Crosby, Stills & Nash - Girl from the North Country (HD)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 177

  • @fms3696
    @fms3696 Рік тому +14

    The wind on the water has carried David home ...
    R I P !!!

  • @johnanderson8096
    @johnanderson8096 3 роки тому +12

    Flat out BEAUTIFUL!!!! so Happy these Dudes bumped into each other...thank you Joni!!!

  • @AleeshaWeesha
    @AleeshaWeesha 11 років тому +50

    Their aged voices seeped in experiences that include love and heartbreak make the song that much better. Sometimes music isn't about the technical aspect but about the emotion. :)

    • @ARichardP
      @ARichardP 3 роки тому

      Great comment.

    • @chrisgleason1344
      @chrisgleason1344 2 роки тому

      What a perfect and spot on comment. Yes, exactly. What I was thinking as I listened.

  • @SuperBSmeter
    @SuperBSmeter 10 років тому +24

    Thank you for giving this song the dignity, heart, and soul that it needs when it shows up on the internet. God bless you and your's David, Steve, and Graham.

  • @CheetoSantana
    @CheetoSantana 10 років тому +86

    I absolutely love this version, but the Cash and Dylan version will always be my favorite. It is truly a great song.

    • @MrShamus07
      @MrShamus07 5 років тому +4

      Mine too!

    • @rayokoa222
      @rayokoa222 5 років тому +3

      me too

    • @larrylinn8589
      @larrylinn8589 5 років тому +16

      Back in 1969, I went to Vietnam as a common 11B Infantryman. Our nation was divided at the time, and when I got out into the field, everyone wanted to know what was new. I told them than Johnny Cash and Bob Dylan just had a fantastic duet called "Girl From The North Country". Nobody believed me.

    • @BeachBadger78
      @BeachBadger78 4 роки тому

      CheetoSantana Nashville Skyline

    • @BeachBadger78
      @BeachBadger78 4 роки тому +1

      CheetoSantana Ian & Sylvia

  • @leeblackmore3025
    @leeblackmore3025 Рік тому +2

    Was so lucky to see them live around 2015 in Wales.

  • @catherine4958
    @catherine4958 3 роки тому +7

    Utterly gorgeous harmony

  • @wygakyl
    @wygakyl 9 років тому +22

    I still remember sitting in the 4th row at Oakland Coliseum, for the Bridge School Benefit 1988, when both Dylan and CSN&Y played, and watching Crosby and Neil Young watching Dylan's set from the wings....still fans, after all those years...it was a special feeling.

    • @JuanJesusCarandellMifsut
      @JuanJesusCarandellMifsut 9 років тому +2

      +wygakyl Tuviste suerte de estar allí.

    • @wygakyl
      @wygakyl 9 років тому +8

      It was the only concert I ever planned to be at the ticket place, when they went on sale...I waited at 4AM, and was 1st in line!

    • @timeeh3052
      @timeeh3052 9 років тому +8

      +wygakyl That's such a nice story. I had a similar special feeling at my first Neil Young concert. He was rockin' so hard on his guitar and all I could do was trying hard to hold my tears and enyoing every single note. Worth every Cent I spent!
      Musicians who really love what they are doing and can convey this feeling to the audience and theire music is one of the most beautiful things in the world for me.

    • @42awww
      @42awww 8 років тому +2

      Great post!!

  • @sharonklinger912
    @sharonklinger912 2 роки тому +7

    Just so very awesome to see all three of the guys on stage and still rock in!!!

  • @charliebrown5611
    @charliebrown5611 3 роки тому +3

    N-I-C-E!!!! Always loved this song.

  • @MattDougan
    @MattDougan 11 років тому +12

    so beautiful...the guys still have it.

  • @mlangbert
    @mlangbert Рік тому

    CSN do a great cover of one of my favorite songs. Thank you.

  • @42awww
    @42awww 8 років тому +6

    Outstanding!!

  • @davedicko
    @davedicko 12 років тому +4

    Excellent!!!!! fantastic cover.

  • @ShunyamNiketana
    @ShunyamNiketana 9 років тому +11

    A beautiful song of love & loss. Many covers, all strong.

    • @juilietpritchard6560
      @juilietpritchard6560 4 роки тому

      well said

    • @thomaskelly8101
      @thomaskelly8101 3 роки тому

      It’s a bitter sweet thing of teen first love
      We all have a ‘Girl from the North Country’ in our lives……beautiful harmony and Stephen Stills guitar play captures the sadness and angst of young love

  • @thomaskelly8101
    @thomaskelly8101 3 роки тому +6

    The harmony and tempo are perfect for this great Dylan song

  • @rknrlgrl6146
    @rknrlgrl6146 5 років тому +3

    Beautiful cover ❤️

  • @bradmossman7201
    @bradmossman7201 2 дні тому

    I play this song regularly with my band.

