I have been making art for over 60 years. I have worked in this world as an artist and this was my living. Few things I have learned thru the years: Be careful if you claim a style or an idea. Someone has already done it. 1000's of people have already done it. We live a life being inspired and as artists we translate that into something we want to express. I like your channel because you create little lovely things that are in my wheel house. I relate to the colors and style. Over 50 years ago i filled journals with similar faces and flowers, text mixed media etc etc. To make a living as an artist it will involve you being inspired by others and they by you, thats the way it is. Be prolific and keep creating. If someone uses your photo image of a design you have done as a tag then thats a HUGE NO, but even on UA-cam i have watched talented scrapbookers, painters, journalists etc using this same form of creative delivery. I had a friend that was upset a few years ago that someone else did an old truck filled with pumpkins and she did it with flowers. I had to remind her a million trucks were done before she did it and head down, do art..keep creating, evolve and make art. You are a lovely sweet lady and I enjoy your channel btw :)
I love your comment. For an artist it's very grounding to hear. Artists can be egocentric and possessive of their ideas and work. Yet we are constantly gaining knowledge, inspiration etc all our lives, and as you say, it's been done before. Art evolves and revolves. 💌
Yes! Everything you said! Nothing is new and not to be insensitive but most mixed media art, esp girls & flowers all look the same! So its very hard to be “original”!
Ive already commented to another comment, but I wanted to add something here - you're right, it's hard to be original in art because even if you think you've invented an idea, there's no way of knowing if someone hasn't thought of it before you. And you'd be safer to assume they have, given the probability.... But I don't think that's what's important. To me, the meaningful difference is between *Originality* and *Authenticity* - make what is true to you, and comes from your heart and soul. It may be similar to other people's art, but its Authentic to you. Real art will have the spirit of authenticity to it. Styles of art are always shared, there wasn't only ONE cubist artist, nor should there be ONE art journaler. And when more people engage in a genre of art, it develops and grows, it benefits all of us artists....that's how art works. Directly copying someone's art and selling it/claiming it as your own, is obviously wrong. But you can't copyright a genre of art, hashtags or subject matter.
A book that may be of interest on this topic is Steal Like An Artist by Austin Kleon... here is a quote by T. S. Eliot from the introduction of said book: “Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal; bad poets deface what they take, and good poets make it into something better, or at least something different. The good poet welds his theft into a whole of feeling which is unique, utterly different from that from which it was torn.”
***After reading your wonderful conversations in the comments I’m just adding this too… That I completely agree - 'nothing new under the sun,’ or nothing is original, in that sense. So, it's not original but is it authentic? If it's not the ‘ideas’ feeding the inspiration to create from our hearts, but, instead, it is truly stolen if it's someone trying to copy directly and claim it as their own. Or, repeatedly copying every little thing another creator does. If that makes sense? Grey areas… Loving this conversation, thanks for comments!*
For a long time, I let the fear of getting negative comments stop me from starting my UA-cam channel. I’ve been very surprised at how few negative comments I’ve gotten and I don’t see those on other people’s channels much either. Largely the UA-cam community is supportive and encouraging and I’m very grateful for that. Thanks for sharing and educating people on these very important issues!! Lots of love, Tara Kate
I rarely respond to comments in any social media on any platforms. Sometimes you get trolls, rage baiters. I have social anxiety caused by past experiences with racism, horrible rude customers and chavs. About few weeks ago I was walking my sister's semi wild dog, this chav turned around and stared at us like we were freaks. Incidents like this plus pandemic turns me in shut in. I don't feel like going out because verbal abuse, funny stares.
According to an article by the Smithsonian all major artistic representational techniques had been developed 17,000 years ago. There are currently 7.9 Billion humans on the planet. Humanity is too old, there are too many of us, everything has been done before thousands of times and will be repeated thousands of times again, each time with the creator thinking that they were the first. As an artist myself, I do love your work and will continue to enjoy your work. For you to believe that anything you or I or anyone else creates is truly unique, new and fully yours is naive at best and egotistical at worst. Have some humility and be grateful that you are a working artist, making a living doing what you love. That in itself is the truest validation that you are a good artist.
The saying, "There's nothing new under the sun", feels very relevant here. Outside of blatant plagiarism or copying someone's work, it's hard to claim copyright over ideas or style. Sometimes the same idea comes to various people. One person runs with the idea whilst another takes their time getting there. Just as our fingerprints are unique to us, so will the creative interpretation of that idea. Unless, like you speak of, it's a blatant copying of someone's creative expression. Alphonso Dunn and the Inktober 'creator' had a disagreement about the similarities in books published by both men. Coincidence or plagiarism? Only the 'offending artist' will ever know. Protecting one's work matters but knowing whether or not one person is copying another is not always easy to discover.
That inktober thing was stupid. The page that Jake supposedly plagiarized was nothing new and there is crossover in all this stuff. I thought Alphonso was pretty childish about it.
@@themysteriousdomainmoviepalace I can understand your thoughts about it. Even though I won't comment on either party, what I learnt is to tread carefully when claiming 'ownership of art' and to be careful about 'calling people out'. I accepted one version of events until I read about how old some of the techniques were. These things/feuds can get unnecessarily ugly and intense. That said, I still think people should protect their art. Ideas are a different kettle of fish altogether.
@@TT-fn1xb If you've been to art school at all its obvious that those were classical techniques. Of course we need to protect our original artwork. Its difficult online but one artist never posts anything without including her name in the link so its obvious who created it.
*@Tigs - I couldn't pin your comment directly because it was in response to another comment but you summed it up so well... so I hope you don't mind me pinning it here. Tigs 16 hours ago Ive already commented to another comment, but I wanted to add something here - you're right, it's hard to be original in art because even if you think you've invented an idea, there's no way of knowing if someone hasn't thought of it before you. And you'd be safer to assume they have, given the probability.... But I don't think that's what's important. To me, the meaningful difference is between Originality and Authenticity - make what is true to you, and comes from your heart and soul. It may be similar to other people's art, but its Authentic to you. Real art will have the spirit of authenticity to it. Styles of art are always shared, there wasn't only ONE cubist artist, nor should there be ONE art journaler. And when more people engage in a genre of art, it develops and grows, it benefits all of us artists....that's how art works. Directly copying someone's art and selling it/claiming it as your own, is obviously wrong. But you can't copyright a genre of art, hashtags or subject matter.*
I love your authenticity. I've been on tiktok for about a year now, and have been considering UA-cam. Your vlog style has inspired me, and I've been considering doing a vlog style as well, rather than the top-down painting videos I had been considering. The next step is for me to find my own voice and own style of vloging. So much has already been done, we'll never be 100% unique, but there is also a very important line of taking that inspiration and making it your own, vs copying completely. As I dive into the world of sharing content I pull from multiple source of inspiration and find ways to put my own creative spins and add in my own unique ideas as they come to me. When you are just following one artist I think that's where it becomes too easy to cross a line. Truly a wonderful video and an important topic! I appreciate your insight 💙
UA-cam is rife with copying. I’ve started changing my channel from embroidery to art and crafts now. But it’s one of those things, even I’ve done it. We follow suite like a tik tok trend. Obviously you wouldn’t want to copy every single thing someone does but we all take bits from others to help mould ourselves. I can understand copying a painting would be a no no but to take inspiration from it and making your own interpretation is ok. The trouble is that you’ve obviously done something right to achieve what you’ve achieved and I think people will try and take elements to help themselves achieve the same. But a sad story is when someone calls their business something so simple(a word) and they’re told they can’t use it because that particular word is copyrighted! Love your channel by the way 💖
One artist had her landscape paintings stolen, the perp took only cropped portions of her paintings and sold them as prints, pillows, mugs - the works. The guts some people have is astounding. Another artist had her painting stolen by some big shot in China and it was reproduces en masse. They made millions off of her work. There is/was a group lawsuit happening with over 20 artist because they do this all the time apparently but the artist could not afford the legal fees. She got nothing, she sold the original once and someone else bought a house with her work. 🤯
It’s a shame that the lawyers didn’t offer her a percentage fee at least. I have heard about Chinese theft of artwork before, but I suppose it could be any country where unscrupulous people would steal from artists.
Wendy, I love how gently you speak about such a difficult subject. You work so hard on your craft and should be able to protect it. Thank you for sharing 🙏🏻💜
You looked so pretty today, Wendy. I adore that you couldnt help but end on a positive note and that you didnt want someone on the verge of shining their light to be put off. That's why I love your light :)
Lots of varied thoughts and ideas on this one. Everyone is different and is inspired by so many different images, thoughts and flashes of insight often by viewing a piece of art. We can't really claim an idea is all our own because other things have influenced us and caused that idea to form. Being yourself means whatever you create will have that essence so it will always look different except if you blantantly copy a piece from someones art. That I feel, is the only real issue. Copying exactly someones art and passing it off as yours and profiting from it is not cool. Being inspired by another to create a new piece of art is adding to this great huge pool of light and joy in the world! We can't stop that. We can't stop sharing our work out of fear of people imitating us. Do your thing, live your life and leave beautiful things out there for people to enjoy I say. Great thoughtful video, Wendy. It will get people talking! 🙏🥰
I surely am inspired by your channel, your positivity and ability to inspire me to look at life more creatively. I am not an art person in your medium, but I do so enjoy working with yarn and producing art in my creations. I love your gentle spirit, and in this world of such loud voices, you are such a welcome change. If it might be possible to love a person on social media, then that is how you make me feel-loved. Your channel is my favorite and I treasure the time you spend with us and all the work and thinking it must take to do this. Also, we share the same life philosophy and in this loud noisy world it is rare to find this. I think what I am trying to say is thank you for being you and sharing with us. We are truly blessed!
It's one thing to attempt to imitate or replicate something someone else does as experimentation , for your own experience, but too many people are doing this to fill their you tube content, and use it as "click bait" to attract others. I do see this as I view various channels. I'm glad you are talking about this.
I once had an Etsy silver jewellery shop and someone copied my shop name and style. I opened another Etsy shop. Again someone copied the name and even opened a physical shop with my shop name. I now create handmade artist teddies and someone has started using my shop name. It's depressing 😞
Well said Wendy. There is a wealth of difference between someone copying your art for the pleasure of personal learning and development - a compliment.... and someone 'stealing' your art and passing it off as their own in order to benefit from your originality and creativity - underhand infringement of copyright.
