Would I Repurchase These Eyeshadow Palettes?!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 78

  • @notaninfluencer4882
    @notaninfluencer4882 10 місяців тому +25

    I know space cowboy gets all the hype but lithium is the most underrated shade! I think you would prefer lithium to space cowboy. The base shade is cooler toned and the sparkle is a warmer champagne with almost a grungy green shift.

    • @melissagodwin1594
      @melissagodwin1594 10 місяців тому +4

      Agreed!! Lithium is absolute perfection. 🤩

    • @julias5980
      @julias5980 10 місяців тому +2

      *adds to list*

    • @mwebba1
      @mwebba1 10 місяців тому +2

      I love lithium and solstice

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому +1

      adds to cart hahah

    • @notaninfluencer4882
      @notaninfluencer4882 10 місяців тому

      @@MartinaLily I can’t wait to see how you like it in person!

  • @rebeccawainwright4515
    @rebeccawainwright4515 10 місяців тому +14

    I love this video! I think you should make this a repeat series!

  • @mintkandi22
    @mintkandi22 10 місяців тому +3

    Please, please, PULEEZ try the Flower Beauty palette! I have seen another UA-camr using it and it seems like a beautiful formula! I would love to see you create a look with that palette! I love my Bronze Seduction palette! I have had it for about two years. I have no complaints. Your makeup in this video is so pretty!

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Shall do for sure and thank you! 💗💗

  • @biznis9965
    @biznis9965 10 місяців тому +6

    I feel the same about Pat McGrath. I picked up Bronze seduction last year together with Moonlit seduction and the formula for me was extremely subpar, especially the mattes. even the regular shimmers are just blah. I am purely keeping them for the special shades but even those I can often dupe with smoother formulas nowadays.

  • @Desertmermaid52
    @Desertmermaid52 10 місяців тому +4

    I have the FLORASIS powder in pale lavender and it is stunning as well as the packaging! Totally agree they are a brand worth trying. ❤

  • @carinekubelec9531
    @carinekubelec9531 10 місяців тому +3

    It's such a fun idea to let your husband pick the palettes ! Yes for another video like this one 😘

  • @melina_m_makeup
    @melina_m_makeup 10 місяців тому +5

    I certainly see a vibe here!! 😂I would def pick up the PM Bronze Sseduction again. I do hear that many people have issues blending the mattes. I've never had problems with mine. It is a drier formula but I haven't had any issues and I've had my palette for 3 or 4 years. Florasis is such a good brand. I bought a lot of their products and they are amazing! The palette I regret the most purchasing is the ND I need a Nude palette. I'm sorry don't come for me but it's so boring for me. I have to add a nuetral multichrome or my indie shimmers because the shimmers in the INAN are more like toppers and they don't even last an hour on my lids even with glitter glue. That's just my opinion and I know so many will prob not like my opinion about it. 😂 I just need a palette with alot more depth. Oh and Flower Beauty is a brand Judy and Anettes makeup Corner really like and they both have very different makeup styles. I've never purchased so I'm not sure how they perform but check put their channels if you want to know more about the brand. Hope you have a lovely day Martina!!! ❤❤❤

  • @FranciscaRigaud
    @FranciscaRigaud 9 місяців тому

    Beautiful makeup, Martina... my first time here and I obviously have a lot to learn!

  • @gwendolinehall1386
    @gwendolinehall1386 10 місяців тому +2

    I loved this video concept, I'd love more musings and updated thoughts on older products and whether they still stand out to you.

  • @igapawlak9273
    @igapawlak9273 10 місяців тому

    Loved the video Martina! But I don't like your response to Clé De Peau Sea Grass Eyeshadow Quad as I thought I made peace with not picking it up, now I'm second guessing 🤣🤣💖

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Hahaha I'm sorry! 💗💗

  • @RebeccaJackson-u1e
    @RebeccaJackson-u1e 11 днів тому

    I love eye shadow, I only have like 2 palettes these days that I use constantly, I had lots of quads. Probably about 10 ish I think and then single eye shadow's. Which is probably about 10 again - I did have a clean out and get rid of quite a few. I use to b a Clarins consultant so I had ever shadow/ lipstick/ nail polish that they bought out every year. And they usually did 2 colour stories a year and bring out new foundations etc during the year. So basically every year I had a clean out as I had so much make up and I wore a different look almost every day ❤❤. Love the video, just brilliant 😊

  • @bonbauman4638
    @bonbauman4638 10 місяців тому

    Loved this video! So! I actually do have a couple of palettes that turned out to be duds: my Pat McGrath Labs Bronze Seduction was absolutely unusable for me. The shades were so dry I literally couldn't get them out of the pan and onto my eyes. It was a bummer. I threw it away because it became so anxiety inducing every time I would "give it another try." Also, at first I loved my Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyes palette, but two or three months in, same thing, it hard panned and dried up and got so dusty that putting it on and wearing it was a mess. And that beautiful green shade became unusable very quickly. It turned super-chunky and dry. So two duds!

