@@stefanomacobi7713 Very, very very generous of him to admit that. I think this is a poor performance of this wonderful, magical sonata, even taking into account when it was recorded. Lots and lots of false notes, very weird (to say the least) changes of mood and time...very poor performance.
Sehr phantasievolle Interpretation! - not bad at all... Das Stück wirkt so, als ob Schumann selbst spielen würde - also wie aus dem Augenblick improvisiert - Das wagt heute niemand mehr - leider! - Die Ungenauigkeiten nehme ich gern in Kauf, wenn ich solch inspiriertes Klavierspiel erleben kann...
@@danielandforok Yeah...pretty lame, in fact. Even worse if compared to Kissin, Perahia or . Perhaps someone messed electronically with the tempo, in particular the first movement. That's not Schummann, notes aren't clear enough...very, very bad!
@@danielandforok Yes I do and, in fact, I am working on this wonderful sonata right now. Of course, I am not Gieseking...but even now I'd say my interpretation of the part I've already mastered are better than Gieseking's in this performance.
My favorite performer of this sonata...
Very generous from you, emilgilels, to admit that!
@@stefanomacobi7713 Very, very very generous of him to admit that. I think this is a poor performance of this wonderful, magical sonata, even taking into account when it was recorded. Lots and lots of false notes, very weird (to say the least) changes of mood and time...very poor performance.
Sehr phantasievolle Interpretation! - not bad at all...
Das Stück wirkt so, als ob Schumann selbst spielen würde - also wie aus dem Augenblick improvisiert - Das wagt heute niemand mehr - leider! - Die Ungenauigkeiten nehme ich gern in Kauf, wenn ich solch inspiriertes Klavierspiel erleben kann...
Wann können wir solches spielen hören heutzutage? Leider niemals!
@@luizfernandg Wann können wir heutzutage ein solches Spiel hören? Zum Glück nie!
22:53
This is all vision! (...we're all execution...)
Connoisseurship unwittingly conspires to kill Art
Bad
@@danielandforok Yeah...pretty lame, in fact. Even worse if compared to Kissin, Perahia or . Perhaps someone messed electronically with the tempo, in particular the first movement. That's not Schummann, notes aren't clear enough...very, very bad!
@@danielandforok Yes I do and, in fact, I am working on this wonderful sonata right now. Of course, I am not Gieseking...but even now I'd say my interpretation of the part I've already mastered are better than Gieseking's in this performance.
The best