so if Palestine referred to a region including parts of modern-day Syria, Lebanon and Jordan, then why aren't the Palestinians asking for territory in those countries?
Because they know that if they riot - there will be no more people to claim they are "palastiniens" - aka they will get shot instantly even if they rise a white flag. Why there are "palastinians" in jordan? or syria? :)
@People, Unite! That's the connotation these days but the denotation for Semite was always intended as the larger diaspora of Semitic Peoples (including Arabs, Assyrians, etc, etc...) and NOT just The Jews as it's commonly referred to these days by layman and ignorant Media members.
Before the ancient Rome existed, Israel was a kingdom on that piece of land Before the ancient Greece, Israel was having royal lineage, king and queens 3500 years of Archeology of ancient written language and cultural artifacts And yes, Kids without basic knowledge of history don't need to comment
@the red tiger you're a disgrace to humanity and its a shame your mother hasn't told you who your biological father is 🤣. Go apologize to the tree that's producing oxygen for you. Troll!
how can god bless a liar???? Hell will be his only resting place unless he really tells the truth about innocent lives being persecuted by his own government/regime
truth can be what you decide to tell when it suits you but what about the whole truth about what is really going on in Palestine and the Gazans.. will you condemn yourself to eternal damnation for the lies and atrocities you will make on this subject?? do you really believe that your god will forgive you for what has happened to the innocent men, women and children of Palestine while you spread the lies of a nation that is committed to the destruction of Palestine
No dear - facts in case i need to spell it out for you - is what is REALLY going in reality which you can back up with proves - opinions are those things you are trying to sell
SimsMoyal i don't think there is a single thing in this world that can backs you up as prove. read the books, that will help you find the real truth behind all of this. don't be an ignorant person please :)
The UN gave that land to Israel in 1948. In fact, they planned to give them most of Jordan too, but Israel agreed that that would cause too much conflict. Israel did not "steal" a thing. Arabs declared war on Israel, not the other way around, in spite of the fact that Palestine was not, and never has been a nation. That is a fact, not subjective in any form. Need I remind everyone that on top of that nugget of truth, the Jews had a genocide committed against them? Dead civilians are truly a tragedy and no one, Israel chief among them, wants that. So maybe you should call Hamas and tell them to stop hiding their rockets cites in playgrounds and UN clinics. So Please don't speak self righteously about who the real victims are when frankly, you have not even done a modicum of research on the history of the conflict. Thanks.
UN did not give them "other's land." The UN gave Jews, Jewish land. There was no country there when League of Nations Proposed Israeli state. Land was occupied by former Ottoman Empire citizens. The Ottomans were beaten by allies (British) and the Brits merely named land confiscated as "Palestine", but it was not a country and was slated to be Jewish state. So I'm sorry, but the Palestinians have no "right" to the land as it was not theirs to begin with. They were offered countless times to split land in two and have two states, one Jewish and one Palestinian, and they have rejected every last one of those proposals. They use terrorism and indiscriminate rocket attacks while Israel takes every opportunity to warn civilians of impending strikes on missile batteries positioned in public spaces. I cannot support terrorism. I must side with Israel who supports women's rights, Arab judges, democracy, impartial courts, and religious freedom. Jews DO live in peace with Arabs IN ISRAEL. There are over one million Arab citizens of Israel, so.... yeah.
***** I am somewhat familiar with how Mohammed helped jews. But it did not last forever. Additionally, it was Ottoman land, then British land, and the Brit's gave it to Israel. It was not until after the holocaust that that finally took shape. In 47 UN proposed a partition giving the land 50/50 to indigenous Jordanians and indigenous and foreign Jews. It was not Palestinian land. It was not stolen. If military conquest by a provoked nation (britain) is a definition of theft, then almost every nation in the entire world has been "stolen" and must be given up.
houdini2233 The Jews based their religion in Israel, not in Europe. The conflict that lasted 70 years because the colonizers (Arabs) do not want the Jews to return to their home.
houdini2233 "The Arabs are not colonisers" Started from Mecca, where a pedophile Jew has made his own faith called Islam, then made an empire, reaching from Spain to India. And look at today. How is that not colonization?
houdini2233 _"__jpupdates.com/2014/04/24/fatah-official-pa-hamas-unity-govt-will-recognize-israels-existence/...__“The reconciliation with Hamas is founded on the two-state solution within the 1967 borders"_ you must believe everything people tell you...are they not capable of political lies? here's what they actually still say: Article 6 Hamas is uniquely Palestinian, and "strives to raise the banner of Allah over _every inch of Palestine_". Article 8 The Hamas document reiterates the Muslim Brotherhood's slogan of "Allah is its goal, the Prophet is the model, the Qur'an its constitution, jihad its path, and _death for the sake of Allah_ its most sublime belief." Article 11 Palestine is sacred (waqf) for all Muslims _for all time, and it cannot be relinquished by anyone._ Article 13 _There is no negotiated settlement possible. Jihad is the only answer._ Article 15 "The day that enemies usurp part of Muslim land, Jihad becomes the individual duty of every Muslim". It states the history of crusades into Muslim lands and says the _"Palestinian problem is a religious problem"._ avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp _Heres another_ news.antiwar.com/2014/04/24/report-palestinian-unity-means-hamas-will-recognize-israel/ ...and? is this _just_ an argument from authority? until hammas repudiates its charter Netanyahu is not only justified in dismissing them, but is rationally obligated to. _"Heres some more reading for you"_ www.intifada-palestine.com/2013/05/mass-graves-of-palestinians-killed-in-1948-nakba-discovered-in-jaffa/ ...this is obviously tragic, but it's called _war_. i wonder if you can guess what those graves would have been filled with if any of the numerous wars against israel had been successful. "972mag.com/stephen-hawkings-message-to-israeli-elites-the-occupation-has-a-price/70719/" ...yet another argument from authority. i wonder how hawkins would feel if he wore a yamaka in israel...being a genius in one area does not preclude you from saying really stupid things in other areas. what an incredible waste of my time...
Andrew Donnelly He destroyed nothing. The fact from where the palestinian name doesnt matter, that the european settlers are stealing the land from the natives.
@@RichardSchmitz12 Just look at the "Palestinian" flag. It is basically the Jordanian flag with the seven pointed Star taken off. Those liars didn't even have the ingenuity to create another flag of their own.
Recently, April, 2019, Jewish artifacts were discovered in the City of David, which prove the Jews held the land. There are Jewish Menorahs imprinted on many ruins, and some great pieces of direct evidence were discovered in digs, where they were going to build. The so called Palestinians moved into the land when the Romans kicked out the Jews & wanted to erase remembrance of Judaism. There is no historical Palestinian "anything", pottery or otherwise. Palestinians are from countries surrounding the land of Israel. There are no Palestinian people in the bible. The Bible says Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea. Jews, under discipline from God, have had a terrible time throughout their history, going into captivity due to disobedience to God. .
The only nation state to have ever existed in those lands was Israel, the rest were empire after empire dislocating people, trying to uproot Jewish people, trying forever to change the demographics of the land, they almost got, but the Jewish people back, fought for their right to the land and succeeded.
its wrong The Palestinians are attributed to many peoples who lived in the region before the Jews, the most important of whom are the Canaanites. The Jews (as the Torah says) came from Iraq, multiplied in Egypt, and occupied the land of Canaan until they were expelled from it. So what do the Jews have a right to the land after all this? As he said in the video, the name Palestine came from hatred towards the Jews, and therefore Palestinians are a name that was generalized to the peoples in the region. Therefore, it does not change anything What happened 3,000 years ago was an occupation of the land of the indigenous people (the Canaanites), and now the same thing is happening to them, but the difference is that they are now called (Palestinians). This is the same thing that happened to the people of the Mayan civilization, whom you called “Red Indians.”
@@QwertyQwerty-ex6xn - So, what does that all mean? People who MOVE IN are not allowed to defend themselves or to hate those who already live there? Maybe you don't know that our ancestors in the U.S. moved in and slaughtered Indians that lived here, even though it was self-defense sometimes or offensive attacks at other times. It doesn't matter, since these facts have reigned throughout history. It doesn't matter who is right or wrong. Are you under 15 or something? You sound like a newby that just learned something, and are trying to tell others about what you learned, AS IF nobody but you ever knew this! Hello?! Helllo?! Is anybody home up there??? .
@@david77james What I was saying is that the Palestinians are not a people that existed about 100 years ago, but rather they have a history and were present in this land before the Jews, and that you have no right to belittle them, and this is not a new matter, as many people speak as if history begins in the twelfth century. B.C.E. And you mislead people with your words Since the city of Jerusalem is a Canaanite city, it is attributed to the Palestinians because they are the descendants of the Canaanites, and everything related to the Canaanites is linked to the Palestinians. I did not say that no one knows this, but you seem to be hateful towards the Palestinians. It is not possible for this people to be merely a mixture of peoples who mixed together nearly a hundred years ago. This is stupidity.
@@QwertyQwerty-ex6xn - Got them querty little pants on, just a little too tight?? Why rant about something you can't change? As a believer, I believe that The God told the Jews to take the land, especially since the Philistines were even much worse than the ancient Jews. There is much in the bible about it. Besides, querty, many lands were taken by conquest, better quit eating so much, or go get some looser fitting panties, eh? It's too bad for those who lose their land, indeed, BUT the hard cold facts just allow for a violin to be played, while their lives, land & homes are destroyed & pillaged, by invaders. So, what do you want from me, a kith on da cheek? I'll pass. Shall we tip a few cold ones together? Yes/No, then just quit whining, cuz some of my ancestors were dispossessed of their land, & were pillaged, raped, etc. Lighten up querty, DON'T tighten up. Relax! Life is tough, ya know? .
Actually the link he supplied was terrible. The guy who authored the video said MUSLIMS drove out/massacred the Jews in the seventh century when in fact they let them back IN!
michardav first the link is good so stop looking for reasons to dislike it, the fact is that you don't know history, it fun to believe that the few people how were her pour the Jews a cup of tea and said there you had some trouble(Germany) but here is paradise. really?
