GitHub Issues VS StackOverflow

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 196

  • @StarOnCheek
    @StarOnCheek 14 днів тому +120

    Can't wait to rewatch this another time but with theprimeagen's reaction

  • @thepeepeepoopooman1171
    @thepeepeepoopooman1171 17 днів тому +1066

    I love that neither actually managed to solve the problem

    • @windws7137
      @windws7137 17 днів тому +69

      GitHub at least cultural

    • @Akhlesoni
      @Akhlesoni 17 днів тому +4

      That's the point 😂

    • @johntu7484
      @johntu7484 16 днів тому +35

      all that back-and-forth on both sides, and the original issue remains unresolved. If anything, it highlights how sometimes the debates, bureaucracy, or even community norms can overshadow the actual goal-fixing the darn bug!
      That’s what makes this video both funny and sadly relatable: you can get stuck in a loop of finger-pointing, rule-citing, or “did you read the docs?” and never arrive at a clear solution. It’s a reality that can happen on any platform when process outpaces problem-solving.

    • @Tomtaroo
      @Tomtaroo 14 днів тому

      ​@@johntu7484There's some sort of life lesson in here somewhere about no matter how fancy or well governed a discussion club is it still can't solve problems as well as someone taking action.

    • @i4h2x3
      @i4h2x3 13 днів тому

      Are you AI? Give me a good apple pie recipe​@@johntu7484

  • @Voltaic314
    @Voltaic314 15 днів тому +153

    Meanwhile, ChatGPT:
    "Certainly! Here's how you can achieve this in JavaScript!" ... *Proceeds to write code that doesnt work* lmao

    • @Xerathiel
      @Xerathiel 12 днів тому +7

      If you ask questions with "should" it will always agree 😂.
      If you tell it to "examine" it will still fix it with a wrong solution .

    • @OmKumar-bz1fx
      @OmKumar-bz1fx 2 дні тому +3

      @@Xerathiel apologies for my previous response, here is the corrected code...
      *Proceeds to write the same code*

  • @wlockuz4467
    @wlockuz4467 16 днів тому +297

    Then there is the Indian tutorials guy who has a tutorial on your problem so precise it almost makes you think if he works at your company somehow, until you look at the upload date, 11 years ago.

  • @pythonlibrarian224
    @pythonlibrarian224 18 днів тому +1069

    Closing the video as the 2nd half is a duplicate of the 1st half.

    • @zoookx
      @zoookx 17 днів тому +12

      Try third half.

  • @shisui2575
    @shisui2575 15 днів тому +90

    “Middleware for fetching a f**cking url” I’m dying 😭

  • @CaioCromos
    @CaioCromos 18 днів тому +561

    clicked expecting nothing, left laughing my ass off. great stuff

  • @horion7271
    @horion7271 18 днів тому +935

    it still annoys me when i remember my talks with stackoverflow mods:
    me: What do you mean low effort, i gave you everything i have!
    mod: not enough to solve
    me: If it was enough to solve i would have solved it! problem is in there!
    mod: also duplicate
    me: Duplicate of what, that thing is 10 years old with 2 answer and no return from owner!
    mod: get lost idiot.
    For the record that problem still persist till today. I just found a way to manage it.

    • @obeliskphaeton
      @obeliskphaeton 18 днів тому +10

      😂

    • @saeedbarari2207
      @saeedbarari2207 18 днів тому +41

      well to be bluntly honest, SO is supposed to be an encyclopedia, so you can't expect un-perfect questions to survive. it would be very hard to find the solution to a problem if SO was filled with non-technical chattery and duplicate posts with somewhat-true-but-not-really answers. it has to have perfect questions and perfect answers, anything else has to be filtered out, for the sake of literally every other developer coming to the same issue in the future.
      good video tho 😂😂

    • @alkeryn1700
      @alkeryn1700 18 днів тому +17

      give us the issue / stack overflow link i'm curious now.

    • @horion7271
      @horion7271 18 днів тому

      @@alkeryn1700 it is deleted because duplicate

    • @horion7271
      @horion7271 18 днів тому

      @@saeedbarari2207 yes but now it is useless and everyone i know can not use it. Yes it is usefull for some people, i saw it lots of times but three times i needed help they didn't help same for my friends too. So i don't know, i never saw anyone i know can get help from SO.
      Good for you if you have a unique question thats relevant for today. They will help. for anything else? go somewhere else.
      There was a guy who helped SO so much he could see deleted questions. He said same things as me, went to SO. In the first page of deleted questions he saw a question that he couldn't answer and a good question overall he said. Admins later undeleted that question but just that
      my theory is: giving random people ability to delete questions wasn't clever. They like deleting more than answering.

