Right. Although this is not based on true events,.it reflects the mental anguish those Germans had suffered and still suffering up to this day, knowing the unthinkable evil they did in the past. Some of their children even changed their surnames. Others underwent sterilization so that their family line would end from them.
@@nemospence2724 Hitlers remain living realitives have all agreed that they will never marry or have children so they will die out all because they are so ashamed of the actions of a realtive they had no control over
The way Vera hyperventilates, cries, and screams senselessly is so heartbreaking 😰 she’s an amazing actress. I love her so much in Bates Motel and The Conjuring films
Cheese Nugget She really captured the unfathomable agony, misery, terror, horror, and total devastation of suddenly knowing a mother has lost her child - especially under such tragic circumstances. 😰
The Greek Pianist I was in tears when i heard that scream, that cry... It broke my heart and to imagine having a husband as a Gestapo is absolutely petrifying. I agree Vera is an absolutely amazing actress.
@@synckronix tbh ig id rather be shot than contribute to a genocide, or at least find a way to flee, also, wasnt the dad enjoying the nazi dictatorship?
Most soldiers did all those atrocities by their own will, many times in ww2 during jews executions soldiers who didnt had the guts for it just asked for a superior to change his job, most people did it bcs they didnt wanted to be saw as weak or be social jokes
@@synckronix nah lol he was high ranking SS, and the SS was mostly a volunteer only force. Concentration camp personnel were almost always volunteers and not conscripts
@@m3gad4n67 nah bro there’s no reason to defend the concentration camp guards cuz the SS was the SS, they committed atrocities all over Eastern Europe (search up the Dirlewanger brigade), sent out death squads (Einsatzgruppen) to find and murder Jews, and was the paramilitary organization of the Nazi Party. Basically they were the hand used by the Nazi party to create the most vile and deadly genocide in world history, they’re irredeemable and shouldn’t be defended.
+McRae4Ever Dresden firebombing. They could have negotiated a peace, but instead asked for "unconditional surrender". So they kept terror bombing cities and burning people alive
+McRae4Ever Not to mention the millions handed over to the Soviets who were promptly sent to the Gulags to be worked to death, tortured, or just shot in the head. Then there were the many rapes in Germany as the allies allowed Soviet troops to take Berlin. USA and Britain could have done so instead, but FDR insisted that Soviets be allowed to attack from the east which helped secure their power and helped divide Germany for decades to come. It was unnecessary as Germany was on its last legs already but was consistent with the Morganthau plan to permanently neutralize German power. FDR let America down for the sake of communism
PleaseExcuseMyDearAuntSemite I consider my self a American patriot, and don't hide the fact that we bombed not just German and Japanese factorys but their cities, but I agree with you, now I hate FDR more a shame he wasn't like his relative Theodore Roosevelt, Theodore born rich but lived with ordinary people, like the cowboys, helped make a man of the people, FDR born rich lived rich and didn't understand the ordinary man, but some how got elected until he died .
The director of this movie said that people who watched the movie felt more bad about Bruno dying rather than Shmuel although they were both innocent children
i can understand a bit since bruno himself got caught up in the mess unknowingly, or its either they re more sad since one more person died? Rest in peace for the jews souls that has been killed.
@@emilynesbitt3514 definitely because he is the main character. The book just ends with saying.... Nothing more was ever heard of Bruno after that. I was very upset with the ending, and felt bad that Bruno had no idea what a horrible person his dad was.
I honestly feel worse for his mom. Bruno didn’t know he was going to die. His mom did. Her screams kill me. And of course I feel awful for Shmuel & all of the other victims. They suffered and died for the crime of being Jewish. They were innocent. They didn’t deserve this. Never forget the past.
Just to imagine, you’re naked, packed in a room so crowded u can’t move, the lights go off then you suffocate. The horror and pain those people in the camps must have felt. Moved me to tears.
The most heartbreaking part is those kids not knowing what’s about to happen and then they hold hands together it’s like the most tragic thing to see in a movie
@Justin Masalon I know it's based off a real life tragedy, but the story itself isn't. It's historical fiction. I'm just speaking truth. They were all scheduled to die, but Bruno snuck in line not knowing the fate that awaited them. He wouldn't have died if he hadn’t snuck in.
@@RYMAN1321 I think what Deborah minter said went right over your head. Your statement only scratches the surface. Yes Bruno shouldn't have been there, of course he should not have been there, literally; but the deeper meaning of it is nor should Shmuel... nor should any one have been. This sort of thing is a tragedy for everyone, the family, the people in the camps, the viewers themselves, nobody wants to live in a world where this sort of injustice happens.
Brunos last words in the book were: "You're my best friend, Shmuel. My best friend for life." And for the horror to be brought upon them, Bruno never let go of Shmuels tiny hand.
@@johnny5aces765 well during that time they were closer then anything, so that made them best friends, even though they died they still died in each other's embrace.
@@johnny5aces765 they were actually friends for almost 2 years. In the beginning of the book Bruno was 9 and in the end he was 11. I would consider that a sort of long time.
Chloe Rorison...as heart breaking the ending is, Bruno´s holding Shumuel´s hand and and his words is so touching and beautiful. Reading this brought tears to my eyes.
Yeah, all seem like she doesn't really change character though, same gestures, smiles, laughs, cries, hysterics, etc., in everything she's in. I like her but just sayin'.
Vera Farmiga should have won an award for this. Watching her slowly become more and more despondent once she realized exactly what was happening at the camps and realizing what her husband was capable of was an amazing performance. And when she realizes what has happened to her son, it's heartbreaking. I think she is seriously underrated as an actress.
Did the father win an award too? His character development was amazing. At the start it looked like he genuinely believed in what was said, then the party happened and his mother (Bruno’s Grandma) voices her opinions, which then he tells her to be careful. Then later when all the high ranking German officers meet to watch the film, he has some sort of skeptical look on his face, not to mention how is wife feels about the whole thing. Then of course, the very ending scene, where he sprints all the way to the chambers, with a sense of guilt and regret and tension.
@@HawksBeast Yes, I think the same. Everyone here praises the mother, but the actor cast as the father was equally wonderful. The way he shouted his son's name at the end has so much emotion. In general, it was a difficult role: on the one hand, he had to be hateful and cold, but on the other hand, he is still a husband and father who loves his family. In fact, he could have reported his wife to the authorities or just punched her in the face during an argument. I think his commitment to Nazism waned more and more over time, and at the end of the book it says that he voluntarily surrendered to the Allies. Anyway, it was very good acting.
the fact that this was true and have happened many times back then is what breaks my heart more, no one should EVER go thru this or even dare this happen again, my heart goes to all the people who have past away in those times, may they find peace.
I think there was a mix of Germans that had basically been brainwashed and desensitised to the point where they see the inmates as just objects to be processed... then there were the real nasty sadistic nutters that just enjoyed it. There was an interesting psychological documentary regarding propaganda, brain washing and group mentality regarding to how the Nazis managed to make people behave like they did. Jordan Peterson also made a point that we all like to think we would do the right thing, but when it comes to survival of you and your family the mind set begins to alter drastically.
I read the book before watching this scene and I was at first stunned and then started sobbing. This is absolutely heartbreaking and the actress who played his mother was amazing. You could feel her anguish. 💔😭
I think the most hurtful part about this is knowing as a mother you couldn’t save your son from the pain physically that he felt. Just knowing in your heart that he was screaming in pain and crying out for his mom makes it even worse I couldn’t even imagine that pain😢
@@wtrmIxn Nazis used loads of the most disturbing, sadistic, and cruel torture methods on Jews. This is the gas chamber where they would lock hundred naked Jews in sealed chambers and introduce asphyxiant and poisonous gases
They died together holding hands. Such an incredibly brutal, sad ending. The horrified expression on the mother's face as reality hit and her screams of agony and loss were terrible. The father's expression of disbelief and horror. Shattering. The Holocaust. Never forget. Never forgive. Never again. ✡🕇😭
dtrix10kc Now now. Never forget yes. Never again yes. But there is great power in forgiveness. Not even concerning religion but we as humans can feel strong emotions sometimes. To be able to let them go is indeed powerful.
His mother couldn't do anything because if she did, she'd be executed. The sister fell for the propaganda and had no clue about what was really going on.
