Opinel Carbon N10 vs Buck 110

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лис 2016
  • XC90 vs 420HC
    Hi everyone,
    My intention was to simply test cutting performance of the blades with "cheap" steel level, i.e. plain carbon steel (Opinel No. 10) vs. stainless 420HC (Buck 110). I did not mean to compare working performance of two blades of different price levels.
    Well, I realize the music is not so cute to the most people's taste. It was just my maiden experimental dubbing, so please pardon the noise

КОМЕНТАРІ • 115

  • @nakinp8525
    @nakinp8525  6 років тому +74

    Hi everyone,
    My intention was to simply test cutting performance of the blades with "cheap" steel level, i.e. plain carbon steel (Opinel No. 10) vs. stainless 420HC (Buck 110). I did not mean to compare working performance of two blades of different price levels.
    Well, I realize the music is not so cute to the most people's taste. It was just my maiden experimental dubbing, so please pardon the noise

    • @advmotorrad
      @advmotorrad 5 років тому +2

      Bro you did really good job.. thanks for saving my money.. really i could not feel any difrance between both .. n i have opinal.. so now im really happy to have that one 😀 no more intrest in buck 110...

    • @MichaelWebber
      @MichaelWebber 5 років тому +3

      I like both Opinel (in the carbon steel!) and Buck. The Buck used to me too heavy but now they have introduced an LT model with FRN handles, no liner. They are great! The Buck is thicker steel designed for toughness, the Opinel is designed to be a folding kitchen knife (in terms of thinner blade, better edge geometry for veggies and slicing meats like salami which tends to split). Better to have them both than to have to choose! Impressed that the Opinel wood handle and shallow tang held up ok.

    • @megadeth22885
      @megadeth22885 5 років тому

      i found the music entertaining

    • @Motoguy94
      @Motoguy94 5 років тому

      So what was your opinion of which knife did better?

    • @05jorgeruiz
      @05jorgeruiz 4 роки тому

      I like the music ...

  • @raphaelargus2984
    @raphaelargus2984 3 роки тому +18

    I have both an Opinel and a 110, I love them both, for different reasons. But I had the 110 for 36 years---that's toughness and longevity in a knife that you gotta respect.

  • @cocabandi
    @cocabandi 6 років тому +55

    You would expect the Buck to perform this task well, as it has such a beefy profile. But for those unfamiliar with Opinel knives, don't let the lightness in weight or thinness of blade deceive you. The Opinel, as you saw in this video is equally up to the task. It's no wonder Opinels are world famous. 👍👍👍

  • @cantstandidiots5839
    @cantstandidiots5839 4 роки тому +16

    And a decent stropping would restore both. Carried a Buck 110 for years until I recently discovered Opinel. Now I opt for the lighter weight and Equal preformance.

  • @knownaigm
    @knownaigm 7 років тому +157

    Nice vid but that music was pure ear cancer.

  • @meg412
    @meg412 6 років тому +49

    14$(opinel)vs 94$(buck)
    In my opinion the winner is Opinel

    • @69GROMINET
      @69GROMINET 6 років тому +2

      What luck. In France it's between 100 ans 200€. Opinel is between 10 and 20€ according the size.

    • @wickedwonderingdream
      @wickedwonderingdream 5 років тому +1

      Tesla alseT buck is 36 and will last 100 years if taken mother moderate care

    • @arctickilla5424
      @arctickilla5424 5 років тому

      Dependin in were you get a Buck 110 the price ranges from $30-$80, for instance in my local Lowe’s it’s $60

    • @mythowrose2742
      @mythowrose2742 4 роки тому +1

      That’s odd to hear I live in America so the buck 110 can be had for ~40 and the opinel for ~15.

    • @russellwyatt9693
      @russellwyatt9693 3 роки тому

      It’s 40 bucks for the buck not 94 and buck is way nicer and more durable

  • @emiledufour5412
    @emiledufour5412 7 років тому +5

    thanks for the comparison

  • @Lex5576
    @Lex5576 5 років тому +6

    Edge performance was about the same. But if I were to have the job of cutting up 100 coconuts, I'd take the Buck because of the better ergonomics. An Opinel is also ergonomic for lighter tasks, but they'll fuck your hand up if you have to do hours of heavy duty cutting.