  • @saturnn77
    @saturnn77 3 роки тому +4

    Dylan was a true poet, great rendition.

    • @mellongfield9873
      @mellongfield9873 4 місяці тому +1

      Dylan ain’t dead, and is still writing

  • @mirennejackrabbit7110
    @mirennejackrabbit7110 5 років тому +1

    gives me a chill ----gorgeous

  • @seili59
    @seili59 11 років тому +1

    Immer wieder SUPER!!!

  • @Philc231
    @Philc231 10 років тому +6

    I can not get this one out of my head . I must grab a guitar and learn it and teach it to my friends.,

    • @coltonnovak1887
      @coltonnovak1887 5 років тому +1

      Edward R. Ryerson or the Wilfred Sykes?

  • @paulfox1210
    @paulfox1210 7 років тому +3

    Tha lads should try to get tickets for the current show at the Old Vic then get themselves on to do this as an encore to what is one brilliant musical play. Praise be to Bobby and to the best ever...'Crosby, Stills & Nash'.

  • @JivinJane
    @JivinJane 11 років тому +2

    Beautiful. Angels that sound like a whole heavenly choir.
    Better and better. Thanks so much CSN.

  • @rocksinger45
    @rocksinger45 11 років тому +4

    I hope you can even sing at all when you reach their age...Great cover of a Bob Dylan Classic

  • @laurinewman7850
    @laurinewman7850 Рік тому +1

    Legend band. ❤

  • @davidklepinger4809
    @davidklepinger4809 2 місяці тому

    Joe Cocker and Leon Russell sang this on Mad Dogs and Englishmen, for Bob Dylan who was in the concert hall at the time. My favorite version.

  • @AleeshaWeesha
    @AleeshaWeesha 11 років тому +1

    I can understand why you'd say that at the same time there would be many fans who would be disappointed if they stopped. Just proves that everyone has an opinion and artists aren't going to be able to please all the people all the time. :)

  • @Thundergod129
    @Thundergod129 11 років тому +6

    CSN have so much of their own material but one of my favourites is Blackbird, not to be confused with the Stills classic Bluebird from his Buffalo Springfield days. The former, written by Sir Paul McCartney is covered with their trademark 3 part harmonies to perfection. A good rendition is on the Daylight Again DVD....

  • @joycemitchell2116
    @joycemitchell2116 2 роки тому +1

    Love it!

  • @gianvittoredeboni1647
    @gianvittoredeboni1647 3 роки тому

    All they touch turns to gold,, ... in this case ... I don't know.... AS Bob and Bob and Johnny......when a song is very good, there in nothinhg much to add., Love!

  • @08shortstop
    @08shortstop 10 років тому +6

    I love Still's backstory and the careful treatment of one of Bob's gems. ... Graham forgot his traveling shoes.

  • @allanfifield8256
    @allanfifield8256 4 роки тому +2

    Jesus! Great Harmony!

  • @irishfield1
    @irishfield1 5 років тому +2

    Tops ever awesome ever thank you

  • @cinnaco
    @cinnaco 2 роки тому

    You Nailed it Jan

  • @thewordofgord
    @thewordofgord 4 роки тому

    Classic version of this timeless ballad. An more from this gig.

  • @foreleftyall
    @foreleftyall 9 років тому +7

    if you're wondering why Jerry Garcia was willing to exchange playing on David's album for David teaching the Dead about harmony...chills.

    • @GGT950
      @GGT950 2 роки тому

      It didn’t help that much. It really unfortunate listening to classic live dead & the singing swing between ok & out of key. They needed a lead vocalist & never got one. The lady whose husband was on piano helped keep bobby from to manny boo boos

  • @hansdevente
    @hansdevente 5 місяців тому +1

    Best ever harmony

  • @mjg11668
    @mjg11668 9 років тому +1

    awesome CSN

  • @tonyschram1260
    @tonyschram1260 6 років тому +3

    Nice cover, especially the finger style guitar.

  • @psalmer5690
    @psalmer5690 10 місяців тому

    Lovely treatment of this beloved song. I also like what Nitty Gritty Dirt Band did with it. Dylan didn't come up with this song out of thin air. Paul Simon's Scarborough Fair is from the same English folk song and there are many other versions.