Thank you Wendy for covering a topic of some concern so beautifully and lovingly. It is really helpful to shed light on these aspects and as always you come from an authentic and generous place. Have a magical week ahead beautiful faery. Keep shining your light
Absolutely Bonnie, I completely agree. It only becomes relevant if someone copies every little thing another artist/creator does for a long period of time and that's when the grey areas become darker... if that makes sense.
@@theunexpectedgypsyIn Australia, once your idea has been made (on paper, canvas or in 3D) then you automatically own the copyright (for free) and anyone who steals it can be sued. So, never TELL anyone your ideas until they are set in stone (so to speak).
I used to wonder about how to find my own style. I read somewhere that it’s a great idea to keep a list of all the artists and creatives you admire and whose work you follow and then write down what it is you are drawn to about their work, eg I love the whimsy in your work, I love the way you layer and your use of colour. I can incorporate more whimsy into my own work then without it looking like your work. Another favourite artist has a clean clear way of using colour that I deeply admire. Maybe I could combine whimsy with a clean clear focus on colour but in my own way of working? Maybe that would be awful, but by experimenting I will eventually find something that is my own. Anyway, I find that by identifying exactly what it is that I like about a piece of art work I’m drawn to (pardon the pun), it helps me understand what I like, and helps me identify my own style.
I could never be on social media like y'all. Once, I had my work blatantly stolen and had to go to small claims court. It was awful. I only won because of the way I wrapped the jewelry I used to make. I had a certain thumb print in my wire work. People wise, I went through a very heart breaking situation with a supposed friend, in 2020. It broke my heart and soul to the point I was depressed for almost a year over it. It was truly tragic. I am an empath and I tend to share too much (this message for instance LOL), I could never put myself out there for EVERYONE to see and know. You are brave and speak from your heart.
The Sunday Stylist (not an artist but another UA-camr) had a similar problem. She tried the gentle nudging approach but it didn't work. In the end she did a video calling the two UA-camrs out. They had blatantly copied one of her videos using the same format and the same words. One was literally word for word. Sometimes we have to call people out publicly. It is a shame. Great video Wendy and love your message of being our authentic self. ❤
Thank you so much for this chat! As a new visual artist coming from the performing arts, I've really struggled to find that line of inspiration and knowing how much is appropriate to borrow in an idea.
Thank you Wendy for taking the time to touch in on a sensitive subject. I can speak from my own experience...and that is that as an artist I have always given credit or said "inspired by" if I post something, even if it doesn't even look anything like the other artist's work! I also write it on the back of the piece of art. I think it helps grow a community when you share with others that somebody inspired you... it's just a kind way to acknowledge someone else!😍 It is said that when someone copies you it is the ultimate compliment, however plagiarism is another thing and I think your suggested approach, if it happens to you, is the best advise! Have a lovely weekend! I enjoyed my cuppa with you. ☕ Always a pleasure to meet up with you each Friday morning dear lady! Stay warm!🌻🌞
You spoke about these sensitive topics in such a kind and gentle way. At the same time, you clearly showed where you draw the line. I think they copy you because they admire you, and they'd like to have some of your success - which is never going to work because you are inimitable and irreplaceable.
Three years ago I was at an exhibition by my favourite artist who I am acquainted with. I had just arrived and had taken my mobile phone out of my handbag to switch it off. Her partner rushed over and knocked it out of my hand, spilling wine over me and into my handbag. He shouted at me accusing me of taking photos to copy her work! Everybody was looking at me and a few made comments to suggest I was taking photos when I shouldn’t be. I felt so embarrassed and sad. The artist came over and apologised sincerely for her partner’s behaviour, she was obviously embarrassed by it. This did give me food for thought about copyright issues though. You raised some very good points Wendy.
I'm an avid art you tube channel follower and to be honest, many of the channels pretty much have the same formats and use the same sentences and styles of presentation. I've also noticed quite a lot of creatives using bought stencils as a basis for their paintings too. It's pretty difficult to reinvent the wheel when the market is soo very flooded with similar things. How many ways can one paint a flower? Interesting vlog, thank you.
Yes, Wendy uses stencils, if somebody uses the same stencils, and blending, but not seen Wendy's work? Are they copying? I don't think they are? I'm a little confused about this video. Some of it I agree with, and some of it concerns me.
@@WendyW123 I like UA-cam videos where artists show ‘how to’ do certain things. They want their viewers to do what they do. They share their knowledge. This seems a little mean and it makes me feel sad. Xxx
Yes I agree with you both, I have mixed feelings about this video. She did preface it by saying its a 'grey' area, but actually I think it's more a case of - some things are clearly wrong, and others are not. It's not grey, there are separate categories. Of course the example of someone using her artwork to make clothes labels, obviously that's wrong and a clear example of stealing artwork. If someone started selling prints of her artwork, that's obviously wrong. But what about a *style* of artwork/journaling/hashtags.....? I love Wendy's work and have followed her for a long time, but I was a bit surprised by the way she phrased this. It's not like she invented writing phrases next to fairies in a journal, I remember having books exactly like that when I was a kid, years ago... And I had how-to-craft books with that *exact* same typewriter font and directions on how to *stamp words next to collages* (of fairies...) Also, she said someone copied her flower-power project.....well, I know she didn't invent the phrase Flower Power, or the idea of painting flowers. Sure, she decided to concentrate on painting them at night, which is more unusual but definitely not original. But it's hard (if not impossible) to be completely original in art, because we are all inspired by what we've seen and experienced. I think as artists we have to accept people might start with the same raw materials and come to a similar conclusion..... In terms of copying hashtags, I thought the more people that use your hashtag, the better..? Isn't that how it works? If more people use the same hashtag, your art will be seen by more people - and the whole point of hashtags is to link you to posts of the same theme, it's basically an index for themes. I've watched a video where Wendy copied an Art Deco paining from a book, and that inspired her to try a new style, to get out of a rut, which flowed into her flower power series. This is copying, and developing into your own style. If other people are doing the same with her style of journaling, I don't really see how that's any different. Of course they should credit her if they've directly copied her work, and they shouldn't sell it without permission because that's against copyright - but you can copy what you want for your own personal artwork. Imagine if Picasso said: 'Right, nobody copy me, I'm the only one allowed to be a Cubist' And if Dali said: 'Nobody copy me, I'm the only one allowed to do Surrealsim' And Leonardo Da Vinci....and the first Cave-man to stamp his handprint on the wall of a cave....✋🏼✋🏼🎨🎨 We would have a whole lot less art in the world. Same with music, artists inspire eachother. Direct copying is stealing. Being inspired by a GENRE of art, or using similar materials, or subject matter.....to me, that's just art, we share those things.
@@tigs6639 of course, you are spot on with the clear divide Tigs. Blatant copying without credit is just definitely wrong. Also passing off someone else's work as your own, is just plain wrong too. I often go onto Pinterest to look for inspiration when I am having a block and end up seeing hundreds of similar pieces of work by different artists, but I think to myself that it must be pretty difficult to change what is essentially a vase of flowers into something new (hope that makes sense, hehe). I truly believe, like you, that authenticity is very rarely achieved in a world where almost everything has already been done in some form or fashion.
I’m always touched by your authenticity! You’re inspiring on so many levels. You’re a beautiful soul that heals so many of us caught in the “out there” hang ups. Being REAL is a medicine for this world. And YOU do that!!! I can definitely relate to infringement topic, one thing I have personally learned is that they may copy for a moment, but they don’t have the infinite access to where all those unique ideas from “ within “ come from! Oh there’s soo much more !!! Lol once we have the inner key, possibilities are endless. Biggest hugs of warmth from Hawaii! 🌺💛🤗💛🌺
I've just been amazed at the tsunami of ideas out in cyberspace. I really only started looking at youtube during lockdown. Everytime I think I'm onto something new and perhaps could make some pin money from it I UA-cam the idea and someone else is doing it. So it must be really hard trying to make a living from your art and seeing it possibly being ripped off. However, that being said from what I see in your niche that you and James are projecting an authenticity that rings true for many people. So many people are just so slick on youtube that you both are very refreshing to follow!
Thank you for the beautiful video. You have a wonderful way with words to get your point across. Just listening to you today makes me feel like you had to be a marvelous teacher. Love everything you create. Onward!!! 🙂
Miss Wendy, You are such a beautiful soul. I am such a follower of you, when I watch and listen to you,and have coffee together, the kindness of your soul shines. I’ll admit,I have tears at times and it’s all good,like today’s video on copyright worries. Some people have a hard time these days with right and wrong it seems to this old girl.My husband Matt Tucker works in pencil,painting and does Ice Sculptures.As an artist that issue has come up in the passed.Not easy. But we move forward and stay inspired everyday to create from our souls,that’s makes us Happy. Huggies to you. Stay strong everyday,we need each other.
The timing of this is really good. And I agree with many who have hit it bang on. We learn from one another so styles can be similar, even content. What I think key is intent. Is someone learning to draw? Learning color combinations? Learning the what and the how’s? Or are their intentions altogether nefarious in origin. I have not shared my artwork, yet, because of this very fear. But I think it’s getting time I just swim because I don’t want to sink…
Your channel is great and I've seen it grow so fast over the time you have been doing it. The lockdowns and such, though bad, were actually quite good for inspiring people to follow and create on their own. You are so sweet and genuine that I think you would make a fantastic sister. I've not spoken to my own for over 15yrs, bad blood there, but I do enjoy having a cuppa with you!🍀💕
I started watching your channel during lockdown here in the US when stumbling across your page while searching "art studio tour". You were and are a BIG inspiration to me starting my own channel last year. My only desire to copy was in how genuine and true to yourself and your art that you are and I wish to show that of myself in my own videos. I am inspired by you to look deep within myself and show people some of what I find in my search. I'm finding it takes a lot of bravery to do what you do and I want to thank you for sharing that and inspiring me to be brave and do the same. 🥰
Not being talented or brave enough to share on social media. I still enjoyed watching you tonight and was so impressed by your attitude. You are such a generous, caring and sweet lady. I’m really glad I found you a year ago. Love and hugs to you and James.😍😍xx
Been knitting along listening to a few of your videos this wintery Sunday, just got my glass paints, grabbed a jar and drew a little winter scene, thank you. Over 10 years since I've done anything creative (only just picked up my very basic knitting again this week as well.) Thank you again
I highly urge every artist to read a book by Elizabeth Gilbert called "Big Magic" about creativity it is very enlightening about creative process and about creatives ideas finding a place to come to fruition ❤️ Great video Wendy as usual 👏👏
THIS. Unfortunately, her explanation is often an unpopular opinion, but one I have fully embraced multiple times in life. There's really no sense holding onto something somebody else can do better. I make what I make when I can/have time, but love when others take it further.