For the billionth time, Palestine was just a Geographical expression - not an administrative unit. Israel is a nation in a region named by Romans Palestine or Syria-palestina. Just like Spain is a nation in the region of Iberia or Finland is a naation in the region of Scandinavia.
...actually, Finland is not in Scandinavia (Sweden, Denmark and Norway), I think you might be thinking of the Nordic Region (Scandinavia + Iceland and Finland (as well as the Faroe Islands, Åland and Greenland).
There are two words that are synonymous with palestinian nation; Phantom Nation. Phantom Nation: Inventing the "Palestinians" as the Obstacle to Peace - Read it.
Phon Xieng He never says that Israel is "the *only* country with free speech for everyone". He says that, between all the Arab countries, Iran, and Israel, only the latter has free speech. And it's true. (Unless you think Iran has free speech or can name an Arab country that has it.)
+Phon Xieng (MrMuaythai84) no, everyone have free speech. look for this: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Arab_members_of_the_Knesset it is a list of every arabic person in the israeli knesset (the israeli opposition)
Todah rabah for this video. When will people ever get it that "Palestine" was Latin for Philistine. The term was pejorative and was given by the Romans after the Jewish wars. Oh, btw, Jerusalem was also renamed Aelia Capitolina by the Romans, but somehow, that never stuck like Palestine. Also, Jews living under the British Mandate were also called, "Palestinians". It was not until 1964 when Yasser Arafat appropriated the name for his PLO, that the term became synonymous with Arabs living in this area. What's in a name? Everything.
About genetics: "About two-thirds of Israeli Arabs and Arabs in the territories and a similar proportion of Israeli Jews are the descendants of at least three common ancestors who lived in the Middle East in the Neolithic period. However, the Palestinian Arab clade includes two Arab modal haplotypes which are found at only very low frequency among Jews, reflecting divergence and/or large scale admixture from non-local populations to the Palestinians.[6" Note, genetic commonality principally derives from ancient times, the Neolithic period - aka, The Stone Age. Point being, that just as, say, the British and German show a much closer genetic relationship than Jews and Palestinians because at one time they were largely the same people, in terms of recorded history this is irrelevant. Long after their common ancestors separated from one another they became distinct peoples living in distinct areas speaking different languages. Neither Britain nor Germany has claims on the other because they share common ancient ancestors. And so it is with Jews and Palestinians. Direct ancestors of today's Jews established ancient Judea and Israel, going back 3,500 years ago. At that time direct ancestors of Palestinians were living largely in what is Saudi Arabia today. Hence, what is relevant is this: the Palestinians are, in their own words and that of fellow Arabs: * Hamas Minister Hammad: "Half of Palestinians are Egyptians, half Saudis" * Khalil Wazir: "Military action against Israel is necessary to fix Palestinian identity” * Zahir Muhsein of the Palestinian Nat Council: “The Palestinian people doesn't exist…Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak of a Palestinian people…to oppose Zionism” * Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi: "There's no such thing as a Palestinian people" (to British Peel Commission in 1937) * Saudi UN amb: “It's common knowledge that Palestine is Southern Syria” * King Abdullah: "Palestine and Transjordan are one” at Arab League meeting in Cairo, 12 April 1948 * Prime Minister of Jordan, Hazza’ al-Majali: "We are the government of Palestine, the army of Palestine and the refugees of Palestine,” Hazza’ al-Majali, 23 August 1959 * Walid Shoebat: "Why is it that on June 4th 1967 I was a Jordanian and overnight I became a Palestinian? We considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. Then all of the sudden we were Palestinians - they removed the star from the Jordanian flag and all at once we had a Palestinian flag.” Between 1932 and 1944 half a million Arabs moved to Palestine for the jobs Jews created. The UN partition plan of 1947 tacitly understood, giving "no consideration of Palestinian claims because Palestinian nationality had not yet been invented.”
Nope, means the Palestinians have been there since the Stone Age and some Arabs came later "Genetic analysis suggests that a majority of the Muslims of Palestine, inclusive of Arab citizens of Israel, are descendants of Christians, Jews and other earlier inhabitants of the southern Levant whose core may reach back to prehistoric times."
“Settlements” are legally Israel’s 1) There’s never been an Arab (or therefore Palestinian) state there to occupy. If the land is not legally occupied, construction on it cannot be illegal. 2) The West Bank is Israel’s under the still legal League of Nations Palestine Mandate. The British illegally gave it to Arabs in 1922, who then lost it to Israel when they coerced a war in 1967 to destroy Israel. 3) Arabs refused the 1922 League of Nations and 1948 UN partition plans, thus the land is legally disputed. 4) UN Resolution 242 provides for negotiation that leaves Israel with secure borders. Until that is negotiated, then Israel can legally possess this land. 5) Land lost in wars of aggression is not occupied - ask Germany. For context, five things should be understood. 1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states 2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100 3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs. 4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided. 5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution.
1) Nope, the UN considered it sovereign Jordanian soil. 2)The Mandate never said anything about a Jewish STATE. Nor did it say anything about a ALL of Palestine, in fact it specifically said IN Palestine. 3)Nope, has nothing to do with. Land acquired by force is illegal PERIOD. 4) UN 242 never transferred sovereignty, and again specifically stated land acquired by force is ILLEGAL. 5) Israel attacked Egypt, and attacked Jordan in 1966. Land can only be reacquired. Israel was not the previous sovereign. 1) Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish. 2) So? 3) Nope, all this fuss is about the right to control your own lives, without being suddenly forced into the street. 4) Been over this, completely false both history and science say otherwise. 5)Israel had no choice but to return the Sinai (which is NOT Palestine). Egypt was internationally accepted as the rightful sovereign. Carter knew Sadat would when at the ICC and Israel wouldn't get a thing- and still lose Sinai. Plus Israel was paid quite well in record aid packages. If Israel would stop taking land, there would be peace. For four years attacks in the West Bank went down- by NINETY per cent. In that time settler attacks increased by ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY PER CENT, settlements increased in record amounts and settlements that were illegal even according to Israeli court rulings, were retroactively legitimized to qualify for Knesset funding. Sure doesn't seem to me Israel wants peace. Why would they? They keep dragging their heels and just keep taking anyway. There is no incentive on their part to continue any peace process.
Palestine Mandate "ARTICLE 2. The Mandatory shall be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home, as laid down in the preamble, and the development of self governing institutions, and also for safeguarding the civil and religious rights of all the inhabitants of Palestine, irrespective of race and religion." So, a Jewish country in which minority rights are to be respected. Which, in any event, was superseded by UN Res 181: "Independent Arab and Jewish States…set forth in Part III of this Plan, shall come into existence in Palestine two months after the evacuation of the armed forces of the mandatory."
SailorSteve Nope, in fact the Mandate says " The Mandatory shall be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home" In words form a government FIRST then establish a Jewish home. Was UN 181 legally binding? Well I guess Israel should be relinquishing Galilee, ACre and Jerusalem don't you think?
Palestinians are descent of settlers from different regions except for Samaritans Here are some common "Palestinian" families and their place of origin: Saudi, Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Arabia Yamani, Azad - Yemen Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids) Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt (Bedouins) Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon Bushnak - Bosnia Khamis - Bahrain Afghani - Afghanistan Mughrabi - Maghreb Araj - Morocco Djazair - Algeria Kurd - Kurdistan Hindi - Indian Subcontinent Abid - Sudan We all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian in Gaza and throughout Palestine can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, Yemen or anywhere else." "... Half the Palestinians are (Arab) Egyptians and the other half are (Arab) Saudis" - Arab "Palestinian" Hamas minister Fathi Hammad, 2012. israel was reformed in 1948 the word Palestinian comes from Hebrew word peleshtim which means invaders it was a term used by jew to describe non-jews who live in the Jewish homeland even a Palestinian politician called Awni Al-Hadi said to the British empire "There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' was invented by the Zionists
This man has utterly destroyed the blabbering of two palestian women with nothing but politeness and respect. He is so beautifully badass I think I might cry.....
Name a famous Palestinian before the age of television. I can only think of one: Goliath. Killed by the Jewish king, King David, who went on to unite the kingdom and formally found the nation-state of Israel. Christianity and Islam regards him as one of the great prophets of their faith. Not a good starting point for Palestinian history.
The only problem with that is that whereas Native Americans call themselves that Palestinians call themselves Philistines in their own language. Even Yasser Arafat said as much before he died. If your statement is infallibly true, then the big looming question remains of when did the nation (not independence or statehood, which is a question for another time) of Palestine become established? As it is, most Palestinians in Gaza reflect more Egyptian culture and those in the West Bank have a more Syrian culture. Palestinian Arabs always wore fezzes as a mark of distinction before 1948, so was Palestinian culture destroyed by adopting the kyffia?
+naapalm82 Only problem is, the Palestinians have nothing to do whatsoever with the philistines. They weren't even Semitic and they vanished 2,700 years ago. The Romans renamed Judea after them, and the Palestinians adopted that name in the 20th century.The original name of the philistines is "Plishtim", it's a Hebrew biblical name meaning "to invade". In Arabic it's "filistine" since they don't have a P. it's not even an Arabic name. Should give you a clue as to who are the natives here.
Rome is the only one that have the right to this land, full stop. The israeli were banished because of their terrorist activities. Palestine7Israel should be given to todays's sole legal owners, that is Italy! No 2 state solution, just an italian colony. and Italian should be the only legal language.
JERUSALEM - A Palestinian man was found dead in his home in the West Bank town of Bir Zeit on Thursday after a standoff with Israeli forces that had come to arrest him, according to the Israeli military. The military said in a statement that the man, identified as Mutaz Washaha, 25, was “suspected of terror activity,” without elaborating. It added that the forces employed various means, including live fire, to complete the arrest, acting “under the premise that he had weapons in his possession.” The military said an assault rifle was later found in the house. There was no indication that Mr. Washaha had used it to fire at the Israeli forces.
