Very nice experiment! I've been wondering about which boards might be most suitable for 18650 power, and this certainly answers that question. The information you provided regarding sleep mode is also very useful -- I wasn't aware that was available. So thanks very much and I'll look for the follow up video you mentioned to see whether you were able to do even better.
i dont understand your voice(fully) but this video is the most usefull video i have ever seen. can you speak more understandable ? (english is not my first language)
3 роки тому+48
Its like testing car Fuel consumption without going anywhere.
Fuel consumption in idle, yes. But it's part of the puzzle, actually the part that I'm looking for: I can calculate how much everything else is using myself.
Not really for the Mega and Uno, but it does make a significant difference for the smaller Arduinos, like the Pro Micro, Nano and Pro Mini. I've recently done a video on this as well - ua-cam.com/video/A3shZgR5Y68/v-deo.html
Where can I find those battery holders with the built in chargers? Those would be really useful. No need to remove the battery from the project to charge them.
@@MichaelKlements Ok, good to know. I bought some similar from Amazon. In addition to the charger, they also have a pair of step down regulators, one for 5v and one for 3v3. www.amazon.com/gp/product/B088BWXPB3/
Battery Time is calculated with the Formula T = (Battery Voltage x Battery Ah) / (MCU Voltage x MCU Current) which will give you the result in Hours. Hours /24 Hours give you the Battery Days without defficiency...
It depends a lot on the type of sensor and how you’re using it. Sensors like thermistors and LDRs use very little power where GPS and GSM modules typically use significantly more than the Arduino would. There are also ways to reduce the power consumption by sensors by only turning them on when they need to be used or using a “sleep” mode.
@@MichaelKlements brother.. i am making a project using arduino uno, touch module ttp223, reset switch, 1 digt lcd 7 segments. Can you tell me what will be the best battery source for it. I bought a single 9v battery for it.
The write-up linked in the video description gives you more information on this. They're in series for the 5V tests and then just a single cell for the 3.3V tests.
remove +5V LED indicators as well as RX/TX uno board is not low power board/components. You can also try running all processors on 1MHz not 16Mhz and see difference :)
I did a follow up on this video where I tried a couple of different things to make a Pro Mini more efficient. I got it down to using a couple of microamps, so the Arduino would outlast the natural discharge rate of the battery.
I’ve had mine running for the last 175 days continually without a problem. It’s been on and running combined for over 250 days easy. I’m using the arduino uno genuine board.
I'm wondering how this compares to, say, using an uno to program the atmega and then operating it as a standalone microprocessor. How much energy cost is in having the rest of the arduino board around going unused?
Well it depends on what you’re trying to do with it. Arduino boards in general are prototyping boards, so they’ve got a lot of components on them to make them as usable as possible but being power efficient isn’t really a consideration.
I bought these same batteries. Once fully discharged, I charged and found them to be only 1800mAh. I learned the hard way, if you want quality batteries try Panasonic or Samsung instead. You get what you pay for. No such thing as a 4200mAh or 9800mAh 18650 on the market only cheap China knockoffs.
Hey man can you please help me , My arduino turn on by battery but it does not run the code ?? It's like there is no code inside it But if i connect to laptop it works . Any solution for this ?
The battery is likely not able to supply enough current (or possibly incorrect voltage) to run the Arduino. The power LED might come on but the controller behaves strangely if it doesn't get enough power.
That's quite an open ended question. 9V batteries vary significantly in capacity and so do servos. It'll also depend on how often you're moving the servo.
anyone help me please. its for my school project. i made a mood lamp and when i connect to the battery(9v), the board only turns on for about 10 seconds and then it will turn off for about 3 sec and turns on again, and the cycle continues. please if anyone knows how to solve this please help me....
Some cheap 9V batteries are really poorly made and can’t handle the current drawn by an Arduino, especially if you’ve got a motor or servo attached. So the voltage drops and the Arduino cuts out and restarts.
it's amusing that people in comments sections tend to pick on "fake battery" instead of appreciation that someone actually measured power consumption in mathematicaly proper way xD Thank you Michael, this video was really educational!
Haha, if there is one thing I've learned about UA-cam its that people will always find something to complain about. At least we all learn from it and can make improvements for the next one.
Nice test to see the bare power consumptions of the controllers. This test does not account for the fact that there is a voltage where the arduino stops working reliable working under a certain voltage. Especially in the case where the 3.7 volt is directly attached to the arduino. Also you did not include a battery protection to prevent deep discharging. When connecting the arduino to the batteryterminals, there is nothing stopping from going under the presumed safe 3.5 volts. The 4200 mAh rating is chemically not feasible, the max capacities with current li-ion technology, you could probably get 3500 mAh.
