Galaxy S24 Ultra vs Pixel 8 Pro: The AI Battle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 чер 2024
- The Galaxy S24 Ultra and the Pixel 8 Pro are the best phones when it comes to AI but, which one is better?
The video includes 6 categories to compare Galaxy AI against Google's AI in real-life scenarios to understand the pros & cons of each one.
#s24ultra #pixel8pro #madebygoogle #ai #galaxyai
*Chapters*
0:00 - Intro
0:25 - Gallery Apps
5:21 - Note Taking
7:28 - AI Wallpapers
8:06 - Typing & Chatting
10:50 - Recorder App
12:42 - Other
For Donations:
paypal.me/indepthtechreviews
75 Exclusive Wallpapers on Patreon (as low as $1):
www.patreon.com/posts/15-excl...
Related Videos Playlist:
• Galaxy S24
Follow me on:
Facebook: / in-depth-tech-reviews-...
Twitter: / idtechreviews
Instagram: / indepthtechreviews
Amazon Affiliate Links:
Amazon US: amzn.to/3AOk4MB
Amazon UK: amzn.to/36uXJFM
Amazon UAE: amzn.to/3k9LLcv
Amazon Canada: amzn.to/3kg0aUy
Amazon Germany: amzn.to/3hZ4zbT - Наука та технологія
Haven't enjoyed a video like this in a while. Such a great comparison.
Typing from Pixel 7 Pro.
🤣
Typing on my pixel 8
This is like the only channel to get useful information on the different features these phones offer and how to use them 👍
I had a feeling you'll make a video on this topic😂 was waiting for ur video ❤
Make sense 😀
This channel should be bigger. Glad I ran into it!
This format is brilliant. I have watched a thousand videos comparing cameras, completely splitting hairs when both have good and bad pics, I dont feel you are losing out much on either but each reviewer has a personal opinion which doesnt help decide between 2. This is real usage, and even the note some Pixel features are US only was super super helpful thank you!
S24 ultra is powerful💪 but pixel is smarter😎
yeah bro
Yea. As always work smart, not work hard. Samsung literally owned by google this time 😂
As always top quality content
Pixel has a huge AI update coming for Feb. Lets see what happens then since most of Samsung's AI comes from Google's Gemini system.
Am sure Google provided them with a less powerful version of everything, the Pixel does things better.
@@IDTR That is correct, Google AI models used for Pixel are proprietary and need G3s NPU and Googles Cloud servers. They are more advanced and more accurate
@IDTR biggest thing is samsung edits on the cloud vs Google does it on hardware. Samsung will charge for AI features from 2025 to pay for said servers. Pixel tensor is the only and best AI chipset by far.
@@yousafmahmood7910 depends who u ask, according to others the SD Gen3 is the fastest AI arm chipset, especially benchmark wise - but how useful is a fast chip when there is no Software to use it on or if it always produces a bad result compared to the "slower chip".
Great comparison video!!
Liked and subscribed!
Camera King = Pixel; Overall Phone King = Samsung; Overrated but still good = iPhone; Can't afford the other 3 but still want good stuff = OnePlus
These Gen AI features are really exciting. I'd be really interested to see this revisited in 1, 2 and 3 years time to see what new Gen AI features get added over time. As well as to see what happens on the S24U when the Gen AI features are no longer
ua-cam.com/video/sDMLqxRXvr0/v-deo.html
I thing it's all in beta phase. Real ones will be with S25 Ultra and Pixel 9 Pro.
Wait for the 10 pro obviously with new chip!😊@@arturgarncarz3631
Te mejoras cada día, enhorabuena!
I'm just wondering how is AI "unethical" all of a sudden for everyone when it comes to editing photos, but Photoshop, which has been there for decades and can do the same things, just a bit slower, is ok. 🤔
I love all the AI features and that they're becoming more accessible. 🙌🏻
I think adding other people to the shot is not a great idea to be too easy. But thanks for sharing your opinion
It can be unethical because of how easy and accessible it's becoming. People weren't willing to put hours into learning Photoshop but people will be the few seconds into this kind of stuff.
Firstly, great video. I really like the format. Unethical, by definition, means "not morally correct". Using AI to creatively change your pictures is not ethical or unethical. How you use modified photos could be unethical. However, we're not talking about use but rather AI as a tool. As @BojanTomic said, tools to creatively enhance photos have been around since the 80s. Photoshop is also not unethical, but people have used it in an unethical manner.