  • @heathersargent289
    @heathersargent289 10 місяців тому +2

    The flower knows lose powder is supposedly amazing people are raving about it . I have almost bought it a few times cause they say it looks beautiful under the eyes very finally milled and nondrying. I really want another CDP quad #1#3 maybe the purple one but wish they didnt put the frangerance in them it kinda bothers my eyes but i love the green one on . Love this video, u did a great job and Shane picked some good stuff.

  • @J_loves_lu
    @J_loves_lu 10 місяців тому +2

    My bronze seduction is old at this point 😅 BUT I had zero issues with it ! Mattes were great & the entire palette impressed me ❤ now the one that I did have issues with the mattes was my original midnight sun 😅 I think it’s batch issues honestly & I adore midnight sun & bought a fresh one (stickergate) 😂 but I’m excited to try it & see if it’s better; another thing I did notice is that my OG midnight sun had a way shorter shelf life than the sticker one 😅 I found that kinda interesting 😊😆🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @kathleenmoortel5449
    @kathleenmoortel5449 10 місяців тому

    Your eyeshadow looks beautiful!

  • @hmm701
    @hmm701 10 місяців тому

    Loved this video,please do again next year, loved Shane's choices....And thank you 😊 you confirmed l don't need CT beautyverse palette

  • @everydayjanuary3648
    @everydayjanuary3648 10 місяців тому

    Such a fun vid. Your makeup looks gorgeous!

  • @atleastimgenuine3566
    @atleastimgenuine3566 10 місяців тому +4

    Should calculate how much each makeup look costs, when only using a 150$ eyeshadow 3x times and other items similarly. I’m also guilty of this. IMO to justify a 200$ palette you have to use it 100+ times. Otherwise each application of multiple high end items used

  • @lavayuki
    @lavayuki 10 місяців тому

    I have the ND glam face light palette which I bought for travel and love it. Whenever I wear it people compliment my eye look, and its become a great travel and also every day palette for me. I don’t use bronzers and never did, so the combination of shadows with sparkle shades, highlighter and blush is perfect for me to get a full look. I also the highlight for my inner corners and under my eyes sometimes

  • @megdvs21
    @megdvs21 10 місяців тому

    This is always a fun topic 🙂, hope you are having a good week love, a few i have currently that am no longer interested in repurchasing are
    Abh norvina vol 5
    Nd glam face

  • @asowell
    @asowell 10 місяців тому

    I am really impressed with the Flower Knows palette that I have based on Annette’s Beauty Corner review… It was from the Strawberry Rococo series in Black Currant Cold Brew. It’s absolutely stunning and the shimmer is gorgeous!! The new swan theme doesn’t interest me as much though…

  • @shawndickson2390
    @shawndickson2390 10 місяців тому

    I really like your honesty. You stopped me from making 2 mistakes on the Minka or the Charlotte Tillbury.
    I have several Sugar Drizzle and MBA Cosmetics palettes that are all shimmer and the colors are dazzling but I don’t do many all matte palettes so hard for me to use them. I think one or two all shimmer works but I think I have at least 10 from these 2 brands and a couple others!

  • @petra6902
    @petra6902 10 місяців тому

    Hi 😊 is there a video of all your makeup collection, beauty room tour or something like that? Would love to see it ❤

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Not an updated one but I will have one up over the next month for sure 💗💗

  • @alynnhirsch
    @alynnhirsch 10 місяців тому +2

    My 6 shades from bronze seduction are terrible. The special shades are great except maybe the one under fire opal. I bought the palette a year and a half ago.

  • @dubsbeautydiary
    @dubsbeautydiary 9 місяців тому

    Love these videos.

  • @kittencakes9836
    @kittencakes9836 10 місяців тому +2

    I bought bronze seduction 2 months ago I’m having no issues I adore that palette, but I don’t use the aubergine shade so I can’t speak for that shade.

  • @sydneybader998
    @sydneybader998 10 місяців тому +1

    I bought my Bronze Seduction about a year ago, and the only matte that sometimes gives me problems is Extreme Aubergine, and I don't know if "problems" is the correct word as much as just it needs built up a bit, and can get patchy if I don't pack on enough and try to blend out too quickly. It can get a bit blown out, but fixes relatively easily. The only shade that makes me truly sad in that palette is Gilty Pleasure. It hardpanned basically immediately. It's still useable but takes some effort, but Bronze Blaze is buttery, smooth, and gorgeous.
    As for palette I don't think I'd repurchase....Zendo from ND. Yama was my favorite ND shade until Plantasia came with Yucca, and that dark matte in there is still beautiful, especially paired in other ND palettes. But overall wouldn't repurchase as I never even think about reaching for it, sadly.