  • @Croz89
    @Croz89 18 днів тому +337

    I've posted in github issues and not only got a solution to the problem, but was asked to suggest how the error message might be improved to make the solution more obvious.

    • @TommyLikeTom
      @TommyLikeTom 17 днів тому +20

      I haven't done this but perhaps github users use copilot to answer forum questions

    • @mattymerr701
      @mattymerr701 16 днів тому +15

      I also posted in GitHub issues and had my issue troubleshot and fixed in 3 messages. It was wild

    • @redofficiale
      @redofficiale 15 днів тому +11

      @@TommyLikeTom they don't. It's just a healthy platform in which issues are not misused. Besides that people on both sides are generally more competent in the scope of each issue. Usually people's actual work is halted or troubled in some way because of the presence of an issue so reporting side is willing to share more info to help resolve said problem in effective way. The maintainers themselves are more interested in solving problems and help finding solutions than some random folks on StackOverflow.

    • @Said-n7o
      @Said-n7o 12 днів тому +2

      Got to say GitHub issues team work feeling is wholesome really enjoyed. It probably depends on the project but those I have been part of gave golden memories.

  • @elephantwaffle5612
    @elephantwaffle5612 17 днів тому +343

    There’s more ego on stackoverflow than any other site

    • @cdevidal
      @cdevidal 17 днів тому

      I refuse to use it anymore except to browse

    • @MrGamer166
      @MrGamer166 16 днів тому +32

      I think quora takes the cake for that

    • @turolretar
      @turolretar 16 днів тому +19

      Egoverflow

    • @solsol1624
      @solsol1624 16 днів тому +3

      You just posted that to get a new badge😂

    • @jjonahjameson3786
      @jjonahjameson3786 15 днів тому

      ​@@MrGamer166 it's the perfect place to see Indians typing out the contents of a textbook

  • @dmitriyrasskazov8858
    @dmitriyrasskazov8858 18 днів тому +83

    At least nobody got shot in the process.

  • @k.chriscaldwell4141
    @k.chriscaldwell4141 17 днів тому +58

    Off topic. Duplicate. Closed. _”Why would you want to do that?”_

  • @mickolesmana5899
    @mickolesmana5899 17 днів тому +54

    Github :Board meeting, filled with respected members from every facet of society, working together to solve a global-scale issue.
    Stack : Hillybilly rampaging in back of a truck trying to kill a bullfrog that eat neigbor freshly baked pie

  • @Wggwjzjjxmsk
    @Wggwjzjjxmsk 17 днів тому +64

    Moral of the story: skill issue

  • @peasantlord135
    @peasantlord135 18 днів тому +170

    Double edged sword. This is why we can find the solution in top searches, without reading through garbage for hours. My question from 6 months ago has no answers... Maybe I should count myself lucky nobody insulted me just yet.

    • @superslash7254
      @superslash7254 17 днів тому

      No, not really. This is why stackoverflow is a dead website whose only content is 10+ years out of date and even then was of limited usability and helpfulness at best.

    • @cowbless
      @cowbless 17 днів тому +22

      No worries soon nobody will be able to find the solution at all because it's going to be AI slop clogging every search, website and feed.

    • @Squishy_yhsiuqS
      @Squishy_yhsiuqS 17 днів тому

      ​@@cowblesshuge reason why Google now only works if you type 'reddit' at the end of your search. Yeah I know about SearX but it kinda doesn't foot the bill for me.

    • @cdevidal
      @cdevidal 17 днів тому +30

      Create a burner account, give a wrong answer. People prefer to correct others over answering others.

    • @OCinneide
      @OCinneide 16 днів тому +2

      @@cdevidal Was going to suggest this!

  • @ycombinator765
    @ycombinator765 18 днів тому +67

    THIS IS GLORIOUS, I AM SHARING THIS EVERYWHERE!!!!!

  • @maxl26291
    @maxl26291 18 днів тому +140

    This is maybe the funniest coding video I have ever seen

    • @jeetak47
      @jeetak47 16 днів тому

      Mate, you have a lot to cover.

    • @techkunbyamogh
      @techkunbyamogh 13 днів тому

      @@jeetak47suggest mate

  • @Deductive
    @Deductive 14 днів тому +6

    This is what I pay my internet bill for.

