Windward and Tradelands weren't included on purpose. Windward is group locked and Tradelands requires crafting to obtain a musket; neither game had fast access to their tech. I also couldn't find any clean footage of their tech like I did with Muskets and Magic.
@@QwerYT4819 windward is actually a great game because of the grouplock. It is by no means a simple game with complex and realistic sailing physics and it really helps to have mandatory trainings and stuff.
@@elheavydonashamblers are referred as cannibals, since they aren’t aware such thing exists, bubbles refers to them as cannibals aswell, us players call it shamblers, since we are aware what they are
i find it interesting how quick you reload in g&b at least compared to the ones before it (from what i can tell) almost as if the reload is done to save as much time as possible which would be valuable in the setting it’s placed in
Why do you like the game so much? And I saw that you banned someone in your 'Britannia for Earth' video just because they didn't wanna be infantry. That's so absurd and that proves my point.
Most games: Careful disciplined reload, aimed at doing it correctly over doing it quickly G&B: Rushed and less disciplined but still careful, showing off veterancy of the survivors and being a fair trade-off in a zombie apocalypse scenario Bots and Muskets: Looks like your MC is smoking crack while reloading, it's not an insult considering the whole game is supposed to look like a highly escalated shitpost
Battles and Musket Testing are thepoopxd (free) modifications from Blood & Iron tech, aswell G&B musket is based on the same games, most of the musket systems from today originated from Gaudia Certaminis (whupdup, rn dev of MoW), and Europa Invicta (turned into NW), also Frontier tech (oldest free one) was replaced by Cooldeath, same tech used by WaH. PD: just realised this is WaH's creator, ayo Okami.
Marque of War's musket tech is my favourite. It feels like you're actually holding an actual weapon, and scoring kills with it is the most satisfying out of any other genre. I hope more games adapt the MoW styled muskets because there ain't much like it.
A House Divided (AHD) is the single greatest one of them all and has the most realistic reload animations compared to real life and it uses rifled muskets from the American Civil War and other weapons like revolvers and breach loaders. Also has realistic artillery.
I remember before CoderQwerty released the B&I muskets as freemodels, Gory had his own musket tech that he used in his Kingdom of Prussia (this was like 2014) before he left it to make BA. They were pretty garbage by today's standards, but they had collisions on so you could do some pretty goofy stuff with them.
I love northwind, sadly the mechanics are confusing, but their just fun in a way, it’s a game that implements features you wouldn’t see anywhere else in Roblox.
@@gnbkid523cuz it was a fucking rifle not an ordinary musket just like how you reload a rifle in blood and iron as a 95th rifles regiment its slow unlike rankers musket
fun fact Everyone will be able to see how when they load the rifles they do so using small cloth bags that are supposed to hold the appropriate amount of powder and the bullet. but that is incorrect, rather that is something from battle recreations where they have measured the number of shots they can fire and the cloth ensures that nothing is going to happen to the rest of the people because you really don't want to kill them. In reality, the soldiers carried with them a horn where they had gunpowder and a bag full of lead balls.
B&I is the OG. Most took inspiration from it or from another game that was inspired by it. Napoleonic wars is the current largest Napoleonic community that organizes events and battles (although it's no longer in development it's still pretty large.) Waterloo at home was basically a cheap fan game/knockoff of Napoleonic wars (which was originally called "Waterloo" hence the name "Waterloo at home") Northern frontier was destroyed by exploiters ages ago but has a remake. Northwind is the official spiritual successor to Northern frontier. Lexington and Concord and G&B have large active player bases. (Guts and black powder is the largest of all these) The rest I have no clue about but are probably community based.
I’m sorry to any Northwind fans, but it looks like it hurts to reload the musket the way he twists his arms. But then again, it’s the only r15 game and I have never played it so :p.