He's right about the use of 'Palestine' as a name for an area rather than a nation. But that was only one small part of the rebuttal video. He still cannot rationally defend the expansion of Israel's settlements.
“Settlements” are legally Israel’s 1) There’s never been an Arab (or therefore Palestinian) state there to occupy. If the land is not legally occupied, construction on it cannot be illegal. 2) The West Bank is Israel’s under the still legal League of Nations Palestine Mandate. The British illegally gave it to Arabs in 1922, who then lost it to Israel when they coerced a war in 1967 to destroy Israel. 3) Arabs refused the 1922 League of Nations and 1948 UN partition plans, thus the land is legally disputed. 4) UN Resolution 242 provides for negotiation that leaves Israel with secure borders. Until that is negotiated, then Israel can legally possess this land. 5) Land lost in wars of aggression is not occupied - ask Germany. For context, five things should be understood. 1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states 2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100 3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs. 4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided. 5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution.
SailorSteve 1)Jordan was recognized as the sovereign nation of the West Bank. 2) Mandate of Palestine never said anything about a Jewish STATE. In fact it said the HOMELAND was to be IN Palestine. 3) The only enforceable legal decision about states after the Mandate was the MacDonald white paper- it stated that Palestine was to be a representational democracy by 1948. UN 181 was a suggestion, nothing more. 4) COMPLETELY FALSE. UN 242 recognized in the preamble that territory acquired by force is illegal. 5) Germany signed treaties, Israel did not. I note that Israel attacked Egypt in 1956, Jordan in 1954 and in 1966. attacked Syria when it had agreed to a ceasefire. "1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states" Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish. "2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100" So? Jews last governed the area over two thousand years ago...you're point? "3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs." Didn't think Jordan Valley was in Jerusalem- but you're kind of right. Israel keeps on increasing the suburbs of Jerusalem until it almost stretches to Jordan now. "4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided" Completely false. The Christian and Muslim population of Palestine in 1922 was 660,000- this was BEFORE the waves of Jewish immigration, of which was kept secret from the Palestinians- they had already been promised the land BEFORE the Balfour Declaration you see. By 1948 this number had climbed to about 1.1 million- WELL within natural means. "5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution." You're including the Sinai which had nothing to do with Palestine. Also Begin and Carter knew that is Sadat took his case before the ICC, Israel wouldn't have a chance. Instead Israel took the 15 BILLION buy out offered by the USA.
SailorSteve that is a pathetic argument that I have heard way too many times. The fact is, what matters in international law is international consensus and the according to the consensus the settlements are illegal whether you like it or not. It is a unique brand of messianic colonializm which has poisoned Israel's soul and helped to mak peace unachievable.
The jewish people also didn't have a home country since the first century. I would rather propose that what qualifies a population to have a country is a national sentiment, historical bonds with the land and international recognition, all of which the so called palestinians possess
The ending was actually really funny. Normally I'd say videos like that aren't worth the time taken to respond, but this was actually really well done.
"President Obama’s meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu came as Israeli government figures showed Israel initiated more than twice as many West Bank settlement homes last year than it did the previous year. Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics said construction began on more than 2,500 settlement housing units in 2013, compared to just more than 1,100 the year before. Last year’s number is the highest in a decade. In the West Bank’s Jordan Valley, Palestinian residents and local officials say Israel has demolished hundreds of homes. Ali Ka’abneh, Jordan Valley resident: "The Israeli occupation forces came here on the 29th. They came in the morning, of course, while we were sleeping, at 6:30 with their bulldozers and their soldiers. They gave us 10 minutes to leave the buildings we lived in, and then they demolished them all at once, without any warning at all." Arif Daraghmeh, head of Al-Maleh Council: "The occupation has demolished more than 500 structures in the past year alone in this area, and now the Israeli army and occupation is carrying out all these policies in order to pressure the people and drive them out. They have demolished these tents and driven out the inhabitants, and they plan to have exercises in this area and to build more settlements and military camps." Why negotiate when the world will sit back an let you take everything?!
James Potter Not just that all his ideas and style of writing itsself was directly stolen from someone who commented pro-Israel. His pic is an imitation and he is a Muslim.
harold kramer"Not just that all his ideas and style of writing itsself was directly stolen from someone who commented pro-Israel. His pic is an imitation and he is a Muslim." hmm an what led you to believe that?
@Diane Monahan so you would think after years of persecution, they wouldn't do it themselves. But glad to see you support a right of return for people that have been driven from their homes
There's no unique Palestinian language, no unique Palestinian cuisine, no unique Palestinian flag, no unique Palestinian culture, no historical evidence of anything Palestinian, neither does the name Palestine written in the Bible or the Gospels not even in the Qur'an. So just as it was a foreign name given by a foreigner it should be treated as such, FOREIGN. So if it foreign then it should be left in the history books or better still to be discarded.
Occurred in October 1953 when Israeli troops under Ariel Sharon attacked the village of Qibya in the West Bank. Sixty-nine Arabs were killed. Forty-five houses, a school, and a mosque were destroyed
"Funerals were held in the occupied West Bank over the weekend for two Palestinians shot dead during the annual Nakba Day protest. The father of 17-year-old Nadim Nuwara called on Israel to try his son’s killer in court."
@Diane Monahan I didn't say funeral, I said tomb or gravesite if you will. I thought you were against people that massacre innocents and those that celebrate them?
@Diane Monahan I'm against all deaths too, and specifically against the Hamas terrorism. I hear you say your against deaths, but you still haven't spoken out against those who regularly visit Goldstein's grave to honour him, which was my point.
As Pierre Orts, chairman of Mandate Commission of the League Of Nations, said that under the mandate, Article 7, obliged Mandatory to enact a nationality law, which again showed Palestinians formed a nation, & that Palestine was a State, though provisionally under guardianship."Palestinian".
The founder of the Arab League created on the desroyed Turkish Empire said this: An October 11, 1947 report on the pan-Arab summit in the Lebanese town of Aley in Egypt's largest paper that day (translated by Efraim Karsh; all ellipses are in the original text): Abdul Rahman Azzam Pasha spoke to me about the horrific war that would happen in the coming months… proclaiming: "I personally wish that the Jews do not drive us to this war, and surrender as I promise this to be a war of extermination and momentous massacre which will be spoken of like the Tatar massacre or the Crusader wars. I believe that the number of volunteers from outside Palestine will be larger than Palestine's Arab population, for I know that volunteers will be arriving to us from [as far as] India, Afghanistan, and China to win the honor of martyrdom for the sake of Palestine … You might be surprised to learn that hundreds of Englishmen, and other Europeans expressed their strong wish to volunteer in the Arab armies to fight the Jews. "This war will be distinguished by three serious matters. First-faith: as each fighter deems his death on behalf of the Ummah of Palestine as the shortest road to paradise; second, [the war] will be an opportunity for vast plunder. Third, it will be impossible to contain the zealous volunteers arriving from all corners of the world to reek vengeance for the martyrs of the Palestine Arabs, and viewing the war as dignifying every Arab and every Muslim throughout the world … "The Arab is superior to the Jew in that he accepts defeat with a smile: Should the Jews defeat us in the first battle, we will defeat them in the second or the third battle … or the final one… whereas one defeat will shatter the Jew's morale! Most desert Arabians take pleasure in fighting. I recall being tasked with mediating a truce in a desert war (in which I participated) that lasted for nine months…While en route to sign the truce, I was approached by some of my comrades in arms who told me: 'Shame on you! You are a man of the people, so how could you wish to end the war … How can we live without war?' This is because war gives the Bedouin a sense of happiness, bliss, and security that peace does not provide! … He [Azzam] ended his conversation with me by saying: "I foresee the consequences of this bloody war. I see before me its horrible battles. I can picture its dead, injured, and victims … But my conscience is clear … For we are not attacking but defending ourselves, and we are not aggressors but defenders against an aggression! …"
This would only fool people who don't know basic history or understand nationalities at all. For one, not being sovereign does NOT mean that Palestine did not exist, or that Palestinians did not exist. As ANYONE who knows anything about nations knows- a nation does NOT create a people, but a people create a nation! Did Americans not exist before American independence? Did Angolans, or Syrians, or Congolese not exist before independence? Who thinks like that? A people create a nation, a nation does NOT create a people. And what about Israel? A nations who's language was spoken today was created in Eastern Europe and is considered more Slavic than Semitic by many language experts. Or that the founders of modern Israel were largely European Jews who all of a sudden became "Israelis." And as someone who knows MANY Palestinian Christians from Bethlehem, Nazareth, Ramallah, etc- not a single one I have ever met has ever said they felt oppressed by Palestinian Muslims Lets be honest here- Israel created millions of Palestinian refugees, many of them Christian. Bethlehem was NOT 60% Christian in 1990. The TRUTH is that it was about 50%, and is today about 40% Christian. The loss was do to the Palestinian uprising, which led to poor security conditions, and an economy in complete shambles do to Israeli restrictions on Palestinian movement and the overall economy. Not because of any Palestinian Muslim. In fact, only 3% of Palestinian Christians stated that they were immigrating because of "Muslims." The rest blamed Israel's brutal treatment of Palestinians. Everyone should watch the 60 Minutes documentary on Palestinian Christians and see what THEY had to say about these false accusations of Muslims harassing them. They ONLY blamed Israel and Michael Oren, Israel's Ambassador to the US, tried having the documentary BLOCKED from American television because he knew that American Christians wouldn't like what Palestinian Christians had to say about Israel. Danny is merely trying to mask the Palestinian Christian voice. PS- those "headlines" Danny posted don't even have any source listed when you look them up. If Danny loves Palestinian Christians so much- allow all Palestinian Christian refugees to return to their homes! Oh wait, you don't love them THAT much- you just like using them as pawns to make the conflict seem likes its poor little Israel against the big bad Muslims *rolls eyes*. Before 9/11 you never heard Israel talk about "persecuted" Palestinian Christians.
Lol who is more righteous hanan ashrawi or walid shoebat? I remember hanan's quote when she said mizrahi jews were not refugees. dude , did she even hear about the farhud?
