The Middle Ages in 3 1/2 minutes
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лип 2013
- An animated timeline from the book 'Science: a Discovery in Comics' by Margreet de Heer. More information: margreetdeheer.com/eng/science...
There's also an animated timeline of the History of the Earth: • History of the Earth i...
*Who else is here from school lol*
me lmao
Same😭
@@ericroberts7655 OOF
mee lol
me
STOP✋🛑 Don't scroll down and procrastinate. Concentrate on your work.
Mitsuki lol
أنت تؤذي ذيلك
Ok-
גווד פה
no lol
who else is watching cuz of covid-19 and homeschool
jollytube yeah I’m watching it right now for school lol
jollytube yeah
Yup im watching it for history ;-;
Me ;u;
@@daniellacarby2580 same
The crusades
"Sir why are we attacking"
"I dont know why just do it"
"who won sir"
"I dont know"
Is the crusades a bunch of people?
@@milenelopez9307 good luck for the essay or test lmaoo
Byzantium is so overlooked here, as if it wasn't the Rome's eastern brother
Stefan Bogdanovic yes indeed
As if it wasn't ROME
It was't just Rome's brother, it literally was Rome, or at least the Roman Empire. Just because the West half was disintegrated doesn't mean it was game over for the Empire.
For sure true
I was about to consider showing this to students until I saw how stupid and biased this was.
Why do think it's biased?
Well let's see. First let me say that although I wouldn't describe myself as religious nor conservative - I live in an area where many people are - so I'm weary of both sides of historical interpretation. There are a few issues with this. One is that it suggests the Crusades just began out of nowhere, as if Christians just did them for fun. It ignores Muslim conquests into Europe as if they didn't exist/weren't provoking a response. In general, it completely leaves out any sort of cause of the Crusades. It leaves out the Seljuk Turks' attacks into the Byzantine Empire, which is what directly led to the Byzantine Emperor calling on the Pope for help. It adds little text bubbles above the crusaders "Let's attack Muslims!" or whatever it says... A student watching is going to get the impression that they were just for fun, an exciting religious conquest. Now it also describes Christianity as an add-on to education during the time of Charlemagne when it was actually the centerpiece. I'm not a religious person, I have no stake in this. It's just interesting how it doesn't show (and even suggests to the contrary) how much of a dominant role churches played in education. Also, it acts as if the plague "undermined" the church...that's completely subjective and debatable. It could be argued that the church was strengthened after the plague. I could keep going, but those are the just the main things that popped out to me as I watched.
prehistoricRAP Thank you sir or ma'am for not falling into this trap! I'm happy I met someone with rational thinking and the capacity to see beyond flashy graphics.
prehistoricRAP Excellent. The video also failed to mention the Reformation which was kind of a big deal.
oh so peaceful catholics helping other christians eh?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Crusade
here educate yourself about "crusades" pretty please
www.usna.edu/Users/history/abels/hh315/crusades_timeline.htm
the crusades had more reasons to start than "just defending againts angry muslims"
For 3-1//2 minutes _Overview_ and not a treatise on world history over a span of 900 years, I appreciate this.
You sir helped me pass my history final with this short video!! Well done!
An enjoyable little summary. I really like the art style and it gave me a giggle in a couple of places.
I realize that some simplification is needed, but just to point out when Leonardo da Vinci was born, the Italian Renaissance was well under way, since the prior century, in fact. A precise date is not really possible, but I think there is a general consensus that it began in the 14th century, whereas he was not born until 1452. Petrarch is generally considered to be an early Renaissance figure and his work was most notable in the 1330's-1350's.
Loved it! Great work! History told in the most interesting way in a short video!
Mr.Margreet I'm currently writing a book where the civilizations in the book is quite similar to the middle age,your brief had helped me a lot!
Awesome
F A K E N E W S compass was invented in china way before the 1200s
Indeed. The Chinese used lodestone to navigate through fog.
Ye school made me
pandemics as well
@@johannehelland5726 your mother's children were invented by me
You have shown my students how bias gets in the way of what is important. thanks
Paddy Wack Youare SPOT ON! ! 😂
Wow! So great introduce. Thank you for posting.