Kid that only plays GnB checklist -Has a GnB profile: check -Compliments how gnb is so good (it kinda is): check -Wants to move while aiming a Musket: check
@@NathanSerratoa Ehh it depends. If you're looking for public gameplay then northwind cleans. If you are looking for a napoleonic/ musket war roleplaying experience than absolutely nothing beats marque of war. The attention to detail and the RDR2 level of animations are amazing. The tech is incredible, the community's laid back and overall great and it has an amazing naval mode. Northwind doesnt really have as good animations, and its roleplaying community is kinda toxic, but definitely has more content and a better open world. Also really more people need to play marque of war, its super underrated. I recommend you check it out by going to the training area and testing out a few things, it will blow your mind especially the artillery. The ragdoll physics is also really funny.
@@AnnoyingOkami they used the same aiming system, and the aim point so they do used almost the same system. Also windward is a naval game, not ground battle game
L&C: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke) MoW: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke) Napoleonic Wars: Mostly Accurate M&M: Mostly Accurate G&BP: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke, incorrect colour) VaM: Accurate - Perfect amount of smoke NW: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke, weird and inaccurate reload animation) NF: Inaccurate as hell (Were you even trying? The musket is famously a very inaccurate weapon, and theres next to 0 smoke. And why the hell did the player put two things in the barrel? Only one!) B&I: Mostly Accurate (Little bit too little smoke, but still accurate. Soldier is holding the musket incorrectly whilst reloading it) WaH: Mostly Accurate (Great amount of smoke, player holds musket incorrectly) FL: Inaccurate (Smoke incorrect color, way too little smoke, shot is too accurate, and the smoke isn;t there long enough.) B&M: ??? (Cartoony so I forgive it for having too little smoke and unrealistic animations) PL: Ehh (smoke is there for a perfect amount of time, right amount of smoke, but the reload is wayyyy too much for historical accuracy, and gameplay wise, I could NOT see where the shot landed. And also, if a fireball forms at the front of your musket, you'd be fucking dead, dude.) EC: Inaccurate (Good amount of smoke, I just don't like how it doesn't come from the musket, and just an invisible part. Reload is way too short.) MT: 10/10 (Perfect smoke, perfect anim, only problem is how the musket is crooked in the make ready position) Battles: Were they even trying? (Way too little smoke, too accurate)
![Minecraft but it's 100 Years Villager War [FULL MOVIE]](/img/n.gif)
Windward and Tradelands weren't included on purpose. Windward is group locked and Tradelands requires crafting to obtain a musket; neither game had fast access to their tech. I also couldn't find any clean footage of their tech like I did with Muskets and Magic.
oof grouplocked games suck
@@QwerYT4819 its to prevent trolls and 10 year old retards
also if you knew how complicated windward is you would understand
@@QwerYT4819 windward is actually a great game because of the grouplock. It is by no means a simple game with complex and realistic sailing physics and it really helps to have mandatory trainings and stuff.
Ngl the muskets on north wind was kinda cursed
@@QwerYT4819 its to prevent alt trolling and 10 year old morons
Most games: slow and calm no need to rush
G&b: rushed and faster reloads since you realized you have to reload fast to shoot the cannibals
Cannibals*
@@CrazyDude-mf5gkshamblers*
@@elheavydonashamblers are referred as cannibals, since they aren’t aware such thing exists, bubbles refers to them as cannibals aswell, us players call it shamblers, since we are aware what they are
@@TriangulationOfSquares cannibals are human they exist on india bro
@@elheavydona I can’t tell if you are trying to make a joke or not lmao 😭
i like how in g&b you can just hear people screaming for help in the background. also i really like the marque reload it sounds nice
HELP ME ❗
DE KOMMER! HJÆLP OS!!
Some dude probably shot a bomber too close
MoW Musket sounds won’t be heard if Your in a Event😭 (We broke the Old Guard 10 Times and Their dudes just started feeding lmfao)
Musket and magic🤮
*3 seconds later*
G&B✨✨✨✨✨✨
I love the eternal classic of B&I, it feels so cool
It is the OG
i think Victoria aut Mors sounds and works the most realistically based on my opinion lol, the Waterloo at Home one just sounds like an arquebus
the one that's most realistic is marque at war with the cartridge sliding down the barrel
other wise yeah
All Of them Are realistic in one way or another , But Yeah
As a Waterloo at Home player I do agree that the muskets sound wonky
Mow has a same reloading as muskets and magic
3:46 We be rotting our brains with this one! 🔥🔥🔥
yes
Yo the creator of bots and muskets
Nice
NORTHWIND MENTIONED🥶🥶🥶❄️❄️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 WE GETTING DRIED WITH THIS ONE
G&B and Blood and Iron is my Fav Reloading. Waterloo at Home is which i despise the most.