***** Hana clearly is more righteous! Walid Shoebat was exposed as a fake and a fraud years ago, which is why he hardly does any lectures these days. Even the Jerusalem Post noted his bold contradictions. LOOOL look at his website these days- it says he was an ex "Muslim Brotherhood" member. Two years ago it said he was an ex PLO member. Neither ended up being true.
The simple fact is that Jews lived in Palestine long before the modern state of Israel was formed. The Ottoman Empire first began allowing Jews to settle there in 1844.
Danny totally took those two ladies to school. At least they were not forced to wear the hijab like they would in Gaza and most Arab countries. They may be dumb but at least they are free.
Over the past century, the percentage of Christian Palestinians has been in decline. The influx of Jewish immigrants since the late 1880s, the Nakba of 1948 and the expulsions of 1967 played a big role in diminishing the presence of Palestinian Christians
Black people have also never been a nation. This was still not a good justification for the Apartheid in South Africa. And the historical Israel never existed in that way what you think today it might have looked like.
I could write a book on how comparing Israel to Apartheid South Africa is ludicrous, dishonest, and affronting to all parties involved, but that would probably be futile in educating you as well as insensitive to the seriousness of both issues. So I'm just going to settle for calling you an idiot. You idiot.
The other thing about the words "Palestine" and "Palestinian" is that they were words used by the Romans to call the area belonging to the "Philistines." The word "Palestine" is, in essence, from a Greek word meaning "the land of the Philistines," who weren't even indigenous people to Israel in the FIRST place. There were, originally, transplanted Greeks (one of the original Greek tribes who were pushed out by invaders from the north) and who settled in Canaan between 1300 and 1200 B.C.E. AND, by the days of the Romans, the Philistines no longer existed in the first place! So, there is NO way that modern "Palestinians" descended from the Philistines! For them to call themselves "Palestinian" they are calling themselves "Philistines" and do not even know it.
SailorSteve 1)Jordan was recognized as the sovereign nation of the West Bank. 2) Mandate of Palestine never said anything about a Jewish STATE. In fact it said the HOMELAND was to be IN Palestine. 3) The only enforceable legal decision about states after the Mandate was the MacDonald white paper- it stated that Palestine was to be a representational democracy by 1948. UN 181 was a suggestion, nothing more. 4) COMPLETELY FALSE. UN 242 recognized in the preamble that territory acquired by force is illegal. 5) Germany signed treaties, Israel did not. I note that Israel attacked Egypt in 1956, Jordan in 1954 and in 1966. attacked Syria when it had agreed to a ceasefire. "1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states" Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish. "2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100" So? Jews last governed the area over two thousand years ago...you're point? "3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs." Didn't think Jordan Valley was in Jerusalem- but you're kind of right. Israel keeps on increasing the suburbs of Jerusalem until it almost stretches to Jordan now. "4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided" Completely false. The Christian and Muslim population of Palestine in 1922 was 660,000- this was BEFORE the waves of Jewish immigration, of which was kept secret from the Palestinians- they had already been promised the land BEFORE the Balfour Declaration you see. By 1948 this number had climbed to about 1.1 million- WELL within natural means. "5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution." You're including the Sinai which had nothing to do with Palestine. Also Begin and Carter knew that is Sadat took his case before the ICC, Israel wouldn't have a chance. Instead Israel took the 15 BILLION buy out offered by the USA.
Those young women sent to refute your discourse on Palestine were pathetic. They had more smiles and cutesy one-liners than historical content. Their video was obviously directed at the young, hedging a bet that historic episodes such as the Munich Olympics, The founding of the PLO, the Palestinian Mufti's alliance with Adolf Hitler, and the anti-Jewish massacres that took place in the Levant as soon as the Ottomans pulled out (long before modern Israel) are all forgotten memories. I for one would respect the Palestinian Arabs more if their public relations were more honest and in line with their fighters. Instead of playing the victim and trying to mislead media and censor history, they should simply explain that they would rather fight than live in peace. Those girls who tried to refute you should wear less clothes next time. It would lend entertainment value to what is otherwise obvious manipulation.
Although that dialogue would be impossible, as any definition of who is and isn't a hard-liner would be inherently flawed. Let some moderates come in and talk over them, perhaps, but don't ever say that one side is any better or worse than the other, or if you do then you do so at your own peril.
i see it this way: I Have a house with a garden. Some people move to my garden and claim it's now theirs, because 1000 years ago some ancesters of theirs lived there. Im pissed and ask em to go away - they won't and start a war, wich they win. They tell me my garden and my house are now theirs and i can move to my garage if i like. I have no choice and move to my garage. Now they move settlers into the garage because they need more space. And again i can't do sh.. Thats how the situation in Palstine/Isreal is, and it's wrong. I have no solution for the problem - but it's just wrong how Palestinian people and Israelis threat each other.
Thank you - I love your truth-revealing videos! Lately I read (Arutz Sheva? Times of Israel? United with Israel?), that leading politicians and other time witnesses wondered about the massive immigration and settlement of arabs (Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, ...) into "Palestine" (they can't even speak a "P" and use "F" instead) in the 1920ies. I think it's worse a research because it was waste land before, just like Mark Twain said inthe 1860ies. L'Shalom B'Yisrael
Judea and Galilee were two separate states and political entities, as illustrated on the map of Palestine in the time of Jesus in the Bible. Jesus Himself was not a Jew (Judean) or resident of Judea, He was a Galilean or resident of Galilee. Jesus grew up in Nazareth in Galilee.
so if Palestine referred to a region including parts of modern-day Syria, Lebanon and Jordan, then why aren't the Palestinians asking for territory in those countries?
Because they know that if they riot - there will be no more people to claim they are "palastiniens" - aka they will get shot instantly even if they rise a white flag.
Why there are "palastinians" in jordan? or syria? :)
Simple reason. Because they want to destroy Israel and not build their lives.
@People, Unite! And ironically, they themselves are Semitic af, like those Jews they hate!!
@People, Unite! That's the connotation these days but the denotation for Semite was always intended as the larger diaspora of Semitic Peoples (including Arabs, Assyrians, etc, etc...) and NOT just The Jews as it's commonly referred to these days by layman and ignorant Media members.
Palestine does not exist
I like these kind of argument videos, they are so much better than the beheadings committed by Hamas.
Hey there, @Basic, care to provide some proof for your keyboard diarrhea?
Of course he can't.
I'm sure they were legit Basic.
Basic Mistakes happen. When attacking enemies who throw rocks daily, it's not easy to be 100% accurate. This was not on purpuse.
Basic I see no proof. I see one link and I responded to it. Plus you have no proof that it's intentional, and claiming it was is literally stupid.
Before the ancient Rome existed, Israel was a kingdom on that piece of land
Before the ancient Greece, Israel was having royal lineage, king and queens
3500 years of Archeology of ancient written language and cultural artifacts
And yes, Kids without basic knowledge of history don't need to comment
Eden Havaov lol fantasies
@@02Nawal you should visit the Jewish museum in Jerusalem and eat your heart up .
@@PhysicsViolator I wouldn't waste my money. I have better things to do than visit that boring place.
@@02Nawal lol ignorant
@the red tiger you're a disgrace to humanity and its a shame your mother hasn't told you who your biological father is 🤣. Go apologize to the tree that's producing oxygen for you. Troll!
AWESOME rebuttal Danny!!!!!!! Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah! God bless you my friend!
how can god bless a liar????
Hell will be his only resting place unless he really tells the truth about innocent lives being persecuted by his own government/regime
He is telling the truth!!!!!
truth can be what you decide to tell when it suits you but what about the whole truth about what is really going on in Palestine and the Gazans.. will you condemn yourself to eternal damnation for the lies and atrocities you will make on this subject?? do you really believe that your god will forgive you for what has happened to the innocent men, women and children of Palestine while you spread the lies of a nation that is committed to the destruction of Palestine
Billy Lopez No Billy: Truth is based on facts, not opinions
@@MrBillylopez80 I've seen 4 clips of the IDF "harming" Arab Israelis (what you call Palestinians).
AMAZING !!!!!!! WELL DONE !! rebutting her false stammerer "claims" professionaly and honestly
***** - that's your opinion.
*****
again that's YOUR opinion -
the fact that you are very uninformed about stuff doesn't mean your opinion is rational
it's just your opinion.
No dear - facts in case i need to spell it out for you - is what is REALLY going in reality which you can back up with proves - opinions are those things you are trying to sell
SimsMoyal i don't think there is a single thing in this world that can backs you up as prove. read the books, that will help you find the real truth behind all of this. don't be an ignorant person please :)
Abdullah md LOL
You should really try stand up - you are sooo funny!!
common sense, basic history, and needed today in this era of Arab propaganda...
Arab propaganda in an Arab world..oh the audacity!
Oh my gosh! Danny said exactly what I was thinking when I watched their rebuttal vid. The whole situation is so sad. So much hate for the Jews.
The UN gave that land to Israel in 1948. In fact, they planned to give them most of Jordan too, but Israel agreed that that would cause too much conflict. Israel did not "steal" a thing. Arabs declared war on Israel, not the other way around, in spite of the fact that Palestine was not, and never has been a nation. That is a fact, not subjective in any form. Need I remind everyone that on top of that nugget of truth, the Jews had a genocide committed against them? Dead civilians are truly a tragedy and no one, Israel chief among them, wants that. So maybe you should call Hamas and tell them to stop hiding their rockets cites in playgrounds and UN clinics. So Please don't speak self righteously about who the real victims are when frankly, you have not even done a modicum of research on the history of the conflict. Thanks.
UN did not give them "other's land." The UN gave Jews, Jewish land. There was no country there when League of Nations Proposed Israeli state. Land was occupied by former Ottoman Empire citizens. The Ottomans were beaten by allies (British) and the Brits merely named land confiscated as "Palestine", but it was not a country and was slated to be Jewish state. So I'm sorry, but the Palestinians have no "right" to the land as it was not theirs to begin with. They were offered countless times to split land in two and have two states, one Jewish and one Palestinian, and they have rejected every last one of those proposals. They use terrorism and indiscriminate rocket attacks while Israel takes every opportunity to warn civilians of impending strikes on missile batteries positioned in public spaces. I cannot support terrorism. I must side with Israel who supports women's rights, Arab judges, democracy, impartial courts, and religious freedom. Jews DO live in peace with Arabs IN ISRAEL. There are over one million Arab citizens of Israel, so.... yeah.
