I love Walters ‘attitude’ when he sings. I love Walter anyway, but when he sings it adds another dimension to the music. I wish he had sang more with SD.
I wonder why Walter didn’t sing more! He’s got a great kind of soulful voice! I guess he backed up Donald with harmony in the studio recordings as well! No question his guitar playing is TOPS !!
Hearing Walter sing this is terrific. I remember hearing walter sing live, I think his vocal range, for some reason, did not translate well and seemed to be muddled. But this version is really good.
Jesus Christ! This is Da Best version out there of this song! Walter Becker is beyond incredible, so much energy & determination in his delivery! The band and particularly the ladies also sound on-point here! An absolute treat for music lovers!
Wow, what a gem of a find, for any Steely Dan fan. That solo is just raw and so powerful, along with a very crisp sounding horn section. Love this version.
coool version. Love the power and drive. fresh snare. And Walter´s singing is kiiler :)))) His voice is so powerful and cool to listen. He drives the band forward. :) I love It. Nice chords. One of my favourite songs on the world. )
He had such a unique, cool voice. I love 11 tracks of whack, his solo album. One of the best of all their albums I think. Even though they are all great!
Notice how the recorded version was reworked. Much soul was lost in transition and let’s be frank: this was Becker’s song and he delivered it with much more power and conviction. It’s a shame how they were boxed into Fagan’s voice, especially for live performances. A true taste of what Becker brought to the table.
The live is loose and snappy , however, the album version might be one of the top-five productions of ever. There's something to be said for both of these guy's vocals, I just happen to be in the Fagen camp when it has Steely Dan on the album. In Becker's solo stuff, I just love the mixture.
Don't get me wrong... Donald Fagen is the voice of Steely Dan, and his production vocals were always spot on. I just enjoy the vocal diversity of their early work, and believe Becker's voice matured well enough to bring it more to the forefront of the live shows. In latter years Fagen's live vocal appeared to falter more often. I know he never chose to be the featured vocalist, and I respect how he overcame personal doubt and anxiety to make it work for live performances. I am thankful they had a productive second iteration regardless.
Same basic structure to the tune but changing up the lead vocals and guitar gives it a totally new feel. Walter's voice should have been heard more I guess?
A bunch of other songs from the Manassas show were on youtube and they seem to have disappeared. Wayne Krantz does an unbelievable solo on Green Earrings and I was half way through learning the thing then it was gone. I can’t find a copy of the show anywhere 🤷🏼♂️
I'm pretty sure Walt took the vocal on this in Birmingham UK when I saw them. I was then surprised that it was Donald on the album. He's cool in his own way.
I saw them at Birmingham NIA in 2007, Heavy Rollers tour. Is that the show you mean? The only one I can recall Walter doing the vocals on was Haitian Divorce.
I’m just repeating what most people have said, but this is by far the superior version. This sounds like classic Royal Scam era Steely Dan, and the album version is like a soft Fagen solo song. Not that I don’t LOVE Nightfly, but it’s just not as gritty
Teddy's rollin' now most every night, Skating backwards at the speed of light, He's changed, In a thousand little ways, he's changed, Woah darlin', yes indeed, You know he's, stuck all in the middle and hanging with the Jack of Speed, At Sheena's party, babe, There's a, case in point, That bogus haircut sure stuck out that joint, He's gone, He may be sleeping' in your bed, But he's gone, Oh darlin', guaranteed, He may be laid out on the sofa, But he's smokin' with the Jack of Speed, I know that you're thinking' how it might be just fine, For one full-blown tear across that thin white line, But will you be laughing' when you're all alone? Lookin' down on the upside, Locked out in the Danger Zone, Well he can't here you, honey, And that's okay, Throw your luggage in that Chevrolet, And you ride on, You run out on that lane's stampede, Ride on, Oh Angel, guaranteed, You got to get out lil' darlin', 'Cause you're dancin' with the Jack of Speed, I know that you're thinkin' how it might be just fine, For one, full-blown tear across that thin white line, But will you be laughing' when you're all alone? Lookin' down on the upside, Locked out in the Danger Zone, Well he can't here you, honey, And that's okay, Throw your luggage in that Chevrolet, And you ride on, You run out on that lane's stampede, Ride on, Yes indeed, You got to get out lil' darlin', 'Cause you're dancin' with the Jack of Speed,
Eh....I still like the studio version sure its mechanical, slightly sterile. The only I have with it is I just heard it as and home at last in 2020. Shit I could've been enjoying it for a decade
@@georggrech5924 It's here: ua-cam.com/video/kF7lCvT_r4o/v-deo.html. Full show: ua-cam.com/video/tEc0W2xP-fE/v-deo.html. Don't know how long it's gonna last...