You sound like you drink coffee with bread
@@Potatodude222 Thee Say speak such Foul Skibidistic Speaking, silence your Rizzhole for I... The Sigma of Ohioington Do not give such Fanum tax!
@@Potatodude222 I actually do
The smoke effect is terrible bc the lag
@@Windmolenliefhebber I knew it
I’m suprise that you added muskets and magic because I really like the game even though its not yet released
i find it interesting how quick you reload in g&b at least compared to the ones before it (from what i can tell) almost as if the reload is done to save as much time as possible which would be valuable in the setting it’s placed in
ITS THE FUNNY ZOMBIE GAME WHICH IS INFACT MY LIFECLWTS GOOOO
Oh hey it’s Luke Skywalker
@@xogleeztastexd583 Lukethougamingsir*
Why do you like the game so much? And I saw that you banned someone in your 'Britannia for Earth' video just because they didn't wanna be infantry. That's so absurd and that proves my point.
@@user-whatareyoudoing that’s called a dictatorship and is totally justifiable
Also how bold of you to assume I think of myself as a “ Good “ person
musket testing uses free models
for the guns?
@@jaywebster624yes
@@foxinino2622 then it’s a free model showcase
@@jaywebster624 i think they credited in the description i thought everybody knew by now
And battles as well, funnily enough they use the same system! The cooldeath49 system!
Most games: Careful disciplined reload, aimed at doing it correctly over doing it quickly
G&B: Rushed and less disciplined but still careful, showing off veterancy of the survivors and being a fair trade-off in a zombie apocalypse scenario
Bots and Muskets: Looks like your MC is smoking crack while reloading, it's not an insult considering the whole game is supposed to look like a highly escalated shitpost
Battles and Musket Testing are thepoopxd (free) modifications from Blood & Iron tech, aswell G&B musket is based on the same games, most of the musket systems from today originated from Gaudia Certaminis (whupdup, rn dev of MoW), and Europa Invicta (turned into NW), also Frontier tech (oldest free one) was replaced by Cooldeath, same tech used by WaH.
PD: just realised this is WaH's creator, ayo Okami.
I guess that makes my tech special as it's not scripted off anyone else's tech. Apart from sounds of course.
Marque of war had the best sounds but the animation in Lexington and Concord is unmatched they did so good with that game
Marque of War's musket tech is my favourite. It feels like you're actually holding an actual weapon, and scoring kills with it is the most satisfying out of any other genre. I hope more games adapt the MoW styled muskets because there ain't much like it.
Gnb making it fast because they know the enemy is not normal
A House Divided (AHD) is the single greatest one of them all and has the most realistic reload animations compared to real life and it uses rifled muskets from the American Civil War and other weapons like revolvers and breach loaders. Also has realistic artillery.
so glad to see a youtuber cover northwind, such an underrated game
I remember before CoderQwerty released the B&I muskets as freemodels, Gory had his own musket tech that he used in his Kingdom of Prussia (this was like 2014) before he left it to make BA. They were pretty garbage by today's standards, but they had collisions on so you could do some pretty goofy stuff with them.
The amount of limb detachment in some of these make it so silly
Bai having the best muskets as always
Others *silent*
G&b "HELP ME"
empire clash mentioned 🗣️🔥
I love northwind, sadly the mechanics are confusing, but their just fun in a way, it’s a game that implements features you wouldn’t see anywhere else in Roblox.