As you've said, this test was more about testing the current draw from each Arduino setup than it was about correctly designing/sizing a battery setup to power them. All your points are valid when designing a battery powered project.
WOW! your batteries break the limits of physics AND chemistry just to be 4200mAH. !this video isnt very scientific, your method stands to be improved in many ways.
@@nbcq302 actually i'll partially agree with OP. Altough cells used in this video are definetely shitty and surely doesn't have 4.2Ah capacity, author's method of measurment is correct. If you really had 4200 mAh 3.6v cell, calculations would be close enough. However if you have something more realistic like Samsung's INR18650-23 with 2.3Ah capacity, just include this in your calculations :)
@@carlerikkopseng7172 its an easy one to prove. The highest capacity li ion18650 battery available is by Samsung, LG and panasonic is 3500 mah. These three companies are very reputable in this field. Even then, these 3500 mah are very expensive. I doubt a random chinese company would be able to achieve higher capacity than these
Do you know that for any given battery chemistry there is a measure known as power density. I don't have the number handy, but I do know a legitimate 18650 LiIon with protection weighs 45gm and has at most 2,600mAh. In order for those batteries to have 4200 they will have to weigh at least 73gm. I guarantee you they are fake. I apologize if later in the video you disclose these facts, but I have only watched the first few minutes. Very unhelpful video. Also, research what happens when using a VOM to measure sub 1A currents. Hint: it messes up your readings and not in a good way.
First the capacity of the battery, that rating is fraud. So not a fair test. 1000ma true capacity battery will run a nano 24 hours. 8 hours a day, so 3 days.
Very valuable data collected and shared. Thanks.
True
Very nice experiment! I've been wondering about which boards might be most suitable for 18650 power, and this certainly answers that question. The information you provided regarding sleep mode is also very useful -- I wasn't aware that was available. So thanks very much and I'll look for the follow up video you mentioned to see whether you were able to do even better.
Thanks John!
Awesome video. Exactly what I was looking for!
I think that as a fairer test you should have used the same two batteries in parallel for the 3.3V versions.
The voltage would have been the same; you would just double the total capacity. Instead of 4 months of life, you'd have 8 months.
i dont understand your voice(fully) but this video is the most usefull video i have ever seen.
can you speak more understandable ? (english is not my first language)
Its like testing car Fuel consumption without going anywhere.
Epic bro
Fuel consumption in idle, yes. But it's part of the puzzle, actually the part that I'm looking for: I can calculate how much everything else is using myself.
You are right, but he still shows something usefull, witch board is the most power efficient, and about speel mode/low power mode
Kinda. Not really
@@wilfdarr exactly
Its giving a nice idea. It would have been great .. if you would have connected few component like LCD and few relays
Does this change substantially by desoldering the on chip LED's?
Not really for the Mega and Uno, but it does make a significant difference for the smaller Arduinos, like the Pro Micro, Nano and Pro Mini. I've recently done a video on this as well - ua-cam.com/video/A3shZgR5Y68/v-deo.html
When testing voltage how do you know where to attach to the location on the breadboard ?
The Raspberry Pi Pico can run on 3.7v with a display attached. It's pointless to boost it up unless you need 5.1v somewhere badly.
Where can I find those battery holders with the built in chargers? Those would be really useful. No need to remove the battery from the project to charge them.
I bought them from Banggood - bit.ly/3nKqyFp . Yes, they're really useful for rechargeable projects!
@@MichaelKlements Ok, good to know. I bought some similar from Amazon. In addition to the charger, they also have a pair of step down regulators, one for 5v and one for 3v3.
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B088BWXPB3/
These one's also look really useful. Having the on-board power switch is neat.
@@MichaelKlements That's what I thought as well. They will be here in a few days so we shall see how well they work.
Be careful, not all of these devices are capable of proper UPS function.
Battery Time is calculated with the Formula T = (Battery Voltage x Battery Ah) / (MCU Voltage x MCU Current) which will give you the result in Hours. Hours /24 Hours give you the Battery Days without defficiency...
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing, this video doesn’t accurately calculate battery run time
is there a way to power down more than 8S ?
this seems like a very bad limitation in the LowPower library
Very informational! Thank you for sharing this experiment with us :)
You have taken lot more effort to make this video. Anyways very useful information for me.
