with your answers are positive qualities which are very rare in this world of illusion and deceptive people.
I'm sure u haven't heard anything about Vipassana except from Sadhguru.
Superb question and answer will help many people with such doubts
"everything is in the middle. Seed is needed to make a tree and tree is needed to make a see. So we can't say one came before or how it started. It's like that, there is no beginning or end, it's just the middle. A plan of existence"
The most incredible thing is that you can know everything you wish to know with your eyes closed.
George Harrison?
In that case, you won't know what you don't know..
Thats so funny! When you close your eyes,you are bound to be taken advantage of!
That is true because the whole universe comes from the mind
who are you?
The Buddha actually answered this himself. He is said to have looked though all his past lives and couldn't conceive a beginning. Saṃsāra just always had been like that.
You are wrong..!
@@dhammikab.3512 Are you just gonna say that or do you have any proof to back yourself?
@@gandalfthemaroon1684 which busshism do u practise, Mahayana or Therawada ?
@@dhammikab.3512 Tibetan Buddhism (Vajrayana)
Could you please link to a source where I can read more about this?
All these questions have to explored by oneself....Intellectual answers....Nobody can answer on this earth..It is beyond mind and matter...Just practice Vipassana to the deepest core...All questions will b answered ...Enlightened...
This was the perfect time that he should have just said "I DONT KNOW".
Bingo!
Yes
Decent Diwan and Thank you ganguly came to ask vipassana questions in the session.
One should ask question without saying ' no one has ever answered it yet ' to really seek for the answer, but not to provoke or insult the person to whom you are asking. Its ok if no one ever answered but someday the aswer is surely gotten. We must not be impatient and our own research and seeking from intellectual persons must be continued with humility and calm mind till the satisfiable answer or information is achieved.
I agree,however in this case,has anybody ever covincingly answered "where we actually came from?",of course there are various answers given by religions and scientists but are they themselves sure?They all admit(scientists) ...it could have been...only various religions are sure!And that we all are sure cant be true!
Any question has an answer. It should not be a problem to the speaker to answer the question. Speaker need not snub the the person who has placed the question. By snubbing method you don't help the society to get a technical answer to the question. Speaker should have taken this opportunity and given some lesson to the listener. which would have been more appropriate.
@@radhakrishnanv2286 if the way of questioning is blended with arrogance or ego, no one will ever have the patience to listen complete answer and the whole conversation spoils up. How politely normal people ask questios to a powerfull businessman or politicians we have seen. Though they dont answer some questions, people dont ask them again why you are not answering them. Try this with your boss in office or local corporator or police or local mp and see how they overpower and stop questioning of normal person without any backup. If someone has patience, that does not mean the questioner can ask in egoistic way.
@@radhakrishnanv2286 but do agree that questioner should say that 'no one ever answered to my questions' ?
hope you find my Answer-comment to that question !!
Great answer Sadhgurujee, respect for the guy for asking a very valid question, that will definitely come into the mind of anyone curious about this life 🙏
Straight n honest is my handicap, Sadhguru you are my teacher, I love you n thank you ❤
When you can't answer question it's easier to say that the questioner is puzzled.
He did answer but with a sense of humour. That's it
@@akankshatiwari4250 what! how, what sense of humor, he just denied. He can't answer. He should not pretend like he knows everything.
Karma is not associated with only physical means even if there's a certain ideas initiated in your mind is by accident or something, karma is happening, that's what he said.
Is this too complex for you too understand it?
@@learniteasy8146 The discussion is about existence not about karma
@@nonglenkhomba6713 he started with big bang, how it happened Energy dance, basically it's E=mc2.
.That's how einstein explained it.
Then he mentioned theory of evolution, by Charles darwin,
Then when evolutionary process separated humans and chimpanzees,
The story of karma started.
He was not giving comtext about these, but if you are a good reader of science, this all you'll know in an instant.
So please don't judge based on your assumptions that you have achieved very little. Please read first.
I like the peaceful atmosphere of that place. It's so soothing 🧡
Wow! That answer! Just Wow, blew my mind
Namaskaaram Sadhguru.
I'm trying my best to follow the instructions without my logic and intellect getting in the way.
Although knowing very well that your logical reasoning and sense is what attracted my strongly athiestic mind in the first place.
Hope to continue to seek until I find the answers.
I admire your knowledge and the ability to soothe our mind. But guruji, this time you did not answer the Qn of the person, Mr. Descent!
Hey he did.... You didn't get it. He explained it very well.
He did actually. The problems is our minds don't want accept it. So it tells us he didn't answer.
@@supbar2007 what a load of bull.....even a deaf person can make out he didn't answer, just made fun of the questioner.
@@danishtrivedi5800 So what's the answer according to you he must have told.... Ask your mind😜
@@ayush09pattnaik89 well I don't pretend to be a guru. If he doesn't know the answer he should be honest. He just insulted the questioner. A genuine guru would not do that.
Great answer! Thank you.🌞
Thank you dear Sadhguru, your teaching is the most truthful teaching there is. Thank you !!!!!!!!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Sadhguru, its not a handicap, i appreciate yr straight forwardness so as not to waste my time trying to figure out what u are saying. I love it . Tqvm