I noticed people of the western world are very into " ME ". So they sign their work. They sell Their work. All about the ego. In India and places like Tibet . It is about the art not the artist. No one signs their name to the work because it is not about the person doing the work. I love that I dea and It has freed me as an artist. Some of my clients want me to sign a piece so for them I sign the back not to affect the art. As an artist for over 45 years I believe this is also the best way for the yogic way is also about letting go of names and identification or labels. There really is nothing more freeing and a little scary about Not signing your work.
Really enjoyed this topic, cannot believe a shop copied your art and put it on their tags!! Unreal!!! Art takes time, and finding your own voice and style also takes time!! Sending lots of love and light!! And of course lots of warm moments!!!❤❤❤
Well said and great topic to address. One important aspect is that artists who work in their craft everyday are trying to make a living. Selling their work contributes to their ability to make a living. Hard work, dedication, love, to do their own work, everyday.
Thanks for sharing Wendy and this is important. no body likes to be copied because it's like having your signature snatched from under your nose most artist would have enough self belief self esteem self worth ideas and inspiration of their own to explore and express while appreciating the works of other artists and not copying I'm sure. like you said its in the minority... I really appreciate our utube artist to help inspire and support I look forward to your videos and other artist on utube who do beautiful inspiring artwork and vlogs it literally makes my heart sing! Have a lovely weekend love and light to you and James 💜 PS. I do want to add that there maybe artist who also do art journaling and styles similar to yours without even knowing you. my style could be similar to someone else I have no idea and it's also very important for that to be taken into account and that no one would have ever copied but only had styles similar to one another there will be people who also love flowers and may have a style similar to yours and do flowers a little like yours so yes this is a tricky Wendy 💜
Thank you for this video. I appreciate it so much. I have been hesitant to show any of my new artwork across social media, after I saw one of my pieces on someone else's page several years ago. It is soooooo annoying to see something you created from your imagination stolen and claimed by another.
The only thing I think about copy writing and have often wondered about is so another person doesn't get me in trouble /accusing me falsely of copying them! Thats why I would do copy writing on my art, other then that they can copy all they want im really free and sharing and I encourage people to copy my handmade rugs and viking ladies in a row garden posts and teach others my really unique and beautiful technique that I invented of hand stitching art with wood and help them with learning what they like and getting their own style by trying out what they like through what I do, im so unique in my art I don't think anybody could do what I do/ im to way off unique, thanks for the discussion on this needed topic, as I don't have a single artist friend to talk to this about who understands this questioning. In the past famous artist that lived at the same time often knew each other and when one of the did a painting that they liked they would all go off and paint a painting inspired by them -they where always doing that and saying good artists copy great artist steal, so you do steal what you like but you you use it in your own style which takes authenticity to find!, love to you on your majestic art journey, your giving good advice here/love to you!
Saturday morning is my 're time's with Wendy and sometimes James. I've been watching your videos for over a year now and I so look forward to my Saturday mornings with you. I admire who you are as a person - your honesty, creativity,inspiration and positivity truly feed my soul. Although I 've never aspired to put myself out there I really appreciate and admire the fact that you have embraced the social media platforms and that you have made such a success of this. Thankyou for sharing some of the more negative aspects of using those platforms that you have experienced and for sharing ideas on how to deal with that. Keep doing what you do as you bring joy and inspiration to so many people. 🥰
I remember one of my tutors explaining this to the class. Thank you for your clarification. I am still finding my style although 3D and mixed media are my first love. I cannot draw,is that negative thought that always comes up because I compare all the time thank you for sharing that. Most of my days are in my daily care of 14 independent elderly as I run the house and listen to what is happening in their daily lives. Taking time for me the last 10 days I have enjoyed your videos, seeing how you take time for you. My go to is my morning pages and Julia Cameron's artist way books my audible go to everyday. Have a blessed week Wendy.
Thank you. Not a waffle at all!! Think you speak authentically and openly about these issues. Beautifully put..good use of your intuitive awareness and thinking on the issues. Well said xxx
You are such a unique artist and wonderful person. Don't let yourself be under that fear. No one can steal your uniqueness. I understand that maybe it costs a lot of energy to fight this fear 😟. But don't let it take your trust in yourself. Just let it flow away with time. You are so much more than artstealers could ever be 😉.
This is a great discussion on a really tricky area. I have no idea why anyone would want to copy someone else's ideas, aesthetic or identity as they'll always get found out? There's no definitive answer to any of this, I guess, other than keep on keeping on.
Such an appropriate topic for this New Moon in Scorpio... Courageous Truth looks very good on you Wendy! I do aspire to video document my artistic process and you inspire me toward that very much. I have yet to make public any of my art processes... I think a part of my hesitation is that I am aware that my personal creative process is still in discovery. It is quite a treat to be invited into yours and others creative processes via the web... If only to inspire ones own authentic expression. Why else create art than to expression ones unique truth!?
I've used it as educational purposes something I've learned from art school. The professors often took us to the art museum, which was connected to the school. Part of the assignment was to copy the masters to learn. Plus as artists we are inspired by others just as we inspire. But copying an exact image to claim as your own then no.
Well said. Image stealing happens far too often. Blanket sellers steal quilt images all the time. Recently it’s been decal companies. Scammers about. Stay the course. As an off side...love your knit wear. Beautiful and cozy!
I've lost count the number of times my work was stolen while I was a student. Always being told, "oh well you should take that as a compliment." WHAT?! That little note just justifying theft. I do appreciate my professors (MUCH later on) reminding me, ALWAYS ALWAYS show credit where credit is due. P.S.: I love your Art Studio chats. They are a great pick me up for when I'm feeling dealing with alot of imposter symptom.
I used to do photography non-professionally and my friend of 40 years decided that she was going to make items out of my photography without asking me. Phone covers, painting my photographs etc. She never once asked me if she could. I so understand where you’re coming from with this and I am so very sorry that you ever have to tolerate peoples negative remarks that they should definitely keep to themselves. It’s a different world out there and we should not have to adjust to people being mean and thoughtless💜
Awwwww, I love the way that you found a positive side of this by very gently encouraging people to find their own style. 🤗🌞 Thanks a ton for your commitment to positivity. ✌❤🕊️
Thank you for sharing this video. I recently came across someone who does pyrography on wood. Sometimes using art created by a different artist not just using the picture as a reference but tracing/transferring the image on to the wood not free hand. Only filling in the details free hand so to me the work is partly the pyrgraphers and partly the artists. I felt quite wound up discussing this an made at point that the artists name should always be mentioned. You've helped me clarify this as I thought I was being over sensitive. I love all your videos by the way.
"Trust that your life is enough. Trust that you are enough" A beautiful silence fills my whole being hearing this. For once, I trust. Thanks for sharing all this. Feels really good and loving
You are such an inspiration! I've followed you pretty much from the beginning of your UA-cam adventure and love everything you do! As an artist, this subject is so important to us and one of my biggest fears of putting my own self out there amidst just the pushing myself to do so. Enjoying my warm cup of coffee with you on this chilly morning. Thank you for keeping your light shining bright! PS when you quote poetry and your writings I find that extra inspiring to hear in my day!
I totally agree Wendy 💛☀️✨ I always think when someone copies there work will carry that energy.. they will never have the authentic truth behind their work! Inspiration is a wonderful thing, you personally inspired me within my UA-cam channel to be more authentic, I share videos on spirituality and seeing your videos and how you shine your light absolutely moved me to just be me more☀️💛✨ I appreciate you sharing your journey sending many blessings from Australia
Miss Wendy I adore you! And I hope you do more on this topic. And please maybe you & James could research some firms that specializes in this. The issue is not going away. Might as well educate & protect the "few gypsies that remain" Praying for you to be blessed with discernment on how to proceed.
Thank you for mentioning this ...so much happened a few years ago really has put things on hold however I switched back to doing my journals and hand drawing rather than my digital work cus I couldnt afford the stockphoto purchases any more and health got rough so selling kinda stuck cus I'm centered on healing on so much but I have found that some of the positives even if it's just a few comments the positive stuff helps alot so I just kinda have been on hiatus and working my journey to be more just for me there was so much that it was just overwhelming yet I do hope to have a local show when I can cus my canvas work kinda boomed during covid beginning and hopefully I can start something back cus this is my life and I been drawing and doing whether it was graphics or fine art for most of I have learned what to let bug me and what not to...for the most part you are correct it's our journey our way and so with that said have a great week and I know I'm not the only one that's dealt with that kinda of stuff
Glad you shared this. Thank you. I've been making some hard decisions regarding my own art studio and work going forward. I no longer engage in any form of social media. I also deleted the blog from my studio site and stopped using online stores & merchandising. If someone wants my work they must get it directly from me. "The Artist's Journey is about the Art, not the artist." - Steven Pressfield, book 'The Artist's Journey'
Sometimes we just have to keep on creating otherwise paralysis can kick in. I’m the master of overthinking so quietening my mind and being a little blinkered to things such as social media comments etc really helps! I haven’t been brave enough to embark on a UA-cam journey yet. Maybe next year 😊🦋✨
I wrote something I found profound but it went to the cloud I guess but I am trying it again. Remember your light and your art it is your universe given to you at your time and if some is forging your work it will not stop your light to keep growing. Yes it is upsetting but if it gets in your way to profit from your art wirk search for laws and find a lawyer to look over the issues... however keep doing your beautiful work you are doing because it had your own personality in it and we all know better and want to keep value your overall art wirk abd how can someone think they can be you as your bring your own soul into your stories your life your relationship and your Art keep believing that it will pass and keep doing what you doing... keep shining and helps us to see that we all can find ourselves in your struggles and successes. Keep your beautiful light shinning! Thank you!