  • @zebradun7407
    @zebradun7407 Рік тому +2

    A Matter of personal choice, I have both, I prefer carrying the Opinel 6, 7 and 9 according to what my day is planned.
    Same with the Buck 110 or similar.
    I prefer the Opinel lighter and thinner blades, if I am going to cut vines, light wood I go with the thicker larger blade.

  • @bobdenarres5378
    @bobdenarres5378 5 років тому +1

    Fascinant.

  • @advmotorrad
    @advmotorrad 5 років тому

    Tha k you for your sharing .. then whats the diffrence between them only brand tag? I have opinal .. i was thinking to buy buck but after watching this i really dont want that... thank you

  • @user-ye1im3hj5q
    @user-ye1im3hj5q 4 роки тому +7

    OPINEL!!!

  • @danielmuller1572
    @danielmuller1572 4 роки тому +4

    When i watched this video the second time i was in a weird way happy about the Music.

  • @user-vy5px3sy6s
    @user-vy5px3sy6s 3 роки тому

    Good work 👍

  • @rideswithscissors
    @rideswithscissors 6 років тому +17

    Never mind cutting paper, try a ripe tomato! But I think the Opinel won for edge retention.

  • @ricardocastillo5485
    @ricardocastillo5485 Рік тому

    Both are awesome! If you are lucky enough to have the resources, get one of both! Buck is a great company. I prefer the No 8 Opinel, seems to be "just right".

  • @nguyenmanhpham6742
    @nguyenmanhpham6742 5 років тому +1

    bao nhieu ten vay co sip ve viet nam k

  • @lehung8309
    @lehung8309 5 років тому

    bác mua con opinel ở đâu thế ạ

  • @arze6849
    @arze6849 3 роки тому +3

    Muy buenas navajas, en mi opinión la buck quedo más afilada que la opinel yo me quedo con la buck se ve muy fuerte, elegante y lejendaria.

  • @petergambino2129
    @petergambino2129 9 днів тому

    Opinels are so much fun to customize! They are light weight excellent very affordable knives.
    The Buck 110,and 112 are the best built and like Opinel offer the best value for the money. A Buck 110 will last for generations to come!

  • @grizzlycountry1030
    @grizzlycountry1030 5 років тому

    🔊🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶 😎👍
    Love that funky music with the footage.

  • @stevehuffman7453
    @stevehuffman7453 2 роки тому +3

    Without watching the video, I know the results.
    The Opinel is the better cutter/slicer, thanks to the thin blade stock and acute edge geometry.
    The 110 is more robust, and possibly more ergonomic for consecutive hours of use. Provided you're not doing something stupid, like stabbing something, either blade lock is suffiently strong for normal use. A slight advantage going to the Opinel, however, for the blade lock that the use of which is optional.
    I've never used the blade lock on any of my Opinel's. I've never cut or amputated any body parts by not using the lock, either.
    (Opinel didn't even add the ring lock on the size 6 and above until 1955. The size 5 and smaller still don't have it.)
    Neither is suitable for batoning or chopping. Which, as Vinnie has proven time, and time again, isn't necessary if you rely on skill and finesse, rather than brute force. 👍
    Mr. Vinnie, a Question if you don't mind?
    Have you ever tried any of the Portuguese MAM friction folders? They make them with or without a "Press to Release" TL29 Electrician's type liner lock.
    Personally, I prefer the lockless. I have the "large" sheepsfoot and "medium" MAM3A spear point (which they call a drop point) Both 4 inch closed with a 3.5 inch blade.

  • @hungle1773
    @hungle1773 6 років тому

    bác mua dao ở đâu thế ạ

  • @eseeskull8439
    @eseeskull8439 3 роки тому

    😂👍👍👍👍💪💪💪💪exellent !!!

  • @kaewkusolsuponthorn8777
    @kaewkusolsuponthorn8777 6 років тому +8

    Opinel

  • @thomasharrison6367
    @thomasharrison6367 6 років тому +4

    The Buck is as we all know a great knife but it comes down to geographics... the buck 110 is obviously cheaper to buy in the US whereas in the UK and Europe it’s expensive.. £55 ($74) if you shop around but the usual price is £80 ($108)!!! Compared to £12 ($16) for Opinel No10 Carbon! Vietnam it’s about the same price difference and if you can just about get away with doing your thing with the Opinel rather than the brilliant Buck 110 at 6 -1 it’s a no brainer,

  • @zxcbfadbnatrn
    @zxcbfadbnatrn 3 роки тому +1

    Theorically, Opinel has a full flatt Blade and for that kind of work Is Better than hollow grind.
    Had u have that impression?