We saw this at school and the whole class was speechless and most of us were crying. This was the saddest thing I’ve ever seen. The fact that those things were actually happening were sickening and heartbreaking. As I get older, it only gets more upsetting.
Morgan Cloutier We watched it in school, and some of us were crying but me I was sick to my stomach and thought the boy was going go live. But in the end he died.
The Nazi soldiers especially the SS did know what they were doing but were under orders from the higher ups in Hitlers circle like Heinrich Himmler so they carried out their orders to a T or else they could get punished it’s like Ralph says in the film “I took an oath”
The fact that both of them didn’t know what was going on and they just wanted to find his father thinking he was still out there is heartbreaking, once the gas room went silent then faded to end credits I was on the floor violently sobbing
Sabotage Gaming wth , you obviously have no emotions as I too cried so much, don’t watch this video if you aren’t going to be grateful for where you are right now
@@tanyakas4111 keep in mimd gretel was only twelve - her embracing nazi ideology was exactly what herr liszt and her father wanted for her. i can guarantee you if she didnt have a nazi soldier for a father she'd be more compassionate
My heart just breaks reading this. my father was a nazi supporter and during my childhood learned us to hate any people who were different then us he would tell us especially stores about the Jewish,Africans and immigrants he got in jail for beating a man almost to death he is still in jail now and I’m glad he is I now realize how disgusting my father is
What hit so hard was the entire movie was centred around these 2 beautiful boys and you almost believe Bruno is going to get that boy out of there. You never expect it to be the other way around. This scene will forever live in my brain… as it should. We won’t forget this happened or the souls lost. Innocent beautiful souls…
Ignorant.they have zero empathy,and I'd steer clear of anyone thinking this film was funny.plain ignorance.I hope you have sound,solid friendships in your life.choose with care.London🌷
When something this gruesome and horrible is shown you merely want to burst into tears but sometimes to cope with the sadness and emotions some laughs because they don't now how to handle it. Its psychology. But if they really thinks this is funny they need a slap in the face!
A lot of people thought it was going to be a good ending. But I’m glad it wasn’t. There was no happy ending to this in real life, and the fact that they made it very real makes everything more “real life.” This was truly a roller coaster of emotions...
That's why it's called a good ending: not because it's happy but because it took us on a emotional ride to give us a glance of what it might have been like in that moment.
Um, Schindler’s List took this topic and while the film WAS hard to watch at times for its graphic yet realistic depiction, it at least ended on an uplifting note showing the real life survivors that Schindler freed at his gravestone. This, I get the idea, especially the point that the father lost his own by the same method he helped use against countless other innocents, but still. As well as Bruno and Shmuel tragically being too young and naive to understand the horrible fate that awaited them. But I really don’t like downbeat endings that make you feel like shit when they’re over.
Yes I agree. That's why I enjoyed the Sum of all fears aswell. The bomb goes off. The mad dash to stop it fails, and the aftermath is ultimately more interesting as it is much closer to real life.
@InsuranceFrauder the only thing that was accurate about this movie was that jews were being murdered. the whole friendship simply couldn't have happened, simply because the majorty of jewish children were murdered upon arriving to the camp, within a few hours.
Gemma Joikhun well she’s not the only one who lost a child. Many mothers in that camp lost their children too. She’s not the only one that deserves sympathy.
Gretel was brainwashed and led by a crush into supporting the Third Reich. Yes, she's a little girl, but still one of them. Respect her a little less for that.
Um... lol? By my comment you should have been able to tell i'm happy the kid died because he would have turned into a nazi too... so how does that make me a nazi fascist? ( Fucking idiot.)
I didn’t feel bad for the dad at all in this scene. He got a taste of his own medicine. But Bruno, the other holocaust victims, and Bruno’s own mom I felt so horrible for. The mom’s crying felt so real and was devastating to watch and it made me cry.
@Basedeyecelwhat will it take for you to finally realize that hating other humans based on attributes they cant change is in fact : IMMORAL. but your username makes sense i guess , youre "based". congragulated in a masturbatory echochamber of sadism.
“And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.” John 9:2-3 ESV
As a kid watching this movie it kept slowly panning out and I was sure Bruno was going to come out or something else would happen to show that he wasn't dead. And then the screen faded to black and I was still hoping there'd be another scene and then my heart sank and I realized both those kids were truly dead.
I remember watching this in class back in high school and we were considered the unruly class at least by the teacher but when we watched this movie everyone was glued to the screen, this scene specifically I remember the deafening silence slowly followed by muffled crying from a few people including myself , man what a heartbreaking movie
bruno didnt know he'd die. he, in fact, was idiot, who didnt even realize its a dangerous place, where people disappear (if i were him, i'd have easily guessed that they get killed), so it happened by accident.
Did you even watch the movie? By you’re comment I’d think you didn’t because the mother actually cared about her son and his mother and sister didn’t even know that concentration camps where real or a thing
This movie made the horror of the Holocaust so much more real to me than it ever was reading about it in school. I cry every single time I watch this scene. I can’t wrap my head around the cruelty
We are a plague on this planet we drop one bomb kill Millions of innocent people. We've killed many species on this planet to the point of Extinction and are still doing it today... we are the cruelest of all species on this planet we kill for no reason. Other species kill for food and to protect their offspring.. we killed for nothing have no morals... 60 years old I don't go anywhere or do anything keep to myself. Carry weapons of self-defense... how sad it is I cannot even trust my fellow human being... Satan has truly taken over this world.. The Killing took place when Cain killed Abel. The Killing for profit goes back to the Roman times and even further back. The Nazis just carried on with it. Not only did the Nazis kill they stripped them of their dignity took all their possessions of value and sold it for profit down to the hair on their bodies. Turn them into slaves so they did not have to work themselves. I myself can't wait until I leave this world...
Bruno died having the correct thoughts on Jews he knew they were kind and at least he died doing something Brave by trying to help his friend, this makes me so emotional😭💔 R.I.P
Gabriela Mauricio no he knew no matter what you were or are you’re still a human being. Even the mother knew that and he told him !!!! But instead he didn’t listen .... ugh always the innocents pay the price instead of those of us who do wrong ....
@@_fox3410 not all humans are kind and not all are horrible either but what the Jews got was just horrible because I don't even understand Jews are humans too so why did the treat them this way
I've heard the screams of a mother who just lost her child. It's a haunting sound that will chill you to the core. It was 18 years ago and it still haunts me to this day.
@CemtecUk Its not funny wtf please consider that something really happened! It's not like laughing at all that's the most inhumane thing that ever happened
I feel like one of the hardest moments in this movie that felt like 100 bullets to my heart was when the soldier turned to the mom and said “they smell worse when their burned don’t they”
That line alone made me feel for the ones who suffered, when in reality they stink more than those who they think smells. I need a new souls 😭😭😭 my current one feels so heavy right now and i cant stop crying since i rewatched it.
The last scene of this movie, where Bruno and Shmuel holding hands, was so emotional to me that I have cried for all those who died inside of this horrible holocaust… I felt the pain from Bruno‘s mother, felt the pain of the victims… It breaks my heart into thousand of pieces.
What stayed with me was that the mother started screaming in anguish whereas the father had little reaction when he realised he effectively killed his son
I don't think it was little reaction. I think it was shock as he realized he had effectively killed his son. I don't think he could do anything but stand there.
I have never ever watched anything more painful than this. Rest in peace to each and every soul who perished in those chambers. You will not ever be forgotten.
We can't change all but we can change ourselves for sure, so start from yourself, and make sure you never hurt anyone, there will be at least two good people on this earth then 😁
He fact that the dad only cared when his son was dead really discussed me. And knowing this actually happend and nobody cared is hurtful. The dad should of looked for Bruno AND the other people in that room. He should feel that pain.
You know what’s sad how the sister thought that the dad “Was a good man and we should proud of him” she literally believed everything their tutor said Jews were bad
Well, there are many reasons why she does. She's been eating that propaganda since she was a kid, it's kinda not her fault, but at the same time it's hard to not point fingers at her.
@@dagu1801 Yeah. I personally think, as someone who has had a father who grew up in a dictatorship (Francoist Spain), that it's not entirely the fault of people like this. They were spoonfed hatred and ignorance since birth (and the pro-fascist media my father in particular still consumes also does), and cognitive dissonance is a very serious issue. I've tried to talk to him openly and understanding(ly?), but some people are just too far gone and probably left well alone.