Interesting topic, I’m currently working on finding my art style and it’s interesting to see it develop naturally. I will have to do research on copyrights in my state I live in California. I am not quite savvy with doing art prints right now so I plan on selling my originals for now until I figure out how to make prints.
Oh Wendy, so sorry someone did this to you, but grateful you found the mindful gentle path through it and shared that with us. It's so easy to react and lose to the negative. Re copyright: Someone copied one of my blogs (the whole site, not just a post) to a foreign-based site and I've hesitated to pursue it, bc I didn't know if it was worth all the work that might be involved, or how to go about it. Thanks to this post, I might actually look into it now. Thanks, Wendy - for finding the gentle path, and James - for getting upset. Bright blessings.
I agree with you. As a photographer and artist, I have been plagued by people printing off wedding photos etc, instead of purchasing from me the creator. I think…well I am thrilled to be inspired and to inspire others…however there is a line like you said that blatant plagiarism is just pure theft!
Such a misunderstood topic, your genuine self shines through as you share feelings and experiences! Through the years I was exposed to myths about this topic, such as: it’s ok if you only use three quarters of the design or if you reverse the image! But in fact none of them are true! I have held onto a photo I would love to draw, I searched for the photographer to get permission,with out luck! I hesitate because I feel even doing it for my own pleasure could lead to misuse! Blessed and safe days!
It's not against copyright to copy a photograph you like for your artwork *if it's only done for personal studies* You can paint DISNEY characters on your kids wall - but not to sell. You can copy the work of famous painters for your own studies and pleasure - it only breaks copyright if you're selling it/claiming it as your own 😌 If you wrote the lyrics to your favourite song in your diary, you haven't stolen them. If you published them and said they were your lyrics, then you have....
@@tigs6639 there is an artist making paintings from rolling stone magazine covers...not sure how he's getting away with this as he's using the original photograph as the 'base' for his 'painting'...and also the magazine masthead etc...like?
It’s such a tough topic and there is quite a fine line sometimes between being inspired by someone’s art and copying someone’s art or ideas. I have had my work copied a couple of times- the kicker was someone who wanted a piece of my art but didn’t agree with the price, so went to a friend who painted it for her for free. They tagged me in the post of the copied art work. It was all very confusing for me, because on the one hand, it was nice that they tagged me and that she wanted my art in the first place but it also felt really sad to have my art totally copied so that someone didn’t have to buy it from me. I let it go, but it did hurt to be honest!
I’ve only recently discovered you Wendy, and I love your essence, your style, your art is beautiful and you have a beautiful soul. I don’t know why, I can’t fully describe, some people have touched on it, but, this video makes me feel sad. 😔 I think you’re a beautiful person inside and out. Blessings to you. 🧚♂️❣️xxx
Wow Wendy. The problem of plagerism and stealing is worse than I thought. This strangely popped up on my news feed. 🙏🏻❤️xxx ua-cam.com/video/9J7SSJTUiOE/v-deo.html
I love this discussion! I am very mindful with having a very distinctive visual language, and I use themes that I can't find others using ... so when followers on IG, for example, suddenly start doing the same thing, then I just unfollow them and try to ignore it. I find that if that's not their natural art style, then they tend to move onto something else pretty quickly ...
I hope nobody says anything unkind to you. You are a lovely lady who brings warmth to many hearts. Thank you. I’ll add a little something. When I was about twelve years old, I entered a speech contest. I wrote a speech for the are of 'dramatic presentation,'. I remember I wrote, and revised, and wrote again. Then I practiced my speech in front of my teacher, my parents, and the mighty mirror. My character was a young woman coming from a communist company and arriving at Ellis Island. On the day of the contest after I performed before the judges my teacher and I were ecstatic expecting the first prize I evidently deserved. I was disqualified for plagiarism! We were stunned. My teacher fought for me but the judges refused to budge. Had young ladies arrived at Ellis Island before? Had I copied the idea? Does a child who reads three books a week have that knowledge in her memory bank? Did I hunt for the idea? The words? Did I plagiarize? The answer was no. I was crushed. I truly was. But when I grew older I realized that I had indeed won a first-in spades! That Wendy, was reverse plagiarism of the meanest kind.
I started painting during the first pandemic - I copied everything and everyone for learning when I started. But I never, never dreamt of passing these painting as coming from my own brain. Almost two years later I now understand what means to get inspired, if I see a drawing about a starred sky for instance I will put myself and paint my own starred sky, with my own colours and the styles I learned and I might specimens more. And then I see another techniques or style I like and I do copy it again to learn and experiment, but only copying feels like to be in a creative jail. At some point there is the physical need to let your mind go and get yourself there on the paper. But at the same time I will never forget all my teachers.
Great video as always Wendy, it even prompted a discussion between me and my partner. I’ve definitely been afraid to share some of my work through fear of copycats….I sometimes feel that the people who take a picture of my work at craft fairs and walk away are thinking of copying it. It doesn’t feel nice. On the other hand, the copying of ideas and styles is a very murky area isn’t it? I have seen talented artists go overboard and call out “copy cats” when the subject matter of their work is very general. I’ve witnessed one artist aggressively asserting their right to be the only painter of realistic toadstools! The way that people present or edit videos is also pretty grey to me. I adore Leigh, but I also know a number of very cool girls who, to me, act in a similar way. I’m sure she is bombarded with very similar content creators and must be exhausted with being linked to them, but I think it would be hard to disentangle the copy-cats from the other genuine rad chicks who share her aesthetic and interests. I think artists walk a very thin line between protecting their work and checking their egos…..totally NOT a reference to you or Leigh, only my experience as an artist dealing with other artists. I hope you don’t take any of this as a criticism of your views but a reflection of how interesting a video you made. Very thought-provoking.
Hmmm this is tricky , I have made paintings looking like your latest work years ago. Colorful flowers on dark background… some look really similar. I did not have social media to put them out there and I never sold them. But gave them away as gifts ….. so does that mean you are copying me or my style ? I don’t know … It has to be blatantly clear actually before reacting …. That’s just my take to it. Ho and I have been art journaling for many many years now ….
And when I think back on it I got my inspiration then from wallpaper motives from the past …. Your flower paintings make me think of those motives. That being said I think you are brave and courageous to put yourself out there like you do . I think you are helping many people with your video’s specially those were you show how insecurity. You push through those times and that brings a message of hope 🤗❤️🙏🏼
Exactly 😌 We are all inspired by the world around us - it's no surprise different people can come up with the same ideas independently of eachother. In fact it reminds me of something, when the camera was invented, I think it was invented by two different people in different countries - at the same time...! They didn't have contact with eachother, it's just pure coincidence. It also reminds me of Charles Darwin, who rushed to publish his theory of Evolution because he realised another scientist had made the same discovery as him, and he wanted to publish it first so he would go down in history as the first person to have this idea. They both arrived at the same idea, separately and independently of eachother. When we start with the same raw materials, a certain number of us will come to the same conclusion. There are so many more people doing art now, as we are lucky to live in a time where we have access to the materials and luxury of time to make art. Also you can't really copyright a genre of art (like journaling), or a subject matter like 'flowers at night/with a black background'. In the same way JK Rowling couldn't stop anyone writing a book about a wizard school (and she got her inspiration from reading old books on Magic anyway). All artists are inspired by what interests them, and if you're good at art, you'll make it your own. I think there's a key difference here, between Originality and Authenticity. It's hard to be truly original, but to be a good artist, you should strive to be Authentic.
Ideas can’t be copyrighted as far as I know. Not ethical maybe, but probably not illegal. Copyright law is very complicated. It’s a shame that we should even have to worry about it.
"Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery." - Despite how upsetting it can be, at least you know one thing. You're fabulous and people want to be you ;-) I do feel sorry for people who have to copy others because they cannot find themselves. xx
This happened to me in art school. I was crushed but my art professor reminded me that I should be flattered that someone liked my work enough to copy it. I was young and didn’t quite understand. Now I have to remind myself of that. People definitely should not copy and make money duplicating your work. But there are so many techniques and ideas out there it seems hard to do something totally original. Even the masters copied each other. Being aware of this and talking about is a positive step. Thank you Wendy for bringing it up!
I have been making art for over 60 years. I have worked in this world as an artist and this was my living. Few things I have learned thru the years: Be careful if you claim a style or an idea. Someone has already done it. 1000's of people have already done it. We live a life being inspired and as artists we translate that into something we want to express. I like your channel because you create little lovely things that are in my wheel house. I relate to the colors and style. Over 50 years ago i filled journals with similar faces and flowers, text mixed media etc etc. To make a living as an artist it will involve you being inspired by others and they by you, thats the way it is. Be prolific and keep creating. If someone uses your photo image of a design you have done as a tag then thats a HUGE NO, but even on UA-cam i have watched talented scrapbookers, painters, journalists etc using this same form of creative delivery. I had a friend that was upset a few years ago that someone else did an old truck filled with pumpkins and she did it with flowers. I had to remind her a million trucks were done before she did it and head down, do art..keep creating, evolve and make art. You are a lovely sweet lady and I enjoy your channel btw :)
I love your comment. For an artist it's very grounding to hear. Artists can be egocentric and possessive of their ideas and work. Yet we are constantly gaining knowledge, inspiration etc all our lives, and as you say, it's been done before. Art evolves and revolves. 💌
Thank you for sharing your wise and compassionate voice 💜
Yes! Everything you said! Nothing is new and not to be insensitive but most mixed media art, esp girls & flowers all look the same! So its very hard to be “original”!
Ive already commented to another comment, but I wanted to add something here - you're right, it's hard to be original in art because even if you think you've invented an idea, there's no way of knowing if someone hasn't thought of it before you. And you'd be safer to assume they have, given the probability....
But I don't think that's what's important. To me, the meaningful difference is between *Originality* and *Authenticity* - make what is true to you, and comes from your heart and soul. It may be similar to other people's art, but its Authentic to you. Real art will have the spirit of authenticity to it.
Styles of art are always shared, there wasn't only ONE cubist artist, nor should there be ONE art journaler. And when more people engage in a genre of art, it develops and grows, it benefits all of us artists....that's how art works.