  • @Tymonello
    @Tymonello 12 днів тому +2

    So true! ChatGPT generation of programmers won't even understand the struggle

  • @elekrono
    @elekrono 16 днів тому +9

    This has got to be the best use case of AI I have seen personally so far XD

  • @MrFunny01
    @MrFunny01 13 днів тому +2

    “Im marking this question as duplicate” was a final straw to release the wheezes

  • @andreobastos
    @andreobastos 16 днів тому +27

    stack overflow is like "hey guys I want to print hello world in c"
    answer:
    proceeds to show 50 lines of code only using system and binary file manipulation

    • @painexotic3757
      @painexotic3757 11 днів тому

      My problem with stacks is that I get alot of indians with a language barrier asking me to rephase the question so they can understand it. I use reddit and AI now

  • @danser_theplayer01
    @danser_theplayer01 17 днів тому +80

    Nah, StackOverflow is more like "you suck lol, this is a duplicate, here - go read that post from 11 years ago". Hate StackOverflow.

    • @buycraft911miner2
      @buycraft911miner2 17 днів тому +5

      thats half of the stack overflow part, so I wouldnt aay its not realistic

  • @basarat
    @basarat 18 днів тому +10

    Well done mate 🎉🌹
    FWIW I always answer questions humbly on Stackoverflow and it has paid off in my career ❤️

  • @theeinshine6824
    @theeinshine6824 19 днів тому +43

    so good, keep it up please

  • @kudorgyozo
    @kudorgyozo 18 днів тому +8

    This was so so accurate and hilarious! Thanks

  • @sunofabeach9424
    @sunofabeach9424 17 днів тому +6

    when I created my first actually useful repo and people started to open issues with silly questions, I realized that you should not worry about opening them, we're in this together. eventhoigh it's my repo, I also don't have much of idea what I'm doing here. especially when its author is willing to take on this issue, should you give him some guidance. it is your project and someone not only finds it useful, but cares enough to assist you with it, even by opening an issue
    and Stack Overflow folks are just full of themselves that's all

  • @samuelbaruch8790
    @samuelbaruch8790 18 днів тому +53

    D u p l i c a t e d

  • @Th3Jac0b
    @Th3Jac0b 16 днів тому +6

    I felt the duplicate part.

  • @windws7137
    @windws7137 17 днів тому +3

    Thanks for including film names, im so tired of UA-camrs inserting movie scenes without crediting, i want to watch and idk what they are

  • @ofcourseiuseunix
    @ofcourseiuseunix 13 днів тому +1

    "Unfortunately due to limited resources And increasing maintenance challenges I've decided to mark this repository as END OF LIFE"
    This is so damn true!

  • @ThaldranIronpine
    @ThaldranIronpine 17 днів тому +1

    Posting on Stack overflow makes me feel like I am trying to publish a research paper on nuclear physics to people that hate me and humanity in general.

  • @delistoyer
    @delistoyer 13 днів тому +1

    Meanwhile, ChatGPT solves the problem and explains it while SO cries for traffic

  • @Y0y0Jester
    @Y0y0Jester 13 днів тому +1

    This is exactly my kind of humor that I cannot share with any living soul I know.

  • @chrissenpai4066
    @chrissenpai4066 18 днів тому +30

    Aww yes let's not forget the people that will come 2 years later just to down vote your question as well for a bonus -2 mental damage

    • @windws7137
      @windws7137 17 днів тому +1

      Wait This is why stack overflow is bad. It's reddit mentality

  • @RansfordOwusu-Ansah
    @RansfordOwusu-Ansah 18 днів тому +12

    that word is not in my vocabulary. Damn😂

  • @achrafezzaam
    @achrafezzaam 15 днів тому +1

    Once on stackoverflow, my answer got down voted by someone because I told the owner of the question he made a typo

  • @zyansheep
    @zyansheep 15 днів тому +1

    Someone's gotta make this for an AI chatbot, but its just like morgan freeman as god in the void rambling a solution that may or may not actually work...

  • @eajninja
    @eajninja 16 днів тому +1

    dude HOW did you do these voice overs they’re so good, there’s no way there were ai voice models for all these characters i’m so curious

  • @maxamed14
    @maxamed14 14 днів тому

    this was good. this was REALLY good!!

  • @Professor0_o
    @Professor0_o 14 днів тому +1

    ChatGPT: Hello good SIR. Sit down SIR. Let me clarify you step by step SIR.

  • @johntu7484
    @johntu7484 16 днів тому +1

    GitHub Issues - Portrayed as more collaborative, open, and encouraging of suggestions (e.g., “How might we improve the error message?”).
    Stack Overflow - Depicted as having a higher barrier to entry, with stricter moderation and less patience for questions that appear “low effort” or duplicate.