It could get some innocent person in a lot of trouble if used to cause trouble! I find it scary! @@IDTR
Photoshop requires some effort+skill. These new AI features allow anyone to do those things in seconds
Pixel is one uping on every categories. Very Impressive.
ua-cam.com/video/sDMLqxRXvr0/v-deo.html
Now if they could make hardware that does not self-destruct in a year or two.
I'll be impressed if one of these companies can create Ultron with their AI.
Until then, no.
@@jimdiet8534 in the past Samsung was pretty decent to self destruct itself & your house included
Nice try😂 We both know I am talking about the pixel.
Love your videos man
Excellent analysis n much needed comparison.
Good comparison. Great to see that Pixel is still doing well even though it doesn't have SD Gen 3 or equivalent processor. Also, it would have been better if you had kept summary of all the comparisons at the end.
The Pixel has the tensor cores dedicated to AI features.
Samsung is using Google's ai so that's that
Awesome video
Thanks for showing the difference 😮😮😮😮
Google's tensor G3 is specifically designed to work well with Gemini AI and that's clearly evident
Hi and thanks, very useful review
The pixel is slightly better at all categories while at the same time is also offering these features for free. Samsung is giving these features for free for only 2 years. The idea of paying for smart features on a smartphone is dumb in my opinion
How will users pay for features. By increasing phone prices ?
@@MzwandileHarmans users shouldn't have to pay for features (provided by the smartphone company) on their own phone
@@MzwandileHarmans they are offering the ai features on samsung for a limited time. After which you will have to pay a monthly fee with a samsung membership to use it... it's what making me choose the pixel over the samsung.
Ive done my own comparrison with my 24 and p8p and the Pixel is much better in finding objects to erase. With my S24 i had object left floating.
What icon and theme do you have on the Pixel? The black and white icons and the lightbulb background is so nice!
Very good keep it up bro
Very good comparison on the 2 phone regarding to their AI feature!
شغلك رائع والله وقناة اسم على مسمى فعلا
بس اتمنى في المراجعات بعد كدا تحط مثلا تحسب نسبة سطوع الشاشة بس كدا انما مؤاجعات رهيبة ومليانة تفاصيل ومش طويلة
استمر في تقديم محتوى ممتاز ❤❤❤
Keep providing great content ❤️🩹
Desperately waited for this one.
Wow the pixel really holds its own against the mighty s24 ultra!
Actually the opposite is surprising. But that would probably not last for long. Google is basically an AI company now and it would be not a long way before we see all of Google's advancements on their mobile devices
Hi what's all your take on both phones, I'm toying between the two for my next phone?
Thanks
I'm really comparing them and the one thing that really has me deciding a lot is the fact that I want an actual rectangle shaped screen and I don't want things being cut, I'm also fed up with cameras being in the actual screen as some random dot, I just want to see a screen shape like my TV with nothing in the way.
Bro can you tell me how many AI feature works on device (without internet) ?? Because they said Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 have very powerful NPU…
Only a few of them work offline like the Grammer and spelling correction as well as the tap and hold for slow-mo while most of them require internet like generative ai photo editing and writing style
i wish people would pay a little attention to 16:9 aspect ratios too, i get it that most people watch things on mobile now but at least keep in mind the cropping area of a 16:9 monitor when adding useful graphic overlays. at the moment the choice is either have useless black bars at top or bottom or lose some information. it's not that hard to pay a little attention to the rest of the users.
Hello I had a question. I wanted to know how good the quality of the s24 ultra camera is when UPLOADED on instagram. My s23+ stories look absolutely terrible and look like it was 720p, it doesn't even support 60fps smooth video on Instagram. I just wanted to know if I will face the same sort of issues with the s24 ultra since Samsung said they worked with instagram. If anybody has an s24 ultra please let me knoe
Salute Sir ❤
From Afghanistan 🇦🇫
Isnt the SGS24U supposed to be based on Googles Ai? When will samsung update the Ai or should i say when will google help them with the update because S24U working on android will always be at a handicap software wise.
Great video! How does speech to text compare in Gboard on them?
Google takes this one. It's more accurate, and you can edit text with your voice too, which is not a possibility on the Samsung.
Thank you! I had the very first Samsung note and then several other editions afterwards. But then I made the switch to pixel and I have to say that I use the speech to text in gboard and find it so much more useful than scribbling notes on my phone. I can do it when walking down the road without having to stop. I think this is a very overlooked feature and one of my favourite things about the Pixel.
Thanks for this, I have 8 Pro now, S24 Ultra arriving on Wednesday. I find the magic eraser on my 8 Pro is still hit & miss the same as my 7 Pro was, it's far from perfect still. I'm reading from several users of S24 Ultra that the camera isn't top notch, and from others it is, I'm a bit worried it won't match my 8 Pro, but I'm hoping it will as the Samsung has more camera options overall. ❤
why are you buying so many phones so frequently?