"So great introduce"
@@emmettonline lol
Thank you so much! Just what I needed! :D
Oi! Crossbow was created by the Chinese like 800-1000 years before the crusades!
and also compass u dumfuck, really pissed u said compass was created in europe
U never knew that china helped the islams, pitty
plus printing press
columbus wasn't the first european to arrive in america
+Justin A. Lee yeah the first was a frenchman
Constantinople was a very important city to Europe, and after the city was taken by the Othmans (The Turks), it was one of the main reasons that ended the Middle Ages.
+Luffy in turkish school they teach us that is the end of the middle age. so agree with you beacuse after falling constantin some of scientist escape to the europe
ottoman turk invasion of egypt (trade route to india)*
dwarfplayer what
The Umbrella Academy fans: Now it's Istanbul, not Constantinople-
Awesome video!! Thanks!
Nice work on the hand animation...
no matter what team nadeshot is on, we will still love you for who u are.
awesome ... short and great fast video....
nice work!
Great video
This is very cool video I will sub u!
great video !
this video was well done!
and just for the record, this video was really short, obviously it wasn't going to get down everything. People want their religion or race to always be superior even in the past. history is history people. Yes the middle east was far ahead of us in science, and yes Europe was stupid.... get over it.
Kind of biased how you mention The Crusades but not the rise of The Ottoman Empire...
thats what i thought……
this video is shit and lying
Great video.
:O I am in awe. This is so amazing. So well done!!! My goodness. Thank you!
Good thing that's not the case :)
What's with all of you thinking the same thing, even after I've indicated otherwise? Is this how you develop your unearned confidence and false sense of security?
Let me be clear: I enjoyed how they compiled important pieces of history into a video. It was well done, and I appreciate how they made it short and sweet because I was taking a history course, in which most of these facts were referenced; it allowed me to stay interested in a class, which was not of my major.
Simple? I think so.
Rich Perez Some people are just too rude...
The only thing I didn't like about your video was towards the end, when you mentioned that Columbus discovered Americas
gfcf14 well, Columbus was the first man outside of the americas to discover them. Ofc the natives had discovered it, nobody else had
@@comrademew6803 actually, it was supposed to be Leif Erikson who made it to America first in around the year 1000, but granted he only lingered around the north of Canada
Whoever was the first Homosapien to discover the Americas was the first Homosapien to discover the Americas technically speaking which was probably thousands of years ago
Columbus was the one who did in fact discover the Americas in the sense that
1: He had no concrete knowledge of them before he arrived and thus finding himself in a new area unknown to him is called a discovery.
2: It was only after Columbus found his way to the Americas that others began to follow suit. Leif Ericson did not cause large numbers of people to begin moving to the Americas, so his "discovery" is far less significant historically in that there was little impact on the world.
Therefore, Columbus being the first man to sail to the Americas and bring back information that led others to sail there as well means he did in fact discover the Americas for Europe to begin settleing there.
Great video!!... Thanks!!
I was able to follow the timeline in spite of the loud bias that kept interrupting
it just confused me more pls explain
So you know how there’s EPCOT Park where there’s a bunch of various countries simulated as tiny villages? I’d love to have that but for different eras. Like a time travel park.
This is a nice video
gets almost 1 million views because are schools forces us to watch this stupid crap lmao
LMAO
imma gonna leave a dislike to the video
Why don’t they make us watch bill wurtz’ video of the entire history of the world and save themselves 6 years of educating lmao
2:47 Sounds familiar
Latino América
What is the music callled
Wow, that was entertaining and educational. Thank you for your work.
Good work, thx for the comment
Hoi, Margreet! Leuke video!
The music slaps. Anyone know the name of the piece?
Wat een klus! En wat geweldig gedaan! Respect :-)
were is the 3 field system? And the Hanse (trading alliance)?
@BenkethePirate the video is 3 and half minutes long...not everything can fit in there
@@Marmaidena Well then the creator of the video shouldn't claim that it is literally 1000 years squeezed into 3 1/2 minutes.
If only I saw this before the test! 😂 great video!
you are a good drawer i have to say
Wow. You totally ignored Justinian, his corpus juris civilis and pretty much everything about the byzantines, even their fall, which marks the end of the middle ages.
The crusades were not so much a holy war as much as a religious pilgrimage in which cities would have to be retaken. They were also a response to Turkish raids of Jerusalem and the moorish occupation of Iberia.
What is the name of the song you used?
Padu bak hang
Love from Malaysia
Very reasonable! Thank you so much!