Thanks RD Gadekar
Where did you get those red PCB battery trays for the 18650s?
They're from Banggood - www.banggood.com/custlink/GDDEjgHQz7
thank you so much. you helped me a lot
How long would a Nano last if I used it 1 minute a day?
One minute a day is less than 0.1% utilization, so it won't be much different to the test results. Probably around 20 days on a 3000mAh battery.
Are the batteries you're using protected or unprotected? They seem to be mounted on a module. Does this module protect against over discharge?
They're unprotected and the module that the battery is on is only a charger.
cool video, and nice projects! Do you know how long those controllers last while in usage? Like with some kind of sensor and transmition (pir/433)
It depends a lot on the type of sensor and how you’re using it. Sensors like thermistors and LDRs use very little power where GPS and GSM modules typically use significantly more than the Arduino would. There are also ways to reduce the power consumption by sensors by only turning them on when they need to be used or using a “sleep” mode.
@@MichaelKlements brother.. i am making a project using arduino uno, touch module ttp223, reset switch, 1 digt lcd 7 segments. Can you tell me what will be the best battery source for it. I bought a single 9v battery for it.
Hey! The link to the batteries no longer works.
How did he wire up the batteries and used them together? Is it in series or parallel? And can you please tell me how they are connected? Thank you!
The write-up linked in the video description gives you more information on this. They're in series for the 5V tests and then just a single cell for the 3.3V tests.
@@MichaelKlements The batteries are 3.7 V each right? Will destroy the board? Sorry I'm kinda new with arduino and really like to learn more. :)
remove +5V LED indicators as well as RX/TX uno board is not low power board/components. You can also try running all processors on 1MHz not 16Mhz and see difference :)
I did a follow up on this video where I tried a couple of different things to make a Pro Mini more efficient. I got it down to using a couple of microamps, so the Arduino would outlast the natural discharge rate of the battery.
What spreadsheet program is that you're using? Doesn't look like Excel or Google
It's Apple's Numbers on macOS.
can a arduino uno board run for 30 days continuously? if i can supply power continuously
Yes it can, they’ll typically run for a couple of years - depending on the quality of the components used.
I’ve had mine running for the last 175 days continually without a problem. It’s been on and running combined for over 250 days easy. I’m using the arduino uno genuine board.
Good Info.
Excellent video, (are we there yet? 🤣🤣)
I'm wondering how this compares to, say, using an uno to program the atmega and then operating it as a standalone microprocessor. How much energy cost is in having the rest of the arduino board around going unused?
Well it depends on what you’re trying to do with it. Arduino boards in general are prototyping boards, so they’ve got a lot of components on them to make them as usable as possible but being power efficient isn’t really a consideration.
@@MichaelKlements True.
Just a curiosity.
I was also wondering how just the chip on a breadboard with a crystal would do.
I bought these same batteries. Once fully discharged, I charged and found them to be only 1800mAh. I learned the hard way, if you want quality batteries try Panasonic or Samsung instead. You get what you pay for. No such thing as a 4200mAh or 9800mAh 18650 on the market only cheap China knockoffs.
can I put 4 18650 lithium-ion battery for Arduino board to power a collision avoidance car
3 would probably be fine, bu t you should be able to use 4 as well.
Hey man can you please help me ,
My arduino turn on by battery but it does not run the code ??
It's like there is no code inside it
But if i connect to laptop it works .
Any solution for this ?
The battery is likely not able to supply enough current (or possibly incorrect voltage) to run the Arduino. The power LED might come on but the controller behaves strangely if it doesn't get enough power.
Hi sir, i want to ask, why my arduino blinking like on off, on off when i measure with my multimeter. I use 9v bat for powering arduino.
What are you measuring and how are you measuring it? This is a very open ended question.
@@MichaelKlements Sorry its my foult, luckly my multimeter doesnt broke😅. Nice video. Thanks for sharing👍
How much time would Arduino nano be on 9v battery if connected to servo
That's quite an open ended question. 9V batteries vary significantly in capacity and so do servos. It'll also depend on how often you're moving the servo.
Very nice
anyone help me please. its for my school project. i made a mood lamp and when i connect to the battery(9v), the board only turns on for about 10 seconds and then it will turn off for about 3 sec and turns on again, and the cycle continues. please if anyone knows how to solve this please help me....
Some cheap 9V batteries are really poorly made and can’t handle the current drawn by an Arduino, especially if you’ve got a motor or servo attached. So the voltage drops and the Arduino cuts out and restarts.