Hi Daniel, thank you, glad you enjoyed it. More Manassas tracks are available on yt in the meantime (as I'm sure you'll have noticed), including a video of this track.
It was on a couple of weeks ago, but gone again. Particularly love Becker singing on Midnite Cruiser. And if they ever remaster Two Against Nature, I hope they include this version of this song - both are great
I guess, it's a hunt to find that at all. I have the Midnite Cruiser cut digitally. And if it's some money they want, I would certainly buy such a CD if they sold it.
Personally-not trying to convince anybody here-I wish Walter had taken over the lead vocals for TAO and EMG … Fagan’s voice had become quite thin and reedy by the mid 90s. In the 70s it really was one of the most beautifully twisted sounds in music, but for anything made after 2000, I know I’d rather listen to Becker’s gruff, no-nonsense interpretations. Circus Money is worth a listen, for anybody else so inclined. And Eleven Whacks, too.
@@danielmccann8325 I don't even dislike the solo on the record but the live versions always end up having more interesting licks. I can live with it, I'm pretty sure that track was Walter's baby
@@USALeonHeart I would add that Walter guitar sound is super clean on the record, on this one, Wayne distorted sound is one that has not been on a SD record since the Royal Scam. Gives this song a rock edge Plus as you write, excellent licks from Wayne.
@@mclff6926 It's here: ua-cam.com/video/kF7lCvT_r4o/v-deo.html. Full show: ua-cam.com/video/tEc0W2xP-fE/v-deo.html. Don't know how long it's gonna last...
In the early band he played mostly bass while in the last band he played mostly rhythmic guitar. Him and Fagen were mostly writers/composers, they always toured with a lead guitarist and a second usually-lead keyboard player.
This is interesting. I prefer the Fagen vocals and the revised lyrics and the cleaner, more pristine version, although the horn lines here are more energetic being a live version.
Good Evening, Can someone please help me here? Why is everyone talking about Walter's vocals?,... Donald is singing lead,... unless there is some other aspect that people are honing in on. Thank you.
I absolutely love this version and the album version 🤷♂️🎸😎
I love Walters ‘attitude’ when he sings. I love Walter anyway, but when he sings it adds another dimension to the music. I wish he had sang more with SD.
I wonder why Walter didn’t sing more! He’s got a great kind of soulful voice! I guess he backed up Donald with harmony in the studio recordings as well! No question his guitar playing is TOPS !!
Hearing Walter sing this is terrific. I remember hearing walter sing live, I think his vocal range, for some reason, did not translate well and seemed to be muddled. But this version is really good.
I died when he did. Then I came back to life. He lives in my soul
Hands down the better version...RIP Walter. Great music will never be the same without you.
Hard to believe that Walter was never replaced when they tour now.
@@AStanton1966 he kind of has been by this guy Connor Kennedy
I just found out that they replaced him. Last time I saw Steely Dan around here, he wasn't.
Nonsense. You don't replace Walter.
I don’t get why they didn’t put this version on two against nature…walt’s version is 150 times better than the one one the album
Jesus Christ! This is Da Best version out there of this song! Walter Becker is beyond incredible, so much energy & determination in his delivery! The band and particularly the ladies also sound on-point here! An absolute treat for music lovers!
Wow, what a gem of a find, for any Steely Dan fan. That solo is just raw and so powerful, along with a very crisp sounding horn section. Love this version.
coool version. Love the power and drive. fresh snare. And Walter´s singing is kiiler :)))) His voice is so powerful and cool to listen. He drives the band forward. :) I love It. Nice chords. One of my favourite songs on the world. )
Mine too..and FM
one of those times where Walter steps up and shows Fagen isn't always the best on vocals, RIP Walt, you moody bastard, we all miss ya :(
Yeah, he was a trip. I got a bunch of pedal from his estate sale.
What a great comment....one I think Walter would have appreciated.
Words fail me - yet another dimension here. Great stuff and thanks for posting. Who needs any other bands when you have Steely Dan!
I can’t believe how good this is! Wayne Krantz and Walter Becker on point with the guitar and vocal work!
Krantz is fabulous. Took a listen or two to get it. Then I got it.
I love you guys so much you will never know!
RIP Walter Becker. A true genius and the soundtrack of my life since 1977.
DITTO
Pretty good. Always loved Walter's voice.
He had such a unique, cool voice. I love 11 tracks of whack, his solo album. One of the best of all their albums I think. Even though they are all great!
You’ve probably listened to Circus Money, his other solo album and my personal fav. If you haven’t, check it out
The best! RIP Walter Becker. Love this song...love this version.
Dam, Walter's singing is great. Sounds like an old fashioned jazz singer. Thanks for posting this.