Directly copying someone's art and selling it/claiming it as your own, is obviously wrong. But you can't copyright a genre of art, hashtags or subject matter.
Great post
A book that may be of interest on this topic is Steal Like An Artist by Austin Kleon... here is a quote by T. S. Eliot from the introduction of said book:
“Immature poets imitate;
mature poets steal; bad
poets deface what they take,
and good poets make it into
something better, or at least
something different. The
good poet welds his theft into
a whole of feeling which is
unique, utterly different from
that from which it was torn.”
Very nice book!!! 💯👌
Great Book! 🎨🖌️🥷
Who are you Eva
***After reading your wonderful conversations in the comments I’m just adding this too… That I completely agree - 'nothing new under the sun,’ or nothing is original, in that sense. So, it's not original but is it authentic? If it's not the ‘ideas’ feeding the inspiration to create from our hearts, but, instead, it is truly stolen if it's someone trying to copy directly and claim it as their own. Or, repeatedly copying every little thing another creator does. If that makes sense? Grey areas… Loving this conversation, thanks for comments!*
For a long time, I let the fear of getting negative comments stop me from starting my UA-cam channel. I’ve been very surprised at how few negative comments I’ve gotten and I don’t see those on other people’s channels much either. Largely the UA-cam community is supportive and encouraging and I’m very grateful for that. Thanks for sharing and educating people on these very important issues!! Lots of love, Tara Kate
Hehe hello there! Did you find me from comments here? xx
@@GillianCrossArt I don’t remember! It may have been from search. I’ve found a lot of good vlogs that way. No matter how we did it, I’m glad we met! 💖
Me too!! Same same!! xxx
@@thebirdartistscottage Yes, me too! 💜
I rarely respond to comments in any social media on any platforms. Sometimes you get trolls, rage baiters. I have social anxiety caused by past experiences with racism, horrible rude customers and chavs. About few weeks ago I was walking my sister's semi wild dog, this chav turned around and stared at us like we were freaks. Incidents like this plus pandemic turns me in shut in. I don't feel like going out because verbal abuse, funny stares.
According to an article by the Smithsonian all major artistic representational techniques had been developed 17,000 years ago. There are currently 7.9 Billion humans on the planet. Humanity is too old, there are too many of us, everything has been done before thousands of times and will be repeated thousands of times again, each time with the creator thinking that they were the first. As an artist myself, I do love your work and will continue to enjoy your work. For you to believe that anything you or I or anyone else creates is truly unique, new and fully yours is naive at best and egotistical at worst. Have some humility and be grateful that you are a working artist, making a living doing what you love. That in itself is the truest validation that you are a good artist.
The saying, "There's nothing new under the sun", feels very relevant here. Outside of blatant plagiarism or copying someone's work, it's hard to claim copyright over ideas or style. Sometimes the same idea comes to various people. One person runs with the idea whilst another takes their time getting there. Just as our fingerprints are unique to us, so will the creative interpretation of that idea. Unless, like you speak of, it's a blatant copying of someone's creative expression. Alphonso Dunn and the Inktober 'creator' had a disagreement about the similarities in books published by both men. Coincidence or plagiarism? Only the 'offending artist' will ever know. Protecting one's work matters but knowing whether or not one person is copying another is not always easy to discover.
Completely agree TF, great points to mention. There are def grey areas, ideas and style within them...
That inktober thing was stupid. The page that Jake supposedly plagiarized was nothing new and there is crossover in all this stuff. I thought Alphonso was pretty childish about it.
@@themysteriousdomainmoviepalace I can understand your thoughts about it. Even though I won't comment on either party, what I learnt is to tread carefully when claiming 'ownership of art' and to be careful about 'calling people out'. I accepted one version of events until I read about how old some of the techniques were. These things/feuds can get unnecessarily ugly and intense. That said, I still think people should protect their art. Ideas are a different kettle of fish altogether.
@@TT-fn1xb If you've been to art school at all its obvious that those were classical techniques. Of course we need to protect our original artwork. Its difficult online but one artist never posts anything without including her name in the link so its obvious who created it.
@@theunexpectedgypsy I know many in the fashion world --- talking about fashion, what makes Zara's owner the richest man in Spain ?? 🤗🇪🇦
*@Tigs - I couldn't pin your comment directly because it was in response to another comment but you summed it up so well... so I hope you don't mind me pinning it here.
Tigs
16 hours ago
Ive already commented to another comment, but I wanted to add something here - you're right, it's hard to be original in art because even if you think you've invented an idea, there's no way of knowing if someone hasn't thought of it before you. And you'd be safer to assume they have, given the probability....
But I don't think that's what's important. To me, the meaningful difference is between Originality and Authenticity - make what is true to you, and comes from your heart and soul. It may be similar to other people's art, but its Authentic to you. Real art will have the spirit of authenticity to it.
Styles of art are always shared, there wasn't only ONE cubist artist, nor should there be ONE art journaler. And when more people engage in a genre of art, it develops and grows, it benefits all of us artists....that's how art works.
Directly copying someone's art and selling it/claiming it as your own, is obviously wrong. But you can't copyright a genre of art, hashtags or subject matter.*
I love your authenticity. I've been on tiktok for about a year now, and have been considering UA-cam. Your vlog style has inspired me, and I've been considering doing a vlog style as well, rather than the top-down painting videos I had been considering. The next step is for me to find my own voice and own style of vloging. So much has already been done, we'll never be 100% unique, but there is also a very important line of taking that inspiration and making it your own, vs copying completely. As I dive into the world of sharing content I pull from multiple source of inspiration and find ways to put my own creative spins and add in my own unique ideas as they come to me. When you are just following one artist I think that's where it becomes too easy to cross a line.
Truly a wonderful video and an important topic! I appreciate your insight 💙
UA-cam is rife with copying. I’ve started changing my channel from embroidery to art and crafts now. But it’s one of those things, even I’ve done it. We follow suite like a tik tok trend. Obviously you wouldn’t want to copy every single thing someone does but we all take bits from others to help mould ourselves. I can understand copying a painting would be a no no but to take inspiration from it and making your own interpretation is ok. The trouble is that you’ve obviously done something right to achieve what you’ve achieved and I think people will try and take elements to help themselves achieve the same. But a sad story is when someone calls their business something so simple(a word) and they’re told they can’t use it because that particular word is copyrighted! Love your channel by the way 💖
You've said everything I was thinking. You've hit the nail on the head. Xxx
I totally agree with all you've said, wise words.
You said what I was thinking. ☺️
One artist had her landscape paintings stolen, the perp took only cropped portions of her paintings and sold them as prints, pillows, mugs - the works. The guts some people have is astounding. Another artist had her painting stolen by some big shot in China and it was reproduces en masse. They made millions off of her work. There is/was a group lawsuit happening with over 20 artist because they do this all the time apparently but the artist could not afford the legal fees. She got nothing, she sold the original once and someone else bought a house with her work. 🤯
It’s a shame that the lawyers didn’t offer her a percentage fee at least. I have heard about Chinese theft of artwork before, but I suppose it could be any country where unscrupulous people would steal from artists.
Wendy, I love how gently you speak about such a difficult subject. You work so hard on your craft and should be able to protect it. Thank you for sharing 🙏🏻💜
You looked so pretty today, Wendy. I adore that you couldnt help but end on a positive note and that you didnt want someone on the verge of shining their light to be put off. That's why I love your light :)
Lots of varied thoughts and ideas on this one. Everyone is different and is inspired by so many different images, thoughts and flashes of insight often by viewing a piece of art. We can't really claim an idea is all our own because other things have influenced us and caused that idea to form. Being yourself means whatever you create will have that essence so it will always look different except if you blantantly copy a piece from someones art. That I feel, is the only real issue. Copying exactly someones art and passing it off as yours and profiting from it is not cool. Being inspired by another to create a new piece of art is adding to this great huge pool of light and joy in the world! We can't stop that. We can't stop sharing our work out of fear of people imitating us. Do your thing, live your life and leave beautiful things out there for people to enjoy I say. Great thoughtful video, Wendy. It will get people talking! 🙏🥰
Loving the conversation, yes, wonderful to hear everyone's thoughts!
I surely am inspired by your channel, your positivity and ability to inspire me to look at life more creatively.
I am not an art person in your medium, but I do so enjoy working with yarn and producing art in my creations.
I love your gentle spirit, and in this world of such loud voices, you are such a welcome change.
If it might be possible to love a person on social media, then that is how you make me feel-loved.
Your channel is my favorite and I treasure the time you spend with us and all the work and thinking it must take to do this.
Also, we share the same life philosophy and in this loud noisy world it is rare to find this.
I think what I am trying to say is thank you for being you and sharing with us.
We are truly blessed!
It's one thing to attempt to imitate or replicate something someone else does as experimentation , for your own experience, but too many people are doing this to fill their you tube content, and use it as "click bait" to attract others. I do see this as I view various channels. I'm glad you are talking about this.
I once had an Etsy silver jewellery shop and someone copied my shop name and style. I opened another Etsy shop. Again someone copied the name and even opened a physical shop with my shop name. I now create handmade artist teddies and someone has started using my shop name. It's depressing 😞
Well said Wendy. There is a wealth of difference between someone copying your art for the pleasure of personal learning and development - a compliment.... and someone 'stealing' your art and passing it off as their own in order to benefit from your originality and creativity - underhand infringement of copyright.
Thank you Wendy for covering a topic of some concern so beautifully and lovingly. It is really helpful to shed light on these aspects and as always you come from an authentic and generous place. Have a magical week ahead beautiful faery. Keep shining your light
Copyright law does not cover an idea or a style. It only covers a specific expression of the idea or style. You cannot copyright an idea.
Absolutely Bonnie, I completely agree. It only becomes relevant if someone copies every little thing another artist/creator does for a long period of time and that's when the grey areas become darker... if that makes sense.
@@theunexpectedgypsy once you have your trademark, you can sue them
@@theunexpectedgypsyIn Australia, once your idea has been made (on paper, canvas or in 3D) then you automatically own the copyright (for free) and anyone who steals it can be sued. So, never TELL anyone your ideas until they are set in stone (so to speak).
