i love lilly, i was so angry seeing her go home, but you know what, whatever. she can score something a thousand times better than american idol. she's so great, somebody's gonna recognize that. i just can't wait to hear more from her.
Lilly did a great job tonight. If you want to keep her in it don't split your vote. The other good ones are doing fine, but for some reason Lilly is coming in last place on dial idol. West coast, you have to vote your ass off the whole time and don't split your vote. We can't let her get voted off, she's too good.
I cried when I saw Lilly get voted off, especially when your family member get's voted off. Yes Lilly Scott is my cousin, i got a letter from her . :D and clothes from Top 24 Party. Woo!
i LOVE adam, but i like this better than his version... i always get so upset when i think of what could have been. i love you lilly, u and your crazy earrings *sad smile*
She sounds EXACTLY like the girl that won Redemption Song on FUSE a few years ago. So for all the people saying her voice is unique, its not. The girl from Redemption Song didn't get very far in the music industry, so I doubt Lilly will.
dudes , okay after just listing to this there was nothing wrong with the vocal , if a person thought something was wrong it would have to do with taste and not execution
Actually listen to simons comments on Crystal last week, they were very critical and mean spirited ( The subway comment) This was the first time Simon really raved about Crystal, It has been Ellen in the past who really said she loved her. just sit back and enjoy both of them, They are both great. While the other 3 judges might have been very high on Lilly They also gushed over Crystal. Im torn I love both of them because neither of them are standard pop
i don't know what America was listening to. You could see it in Lily's face. She thought she had it on lock..i was hoping it would come down to her cystal bowersox and Big Mike as they are all my favorites. I don't think I will watch the show anymore
@Chicley Didi is good, and her rendition of Terrified is the best I've heard. I thought she was a sure thing for the top 5 at least. But now she seems to be one crappy song choice away from destroying any chance she ever had to make it in the music business. I'd love to see her pull it together and get back in the game. But the reality is that she has fallen about as far and fast as an early front runner possibly could.
lilly not winning the competition is not the loss here...she's not my bet throughout the contest... the loss here is the entertainment...which lilly gives...AI is entertainment TV, it needs to be entertaining...and not be full of bad singers...
@LuniaVideo yup, me too...the girls really are better than the boys this season, because of these 3... the reason that there are 4 boys in the top 5 is that lilly was eliminated before the top12, and the boys are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO pimped that siobhan never had the chance...
@kstewfan115 I wouldn't say Crystal is better. They are very different. I think what Lilly does is far more complex and I wouldn't really compare the 2. They are my top 2 though. Then for me it's Katelyn.
@bnice115 do i here lacey brown and katie stevens???? good thing lacey's the first to go in the finals, she just wasted her place to be eliminated first, tsk tsk tsk... katie's getting good though...her vocals in "let it be" is phenomenal...
I agree Simon was way off base, Crystal is amazing and was my early favoritebut Lilly is now dead even in my mind. Lilly ddoes have a VERY uniqe sound,. I hope to hear great things from both
I DON'T GET IT !!... all the judges always give good reviews on Lilly's songs... what are you people listening to?? Are you stoned deaf??? There are two other singers that should have been eliminated first besides Lilly! Anyhow, I hope Lilly Scott gets discovered by some record company and prove the people wrong!
i miss you and i wish we had gotten more of you! Please please please stay with music!
She is an amazing talent and I really wanted to hear her on Idol for a lot longer. Wish her well
i love lilly, i was so angry seeing her go home, but you know what, whatever. she can score something a thousand times better than american idol. she's so great, somebody's gonna recognize that. i just can't wait to hear more from her.
That was the best performance withh Crystal :) !! I love how unique and different she is!
I love her arrangement. I miss her.
So true! That's exactly what I think!
@Beachdudeca totally agreed, she has a lot of charachter to her voice and some people aren't going to get it. This was the best for me.