Well it’s not like she had any other choice. She was taught that jews were bad her whole life. I can’t bring myself to blame her (as she did nothing wrong, she was born in the wrong family)
When Vera Farmiga cried and screamed out for her child, i had literal chills throughout my body!🥶 she played this role so well and every one she plays she is amazing!💔 heartbreaking movie
The really disgusting thing is that Hitler hated the camps too. He never visited them. He just saw them as something necessary to further his plan. It's truly sick
Kaylyn Boyd what she meant was that jewish israelis are doing some horrible stuff to palestinians and that is true, not to the extent nazis did but after what your people went through you’d think you wouldn’t want to do it to someone else. And what china is doing to uyghur muslims right now in this moment, google it, i get it white people suck or whatever but right now they definitely aren’t the perpetrators.
The plot alone was enough to drive me to tears, but what had me sobbing was the mother's screaming. She was screaming in complete agony over her lost son, something that hit my chest so deep. I honestly felt myself change after this movie. Just a few hours ago, one of my classmates were making jokes about Hitler. I could practically feel the steam radiating off my body.
The filmmakers were manipulating your emotions. Some people react differently to that. And there is such thing as gallows humour. I'll ask you to consider for a moment that horrible things have taken place throughout human history. It is very difficult to demonstrate sympathy when time and place are so distant. Also the suspension of disbelief. While you might have been lost in the story, your peers saw this as a production with actors and sets. In a video game I can shoot an innocent person, kick a cat and drive my car on the sidewalk with no regard for the pedestrians. Because it isn't real. They aren't real people. Only a representation of people. If we are to have a serious talk about real people then it's much different. Of course the suffering and premature death of gypsies, gays and the Jewish people in Nazi concentration camps was absolutely horrible. With no benefit to anyone. Oh wait. Was your compassion only for the innocent boy of the Nazi officer and the Jewish prisoners? Were you unaware of the other people in the camps including gypsies and gays? Yes, during the Second World War a British scientist Alan Turing pioneered modern computers and artificial intelligence to break German codes and helped end the war. For his trouble he lived in obscurity because he couldn't speak publicly of his work during the war. Possibly the scientist that contributed the most to the war effort for the allies. Later he faced prison time or forced chemical castration for sodomy. Yeah, you can save the free world but you better not be gay! Can't have any of that when you're "The Good Guys".
Yeah. Too bad it's just fiction. The youngest surviving SS officers are in their 90s and still don't think there was anything wrong with what they did. For one to feel any remorse is so rare.
@@anjbarker5015 I know some of these events have happened in the past, but _this_ in particular is a well executed movie with amazing acting that takes you on an emotional roller coaster. You think for a sec these events are actually happening in front of your eyes.
The fact that this is happening in China right now with millions of Muslims, and no one is talking about it...and we said we would NEVER let this happen again.
@@mackavelly x I myself am 100% Chinese and was adopted and taken to Hawaii. I myself am thoroughly disgusted by my country and what they are doing right now. I don’t want them to die, I don’t hate them, I just want them to learn a lesson. Also being Chinese is a little hard right now because of COVID-19 but we are trying to pull past that and try to smile during these horrible times.
@@m3_mac I’m also adopted from China and COVID-19 and these horrible things that happens in China makes me so embarrassed of my origin... Everyday I hear people in my school yelling bad about Chinese people and I understand why since they only see it from that perspective... But we all have to understand that China is such a big country with a lot of people and just because their government and these people sucks it doesn’t mean all Chinese people should be blamed for it... We hate it as much as you do and I know that most people in China still fights for human rights and a better government.
I get a bit of comfort in knowing that Shmuel didn't have to die alone, scared and confused. He had Bruno by his side until the end. Let's not forget the real children that didn't have this comfort though
This is heartbreaking because you can't take a step back and say it was just a movie. This actually happened. Not the certain situation with Bruno and Shmuel, but to millions of others.
I’m so glad there was music covering up this whole entire shot. Can you imagine if they didn’t and you could just hear the screams and cries for help? Maybe Bruno shouting for his parents or sister? Devastating
in movie you hear them banging and shouting for help. then it gets softer and softer till that eerie quiet and the music starts playing as it zooms out
Vera's cry is absolutely agonizing. It shocked me right to my core. I had to step out of my class when we watched it at school, it was so heartbreaking to hear. And the most heartbreaking fact about it is how it actually happened.
On the wall of the concentration camp someone wrote this with his nail " if there is a god , he will have to beg for my forgiveness " I really felt it after watching this movie .
Its soooooooooooo sad :'( In class we starred watching it only when the fathers in his office we are reading the book as well we only got to about chapter 5-6
The acting was flawless in this movie. The kids were well trained, a great yet underrated performance by David Thewlis as well, and Vera is just amazing
This is the movie that will psychologically damage you if you watch it in middle school. It will absolutely ruin your day and make you rethink damn near everything you've done in your life, because as you watch this movie, you think to yourself, "this actually happened, and it wasn't even a century ago."
yea first time I saw Vera, and first time an actress hit me liked that, I was litterally shocked in the final by her acting, seems too real, horrific..
When I had watched this movie at 7, I told my dad “that was a bad cliffhanger, all they did was have a shower” I only learnt what really happened years later
Very poetic, Bruno's death caused by the very wickedness atrocity his family brought upon those poor souls who Bruno literally thought he could've been friends with.
![НЕМЕЦКИЙ ДЕЗЕРТИР нашел офицерский мундир и устроил настоящую бойню [краткий пересказ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GJS-hG2lly4/mqdefault.jpg)
He now feels the pain that he brought on to millions of parents.
This ending is pure poetry.
Right. Although this is not based on true events,.it reflects the mental anguish those Germans had suffered and still suffering up to this day, knowing the unthinkable evil they did in the past. Some of their children even changed their surnames. Others underwent sterilization so that their family line would end from them.
For real 😪 also out of the blue moon, but do u play book beach? Are Fabio 123 from mini rejects 2?
@@nemospence2724 Hitlers remain living realitives have all agreed that they will never marry or have children so they will die out all because they are so ashamed of the actions of a realtive they had no control over
@@nemospence2724 oh dang
omg you just helped me answer the last question on my assignment for this movie, THANK YOU
The way Vera hyperventilates, cries, and screams senselessly is so heartbreaking 😰 she’s an amazing actress. I love her so much in Bates Motel and The Conjuring films
The Greek Pianist her cries are the saddest part 💔
Cheese Nugget She really captured the unfathomable agony, misery, terror, horror, and total devastation of suddenly knowing a mother has lost her child - especially under such tragic circumstances. 😰
She is amazing actress
The Greek Pianist I was in tears when i heard that scream, that cry... It broke my heart and to imagine having a husband as a Gestapo is absolutely petrifying. I agree Vera is an absolutely amazing actress.
And the nun. And Annabelle. N her sister or niece or whatever taissa is good too
What's also sad is that even if he would've arrived on time, he would've just took his son away and let the others die.
Right so now he knows what it feels like to lose someone very important
I don’t think men like that truly love their own children.
EXACTLY
This is so sad
Who is at school doing this
I think the father was given the greatest possible punishment, but the child was not to blame.
@@synckronix tbh ig id rather be shot than contribute to a genocide, or at least find a way to flee, also, wasnt the dad enjoying the nazi dictatorship?
Most soldiers did all those atrocities by their own will, many times in ww2 during jews executions soldiers who didnt had the guts for it just asked for a superior to change his job, most people did it bcs they didnt wanted to be saw as weak or be social jokes
@@synckronix nah lol he was high ranking SS, and the SS was mostly a volunteer only force. Concentration camp personnel were almost always volunteers and not conscripts
@@Jrexhepiii in there eyes, it was probably safer to volunteer at a camp than be thrown on the front lines
@@m3gad4n67 nah bro there’s no reason to defend the concentration camp guards cuz the SS was the SS, they committed atrocities all over Eastern Europe (search up the Dirlewanger brigade), sent out death squads (Einsatzgruppen) to find and murder Jews, and was the paramilitary organization of the Nazi Party. Basically they were the hand used by the Nazi party to create the most vile and deadly genocide in world history, they’re irredeemable and shouldn’t be defended.