  • @katebruckner3731
    @katebruckner3731 10 місяців тому

    Really cool ☺️

  • @cynthialees2760
    @cynthialees2760 10 місяців тому +4

    I picked up bronze seduction this year and I was surprised by how different the quality is from the others. It really surprised me. It is my least favorite. I contacted PM and the sent another, as I thought it was just that palette but the one they sent was also sketchy. Certain shades didn’t work at all. So strange!

    • @elissacox4291
      @elissacox4291 10 місяців тому +1

      The colours are beautiful, but there are a couple of them that are a thick hard panned mess that need to be dug out and smeared on. Ugh!

    • @mirandaquinnn
      @mirandaquinnn 10 місяців тому +1

      Thanks so much for reporting back. The mattes on the Bronze seduction palette are not great in my palette, and I was thinking about replacing it, but it seems as it's not worth it. 😢

    • @elissacox4291
      @elissacox4291 10 місяців тому +2

      @@mirandaquinnn I picked it up during a glitch where I paid around 30% of the RRP (if that, maybe less). And mainly for the “special” shades since that green one is my favourite PML shade ever. So maybe if you see it on super special you might think it’s worth it. But yes, some of the shades are very odd textures. And yet my subversive palette that is getting on in years is still performing beautifully.

    • @rallara
      @rallara 10 місяців тому

      Never had issues with the mattes myself 🍀

  • @MaryintheCLE
    @MaryintheCLE 10 місяців тому

    ***RED ALERT: IntensifyEYES wand is now back up on Pat's site! Hopefully, that means it's not being discontinued. You sparked my love for it and now I use it on the daily. P.S. Loved the video, as usual, and picked up 2 UD Space Cowboy palettes (1 for me, 1 for a friend) from their site--had to finally bite the bullet after watching this. Hope you're having a gorgeous day! 😘

  • @PattyBookh
    @PattyBookh 10 місяців тому

    Missed watching your videos. Trying to catch up now

  • @LisaF_
    @LisaF_ 10 місяців тому

    I really like the CT holiday palette. I love the mattes and all of the shimmers.
    I have the other of the Urban Decay Moondust palette and I love it, too.
    I have that same Florasis palette. I think the quality is outstanding, too.
    I’d honestly repurchase Mothership V for just VR Fire Opal. I know that’s crazy, but I love that shade without measure. One of the regular metallics is a dude for me. Like, I can’t get it to give any pigment at all.
    The only palette I’ve gotten in the past few months I don’t think I’d repurchase is the Sugar and Spice palette. I absolutely love Glaminatrix, but I don’t like the shades or formulas of the mattes in the center row at all. I never reach for it because of that.
    Of palettes I initially loved but don’t think I’d pick up again at this point, what comes to mind is the Circo Loco palette. I loved it when I got it, but I don’t gravitate toward it much anymore and it was in the giant $125 size and I’d not spend that again for my collection now.

  • @stephaniechapman4444
    @stephaniechapman4444 10 місяців тому

    I wish you would have swatched out the flower beauty pallet

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      I will do a video for sure 💗💗

  • @coleoftheball
    @coleoftheball 10 місяців тому

    The flower beauty palettes are so gorgeous but I just would never use them they’re wayyyy too subtle for me ahaha ❤

  • @kyliejj5028
    @kyliejj5028 10 місяців тому

    My bronze seduction was bought in the summer and I was expecting the lattes to be “crispier” than I’ve found them. Will definitely retry again soon

  • @estherc6487
    @estherc6487 10 місяців тому

    I live in Aus too and have been asking Mecca staff since mid October when they will get the UD quad. They don’t even know what I am talking about haha. I purchased Glaminatrix 6 pan fairy lights palette instead. Can you tell me are the shadows similar? Is it worth purchasing both? Are the UD shadows moon dust more glittery? The CT holiday palette was a pass for me. Hugs

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Hahah honestly (and I'm sure this isn't everyone at the stores) but I feel like a lot of them don't even actually like makeup lol The amount of times I go in there asking them about new releases etc they never ever even know what I'm talking about at all its annoying lol And I really do think they are both worth it cos they are very very different formulas to each other. I would describe the UD ones as a softer subtle version 💗💗

  • @ZiggyKitty
    @ZiggyKitty 10 місяців тому

    I haaaate that the florasis palette has the lid separate from the base and disconnected entirely (held together by magnets). I’ve caught the stinkin corner of the lid in a shadow so many times it puts me off using it. Such a hassle for such a small thing.

