As we have a very close look at the Russian military and its transformation it lacks a lot: a lack of maintenance,. a lack of logistics, a lack of combined arms, a lack of an NCO corps, a lack of discipline and motivation.
Yup, historia magistra vita est. Michael finished on this note, and I cant agree more. Its just a hobby of mine, since 40 years ago, and yes, one never stops learning. Michael's presentations are for me, a kind of lullaby, and I dont mean it in a derrogatory way. He presents his military thoughts in simple and logical ways, like on a platter. Not that i'm in full agreement with him on everything, but we're rarely on opposite sides.
If There Is No even the Conflict Between You And Russia What Could you Do , ? Amy Time I have Right To Defend My Independent And Sofranty I Have . I Didn't Do Any Attacks To Other Country And Didn't Do Any Aggressive In Other Country In A World . I Would Not Accept Any Aggressive From Whole Country In World. Let Alone One Or Two , three , Up To 10 , What Ever Whey Are . .
Michael Kofman is now a very popular expert. What will he do? Military actions will end sooner or later. The war between Ukraine and Russia has become a tragedy for millions of people. But Michael Kofman owes this war. She made him popular, in demand. For some, death, poverty, ruin. For others, honor, respect on the part of Western society. It seems that we have begun to forget the true causes of wars. Civilian military experts serving the military industrial complex are very dangerous people. They create a toxic information field that contributes to the outbreak of wars. civilian people do not understand the full weight of the war that falls on society. For these experts, war is a fun game, an exciting game. It feels like these guys haven't had enough of playing soldiers in childhood. They decided to put into practice their complexes and dreams. It's dangerous. These experts popularize the war. This is a dangerous phenomenon. War becomes something acceptable, something popular. And millions of people are paying for these ideas. We live in a world of ideas. The ideas that Kofman and other military experts spread, especially civilians. People who never they didn't fight, they didn't kill. People who do not know the price of war and peace. We can say that the conflict in Ukraine in 2022 was a gift of fate for Michael Kofman. But this war is a tragedy for millions of people... It can be said that drops of blood are dripping from the hands of this person... There is not much difference between Putin's conditional Ruslan Pukhov and Western Michael Kofman. Both of these people drag their countries and societies into the crucible of war. both of them defend the interests of the military-industrial complex in the public space of their communities. this is what makes war acceptable and possible. soon these experts will say that nuclear war is cool. The tragedy of millions is an opportunity for hype for a huge number of military experts, retired military. Glory and honors for some, the severity of the war, loss, death of loved ones for others... The irony of fate... The joke of the story.. In 25 years there will still be a revision of historiography, revision of ideas, revision of opinions. Opinions will change again.....
Try To Firce us Your Wrong Idea . Use Your Power And Technology and Military You Have , Test If You Force Us ,Because World Need History To Discuss Later.
I mean the myth they perpetuate to their people is that they are peer with the USA A sentiment no one in the military agrees with by the way Also that their neighbors are Russophobes cuz racism or whatever, as the Russian government continues very effectively its efforts to cover up and revise history
Hah that thick damn accent. Some of the things he said, which sounded rather important, I couldn't ascertain no matter how many times I reminded hahah. Great talk though.
That is a gross oversimplification of both Soviet and especially current Russian doctrine. Junior officers did and even more so than in the Soviet Army do have latitude to execute a number of battle drills that they are expected to apply correctly and tailor to the situation at hand. Battle drills are NOT as practiced by Arab militaries such as the Egyptians or Syrians but more analogous to Russian tactical performance in Afghanistan and in Georgia.
Dewitt Bourchier Of course I Over stared. My response was only one or two sentences long. I’m I was referring to the mid grade offices majors, lieutenant colonel’s, and colonels. But especially no professional NCONcoro.
@@WorshipinIdols The lack of professional NCOs is a weakness but there are battle drills for each level, and battalion and regimental commanders have always been expected to know them well and when in exercise practice them with low levels of interference from high command except to simulate changes in the tactical or operational situation. Of course, higher level commanders reserve the right to bypass the chain of command - but that does not mean that mid level officers are expected to be unimaginative, rigid, and have little knowledge of wielding formations autonomously.
The Russian military despite its flaws is certainly the second most powerful in the world, on land and air. There is no other military in Europe that comes close to matching Russia's overall firepower, logistics, and numbers.
non native speaker hear. i have no problem following him and he only has a very light accent imo. also non-english speakers cant understand english by definition
This "teddy bear" is more than capable of ending the world at worst, and Russian Federation itself in less awful scenario - which is still eons far from being anywhere near "best". If somebody would've not introduced sanctions - this "teddy bear" would've been questioned about it's disgustingly over-inflated scale and cost *years ago*. Sadly, we have what we have. Hope you're enjoying new Cold War even a slightest bit. I certainly do not.
