Debunking the Myth of the "Golden Age of Islam"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
- www.nielsenrep... ✅ Debunking the Myth of the "Golden Age of Islam"
In their defence of further islamisation of Western nations, Muslim activists often claim that Islam had a great period of scientific work called the "Golden Age of Islam". For example, Mehdi Hasan - an activist originating from Al Jazeera, the propaganda outlet of Qatar, one of the great funders of the Muslim Brotherhood - in his Oxford Union debate even claimed that "Muslim scientists" are at the foundation of the European Rennaissance.
This claim made by Mehdi Hasan is a great disrespect:
- towards the ancient Greece, Persian and Indian scientists that actually had an impact on the state of scientific progress on the whole Eurasian continent around the year 600AD, just ten years before Muhammad made up his first "revelation".
- towards these advanced civilizations of the Ancient World and their science, because Islam was the force that destroyed them and/or greatly limited the continuation of scientific work that they had been doing for entire centuries before Islam came to stop it.
- towards the European nations during the Renaissance and Enlightenment, because not a single part of the world came even close to the progress that the Europeans produced during these time periods (and actually also already before it during the period we now know as the Middle Ages).
It you only take the scientific progress that a small country like the Netherlands produced during its Golden Age, you have list of scientists and inventions that overwhelms the "Golden Age of Islam", even if you were to multiply the list of the mostly Persian individuals claimed to have been "Muslim scientists" by x10.
In this video I debunk the myth of the Golden Age of Islam by digging into the broader historic context and discussing many of the individuals claimed by people like Mehdi Hasan to have been "Muslim scientists".
Footage of spread of Islam taken from Bill Warner of Center of Study of Political Islam.
Source: • Bill Warner, PhD: The...
Paul Nielsen
Buy my book: www.amazon.com...
Website: www.nielsenrep...
Bitchute: www.bitchute.c...
We even talk about "Arabic numerals" whereas in fact they took their numbering system from the Hindus in India. The Arabs still have not developed a symbol for zero! They just use a dot.
Whenever Muslims bring this up, I always make the distinction that at best, they can claim to have created a font-style for a numerical set of symbols. They did not create the system, they copied it.
A zero is a zero, no matter the shape
What's wrong with using a dot as a symbol for zero?
By the way, here in Arabia we call the numbers we use Indian numbers, only in the west they are called Arabic numerals, lol it's not our fault you claimed the numbers to us?
@@yuzan3607 I think it is wrong too, saying it is the fault of Arabic people that it is called Arabic Numerals. You adopted it from India, we adopted it from your writings, the people who named them so in European literature, came in to contact with them from Arabic writings on math, so that was the name it was given. The issue is more that Muslims in Europe are now using it falsely, as a statement about how the Islamic Golden Age is what created the number system, as a means to sell Islam as a highly scientifically minded religion, when that is based on their need to dress Islam up as something it is not.
They use a dot for a zero as you say. Is that not then a symbol for zero you genius LOL
Strong message: The science in Islamic regions were done in spite of Islam not because of it.
And also mostly done by Christians and Jews, many of whom ended up assassinated and their works deleted.
Wrong. Centers of learning were created because of Islam.
That's not true Islam asks for knowledge and knowledge is an act of worship
@@ahmadfrhan5265 Get on with it then, it's past time for Islam to debunk Islam
@@HeLpLOstGOdAny1 is this objectively true or subjectively true?
It is said that when the Muslims conquered Amida (Diyarbakir on the Tigris), they hauled away a million academic scrolls - none of which survive.
Muslims of that era were the same as lSlS today, destroying every statue and text they can find. lSlS destroyed the whole of Palmyra.
Ralph
Arabs burned all libraries in the countries they conquered. Egypte, India, Central Asia, Spain etc
( It is said that … )
is hardly valid
Zero Reliability
I mean was Islam the only destroyer of the world and it’s knowledge, if you looked into Islam you wouldn’t be able to provide one source from the Quran of the teaching of the prophet may peace be upon him ( hadeeth) that tells humanity to destroy and delete knowlege
Do u really think so? What about all of the churches and synagogues that are preserved till that day in the muslim world?! Who returned the Jews to Jerusalem after they were expelled from it by the crusaders?! Get your facts right mate
It is said?? by who? source? stop pulling shit out of yours ass and internet.
I am an ex-Muslim. Therefore I am an apostate and my life would be forfeit if I wrote this under my real name.
Islam is not a religion of peace, and it is not an ideology that embraces science.
Even in the west it is understood that Galileo and Newton did not make their brilliant discoveries based on their understanding of Christianity. There is no such thing as Christian physics, just as there is no such thing as Islamic algebra.
The great minds of history had to struggle against religious dogma in order to enlighten the world.
Kepler wanted to prove that we live in a world governed by perfect spheres and heavenly circles, but the data of his observations didn’t match Church dogma.
All of the classical thinkers who happened to be Muslim were the beneficiaries of Greek and Persian science and philosophy, and were all labeled infidels at one point or another.
Mehdi Hasan does what all Islamists do; he revises history to put Islam in a positive light.
Thank you for your courage. It is indeed dangerous to be an apostate. We need Islam to be debunked by muslims themselves , that is the only way.
It's crazy how much harm islam has done to the world yet we keep accepting its presence like nothing happened.
We with no or other religions are not allowed to say anything or react to anything that has to do with Islam. The opposite is of course perfectly ok to complain about ..
The elite use muslims as a pawn on their chessboard.
@@_Razpberrie Yes, for sure, but so does Islam and any other Religion.
You know very well that Islam has always been aginst science so to claim so, as this activist does, is outright a lie! If you mean that I'm wrong, I'm happy to accept links that show the opposite. I'm not saying this to be disgusting to you, but if we do not have the Truth, we have lost everything!
Just like communism
Like a battered wife.
It made absolutely no sense to me that a religion which is anti science and anti progress back then made such a contribution to science and in the modern world basically somehow got tired of it.
Islam made no contribution at all.
"Anti-Science", i want you to give me one Verse from the Quran that says something like this. stop the Bullshit.
Infact one of the first words in quran told to the prophet was "iqrae bismi rabika ladi khalaq" which means learn and study. So saying that islam is anti science and learning is just pure bs with no background
Science and religion were never an oxymor in islamic societies
@@grizius4123 Learn and study =/= doing science. Furthermore, I'm getting a bit tired of muslim apologists taking a quote and ripping it out of context.
@@ZTRCTGuy Wrong. Islam the religion itself has NEVER been anti science. This is something peddled by many muslims of the modern era who are uneducated on their own religion. Many muslims sadly oppose scientific progress and are in fact anti science. However you've got it twisted. The religion is not anti-science, its the vocal followers who are anti-science.
One thing that would be helpful is not to confuse islam with crazy middle aged arab men who think they're good muslims telling everyone that science is the work of the devil. This is not islam.
Now please look at this from an open mind before you reply with the same BS about "anti-science" islam and maybe try to get somewhere with me here eh?
I am Indonesia and I gladly confirm that there is no scientific progress by muslim here :)
It was about time someone made this video!