The fact that they did this to innocent children, women, and men actually makes me sick to my stomach.
+McRae4Ever Dresden firebombing. They could have negotiated a peace, but instead asked for "unconditional surrender". So they kept terror bombing cities and burning people alive
+McRae4Ever Not to mention the millions handed over to the Soviets who were promptly sent to the Gulags to be worked to death, tortured, or just shot in the head. Then there were the many rapes in Germany as the allies allowed Soviet troops to take Berlin. USA and Britain could have done so instead, but FDR insisted that Soviets be allowed to attack from the east which helped secure their power and helped divide Germany for decades to come. It was unnecessary as Germany was on its last legs already but was consistent with the Morganthau plan to permanently neutralize German power. FDR let America down for the sake of communism
PleaseExcuseMyDearAuntSemite I consider my self a American patriot, and don't hide the fact that we bombed not just German and Japanese factorys but their cities, but I agree with you, now I hate FDR more a shame he wasn't like his relative Theodore Roosevelt, Theodore born rich but lived with ordinary people, like the cowboys, helped make a man of the people, FDR born rich lived rich and didn't understand the ordinary man, but some how got elected until he died .
ikr
Jullie huh?
The director of this movie said that people who watched the movie felt more bad about Bruno dying rather than Shmuel although they were both innocent children
i can understand a bit since bruno himself got caught up in the mess unknowingly, or its either they re more sad since one more person died?
Rest in peace for the jews souls that has been killed.
It’s because it was unexpected
@@emilynesbitt3514 definitely because he is the main character. The book just ends with saying.... Nothing more was ever heard of Bruno after that. I was very upset with the ending, and felt bad that Bruno had no idea what a horrible person his dad was.
He was the main character so we connected to him more...... Plus it was super out of the blue
I honestly feel worse for his mom. Bruno didn’t know he was going to die. His mom did. Her screams kill me. And of course I feel awful for Shmuel & all of the other victims. They suffered and died for the crime of being Jewish. They were innocent. They didn’t deserve this. Never forget the past.
"Bruno wasn't supposed to die in there!"
False. NONE of them were supposed to die in there
Corection:ethically they weren’t ment to die but history / angry man with a silly mustash said differently
@@Outdoorrobin551 His mustache is quite good if you compare it to others like him
@@krieger8825 no shit
Dude who are you arguing against😂 your preaching to the choir
Wrong. His father was supposed to die
Just to imagine, you’re naked, packed in a room so crowded u can’t move, the lights go off then you suffocate. The horror and pain those people in the camps must have felt. Moved me to tears.
If I had been his wife, after Bruno died I would have immediately left him with my daughter instead of living with a conspirator to mass murder
I will go to mars lol
That’s what happened to my ancestors
@@AlejandraNavrockaI'm sorry
Did they burry them alive?
The most heartbreaking part is those kids not knowing what’s about to happen and then they hold hands together it’s like the most tragic thing to see in a movie
Add to the fact that Bruno shouldn’t have even been there :(
Wrong place at the wrong time.
@@RYMAN1321 I think that was the point of the film. None of the children should have been there.
@Justin Masalon I know it's based off a real life tragedy, but the story itself isn't. It's historical fiction.
I'm just speaking truth. They were all scheduled to die, but Bruno snuck in line not knowing the fate that awaited them. He wouldn't have died if he hadn’t snuck in.
@@RYMAN1321 I think what Deborah minter said went right over your head. Your statement only scratches the surface. Yes Bruno shouldn't have been there, of course he should not have been there, literally; but the deeper meaning of it is nor should Shmuel... nor should any one have been. This sort of thing is a tragedy for everyone, the family, the people in the camps, the viewers themselves, nobody wants to live in a world where this sort of injustice happens.
It's so sad bc all they thought was that they were going to have a shower it's truly heartbreaking
Brunos last words in the book were:
"You're my best friend, Shmuel. My best friend for life."
And for the horror to be brought upon them, Bruno never let go of Shmuels tiny hand.
Well they weren't friends for long apparently
@@johnny5aces765 well during that time they were closer then anything, so that made them best friends, even though they died they still died in each other's embrace.
@@johnny5aces765 they were actually friends for almost 2 years. In the beginning of the book Bruno was 9 and in the end he was 11. I would consider that a sort of long time.
Chloe Rorison...as heart breaking the ending is, Bruno´s holding Shumuel´s hand and and his words is so touching and beautiful. Reading this brought tears to my eyes.
Honestly, nobody will understand this book, unless they know history properly. Thats why most people in the comments find it a joke or pure fiction.
I still don’t know how Vera still doesn’t have an Oscar, like... she’s fucking brilliant at every role she has done! Smh.
"Like"?
She is..
Agree! Absolutely agree!
Sooooo true
Yeah, all seem like she doesn't really change character though, same gestures, smiles, laughs, cries, hysterics, etc., in everything she's in. I like her but just sayin'.
100 percent agree
Vera Farmiga should have won an award for this. Watching her slowly become more and more despondent once she realized exactly what was happening at the camps and realizing what her husband was capable of was an amazing performance. And when she realizes what has happened to her son, it's heartbreaking. I think she is seriously underrated as an actress.
She is truly talented at being incredibly sad and incredibly scared. She’s criminally underrated.
She did win an award for this..
She won a British Independent Film award and a CinEuphoria award :)
Did the father win an award too? His character development was amazing.
At the start it looked like he genuinely believed in what was said, then the party happened and his mother (Bruno’s Grandma) voices her opinions, which then he tells her to be careful.
Then later when all the high ranking German officers meet to watch the film, he has some sort of skeptical look on his face, not to mention how is wife feels about the whole thing.
Then of course, the very ending scene, where he sprints all the way to the chambers, with a sense of guilt and regret and tension.
@@HawksBeast Yes, I think the same. Everyone here praises the mother, but the actor cast as the father was equally wonderful. The way he shouted his son's name at the end has so much emotion. In general, it was a difficult role: on the one hand, he had to be hateful and cold, but on the other hand, he is still a husband and father who loves his family. In fact, he could have reported his wife to the authorities or just punched her in the face during an argument. I think his commitment to Nazism waned more and more over time, and at the end of the book it says that he voluntarily surrendered to the Allies. Anyway, it was very good acting.
It horrifies me that there are people alive who still don't care, about this or any other tragedy.
Alisha Rickman Or don’t believe it even happened. That I don’t understand.
Like slavery, USA treatment of immigrants...
Idgaf
@@essencekk boi
essencekk illegal immigrants
How he only cry’s when he knows his son is there. How many sons daughters and families did they kill and not even batter an eyelid 😔😔
the fact that this was true and have happened many times back then is what breaks my heart more, no one should EVER go thru this or even dare this happen again, my heart goes to all the people who have past away in those times, may they find peace.
You mean she
It is the power of dehumanizing someone/ some group of people. Horrible
I think there was a mix of Germans that had basically been brainwashed and desensitised to the point where they see the inmates as just objects to be processed... then there were the real nasty sadistic nutters that just enjoyed it. There was an interesting psychological documentary regarding propaganda, brain washing and group mentality regarding to how the Nazis managed to make people behave like they did. Jordan Peterson also made a point that we all like to think we would do the right thing, but when it comes to survival of you and your family the mind set begins to alter drastically.
Well yeah. People tend to only care about things that affect THEM.
The way they both held hands completely broke me down. This movie made me she'd tears like I've never done before.
Same here. They didn't know what was about to happen, only that it was bad 😭.
I read the book before watching this scene and I was at first stunned and then started sobbing. This is absolutely heartbreaking and the actress who played his mother was amazing. You could feel her anguish. 💔😭
@@ginahormann9768 Her names Vera Farmiga. You might at least know her from The Conjuring, Bates Motel and Orphan. She's amazing.
Deepti G I actually don’t watch horror films, so I wouldn’t know her.
Hey did they die at end i haven't watched the movie yet???
I think the most hurtful part about this is knowing as a mother you couldn’t save your son from the pain physically that he felt. Just knowing in your heart that he was screaming in pain and crying out for his mom makes it even worse I couldn’t even imagine that pain😢
Yeah that's the saddest part
@@nikemaraje5 what did they do them? Ik it was probably smt bad but I’m curious abt what happened to them
@@wtrmIxn the soldiers shut all of them in a gas chamber room and then released fatal poisonous/toxic gas.