Jaasau my jewish friend, i hope my brothers and i from isis will one day come to your jewish friends and tell them something..
ShadowLegendxxx
I'm not Jewish, but i am heavily armed, so...good luck with that.
*****
I am somewhat familiar with how Mohammed helped jews. But it did not last forever. Additionally, it was Ottoman land, then British land, and the Brit's gave it to Israel. It was not until after the holocaust that that finally took shape. In 47 UN proposed a partition giving the land 50/50 to indigenous Jordanians and indigenous and foreign Jews. It was not Palestinian land. It was not stolen. If military conquest by a provoked nation (britain) is a definition of theft, then almost every nation in the entire world has been "stolen" and must be given up.
Why not move all the 'Palestinians' to Arab countries?
They can't because of the UN and Arab countries prohibiting them from entering... dang it
houdini2233
The Jews based their religion in Israel, not in Europe. The conflict that lasted 70 years because the colonizers (Arabs) do not want the Jews to return to their home.
houdini2233
"The Arabs are not colonisers"
Started from Mecca, where a pedophile Jew has made his own faith called Islam, then made an empire, reaching from Spain to India. And look at today. How is that not colonization?
houdini2233 we're not scared of you, we're scared of what our weak-kneed politicians are going to give into next.
houdini2233
_"__jpupdates.com/2014/04/24/fatah-official-pa-hamas-unity-govt-will-recognize-israels-existence/...__“The reconciliation with Hamas is founded on the two-state solution within the 1967 borders"_
you must believe everything people tell you...are they not capable of political lies? here's what they actually still say:
Article 6 Hamas is uniquely Palestinian, and "strives to raise the banner of Allah over _every inch of Palestine_".
Article 8 The Hamas document reiterates the Muslim Brotherhood's slogan of "Allah is its goal, the Prophet is the model, the Qur'an its constitution, jihad its path, and _death for the sake of Allah_ its most sublime belief."
Article 11 Palestine is sacred (waqf) for all Muslims _for all time, and it cannot be relinquished by anyone._
Article 13 _There is no negotiated settlement possible. Jihad is the only answer._
Article 15 "The day that enemies usurp part of Muslim land, Jihad becomes the individual duty of every Muslim". It states the history of crusades into Muslim lands and says the _"Palestinian problem is a religious problem"._
avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp
_Heres another_
news.antiwar.com/2014/04/24/report-palestinian-unity-means-hamas-will-recognize-israel/
...and? is this _just_ an argument from authority? until hammas repudiates its charter Netanyahu is not only justified in dismissing them, but is rationally obligated to.
_"Heres some more reading for you"_
www.intifada-palestine.com/2013/05/mass-graves-of-palestinians-killed-in-1948-nakba-discovered-in-jaffa/
...this is obviously tragic, but it's called _war_. i wonder if you can guess what those graves would have been filled with if any of the numerous wars against israel had been successful.
"972mag.com/stephen-hawkings-message-to-israeli-elites-the-occupation-has-a-price/70719/"
...yet another argument from authority. i wonder how hawkins would feel if he wore a yamaka in israel...being a genius in one area does not preclude you from saying really stupid things in other areas.
what an incredible waste of my time...
houdini2233 yup i'm as extreme as you get when it comes to countering anti-semitism and advocating the truth.
Danny destroyed her with this video, its funny how she hasnt made another video since then
Andrew Donnelly He destroyed nothing. The fact from where the palestinian name doesnt matter, that the european settlers are stealing the land from the natives.
abdullah99Islam The natives are the Jews. The Palestinians are the descendants of the Islamic occupation.
abdullah99Islam what natives? Syrians jordanians? Egyptians ? Your lies are exposed muslim . Stop pretending
@@RichardSchmitz12 Just look at the "Palestinian" flag. It is basically the Jordanian flag with the seven pointed Star taken off. Those liars didn't even have the ingenuity to create another flag of their own.
Although its not hard to rebuke idiots, the challenge is to get the audience to listen.
Well done!!!
Recently, April, 2019, Jewish artifacts were discovered in the City of David, which prove the Jews held the land. There are Jewish Menorahs imprinted on many ruins, and some great pieces of direct evidence were discovered in digs, where they were going to build. The so called Palestinians moved into the land when the Romans kicked out the Jews & wanted to erase remembrance of Judaism.
There is no historical Palestinian "anything", pottery or otherwise. Palestinians are from countries surrounding the land of Israel. There are no Palestinian people in the bible. The Bible says Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea. Jews, under discipline from God, have had a terrible time throughout their history, going into captivity due to disobedience to God.
.
The only nation state to have ever existed in those lands was Israel, the rest were empire after empire dislocating people, trying to uproot Jewish people, trying forever to change the demographics of the land, they almost got, but the Jewish people back, fought for their right to the land and succeeded.
its wrong
The Palestinians are attributed to many peoples who lived in the region before the Jews, the most important of whom are the Canaanites. The Jews (as the Torah says) came from Iraq, multiplied in Egypt, and occupied the land of Canaan until they were expelled from it.
So what do the Jews have a right to the land after all this?
As he said in the video, the name Palestine came from hatred towards the Jews, and therefore Palestinians are a name that was generalized to the peoples in the region.
Therefore, it does not change anything
What happened 3,000 years ago was an occupation of the land of the indigenous people (the Canaanites), and now the same thing is happening to them, but the difference is that they are now called (Palestinians). This is the same thing that happened to the people of the Mayan civilization, whom you called “Red Indians.”
@@QwertyQwerty-ex6xn - So, what does that all mean? People who MOVE IN are not allowed to defend themselves or to
hate those who already live there?
Maybe you don't know that our ancestors in the U.S. moved in and slaughtered Indians that lived here, even though it was self-defense sometimes or offensive attacks at other times. It doesn't matter, since these facts have reigned throughout history. It doesn't matter who is right or wrong.
Are you under 15 or something? You sound like a newby that just learned something, and are trying to tell others about what you learned, AS IF nobody but you ever knew this! Hello?! Helllo?! Is anybody home up there???
.
@@david77james What I was saying is that the Palestinians are not a people that existed about 100 years ago, but rather they have a history and were present in this land before the Jews, and that you have no right to belittle them, and this is not a new matter, as many people speak as if history begins in the twelfth century. B.C.E.
And you mislead people with your words
Since the city of Jerusalem is a Canaanite city, it is attributed to the Palestinians because they are the descendants of the Canaanites, and everything related to the Canaanites is linked to the Palestinians.
I did not say that no one knows this, but you seem to be hateful towards the Palestinians. It is not possible for this people to be merely a mixture of peoples who mixed together nearly a hundred years ago. This is stupidity.
@@QwertyQwerty-ex6xn - Got them querty little pants on, just a little too tight?? Why rant about something you can't change? As a believer, I believe that The God told the Jews to take the land, especially since the Philistines were even much worse than the ancient Jews. There is much in the bible about it.
Besides, querty, many lands were taken by conquest, better quit eating so much, or go get some looser fitting panties, eh? It's too bad for those who lose their land, indeed, BUT the hard cold facts just allow for a violin to be played, while their lives, land & homes are destroyed & pillaged, by invaders.
So, what do you want from me, a kith on da cheek? I'll pass. Shall we tip a few cold ones together? Yes/No, then just quit whining, cuz some of my ancestors were dispossessed of their land, & were pillaged, raped, etc. Lighten up querty, DON'T tighten up. Relax! Life is tough, ya know?
.
Well done Danny!
i love this guy. this is a video battle Israel-1 Palestinian-0
it's not about who's winner , it's about how to fake the history .
ahmed shahwan come on, don't be a sour loser
ahmed shahwan and who is faking history?
Actually the link he supplied was terrible. The guy who authored the video said MUSLIMS drove out/massacred the Jews in the seventh century when in fact they let them back IN!
michardav first the link is good so stop looking for reasons to dislike it, the fact is that you don't know history, it fun to believe that the few people how were her pour the Jews a cup of tea and said there you had some trouble(Germany) but here is paradise. really?
I hope the smug "Palestinian" girls listen and learn. Great video.
For the billionth time, Palestine was just a Geographical expression - not an administrative unit. Israel is a nation in a region named by Romans Palestine or Syria-palestina. Just like Spain is a nation in the region of Iberia or Finland is a naation in the region of Scandinavia.
...actually, Finland is not in Scandinavia (Sweden, Denmark and Norway), I think you might be thinking of the Nordic Region (Scandinavia + Iceland and Finland (as well as the Faroe Islands, Åland and Greenland).
That Palestinian propaganda video made me cringe so hard
Especially with her bitchy attitude and awful, condescending attempt to do an Israeli accent.
+Ahmed Ak Name a single lie in the video. I dare you.
Its called Al Teqiyya. They really believe their lies.
@@fivishproof?
This...is...brutal XD
I fucking love Danny.
Danny I applaud you. you put it the best way possible!! Keep up the awsome way!
bless ISRAEL from panama
No such country as Palestine. Never has been, never will be.
BUUUUUURN!!!!
Your comment is soooo! I just love it! XDDDDD
Eli P.
;)
indeed. danny summed up an international proble in 3 minutes
Excellent, why isn't this taught in schools today?
There are two words that are synonymous with palestinian nation; Phantom Nation. Phantom Nation: Inventing the "Palestinians" as the Obstacle to Peace - Read it.
Wooooooow that video made the girls video to a pile of shit . Great rebbutal Mr.Ayalon
Tropicadero Didn't take much.:)
+Tropicadero this channel is pile of shit to he say israel only country with free speech. yeah if you are a jews
oh yeah and the so called Palestinian has free speech for everyone right?