It is truly frightening that propaganda has superseded critical analysis ! Even worse is to view the " happy clappy " audience ,composed largely of gullible bien pensants, willing as ever to swallow the prevailing, fashionable zeitgeist. Good video !!!!
Ever heard of Bill Warner phd
@@jackmcnally9237it's propaganda to make you guys fools and you guys are fools
All dude did was cherrypick philosophers ...... remove credit away from Islam ......
Why were those discoveries not done under peaceful Romans or Persian .....
@@Bla3817 The technogical advancement in Zoroastrian Persia and the former Roman territories was far greater than anything that came after. It wasn't until the 1400s in Northern Italy when we regained our momentum. About 1000 years after the fall of Western Rome, and 800 years after the fall of the Sassanid Empire.
Many of the Founders of the Translation movement of early Abbasid Period were Nestorian Christian monks and Physicians Like Hunyan Ibn Ishaq, Yuhanna Ibn Masawiyah who translated and improved upon huge amounts of ancient greek works into arabic and wrote treatisies on opthalmology. Infact the Academy of Gondishapur was a center of Assyrian Christian Intellectual center in the Persian Sassanid empire long before islam. And now islam shamlessly takes all the credit for it.
They've always been the pot calling the kettle back. They stole a lot and yet call those who were much better than them who've defeated them, "thieves"
No islam doesn't take credit of it. House of wisdom, was the largest library of the middle ages was made by muslim s
A rhetoric without an evidence
In a most prestige university, thefact a group of supposed most clever people applauded so loudly an obvious nonsense of an Islamic activist is most disturbing.
You are right, most of these people come to socialize (rather than learn) and meet other people like them. Most of them do not read books and if they did they read fictitious/romantic novels. On one occasion, I have attended a stupid lecture (similar to this one), I was sitting almost at the front table, I did not applaud. People around me were looking at me with anger (like saying why this guy is not applauding like everybody.
@@ibatan7243 you must be so based😱😱
the mere fact that a university invites someone like this mehdi hassan (an al jazeera propagandist) is a sign of the times: politically correct leftist agenda ;-)
@@ibatan7243 omg u didn't applaud?? Everyone must had had been furious!!!1!
Islamic activist? Nah. Its an islamic nationalist.
This religion is barbaric ... if anything developped in that region is not because of this religion but rather common sense of the people
Exactly, and I wouldn't be that the surprised either if these people weren't that religious or weren't even religious at all to begin with, because we all know what happens if persons were to announce their disbeliefs.
@@amko123 Bagdad ?
"This religion is barbaric" ah yes, this religion is barbaric. It allows women to hold their own property, divorce their husbands, and enforces a strict legal code. For the next 1000 years, Islam was far more lenient than Christianity. Even in the days of the prophet women were employing their husbands and were given education. But unfortunately, due to a couple of Eastern European children we have to call it "barbaric".
@@what2717 taqqya Alert ! You can beat your wife if she deshobey 👍🏽... how does polygamy empowers women ? Or Muttah ? 👍🏽
This religion is the fastest growing religion in west. Your grand daughters will have babies with us, you can not stop that.
Clapping their hands like a herd of sheep.
That would be banging hooves, surely?
Not everyone did.
It’s ‘Herd of Sheep’. Heard is a verb. Herd is a noun. Otherwise, still a stupid comment.
@@seandavidt3538, thanks for teaching me. English is my third languange. But the comment is an correct observation.
'comment is A correct observation'. I hope you are more proficient in your other language studies. I am here (not hear) to help
Do Muslim Science apologists not realize that scientific progress doesn't rely on one particular individual at each step? Numerous people study the same fields (not just today), and at some point one of them will come upon a discovery. If Einstein had died in his teens, would scientists never ever have discovered relativity? :))
thats not the point. Muslim sicence apologists focus on these individuals because they did acheive something regardless of if someone was going to do so anyway. Thats as stupid as saying we shouldn't give two shits about who invented the light bulb or who put who on the moon or who developed algorithms for computers because it doesnt matter, someone else was bound to discover it sooner or later.
Sounds a bit silly mate. Rethink your comment.
Good point. I think it is probably a vast body of collective work out of which 'some' contributing individuals are a bit more outstanding than others. There are probably a lot of individuals being underrated, while others are overrated and everything in between. It is probably an endless debate that will never end.
It is just that the Europeans during the Enlightenment put the entire scientific advancement process on steroids as a consequence of the competition between the nation-states/empires, which also led to very fast advances in military technology.
@@paulnielsen8784 Nobody is denying European achievments. Its simply insulting that when people acknowledge and appreciate European advancements as well as Islamic ones they are deemed misinformed since the "Muhamatans" were influenced by someone which is irrelevant because everyone was influenced regardless of how much they relied on that influence to spark turning points or advancements.
I agree that some people relied less on influence than others and may have contributed less or more than the founders of past knowledge but all of that is irrelevant. Its human nature to communicate our ideas and defining which achievments deserve acknowledgement and appreciation based on the situation of influence is totally impractical and we should applaud and appreciate every human for all they've contributed regardless of who influenced them and how.
If you have an issue with Islam, please focus on criticisng Islam then, don't try and undermine or discredit the achievments of people because you disagree with the religion they follow. It comes off as a little bit shallow with all due respect.
@@cloroxbleach9237 *"Rethink your comment"*
Nothing to rethink. I didn't say anything along the lines of *"we shouldn't give two shits about who invented the light bulb"* etc. Both the light bulb and eg. evolutionary theory had several people working on them at the same time. I don't see how that diminishes anyone. Someone had to come in "first", and this is sometimes even a topic for disagreement.
*"don't try and undermine or discredit the achievments of people because you disagree with the religion they follow"*
Well, Islam is not exactly the best environment for scientific discovery, now is it? This is highly relevant. Crucial, actually.
Nothing wrong with being proud of Muslim scientific discoveries, but it often extends to claiming that Europeans would almost still be living in caves were it not for the Muslims. And that's a bit arrogant.
@@paulnielsen8784 *"the Europeans during the Enlightenment put the entire scientific advancement process on steroids"*
Precisely. And I sense that Muslims kind of envy that, so they feel they MUST point out that "Europeans would be nothing" without them, which I see as false. Europe had a way better environment for scientific inquiry than the Middle East or anywhere else during the Enlightenment. And competition, as you also mention.
Instead of the black history month rubbish taught in our schools, videos such as this would be much more beneficial. History Debunked is also another excellent source of proper historical perspective rather than the woke agenda being pushed eveywhere by our institutions.
Even this video isn't cold hard plain historical fact. Its historical facts then fried with some personal opinion, topped with some discrediting and misrepresentation and then an odd and debateable conclusion to be the cherry on top.
If you're talking about things that should be pushed around in institutions it should be nothing but the facts. Leave the opinions and analysis of the history for the students themselves because then you're just as bad that "woke agenda" you detest so much. Im also pretty sure when your history teacher taught you history, he/she didn't give you their opinion followed by an argument and then analysis that supports their opinion. The teacher is there to show you the facts and make clear anything you don't understand. What you're pushing for is the exact same thing as that "woke agenda" except you're doing it just to support *YOUR* point of view and *YOUR* side of the spectrum. Lovin the double standards but thats typical in this comment section.