@@wtrmIxn
They got all poisoned and died
@@wtrmIxn Nazis used loads of the most disturbing, sadistic, and cruel torture methods on Jews. This is the gas chamber where they would lock hundred naked Jews in sealed chambers and introduce asphyxiant and poisonous gases
They died together holding hands. Such an incredibly brutal, sad ending. The horrified expression on the mother's face as reality hit and her screams of agony and loss were terrible. The father's expression of disbelief and horror. Shattering.
The Holocaust.
Never forget.
Never forgive.
Never again. ✡🕇😭
dtrix10kc Amen. but we can forgive. these lives weren't in vain.
dtrix10kc Now now. Never forget yes. Never again yes. But there is great power in forgiveness. Not even concerning religion but we as humans can feel strong emotions sometimes. To be able to let them go is indeed powerful.
CocoEspada Amen
pretty funny ngl
Shmigidy Shmoul how is this funny?
Do I feel bad for Bruno's dad? No.
His mom? Yes
Bruno and Shmuel? Absolutely
His sister too
@@anushkadesai7966 Not a lot since she was pretty much accepting the Nazi teachings and doctrines. Bruno's mom at least questioned things.
@@TheFacelessStoryMaker Plus her reaction when she found out what all that smoke was.
His mother couldn't do anything because if she did, she'd be executed. The sister fell for the propaganda and had no clue about what was really going on.
@@TheFacelessStoryMaker Not everyone knew what was really happening inside the camps.
We saw this at school and the whole class was speechless and most of us were crying. This was the saddest thing I’ve ever seen. The fact that those things were actually happening were sickening and heartbreaking. As I get older, it only gets more upsetting.
Morgan Cloutier We watched it in school, and some of us were crying but me I was sick to my stomach and thought the boy was going go live. But in the end he died.
Morgan Cloutier me too
Morgan Cloutier when my class watched it, some dumbass shouted “Hitler needs to pay the gas bill!” And everyone started laughing... I was pissed
My brother got the book but he didnt watch the movie . I read it.
I didn't cry, but it definitely left a scar on me and everyone else, my tougher friends were tearing up!
The fact that the father had to have his own son killed to see it was so wrong is truly heartbreaking 😭
Truly a great movie. Top 5 comedies of all time!
These Nazi generals didn't see it that way. He didn't have the realisation.
The Nazi soldiers especially the SS did know what they were doing but were under orders from the higher ups in Hitlers circle like Heinrich Himmler so they carried out their orders to a T or else they could get punished it’s like Ralph says in the film “I took an oath”
And that’s if (a huge IF) he saw it as wrong then
@@bigtomtube532blud it’s not a comedy
The fact that both of them didn’t know what was going on and they just wanted to find his father thinking he was still out there is heartbreaking, once the gas room went silent then faded to end credits I was on the floor violently sobbing
Yılmaz Temiroğlu they got gassed to death
@Yılmaz Temiroğlu poisonous gas
Sabotage Gaming what’s so weird about it? this is a sad movie and most people cry from it. especially since it took place of real events
Daneca /Layla i thought they were burned..?
Sabotage Gaming wth , you obviously have no emotions as I too cried so much, don’t watch this video if you aren’t going to be grateful for where you are right now
His mother just knew. She knew without a single sign. She could feel it. My heart aches for Bruno and Shmuel.
And for Bruno's mother and sister. His mother knew what was going on, but it is clear she was NOT comfortable with it at all.
@@altareggo dnt feel bad for e sister she was accepting all this bs
A mother’s love is like no other.
@@tanyakas4111 keep in mimd gretel was only twelve - her embracing nazi ideology was exactly what herr liszt and her father wanted for her. i can guarantee you if she didnt have a nazi soldier for a father she'd be more compassionate
My heart just breaks reading this. my father was a nazi supporter and during my childhood learned us to hate any people who were different then us he would tell us especially stores about the Jewish,Africans and immigrants he got in jail for beating a man almost to death he is still in jail now and I’m glad he is I now realize how disgusting my father is
Vera’s acting was sooo good, especially in her last scene👏🏻👏🏻she is so talented
right?? she's my favorite. she deserves so much more recognition. I think she may be the most underrated actor ever )':
@@baharmonyy I know right
Oh yes she is!😍
Yes she is so amazing I love her
Yes, i was searching for a comment like this
What hit so hard was the entire movie was centred around these 2 beautiful boys and you almost believe Bruno is going to get that boy out of there. You never expect it to be the other way around. This scene will forever live in my brain… as it should. We won’t forget this happened or the souls lost. Innocent beautiful souls…
people at my school laughed at this scene. absolutely disgusting. this never should even be a joke.
Ignorant.they have zero empathy,and I'd steer clear of anyone thinking this film was funny.plain ignorance.I hope you have sound,solid friendships in your life.choose with care.London🌷
THAT DISGUSTS ME
When something this gruesome and horrible is shown you merely want to burst into tears but sometimes to cope with the sadness and emotions some laughs because they don't now how to handle it. Its psychology. But if they really thinks this is funny they need a slap in the face!
MYLIFEISPAIN ! How tf is that funny!!!!!?? You’re fucked up dude!!!!! 😡😡😡😡😡
Mylifispain!!! You need to go to effing therapy and figure out another way to cope with "bad stuff" than to laugh!!!!
"Don't worry it's just a shower" a man who knew what was happening, but didn't want to scare the young boys.
Wait who said that
@@caralouise1117 aaahhh sorry I think it was in a different version... there’s some versions with only music, and others have words...
others said it was to hide from the rain :(
@@carraley yea 😞
@@sophiejaycolt4374 no, a guy said that a little before this chamber scene. This video just doesn’t show him saying it
A lot of people thought it was going to be a good ending. But I’m glad it wasn’t. There was no happy ending to this in real life, and the fact that they made it very real makes everything more “real life.” This was truly a roller coaster of emotions...
That's why it's called a good ending: not because it's happy but because it took us on a emotional ride to give us a glance of what it might have been like in that moment.
@@girl1213 deep. but this ending wasn't sad? Only sad was Bruno dying and his dad's reaction
man fuck u...I see where ur goin but fuck u... 😔
Um,
Schindler’s List took this topic and while the film WAS hard to watch at times for its graphic yet realistic depiction, it at least ended on an uplifting note showing the real life survivors that Schindler freed at his gravestone.
This, I get the idea, especially the point that the father lost his own by the same method he helped use against countless other innocents, but still. As well as Bruno and Shmuel tragically being too young and naive to understand the horrible fate that awaited them.
But I really don’t like downbeat endings that make you feel like shit when they’re over.
Yes I agree. That's why I enjoyed the Sum of all fears aswell. The bomb goes off. The mad dash to stop it fails, and the aftermath is ultimately more interesting as it is much closer to real life.
This hurts because you realize this isn't fiction
It literally is though. There are dozens of other stories that are REAL. I don’t get why they use this one in school.
@@andrewsunk9880 maybe because this is the lowest age rating idk, some holocaust movies have disturbing scenes in them
@@andrewsunk9880the story is fiction but everything else is terribly accurate to what children and other people would have gone through
@InsuranceFrauder the only thing that was accurate about this movie was that jews were being murdered. the whole friendship simply couldn't have happened, simply because the majorty of jewish children were murdered upon arriving to the camp, within a few hours.
This story is fiction. Because no kid could survive when they were brung to Auschwitz. That means the friendship of those two kids could not happen.
The pain of mother when losing their children is really heart breaking, to see her scream and cry like that actually break my heart
Gemma Joikhun well she’s not the only one who lost a child. Many mothers in that camp lost their children too. She’s not the only one that deserves sympathy.
Watch Sophie's choice
Yeah 💔😭
One part that broke me in some way also is the fact the father was so cruel because he got influenced by some evil ideology.
@@yumiko0017 I agree, but the mother shold get no sympathy for even tolerating these camps
Bruno and his mum where the only ones I respected
And the grandmother. She was a nice character
Of course. How could I forget Schmuel? And that poor old Jewish doctor who took care of Bruno. (I forgot his name. Help me out?)