10:18 - Emad, there's a proofread option on Gboard that does the entire sentence. You don't have to do it individually, thr symbol is an A and a checkmark like [A✓]
Do you need the photo to be in the cloud on s24 like on pixel?
Do the Pixel's generative tools work on the photos in gallery or I have to sync them to Google photos in other to apply the effects?
Long time pixel user here. Currently on the pixel 8 Pro. The only feature I know of that requires it being uploaded to the cloud is video boost which isn't really an AI feature. And I can't really say with 100% certainty that there aren't other features that require an upload to Google photos because all of mine get uploaded to Google photo so I wouldn't really know the difference. But even if you had to upload it, you could do your changes and then delete it off of Google photos
LOVE PIXEL MORE
Thank you for the video. What I am interested in knowing is for pixel owners, how important is the call screening function, and is it important enough to not switch to another phone.
With the spelling and grammar section, on the Pixel you can fix it in one shot when you hit the punctuation and then the space bar. It comes up with a "Fix it" button and fixes the whole thing.
Did you get the pixel january drop uodate?
This video really needs more views
That's why i own both and kicked out iPhone
It was expected considering how mature Google's AI is with it's Tensor TPU integration. Sadly no top reviewers talked about it while praising the AI on S24 series.
Also, many countries don't have Pixel's call screening so Samsung is better in providing services globally. The notes app is also impressive.
شغلك حلو و افكارك جديدة
عاش فشخ
Picked the 24 ultra as in my country the 8 pro is extremely close to the 24 ultras price point at which 24 ultra is a better buy.
However in the US, P8P is significantly cheaper and I can see why people pick that instead.
even in the EU the p8p is already pretty cheap to buy compared to the s24u.
10:10 Gboard can do it all at once too, if you press the button to the left of the suggestions there is a button that is an A✔️ and by pressing it you get multiple options on how to correct the spelling and grammar all at once.
Also, you can clearly see the magic composed button on The s24 ultra as well but he doesn't mention it lol. One thing guys that you can also do is you can switch to Gboard on the s24 ultra and get all of the same features you're getting on your Pixel device
Hey, did you know that the Generative Edit feature on the Galaxy phone can remove, change clothes, and even regenerate hair and all facial features? It's pretty cool, and the S-Pen comes in handy for drawing accurately.
I know an Egyptian brother when i see one. So subscribing. All jokes aaide this is a very informative & important video that one might've not considered. But it's even more important since this year high end smartphone want to label themselves as the AI or smartest phone of them all. The pixel wins for me here but Samsung did a good job as well. I personally like the vanilla Android of Pixel & really am annoyed with bloatware on my current Samsung phone. I really hope these features & that beautiful blue colour 💙 😍 also comes on Pixel 8A, because i so look forward to going back to a Pixel phone. Thanks for the video. Thoroughly enjoyed it
Google has massive amount of datasets, that's why, when it comes to accuracy in generative AI. No one can beat Google. Google improved the AI era day by day, but Samsung also did a very good job.
Are all these ai features available for vanilla Pixel 8 too?
Yes
Yes, exceot video boost.
Great work! Always watching your well documented videos. The Pixel's screen looks so much better. I am not sure why people say that Samsung is the best. That white looks blueish and transparent. Deal breaker.
ua-cam.com/video/sDMLqxRXvr0/v-deo.html
Anti Reflective coating. Keeps the same colour and contrast in all lighting conditions
ua-cam.com/video/RTJr_y-UReM/v-deo.htmlsi=oEYNiUriF7t12Mqo
Both have great screens but the S24U has a better one.
You can literally change it to vivid or just adjust thr color to your own liking and balance them out.....
AI in Google Keep is in development or rather hidden and locked server-side, but worked for a while and very good.
Pixel cameras are years ahead of Samsung. My old pixel 3A takes clear images than my s23. Its disappointing.
I think that this test is too early because the Galaxy S24 ultra hasn't received its final (launching) firmware yet while the pixel 8 pro has already received a lot of software updates that makes its IA more stable and more efficient...
You missed call screen features?
Can someone please make clear where on device does the AI processing on device while the other one sends it off to the cloud? Specifically as it regards to the transcription and note taking functionality.