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      it isnt full flat grind. it has a very tiny second bevel

    • @zxcbfadbnatrn
      @zxcbfadbnatrn 3 роки тому

      @@HaraldSjellose full flat has microbavel

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      @@zxcbfadbnatrn never heard that before

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      and everyone talking about opinels on internet says 'it looks full flat but actually has a second bevel on it'

  • @f.tscent1158
    @f.tscent1158 4 роки тому +7

    Opinel has thin blade I always have the feeling its gona break

    • @fe02lix
      @fe02lix 3 роки тому

      I was carving a little bit to get a point on a atlal the egde chipt on little use

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      @@fe02lix well it isnt made for carving..simple knife for simple use with a simple price

    • @fe02lix
      @fe02lix 3 роки тому

      True

  • @petitponey914
    @petitponey914 6 років тому

    pareil

  • @Dolmio24
    @Dolmio24 6 років тому +4

    I've just been diagnosed with cancer due to this music, save yourself!

  • @ronaldoronaldo4898
    @ronaldoronaldo4898 7 років тому +4

    guter vergleich.

  • @viseshseernam39
    @viseshseernam39 3 роки тому

    what i done that the french knife haslost it extreme sharpness when cutting hard stuff such as coconut

  • @G11354
    @G11354 4 роки тому

    Great video, which did you prefer?

    • @nakinp8525
      @nakinp8525  4 роки тому +3

      I love Opinel for cutting and 110 for classic beauty

  • @luisnunes3220
    @luisnunes3220 6 років тому +2

    And the winner is: the Music! Very fun!

  • @rtaylor61
    @rtaylor61 3 роки тому +1

    I've got both. Love them both. But this is almost a Laurel vs Hardy comparison. But then again, it's not.

  • @adamkepka8965
    @adamkepka8965 7 років тому +1

    In your opinion...which is better?

    • @nakinp8525
      @nakinp8525  7 років тому +3

      Opinel Carbon better than, but its rust

    • @adamkepka8965
      @adamkepka8965 7 років тому +3

      Phương Nguyễn
      In Poland we say "something for something"
      Greetings from Poland 😆

    • @xDarkPrototypex
      @xDarkPrototypex 6 років тому

      Howard Pearcey your chemical formulas for iron oxide are completely off. When you are using Fe3+ the correc formula is Fe2O3 (red stuff), and when using Fe2+ the forumula is simply FeO. Get your chemestry straight.

    • @xDarkPrototypex
      @xDarkPrototypex 6 років тому

      Howard Pearcey No problem, im just a little obsessed with chemestry ;)

    • @xDarkPrototypex
      @xDarkPrototypex 6 років тому

      Howard Pearcey whats wrong with my spelling? I dont really use ' much because im on an ipad and its a pain to constantly change keyboard for a UA-cam comment.

  • @cool_hand_luke97
    @cool_hand_luke97 5 років тому

    If you find any carbon in that opinel let me know.

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      @@unnamed47 i think he is trying to say that carbon content of opinels blade steel is very low, but still nonsense since its 1090 steel with 0,90 percent carbon

    • @guillaumelecocq5525
      @guillaumelecocq5525 3 роки тому +1

      I think opinel uses 1075 carbon steel. 0.75% of carbone. Here in france we call this steel xc75 and is the most used carbon steel for cuttelry. Less hard than 1090, but breack less, and easyer to sharpen

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      @@guillaumelecocq5525 No sir, it is xc90-1090-c90 grade steel. Source is their own website

  • @ArcticGator
    @ArcticGator 7 років тому

    Wouldn't mind it if you had done the same with the aranyik lol

    • @tuanvuanh742
      @tuanvuanh742 6 років тому

      He had done the same with an Aranyk equivalence. It's almost the same blade from Aranyk but this one is made in Vietnam.
      Check it in his channel: ua-cam.com/video/qwnbem1QwVE/v-deo.html

    • @tuanvuanh742
      @tuanvuanh742 6 років тому

      Another coconut chopping test, compared with Kabar Becker. Same profile, bigger blade though.
      ua-cam.com/video/eTpGDqgJ9BA/v-deo.html

  • @chicco1948
    @chicco1948 5 років тому +1

    zero/zero right?