I used to wonder about how to find my own style. I read somewhere that it’s a great idea to keep a list of all the artists and creatives you admire and whose work you follow and then write down what it is you are drawn to about their work, eg I love the whimsy in your work, I love the way you layer and your use of colour. I can incorporate more whimsy into my own work then without it looking like your work. Another favourite artist has a clean clear way of using colour that I deeply admire. Maybe I could combine whimsy with a clean clear focus on colour but in my own way of working? Maybe that would be awful, but by experimenting I will eventually find something that is my own. Anyway, I find that by identifying exactly what it is that I like about a piece of art work I’m drawn to (pardon the pun), it helps me understand what I like, and helps me identify my own style.
hi art style just happens. some people just have it, others just think they need to work to have it... its a lie.
You have explained this difficult subject beautifully. Thank you for sharing your views and insight.💐❤️
I could never be on social media like y'all. Once, I had my work blatantly stolen and had to go to small claims court. It was awful. I only won because of the way I wrapped the jewelry I used to make. I had a certain thumb print in my wire work. People wise, I went through a very heart breaking situation with a supposed friend, in 2020. It broke my heart and soul to the point I was depressed for almost a year over it. It was truly tragic. I am an empath and I tend to share too much (this message for instance LOL), I could never put myself out there for EVERYONE to see and know. You are brave and speak from your heart.
Can you copyright jewelry?
The Sunday Stylist (not an artist but another UA-camr) had a similar problem. She tried the gentle nudging approach but it didn't work. In the end she did a video calling the two UA-camrs out. They had blatantly copied one of her videos using the same format and the same words. One was literally word for word. Sometimes we have to call people out publicly. It is a shame. Great video Wendy and love your message of being our authentic self. ❤
Thank you so much for this chat! As a new visual artist coming from the performing arts, I've really struggled to find that line of inspiration and knowing how much is appropriate to borrow in an idea.
This is why I do my research for ideas but use them in a new way. What helps is to always give the creators of those ideas credit for inspiring you.
Thank you Wendy for taking the time to touch in on a sensitive subject. I can speak from my own experience...and that is that as an artist I have always given credit or said "inspired by" if I post something, even if it doesn't even look anything like the other artist's work! I also write it on the back of the piece of art. I think it helps grow a community when you share with others that somebody inspired you... it's just a kind way to acknowledge someone else!😍 It is said that when someone copies you it is the ultimate compliment, however plagiarism is another thing and I think your suggested approach, if it happens to you, is the best advise! Have a lovely weekend! I enjoyed my cuppa with you. ☕ Always a pleasure to meet up with you each Friday morning dear lady! Stay warm!🌻🌞
Beautifully said. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. You really are a rare gem!
You spoke about these sensitive topics in such a kind and gentle way. At the same time, you clearly showed where you draw the line. I think they copy you because they admire you, and they'd like to have some of your success - which is never going to work because you are inimitable and irreplaceable.
Three years ago I was at an exhibition by my favourite artist who I am acquainted with. I had just arrived and had taken my mobile phone out of my handbag to switch it off. Her partner rushed over and knocked it out of my hand, spilling wine over me and into my handbag. He shouted at me accusing me of taking photos to copy her work! Everybody was looking at me and a few made comments to suggest I was taking photos when I shouldn’t be. I felt so embarrassed and sad. The artist came over and apologised sincerely for her partner’s behaviour, she was obviously embarrassed by it. This did give me food for thought about copyright issues though. You raised some very good points Wendy.
Wow, that's terrible!!
People can be sooo stupid. Sigh. 😖😓🥸
I'm an avid art you tube channel follower and to be honest, many of the channels pretty much have the same formats and use the same sentences and styles of presentation. I've also noticed quite a lot of creatives using bought stencils as a basis for their paintings too. It's pretty difficult to reinvent the wheel when the market is soo very flooded with similar things. How many ways can one paint a flower? Interesting vlog, thank you.
Yes, Wendy uses stencils, if somebody uses the same stencils, and blending, but not seen Wendy's work? Are they copying? I don't think they are? I'm a little confused about this video. Some of it I agree with, and some of it concerns me.
@@Beatles.lassie I feel the same way. Mixed feelings.
@@WendyW123 I like UA-cam videos where artists show ‘how to’ do certain things. They want their viewers to do what they do. They share their knowledge. This seems a little mean and it makes me feel sad. Xxx
Yes I agree with you both, I have mixed feelings about this video. She did preface it by saying its a 'grey' area, but actually I think it's more a case of - some things are clearly wrong, and others are not. It's not grey, there are separate categories.
Of course the example of someone using her artwork to make clothes labels, obviously that's wrong and a clear example of stealing artwork. If someone started selling prints of her artwork, that's obviously wrong.
But what about a *style* of artwork/journaling/hashtags.....? I love Wendy's work and have followed her for a long time, but I was a bit surprised by the way she phrased this. It's not like she invented writing phrases next to fairies in a journal, I remember having books exactly like that when I was a kid, years ago... And I had how-to-craft books with that *exact* same typewriter font and directions on how to *stamp words next to collages* (of fairies...)
Also, she said someone copied her flower-power project.....well, I know she didn't invent the phrase Flower Power, or the idea of painting flowers. Sure, she decided to concentrate on painting them at night, which is more unusual but definitely not original.
But it's hard (if not impossible) to be completely original in art, because we are all inspired by what we've seen and experienced. I think as artists we have to accept people might start with the same raw materials and come to a similar conclusion.....
In terms of copying hashtags, I thought the more people that use your hashtag, the better..? Isn't that how it works? If more people use the same hashtag, your art will be seen by more people - and the whole point of hashtags is to link you to posts of the same theme, it's basically an index for themes.
I've watched a video where Wendy copied an Art Deco paining from a book, and that inspired her to try a new style, to get out of a rut, which flowed into her flower power series. This is copying, and developing into your own style. If other people are doing the same with her style of journaling, I don't really see how that's any different. Of course they should credit her if they've directly copied her work, and they shouldn't sell it without permission because that's against copyright - but you can copy what you want for your own personal artwork.
Imagine if Picasso said: 'Right, nobody copy me, I'm the only one allowed to be a Cubist'
And if Dali said: 'Nobody copy me, I'm the only one allowed to do Surrealsim'
And Leonardo Da Vinci....and the first Cave-man to stamp his handprint on the wall of a cave....✋🏼✋🏼🎨🎨
We would have a whole lot less art in the world. Same with music, artists inspire eachother. Direct copying is stealing. Being inspired by a GENRE of art, or using similar materials, or subject matter.....to me, that's just art, we share those things.
@@tigs6639 of course, you are spot on with the clear divide Tigs. Blatant copying without credit is just definitely wrong. Also passing off someone else's work as your own, is just plain wrong too. I often go onto Pinterest to look for inspiration when I am having a block and end up seeing hundreds of similar pieces of work by different artists, but I think to myself that it must be pretty difficult to change what is essentially a vase of flowers into something new (hope that makes sense, hehe). I truly believe, like you, that authenticity is very rarely achieved in a world where almost everything has already been done in some form or fashion.
I’m always touched by your authenticity! You’re inspiring on so many levels. You’re a beautiful soul that heals so many of us caught in the “out there” hang ups. Being REAL is a medicine for this world. And YOU do that!!! I can definitely relate to infringement topic, one thing I have personally learned is that they may copy for a moment, but they don’t have the infinite access to where all those unique ideas from “ within “ come from! Oh there’s soo much more !!! Lol once we have the inner key, possibilities are endless. Biggest hugs of warmth from Hawaii! 🌺💛🤗💛🌺
Thank you for sharing this! It's such a difficult conversation that has to be tiptoed around. You handled it compassionately, as always!
I've just been amazed at the tsunami of ideas out in cyberspace. I really only started looking at youtube during lockdown. Everytime I think I'm onto something new and perhaps could make some pin money from it I UA-cam the idea and someone else is doing it. So it must be really hard trying to make a living from your art and seeing it possibly being ripped off. However, that being said from what I see in your niche that you and James are projecting an authenticity that rings true for many people. So many people are just so slick on youtube that you both are very refreshing to follow!
Thank you! I love your kindness and your pureness. Your voice is so soothing and you're so inspiring! Love from Montreal, Canada💕
Thank you for the beautiful video. You have a wonderful way with words to get your point across. Just listening to you today makes me feel like you had to be a marvelous teacher. Love everything you create. Onward!!! 🙂
Miss Wendy, You are such a beautiful soul. I am such a follower of you, when I watch and listen to you,and have coffee together, the kindness of your soul shines. I’ll admit,I have tears at times and it’s all good,like today’s video on copyright worries. Some people have a hard time these days with right and wrong it seems to this old girl.My husband Matt Tucker works in pencil,painting and does Ice Sculptures.As an artist that issue has come up in the passed.Not easy. But we move forward and stay inspired everyday to create from our souls,that’s makes us Happy. Huggies to you. Stay strong everyday,we need each other.
The timing of this is really good. And I agree with many who have hit it bang on. We learn from one another so styles can be similar, even content. What I think key is intent. Is someone learning to draw? Learning color combinations? Learning the what and the how’s? Or are their intentions altogether nefarious in origin. I have not shared my artwork, yet, because of this very fear. But I think it’s getting time I just swim because I don’t want to sink…
Your channel is great and I've seen it grow so fast over the time you have been doing it. The lockdowns and such, though bad, were actually quite good for inspiring people to follow and create on their own.
You are so sweet and genuine that I think you would make a fantastic sister. I've not spoken to my own for over 15yrs, bad blood there, but I do enjoy having a cuppa with you!🍀💕
Great conversion, you have inspired me to send others "warm hugs" because we can not actually hug yet. I hope that is okay?
I started watching your channel during lockdown here in the US when stumbling across your page while searching "art studio tour". You were and are a BIG inspiration to me starting my own channel last year. My only desire to copy was in how genuine and true to yourself and your art that you are and I wish to show that of myself in my own videos. I am inspired by you to look deep within myself and show people some of what I find in my search. I'm finding it takes a lot of bravery to do what you do and I want to thank you for sharing that and inspiring me to be brave and do the same. 🥰
Thank you for your thoughtful, nuanced discussion of the imitation/copyright infringement issue.
Not being talented or brave enough to share on social media.