@@Iwor735 Трамп Против Мадуро. Переворот в Венесуэле Hot take there bucko. What should have really happened was that the west shouldn't have allowed russian capital and corruption to enter its economies, a very tough ask and no use now but there it is. Much else that could have been done? Well I would say rather than sending a bunch of idiot true believer randite 24 year olds over to reorg russias society and economy after the fall, we should have focused above all else in splitting russia into different countries along its true pre-existing fault lines. All that effort and suddenly we forget how effective divide and rule is? No use now. So what do we do? We face reality. Start the dark arts up again, try to make some free capital at russian expense and wait for them to suffer its next external or internal crisis.
@@fredmed9742 Extremely charming that bot, navigated by tags of video that I watched nearly month ago, routs for aggressive partition of my country. And I thought these things were made to only repeat "putin is good, putin is love" mantra. Who knew.
@@Iwor735 Beep beep etc... I'm Scottish doode, not Bottish. And no, I am not calling for "aggressive partition of [your] country". I am saying that a partition of your country in 1991 accomplished through political subversion was a sitter, it was obvious. I'm saying that instead of that, the neoliberals believing their own theories in their ouroboros way, thought that capitalism was self organising. That after the 'spark' was ignited, by the aforementioned 24 year old idiots, they could stand back and watch as thousands of Gordon Geckos and Ronald Reagans sprouted up and led russia towards shoulder pads and large hairspray supported do's. I am saying partition should have been the goal of the western powers back then. It wouldn't have solved the problem for a century. But you have to admit, the peace dividend didnt really last that long after 'the end of history' was declared, did it? Doesn't help us now of course, so a pointless discussion. But, isn't the vast majority of discussion pointless anyway? So Boris baby, all I'm doing is joining in.
@@fredmed9742 Well, "scottish dude", bother to explain "Трамп Против Мадуро. Переворот в Венесуэле" text in your first reply. Is it just a miraculous glitch of the Internet that added that into your message?
Michael Kofman is MARVELOUS. Real jewel of military thinking.
Nope. He's Ukranian, lost between Lvov Galizien Nazis, and his new country america. Kofmann is dead meat.
As we have a very close look at the Russian military and its transformation it lacks a lot:
a lack of maintenance,.
a lack of logistics,
a lack of combined arms,
a lack of an NCO corps,
a lack of discipline and motivation.
Three years later... this lecture is spot on.
We need more Michael Kofman on UA-cam speaking on Russia in Ukraine 🇺🇦
Yup, historia magistra vita est. Michael finished on this note, and I cant agree more. Its just a hobby of mine, since 40 years ago, and yes, one never stops learning. Michael's presentations are for me, a kind of lullaby, and I dont mean it in a derrogatory way. He presents his military thoughts in simple and logical ways, like on a platter. Not that i'm in full agreement with him on everything, but we're rarely on opposite sides.
If There Is No even the Conflict Between You And Russia What Could you Do , ? Amy Time I have Right To Defend My Independent And Sofranty I Have . I Didn't Do Any Attacks To Other Country And Didn't Do Any Aggressive In Other Country In A World . I Would Not Accept Any Aggressive From Whole Country In World. Let Alone One Or Two , three , Up To 10 , What Ever Whey Are . .
Michael Kofman is now a very popular expert. What will he do? Military actions will end sooner or later. The war between Ukraine and Russia has become a tragedy for millions of people. But Michael Kofman owes this war. She made him popular, in demand. For some, death, poverty, ruin. For others, honor, respect on the part of Western society. It seems that we have begun to forget the true causes of wars. Civilian military experts serving the military industrial complex are very dangerous people. They create a toxic information field that contributes to the outbreak of wars. civilian people do not understand the full weight of the war that falls on society. For these experts, war is a fun game, an exciting game. It feels like these guys haven't had enough of playing soldiers in childhood. They decided to put into practice their complexes and dreams. It's dangerous. These experts popularize the war. This is a dangerous phenomenon. War becomes something acceptable, something popular. And millions of people are paying for these ideas. We live in a world of ideas. The ideas that Kofman and other military experts spread, especially civilians. People who never they didn't fight, they didn't kill. People who do not know the price of war and peace. We can say that the conflict in Ukraine in 2022 was a gift of fate for Michael Kofman. But this war is a tragedy for millions of people... It can be said that drops of blood are dripping from the hands of this person... There is not much difference between Putin's conditional Ruslan Pukhov and Western Michael Kofman. Both of these people drag their countries and societies into the crucible of war. both of them defend the interests of the military-industrial complex in the public space of their communities. this is what makes war acceptable and possible. soon these experts will say that nuclear war is cool. The tragedy of millions is an opportunity for hype for a huge number of military experts, retired military. Glory and honors for some, the severity of the war, loss, death of loved ones for others... The irony of fate... The joke of the story.. In 25 years there will still be a revision of historiography, revision of ideas, revision of opinions. Opinions will change again.....
Try To Firce us Your Wrong Idea . Use Your Power And Technology and Military You Have , Test If You Force Us ,Because World Need History To Discuss Later.
Soviet Union had popular myth and symbols. What does today's Russia offer, myth/symbol wise?