What about the little girl who was with the mother in this scene
Gretel was brainwashed and led by a crush into supporting the Third Reich. Yes, she's a little girl, but still one of them. Respect her a little less for that.
@@ruthcaperchione4103 ohh I see, I havent watched the movie in so long i forgot lol
Imagine that, standing by the system, supporting the system that got your own son killed
Good riddance. That could would have turned out to be a nazi too so fuck it.
alex loyal you nazi facist scumbag!
Um... lol? By my comment you should have been able to tell i'm happy the kid died because he would have turned into a nazi too... so how does that make me a nazi fascist? ( Fucking idiot.)
alex loyal no he wouldn't
alex loyal and sorry
I didn’t feel bad for the dad at all in this scene. He got a taste of his own medicine. But Bruno, the other holocaust victims, and Bruno’s own mom I felt so horrible for. The mom’s crying felt so real and was devastating to watch and it made me cry.
@prettyBoyIncelnuh uh
@prettyBoyIncelwe ? 🤨📸
@Basedeyecelwhat will it take for you to finally realize that hating other humans based on attributes they cant change is in fact : IMMORAL.
but your username makes sense i guess , youre "based". congragulated in a masturbatory echochamber of sadism.
@BasedeyecelWE!!!!?!!??!!?
@Basedeyecelfym we? 😟
"Sons will pay for the sins of their fathers"
Jesus paid for his father's
@@Heart2HeartBooks Jesus didn’t pay for Gods sin he paid for the sins of the world. For you and me!!! 😁
@@anastasiavendredi9272 Amen
“And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.”
John 9:2-3 ESV
@Oddishion Laos God isn't real
The end, where they zoom out, fucks me up so hard. The slow lingering frame just really emphasizes what has occurred.
Nessie ! What happens to them??? I'm confused. I know something bad happens but I just don't know what.
Random Nerd they got gassesd
As a kid watching this movie it kept slowly panning out and I was sure Bruno was going to come out or something else would happen to show that he wasn't dead. And then the screen faded to black and I was still hoping there'd be another scene and then my heart sank and I realized both those kids were truly dead.
@@KR-lp8fr thats not nessacary you fucked up person like how tf can u even say that when these kids , woman were during the holocaust?
That was the worst 😞
probably one of the saddest movie endings of all time. left me depressed for days
Meme Star check out buried ending
I relate
Meme Star and you're a meme star too
no Braveheart was the saddest
not only with jews, tho... polish and others, too
I remember watching this in class back in high school and we were considered the unruly class at least by the teacher but when we watched this movie everyone was glued to the screen, this scene specifically I remember the deafening silence slowly followed by muffled crying from a few people including myself , man what a heartbreaking movie
Anyone else feel like their soul has been ripped out of their body
Batlover Sings Yes
Yess! Im over hear bawling like the mom in the movie. I feel sick
Yes so very much to hard tho
Yup
Not me
One of the prisoners said in the changing rooms “It’s just a shower” He knew they were going to die but didn’t want to scare the children
Reminds me of Life is Perfect
@Veteran PG3D I think you mean 'Life is Beautiful'
@@elder-woodsilverstein7716 Oops yeah, I always used to name the movie correctly, sorry
@@veteranpg3d156 Its all right. That was a great movie.
he didnt know
Poor kids had to pay the ultimate price in order for the father to feel what millions of people felt. 😢
A story of innocence in the world of ignorace.
A story of a small peace in a world of cruelty.
Dr. Barber very true
John Smith very much true
thats what is written in the cover of the book
Dr. Barber true
Bruno is really a dedicated friend. He was able to be with Shmuel even he died with him. Now that is what I call true friendship.
Not sure Bruno knew he was going to be put in the gas chamber.
The sad thing is Bruno will have a proper grave while Shmuel won't
@@avahowell4666 Once one is dead,a grave matters nothing.
@@perks9895 No U
bruno didnt know he'd die. he, in fact, was idiot, who didnt even realize its a dangerous place, where people disappear (if i were him, i'd have easily guessed that they get killed), so it happened by accident.
They only cared when they were effected by it.
Thank you
Exactly. That's the point.
Did you even watch the movie? By you’re comment I’d think you didn’t because the mother actually cared about her son and his mother and sister didn’t even know that concentration camps where real or a thing
Savage Takis I know she cared about her son, I wasn’t trying to say differently. And no I have never seen this movie😂
@@wyattfields6965 Then why do you comment if you didn't see it, kid?
This movie made the horror of the Holocaust so much more real to me than it ever was reading about it in school. I cry every single time I watch this scene. I can’t wrap my head around the cruelty
Uhum
i actively searched this scene knowing it would make me sad
Catacal Same
Какой ужас!Какая несправедливость!!НЕВИННЫЙ РЕБЁНОК ПОГИБ...
Some things are worth grieving for.
@@ГалинаЗахарова-о5м Galina, they were *both* innocent children.
@@a_diamond напишите по-русски.
I'm more scared of humans than any other specie in the planet
We are a plague on this planet we drop one bomb kill Millions of innocent people. We've killed many species on this planet to the point of Extinction and are still doing it today... we are the cruelest of all species on this planet we kill for no reason. Other species kill for food and to protect their offspring.. we killed for nothing have no morals... 60 years old I don't go anywhere or do anything keep to myself. Carry weapons of self-defense... how sad it is I cannot even trust my fellow human being... Satan has truly taken over this world.. The Killing took place when Cain killed Abel. The Killing for profit goes back to the Roman times and even further back. The Nazis just carried on with it. Not only did the Nazis kill they stripped them of their dignity took all their possessions of value and sold it for profit down to the hair on their bodies. Turn them into slaves so they did not have to work themselves. I myself can't wait until I leave this world...
Willy D. Well ain’t you just a ball of sunshine
Im scared of people after this people are capable of hurting people.
Humans are barbaric!!!!
Right you are Alien .... Remove Humanity and this planet would be Beautiful !
Bruno died having the correct thoughts on Jews he knew they were kind and at least he died doing something Brave by trying to help his friend, this makes me so emotional😭💔 R.I.P
Gabriela Mauricio no he knew no matter what you were or are you’re still a human being. Even the mother knew that and he told him !!!! But instead he didn’t listen .... ugh always the innocents pay the price instead of those of us who do wrong ....
Im dead . this movie killed me . so sad
uh not all Jews are kind
@@_fox3410 not all humans are kind and not all are horrible either but what the Jews got was just horrible because I don't even understand Jews are humans too so why did the treat them this way
@@rohitjammu6047 flawed ideology nothing more
I've heard the screams of a mother who just lost her child. It's a haunting sound that will chill you to the core. It was 18 years ago and it still haunts me to this day.
I understand. I screamed like this when I found out my son had died.
This isn't just a movie...
This happened
CemtecUk 😂😂
CemtecUk it’s real bruv🤭🤭 that actually happened.
It’s historical fiction
Stephanie & Rachel yes
@CemtecUk Its not funny wtf please consider that something really happened! It's not like laughing at all that's the most inhumane thing that ever happened
The loudest silence in cinema history. *Chills*
Avengers Infinity War/Endgame: hold these beers
@@tmac731 i can see that. But no
@@germanmata5946 yes
@@tmac731 lol
@@tmac731 Did you just compare Infinity War and the overrated fanservice that was Endgame to a movie about the Holocaust?
I feel like one of the hardest moments in this movie that felt like 100 bullets to my heart was when the soldier turned to the mom and said “they smell worse when their burned don’t they”
McKenna 4Lyfe yeah and then she was like “?” Cus he said they and you would usually think of people when you say they
Yes!!!
That line alone made me feel for the ones who suffered, when in reality they stink more than those who they think smells.
I need a new souls 😭😭😭 my current one feels so heavy right now and i cant stop crying since i rewatched it.
@@tangierh.4581 no
The last scene of this movie, where Bruno and Shmuel holding hands, was so emotional to me that I have cried for all those who died inside of this horrible holocaust… I felt the pain from Bruno‘s mother, felt the pain of the victims… It breaks my heart into thousand of pieces.
What stayed with me was that the mother started screaming in anguish whereas the father had little reaction when he realised he effectively killed his son
I think his silent, stoned face was screaming with emotion and realization. Reality hit him in that moment and his silence says it all.