They both do certain things on device. For instance, when it comes to doing things on device I would say the s24 ultra is doing more on device right now than the pixel is
Its not a battle at all lol. Google created the AI
To be honest while Google has better AI samsung has better track record and despite google making it the s23 series and s22 series are getting all the galaxy AI while the s22 series and s23 fe miss out on instant slow mo, pixel didn't even give pixel 8 galaxy AI.
Something like Samsung's Writing style (device-wife) and Grammar correction can be gotten on third party keyboards like Microsoft SwiftKey.
I like this comparison demo it show Google Pixel 8 Pro is still in the game except being disadvantages with the Live translation Ai utility. 😎💯💪🏿👍🏿
Early days yet for S24U. Software updates will make it a top notch. Great work ! Samsung
Google won't stop updating their phones as well. They always improve.
funny thing is most of the feature ran by Samsung is provided by google
@@RahulRoy-tl1iq yeah and all the features that are samsung exclusive for now are already announced for the pixel phones as well
You shouldn't have to argue, because if you watch galaxy unpacked SAMMY & GOOGLE really work together!!
ua-cam.com/video/sDMLqxRXvr0/v-deo.html
How Samsung notes is better than keep is crazy
This comparison is focused on AI and Keep Notes doesn't have any just yet
@@IDTRan article from 9to5google(if I remember correctly,)stated that the update coming in February will include A.I features in keep notes, Google home, UA-cam (world wide release)and other apps.
Good job on covering all of this. But am I the only one that doesn't care about most of this stuff? The only thing out of all of this that I like and would use is the circle to search. I am looking forward to getting that one on my Pixel 8.
لسه بدات اتابعك امبارح
عرفت ان اسمك باش مهندس عماد
عندي سؤال ليك
انا عايز اجيب موبايل متطور يعيش معايا ٥ سنين
ايه رايك بين الاتنين دول
S24 ULTRA
ولا ال
Pixel 8 pro
متردد بين الاتنين مش عارف اختار ايه منهم
مهم عندي جزء الذكاء الاصطناعي وان الجهاز يكون قوي ويتحمل ٥ سنين بدون مشاكل
لاني شغال فى مجال ال Marketing ف لازم موبايل فيه خصائص Creative ومميز
ترشحلي ايه فيهم ؟!
اول مرة اعرف انى بشمهندس 😀 بس انا خريج تجارة على فكرة.
ال بيكسل اكيد احسن فى ال AI والكاميرا والاداء ممتاز وارخص.
الحلو فى ال s24u الشاشة البروسيسور والبطارية وطبعا موضوع الضمان، لو انت فى بلد عربي الSamsung هيديك ضمان البيكسل لا.
@@IDTR
🤣🤣🤣
بص طول عمرنا متعودين ان اي حد بيشتغل ف اي مجال بيتقاله بمجاله فل يا هندسه 🤣
انا شغال ف الماركتينج لطب الاسنان وخريج علوم بيقولولي يا دكتور معرفش ليه 🤣
المهم انا في الخليج السعوديه .. والتشتت بين الموبايلين دول..
بس انت رايك كده ال S24U هيبقا افضل للحاله دي ..
Outstanding thorough comparison. You deserve an award for this one, and for the one confronting iPhone users 😂.
I hate to be labeled as an Apple hater, but I show why I think they have a lot of problems that no one talks about, but people don't like that.
Apple is very exclusive, they don't care much about what their user's need unlike Android and Windows which has a very open community for improvement, suggestions and troubleshooting (ex. XDA and TEAMOS).
One thing that I really don't like about Apple is that they become too greed unlike before, because their product wasn't meant to last and you are forced to go to repair shop or have it replaced/upgrade an example is Apple's Li-ion Battery health (not percentage) which degrades faster than Li-Polymer battery. Apple always brag their processor and integrated gpu of having better Antutu results but what is the point of having fast cpu and gpu if it has no decent cooling system at all that's why it thermal throttles when playing heavy games for long period.
You forgot to mention the "proofread" feature for the Pixel using Gboard in the typing category. You press one button and it auto corrects all your grammar and spelling
can you pls tell me how to use it
@@M.Adhnaanthere's a button that appears when you highlight text that looks like a capital A with a checkmark next to it, tap that and it will proofread what you selected. it's only on pixel 8 series btw
I don't have this one, but I heard about it, does it work in all apps?
@IDTR Yes it works in all apps just click the proofread icon in the keyboard after you typed the sentence.
this is mentioned on launcher of p8.@@IDTR
Plus with the pixel you dont have to wait for updates.Every year that passes the s24 is going to take longer and longer to get the updates since the newest device is going to be first in getting the updates
Good
Such a nice comparison ❤
Watching from Pixel 8 pro 👀
Super glad i switch to pixel phone.. 📱😀 dont have the 8 pro though 😅
Torn between these 2 beasts,.. mostly will use for videos and photos which one is the best choice.. oops and also translate and interpreter..