I like how ROBLOX games have better depiction of operating a musket than most non-ROBLOX games
Musket testing reload is uncanny ☠️
ikr its so slow 😭
@@gnbkid523cuz it was a fucking rifle not an ordinary musket just like how you reload a rifle in blood and iron as a 95th rifles regiment its slow unlike rankers musket
We will never forget WAH ❤😭
I like how Napoleonic Wars as the most realistic and smooth animation for a musket
1:36 where to find this game?
www.roblox.com/games/15083703268
I am irritated that you missed the musket in windward 😭
Windward is group locked so I couldn't get any footage.
i remember when battles wasn't dead
Yo goodluck with your new upcoming game
Battles mentioned🗣️⁉️⁉️⁉️🤯
VaM or NW
Arent you the dude who made that gambling game on roblox, fire stuff 👍teach em young
NORTHWINDDD HOORAYYYY
fun fact
Everyone will be able to see how when they load the rifles they do so using small cloth bags that are supposed to hold the appropriate amount of powder and the bullet.
but that is incorrect, rather that is something from battle recreations where they have measured the number of shots they can fire and the cloth ensures that nothing is going to happen to the rest of the people because you really don't want to kill them. In reality, the soldiers carried with them a horn where they had gunpowder and a bag full of lead balls.
My old game has an accurate rifle reload if you want to see it: www.roblox.com/games/14471925294/Camden-at-home
Marque of War seem have accurate reloading animation, but it slow
I havent played northwind for like 1 or 2 years
HOW ARE THESE GAMES ALL SO UNDERRATED HUHHH???
Why are there so many games with Muskets? When I searched for musket games in Roblox, I found barely any. Are some of them in the video dead games?
Most of these games have an active community. Links for them are in the video description.
@@gamerkreep It's honestly sad that some of these games don't have much active players
@@WolfieBiz11 Most of the games here are not meant to be played by an average player and is only for exclusive use by the community.
Guts and blackpowder has a active community for the most part, I can just hop in and get to playing.
B&I is the OG. Most took inspiration from it or from another game that was inspired by it.
Napoleonic wars is the current largest Napoleonic community that organizes events and battles (although it's no longer in development it's still pretty large.)
Waterloo at home was basically a cheap fan game/knockoff of Napoleonic wars (which was originally called "Waterloo" hence the name "Waterloo at home")
Northern frontier was destroyed by exploiters ages ago but has a remake. Northwind is the official spiritual successor to Northern frontier.
Lexington and Concord and G&B have large active player bases. (Guts and black powder is the largest of all these)
The rest I have no clue about but are probably community based.
Blood and iron is a certified hood classic
I’m sorry to any Northwind fans, but it looks like it hurts to reload the musket the way he twists his arms. But then again, it’s the only r15 game and I have never played it so :p.
In Globelore II, the reload time is only 2 seconds & the character does not even use the ram-rod
😢
literally every single one uses the blood and iron framework, its not suprising though honestly, it works just fine
What if in g&b, if you're low and infected, your reloading time takes a bit longer due to shaky hands and panic
I like the games where you can move around while reloading
And I ESPECIALLY like guts and blackpowder because of these gun things
BUT, northwind is also very good at that
Kid that only plays GnB checklist
-Has a GnB profile: check
-Compliments how gnb is so good (it kinda is): check
-Wants to move while aiming a Musket: check
Battles was my life I was so sad when it died
Northwind and G&B best
What about marque of war. I mean, out of all of these games marque of war definitely has the best tech.
@@ASB22224 You're right, I think the reload animation is fine, but generally speaking, NORTHWIND humiliates all the games featured there.
@@NathanSerratoa Ehh it depends. If you're looking for public gameplay then northwind cleans. If you are looking for a napoleonic/ musket war roleplaying experience than absolutely nothing beats marque of war. The attention to detail and the RDR2 level of animations are amazing. The tech is incredible, the community's laid back and overall great and it has an amazing naval mode. Northwind doesnt really have as good animations, and its roleplaying community is kinda toxic, but definitely has more content and a better open world.
Also really more people need to play marque of war, its super underrated. I recommend you check it out by going to the training area and testing out a few things, it will blow your mind especially the artillery. The ragdoll physics is also really funny.
Its Crazy cuz when you now search Battle its not popular but i played it Like 1 year ago it was popular
What's the music at Blood and Iron part?
ua-cam.com/video/3U0Cca1TtUY/v-deo.html
why do i feel like this is a GnB combine with BnI
Forgetting tradelands is criminal
Napoleonic wars is my fav
Man i want to play northwind so bad
4:00 musket 2072
is that a reference that we will get a new flintlock game from you like camden?