@@cloroxbleach9237 I beg to differ, Clorox Bleach, this video does give out a lot of facts on this interesting issue. Much more so than the made up nonsense of black history month and its massive distortions of history. I am sure we both can agree on this.
@@DrJefflang A quick search online would answer that. Who's biased?
History Debunked is a very interesting channel. He usually will leave a link, or otherwise indicate his sources unlike some. I may not always agree with his views but he seems to cover various topics with respect & research.
@@annem9195 Agreed Ann Em, he makes a statement and then backs it up with evidence. There are so many that make statements based on emotion and feelings rather than any facts, that is the probelm with the woke nonsence that is all about us these days.
not a single person actually knew what was being said and was just clapping out of academic virtue signaling group pressure
So true!!
probably true but the audience bear an exact resemblance to this comment section if you scroll around here for longer than 15 seconds
Too bad real expert like you and UA-camrs are not taken seriously by university and teachers
Imagine labeling the renaissance, enlightenment age and industrial revolution part of a christian golden age. Copernicus would be turning in his grave.
Right? Religious fundamentalists often seek to co-opt everything, because at the base, Abrahamic faiths are about syncretism and consolidation of cultural power, through theological narratives of grand plans by a creator. This is about power to them, nothing else.
@@markustanbeck9149 it's pure entitlement and arrogance. Just as with the entitlement that non believers shouldnt criticise the religion. Disgusting attitude imo
Swallowing the enlightenment myth?
The Christian Golden Age is yet to come
The rise of the West including Science and Industrialism were born from the civilization of Catholic Christianity and no where else.
As Steven Crowder would say, "prove me wrong"
Activists, separatists, extremists and finally terrorists, that’s Islamic history.
Burning widow, developing caste system, killing people for eating beef, that's Hindu and Indian history.
Colonialism, genocide of natives. Burning heretics and witches is Christian history
This is so stupid and terrible saying all Muslims are Terrorists but in fact it’s the completely the opposite..
Islam stole everything from zoroastianism
Lol that’s impossible to prove, try and prove it
And hate stole your thinking capabilities.
Not just Zoroastianism, but from Jews and Christians too like Islam should be called the father of plagiarism
@@fearallah9251 zoroastrianism and anything that is still left is destroyed by islam. Their temples statues etc. Zoroastrianists were one of the first people in the regions where everyone is muslim they were killed or forced to convert. They were into science and engineering, astronomy, also the Byzantine empire in turkey and Iran and Iraq. The pyramids were damaged by muslims. The library of Alexandria that stored the biggest and oldest papers in history was destroyed by muslims. The buddhist temples in the middle east are blown up and were killed by muslims.
Basically. And it is not surprising. Arab where pretty much a group of semibarbarian nomads, not a civilization. Even the typical "islamic" architecture was basically persian and bizantine. Tent dwellers don't build domes.
Thank you for bringing this to light. I sensed that there was something sketchy about the Islamic "Golden Age", now I know why.
it was sketchy because you probably didn't belive people who weren't white were capable of being civilised and making mathematical and scientific advancements.
Me too.
Do you think that the following video contributes an accurate criticism of the suggested Islamic Golden age? Do you think all his suggested points are not manipulated or briefly searched, or even made a biased source?
I am not trying to tell you that the video is inaccurate, but I want to shed the light that what you see can be manipulated by your bias, depending on your tendency to believe.
@@MM-KunstUndWahrheit Because that guy presenting Islam as such a great thing is not manipulated by his bias? Give me a break, mate. We all have a bias, anyone who will tell you the opposite is a fool. I do not believe that Islam is as progressive as it is made up to be and judging by the way Islam rules in certain countries, I have no reason to believe otherwise.
@@amko123 Storing data from past civilizations does not necessarily make you a creative mind.
ISLAMIC IMPERIALISM
Conquest of Syria: 634-641 Conquest of Maghreb: 670-742
Conquest of Egypt: 639-642 Conquest of Hispania: 711-721
Conquest of Persia: 633-651 Conquest of Sindh: 711-714
Conquest of Transoxiana: 673-751
''Islamic golden age'' was just an echo of Greek/Roman and Persian civilizations, that's why islamic world didn't even come close to repeating anything like it for the last 1000 years.
@KHABIB ** TIME Only thing they did is that 'Muslim scholars preserved and enhanced the learning of ancient Greece' And then Western civilization enhance it 10 times more. While muslim world did nothing. So all this ''European culture owes an immense and immeasurable debt to the world of Islam'' is the biggest exaggeration and islam pandering I ever read.
Western Europe lost many classic Greek and Roman texts due to wars in Migration Period. While islam conquer the richest parts of Roman Empire and with that all the knowledge with it. Then all this conquered people, many of them were eastern christians, translated all that texts to arabic. So islam's only achivement was that it did not destroy ancient texts like barbarians in Europe did.
When Western Europe got to their feet together after all that devastation of Migration Period, it quickly start to collect lost knowledge (with some help of ''islam'') and what more, it start to upgrade with a fast pace. And this is what makes Christian world and muslim world different. Islam had the knowlage and advantage and didn't do much with it. It only preserve European knowledge, while Europeans lost their own. LIke I say islamic golden age is just an echo of Greek, Roman and Persian civilization.
@KHABIB ** TIME I already tell you that ''Dark ages'' were only for Europe and why.
My question is, if science in islam is a real thing why islamic world didn't discover nothing in the last 1000 years?
This
The reason the "islamic world" (or the places that western powers obsess over occupying and pouring millions of dollars into military funding over in order to bomb the shit out of then destroying crucial infrastructure, homes, markets and places of education) won't come close to repeating anything is pretty obvious if you do a little research on the history of the middle east throughout the past century.
@@cloroxbleach9237 Oh, cry me a river. So what, they have wars. Europe has far more and bloody wars than middle east. Even Russian who lost almost 30 million people and much of the country was destroyed in WW2, then 20 years after that they send a human into a space. Meanwhile middle east has couple of wars in the last 100 years and that's why whole islamic world can't discover nothing in the last 1000 years. Your logic is unbelievable.
there wouldn't have been a need for a renaissance if the muslims didn't burn all those libraries 😆
LOL dog, Mongols did it, basic history.
Fun fact they would have also tore down the Pyramids but the locals created and spread superstitious rumors about them so they were left alone .
The Egyptians probably predicted their kind comming and made the pyramids supremely stable structures.
"superstition" sounds very sinful in the context of islam. So this statement makes 0 sense because any muslim knows there is no such thing as superstition but its ok, you probably don't know anything about the religion you love to tear down.
@@MrZoomZone I Hope this is satire🤣🤣
Saladins son, Al Aziz Uthman tried to tear down the pyramids starting with the pyramid of menkaure and it was almost as costly to destroy it than build it and gave up after 8 months, its still got a huge gash down one side from the damage
I wonder if the pyramids could even be destroyed without modern day equipment and weaponry.