You forgot to revise Bixby Custom Voice. It is a silly feature but very cool as you can train your own AI model. Now Bixby talks in my voice.
Where is the conclusion? 🤔
its left for audience
Pixel Better in typing,voice typing translation, proofread , emoji kitchen, A. I wallpapers, recorder app while Samsung better in erasing some part or replacing a person in an image, notes and article summaries.
I hope we get this gallery update on pixel 6 series
Microsoft SwiftKey Keyboard provides similar (but limited)of the features even in iOS
My question is are these AI features available across all the models of each phone after the galaxy has 3 models
We want Pixel8/8pro astrophotography video...
3:25 this thig we also can do other Photo editing softwares... So not only this feature is for unethical use
10:07 wrong. There's a check writing option on gboard that will let you correct mistakes on sentences. It looks like an A with a checkmark.
Even though I'm a Samsung fan, I would prefer Google in this.
So all these new features are only for pixel 8 series cause I'm using 7pro and I haven't received any of these updates
Shamefully discriminating.. ain't so
Shamefully many of these ai feature are not available for normal 8 either
They are, you just hating lol. Pixel 8 doesnt have Video Boost. Thats it!@@user-hq8iq8im1u
Many are region-locked on the Pixel. Also, Samsung only has them on the S24U, though the S23U will get them in Q2-Q3/2024. So both are the same as the Pixel 9 will be Google's 2024 phone, as is the S24U.
What about AI Calls?
What about voice typing?
I did a comparison about that a long time ago, and nothing has changed since then. The win goes to the Pixel for this one
Im genuinely impressed by both devices
I love my pixel
Did you face any problem with the singl abd networks
My area has a strong signal, not the best person to ask for this
Pixel still the smartest smartphone in the market 📚 🤓
If google see this vid or get their hands on the S24 ultra and give update on some missing features that s24 ultra have it would be perfect
The question is how can we trust both pictures are taking in the same phone ?
First commenter💯🇿🇲
Wow, I thought that the sheer amount of raw performance from the Snapdragon chipset on the S24 would allow Samsung to take the advantage, but Pixels results were way ahead of Samsung's.
Have to keep in mind Samsungs ai features are still using googles cloud and servers, exactly the same as pixel so speed wouldn't really be a big difference and Google has tailored and optimized their own features to their own device the best.
You missed out when someone ring you in Arabic it can translate in real time to other languages. On pixel has Call screen, also translate in other languages also.
Thanks once again Emad.
I am definitely a Google Fan, (I have the 6 Pro) and am very pleased to see Google holding their own.
To be as candid as possible, I must admit I like Samsungs Hardware, preferring square corners to the rounded corners.
I'm hoping Google will follow suit in their future Phones. (Hardware Only)
Have a great weekend ✨
JaneLee - in Suburban Philadelphia
1/28/24
Should try the live translation by talking random people with different languages and which phone is more useful
Overall, day to day functions...I will stick with my Pixel 8 Pro over the Samsung 24 Ultra. The biggest reason is update on Google is fairly fast and their phones generally gets better over times whereas Samsung lacks the overall efforts on their department and each of "last year's iteration" gets phase out as quickly as the newest one with little to no support. Update has always been a doozy with Samsung...its always everyone first then even then, Samsung will have to think twice just to make sure they are willing to follow up. I remembered when Samsung Note 4 and its VR was touted as revolutionary only to find out next year. Silent, no support and they moved on...this isn't an isolated incident. Remembered Samsung's 108mp camera on their S22? Yeah, just like that...its forgotten and support can wait. Instead, they push for a 200mp, 300mp, 500mp (sarcasm)....at 108mp let a lone 200mp. I expect the phone's camera to literally make Google's photo look like amateur stuff but no....2XXXX doesn't meant squat when 6 months in and the phone is already slowing down and the typical stuff isn't all it cracked up to be. Overall, the Pixel photos still wins hands down on various blind study and their night sight let alone now having "manual" mode really pushes the gap wider. I thought about going back to Samsung but as an everyday phone, the Pixel 8 Pro is a hard phone to beat overall! Sure the whole AI stuff feels gimmicky at this moment but overtime...Google's AI is unmatched.
Dang. Some of the features in samsung are honestly more practical. Im still waiting for the day when i can create stickers from photos on the pixel..
The thing is they're both going to have the same features in the future anyway, Samsung just came out and they always update couple months later