I still enjoyed watching you tonight and was so impressed by your attitude.
You are such a generous, caring and sweet lady.
I’m really glad I found you a year ago.
Love and hugs to you and James.😍😍xx
Been knitting along listening to a few of your videos this wintery Sunday, just got my glass paints, grabbed a jar and drew a little winter scene, thank you. Over 10 years since I've done anything creative (only just picked up my very basic knitting again this week as well.) Thank you again
I highly urge every artist to read a book by Elizabeth Gilbert called "Big Magic" about creativity it is very enlightening about creative process and about creatives ideas finding a place to come to fruition ❤️ Great video Wendy as usual 👏👏
THIS. Unfortunately, her explanation is often an unpopular opinion, but one I have fully embraced multiple times in life. There's really no sense holding onto something somebody else can do better. I make what I make when I can/have time, but love when others take it further.
FAB book! xx
I just ordered it, because I am stuck in my creative process!
I noticed people of the western world are very into " ME ". So they sign their work. They sell Their work. All about the ego. In India and places like Tibet . It is about the art not the artist. No one signs their name to the work because it is not about the person doing the work. I love that I dea and It has freed me as an artist. Some of my clients want me to sign a piece so for them I sign the back not to affect the art. As an artist for over 45 years I believe this is also the best way for the yogic way is also about letting go of names and identification or labels. There really is nothing more freeing and a little scary about Not signing your work.
Really enjoyed this topic, cannot believe a shop copied your art and put it on their tags!! Unreal!!! Art takes time, and finding your own voice and style also takes time!! Sending lots of love and light!! And of course lots of warm moments!!!❤❤❤
Well said and great topic to address. One important aspect is that artists who work in their craft everyday are trying to make a living. Selling their work contributes to their ability to make a living. Hard work, dedication, love, to do their own work, everyday.
Thanks for sharing Wendy and this is important. no body likes to be copied because it's like having your signature snatched from under your nose most artist would have enough self belief self esteem self worth ideas and inspiration of their own to explore and express while appreciating the works of other artists and not copying I'm sure. like you said its in the minority... I really appreciate our utube artist to help inspire and support I look forward to your videos and other artist on utube who do beautiful inspiring artwork and vlogs it literally makes my heart sing! Have a lovely weekend love and light to you and James 💜 PS. I do want to add that there maybe artist who also do art journaling and styles similar to yours without even knowing you. my style could be similar to someone else I have no idea and it's also very important for that to be taken into account and that no one would have ever copied but only had styles similar to one another there will be people who also love flowers and may have a style similar to yours and do flowers a little like yours so yes this is a tricky Wendy 💜
Thank you for this video. I appreciate it so much. I have been hesitant to show any of my new artwork across social media, after I saw one of my pieces on someone else's page several years ago. It is soooooo annoying to see something you created from your imagination stolen and claimed by another.
The only thing I think about copy writing and have often wondered about is so another person doesn't get me in trouble /accusing me falsely of copying them! Thats why I would do copy writing on my art, other then that they can copy all they want im really free and sharing and I encourage people to copy my handmade rugs and viking ladies in a row garden posts and teach others my really unique and beautiful technique that I invented of hand stitching art with wood and help them with learning what they like and getting their own style by trying out what they like through what I do, im so unique in my art I don't think anybody could do what I do/ im to way off unique, thanks for the discussion on this needed topic, as I don't have a single artist friend to talk to this about who understands this questioning. In the past famous artist that lived at the same time often knew each other and when one of the did a painting that they liked they would all go off and paint a painting inspired by them -they where always doing that and saying good artists copy great artist steal, so you do steal what you like but you you use it in your own style which takes authenticity to find!, love to you on your majestic art journey, your giving good advice here/love to you!
Saturday morning is my 're time's with Wendy and sometimes James. I've been watching your videos for over a year now and I so look forward to my Saturday mornings with you. I admire who you are as a person - your honesty, creativity,inspiration and positivity truly feed my soul. Although I 've never aspired to put myself out there I really appreciate and admire the fact that you have embraced the social media platforms and that you have made such a success of this. Thankyou for sharing some of the more negative aspects of using those platforms that you have experienced and for sharing ideas on how to deal with that. Keep doing what you do as you bring joy and inspiration to so many people. 🥰
Thanks for keeping me company all the while Sue xxxxxx
As a pretty new artist, I really appreciate your point of view on this topic.
I remember one of my tutors explaining this to the class. Thank you for your clarification. I am still finding my style although 3D and mixed media are my first love. I cannot draw,is that negative thought that always comes up because I compare all the time thank you for sharing that. Most of my days are in my daily care of 14 independent elderly as I run the house and listen to what is happening in their daily lives. Taking time for me the last 10 days I have enjoyed your videos, seeing how you take time for you. My go to is my morning pages and Julia Cameron's artist way books my audible go to everyday. Have a blessed week Wendy.
Thank you. Not a waffle at all!! Think you speak authentically and openly about these issues. Beautifully put..good use of your intuitive awareness and thinking on the issues. Well said xxx
That's a lovely share, thank you. Principles that could be taught to children...very powerful. Thank you xxx
You are such a unique artist and wonderful person.
Don't let yourself be under that fear. No one can steal your uniqueness.
I understand that maybe it costs a lot of energy to fight this fear 😟.
But don't let it take your trust in yourself. Just let it flow away with time. You are so much more than artstealers could ever be 😉.
This is a great discussion on a really tricky area. I have no idea why anyone would want to copy someone else's ideas, aesthetic or identity as they'll always get found out? There's no definitive answer to any of this, I guess, other than keep on keeping on.
Such an appropriate topic for this New Moon in Scorpio... Courageous Truth looks very good on you Wendy! I do aspire to video document my artistic process and you inspire me toward that very much. I have yet to make public any of my art processes... I think a part of my hesitation is that I am aware that my personal creative process is still in discovery. It is quite a treat to be invited into yours and others creative processes via the web... If only to inspire ones own authentic expression. Why else create art than to expression ones unique truth!?
Empowering and very well said ....
Let's " be " .....and be happy 😊
I've used it as educational purposes something I've learned from art school. The professors often took us to the art museum, which was connected to the school. Part of the assignment was to copy the masters to learn. Plus as artists we are inspired by others just as we inspire. But copying an exact image to claim as your own then no.
Well said. Image stealing happens far too often. Blanket sellers steal quilt images all the time. Recently it’s been decal companies. Scammers about. Stay the course. As an off side...love your knit wear. Beautiful and cozy!
I've lost count the number of times my work was stolen while I was a student. Always being told, "oh well you should take that as a compliment." WHAT?! That little note just justifying theft. I do appreciate my professors (MUCH later on) reminding me, ALWAYS ALWAYS show credit where credit is due.
P.S.: I love your Art Studio chats. They are a great pick me up for when I'm feeling dealing with alot of imposter symptom.
I used to do photography non-professionally and my friend of 40 years decided that she was going to make items out of my photography without asking me. Phone covers, painting my photographs etc. She never once asked me if she could. I so understand where you’re coming from with this and I am so very sorry that you ever have to tolerate peoples negative remarks that they should definitely keep to themselves. It’s a different world out there and we should not have to adjust to people being mean and thoughtless💜
Awwwww, I love the way that you found a positive side of this by very gently encouraging people to find their own style. 🤗🌞 Thanks a ton for your commitment to positivity. ✌❤🕊️
Oh I love your scarf. It’s so gorgeous. Looks beautiful on you. I am a knitter, so I appreciate those sort of things.❤
Thank you for sharing this video. I recently came across someone who does pyrography on wood. Sometimes using art created by a different artist not just using the picture as a reference but tracing/transferring the image on to the wood not free hand. Only filling in the details free hand so to me the work is partly the pyrgraphers and partly the artists. I felt quite wound up discussing this an made at point that the artists name should always be mentioned. You've helped me clarify this as I thought I was being over sensitive. I love all your videos by the way.
"Trust that your life is enough. Trust that you are enough" A beautiful silence fills my whole being hearing this. For once, I trust. Thanks for sharing all this. Feels really good and loving
You are such an inspiration! I've followed you pretty much from the beginning of your UA-cam adventure and love everything you do! As an artist, this subject is so important to us and one of my biggest fears of putting my own self out there amidst just the pushing myself to do so. Enjoying my warm cup of coffee with you on this chilly morning. Thank you for keeping your light shining bright! PS when you quote poetry and your writings I find that extra inspiring to hear in my day!
I totally agree Wendy 💛☀️✨ I always think when someone copies there work will carry that energy.. they will never have the authentic truth behind their work! Inspiration is a wonderful thing, you personally inspired me within my UA-cam channel to be more authentic, I share videos on spirituality and seeing your videos and how you shine your light absolutely moved me to just be me more☀️💛✨ I appreciate you sharing your journey sending many blessings from Australia
Miss Wendy I adore you! And I hope you do more on this topic. And please maybe you & James could research some firms that specializes in this. The issue is not going away. Might as well educate & protect the "few gypsies that remain" Praying for you to be blessed with discernment on how to proceed.
Thank you for mentioning this ...so much happened a few years ago really has put things on hold however I switched back to doing my journals and hand drawing rather than my digital work cus I couldnt afford the stockphoto purchases any more and health got rough so selling kinda stuck cus I'm centered on healing on so much but I have found that some of the positives even if it's just a few comments the positive stuff helps alot so I just kinda have been on hiatus and working my journey to be more just for me there was so much that it was just overwhelming yet I do hope to have a local show when I can cus my canvas work kinda boomed during covid beginning and hopefully I can start something back cus this is my life and I been drawing and doing whether it was graphics or fine art for most of I have learned what to let bug me and what not to...for the most part you are correct it's our journey our way and so with that said have a great week and I know I'm not the only one that's dealt with that kinda of stuff
This was my first time finding you , thank you for what you read , it was lovely , I'm looking forward to seeing your work .
Thankyou Wendy, for your channel, and sharing your wisdom with us.