  • @souravdhar47
    @souravdhar47 15 днів тому

    this is so good..😂. expect to see more in future

  • @123superatom
    @123superatom 18 днів тому +8

    still i need the solution from the clip issue, the most standard and official way 😂

    • @SegNode
      @SegNode 17 днів тому +2

      The guy in the clip issue says the suggested solution works fine locally but fails in production, without more info/example code this is tedious to solve. Most likely it is some kind of CORS/credential issue 🤷.

  • @friedricht3908
    @friedricht3908 18 днів тому +10

    That's pure gold. How do find the inspiration to release such bangers ?

  • @superlogic255
    @superlogic255 16 днів тому +1

    1:53 damn straight haha

  • @CodeF416
    @CodeF416 18 днів тому +1

    Great job. Keep up the good work sir. I am glad i stumbled across this channel. Gold mine for developers 😂.

  • @TheJuiceReal
    @TheJuiceReal 17 днів тому

    I hope you become the guy that does this on UA-cam. This is amazing stuff. pls keep it up!

  • @typosbro_
    @typosbro_ 17 днів тому

    this is exactly what I needed

  • @fuu812
    @fuu812 17 днів тому +3

    I was expecting a slap as answer in stackoverflow. At least they closed it and mark it as duplicate ❤

  • @jayb555-r9k
    @jayb555-r9k 15 днів тому

    “How can I add 2 numbers in C++?”
    “boost has a function for that”
    Every. Damn. Time.

  • @jafeta.7553
    @jafeta.7553 18 днів тому +2

    I laughed a lot, thank you

  • @gadangfawwaz6389
    @gadangfawwaz6389 14 днів тому

    This video is MASTERPIECE!

  • @HealmaTech
    @HealmaTech 18 днів тому +17

    Please how comes this channel is not STACK-OVERFLOWING with views, likes and subscriptions😢
    That's weird and buggy - in fact, I am marking all existing comments as "liked"!

  • @AqgvP07r-hq3vu
    @AqgvP07r-hq3vu 16 днів тому

    This is a masterpiece

  • @testdevk
    @testdevk 17 днів тому

    Dude, you nailed it.

  • @EpicVideos2
    @EpicVideos2 18 днів тому +1

    This is the most accurate swe video i've ever seen

  • @Pikopati
    @Pikopati 15 днів тому

    The second part is missing a suggestion of not doing what the question is asking.
    And another suggesting he fix it by restarting his pc

  • @MohanadSaid-u8x
    @MohanadSaid-u8x 4 дні тому

    pfft, now in my day we dont even ask in forums

  • @C4rb0neum
    @C4rb0neum 17 днів тому +11

    So the commenters have been predicting that we only would get AI slop, when in fact we get this brilliant stuff

    • @Tyretes
      @Tyretes 17 днів тому +1

      where?

    • @windws7137
      @windws7137 17 днів тому

      Where is AI? text to speech?

    • @thatsalot3577
      @thatsalot3577 16 днів тому

      ​@@windws7137bruh it's not just TTS it's straight up voice cloning which is AI generated
      But this is still the best usecase of AI for making videos because it elevates the quality of this meme instead of degrading.

  • @Joelbu_v2
    @Joelbu_v2 16 днів тому +1

    Had a guy tell me that my post contained too much code because I put 2 different methods in it (first one caused the issue, second one was important for the first ones functionallity), turned out he only knew JS, my code was written in C and he thought the sprintf_s calls and error handling code blocks in my functions (which are really important) were unnecessary garbage that made the code unreadable and slow.
    StackOverflow is a fucked up place

    • @invven2750
      @invven2750 16 днів тому

      And I thought Stack was about being higher quality

  • @RenatBikaev-nt7hq
    @RenatBikaev-nt7hq 16 днів тому +1

    I had a question on StackOverflow. I couldn’t understand why a string variable containing a word in Cyrillic is not output to the terminal, but if I enter a word into the variable and then call it, it is output normally. My question was simply marked as a duplicate, citing that there was already a question about how to display text in Cyrillic... But that’s not what I asked, it’s still offensive.

  • @Jackson_Zheng
    @Jackson_Zheng 15 днів тому +1

    🤣🤣 you should have included Reddit as well

  • @TheJuiceReal
    @TheJuiceReal 17 днів тому +1

    I could tell you included Alfie scene just cuz you love Alfie haha

  • @vitdemidenko
    @vitdemidenko 17 днів тому +1

    So Tom and Anya acting in blinders? I should to continue watching it...