I don't think it was little reaction. I think it was shock as he realized he had effectively killed his son. I don't think he could do anything but stand there.
I think he was in shock.
I think he was in complete and utter shock because he knew it was his fault his son was dead
He was a werewolf!
The first time I saw this movie I cryed when I read the book I cryed. This was the saddest thing I have ever seen.
j sj Had you red the book: The Boy on the Hill? I think it's much better...
Yeah it's sad in both of them
Same
*cried
Pussy
The way the camera slowly, painfully zooms out to show all the clothes on the floor/hanging. Haunting.
It's the clothes that haunted the soldiers and survivors for the rest of their lives. They always remembered the clothes.
I hate to be the one and ask but what was the stuff they poured down the hole
@@HelloThere-yt3pv gasses to kill them
@@caralouise1117 thanks
I have never ever watched anything more painful than this. Rest in peace to each and every soul who perished in those chambers. You will not ever be forgotten.
Watch "Life is Beautiful". A much better movie which actually puts victims' narrative first.
_But at what cost?_
_At what cost do people have to learn?_
Your Dry Blazer all of it......it takes so much for us to see the mistakes we make and do to learn
We can't change all but we can change ourselves for sure, so start from yourself, and make sure you never hurt anyone, there will be at least two good people on this earth then 😁
madison knight\ Decayed knight. Are you actually stupid
Is this a quote? If so, from where?
Never enough unfortunately.
He fact that the dad only cared when his son was dead really discussed me. And knowing this actually happend and nobody cared is hurtful. The dad should of looked for Bruno AND the other people in that room. He should feel that pain.
Of course it hits different when your family member dies rather than random strangers, but I see your point
@@karinkorenkova6190 i agree
@@karinkorenkova6190 agree
*disgusted
You're really right.
It’s so sad how this happened to so many innocent people who did nothing wrong...
Emma Vanilla 500,000 died of famine and disease, truly a shame.
This movie was inhuman, my poor heart hurts so much 😢😭💔
It’s still happening today. Nothing has changed.
all because the nazi ideology was that some races didnt deserve to exist. Fucked up stuff
@@random_meta i Hope they're in hell
the most tear-jerking, depressing, agonizing, blood-curdled, traumatized, devastated scream in all of cinematic history
This is heartbreaking “it’s just a shower “ bless there little hearts the sad thing is this happens to so many people in real life
@Craig Adams seriously? u have to correct there grammar? on such a sad video? on such a respectful comment?
so disrespectful.
@@AidenLiquid ah yes, correcting grammar = disrespect. Fix your grammar, and your self steem while you're at it.
@@AidenLiquid movie , not real life.
@@realdragao6367 yeah but, these events actually happened. although bruno and shmuel weren’t real.
@@realdragao6367 but it is, the holocaust was a real life event and many children were slaughtered during it.
I heard the cry of a mother who found her son dead to suicide. It's a sound you never want to hear EVER. It still haunts me to this day.
how did it sound? wailing? how horrible... :(
My son died by suicide. I screamed.
@@deekang6244 that sounds really casual
@@puma6947 bruh
@@puma6947 it sucks having people you know die by suicide.
My friend attempted to hang himself.
Barely survived because of his sweatshirt
You know what’s sad how the sister thought that the dad “Was a good man and we should proud of him” she literally believed everything their tutor said Jews were bad
Well, there are many reasons why she does. She's been eating that propaganda since she was a kid, it's kinda not her fault, but at the same time it's hard to not point fingers at her.
@@dagu1801 Yeah. I personally think, as someone who has had a father who grew up in a dictatorship (Francoist Spain), that it's not entirely the fault of people like this. They were spoonfed hatred and ignorance since birth (and the pro-fascist media my father in particular still consumes also does), and cognitive dissonance is a very serious issue. I've tried to talk to him openly and understanding(ly?), but some people are just too far gone and probably left well alone.
@@caramel7050 And there is no real way to make them believe anything else at this point. It's scary.
Well it’s not like she had any other choice. She was taught that jews were bad her whole life. I can’t bring myself to blame her (as she did nothing wrong, she was born in the wrong family)
Lil LeBron 23 it goes to show how brain washed Hitler actually made people
When Vera Farmiga cried and screamed out for her child, i had literal chills throughout my body!🥶 she played this role so well and every one she plays she is amazing!💔 heartbreaking movie
Makes me cry everytime
and the most terryfying thing is that a living human being was able to do this to other of their kind just because of one guy's ideology.
The ideology is way older than Hitler. Antisemitism, Racism and the idea of euthanasia go back to the early middle ages.
Tralala_Beez the perpetrators are still white Europeans. Nothing has changed.
The really disgusting thing is that Hitler hated the camps too. He never visited them. He just saw them as something necessary to further his plan. It's truly sick
Tralala_Beez, what are examples of that lol
Kaylyn Boyd what she meant was that jewish israelis are doing some horrible stuff to palestinians and that is true, not to the extent nazis did but after what your people went through you’d think you wouldn’t want to do it to someone else. And what china is doing to uyghur muslims right now in this moment, google it, i get it white people suck or whatever but right now they definitely aren’t the perpetrators.
The plot alone was enough to drive me to tears, but what had me sobbing was the mother's screaming. She was screaming in complete agony over her lost son, something that hit my chest so deep. I honestly felt myself change after this movie. Just a few hours ago, one of my classmates were making jokes about Hitler. I could practically feel the steam radiating off my body.
What were the jokes about? If they were insulting him then that's fine
He should be arrested
Jug Head 21
For saying things that you don't approve of? Well, how Nazi of you.
Play wolfenstein the new collosus. Good way to let your anger out on nazis
The filmmakers were manipulating your emotions. Some people react differently to that. And there is such thing as gallows humour. I'll ask you to consider for a moment that horrible things have taken place throughout human history. It is very difficult to demonstrate sympathy when time and place are so distant. Also the suspension of disbelief. While you might have been lost in the story, your peers saw this as a production with actors and sets. In a video game I can shoot an innocent person, kick a cat and drive my car on the sidewalk with no regard for the pedestrians. Because it isn't real. They aren't real people. Only a representation of people. If we are to have a serious talk about real people then it's much different. Of course the suffering and premature death of gypsies, gays and the Jewish people in Nazi concentration camps was absolutely horrible. With no benefit to anyone. Oh wait. Was your compassion only for the innocent boy of the Nazi officer and the Jewish prisoners? Were you unaware of the other people in the camps including gypsies and gays? Yes, during the Second World War a British scientist Alan Turing pioneered modern computers and artificial intelligence to break German codes and helped end the war. For his trouble he lived in obscurity because he couldn't speak publicly of his work during the war. Possibly the scientist that contributed the most to the war effort for the allies. Later he faced prison time or forced chemical castration for sodomy. Yeah, you can save the free world but you better not be gay! Can't have any of that when you're "The Good Guys".
I remember reading the book and thinking "the kid is sure to escape and they'll run away together".... never expected this.
I thought it was either going to be an actual shower or the father was going to command them to not gas everyone
Same, it was very painful when I realized it wasn't ending like that, and that was the first time I cried reading a book.
Yes man in the book the ending had been so short
Me too but instead i got my heart ripped into pieces
The way Bruno grabs and holds Shmuel''s hand before the end, made me tear up so much, but they both perished holding hands, wow.
Bruno’s death was a lesson for his dad.. now he knows the feeling.
Yeah. Doesn’t feel good now doesn’t huh.
Yeah. Too bad it's just fiction. The youngest surviving SS officers are in their 90s and still don't think there was anything wrong with what they did. For one to feel any remorse is so rare.
He will condolence himself by accusing Jews, that's Nazi for You
@@Elly3981 Wow i wonder if they get harassed daily for such
@@ICruz-vq1ze no they don't even get any punishment and many people say we should leave them alone...
Sometimes you forget this is a movie, since the acting is so well done
ღ Dumpling ღ but technically it wasn't a just a movie
@@anjbarker5015 I know some of these events have happened in the past, but _this_ in particular is a well executed movie with amazing acting that takes you on an emotional roller coaster. You think for a sec these events are actually happening in front of your eyes.
fox world they had it worst. This movies shows heaven compared to what happened.