I am working on a new flintlock game. It should be released in a month or two.
Who came here to see the legendary b&I
BATTLESSSS I MISS U
DUDE VICTORIA AUT MORS LOOKS SO GOOD, sad i couldn't find it by looking it up, how do you play that game?
There's a link for it in the video description.
bots & muskets musket reload animation has the same speed of RDR2's reload anims,
ion think you can reload a musket THAT fast 😭
No windward?
they used a kind of same musket system as the Napoleonic Wars
@@thghans1758 no not at all.
@@AnnoyingOkami they used the same aiming system, and the aim point so they do used almost the same system. Also windward is a naval game, not ground battle game
Couldn't figure out how to spawn. I think it's group locked.
@@gamerkreep it is group locked, unfortunately.
u forgot to add zulu muskets, they are the best!
G&B is the most realistic
you reload in like 5 seconds lol (unless you mean the animation itself)
@@petermmm42Yeah because you need to reload fast when there’s a horde of zombies coming after you, going slow isn’t an option.
@@reymen106 im not saying its bad im just saying its not realistic even if its needed
I doubt it
you should try "Musket showdown"
It's such a shame that battles died
Blood and iron would have been much better but it was made in 2009
It wasnt made in 2009 dude
NAPOLEONIC WARS BATTLES MENTIONED!!!!
musket asmr
lexington and asscord
wait you got unhacked?
Blood and Iron has the best one
Most of the games use reanimated, or repacked cooldeath
is this the creator of wah?
Wait gamerokami??
2:06
GamerOkami!?!?
Windward??
Napoleonic is literally mount and blade
You forgot the windward
Wheres windward
There’s a new one pirate wars
fym pirate wars
Yay empire clash
Empire clash is mid as hell
Gyatokami💔
Tradeland musket
Northwind on top
musket testing and battles use the same tech, its poopxd
L&C: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke)
MoW: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke)
Napoleonic Wars: Mostly Accurate
M&M: Mostly Accurate
G&BP: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke, incorrect colour)
VaM: Accurate - Perfect amount of smoke
NW: Inaccurate (Way too little smoke, weird and inaccurate reload animation)
NF: Inaccurate as hell (Were you even trying? The musket is famously a very inaccurate weapon, and theres next to 0 smoke. And why the hell did the player put two things in the barrel? Only one!)
B&I: Mostly Accurate (Little bit too little smoke, but still accurate. Soldier is holding the musket incorrectly whilst reloading it)
WaH: Mostly Accurate (Great amount of smoke, player holds musket incorrectly)
FL: Inaccurate (Smoke incorrect color, way too little smoke, shot is too accurate, and the smoke isn;t there long enough.)
B&M: ??? (Cartoony so I forgive it for having too little smoke and unrealistic animations)
PL: Ehh (smoke is there for a perfect amount of time, right amount of smoke, but the reload is wayyyy too much for historical accuracy, and gameplay wise, I could NOT see where the shot landed. And also, if a fireball forms at the front of your musket, you'd be fucking dead, dude.)
EC: Inaccurate (Good amount of smoke, I just don't like how it doesn't come from the musket, and just an invisible part. Reload is way too short.)
MT: 10/10 (Perfect smoke, perfect anim, only problem is how the musket is crooked in the make ready position)
Battles: Were they even trying? (Way too little smoke, too accurate)
You forgot arseanal 🙃
Pirate legends musket looks shitty as hell and has no reload
you're comparing muskets, not flintlocks.
fixed
Pretty sure all the muskets presented are flintlocks anyways
these are all flintlocks you pigeon livered buffoon
flintlock is an ignition system. all the muskets shown here are flintlock.
@@dolsopolar ok I'm stupid
Napoleon war is so bad not gonna lie and no one plays because it’s a computer game and who Wil waste more than 1000 dollars in a pc?
You forgot centaura
Centaura doesn't have muskets
It would be funny if they if and could be a new story element @Maxi-wp7xd