LED bulb interference with radio reception

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • The switchmode drivers used in some LED bulbs can interfere with radio reception. I take a look at one such bulb.
    Support this channel on Patreon www.patreon.co...
    Email: johnaudiotech@gmail.com
    Thank You!

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @teamkeller
    @teamkeller Рік тому +3

    I was looking for a good video explaining why this happens but why did you feel it was necessary to disparage religion?

  • @davidahmad6090
    @davidahmad6090 2 роки тому +4

    Great stuff as usual sir, i had a similar problem with a dodgy high power led lamp, you could hear the hiss a meter away, and even my scope could pick up a few spikeis from the emission of the crapy LED lamp, the sad thing is that i thought my scope had a poor noise floor, due to the harmonics emitted from the awful led lamp. Good work John please keep it up.

  • @blobscott
    @blobscott 2 роки тому +5

    It seems that the FCC has given up protecting the analog radio bands. It's sad, but not surprising at this point.

    • @kevindavis4709
      @kevindavis4709 Рік тому +2

      Yet if you put up a fan transmitter it bleeds in over your neighbors, radio station you get in trouble. But you have a big building filled up with LED lighting FCC don’t care if your neighbors pick up interference from lighting

  • @worstuserever
    @worstuserever 2 роки тому +9

    If we put our minds to it and design custom lighting power circuits, perhaps we can find a way to block all the god-bothering stations.

    • @andymouse
      @andymouse 2 роки тому +2

      Amen, Lol !

    • @johncoops6897
      @johncoops6897 2 роки тому +2

      This definitely needs further study.
      Do they all use a special frequency, perhaps 666 on the AM radio dial?
      Are they using a form of direct injection to reach their followers?
      Perhaps there's a chip that get injected under the skin?

    • @robbieaussievic
      @robbieaussievic 2 роки тому +1

      ..... Find the transmission source and donate the noisy LED's

    • @robbieaussievic
      @robbieaussievic 2 роки тому +1

      @@johncoops6897 ..... All religions know that if they don't get you by age 12, they are unlikely to.

  • @KissAnalog
    @KissAnalog 2 роки тому +1

    Great video John! Thank you!

  • @kevindavis4709
    @kevindavis4709 Рік тому +1

    I’m surprised the FCC isn’t raising Cane over this . As much as they hate an unlicensed radio station bleeding on over a neighbors, radio station

  • @Chupacabras222
    @Chupacabras222 2 роки тому +3

    It would be interesting to see the difference with that capacitor.

  • @iblesbosuok
    @iblesbosuok 2 роки тому +5

    I miss Snickers 🥲

    • @mrb.5610
      @mrb.5610 2 роки тому +1

      If I was John, I'd seriously think about another cat or kitten !

  • @rogerwalter2500
    @rogerwalter2500 2 роки тому

    Thanks John, i have collected many such chokes, salvaged from dead SMPS. Planning to do the same

  • @generalleigh7387
    @generalleigh7387 2 роки тому +1

    I’m amazed to hear a man your age and caliber speaking in an unkind way about Jesus. I actually had just subscribed to your channel and immediately hit all bell notifications and was wondering at the same time just what you think about Jesus. And God consistently answers my questions that way, it’s an amazing reminder of His sovereignty. Great channel, be blessed all the more in it☺️

  • @montynorth3009
    @montynorth3009 2 роки тому +1

    The battery leads are acting as aerials.
    I would try a shunt capacitor as mentioned across the bulb terminals.

  • @andymouse
    @andymouse 2 роки тому +1

    Prophesy today, oh dear ! interesting stuff...cheers.

  • @EightiesJames
    @EightiesJames 3 місяці тому

    THE LEDS ARE ACTING AS SOLAR CELLS... You can put MANY on a panel in S-P... The current is creating an interference field.

  • @leiferickson3183
    @leiferickson3183 2 роки тому +3

    You know, when(if?) they tested this for the FCC they might have been using power leeds that are shielded right up to the bulb in order to pass. This methos of testing doesnt take into account all the wiring. I have pretty bad electronic noise issues in my house - I think from polluted wiring - it is even worse because it is knob and tube so my wiring is made of giant loop antennas.

    • @johncoops6897
      @johncoops6897 2 роки тому

      No way that this was ever tested for the FCC requirements.