Glad you shared this. Thank you. I've been making some hard decisions regarding my own art studio and work going forward. I no longer engage in any form of social media. I also deleted the blog from my studio site and stopped using online stores & merchandising. If someone wants my work they must get it directly from me. "The Artist's Journey is about the Art, not the artist." - Steven Pressfield, book 'The Artist's Journey'
Sometimes we just have to keep on creating otherwise paralysis can kick in. I’m the master of overthinking so quietening my mind and being a little blinkered to things such as social media comments etc really helps! I haven’t been brave enough to embark on a UA-cam journey yet. Maybe next year 😊🦋✨
You are so special Wendy and you have treated this subject brilliantly! Thank you.
I wrote something I found profound but it went to the cloud I guess but I am trying it again. Remember your light and your art it is your universe given to you at your time and if some is forging your work it will not stop your light to keep growing. Yes it is upsetting but if it gets in your way to profit from your art wirk search for laws and find a lawyer to look over the issues... however keep doing your beautiful work you are doing because it had your own personality in it and we all know better and want to keep value your overall art wirk abd how can someone think they can be you as your bring your own soul into your stories your life your relationship and your Art keep believing that it will pass and keep doing what you doing... keep shining and helps us to see that we all can find ourselves in your struggles and successes. Keep your beautiful light shinning! Thank you!
The only way to not be copied is to not go public. Sadly.🌼 But your uniqueness is original you! 💝 Love you!
Interesting topic, I’m currently working on finding my art style and it’s interesting to see it develop naturally. I will have to do research on copyrights in my state I live in California. I am not quite savvy with doing art prints right now so I plan on selling my originals for now until I figure out how to make prints.
Just found your channel and thank you. Love your art and your honesty (esp. the one about the messy studio).
Love your work and your encouragement, I’m on “the cusp” of doing something on UA-cam, so this was very helpful x
Oh Wendy, so sorry someone did this to you, but grateful you found the mindful gentle path through it and shared that with us. It's so easy to react and lose to the negative. Re copyright: Someone copied one of my blogs (the whole site, not just a post) to a foreign-based site and I've hesitated to pursue it, bc I didn't know if it was worth all the work that might be involved, or how to go about it. Thanks to this post, I might actually look into it now. Thanks, Wendy - for finding the gentle path, and James - for getting upset. Bright blessings.
Wendy you are so wonderful in presenting a topic in a positive light. Sending you love and hugs. 😘🥰❤️💋🙏💐✨🤗🎹⭐️🌹🐶❤️🙏
I agree with you. As a photographer and artist, I have been plagued by people printing off wedding photos etc, instead of purchasing from me the creator. I think…well I am thrilled to be inspired and to inspire others…however there is a line like you said that blatant plagiarism is just pure theft!
Such a misunderstood topic, your genuine self shines through as you share feelings and experiences! Through the years I was exposed to myths about this topic, such as: it’s ok if you only use three quarters of the design or if you reverse the image! But in fact none of them are true! I have held onto a photo I would love to draw, I searched for the photographer to get permission,with out luck! I hesitate because I feel even doing it for my own pleasure could lead to misuse! Blessed and safe days!
It's not against copyright to copy a photograph you like for your artwork *if it's only done for personal studies*
You can paint DISNEY characters on your kids wall - but not to sell.
You can copy the work of famous painters for your own studies and pleasure - it only breaks copyright if you're selling it/claiming it as your own 😌
If you wrote the lyrics to your favourite song in your diary, you haven't stolen them. If you published them and said they were your lyrics, then you have....
@@tigs6639 there is an artist making paintings from rolling stone magazine covers...not sure how he's getting away with this as he's using the original photograph as the 'base' for his 'painting'...and also the magazine masthead etc...like?
Hope your heat gets fix. Love hearing you talk and seeing you paint.
It’s such a tough topic and there is quite a fine line sometimes between being inspired by someone’s art and copying someone’s art or ideas. I have had my work copied a couple of times- the kicker was someone who wanted a piece of my art but didn’t agree with the price, so went to a friend who painted it for her for free. They tagged me in the post of the copied art work. It was all very confusing for me, because on the one hand, it was nice that they tagged me and that she wanted my art in the first place but it also felt really sad to have my art totally copied so that someone didn’t have to buy it from me. I let it go, but it did hurt to be honest!
I’ve only recently discovered you Wendy, and I love your essence, your style, your art is beautiful and you have a beautiful soul. I don’t know why, I can’t fully describe, some people have touched on it, but, this video makes me feel sad. 😔
I think you’re a beautiful person inside and out. Blessings to you. 🧚♂️❣️xxx
Wow Wendy. The problem of plagerism and stealing is worse than I thought. This strangely popped up on my news feed. 🙏🏻❤️xxx
ua-cam.com/video/9J7SSJTUiOE/v-deo.html
You addressed this topic beautifully. I really admire you.
My mum always said' most people are nice' good to speak up about things like this.
I just adore you so much! Hope you're able to get the heat fixed in your studio! Have a wonderful weekend Wendy!
I love this discussion! I am very mindful with having a very distinctive visual language, and I use themes that I can't find others using ... so when followers on IG, for example, suddenly start doing the same thing, then I just unfollow them and try to ignore it. I find that if that's not their natural art style, then they tend to move onto something else pretty quickly ...
I hope nobody says anything unkind to you. You are a lovely lady who brings warmth to many hearts. Thank you.
I’ll add a little something. When I was about twelve years old, I entered a speech contest. I wrote a speech for the are of 'dramatic presentation,'. I remember I wrote, and revised, and wrote again. Then I practiced my speech in front of my teacher, my parents, and the mighty mirror. My character was a young woman coming from a communist company and arriving at Ellis Island. On the day of the contest after I performed before the judges my teacher and I were ecstatic expecting the first prize I evidently deserved. I was disqualified for plagiarism! We were stunned. My teacher fought for me but the judges refused to budge. Had young ladies arrived at Ellis Island before? Had I copied the idea? Does a child who reads three books a week have that knowledge in her memory bank? Did I hunt for the idea? The words? Did I plagiarize? The answer was no. I was crushed. I truly was. But when I grew older I realized that I had indeed won a first-in spades! That Wendy, was reverse plagiarism of the meanest kind.
I started painting during the first pandemic - I copied everything and everyone for learning when I started. But I never, never dreamt of passing these painting as coming from my own brain. Almost two years later I now understand what means to get inspired, if I see a drawing about a starred sky for instance I will put myself and paint my own starred sky, with my own colours and the styles I learned and I might specimens more. And then I see another techniques or style I like and I do copy it again to learn and experiment, but only copying feels like to be in a creative jail. At some point there is the physical need to let your mind go and get yourself there on the paper. But at the same time I will never forget all my teachers.
this has stopped me from uploading & sharing my art over the years !! great conversation today XXX
Great video as always Wendy, it even prompted a discussion between me and my partner.
I’ve definitely been afraid to share some of my work through fear of copycats….I sometimes feel that the people who take a picture of my work at craft fairs and walk away are thinking of copying it. It doesn’t feel nice.
On the other hand, the copying of ideas and styles is a very murky area isn’t it? I have seen talented artists go overboard and call out “copy cats” when the subject matter of their work is very general. I’ve witnessed one artist aggressively asserting their right to be the only painter of realistic toadstools!
The way that people present or edit videos is also pretty grey to me. I adore Leigh, but I also know a number of very cool girls who, to me, act in a similar way. I’m sure she is bombarded with very similar content creators and must be exhausted with being linked to them, but I think it would be hard to disentangle the copy-cats from the other genuine rad chicks who share her aesthetic and interests.
I think artists walk a very thin line between protecting their work and checking their egos…..totally NOT a reference to you or Leigh, only my experience as an artist dealing with other artists.
I hope you don’t take any of this as a criticism of your views but a reflection of how interesting a video you made. Very thought-provoking.
love this ! xx Thanks for sharing!
Hmmm this is tricky , I have made paintings looking like your latest work years ago. Colorful flowers on dark background… some look really similar. I did not have social media to put them out there and I never sold them. But gave them away as gifts ….. so does that mean you are copying me or my style ? I don’t know … It has to be blatantly clear actually before reacting …. That’s just my take to it. Ho and I have been art journaling for many many years now ….
And when I think back on it I got my inspiration then from wallpaper motives from the past …. Your flower paintings make me think of those motives. That being said I think you are brave and courageous to put yourself out there like you do . I think you are helping many people with your video’s specially those were you show how insecurity. You push through those times and that brings a message of hope 🤗❤️🙏🏼
Exactly 😌 We are all inspired by the world around us - it's no surprise different people can come up with the same ideas independently of eachother.
In fact it reminds me of something, when the camera was invented, I think it was invented by two different people in different countries - at the same time...! They didn't have contact with eachother, it's just pure coincidence.
It also reminds me of Charles Darwin, who rushed to publish his theory of Evolution because he realised another scientist had made the same discovery as him, and he wanted to publish it first so he would go down in history as the first person to have this idea. They both arrived at the same idea, separately and independently of eachother.
When we start with the same raw materials, a certain number of us will come to the same conclusion. There are so many more people doing art now, as we are lucky to live in a time where we have access to the materials and luxury of time to make art.
Also you can't really copyright a genre of art (like journaling), or a subject matter like 'flowers at night/with a black background'. In the same way JK Rowling couldn't stop anyone writing a book about a wizard school (and she got her inspiration from reading old books on Magic anyway).
All artists are inspired by what interests them, and if you're good at art, you'll make it your own. I think there's a key difference here, between Originality and Authenticity. It's hard to be truly original, but to be a good artist, you should strive to be Authentic.
Ideas can’t be copyrighted as far as I know. Not ethical maybe, but probably not illegal. Copyright law is very complicated. It’s a shame that we should even have to worry about it.
"Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery." - Despite how upsetting it can be, at least you know one thing. You're fabulous and people want to be you ;-) I do feel sorry for people who have to copy others because they cannot find themselves. xx
This happened to me in art school. I was crushed but my art professor reminded me that I should be flattered that someone liked my work enough to copy it. I was young and didn’t quite understand. Now I have to remind myself of that. People definitely should not copy and make money duplicating your work. But there are so many techniques and ideas out there it seems hard to do something totally original. Even the masters copied each other. Being aware of this and talking about is a positive step. Thank you Wendy for bringing it up!
Well said, good point!
Beautifully said!
Within vulnerability we find our strength.
great subject , thank you for sharing ...I appreciate you as well Wendy ...please keep inspiring us as we walk this journey with you