Phon Xieng He never says that Israel is "the *only* country with free speech for everyone". He says that, between all the Arab countries, Iran, and Israel, only the latter has free speech. And it's true. (Unless you think Iran has free speech or can name an Arab country that has it.)
+Phon Xieng (MrMuaythai84) no, everyone have free speech.
look for this:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Arab_members_of_the_Knesset
it is a list of every arabic person in the israeli knesset (the israeli opposition)
Todah rabah for this video. When will people ever get it that "Palestine" was Latin for Philistine. The term was pejorative and was given by the Romans after the Jewish wars. Oh, btw, Jerusalem was also renamed Aelia Capitolina by the Romans, but somehow, that never stuck like Palestine. Also, Jews living under the British Mandate were also called, "Palestinians". It was not until 1964 when Yasser Arafat appropriated the name for his PLO, that the term became synonymous with Arabs living in this area. What's in a name? Everything.
Always great to see people calling these lies out. Good on you Danny, we salute you!
Long Live The House Of David
Most probably the dissidents of the real house of David are among some old Palestinian families that you are prosecuting now.
I prosecuting no one. For I love all men weather they love me or not.
Great rebuttal Mr. Ayalon!
Nice debunking there
God Bless Israel as a Christian we offer all support and resources necessary. Time to rebuild the third temple!!
Long live Israel!
calling Judea and Samaria "West Bank" is like calling Poland "General Government"
Danny Ayalon is my favourite Jew.
This guy is amazing. Keep up the good work!
Finally! I was waiting for this so long.
And nice editing! "Would you make a clip about that" lololol :D
They can't name one, because 'palestine' never existed, and continues to not exist.
Well said, well said.
Isn’t it ironic that “the Middle East’s only democracy” has a lower democracy rating than Tunisia?
Great to get the truth instead of the lies and propaganda served up by the duped.
+Alistair McIver if you take this has the truth then god help u
@@PhysicsViolator you watching a youtube video and thinking its the truth show what kind moron you are
About genetics:
"About two-thirds of Israeli Arabs and Arabs in the territories and a similar proportion of Israeli Jews are the descendants of at least three common ancestors who lived in the Middle East in the Neolithic period. However, the Palestinian Arab clade includes two Arab modal haplotypes which are found at only very low frequency among Jews, reflecting divergence and/or large scale admixture from non-local populations to the Palestinians.[6"
Note, genetic commonality principally derives from ancient times, the Neolithic period - aka, The Stone Age.
Point being, that just as, say, the British and German show a much closer genetic relationship than Jews and Palestinians because at one time they were largely the same people, in terms of recorded history this is irrelevant. Long after their common ancestors separated from one another they became distinct peoples living in distinct areas speaking different languages. Neither Britain nor Germany has claims on the other because they share common ancient ancestors.
And so it is with Jews and Palestinians. Direct ancestors of today's Jews established ancient Judea and Israel, going back 3,500 years ago. At that time direct ancestors of Palestinians were living largely in what is Saudi Arabia today.
Hence, what is relevant is this: the Palestinians are, in their own words and that of fellow Arabs:
* Hamas Minister Hammad: "Half of Palestinians are Egyptians, half Saudis"
* Khalil Wazir: "Military action against Israel is necessary to fix Palestinian identity”
* Zahir Muhsein of the Palestinian Nat Council: “The Palestinian people doesn't exist…Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak of a Palestinian people…to oppose Zionism”
* Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi: "There's no such thing as a Palestinian people" (to British Peel Commission in 1937)
* Saudi UN amb: “It's common knowledge that Palestine is Southern Syria”
* King Abdullah: "Palestine and Transjordan are one” at Arab League meeting in Cairo, 12 April 1948
* Prime Minister of Jordan, Hazza’ al-Majali: "We are the government of Palestine, the army of Palestine and the refugees of Palestine,” Hazza’ al-Majali, 23 August 1959
* Walid Shoebat: "Why is it that on June 4th 1967 I was a Jordanian and overnight I became a Palestinian? We considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. Then all of the sudden we were Palestinians - they removed the star from the Jordanian flag and all at once we had a Palestinian flag.”
Between 1932 and 1944 half a million Arabs moved to Palestine for the jobs Jews created. The UN partition plan of 1947 tacitly understood, giving "no consideration of Palestinian claims because Palestinian nationality had not yet been invented.”
Nope, means the Palestinians have been there since the Stone Age and some Arabs came later "Genetic analysis suggests that a majority of the Muslims of Palestine, inclusive of Arab citizens of Israel, are descendants of Christians, Jews and other earlier inhabitants of the southern Levant whose core may reach back to prehistoric times."
“Settlements” are legally Israel’s
1) There’s never been an Arab (or therefore Palestinian) state there to occupy. If the land is not legally occupied, construction on it cannot be illegal.
2) The West Bank is Israel’s under the still legal League of Nations Palestine Mandate. The British illegally gave it to Arabs in 1922, who then lost it to Israel when they coerced a war in 1967 to destroy Israel.
3) Arabs refused the 1922 League of Nations and 1948 UN partition plans, thus the land is legally disputed.
4) UN Resolution 242 provides for negotiation that leaves Israel with secure borders. Until that is negotiated, then Israel can legally possess this land.
5) Land lost in wars of aggression is not occupied - ask Germany.
For context, five things should be understood.
1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states
2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100
3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs.
4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided.
5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution.
1) Nope, the UN considered it sovereign Jordanian soil.
2)The Mandate never said anything about a Jewish STATE. Nor did it say anything about a ALL of Palestine, in fact it specifically said IN Palestine.
3)Nope, has nothing to do with. Land acquired by force is illegal PERIOD.
4) UN 242 never transferred sovereignty, and again specifically stated land acquired by force is ILLEGAL.
5) Israel attacked Egypt, and attacked Jordan in 1966. Land can only be reacquired. Israel was not the previous sovereign.
1) Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish.
2) So?
3) Nope, all this fuss is about the right to control your own lives, without being suddenly forced into the street.
4) Been over this, completely false both history and science say otherwise.
5)Israel had no choice but to return the Sinai (which is NOT Palestine). Egypt was internationally accepted as the rightful sovereign. Carter knew Sadat would when at the ICC and Israel wouldn't get a thing- and still lose Sinai. Plus Israel was paid quite well in record aid packages. If Israel would stop taking land, there would be peace. For four years attacks in the West Bank went down- by NINETY per cent. In that time settler attacks increased by ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY PER CENT, settlements increased in record amounts and settlements that were illegal even according to Israeli court rulings, were retroactively legitimized to qualify for Knesset funding.
Sure doesn't seem to me Israel wants peace. Why would they? They keep dragging their heels and just keep taking anyway. There is no incentive on their part to continue any peace process.
Palestine Mandate
"ARTICLE 2. The Mandatory shall be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home, as laid down in the preamble, and the development of self governing institutions, and also for safeguarding the civil and religious rights of all the inhabitants of Palestine, irrespective of race and religion."
So, a Jewish country in which minority rights are to be respected.
Which, in any event, was superseded by UN Res 181: "Independent Arab and Jewish States…set forth in Part III of this Plan, shall come into existence in Palestine two months after the evacuation of the armed forces of the mandatory."
SailorSteve Nope, in fact the Mandate says " The Mandatory shall be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home" In words form a government FIRST then establish a Jewish home.
Was UN 181 legally binding? Well I guess Israel should be relinquishing Galilee, ACre and Jerusalem don't you think?
@@michardav1248 wow. Thanks for info. So more to know whos home were destroyed and stolen.
@Rodan The Fire Demon funny because I quoted the Balfour Declaration. Haven't YOU read it?
Palestinians are descent of settlers from different regions except for Samaritans
Here are some common "Palestinian" families and their place of origin:
Saudi, Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Arabia
Yamani, Azad - Yemen
Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids)
Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt
Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt (Bedouins)
Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey
Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq
Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria
Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon
Bushnak - Bosnia
Khamis - Bahrain
Afghani - Afghanistan
Mughrabi - Maghreb
Araj - Morocco
Djazair - Algeria
Kurd - Kurdistan
Hindi - Indian Subcontinent
Abid - Sudan
We all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian in Gaza and throughout Palestine can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, Yemen or anywhere else." "... Half the Palestinians are (Arab) Egyptians and the other half are (Arab) Saudis" - Arab "Palestinian" Hamas minister Fathi Hammad, 2012.
israel was reformed in 1948
the word Palestinian comes from Hebrew word peleshtim which means invaders
it was a term used by jew to describe non-jews who live in the Jewish homeland
even a Palestinian politician called Awni Al-Hadi said to the British empire
"There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' was invented by the Zionists
Maghreb means Morocco
I had to retweet this Danny. We should do a follow up of those very young children being
indoctrinated to hate the Jewish people. Where are they ?
This man has utterly destroyed the blabbering of two palestian women with nothing but politeness and respect.
He is so beautifully badass I think I might cry.....
Name a famous Palestinian before the age of television. I can only think of one: Goliath. Killed by the Jewish king, King David, who went on to unite the kingdom and formally found the nation-state of Israel. Christianity and Islam regards him as one of the great prophets of their faith. Not a good starting point for Palestinian history.
The only problem with that is that whereas Native Americans call themselves that Palestinians call themselves Philistines in their own language. Even Yasser Arafat said as much before he died. If your statement is infallibly true, then the big looming question remains of when did the nation (not independence or statehood, which is a question for another time) of Palestine become established? As it is, most Palestinians in Gaza reflect more Egyptian culture and those in the West Bank have a more Syrian culture. Palestinian Arabs always wore fezzes as a mark of distinction before 1948, so was Palestinian culture destroyed by adopting the kyffia?
+naapalm82 haha you are totally right, except for one thing - Goliath wasn't a palestinians, he was a philiste. there is a big differnce.
+lidorvl Not in Palestinian's native Arabic. Their words make no distinction.