I mean the myth they perpetuate to their people is that they are peer with the USA
A sentiment no one in the military agrees with by the way
Also that their neighbors are Russophobes cuz racism or whatever, as the Russian government continues very effectively its efforts to cover up and revise history
In this CSS lecture, Michael Kofman will finally teach us how to center a div
Let Michael speak of today's deliberations... 2022.
check out war on the rocks or geopolitics decanted podcasts. michael kofman in spades
@@broculee5218 Bruce Lee... Michael opened his mouth about this war, and there is no more Kofmann. Thats it.
@@janezjonsa3165 u high?
打卡
Hah that thick damn accent. Some of the things he said, which sounded rather important, I couldn't ascertain no matter how many times I reminded hahah. Great talk though.
Andrei Sakharov calculate the force to make the ultimate boomb. Last year Russia finnst building them Putin lower the money to wepon system
The Russian militaries Achilles heel is refusing to delegate the right to take personal initiative to lower ranking commanders.
That is a gross oversimplification of both Soviet and especially current Russian doctrine. Junior officers did and even more so than in the Soviet Army do have latitude to execute a number of battle drills that they are expected to apply correctly and tailor to the situation at hand. Battle drills are NOT as practiced by Arab militaries such as the Egyptians or Syrians but more analogous to Russian tactical performance in Afghanistan and in Georgia.
Dewitt Bourchier Of course I Over stared. My response was only one or two sentences long. I’m I was referring to the mid grade offices majors, lieutenant colonel’s, and colonels.
But especially no professional NCONcoro.
@@WorshipinIdols The lack of professional NCOs is a weakness but there are battle drills for each level, and battalion and regimental commanders have always been expected to know them well and when in exercise practice them with low levels of interference from high command except to simulate changes in the tactical or operational situation. Of course, higher level commanders reserve the right to bypass the chain of command - but that does not mean that mid level officers are expected to be unimaginative, rigid, and have little knowledge of wielding formations autonomously.
@@dewittbourchier7169 This sentiment has aged poorly, while OP's has aged like wine.
You nailed it.
The Russian military despite its flaws is certainly the second most powerful in the world, on land and air. There is no other military in Europe that comes close to matching Russia's overall firepower, logistics, and numbers.
Not so sure about logistics...
Always and forever behind the United States of America
I'm British and I can just about keep up, but for any non-english speaking person, to understand that stuff at high speed with his accent. No chance!
The british hardly speak english so thats alright
non native speaker hear. i have no problem following him and he only has a very light accent imo. also non-english speakers cant understand english by definition
Yes, Ivan's military has reformed but it's still a teddy bear.
This "teddy bear" is more than capable of ending the world at worst, and Russian Federation itself in less awful scenario - which is still eons far from being anywhere near "best".
If somebody would've not introduced sanctions - this "teddy bear" would've been questioned about it's disgustingly over-inflated scale and cost *years ago*. Sadly, we have what we have. Hope you're enjoying new Cold War even a slightest bit. I certainly do not.
@@Iwor735 Трамп Против Мадуро. Переворот в Венесуэле
Hot take there bucko. What should have really happened was that the west shouldn't have allowed russian capital and corruption to enter its economies, a very tough ask and no use now but there it is.
Much else that could have been done? Well I would say rather than sending a bunch of idiot true believer randite 24 year olds over to reorg russias society and economy after the fall, we should have focused above all else in splitting russia into different countries along its true pre-existing fault lines. All that effort and suddenly we forget how effective divide and rule is?
No use now. So what do we do? We face reality. Start the dark arts up again, try to make some free capital at russian expense and wait for them to suffer its next external or internal crisis.
@@fredmed9742 Extremely charming that bot, navigated by tags of video that I watched nearly month ago, routs for aggressive partition of my country. And I thought these things were made to only repeat "putin is good, putin is love" mantra. Who knew.
@@Iwor735 Beep beep etc... I'm Scottish doode, not Bottish. And no, I am not calling for "aggressive partition of [your] country". I am saying that a partition of your country in 1991 accomplished through political subversion was a sitter, it was obvious. I'm saying that instead of that, the neoliberals believing their own theories in their ouroboros way, thought that capitalism was self organising. That after the 'spark' was ignited, by the aforementioned 24 year old idiots, they could stand back and watch as thousands of Gordon Geckos and Ronald Reagans sprouted up and led russia towards shoulder pads and large hairspray supported do's.
I am saying partition should have been the goal of the western powers back then. It wouldn't have solved the problem for a century. But you have to admit, the peace dividend didnt really last that long after 'the end of history' was declared, did it?
Doesn't help us now of course, so a pointless discussion. But, isn't the vast majority of discussion pointless anyway? So Boris baby, all I'm doing is joining in.
@@fredmed9742 Well, "scottish dude", bother to explain "Трамп Против Мадуро. Переворот в Венесуэле" text in your first reply. Is it just a miraculous glitch of the Internet that added that into your message?