Walter sang better live than on record. Although, there are some really good vocals on Slang of Ages and Circus Money.
I think that’s what he was going for ❤
Wayne Krantz solo is killer!!
Jeez Krantz Solo is pure gold.
The drop has so much punch to it. love it
Lovelovelove Walter Becker 🥰
Best version of this song ever!
Thanks for the great music Walt.
Good to here the voice of Walter Becker
Notice how the recorded version was reworked. Much soul was lost in transition and let’s be frank: this was Becker’s song and he delivered it with much more power and conviction. It’s a shame how they were boxed into Fagan’s voice, especially for live performances. A true taste of what Becker brought to the table.
The live is loose and snappy , however, the album version might be one of the top-five productions of ever. There's something to be said for both of these guy's vocals, I just happen to be in the Fagen camp when it has Steely Dan on the album. In Becker's solo stuff, I just love the mixture.
Don't get me wrong... Donald Fagen is the voice of Steely Dan, and his production vocals were always spot on. I just enjoy the vocal diversity of their early work, and believe Becker's voice matured well enough to bring it more to the forefront of the live shows. In latter years Fagen's live vocal appeared to falter more often. I know he never chose to be the featured vocalist, and I respect how he overcame personal doubt and anxiety to make it work for live performances. I am thankful they had a productive second iteration regardless.
I love Walter's vocals here. Especially how it mixes with the female background vocals.
Krantz semi-tamed - what a monster. No better version of this song exists.
(Semi-tamed Wayne Krantz)...well Said...yeah this rocks!!
Same basic structure to the tune but changing up the lead vocals and guitar gives it a totally new feel. Walter's voice should have been heard more I guess?
Its more than just that; the lyrics are different as well as the changes in the bridge...way hipper than the 2VN version
💯
@@timcardona9962 💯
Incredible music. WB in full.
😮 i never knew walter. You never told me you can sing.Jeez the gift
he also sings slang of ages and midnight cruiser outside of his solo work
Best version of this song
Listening to this makes me think Donald was doing a cover of a Walter Becker song on Two against Nature. Walter owns this song.
💯
I hate to say how disappointed I was in the official album version, but then, that's why I'm here. Walt ruled in a thousand different ways.
@@Creaulx I agree but then I remember watching it rise in the Billboard "Smooth Jazz" charts, rooting it on.
Thanks for this.
Krantzs’ solo is 🔥
A bunch of other songs from the Manassas show were on youtube and they seem to have disappeared. Wayne Krantz does an unbelievable solo on Green Earrings and I was half way through learning the thing then it was gone. I can’t find a copy of the show anywhere 🤷🏼♂️
this version is so free and open...best Becker vocal of his life....the studio version is soooo closed, tight and sterile...too careful. NB
neldinsky Nailed it! This is my "official" version.
Brass is louder it seems too
FULLY AGREED!
💯
@@Creaulx 💯
I'm pretty sure Walt took the vocal on this in Birmingham UK when I saw them. I was then surprised that it was Donald on the album. He's cool in his own way.
I saw them at Birmingham NIA in 2007, Heavy Rollers tour. Is that the show you mean?
The only one I can recall Walter doing the vocals on was Haitian Divorce.
I’m just repeating what most people have said, but this is by far the superior version. This sounds like classic Royal Scam era Steely Dan, and the album version is like a soft Fagen solo song. Not that I don’t LOVE Nightfly, but it’s just not as gritty
Teddy's rollin' now most every night,
Skating backwards at the speed of light,
He's changed,
In a thousand little ways, he's changed,
Woah darlin', yes indeed,
You know he's, stuck all in the middle and hanging with the Jack of Speed,
At Sheena's party, babe,
There's a, case in point,
That bogus haircut sure stuck out that joint,
He's gone,
He may be sleeping' in your bed,
But he's gone,
Oh darlin', guaranteed,
He may be laid out on the sofa,
But he's smokin' with the Jack of Speed,
I know that you're thinking' how it might be just fine,
For one full-blown tear across that thin white line,
But will you be laughing' when you're all alone?
Lookin' down on the upside,
Locked out in the Danger Zone,
Well he can't here you, honey,
And that's okay,
Throw your luggage in that Chevrolet,
And you ride on,
You run out on that lane's stampede,
Ride on,
Oh Angel, guaranteed,
You got to get out lil' darlin',
'Cause you're dancin' with the Jack of Speed,
I know that you're thinkin' how it might be just fine,
For one, full-blown tear across that thin white line,
But will you be laughing' when you're all alone?