    • @kevindavis4709
      @kevindavis4709 Рік тому

      @@johncoops6897if my big bulging full of LED lighting interferes with the neighbors radio FCC won’t care. But if my little radio station interfered with the neighbors radio FCC cares lol

  • @DevJB
    @DevJB Рік тому

    There is many LED bulbs that will interfere with your cable modem\catv signal from your ISP and cause signal leakage which causes issues to the entire neighborhood and your ISP should or will eventually show up and try to install ground block(s) and tell you that the signal leak is from inside your house because of bad catv connector, uncapped or bad splitter, non terminated or bad catv cable, bent cable etc. Meanwhile the problem may be a cheap led bulb when turned on will cause noise\hum interference on catv signals (egress) until turned off or removed
    eplaced with a bulb that doesn't cause interference.
    To easily find the bulbs in your house causing interference, plug a radio into any power receptacle in the house, put the radio on AM 520 or AM 530. Turn off all the lights in house, turn off tv's and other devices would be essential for best test method. You should hear a slight humming background noise sound, you might also hear a random ping tone. Then run around house to test each light switch 1 at time, if you hear a loud hum from the radio, then you know it's that string. So, then you remove each bulb from that string until the hum noise stops. Replace bulb with different bulb making sure the loud background noise from radio doesn't come back.
    Why care?
    1. FCC.
    2. ISP.
    3. Being blamed by 1 and 2.
    4. Less RF in your life.
    5. Letting the neighbors get what they paid for.
    6. Helping your internet speeds be more solid.
    7. Helping the local emergency radio channels be more clear.
    All because of a lightbulb.

  • @tim2468
    @tim2468 2 роки тому +2

    This has been bugging for years. Try playing electric guitar in a house full of LED bulbs!

  • @CraftAero
    @CraftAero 2 роки тому +1

    "...so that's one less good station to listen to." 😂

  • @jamesdavies686
    @jamesdavies686 2 роки тому +1

    I installed LED bulbs in my garage door opener... Guess what stopped working... That's right, the radio controlled remote openers. Had to switch back to a tungsten style bulb for now.

  • @HillsWorkbench
    @HillsWorkbench 2 роки тому

    I want to do some videos on line noise too if I can clear some dogs off the bench. Skiing is wrapping up but now I have other issues to contend with, Mom is back in the hospital. Anyway, my challenge is with my X10 stuff. The old UPS I brought home actually works but totally blacks out nearly all X10 communication when plugged in. Bought something that might help.

    • @JohnAudioTech
      @JohnAudioTech  2 роки тому

      I know you've had issues with some LED bulbs and X10. The protocol does not seem to have any resilience to interference. Sorry to hear about the downturn of your mom's health.

  • @listerine-pr5lt
    @listerine-pr5lt 2 роки тому +1

    I am eager to see what in that LED bulb causes the interference noise.

    • @mrb.5610
      @mrb.5610 2 роки тому +1

      A nasty little switched mode power supply with minimal filtering to keep the costs down and fit into the relatively small bulb housing.

    • @listerine-pr5lt
      @listerine-pr5lt 2 роки тому

      Why do they put a power supply when the input voltage for the LED bulb is already 12 VDC?

    • @russellhltn1396
      @russellhltn1396 2 роки тому

      @@listerine-pr5lt LEDS are usually driven to a fixed current. Without a regulator, it would be far to sensitive to variations in the "12 V".

    • @mrb.5610
      @mrb.5610 2 роки тому +1

      @@listerine-pr5lt Several reasons.
      LEDs work on a constant current, not voltage so need at least a resistor. But that's inefficient if you're dealing with the amount of current you need for a bulb.
      And LEDs need to be fed with the right polarity so again, that's at least a rectifier as the bulb and holder aren't polarised.
      Finally, there are a lot of low voltage lighting installations that use just an AC 12v transformer for power - fine for an incandescent bulb, again no good for an LED. You're going to need a rectifier AND a smoothing capacitor now as well. But this will give a peak DC voltage of just over 15V (assuming a 0.7v drop across the rectifier diodes)
      A solid state 'transformer' however will be DC at pretty much dead on 12V.
      Add the whole lot of requirements together and you end having to include some kind of regulator that can provide the right amount of current for the LED from a relatively wide variety of input voltages, polarities and frequencies.
      And the smallest and most efficient way of doing this is with a single chip switcher regulator.
      The downside is they give out a lot of RF noise if they're not suppressed correctly.
      There are probably some other good reasons too !

  • @chrisharper2658
    @chrisharper2658 2 роки тому

    I ran into the same problem with those low voltage LED conversion lamps. Installed an inline EMI filter on the primary of the transformer, that helped but also had to rectify the secondary and filter the output. So I ended up feeding the lamps with DC instead of AC to keep them quiet. Not sure what a home inspector might say about all that sitting on top of a kitchen cabinet.