  • @skeletongirl76
    @skeletongirl76 10 місяців тому

    I’m curious to know how you would compare the Minka palette to the Glimmering creatures from Glaminatrix. You have really influenced me in buying the latter but to my eye they look a bit similar and I already have the Minka. Thanks for a lovely video! I’d love to see more of this kind of content.

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому +1

      Oh thank you, I'm so glad you enjoyed it :) So Minka is a lot thicker and more of a chunky glitter formula. I find it to behave a lot like traditional glitter shadows but the Glaminatrix ones are more of a cream, molten metallics with sparkle but the sparkle is super super fine so doesn't behave like the more chunky glitter. I don't know if that helps at all sorry 💗💗

    • @skeletongirl76
      @skeletongirl76 10 місяців тому

      @@MartinaLily Thank you for your reply! Your description do help a lot, and I will need to buy the Glimmering Creatures. Hope you are having a lovely weekend!

  • @mariam.a.
    @mariam.a. 10 місяців тому

    Haven't commented in a while and had to say hi 💗. Hmm, I bought a quad from Suqqu a while ago which I definitely would not repurchase. Not to say their formula is bad, but that specific quad was not worth it to me.

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Hi lovely! its been such a crazy busy time hasn't it? Hmm was that your first suqqu quad? I've been wanting to try them for a while but I've never found the exact color story i want 💗💗

    • @mariam.a.
      @mariam.a. 10 місяців тому

      @@MartinaLily Haha I think we have both been crazy busy lately. You still put out so much fun videos though, love it!! 🩷
      It was a limited edition from a few years ago (I have the feeling most of Suqqu’s palettes are limited edition). It just didn’t grow on me, neither the formula nor the shade selection.
      I think their more recent releases have looked quite intriguing with some interesting textures in there so I might give them another chance.

  • @Cascadeis
    @Cascadeis 10 місяців тому +1

    Just the thought of spending more than 30 Australian dollars on a single eyeshadow is scary… That quad must be extremely good.

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      I mean honestly I'm just ridiculous lol I doubt anything is 'worth' that much money but it just depends on the eye of the beholder haha 💗💗

  • @lisanutini5183
    @lisanutini5183 10 місяців тому

    I get frustrated with Natasha Denona blushes. Are they hard panning or something?

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому +1

      Yes! So annoying 💗💗

  • @harryjamo6361
    @harryjamo6361 10 місяців тому

    What eyeshadow are you wearing?

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      Its the whats up dragon eye palette. The look will be up next week :) 💗💗

  • @Bazibishop
    @Bazibishop 9 місяців тому

    My shimmers on my mother ship bronze seduction are tight and almost hard panned. I’ve seen this is a common thing. None of my other other motherships have that issue

  • @tianiortiz8529
    @tianiortiz8529 10 місяців тому

    ❤❤

  • @dimavgo4396
    @dimavgo4396 10 місяців тому

    My name Stella κάνεις ωραίο λαμπερό Μακιγιάζ θέλω να κάνω το ίδιο Μακιγιάζ με το δικό σου ❤

  • @notimportant123
    @notimportant123 10 місяців тому +1

    While him picking palettes per his own taste is cute, I think it would be more helpful if you selected palettes that were popular or that a lot of people were interested in. E.g. Moondust, CT, both of the ND ones were interesting.

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      I can do that for sure 💗💗

  • @Anonymous-sh9vk
    @Anonymous-sh9vk 10 місяців тому

    Hi! Greeting from Texas! :How was your Thanksgiving? :)

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому

      It was amazing, thank you! How was yours? 💗💗

    • @Anonymous-sh9vk
      @Anonymous-sh9vk 10 місяців тому

      @@MartinaLily very good, thanks! Small family thing that still somehow requires hours and hours of prep/cooking. :)

  • @lisanutini5183
    @lisanutini5183 10 місяців тому

    OMG you must wear the shades in that blouse (and eye shadow) more often! As soon as I opened the video I was struck by how lovely these colors look on you.

    • @MartinaLily
      @MartinaLily  10 місяців тому +1

      Aw thank you! 💗💗

  • @RoseOfMadina
    @RoseOfMadina 10 місяців тому +2

    The CT palette is underwhelming. I feel the outer packaging is prettier than the quality of the actual shades.
    Wish the color story was a bit more cohesive and that the glitter and metallic shades just had a notch * more * umpf to them. A pastel green in there would have been nice. The three brown mattes are redundant. Hard pass to be honest.