13th century: "Finally we see some progress." Okay, this is not the Middle Ages, this is mainstream history. During the Middle Ages, NOTHING was more decisive than agriculture, not the crossbow, not the compass, not the windmill, not even the influence of the Church. There were a HUGE amount of innovations regarding agriculture during that period, and without those innovations, we wouldn't be where we are now. Yet, we don't hear of it, because you stick with that biased Renaissance view of the medieval Era.
"Science: a Discovery in Comics", you say? No, I'm sorry but this is not science. This is fairytales. Learn some history and demographics before you pretend to pass knowledge on our children.
Gaius Baltar o come I think you dint read the history
I am 10 years old and I know better than you
James Lee thanx
Now I'm confused on what history should be the turth. Where do we find proves of fact of what really did happen in the past? Do you even sure if what you believe to be the truth of history of the world is the real truth? How can one proves it?
Damn, everyone is hating.
Hi, can you send me link the picture from this time ua-cam.com/video/6EAMqKUimr8/v-deo.htmlm30s (3:30)? Thx
Crossbows were not a new Invention in the crusades the the first account of crossbows were actually in China in the 6th Century BC and the first European Crossbows were found in the 5th Century BC. Most of this information is from this Wikipedia page sorry if any of it is incorrect en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_crossbows
so good
excellent!
Why did you paint the Christians in a bad light?
Hamish Ryan hmm maybe because,y’know,they WERE bad people back in the day?!?
@@ecolieee628 It is lame/BIAS. Crusades were a way to rid the Muslims out of Europe/Africa/Eastern Europe and take back what was originally Byzantium and Christendom. The Muslim menace was even in Ibera (Italy) which was eventually taken back by Christians. Christians were raided by, vikings, attacked by ottomen Empire and attacked by the Muslim menace. Everyone was "bad" back in the day lol.
No mention of the Magna Carta even...
@@hellinterface6721 The crusades were first taking back, later they attacked muslims original lands.
awesome!
You drew knights in plate armor for the 1100s, which predates the existance of plate by a couple hundred years.
this video burns my eyes
Fabulous and the incidental music too. Is there a young kid's version, say six thru ten?
Que aplicación es?
2:47- Mr. Peasant, I don't feel so good.
*SNAPS!
Were did you get the song form
i like this video!
What are the three time periods that make up the middle ages
This is a treasure. Congratulations on your wonderful work! Este es un tesoro. Felicitaciones por tu magnífico trabajo!
I sort it's important to point out that the foundations for the university system was first laid down in Europe in the twelfth century. There have always been "schools of learning" and Al-Azhar in Cairo and Qarawiyyin Mosque in Fez, Morroco claim to be the continually oldest because they are now universities. But there were many schools of learning in India and in ancient Greece too prior to this. I think it's important to point out that the recognizable system that we know as a university (with the recognizable university academic rankings etc) has been applied backwards to these schools. Does this affect this info graphic? Only that the Islamic world did not have a "university" we'd recognize them today. They had schools of learning of which some have adopted the university system since.
But in Arabic they call the ones you mentioned "jami'a"
Which translates to University
@@Mitsuki_Yukito The system of "university" cannot exist before the first university was created in the 11th century. You can say a word is a translation and it doesn't indicate when that translation got that meaning. It's a translation and the meanings of words change all the time. If someone said "jami'a" meant "university" in the 10th century that would have been impossible because the concept of a university hadn't been invented, so they couldn't apply the concept. As an example, someone today could decide that "jami'a" also now means "airplane" (I know it doesn't, its just an example). You wouldn't then argue that because the word "jami'a" has been in use for centuries it means the airplane was invented years before it was actually invented.
@@harryunderhill5041
Oh I get you
Thank you this is so helpful for my midterm
Te falta el virus, la corona ya la tenes
nice video :D
Forgot the Byzantine empire :-) . I wonder why people forget it, The arabs and eastern romans- byzantines were into glorious era in the Middle Ages while in west it was a dark era..
People sweep the Eastern Romans under the rug most probably because the catholics in Western Europe where not fans of Orthodox Christianity (the religion of the Eastern Romans) and in the Renaissance, people in Italy who glorified the memory of their ancestors in Ancient Rome didn't like the fact that Rome still actually existed, but maintained by ethnic Greeks, so they gave them the title "Byzantines". This rhetoric is actually really annoying and makes people generally completely forget that the Roman Empire existed through to the very end of the Middle Ages. It's really annoying and it's good to see others pointing them out.