  • @cclion6589
    @cclion6589 6 років тому +1

    メンテナンスって大事だな

  • @ventsolaire
    @ventsolaire 6 років тому +3

    I like your video.
    Although I do not fancy your music either, however, I have survived worse.
    Above all, it is indeed kinda cute.

  • @russellwyatt9693
    @russellwyatt9693 3 роки тому

    Hell yes buck baby way better knive in my little opinion

  • @felinebline7154
    @felinebline7154 2 роки тому

    Opinel ..Antonini.. And M.A.M. are best in the world.

  • @crazyhorse7584
    @crazyhorse7584 5 років тому +1

    I've had Opinel knives, and they're good knives but easy to mess up. The vid below shows how hard it is too hurt the American classic Buck 110.
    ua-cam.com/video/UP75zLlOP5U/v-deo.html
    You for sure can't do that w/an Opinel (you shouldn't do it to your Buck LOL).

  • @mickeymickey2188
    @mickeymickey2188 5 років тому

    What is tha fruit ??
    I'm from centrall EU , not kiddin' , I can't reconize ... .
    🍍😇

    • @nakinp8525
      @nakinp8525  5 років тому +3

      Its fresh Coconut

    • @mickeymickey2188
      @mickeymickey2188 5 років тому +3

      Thanks ! That was my first tought , that is "fresh" coconut ( I saw only on TV ) ... But I didn't know , that "stuff" is so thick. Here in Hungary we don't see coconut in this way ... Only that brown inside ... . Lol ...! 😯😇😆😋

  • @BTeamHooligan
    @BTeamHooligan Рік тому +1

    Buck 110 is a hunting knife made to slice, skin, hack/pry through joints. Opinels are fine knives as well for uses.

  • @pierre-yvesguerin63
    @pierre-yvesguerin63 3 роки тому

    SOLD

  • @fredgdn549
    @fredgdn549 3 роки тому +3

    Opinel 12,9 €, Buck 89 $ (75 €)....any other question ?

  • @squidnigga6985
    @squidnigga6985 6 років тому +5

    Hey guys generic dubstep here

  • @tylerrohn6938
    @tylerrohn6938 7 років тому +5

    Worse noise than nyan cat. Good compare vid though

  • @gcalvaro
    @gcalvaro 5 років тому +2

    Both blades lost part of their sharpness.

  • @DeeegerD
    @DeeegerD 6 років тому +3

    Disappointing edge retention on both knives.

  • @D5quared91
    @D5quared91 5 років тому +1

    The Oh-Pee-Nehl is a good knife but the Buck 110 is far more durable and tough!

  • @DuyTran-nn9cf
    @DuyTran-nn9cf 2 роки тому

    Vãi, hóa ra ông này ng Việt

  • @arctickilla5424
    @arctickilla5424 5 років тому +1

    Opinel:
    Pros: cheap, comes sharp, easy to sharpen
    Cons: cheaply built, cheap materials, 2 handed open
    Buck 110:
    Pros: Quality made, quality materials, forever warranty, not expensive, comes sharp, will last literally forever especially with the warranty service, easy to sharpen
    Cons: 2 handed open

    • @neo187420
      @neo187420 5 років тому

      You can one hand open both of these knifes. Just takes a bit of practice and dexterity.

    • @HaraldSjellose
      @HaraldSjellose 3 роки тому

      @@neo187420 and it harms its pivots in the long run

  • @noahfb1
    @noahfb1 3 роки тому

    Opinel for slicing, buck for more robust tasks.

  • @ThatIsOneRichSmith
    @ThatIsOneRichSmith 4 роки тому

    had to quit this video, the music is impossible

  • @Cypy1985
    @Cypy1985 9 місяців тому

    Opinel parece un poco mejor

  • @killough71010
    @killough71010 6 років тому +5

    That is the worst song I ever heard

  • @pault5947
    @pault5947 6 років тому +2

    down vote for the irritating music

  • @Saad_Khan952
    @Saad_Khan952 6 років тому +3

    buck is best knife in the world