@@MichaelKlements oh but i think its bc of my battery holder bc my dad said they're low quality and the wires in it is too thin
Yes, it could also be that!
So finaly i found it
it's amusing that people in comments sections tend to pick on "fake battery" instead of appreciation that someone actually measured power consumption in mathematicaly proper way xD
Thank you Michael, this video was really educational!
Haha, if there is one thing I've learned about UA-cam its that people will always find something to complain about. At least we all learn from it and can make improvements for the next one.
Not just fake batteries, but incorrect mesuring method plus, all that data is in the data sheets.
What about esp8266?
Less than 10 seconds into the video and I'm seeing fake batteries with a capacity that we can only dream to be possible....
Who knows, maybe he has a time machine, and get those batteries from the future
How did you set up the wiring?
It’s just the two batteries in series and then those connected in series with the multimeter current probes and then onto each Arduino
@@MichaelKlements Thanks!
@@MichaelKlements so it's not a problem when the arduino connected with 7,4v as long as it's attached in Vin-G pin?
@@aaivilchip yeah the vin pin has a voltage regulator so no problem
Nice test to see the bare power consumptions of the controllers.
This test does not account for the fact that there is a voltage where the arduino stops working reliable working under a certain voltage. Especially in the case where the 3.7 volt is directly attached to the arduino.
Also you did not include a battery protection to prevent deep discharging. When connecting the arduino to the batteryterminals, there is nothing stopping from going under the presumed safe 3.5 volts.
The 4200 mAh rating is chemically not feasible, the max capacities with current li-ion technology, you could probably get 3500 mAh.
As you've said, this test was more about testing the current draw from each Arduino setup than it was about correctly designing/sizing a battery setup to power them. All your points are valid when designing a battery powered project.
Try an attiny85 @ 1MHZ Great vid BTW.
Thanks for the suggestion, I’ll try it out
Unbranded 4200 mAh 18650's is really not believable, maybe doing it with a Panasonic/Samsung/Mollicell would be a lot more scientific
The max a li-ion can have is 3500 mah, u got cheated bro
Yeah I've seen a lot of people have said this!
Would it work if i use 3 in series instead? Its 11,1 v.
WOW! your batteries break the limits of physics AND chemistry just to be 4200mAH.
!this video isnt very scientific, your method stands to be improved in many ways.
Zero arguments, stop spamming please
@@nbcq302 actually i'll partially agree with OP. Altough cells used in this video are definetely shitty and surely doesn't have 4.2Ah capacity, author's method of measurment is correct. If you really had 4200 mAh 3.6v cell, calculations would be close enough. However if you have something more realistic like Samsung's INR18650-23 with 2.3Ah capacity, just include this in your calculations :)
@@lis6502 with the calculations, he had a wrong, it’s 4500 mA hours at 3.7 V, the total milliamp hours changes when he’s running them in series at 5V
Not 4.2 mA i hope... 4.2A
Not on those batteries you have pictures those batteries are fake there's no 18 650 battery that is over 3,500
Im 100% sure that battery is not 4200mAh
Yes, and I am 100% sure you are pulling facts out of your ass.
If you make allegations, back them up
@@carlerikkopseng7172 its an easy one to prove. The highest capacity li ion18650 battery available is by Samsung, LG and panasonic is 3500 mah. These three companies are very reputable in this field. Even then, these 3500 mah are very expensive. I doubt a random chinese company would be able to achieve higher capacity than these
>that battery is not 4200mAh
guess we need to invade china so we can put those people putting wrong numbers on batteries in prison
@@Henry-sv3wv you can simply not buy scam products.
Do you know that for any given battery chemistry there is a measure known as power density. I don't have the number handy, but I do know a legitimate 18650 LiIon with protection weighs 45gm and has at most 2,600mAh. In order for those batteries to have 4200 they will have to weigh at least 73gm. I guarantee you they are fake. I apologize if later in the video you disclose these facts, but I have only watched the first few minutes. Very unhelpful video. Also, research what happens when using a VOM to measure sub 1A currents. Hint: it messes up your readings and not in a good way.
First the capacity of the battery, that rating is fraud. So not a fair test.
1000ma true capacity battery will run a nano 24 hours. 8 hours a day, so 3 days.
Cool….
These 18650 cells are fake. There are no cells with more than about 3600mAh only the very best LG cells have it. More often 3000 mAh or 3400mAh.
The high capacity ones are quite expensive. Typically you get 2400mAh-2800mAh
niceeeeee