Thank you so much... :)
this is really good! ^^
thank you for sharing this :)
it was amazing. im glad this was made
:)
hello, what book is this taken from? thanks
2:01- Well, except Genoese seem to use them alot, even against English knights. But maybe exempt after Pope got his power neutered or that Genoese happened to be very rich nobles.
Well the Pope only has so much power (and Pope Innocent was especially not very respected, which is fully justified based on his acts) and the crossbow, as well as bows and slings where only banned by the pope when used against christians.
This wasactually arealy well made video! I usually hate history, buti thought this was super interestiN!!!
love it
Song?
Gr8 vid brah
For some reason this was shown in my music class...
This really helped me for my homework, and made it in an interesting way. Thank you.
music?
Bruh i have a test paper that ask what does i notice from the video clip. Could u og’s help me out?
Great video, thank you very much , note to self(nts) watched all of it 3:30
Great expl bro
This is pretty good but I take issue with the "Columbus discovers America". He thought he was in Asia and he never even got to North America, only the Caribbean islands.
I wish i can live every period in the past to experience how the culture and life was in person..I can only hope..
Yay! You might get executed for a minor crime, or tortured or imprisoned in a terrible prison. You might even get caught in a war if you're lucky! Then you'll become either a refugee, a prisoner, a conscripted soldier, slave or perhaps even a dead body! But wait, there's more! Have some diseases, whether it be infections from minor flesh wounds or simply a virus from simply eating a piece of food!
I know this is a bit cynical, but the point is that historical periods are romanticized as amazing times when it would be so cool to be there, but then society was pretty segregated between classes, death and suffering was around every corner and life would generally be ... well ... not so great. To me, 10 minute trips in a time machine would be a better idea.
Great video Margreet! I like the drawings and the simplicity of it. The colours are also very suitable to the theme. Did do you do them from scratch or are they part of the software you were using? Would you mind please telling me what you used to make your animated timeline?
While I agree with comments here that it is difficult to cover a period of history in such a short time and certainly important things happened during those years in the Americas, as well as in the Middle and Far East, as a Medieval scholar, I feel this video reinforces the myth that the period was a "dark age" where technology and classical learning and technology suffered, especially compared to the previous Roman period and subsequent Rennaisance period as well the related concept that the church was largely a force for suppressing learning.
When was the Medieval Europe? (from-to)
What are some of the key features of the Medieval time period?
Who were some significant individuals in Medieval Europe? Write a list.
What was feudalism? Write a list of the terms that make up the social system.
Why did the Medieval era end?
500 AD - 1500 AD is the first
@@archie7225 476~1453 real history :)
So uh, this video seems a little harsh on Europe? Why does the artist feel the need to say "we beat you to it" after a European invents something?
1:02 & 2:25
also I personally think you should have talked about Justinian conquests but that's just me
Or you know, about the general fact that the LITERAL ROMAN EMPIRE was still around. Just, you know, very important stuff to include.
I would have loved to see some extra tid-bits (ex : Mongol Invasion , First Use Of GunPowder in Europe , fall of Constantinople , and a few more events) but this is quite good !
TID-BITS? You mean important events that should definitely have been included. Without the Mongol invasions, much technology and knowledge from East Asia would not have arrived to Europe until probably centuries later (since the Mongols where the ones to restore the silk road), and there would likely be no Russian Nation. Without gunpowder in Europe, there would have likely been practically no European global empires and widespread colonialism by the English, Spanish, French and others. Without the fall of Constantinople, Rome would have endured and the ancient classical Greek and Roman art and information would not have reached Western Europe to kickstart the Renaissance, which led to the Enlightenment, which led in turn to the Industrial Revolution etc... In conclusion, you can't wrap 1000 years of important history into 3 1/2 minutes, because it just isn't possible, especially when the creator of the video is approaching it from a Euro-centric, biased and unhistorical perspective. So there.
So, "meanwhile in the East" means the Muslim world? Seriously? Not a word about the Byzantine civilization?
Clueless...
Themistocles Papassilekas Lets not forget China and Japan.
Of course, but I think the vid is so one sided the creators don't even consider this as "east", most probably for them it's a "galaxy far, far away" :D
because byzantine was backwards and not really done any progress also hated by west. not comparable to advances that muslim world made
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Crusade
but you are right it should have included
+Richard Winters lol, good one
Gryzor care to debunk?
I just wish you could have the comic appear without that hand blocking it
I love him
Nice
Too much years in a minute. Great!!!
awesome :D