  • @gass-tube
    @gass-tube 18 днів тому

    dude! this is awesome! 🤣🤣

  • @samuelgunter
    @samuelgunter 13 днів тому

    incorrect, the stack overflow one would be closed as duplicate without any discussion

  • @entechcore
    @entechcore 16 днів тому +1

    audio editing is slightly jarring; the echo suddenly cuts off between voicelines

  • @lvcsilva
    @lvcsilva 19 днів тому +8

    accurate

  • @jinglebells-bv2lw
    @jinglebells-bv2lw 16 днів тому

    Github issues is actually pretty good

  • @ada0015
    @ada0015 18 днів тому

    you just earned a sub bro

  • @proficode
    @proficode 13 днів тому

    Wow stack overflow looks so real!

  • @lordew9476
    @lordew9476 17 днів тому

    Now we need chat version 😂

  • @helal0
    @helal0 13 днів тому

    Lol 😂😂😂😂😂😂 you forgot the voting system in stack overflow

  • @william254
    @william254 16 днів тому

    Thank god we now have ai. Chatgpt & claude can solve anything

  • @huberthurban
    @huberthurban 16 днів тому

    I don't understand any of this at all, but it's still funny!

  • @tjanos88
    @tjanos88 18 днів тому +1

    Well done 😂

  • @bhuvanasri7976
    @bhuvanasri7976 18 днів тому +1

    Damn it so accurate 🤣😂😂🤣

  • @viniciusVS8v
    @viniciusVS8v 15 днів тому

    amazingly accurate

  • @JohnJohn-fm3dx
    @JohnJohn-fm3dx 16 днів тому

    That hits me so hard 😅

  • @zelasd3125
    @zelasd3125 13 днів тому

    And then people are shocked everyone is using AI tools.

  • @yizhizhu5154
    @yizhizhu5154 16 днів тому

    We need a llm as the 3rd part!

  • @yhr4052
    @yhr4052 15 днів тому

    What about Reddit? It feels like people are less keen to post on StackOverflow by fear of getting down-voted

  • @justinstorm
    @justinstorm 14 днів тому

    Meanwhile in Reddit
    Rick:do you have any idea how much work would have to go into a machine th..
    Morty: Aha! you cant do it
    Rick:I can do anything Morty, your idea is not worth doing
    Morty:you cant do it
    Rick:there's nothing i cannot do
    Morty: A place saving video game
    Rick: you're a pos
    Morty:just say you cant do it
    Rick:I wont
    Morty:you wont say you cant
    *fu-fu -fu fu-*crash
    ....
    Morty: so are you gonna
    Rick yes im gonna fkn do it

  • @akashdahane9136
    @akashdahane9136 16 днів тому

    AI is getting better to handle this.

  • @snowsearch
    @snowsearch 16 днів тому

    did the jquery part suppose to rhyme 🥶

  • @j.jarvis7460
    @j.jarvis7460 15 днів тому

    Listen yall. Money solves these problems. Free might solve an issue here and there but it takes big money to solve big problems. (Money is an equal opportunity motivator for everyone)

  • @Fisteshak
    @Fisteshak 15 днів тому

    Everyone is hating stackoverflow but i actually had really good experience with it. Like, in 7/10 cases my question was answered in couple of days, and in remaining 3/10 it wasn't answered at all, but never had rudeness in answers or annoying mods.

  • @Q_20
    @Q_20 14 днів тому

    We're all so selfish stupid and short sighted. We're doomed.

  • @haideralibd
    @haideralibd 13 днів тому

    I am currently facing this problem😅😅. Passing a zip from php to vue js.

  • @pk_fauxtaux
    @pk_fauxtaux 16 днів тому

    That's genious

  • @RektYuan
    @RektYuan 16 днів тому

    Too real

  • @nowatcher123-g5f
    @nowatcher123-g5f 11 днів тому

    we never had these abstractions... we had jquery!

  • @azizbekibnhamid642
    @azizbekibnhamid642 19 днів тому +2

    Epic

  • @Bit_Maximum
    @Bit_Maximum 17 днів тому

    This is so true

  • @martinmitrov788
    @martinmitrov788 14 днів тому

    Unfortunately Stack Overflow turned extremely toxic. Good that it is now kind of dying due to AI and these EGO bandits, which have made the community slightly less toxic.

  • @Browncoyote
    @Browncoyote 16 днів тому

    Hilarious.

  • @mustafayazlmc3973
    @mustafayazlmc3973 19 днів тому +1

    I like it ❤

  • @1nwb-4dnws
    @1nwb-4dnws 18 днів тому

    Ah yes vue as the alt of some webUI

  • @matevzvidovic6708
    @matevzvidovic6708 18 днів тому

    amazing