Yay! Lilly's our girl! Amazing,ARTISTRY! strange rendition though
that was a brilliant song choice - even if she can't do it vocally like Seal, it was memorable which is the most important thing
Lilly did a great job tonight. If you want to keep her in it don't split your vote. The other good ones are doing fine, but for some reason Lilly is coming in last place on dial idol. West coast, you have to vote your ass off the whole time and don't split your vote. We can't let her get voted off, she's too good.
NOOO! she got voted off =( she was my favorite!!
I cried when I saw Lilly get voted off, especially when your family member get's voted off. Yes Lilly Scott is my cousin, i got a letter from her . :D and clothes from Top 24 Party. Woo!
Great stuff. I thought she left way too soon.
i LOVE adam, but i like this better than his version... i always get so upset when i think of what could have been. i love you lilly, u and your crazy earrings *sad smile*
She sounds EXACTLY like the girl that won Redemption Song on FUSE a few years ago. So for all the people saying her voice is unique, its not. The girl from Redemption Song didn't get very far in the music industry, so I doubt Lilly will.
god she was way fucking better than the people left right now WHAT THE HELL
I can't believe she got voted off. I would of stopped watching the show if it wasn't for sioban. I hope she wins!
dudes , okay after just listing to this there was nothing wrong with the vocal , if a person thought something was wrong it would have to do with taste and not execution
Actually listen to simons comments on Crystal last week, they were very critical and mean spirited ( The subway comment) This was the first time Simon really raved about Crystal, It has been Ellen in the past who really said she loved her. just sit back and enjoy both of them, They are both great. While the other 3 judges might have been very high on Lilly They also gushed over Crystal. Im torn I love both of them because neither of them are standard pop
i don't know what America was listening to. You could see it in Lily's face. She thought she had it on lock..i was hoping it would come down to her cystal bowersox and Big Mike as they are all my favorites. I don't think I will watch the show anymore
@Chicley Didi is good, and her rendition of Terrified is the best I've heard. I thought she was a sure thing for the top 5 at least. But now she seems to be one crappy song choice away from destroying any chance she ever had to make it in the music business. I'd love to see her pull it together and get back in the game. But the reality is that she has fallen about as far and fast as an early front runner possibly could.
don't forget crystal, she'll win this thing...
lilly not winning the competition is not the loss here...she's not my bet throughout the contest...
the loss here is the entertainment...which lilly gives...AI is entertainment TV, it needs to be entertaining...and not be full of bad singers...
@LuniaVideo
yup, me too...the girls really are better than the boys this season, because of these 3...
the reason that there are 4 boys in the top 5 is that lilly was eliminated before the top12, and the boys are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO pimped that siobhan never had the chance...
Shame she had to go so early. She would have made it very far.
well...indie is still indie in america...guess that's just how it goes....
@kstewfan115 I wouldn't say Crystal is better. They are very different. I think what Lilly does is far more complex and I wouldn't really compare the 2. They are my top 2 though. Then for me it's Katelyn.
@osaskater Yes and last week we could have done without the star power/internet comment too. Simon really pisses me off.
@bnice115
do i here lacey brown and katie stevens????
good thing lacey's the first to go in the finals, she just wasted her place to be eliminated first, tsk tsk tsk...
katie's getting good though...her vocals in "let it be" is phenomenal...
I agree Simon was way off base, Crystal is amazing and was my early favoritebut Lilly is now dead even in my mind. Lilly ddoes have a VERY uniqe sound,. I hope to hear great things from both
i think lilly, siobhan and crystal did best today!
I DON'T GET IT !!... all the judges always give good reviews on Lilly's songs... what are you people listening to?? Are you stoned deaf??? There are two other singers that should have been eliminated first besides Lilly! Anyhow, I hope Lilly Scott gets discovered by some record company and prove the people wrong!
@RosieGrl26 ahahaha she is a little pale but thats too harsh! shes beautiful! that albino was weerd o.o
I still can't believe she got voted off. I guess America has terrible taste in music or somethingg..
America put Megan Doi through week after week last season,but Lilly is already gone....Have you losted?!
i pretty much stopped watching after she got kicked off.
@osaskater chill out man. lilly is ok... Nothing special.. pe@ce.
Lacey should have gone...... not lilly