+naapalm82
Only problem is, the Palestinians have nothing to do whatsoever with the philistines. They weren't even Semitic and they vanished 2,700 years ago. The Romans renamed Judea after them, and the Palestinians adopted that name in the 20th century.The original name of the philistines is "Plishtim", it's a Hebrew biblical name meaning "to invade". In Arabic it's "filistine" since they don't have a P.
it's not even an Arabic name. Should give you a clue as to who are the natives
here.
You are wrong, Goliath was a Philistine not a Palestinian. It's different
Rome is the only one that have the right to this land, full stop. The israeli were banished because of their terrorist activities. Palestine7Israel should be given to todays's sole legal owners, that is Italy! No 2 state solution, just an italian colony. and Italian should be the only legal language.
+Guro Jose but wait, g-fucking-d didnt promise it to italy.
GOD BLESSES ALL THE JEWS AND CHRISTIANS!
SHALOM!
JERUSALEM - A Palestinian man was found dead in his home in the West Bank town of Bir Zeit on Thursday after a standoff with Israeli forces that had come to arrest him, according to the Israeli military.
The military said in a statement that the man, identified as Mutaz Washaha, 25, was “suspected of terror activity,” without elaborating. It added that the forces employed various means, including live fire, to complete the arrest, acting “under the premise that he had weapons in his possession.” The military said an assault rifle was later found in the house. There was no indication that Mr. Washaha had used it to fire at the Israeli forces.
I don't support Israel, but I must admit that Ayalon really gave a big jab in the face with that rebuttal...
So you have My respect then :)
128 people hate facts
He's right about the use of 'Palestine' as a name for an area rather than a nation. But that was only one small part of the rebuttal video. He still cannot rationally defend the expansion of Israel's settlements.
“Settlements” are legally Israel’s
1) There’s never been an Arab (or therefore Palestinian) state there to occupy. If the land is not legally occupied, construction on it cannot be illegal.
2) The West Bank is Israel’s under the still legal League of Nations Palestine Mandate. The British illegally gave it to Arabs in 1922, who then lost it to Israel when they coerced a war in 1967 to destroy Israel.
3) Arabs refused the 1922 League of Nations and 1948 UN partition plans, thus the land is legally disputed.
4) UN Resolution 242 provides for negotiation that leaves Israel with secure borders. Until that is negotiated, then Israel can legally possess this land.
5) Land lost in wars of aggression is not occupied - ask Germany.
For context, five things should be understood.
1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states
2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100
3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs.
4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided.
5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution.
SailorSteve 1)Jordan was recognized as the sovereign nation of the West Bank.
2) Mandate of Palestine never said anything about a Jewish STATE. In fact it said the HOMELAND was to be IN Palestine.
3) The only enforceable legal decision about states after the Mandate was the MacDonald white paper- it stated that Palestine was to be a representational democracy by 1948. UN 181 was a suggestion, nothing more.
4) COMPLETELY FALSE. UN 242 recognized in the preamble that territory acquired by force is illegal.
5) Germany signed treaties, Israel did not. I note that Israel attacked Egypt in 1956, Jordan in 1954 and in 1966. attacked Syria when it had agreed to a ceasefire.
"1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states" Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish.
"2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100" So? Jews last governed the area over two thousand years ago...you're point?
"3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs." Didn't think Jordan Valley was in Jerusalem- but you're kind of right. Israel keeps on increasing the suburbs of Jerusalem until it almost stretches to Jordan now.
"4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided" Completely false. The Christian and Muslim population of Palestine in 1922 was 660,000- this was BEFORE the waves of Jewish immigration, of which was kept secret from the Palestinians- they had already been promised the land BEFORE the Balfour Declaration you see. By 1948 this number had climbed to about 1.1 million- WELL within natural means.
"5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution." You're including the Sinai which had nothing to do with Palestine. Also Begin and Carter knew that is Sadat took his case before the ICC, Israel wouldn't have a chance. Instead Israel took the 15 BILLION buy out offered by the USA.
michardav
We'll let others decide between your dissembling and the evident truth.
SailorSteve Well let's start off with the points you disagree with. Which one of my points is not true?
SailorSteve that is a pathetic argument that I have heard way too many times. The fact is, what matters in international law is international consensus and the according to the consensus the settlements are illegal whether you like it or not. It is a unique brand of messianic colonializm which has poisoned Israel's soul and helped to mak peace unachievable.
need to be shared
Very well done, Danny! Good on you.
Love it! Well said, Danny Ayalon!
LOL, love the ending. That B^tch was like uhahhh
The jewish people also didn't have a home country since the first century. I would rather propose that what qualifies a population to have a country is a national sentiment, historical bonds with the land and international recognition, all of which the so called palestinians possess
very convincing
Awesome! I appreciate your professional rebuttal. You deliver the truth with anger or personal attack. Well done Sir. Shalom shalom!
The ending was actually really funny. Normally I'd say videos like that aren't worth the time taken to respond, but this was actually really well done.
"President Obama’s meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu came as Israeli government figures showed Israel initiated more than twice as many West Bank settlement homes last year than it did the previous year. Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics said construction began on more than 2,500 settlement housing units in 2013, compared to just more than 1,100 the year before. Last year’s number is the highest in a decade. In the West Bank’s Jordan Valley, Palestinian residents and local officials say Israel has demolished hundreds of homes.
Ali Ka’abneh, Jordan Valley resident: "The Israeli occupation forces came here on the 29th. They came in the morning, of course, while we were sleeping, at 6:30 with their bulldozers and their soldiers. They gave us 10 minutes to leave the buildings we lived in, and then they demolished them all at once, without any warning at all."
Arif Daraghmeh, head of Al-Maleh Council: "The occupation has demolished more than 500 structures in the past year alone in this area, and now the Israeli army and occupation is carrying out all these policies in order to pressure the people and drive them out. They have demolished these tents and driven out the inhabitants, and they plan to have exercises in this area and to build more settlements and military camps."
Why negotiate when the world will sit back an let you take everything?!
michardav Why are you even here? Why are you on a pro Israel video commenting anti Israel stuff? Do you even have a life?
James Potter Not just that all his ideas and style of writing itsself was directly stolen from someone who commented pro-Israel. His pic is an imitation and he is a Muslim.
harold kramer"Not just that all his ideas and style of writing itsself was directly stolen from someone who commented pro-Israel. His pic is an imitation and he is a Muslim."
hmm an what led you to believe that?
@Diane Monahan so why are illegal settler outposts mostly (mostly) allowed to continue?
@Diane Monahan so you would think after years of persecution, they wouldn't do it themselves. But glad to see you support a right of return for people that have been driven from their homes
good arguments based from historical and biblical sources...superb
There's no unique Palestinian language, no unique Palestinian cuisine, no unique Palestinian flag, no unique Palestinian culture, no historical evidence of anything Palestinian, neither does the name Palestine written in the Bible or the Gospels not even in the Qur'an.
So just as it was a foreign name given by a foreigner it should be treated as such, FOREIGN.
So if it foreign then it should be left in the history books or better still to be discarded.
Occurred in October 1953 when Israeli troops under Ariel Sharon attacked the village of Qibya in the West Bank. Sixty-nine Arabs were killed. Forty-five houses, a school, and a mosque were destroyed
Very thoughtful and to the point. Loved it.
"Funerals were held in the occupied West Bank over the weekend for two Palestinians shot dead during the annual Nakba Day protest. The father of 17-year-old Nadim Nuwara called on Israel to try his son’s killer in court."
@Diane Monahan so how many gathered at Baruch Goldstein's tomb last year to celebrate his murder of 29 Palestinians?
@Diane Monahan I didn't say funeral, I said tomb or gravesite if you will. I thought you were against people that massacre innocents and those that celebrate them?
@Diane Monahan I'm against all deaths too, and specifically against the Hamas terrorism. I hear you say your against deaths, but you still haven't spoken out against those who regularly visit Goldstein's grave to honour him, which was my point.
You the man Danny!
As Pierre Orts, chairman of Mandate Commission of the League Of Nations, said that under the mandate, Article 7, obliged Mandatory to enact a nationality law, which again showed Palestinians formed a nation, & that Palestine was a State, though provisionally under guardianship."Palestinian".
Love
The founder of the Arab League created on the desroyed Turkish Empire said this:
An October 11, 1947 report on the pan-Arab summit in the Lebanese town of Aley in Egypt's largest paper that day (translated by Efraim Karsh; all ellipses are in the original text):
Abdul Rahman Azzam Pasha spoke to me about the horrific war that would happen in the coming months… proclaiming:
"I personally wish that the Jews do not drive us to this war, and surrender as I promise this to be a war of extermination and momentous massacre which will be spoken of like the Tatar massacre or the Crusader wars. I believe that the number of volunteers from outside Palestine will be larger than Palestine's Arab population, for I know that volunteers will be arriving to us from [as far as] India, Afghanistan, and China to win the honor of martyrdom for the sake of Palestine … You might be surprised to learn that hundreds of Englishmen, and other Europeans expressed their strong wish to volunteer in the Arab armies to fight the Jews.
"This war will be distinguished by three serious matters. First-faith: as each fighter deems his death on behalf of the Ummah of Palestine as the shortest road to paradise; second, [the war] will be an opportunity for vast plunder. Third, it will be impossible to contain the zealous volunteers arriving from all corners of the world to reek vengeance for the martyrs of the Palestine Arabs, and viewing the war as dignifying every Arab and every Muslim throughout the world …
"The Arab is superior to the Jew in that he accepts defeat with a smile: Should the Jews defeat us in the first battle, we will defeat them in the second or the third battle … or the final one… whereas one defeat will shatter the Jew's morale! Most desert Arabians take pleasure in fighting. I recall being tasked with mediating a truce in a desert war (in which I participated) that lasted for nine months…While en route to sign the truce, I was approached by some of my comrades in arms who told me: 'Shame on you! You are a man of the people, so how could you wish to end the war … How can we live without war?' This is because war gives the Bedouin a sense of happiness, bliss, and security that peace does not provide! …
He [Azzam] ended his conversation with me by saying: "I foresee the consequences of this bloody war. I see before me its horrible battles. I can picture its dead, injured, and victims … But my conscience is clear … For we are not attacking but defending ourselves, and we are not aggressors but defenders against an aggression! …"
This would only fool people who don't know basic history or understand nationalities at all.