This is such a dead on video. Mehdi Hassan and his obsessive need to bolster his ego and ward off his stunning ( and most certainly obnoxious) insecurity through cultural appropriation. Whatever the contribution of those he references one things for sure, he or Islam would never hold a candle to any of the scholars, Muslim or not, he oh so wishes to associate himself and his precious Islam with. We'll _never_ see that a-hole in any lab or study solving any of the worlds problems or making any contributions to the repository that could be considered the knowledge of man.
Edit: I truly despise the type of people that knod, approve and clap so instantaneously and automatically at his, or for that matter any other sjw activist's, every word, utterance or assertion.
you are 100% right, that obnoxious idiot should ask himself why Islam descended to primitive societies despising true knowledge if Islam really was that golden, the sad fact is that most people don't know how advanced western technology AND mathematics are compared to what they had in the "dark ages", another sad fact is that people in political power positions usually don't have a clue either, they are just rarely engineers and realists, i'm afraid the battle is lost
Very interesting video, looking at that ‘blind’ young audience applauding, and take it for granted what this man is telling them give me not a good feeling.
it's as if a confident delivery means it MUST be true - and it's polite to clap.
The people who clap should have their civil rights reduced to the level of a serf.
Boomers still thinks they are smarter, blind clown sitting at home and thinks he understands everything because he googled it.
If Islam was so advanced as some claim how did it not advance for over 1000 years and was overtaken completely by the west , how come Islam did not invent TV Radio Planes trains engineering feats medical advances telecommunications etc, somehow Islam never got around to discovering these
greek and Indian (hindu) sciences is an essential part of the foundation of the modern day science.
because the islamic world went to shit? crusades, mongol invasions, turkic invasions, and later on colonialism. This is like shooting a dog 8 times and then wondering why It stopped moving. You can see the same things happening in Eastern europe with Russia. The Russian tsars stomped on democracies like Novgorod, and became an absolute monarch leaving Russia in the 1200s for centuries to go. This is just blatant islamaphobia.
@@what2717 Yet Europe suffered the same fate but yet has contributed far more to humanity than any Islamic nation has
@@clay119ya
In genocids as well
@@Bla3817not more than how much destruction is lam brought to so many civilisations.
Literally all of your arguments could be applied to any religion and any intellectual, it’s got nothing to do with Islam specifically
The closest to "Islamic Golden Age" that was at the time should be really called Persian Golden Age, after the Abbasid revolution marked by the succession of several enlightened rulers and the general shift to eastern influence in the Caliphate.
In university I was asked to choose between writing a paper on the contributions of Islam to science and the modern world and patriarchal themes in television series. This was in Australia and it was a marketing degree. I quit university not long after because I could see I wasn't going to learn anything useful.
LOL
as a muslim i say: wow . u stopped ur studies because of Islamophobic ideology. good job. next year come to us saying "U HERETICS WILL ALL BURN! DEUS VULT!, for jesus!!!" keep it up
I write whatever the university wants me to write. This is just to get my degree. Am I proud of it? Nope, but I certainly want to beat these people at their own game.
@@storyworld1866 that's up to you, but I personally think it is a waste of money. You won't beat them by doing exactly what they want.
@@hidolu3104 Eeee... waste of money? University is free though. And as for what I'm studying. I'm becoming an elementary school teacher... so I know the shit they want me to teach children. Here's the thing. I think my professors are just the same as me but they also have to follow the university's guidelines and so they comply with it and I try to see something to learn from the lectures and seminars even in the most useless lectures ever before which was on gender studies or whatever.
The point is. I'm trying to establish a name for myself so that I become trustworthy just like Jordan Peterson. I'm trying to create an ethos. Because it is clear to me that most people these days don't care about logos. All they care about is ethos and pathos, soooo since they only do that I'll lead them to logos through ethos and perhaps even using pathos.
How can a plagiarised book contrubuted to science and philosophy?
Plagiarised how? Because the same people who criticise Islam are likely Christians and Jews and so if the Quran is plagiarised, Christianity and Judaism are both as deserving of the same if not more ciriticism than Islam because these are the only two religions that you're probably implying the Quran had plagiarised off of.
@@cloroxbleach9237 ''Plagiarised how?'' Islamic stories and accounts (complete with the exact claims and errors) the original sources made are known, some of the Islamic stories literally cut, copy, pasted these accounts. It's embarrassing how bad this plagiarism is, I guess the many scholars are afraid of losing relevance so continue to perpetuate propaganda and trying to cover tracks for Islam.
Islam plagiarized multiple sources, Zoroastrian, Christian, Gnostic Jewish, Arab folk tales Ancient Mariners accounts, Greek observations.
The flying donkey (Burag) sourced 3000 years earlier under Zoroastrianism.
The Apocryphal stories known by Jewish Rabi & Christian scholars to be later forgeries that islam copied, such as the Jewish folktale Adam was 60 cubits or almost 30 meters high, the tallest man died age 22 last century, he suffered from circulatory problems because the human heart struggles to pump blood in people that are exceptionally tall (over 2.5 meters), research giantism and the many health conditions it brings, and all this in people well under 3 meters high; at 30 meters a human skeleton could not even stand due to the earth's gravity, their lungs would be crushed.
Muhammad was from a Hindu sect originally in his infancy, Hindus for centuries recite long oral traditions for hours at a time, they circumambulate around their holy shrines like the Muhammadan do with Kaaba.
There are hundreds / thousands of websites, videos and individuals who have debunked all of the endless fallacies and claims of the Quran and the attendant books.
Claim the Bible 'corrupted' did not appear until 4 centuries of Islam had elapsed, by a frustrated Islamic scholar, the founder had claimed Torah & Injeel as foundation and light, he genuinely believed it was a firm revelation but he desired to be the ultimate abrogation to all that had gone before (or so the stories go), but
The Arab who studied under the Greek Galen and brought back the embryological claims the Quran makes replete with exactly the same short comings Galen made.
@desneribe actually, quran is heavly influenced by christianity, judaism and arabic paganism.
See also the useful video "Bill Warner, PhD: The Not So Golden Age of Islam". Bill has a methodical way of presenting information.
I think this video ispiring by him too
I think this video was too kind to Islam. The destruction of flowering civilisations and the snuffing out of the potentially great civilisation in Visigoth Spain were global disasters that have set the world back centuries.
Not to mention the 50M Hindus massacred by the Mughals.
What was done in India was also bad. Two huge universities Nalanda and Takshilla. Was centre of Ayurveda (medicine ) philosophy science etc. Everything. But . Its well recorded that Bhaktiyar Khilji when invaded this subcontinent in A.D 1197 destroyed and burned all that was there. There were so many books that it burned for a whole 3 months. A lot of work we lost. And from then onwards when islamic rulers ruled all the sciences philosophy that was taking place came to a standstill for 900 years. They were much more hostile to us because we were recognised wid pagan culture.