@@shiashia8463 heaven?! you have to be joking.
Yh i know💔💔
I hope with all my heart that people realize that it has only been a few decades since this has happened. DECADES! What has come of our world! BRUH!
It’s been like 70 years
savvy briceño now Zionist treating Palestines almost in the same manner
as of may 8 2020 it has been 75 years since the holocaust
That's an under statement but it's still closer than most people feel
I can only pray that it will never happen again. It begun with hatred and ugly words.
The fact it took a german boy accidentally dying for them to see the horrors they caused millions of parents who were still inside those gates
The fact that this is happening in China right now with millions of Muslims, and no one is talking about it...and we said we would NEVER let this happen again.
Yep. I hate China, simply for that.
@@mackavelly x I myself am 100% Chinese and was adopted and taken to Hawaii. I myself am thoroughly disgusted by my country and what they are doing right now. I don’t want them to die, I don’t hate them, I just want them to learn a lesson. Also being Chinese is a little hard right now because of COVID-19 but we are trying to pull past that and try to smile during these horrible times.
@@m3_mac i don't hate CHINESE (i mean it depends) but fuck China. I cant smile knowing what horrid shit is going on
You copied another comment
@@m3_mac I’m also adopted from China and COVID-19 and these horrible things that happens in China makes me so embarrassed of my origin... Everyday I hear people in my school yelling bad about Chinese people and I understand why since they only see it from that perspective... But we all have to understand that China is such a big country with a lot of people and just because their government and these people sucks it doesn’t mean all Chinese people should be blamed for it... We hate it as much as you do and I know that most people in China still fights for human rights and a better government.
When the mother cried, a shiver went down my entire body. It so real..
I'm literally shaking like mad it's so sad that this actually happened 😭 were so lucky to be alive now
Vera’s wailing at the end of this movie is absolutely haunting. Always makes me cry. Fantastic acting.
She’s so goooood
It wasn't acting
Yeah I lost it seeing that. That part felt so real and like she really lost her own kid.
@@ibrahimzyiadh7826then why would it be recorded?
@cheeseyfingers9046 I meant it as a metaphor
This scene absolutely broke me.
None of them deserved that.
This is one of the few movies that has actually made me cry
Can we just make sure nothing like this ever happens again?
Its happening to muslims in china as we speak
Very similar things like this are still happening. Not (exclusively) on the base of race/religion but still due to politics.
_ EdieMcCreadie _ we can try...
@gamewizard I I nominate you the first up. Evil bastard
@gamewizard I Karma will get you someday. You just wait
I am just disgusted that this happened. The horrible psychos that did this should have never been aloud on earth.
@Oops I tripped allowed*
QuasiHornet3516 yes lol
There still with us buddy. Must remember, they held public office...
@Truth Pretty sure the mounds of human shoes in the abandoned camps say otherwise.
@@EmptyMan000 this guy is a pathetic troll dont listen to him
This is so sad. All Bruno and Shmuel wanted to do was find his father. The fact that they are just kids makes it sadder 😢
You say that but none of them did anything wrong
yes, and Shmuel´s dad must have been dead too
@@hollandspotje7812 she is right
The even sadder thing is this happened to millions of people
I hate to sound heartless but I mean- they did- ( oh god I feel so bad now)
I get a bit of comfort in knowing that Shmuel didn't have to die alone, scared and confused. He had Bruno by his side until the end.
Let's not forget the real children that didn't have this comfort though
1:44 Can you imagine being the guy who has to close the door on his own people, knowing that they are about to die in minutes?
Not ’his’ people. Just innocent people.
@Andrea Zan Zanardi l'infame your based
I literally thought the same thing
@@misslizard1991 No one cares about your fan fiction
@@recoveringincel2933 you have issues.
This is heartbreaking because you can't take a step back and say it was just a movie. This actually happened. Not the certain situation with Bruno and Shmuel, but to millions of others.
it's sad to think that even if Bruno moved or not, it would be the last time he and Shmuel would see each other anyway
The way the older man looked over at them knowing the kids had no idea what was going on
Seeing a mother's grief like that is beyond sad
Yea and this actress did it well. That was a true representation of actual feelings, she must be a method actress
The moms acting is so good but so sad
I’m so glad there was music covering up this whole entire shot. Can you imagine if they didn’t and you could just hear the screams and cries for help? Maybe Bruno shouting for his parents or sister? Devastating
@Bubble Tea 123 I can’t even begin to imagine. The silence when they showed the empty room really got to me
in the movie there is actually no music in the background they just pasted a soundtrack in the back
in movie you hear them banging and shouting for help. then it gets softer and softer till that eerie quiet and the music starts playing as it zooms out
Bruno didn’t know what was happening so I don’t think he’d scream out for his parents
Wouldve been nice to hear
Ive never seen someone able to so perfectly capture the pain and agony of losing someone like Vera Farmiga did here
Vera's cry is absolutely agonizing. It shocked me right to my core. I had to step out of my class when we watched it at school, it was so heartbreaking to hear. And the most heartbreaking fact about it is how it actually happened.
when the mom cried , i lost it
Calvin Older lel
angelys montanez
I was asleep in class when this scene happened so when the credits appeared I started clapping by accident
angelys montanez elsa that's her name I was in a same reaction as her
Sam omg i laughed way to hard at your comment
Same
On the wall of the concentration camp someone wrote this with his nail " if there is a god , he will have to beg for my forgiveness "
I really felt it after watching this movie .
Why? Evil isn't God's doing
@@Thatlovelygirl3 I agree but he was the one was supposed to protect them
@tom lewis God does not mess with free will, wich is what our humanity has, the free will to do good or the free will to do evil.
@tom lewis i recommend you watch the movie The Shack, it will explain better to you how God works or does not in our lives
@@Thatlovelygirl3 Also if God has a "plan for us all", that means we dont have this "free will" youre talking about.
The moment he got into the camp my heart was beating so fast, especially when they told them to take their clothes off.
this scene hit me so deep :'(
fathima azeena well good thing he died teach the Germans a lesson
+Mr Kyle Kyle omg lol
Mr Kyle Kyle Your legit a scumbag piece of shit
Its soooooooooooo sad :'( In class we starred watching it only when the fathers in his office we are reading the book as well we only got to about chapter 5-6
fathima azeena that's what she said
The acting was flawless in this movie. The kids were well trained, a great yet underrated performance by David Thewlis as well, and Vera is just amazing
...atleast he died with his bestfriend😭💔.....
It broke my heart
My Friends Club Mine too.... 😢😢😢😢💔💔💔💔
Peep Trollers they're friendship never die sound familiar
Peep Trollers 😭
Schmul was never meant to be out there in the first place, and neither was Bruno, so they were extremely unlucky.
This is the movie that will psychologically damage you if you watch it in middle school. It will absolutely ruin your day and make you rethink damn near everything you've done in your life, because as you watch this movie, you think to yourself, "this actually happened, and it wasn't even a century ago."
this scene really killed me. “its just a shower”.
I know that guy trying to bring hope or trying to is just sad
@Miko Max It’s not in this video due to the audio player over it
They had no idea what awaited them :(
That’s why it’s so heartbreaking.
The mum's acting got me shaking 💔
Sophia Vera Farmiga was good. shes awesome as Norma Bates too in Bates Motel.
yea first time I saw Vera, and first time an actress hit me liked that, I was litterally shocked in the final by her acting, seems too real, horrific..
Sophia Same
HAPPY CUPCAKE yup.
Asanas M WHATTT THATS HER LIL SISTER
When I had watched this movie at 7, I told my dad “that was a bad cliffhanger, all they did was have a shower” I only learnt what really happened years later
Back when everything was so innocent minded
I showed this to my 8 year old sister and told her what it means no need to keep things like that from children they should know the truth
@@SimGirl00 8 years old? That poor child
@@Holyvixen and I took her to Auschwitz at 9. It’s allowed but not recommended to bring children .
@@SimGirl00 I believe people should be educated on this topic , but bringing a 9 year old child to a concentration camp is too much
Very poetic, Bruno's death caused by the very wickedness atrocity his family brought upon those poor souls who Bruno literally thought he could've been friends with.
It doesn't really hit me until the Mother starts screaming then boom I become a hideous mess