    • @rogerwalter2500
      @rogerwalter2500 2 роки тому

      I use laptop power supply brick adaptor, they have better noise suppression.

    • @harrywalker968
      @harrywalker968 Рік тому

      if tesla got his way & wasnt murdered,,we,d all have dc,,not ac, bs..

  • @scarakus
    @scarakus 2 роки тому +1

    Technology has gone too far. ..Unplug, and Disconnect..

  • @EngineeringEssentials
    @EngineeringEssentials 2 роки тому

    Good video..

  • @Paul-gh9ky
    @Paul-gh9ky 10 місяців тому +1

    Why would you say playing a religious is unfortunate? You must be a Biden voter.

  • @amitghosh6966
    @amitghosh6966 2 роки тому

    Nice video

  • @amitghosh6966
    @amitghosh6966 2 роки тому

    Can a filter capacitor value be responsible for change in output voltage ? Suppose if a 12 volt 2 Ampere transformer is connected a 2200 uF capacitor instead of usual 4700 uF , will that result in increase or decrease in output peak voltage ?

    • @HillsWorkbench
      @HillsWorkbench 2 роки тому +1

      Normally, No. Only if the original value was too low to adiquatly filter VS demand. John showed that in a video where he was able to get slightly more power out of an amplifier by increasing capacitance.

    • @rogerwalter2500
      @rogerwalter2500 2 роки тому

      2- 2200uf in parallel are better than 1 4700uf, less Resistance . Rule of thumb is 2200uF per 1 amp of current

  • @Cotronixco
    @Cotronixco 10 місяців тому

    Connect the second coil in the opposite direction. Problem solved.

  • @TheTrueVoiceOfReason
    @TheTrueVoiceOfReason 2 роки тому +1

    Have any ferrite beads? Maybe one of those clip on ones? Put the wire leads back on and the bead, see what happens.
    I'm in line with Leif, this is an FCC issue.

    • @HillsWorkbench
      @HillsWorkbench 2 роки тому

      I had an LED spotlight that was knocking out TV reception. Ferites didn't seem to help too much for me but worth a try.

    • @russellhltn1396
      @russellhltn1396 2 роки тому

      Depends on the issue. The ferrites should help keep the wiring from acting like an antenna but doesn't clean up the source. Also note the formula used for the ferrite - you might be using the wrong formula for the frequency of interest.

    • @TheTrueVoiceOfReason
      @TheTrueVoiceOfReason 2 роки тому

      @@russellhltn1396 I went back and watched the video again, comparing the light with leads and.the light with just pins. It did seem a hair louder with the leads, but there were still power leads from the power supply, so you still had a pretty long length of radiator. When put through the choke, it was most definitely attenuated. Now a ferrite bead may be way off, but it wouldn't hurt to try. Still needs to be reported to the FCC with this video as support.
      John, do you have a housing for the lamp that you could wire up on the bench to see if there's any additional shielding there?

  • @SunitaSharma-eo6ud
    @SunitaSharma-eo6ud 2 роки тому

    Subscribers near 50k 🎇🎈

  • @glenmartin2437
    @glenmartin2437 Рік тому

    Thanks.

  • @gmg325
    @gmg325 2 роки тому

    They can transmit signals and subliminal speech on these thing theu are also all microphones. U probably already know all this. But yeah I'm raking them all out my house. Question what about flashlights?

    • @gmg325
      @gmg325 2 роки тому

      The thought of those old flashlights... maglight wasn't bad tho

    • @DevJB
      @DevJB Рік тому

      They are not microphones, even if you knew how to speak RF.

  • @victorpuente4525
    @victorpuente4525 9 місяців тому

    It also interferes with my garage door opener 😢

  • @MichaelBeeny
    @MichaelBeeny 2 роки тому +3

    If only it was something as simple as a LED lamp to rid the world of religion!

  • @vaasugastrokpm9792
    @vaasugastrokpm9792 Рік тому

    Problem ok my fm radio

  • @vaasugastrokpm9792
    @vaasugastrokpm9792 Рік тому

    Fm radio, LED light stations problem

  • @wegoall9188
    @wegoall9188 6 місяців тому

    Christ offers forgiveness for everyone everywhere. He'll forgive you if you ask Him to.🙏🏽

  • @user-cj2cm5yb4o
    @user-cj2cm5yb4o Рік тому

    Ok fm radio station problem led tipe sound problem ok in Tamil meaning

  • @twobob
    @twobob 2 роки тому

    a baba ba ba babaa indeed

  • @gkcnalaka
    @gkcnalaka 2 роки тому

    📻

  • @scarakus
    @scarakus 2 роки тому

    George Noory. lol