Huh? What? Fremen harnessing sound? That's an invention of the 1984 movie which is not at all present in the book(s). Fremen have thumpers, and that's about it.
I would like to see a full 'Complete Guide' but it might be better to wait until part to 2. Doing a full treatment for essentially half a movie might be difficult and the ending may differ much than the original source material.
I think you're completely right dude, I'm also not convinced 'Part 2' will necessarily be the end of that first story. I genuinely hope it is though, not because I don't like what Villeneuve did with the franchise, I'd just rather see the later stories that we haven't seen on screen yet and imo are a lot more interesting! God Emperor Atreides all the way.
Good review but two points. Maybe I forgot but I don’t recall the book having any “sound as a weapon” like the 1980s version. So not sure why you would expect it. Also It’s Arrakis not Arraxis,
Yo, you said that there is no logical spot to cut the movies up- but the first dune book is divided into three “books” with the first “book” ending after the siege and after a tender moment between paul and Jessica stuck after the crash landing- This would have been a proper stopping point, but it would have forced a trilogy of movies- which perhaps is the best way to handle the adaptation. I’m general, love your videos! Thanks
Arrakis not Araksis, other than that a decent review. Your Alien in-depth revew was magnificent even if I disagree on some of your conclusions. Keep going you deserve better but don't try to take short cuts, there is enough of that on youtube.
Sorry I've only just seen this! There is a LOT coming, got Hereditary Complete Guide nearly complete, VO recorded for something about Arcane and animation and just putting the finishing touches to something secret I'm super poud of but there is a lot coming in the next few weeks.
Great Vid, id totally agree, the spaceship design and Harkkonen invasion of Araxis were absolutely immense, two of my favorite aspects by far. Ultimately i think the hardcore Sci-Fi fans appreciated the arty approach and i really really hope we see a part 2.
Thanks for watching guys! Let me know here if you'd like this movie to get the full 'Complete Guide' treatment. Another video coming very soon!
Well, of course ;)
YUP
Huh? What? Fremen harnessing sound? That's an invention of the 1984 movie which is not at all present in the book(s). Fremen have thumpers, and that's about it.
Thankfully Part 2 was indeed filmed and released 😜 Do we get to hear your thoughts? I've still not yet gone to see it, but am eager to do so
Rewatching this video after seeing part 2 and knowing DV is already writing Dine Messiah is so fun
I would like to see a full 'Complete Guide' but it might be better to wait until part to 2. Doing a full treatment for essentially half a movie might be difficult and the ending may differ much than the original source material.
I think you're completely right dude, I'm also not convinced 'Part 2' will necessarily be the end of that first story. I genuinely hope it is though, not because I don't like what Villeneuve did with the franchise, I'd just rather see the later stories that we haven't seen on screen yet and imo are a lot more interesting! God Emperor Atreides all the way.
Good review but two points. Maybe I forgot but I don’t recall the book having any “sound as a weapon” like the 1980s version. So not sure why you would expect it. Also It’s Arrakis not Arraxis,
Yo, you said that there is no logical spot to cut the movies up- but the first dune book is divided into three “books” with the first “book” ending after the siege and after a tender moment between paul and Jessica stuck after the crash landing-
This would have been a proper stopping point, but it would have forced a trilogy of movies- which perhaps is the best way to handle the adaptation. I’m general, love your videos! Thanks
YES!!!
Ditto, give us God Emperor Leto!!!
Arrakis not Araksis, other than that a decent review. Your Alien in-depth revew was magnificent even if I disagree on some of your conclusions. Keep going you deserve better but don't try to take short cuts, there is enough of that on youtube.
Please do a complete guide to Dune. Please. ❤
Only 399 views? So underrated
Yes we want an in depth analysis, you could analyse any movie and i would watch it so please do!
Do a complete guide!!
There's hereditary and a couple of others to come first but it's on the list!
Where you at man 😭
Sorry I've only just seen this! There is a LOT coming, got Hereditary Complete Guide nearly complete, VO recorded for something about Arcane and animation and just putting the finishing touches to something secret I'm super poud of but there is a lot coming in the next few weeks.
@@Novum_YT thank goodness man I've missed your channel.
Complete guide yes!
Great Vid, id totally agree, the spaceship design and Harkkonen invasion of Araxis were absolutely immense, two of my favorite aspects by far. Ultimately i think the hardcore Sci-Fi fans appreciated the arty approach and i really really hope we see a part 2.
nice job. I just discovered your videos and left a heartfelt thought on your “Promising Young Woman” video.
A complete guide to DUNE would be great.
My favourite channel! Massive amounts of work here. Always looking forward to see what’s coming next. Thank you!
amazing movie
Obsessed with your channel, another cracking video 🙏 Can't wait to see what you do next!
Wonderful video, I love your channel!! Your definitely underrated!
Cheers Soffy! New stuff coming very soon