Lookin' down on the upside,
Locked out in the Danger Zone,
Well he can't here you, honey,
And that's okay,
Throw your luggage in that Chevrolet,
And you ride on,
You run out on that lane's stampede,
Ride on,
Yes indeed,
You got to get out lil' darlin',
'Cause you're dancin' with the Jack of Speed,
I LOVE his new lyrics
Eh....I still like the studio version sure its mechanical, slightly sterile. The only I have with it is I just heard it as and home at last in 2020. Shit I could've been enjoying it for a decade
I need to see this video...
Here you go: ua-cam.com/video/CsTeqXC0K7c/v-deo.html :-)
Damn it! I'm late...
Video is back online now: ua-cam.com/video/RW2mGFKQWlg/v-deo.htmlm6s.
@@DrNanook It isn't anymore mate
@@georggrech5924 It's here: ua-cam.com/video/kF7lCvT_r4o/v-deo.html. Full show: ua-cam.com/video/tEc0W2xP-fE/v-deo.html. Don't know how long it's gonna last...
This is Beautiful it seems to have a new story line when you compare Walter’s voice with Donald’s tempo to this piece
Maybe I have to get used to this version but for now I like the original version better 😎
J Liz *the newer version
Bobby Willis this version was first?
@@jliz6435 Yip. This was live in 1996. Two Against Nature with the studio Jack of Speed came out in 2000
Been looking for this, great work. Apparently the Manassas concert is not available on youtube anymore.
Hi Daniel, thank you, glad you enjoyed it. More Manassas tracks are available on yt in the meantime (as I'm sure you'll have noticed), including a video of this track.
Daniel Tamir Nilsson it's back on there now
It was on a couple of weeks ago, but gone again. Particularly love Becker singing on Midnite Cruiser. And if they ever remaster Two Against Nature, I hope they include this version of this song - both are great
Steely Dan guards their copyright big time. I got a strike for filming part of a concert. All I used was little blurs.
I guess, it's a hunt to find that at all. I have the Midnite Cruiser cut digitally.
And if it's some money they want, I would certainly buy such a CD if they sold it.
song evolved.
11 Tracks of Whack
😁
Personally-not trying to convince anybody here-I wish Walter had taken over the lead vocals for TAO and EMG … Fagan’s voice had become quite thin and reedy by the mid 90s. In the 70s it really was one of the most beautifully twisted sounds in music, but for anything made after 2000, I know I’d rather listen to Becker’s gruff, no-nonsense interpretations.
Circus Money is worth a listen, for anybody else so inclined. And Eleven Whacks, too.
Walter agreed to the final version
I'm a massive fan of Walter's solo work but this song is definitely more suited to Don's voice.
Fill that need, lower lower Whacker
Fantastic! Did Krantz a whole tour with The Dan?
Krantz is the best!
Why does every live version of this song have a better solo than the record?
Walter did the solo on the record, Wayne did the live version, that may be why.
@@danielmccann8325 I don't even dislike the solo on the record but the live versions always end up having more interesting licks.
I can live with it, I'm pretty sure that track was Walter's baby
@@USALeonHeart I would add that Walter guitar sound is super clean on the record, on this one, Wayne distorted sound is one that has not been on a SD record since the Royal Scam. Gives this song a rock edge Plus as you write, excellent licks from Wayne.
'bogus haircut'...!
Why has the video of this disappeared? I had it snd lost it when i got my new phone
Video is back online now: ua-cam.com/video/RW2mGFKQWlg/v-deo.htmlm6s.
@@DrNanook Gone again )-:
@@mclff6926 It's here: ua-cam.com/video/kF7lCvT_r4o/v-deo.html. Full show: ua-cam.com/video/tEc0W2xP-fE/v-deo.html. Don't know how long it's gonna last...
Hey is that David Bowie? If not should be.
doesn't sound like Fagan is singing lead vocal
KICK ASS. Yeah, I am fully versed in the 2000 Two Against Nature recording. It's fantasta-taticus, but this??? SHEEEEEEEEIT! LOL.
Walter kinda sounds like Zappa
I thought Walter was thr bassist?
In the early band he played mostly bass while in the last band he played mostly rhythmic guitar. Him and Fagen were mostly writers/composers, they always toured with a lead guitarist and a second usually-lead keyboard player.
This is interesting. I prefer the Fagen vocals and the revised lyrics and the cleaner, more pristine version, although the horn lines here are more energetic being a live version.
shoutout Johnny Urethra
Good Evening,
Can someone please help me here?
Why is everyone talking about Walter's vocals?,... Donald is singing lead,... unless there is some other aspect that people are honing in on.
Thank you.
It's clearly Walter singing lead. :-) See here for the video: ua-cam.com/video/y0zJs937AQk/v-deo.html (Dan Belcher's channel).
The band sounds better, not so sure of the slightly out of tune vocal.