What scientific/mathematical accomplishment did the spainards or Mexicans created? I’ll wait
@@rajibdattaroy9105everything created in india was done by Persians, Elamites and indo Europeans. It’s truly embarrassing to call it Indian inventions
More than kind
I think this channel is so underrated. That narcissist is either a pseudo intellectual or is a total liar trying to take credit from the the works of great minds to make his so called peaceful religion look good. It's really sad to see so many young people influenced by misinformation. This is what happens when people don't learn just mug up subjects like history in school. They also need to integrate Philosophy along with subjects like history and geography! I'll be Sharing this video now. Unfortunately most people aren't interested in these topics but I'll do my part. Keep post content like this. I learn a ton. Thank you for sharing your knowledge ❤️
why is islam not a peaceful religion for this
Excellent analysis.
@@amko123 Because it was destroyed.
I don't like disrespecting religions, but I think I lean this way, after seeing how 2 women's intelligence is equal to 1 man's, and how these days radical islamists also want to destroy history and any tech they don't understand, wanting to stay primitive and revert to olden more traditional living, I think traditional living can be great for some people, but burning books and destroying architecture in turn erasing important history is despicable by any means, if the ancients beliefs were wrong it should be established through education not eradication, it's just dumb to press delete on what came before, would I delete all watches and restart a new watch design from scratch? Hell no! Just like George Daniels did, he learnt about cutting edge watch tech and redeveloped the mechanical escapement to be more efficient then the digital watches of the time, which is an EXTRAORDINARY feat of engineering! A mechanical watch made out of 100% metal more accurate then a digital quartz watch in the 70s- early 80s!!!!!! Mind blowing! And he did it through education and engineering, if he eradicated the original watch designs from his bran he would NEVER have been able to come up with such an efficient escapement within his lifetime!
This example just plainly shows how ignorant, backwards and damaging destroying what came before can be and how useful and helpful previous iterations of knowledge and technology can be for making life easier and more efficient..
@Danny Timms well majority of religions bring alot of civility and peace to people's lives, at the same time extremists should be rejected, so people should be analyzed and criticized not the religions themselves..
Of course there are a few exceptions with the religions that are just silly and delusional..
No1 knows 100% what or how our realm was created and what's going on, any1 claiming to is dumb as hell..
Many bad things have come out of religions but if the religions didn't exist humans will still do bad things lol
Blame human nature, not a set of beliefs and morals used to keep civilisations civil, stable and community orientated which is what's needed for healthy numbers to increase and overall happiness, wellbeing and solid structure thruought the communities that are expanding, religions have been an excellent tool for that, when empires get obsessed with gender and social science rejecting moralistic religions, is when empires crumble, I'm sure you've seen the reasons why the major empires failed in the past, mainly a direct consequence of the previously mentioned factors .. scary as fuck!
@Danny Timms a book? My rebuttal was a straight forward remark, can barely articulate a point of view from a few paragraphs..
Maybe the books you read are a couple paragraphs..
Btw, I'm far from religious, just use logic and reason unlike some people..
@Danny Timms You can criticise a religion all you want in order to prove it doesn't deserve respect but when the basis of your whole argument is the actions of the followers, You've already lost the argument and you've no justifications for any disrespect.
What I struggle to understand is despite all you people hating Islam, you rarely criticise it. You're always focusing on the actions of the followers as if it has any relevance to the nature of islam in its true form.
Criticise the fucking religion then maybe you can prove to anyone whose sane that it doesn't deserve respect. If all you're going to talk about is ISIS and the trans-saharan slave trade then I guess every religion in existence also doesn't deserve respect.
@Danny Timms Thanks for the insightful and useful reply there, I've learned alot.
I did a white paper in university days about Arab medicine. The following findings I recall: 1) 99% of the most fameous Arab medical scientists was merely applying Roman medical traditions (Galen - 4 body humours). 2) From 650 to 1650 AD there was only one original chirurgical innovation by Arabs - the operation of eye cataracts - it was only practiced in Egypt by one fameous doctor and forgotten afterwards. 3) Most "Arab scientists" weren't Muslims but (formally converted)Jews. That is also why "Golden Age" stuff of islam only happened in Egypt, Andaluz (Spain) and Isfahan (Persia) where large Jewish-Christian minorities lived. 4) There were no universities ever and the science greats of the Golden Age were singular aberrations, a few in the 10th to 13th century, nothing after 1256 (fall of Bagdad to Mongols)
6) the only tangible role of the Arabs was preserving a solid amount of Greco-Roman writings via translations by Jews into Arabic that would be translated a few hundred years later back into Latin by other Jews. Not sure how highI would rank that achievement consider it was the Muslims who destroyed the Romano-greek and Persian empires in the first place.
Most of what you mention involving the applying of roman traditions was ALSO being done in europe at the time. Europe hadpretty much 0 medical innovations up until the 1800s with ideas such as germ theory, spontaneous generation and advancements involving immunisation. The only pre-enlightenment medical innovations and advancements made by the europeans then was ideas such as basic hygiene and theories that were complete regurgitations of much older already known roman ideas. Mind you basic hygiene was a thing in arabia for quite some time too ;)
The only difference is, whilst both were applying roman traditions, the Arabs were the ones who were actually researching and developing different perspectives when it came to medicine. The europeans sat with the 4 humours and the Theory of Opposites for about 900 years until they decided they should do something. Research it yourself, Im not bullshitting you
"No universities ever". Somebody didnt do his homework lmao. Some of the earliest universities were created by muslims. Timbuktu, The university of Al-Qarawiyyin, The many smaller universities established by the Mali Empire, The entirity of the Ottoman empire had also quite a few universities. This is off the top of my head but it already shows how little you know about Islamic history.
I know when you mentioned this you referenced arabs and I have included non arab examples, but lets be honest, you're not trying to criticise Arabs, you're going for Islam so I have mentioned muslims who have created universities during the Islamic Golden Age.
@@cloroxbleach9237you seem to misunderstand how universities are defined in academic circles. Example: It is true that Timbuktu for hundreds of years was a place of scholarship and the foremost chronicles regarding the history of West African kingdoms. However, just like Rome never developed universities in the sense of modern "college traditions", that tradition is traceable to Athenean philosophical academies with the first post-Greek examples popping up for philosophy, law, theology and medicine in Italy (Salerno, Bologna, Salamanca) in the 13th century. There is no university in the Islamic world that can trace its lineage directly back to the places you mention. There are quite a few universities in Spain, France, Italy and even England who have been universities in name and practice without interruption for 600 to 800 years. So even if we would agree these centers of yours had universities and not just a scholarly community it is undisputable that the "scientific traditions" in the Islamic world were too weak to allow a consistent development and expansion of collective and collaborative scientific knowledge management on the basis of full-time academics teaching classes of students. Already Martin Luther went to a university and had classes, but none of the Muslim great minds in the 15th or 16th century did.