For one, not being sovereign does NOT mean that Palestine did not exist, or that Palestinians did not exist. As ANYONE who knows anything about nations knows- a nation does NOT create a people, but a people create a nation!
Did Americans not exist before American independence? Did Angolans, or Syrians, or Congolese not exist before independence? Who thinks like that? A people create a nation, a nation does NOT create a people. And what about Israel? A nations who's language was spoken today was created in Eastern Europe and is considered more Slavic than Semitic by many language experts. Or that the founders of modern Israel were largely European Jews who all of a sudden became "Israelis."
And as someone who knows MANY Palestinian Christians from Bethlehem, Nazareth, Ramallah, etc- not a single one I have ever met has ever said they felt oppressed by Palestinian Muslims Lets be honest here- Israel created millions of Palestinian refugees, many of them Christian. Bethlehem was NOT 60% Christian in 1990. The TRUTH is that it was about 50%, and is today about 40% Christian. The loss was do to the Palestinian uprising, which led to poor security conditions, and an economy in complete shambles do to Israeli restrictions on Palestinian movement and the overall economy. Not because of any Palestinian Muslim. In fact, only 3% of Palestinian Christians stated that they were immigrating because of "Muslims." The rest blamed Israel's brutal treatment of Palestinians.
Everyone should watch the 60 Minutes documentary on Palestinian Christians and see what THEY had to say about these false accusations of Muslims harassing them. They ONLY blamed Israel and Michael Oren, Israel's Ambassador to the US, tried having the documentary BLOCKED from American television because he knew that American Christians wouldn't like what Palestinian Christians had to say about Israel.
Danny is merely trying to mask the Palestinian Christian voice.
PS- those "headlines" Danny posted don't even have any source listed when you look them up.
If Danny loves Palestinian Christians so much- allow all Palestinian Christian refugees to return to their homes! Oh wait, you don't love them THAT much- you just like using them as pawns to make the conflict seem likes its poor little Israel against the big bad Muslims *rolls eyes*. Before 9/11 you never heard Israel talk about "persecuted" Palestinian Christians.
Lol who is more righteous hanan ashrawi or walid shoebat?
I remember hanan's quote when she said mizrahi jews were not refugees. dude , did she even hear about the farhud?
***** Hana clearly is more righteous! Walid Shoebat was exposed as a fake and a fraud years ago, which is why he hardly does any lectures these days. Even the Jerusalem Post noted his bold contradictions. LOOOL look at his website these days- it says he was an ex "Muslim Brotherhood" member. Two years ago it said he was an ex PLO member. Neither ended up being true.
Daveissa87
Big like
There are many Palestinians christians refugees who are not allowed to return to Palestine and I'm one of them.
The simple fact is that Jews lived in Palestine long before the modern state of Israel was formed. The Ottoman Empire first began allowing Jews to settle there in 1844.
Thank you for the truth. This truth has to go global, because most people don't know the real history. Shalom.
Danny totally took those two ladies to school. At least they were not forced to wear the hijab like they would in Gaza and most Arab countries. They may be dumb but at least they are free.
Israel 4 the WIN
Over the past century, the percentage of Christian Palestinians has been in decline. The influx of Jewish immigrants since the late 1880s, the Nakba of 1948 and the expulsions of 1967 played a big role in diminishing the presence of Palestinian Christians
That was awesome
Danny:
Wouldn't it be more effective to have an American Jewish celebrity rather than an Israeli politician teach these truths?
Black people have also never been a nation. This was still not a good justification for the Apartheid in South Africa. And the historical Israel never existed in that way what you think today it might have looked like.
they got the reight to self determination
I could write a book on how comparing Israel to Apartheid South Africa is ludicrous, dishonest, and affronting to all parties involved, but that would probably be futile in educating you as well as insensitive to the seriousness of both issues. So I'm just going to settle for calling you an idiot. You idiot.
You are right, South Africa never attacked another country. Israel is worse than South Africa.
Julian Hans Halbeisen you did a mistake , israel didn't attack first they was all the time attacked .
Julian Hans Halbeisen Israel never attacked any country, but She does have the right to defend herself !
Danny fades back, and sswoosh! And that's the game ! Nothing further, your Honour!
Hahahaha
Love your videos, please keep up the good work and may The Lord bless you and yours.
The other thing about the words "Palestine" and "Palestinian" is that they were words used by the Romans to call the area belonging to the "Philistines." The word "Palestine" is, in essence, from a Greek word meaning "the land of the Philistines," who weren't even indigenous people to Israel in the FIRST place. There were, originally, transplanted Greeks (one of the original Greek tribes who were pushed out by invaders from the north) and who settled in Canaan between 1300 and 1200 B.C.E. AND, by the days of the Romans, the Philistines no longer existed in the first place! So, there is NO way that modern "Palestinians" descended from the Philistines! For them to call themselves "Palestinian" they are calling themselves "Philistines" and do not even know it.
They are Arabs no such thing as Palestanian ethnicity it’s Arab nationalism
Go Danny
SailorSteve 1)Jordan was recognized as the sovereign nation of the West Bank.
2) Mandate of Palestine never said anything about a Jewish STATE. In fact it said the HOMELAND was to be IN Palestine.
3) The only enforceable legal decision about states after the Mandate was the MacDonald white paper- it stated that Palestine was to be a representational democracy by 1948. UN 181 was a suggestion, nothing more.
4) COMPLETELY FALSE. UN 242 recognized in the preamble that territory acquired by force is illegal.
5) Germany signed treaties, Israel did not. I note that Israel attacked Egypt in 1956, Jordan in 1954 and in 1966. attacked Syria when it had agreed to a ceasefire.
"1) Through all history there has never been an Arab state on the West Bank, but there have been 3 Jewish states" Ancient Israel wasn't Jewish.
"2) Until Israel agreed to allow the PLO to return in 1993 to govern, Arabs last governed this land in the year 1100" So? Jews last governed the area over two thousand years ago...you're point?
"3) Almost all the fuss is about Jerusalem suburbs." Didn't think Jordan Valley was in Jerusalem- but you're kind of right. Israel keeps on increasing the suburbs of Jerusalem until it almost stretches to Jordan now.
"4) Most of those we call Palestinian are disparate Arabs from disparate Arab nations and regions, who came with and after the returning Jews, for the jobs and services the Jewish created economy provided" Completely false. The Christian and Muslim population of Palestine in 1922 was 660,000- this was BEFORE the waves of Jewish immigration, of which was kept secret from the Palestinians- they had already been promised the land BEFORE the Balfour Declaration you see. By 1948 this number had climbed to about 1.1 million- WELL within natural means.
"5) Israel has returned 96% of the land it has won defending itself against Arab efforts to annihilate it and commit another Holocaust. When Palestinians are serious about a permanent peace, Israel will surrender yet more to achieve a 2 state solution." You're including the Sinai which had nothing to do with Palestine. Also Begin and Carter knew that is Sadat took his case before the ICC, Israel wouldn't have a chance. Instead Israel took the 15 BILLION buy out offered by the USA.
Well replied sir keep it up
That was one of the most wishy-washy arguments I have ever heard.
Thank you for making this very informative video! =)
Those young women sent to refute your discourse on Palestine were pathetic. They had more smiles and cutesy one-liners than historical content. Their video was obviously directed at the young, hedging a bet that historic episodes such as the Munich Olympics, The founding of the PLO, the Palestinian Mufti's alliance with Adolf Hitler, and the anti-Jewish massacres that took place in the Levant as soon as the Ottomans pulled out (long before modern Israel) are all forgotten memories. I for one would respect the Palestinian Arabs more if their public relations were more honest and in line with their fighters. Instead of playing the victim and trying to mislead media and censor history, they should simply explain that they would rather fight than live in peace. Those girls who tried to refute you should wear less clothes next time. It would lend entertainment value to what is otherwise obvious manipulation.
Excellent
Thank you. I don't have to spend time commenting the ladies's video.
Thanks for sharing the truth!
I think the word "truth" lost its meaning completely.
once again we prove that they are clever but we are smart.
I would hate to debate that guy. If we could do away with the hardliners on both sides I bet there could be decent dialog
Although that dialogue would be impossible, as any definition of who is and isn't a hard-liner would be inherently flawed. Let some moderates come in and talk over them, perhaps, but don't ever say that one side is any better or worse than the other, or if you do then you do so at your own peril.
Much respect for this rebuttal video, Mr Ayalon.
i see it this way:
I Have a house with a garden. Some people move to my garden and claim it's now theirs, because 1000 years ago some ancesters of theirs lived there. Im pissed and ask em to go away - they won't and start a war, wich they win. They tell me my garden and my house are now theirs and i can move to my garage if i like. I have no choice and move to my garage. Now they move settlers into the garage because they need more space. And again i can't do sh..
Thats how the situation in Palstine/Isreal is, and it's wrong.
I have no solution for the problem - but it's just wrong how Palestinian people and Israelis threat each other.
Thank you - I love your truth-revealing videos!
Lately I read (Arutz Sheva? Times of Israel? United with Israel?), that leading politicians and other time witnesses wondered about the massive immigration and settlement of arabs (Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, ...) into "Palestine" (they can't even speak a "P" and use "F" instead) in the 1920ies.
I think it's worse a research because it was waste land before, just like Mark Twain said inthe 1860ies.
L'Shalom B'Yisrael
"She's wrong because **Insert Opinion**"
You get a sub for that pimp slap!
Judea and Galilee were two separate states and political entities, as illustrated on the map of Palestine in the time of Jesus in the Bible. Jesus Himself was not a Jew (Judean) or resident of Judea, He was a Galilean or resident of Galilee. Jesus grew up in Nazareth in Galilee.
דני, אהבתי! לא מבין למה ליברמן צינזר אותך.
People like you , make it harder to make peace
#TruthHurts
You can't have any peace with people who spread lies /hatred/ false claims