@@cloroxbleach9237 by 1650 the Ottoman sultans regularly consulted and by 1700 regularly employed as personal physicians European doctors. That yardstick strongly suggests the Europeans had significantly bypassed Islamic medicine by that point. Galen wasn't a thing in Western medicine after 1550. By then the scientific method of documented experimentation and the principle of deriving medical knowledge from exhuming human corpses followed by teaching these findings broadly to college attendees gained broad and soon general acceptance in universities in Western Europe. This is one reason why the "enlightenment" period fully bypassed the Ottoman empire wnd all orher Islamic states .... Another was that islamic, scholars after 1400 suffered much more suppression from Muslim clerics than their European counterparts and took centuries longer than the Europeans and Americans to adapt the Gutenberg printing press which greatly sped dissemination of ideas. Most of Ibn Rushd's scrolls were burned by clerics during his lifetime....
Arabs them self claim that indians had great knowledge of medicine
Thanks for debunking the Myth of the "Golden Age of Islam". My question to Muslims: if Islam contribute such a great deal to the mankind, why doesn't it continue to contribute to the humankind's development since the Renaissance and the first industrial revolution?"
What do u mean
The app u using right now was made by a Muslim
You should have ended the video with a comparison of scientific Nobel Prizes won by muslims versus those won by Jews for example. And make sure to als mention the total number of jews and muslims. It was a difference that was almost 200-fold!
In the modern islamic world, its an undeniable fact that science is detested however this has nothing to do with Islam in itself and is mainly just far-right muslims who think anything is apostasy or blasphemy.
Are Jewish people that jealous? All I’m seeing is Jewish and Indians. Those “Jews” that won Nobel awards are 100 percent european, mainly Russian. They’re not the real Hebrews of Middle East. The real jews have never accomplished anything history other than being gypsies. Why don’t you compare real jews to Muslims? Btw Nobel prize awards are controlled by jeiwsh elites, they hand themselves awards left and right but yea let’s compare the two 😂
We have Afghanistan under complete Islamic rule at the moment, now let’s see how they’re all getting on...
Wonderful video. I have to share this. More people needs to be awaken to the rubbish Islam teaches.
@@DrJefflang he either doesn't know about it or isnt ready to have to open up his mind to another perspective
@@DrJefflang in his book he describes the influence of al khwarizmi when he went to study in Baghdad, meaning the general library there
@@DrJefflang do you really think that these scums are bothering to research about Islam?
Cry kid 🤣🤣🤣
....and thet say we love our enemy😂😂stupid xtians
*After muslims invaded Persia & then India they gradually came in contact of the huge knowledge repository of the Ancient Hindus. The arabic number system that they taught the Europeans were from India. By the way relevant to mention here that Zoroaster belongs to the Atharvan sect of Vedic Hindu culture*
Zoroaster does not belong to Vedic Hindu valley, it was created by indo european Persians who then traveled to India and created Buddhism/Hinduism. Indians didn’t create anything, it was indo Europeans both in Persia and India. Very funny delusional comment though
@@eliza1826 So "indo european" what is that Indian or european? And if they created Buddhusm/Hinduism [dont even know what is that] why didn't they spread that in europe first? Do we see any traces of Ayurveda, yoga, Sanskrit and thousands ancient of Hindu text anywhere in the history of ancient Europe? wonder why?
@@wastedkafir9134 You know..The indo european Aryans that are responsible for most of “indian” accomplishment. the same ones that indians obsess over. Before aryran, Elamites (native to persia) traveled to the Indus and introduced farming to the South Asian Hunter Gatherer Natives. Basically, Indo Europeans and elamites created your culture but you’re too embarrassed to be associated with dravidian whom came from africa and aboriginals from Southeast Asia.
@@wastedkafir9134 Sanskrit belongs to the Indo-European family of languages. It is one of the three earliest ancient documented languages that arose from a common root language now referred to as Proto-Indo-European language: Vedic Sanskrit ( c. 1500-500 BCE). Same with Hindu text :))) basically correlates with European language, native Indians (dravidians) had their own set of language that is completely different to Sanskrit and Hindu text. any other question?
@@wastedkafir9134 are you Jewish? Usually it’s a jew or Indian that eagerly tries to dismiss/claim Persian accomplishment because of jealousy and inferiority compelx . All of Indians Vedic Hindu culture were from Persians/indo Europeans. Zoroaster was main influence for both Buddhism and Hinduism.
So basically Islam shows up carves a hole in knowledge then shoves it with Allah amazing
I'm so sick of the clapping like 'Yeah, go you. Brilliant.'
@JanicePortugaliza who me? lol I'm not crying, I just don't like misinformation.
@@cat67834Where is the misinformation?!
Ye gooo oooon brilliant....
Hell with Allah though 😅
You are sick because you are sick already in your heart
@@godtheonlyguide I'm only going to respond to that by saying have a lovely evening and I hope you find what makes you happy, centered and healthy in life.
This pro-Islam perspective on science and history was even being taught when I was at school in the 2000’s and at uni in the 2010’s. But of course it’s complete nonsense! Very concise video pointing out how Islam has not helped science or civilization at all. Another good example is the basket case of Somalia - where are all the scholars and scientists hailing from there? Keep up the good work!
Really nice, been arguing this for ages. This has given me more data, thanks.
if someone you argued with asked for a source all u could give them is a video full of maps and names
Only the lazy remains gullible and ignorant. Sadly, most of the Western youths have fallen to the snare of complacency, apathy and narcissism, they will believe anything as long as it conforms to "comfort".
If what that guy were to be true . Then there would be lots of Nobel prize winners coming out of the Islamic countries 😂😂
Weird, I was taught about the golden age of islam in highschool history class in the 1987-1990. It never proved to be true, mostly islam destroys history or lies about it.
And if most people bothered to do the research, they would find out that most of the mathematical breakthroughs, and for that matter, mathematics in general...most..if not all knowledge that the Arabs, Persians, and Muslims came from India. India taught all of them mathematics.
Finally!!
Imajine this guy at Oxford- now a joke along with much of the UK and most of the major universes in the US
Once upon a time india was richest among the civilization science fruished , philosophy , relationship started with Greeks and Romans, indo western school started , and then Islam enter and barbaricaly (through cheating ) destroyed india
Plz don't abuse ,
Iam saying facts
Hail Zeus
Hail Jesus
Har har mahadev ( prasing shiva)
He has already shown clips of aryabhatta and brahmagupta in the video, i think he couldn't pronounce it hence he didn't say the names
India was the most powerful and advanced civilization during the Middle Ages. I respect that.
so if these so called enlightend muslims had a golden age why is it every country they conquer they keep the people in the stoneage one thing i hate the most is hypocrosy
Saying "Golden Age of Islam" is like saying the Crusade never happened.
The “golden age of islam.” Known by the rest of humanity as “The Dark Ages.”
The question remains, was that the case because or despite of Islam?
@@ashokafulcrum4795
Historian and author, William Federer, has written comprehensively about the negative effect Islam expansion had on the rest of the world. Particularly with a view to slavery! And it’s barbaric practices towards other nations, at its height, reaching as far as Poland. The Poles pushed Islam, out of Europe.
@@ashokafulcrum4795
I’ll go as far as to say that, Sturgeon is pro Islam and anti-christ.
“If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it is a duck.”
It’s laughable to talk of a so called “golden age of islam,’ when comparing the number of Israeli “Nobel Prize” winners, to that of the Arab nations.😆
They should call it the Arabian Golden Age, instead. Also, they don't call the Renaissance the "Golden Age of Christianity"
We miss you Paul. You have a unique and truthful message. Hope you’re doing well.
is he dead !?!
@@Booklivre I don’t know. All I know is that He’s not posting. I hope he comes back, though.
If the gentleman were correct, then there must have been hundreds of other Muslim scholars inspired by them, and their ideas must have been taken up by society in general. If not, and we know the answer to that, all we have is a few isolated scholars being ignored by everyone else- even if they were all devout Muslims and accepted as such.
To put it more simply, if these were the founders of the renaissance how come the renaissance happened in Christian Italy?
Probably because the entire world was coming out of all ‘Dark Age’ and into an ‘Age of Enlightenment’, you just only study European history. It was happening everywhere. Do some research my dude.
There is no over confidence like Muslim confidence.😁
You have the nerve to say this while trying to steal the work of Islamic golden age because of some conspiracy theory wannabe historian Jewish nobody on UA-cam told you so? you must be Indian or Jewish because this sounds like huge projection.
You apparently never of Indians. All of Indians accomplishments were done by Persians, indo Europeans but here you have Indians claiming Europeans traveled out of India. Apparently they invented the internet during ancient era too 😂don’t forget
@@eliza1826 steal the work of?most of the work done was stealing from others and when that ran out?well you can see the present conditions lmao
@@JjkJjk-or9kc just say you’re a jealous jewish indian mongol 🥰imagine being so jealous you have to make up false information sorry but Jews never had empire and not one thing in this world
@@JjkJjk-or9kc look at the present condition of China/India. You’re going to tell me the same Indians of before are the same Indians of today? 🥰😂😂
EXCELLENT VIDEO NO WORD TO PRAISE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU ARE THE ONLY WESTERN MAN CURRENTLY IN MY KNOWLEDGE WHO INCLUDES TRUTH NO MATTER HOW HARSH IT IS TO WOKE PEOPLE. YOU INCLUDED INDIA ALSO WHICH WAS GREAT SEAT OF KNOWLEDGE BUT EVEN ITS NAME IS NOT TAKEN BY WESTENERS. THANKS ONCE AGAIN FOR THE TRUTH. THIS VIDEO SHOUL BE SEEN BY MILLIONS IF NOT BILLIONS.
Jai Shree 32gb ram 😂
Great video, its time to challenge these claim made by Islamists.
They lie through their teeth to peddle Islam, because this is about power to them, not about truth.
Just like leftists. What did Joe Brandon say? Something like "We care about truth, not facts." That says a lot in so few words.
nice research paul. i believe in a comment that i had also talked about how i kinda debunked the golden age of islam and how al-khwarizmi discovered algebra and algorithms and how ancient india had also discovered it much before. also thank you for including nalanda! overall superbe work!
I got nothing against Indians but in every History debunking video involving the discovery of something, there is always some Indian dude in the comments claiming Indians found it first and the number of times I've seen this makes me and any sane person skeptical of this random claim.
@@cloroxbleach9237 I think the claim is only regarding Al-Khwarizmi's inventions, especially on numerals when his book on it was literally called "On the Calculation with Hindu Numerals" (translated to latin as Algoritmi de numero Indorum) and that his algebra might have been inspired by works of Brahmagupta and Diophantus. Don't believe them, but you can always do a personal enquiry to know if it's a true claim or not, without disregarding it right? I do the same with the other view points. Nothing can be trusted on the internet, so better enquire yourself and find if the other person is wrong instead of outrightly dismissing something just because they are associated with labels that are not considered politically correct in current socia climate.
After watching Paul Nielsen's videos for instance, I go online to make sure if he's saying the truth, I'll trust his narrative after I fact check some claims myself. When he turns out consistently honest, I can start believing him without cross checking facts. But in modern political climate, people blindly believe the politically correct narratives without fact-checking, this is very anti-intellectual trend and would affect our scientific progress in the long run.
@@cloroxbleach9237 😂😂. See there were bunch of people in ancient India who worked on these areas like any other people on other parts of the world.
So ya I agree always chest thumping about it might make others skeptical about it.
@@cloroxbleach9237 even chess was invented by inda.
@@lfds8342 Im not claiming Indians didn't contribute anything. Every nation and every people have did wonderful things its just I see too many Indians claiming the achievments of others it makes me skeptical of any claim made by an Indian involving something Indians invented.
Somehow I ask myself why the "Golden Age" did not lasted, I guess because the Islam became more radical, but I am not sure.
Coz you dont know*
Mongols invaded Baghdad and destroyed all the libraries
I think C. Hitchens had a great exposé on the matter.
Love to hear that.
@@danbaumann8273 Bill Warner phd as well
Pierre Curie said
"We have just 30 books left from Muslim Spain and we were able to split the stoke with it. If we only had a half of the million books burned we would be travelling through galaxies by now"
Roger Bacon who you call The father of the Scientific Method, said that it was Ibn Al Haythem was the actual father of the Scientific Method..
The myth comprehensively debunked. But it was painful to see so any naive faces in Oxford. 12 Year-olds in southern Europe could teach them a thig or two
Look at all those seals applauding without questioning anything.
He Nielsen. I really miss your insight in these topics. When would you make a new video?
You don’t even look human. Wtf 😳
Many of the same "Muslim" scientists that modern Muslims are so proud of and site their contributions as proof for their dogma's rightfulness were not actually Muslims. Some of them were even atheists and criticized not only Islam but all religions openly. Rhazes and Khayyam being the famous ones.
I would argue, as an atheist, that the religion of Islam was in fact one of the main factors in the occurrence of the "Golden Age." Had those Arabs not been united under the banner of Islam by their prophet, they wouldn't and couldn't set out to create the largest empire the world had seen up to that point. Without those conquests happening, all those different peoples wouldn't have a common tongue to communicate in. The Moors from North Africa, for example, wouldn't be as interested in reading the writings of some guy in a faraway land called Persia, written in an unknown language. Islam also gave all those different peoples a single identity, which helped a lot. Knowledge wouldn't travel nearly as swiftly and efficiently as it did under the caliphates, either.
Those fanatic desert-dwelling Arabs did cause the Golden Age, even if unintentionally.
Not sure the peoples they conquered were that much interested in yet another imperial incorporation after they sorted themselves out of the Roman Empire.
@@MatthewVanston Not sure why you would think that, and not sure what that has to do with what I wrote :)
One day, a priest is walking down the street and sees a little girl with a box. “What’s in the box?”, the priest asks. “Christian kittens”, the little girl answers. Pleased, the priest smiles and continues on his way. A week later, the same priest is walking down the street with a nun when he sees the little girl and the box again. “Ask her what she has in the box”, he says, “It’s the cutest thing!” The nun walks up and asks the girl what she has in the box. “Atheist kittens”, she says. The priest rushes forward and says "ATHEIST KITTENS!!! Last week you said they were “Christian kittens!!!” “They were”, she says. “Now their eyes are open”.
An old interconfessional joke that has been turned on its head.
The Audience applauded at the Oxford Union with them not having a clue what the Speaker was talking about.
The Islamphobic boomers sitting in his house knows the real truth
He is a PR agent for the political machine known as Islam
Thanks for this video ! We need facts with research ! Amazing
Great video! I remember reading that, in the glory days of the old Soviet Union, the USSR was also credited with inventions it wasn't really responsible for.
this video is first class
Thanks Paul, as usual, excellent screen shots, commentary, clear explanations.
Pace and pauses as I often notice, is excellent also, easy to digest the info and hold the concepts.
Your approach in analysis is very effective no matter what your topic.
Keep'em coming
The most idiotic thing is that Mehadi is of Indian origine, most probably a Hindu converted to Islam but look how is singing songs for Izlam. This shows how inferiority complex he has.
The early caliphs were influenced by Roman, Greek and Persian rulers who were open, then the influenced died when religious zealots within Islam became more resilient.
Thank goodness for facts, and those who still care about them! Well done, sir!
The sun sets in a muddy pool of warm water somewhere in the far West where a group of people are said to be living dhul Quarnain was said to have reached that place 😅😅😅😅
The earth is spread out flat like a carpet and the mountains are pegs that hold the earth down 😅😅😅😅
The sun travels under the earth towards the East and then rises again 😅😅😅
shooting stars aka meteors/ comets are missiles from god to blast devil's arse
Brilliant work and well researched . Thank you for doing this and I hope more people watch this , so they can confidently dismantle the misinformation spouted by Mehdi and his likes . I wish all the religions and ethnic groups would be prosperous and contribute to a better world . However ,the dishonesty by people like Mehdi and Reza Aslan needs to be checked .
Lay out the claims. Then debunk them with historical background, timeline, and facts, all in under 20 minutes. Against the tide of modern so-called scholars and historians repeatedly pushing a tired old but apparently popular golden narrative. Unsurprisingly, this video has less than 25K views. Quite a world we live in.
… very eloquent, well argued and demonstrated documentation, not least the apt description of ‘… pationate delivery….” and “… young Western Europeans impressed by marginalized group standing up for themselves…’ in the introduction to show what they capitalize on to proof their point.
Well more "europeans" need to stand up for Ukriane, for Tibet, oppressed people in China and all the oppressed people in Islamic countries. Even the Feminists are silent about the oppression of women by leftist groups and Muslims and all their other darlings. They are too stupid to realize that under sharia the postmodern and feminatzis and all those will be stoned to death first
Yes Islamic rulers destroyed Nalanda library in India, and God knows what it had, maybe Science and Algebra.
Islam rejected the logos. Except before Islam Arabs were more advanced, but the golden age of Islam um no, this is a lie
@desneribe I was no defending them , I was jujst trying to tell the truth, geez. I do not believe in the golden age of Islam. Your answer is childish, this is why nobody can have a ratioanal discussion anymore. Everyone has done bad in history, I was not even pointing that out
@@shiro703 I am not saying they were as advanced as Europeans, but they went downhill slowly after Islam
If he is correct, then the middle east would be very advance & developed by now. Lets see what happens when the world dont need their oil anymore.
This was the talk I began to dislike that muslim guy. Years ago,, he was good at twisting and lying about things. Kinda like his religion it would seem.
Perhaps the Dumbing Down of the Western World by the Left has something to do with the applause he gets. Anyway, after all the "Islamic" scholars came the real Islamic puritan Ibn Taiyymiah (Spelling may differ) who is also called the Shaykh ul Islam, and because of whom, Islam is what it is today
It's as fake as a black Anne Boleyn.
The Encyclopedia Brittanica says that the library had in fact been destroyed long before the advent of Islam - in the fourth century AD. Phillip K. Hitti,
Luciano Canfora[27] afferma che gli Arabi avrebbero cagionato seri danni alla biblioteca, seguito da Franco Cardini[28], che afferma che taluni studiosi di oggi tendono ad eliminare le fonti che non godono di buona stampa nel mondo musulmano; secondo Cardini, «il corso più probabile degli avvenimenti secondo la critica storica, filologica e archeologica recente è questo: (…)
48-47 a.C.: primi danni, collaterali a un incendio che vide Giulio Cesare come corresponsabile;
III secolo: incendio della biblioteca. Successiva ricostruzione nel IV secolo. La biblioteca si arricchisce dei nuovi volumi della celebre scuola alessandrina. Il fondo tocca i 40.000 volumi.
642: distruzione definitiva da parte degli arabi[29]».
Fyi - The video is full of logical fallacies.
Nope, your islam is.
@@fitzburg63 ok😂
@@muhamedloshi433 Sure, sure, laugh... that's all you can do.
@@fitzburg63don’t be mad that Jews were bunch of historical nobodies from the desert who never accomplished anything.
@@eliza1826 He doesn't have to be sad. Jews over Muslims any day.
Islam changes everything it touches in a desert.
Islam is where Christianity was 1000 years ago … simple as that
whatever the achievements of islam over a thousand years ago might have been, there is a distinct lack of any more modern ones
The Ottoman empire ended at 1922, it wasn't thousand years ago.
@@yuzan3607 and what does the "sick man of Europe" has to do with the golden age of islam?
@@amko123 and caused the Renaissance thanks to it's advanced time travell?
read history
That is the history with no islamic lies.
You are aware that the library of Alexandria had already been destroyed, wiping out much learning (probably with the help of and/or organized by Fundamentalist Christians), right?
It was probably destroyed in a political dispute, where the left-over Library became Collateral damage.
I'm always thinking can't we just change the Qur'an to be more friendly to Western civilization and science and teach Muslims that version. Having a version of Islam that is updated could do wonders for the Muslims here.
Problem is that the Quran is believed to be the direct word of god and that anyone who tries to change it is an apostate who should be killed. That is why Islam is so rigid.
quran be changes?,brother look what happened to the bible.There are so many versions of it until it lost its meaning.The christians even disrespect their own jesus.The problem we muslims are having because of politics and some are just too extremists.
What wonders?.All those techs and new knowledges discovered by those europeans have causes many implications to our earth.The introduction of steams alone even caused climate change and the discoveries of atom which bring destruction to our extinction.The europeans have bring more harm than good.Even our fiat money.A paper money system with no value!
@@paulnielsen8784 EUROPEANS 🤪
@@genghiskhan3914 Huh?
Unfortunately not possible Islam wants to conquer the world and cause all to become Mohammedans which cannot and will never happen as there are Millions that KNOW that Islam is a false religion.
Does people clapping are worse than the clown talking
Mr. Nielsen, what do you think about the books of Michel Houellebecq regarding islam in France?
Probably a look into the future of France.
580 AD, you mean 680 AD right?
or wouldn't it have been 850?
We wuz kingz nd queens nd shiettt
You should really include sources in your videos in the future, it would make it a lot easier to understand where your claims come from & make them a lot more believable.