  • @agaafear
    @agaafear 10 років тому +9

    These guys always give me goose pimples - harmonies are superb.

    • @juilietpritchard6560
      @juilietpritchard6560 4 роки тому

      after not hearing it for say 30 years.....the harmonies nearly knocked me over...(.not this song tbh.....)

  • @TheYoyotiti
    @TheYoyotiti 10 років тому +1

    Good by the greatest pop singers of the USA !

  • @paigeberse4527
    @paigeberse4527 10 років тому +8

    Great song lot's of nice comments, but for some reason that raspy Joe Coker version still does it for me, pure emotion. RIP joe

  • @bjarnijuliusson1888
    @bjarnijuliusson1888 5 років тому +2

    Love IT

  • @skabibble
    @skabibble 3 роки тому

    i Do Love This..

  • @Pan3405
    @Pan3405 5 років тому +1

    Wowwwww… like the older days!!!

  • @williefinn4932
    @williefinn4932 8 років тому +5

    obviously a great song....dylan`s unique live version on youtube with smith playing along side him too is hard to beat.....nobody had that intense, eccentric sneering drive like dylan....CSN take it at a more leisurely pace, with beautiful hamonies/

  • @danwaldie4661
    @danwaldie4661 4 місяці тому

    Beautiful Bob Dylan song.

  • @jrh11254
    @jrh11254 5 років тому +3

    Let’s not forget the classic cover by Joe Cocker & Leon Russell on the Mad Dogs & Englishmen LP!

  • @reliablebow
    @reliablebow 10 років тому +1

    sweetness

  • @richardricca8012
    @richardricca8012 5 місяців тому

    One afternoon, 1971, my friend Doug Finley invited me to come up and spend the weekend at his family's home. Little did I know that neighbors next door were Crosby. Stills, and Nash, just happening to be they're one afternoon and they play some tunes. I didn't see Doug after that. He was shipped off to who knows where.
    It wasn't until later that year, I was shipped off to South Korea. I was standing on sidewalk waiting for the bus to take me to my company, when all of of a sudden I hear the sound of someone burning rubber fromtires. Out of nowhere this Army jeep comes around the corner and passes me by. Driver slams on his brakes, puts it in reverse and stops next to me and I hear him shout out to me, "Rick is that you?" I said yes, and he proceeded to take me up to my, Company in camp Casey, South Korea.
    We saw each other occasionally while we were stationed in South Korea. And then when we both got out. We occasionally communicated by telephone. One time, when my friend Charles Carney and I drove up to San Francisco. We proceeded to go North into Mendocino county and see Doug again. Some years later, I found out if he passed away from a heart attack. I miss you so very much. And I want to dedicate today to Doug, because it's Crosby's birthday and also my friend's birthday as well. Happy Birthday Doug and David. ✌️❤️🙏

  • @giuseppealciatore5156
    @giuseppealciatore5156 2 роки тому

    Immenso Stills

  • @Robbo57
    @Robbo57 Рік тому

    Marvellous

  • @flyerphil
    @flyerphil 11 років тому +3

    Excellent rendition by the guys of Dylan's classic. where was this filmed.? A great video close up with no distraction or noise from audience

  • @lynmae3474
    @lynmae3474 11 років тому +11

    proud to be a 'girl from the north country'

    • @Mostafa20268
      @Mostafa20268 5 років тому +1

      OHH ..HOW A LOVELY COMMENT !!

    • @lizlawley6680
      @lizlawley6680 5 років тому +1

      Me too, Lyn Mae!

    • @RSVPini
      @RSVPini 5 років тому +1

      @@lizlawley6680 - Please see that you're wearing a coat so warm, to keep you from the howling winds.

  • @wilmusic2
    @wilmusic2 5 років тому +4

    does anyone know what model Martin he's playing??

    • @gowwar491
      @gowwar491 5 років тому

      wilmusic2 I was about to ask the same question...

    • @donkeninitz4590
      @donkeninitz4590 4 роки тому +1

      His signature 0-45. It's a 12-fret model and if you look closely you can see his signature inlaid at the 12th fret. It's based on the guitar on the album cover of his first solo album, where he's sitting on a bench in the snow with a toy giraffe to his right (while he's got a burning cigarette tucked in the pinky of his picking hand while playing what was undoubtedly a ridiculously valuable guitar - note the slotted headstock). Martin also made signature 000-45 and D-45 models for him, but the D-45 is the most significant. IIRC, only 91 pre-war D-45s were made; only 87 have been accounted for, and Stephen owns two of them (he calls the main one "Mother Maybelle). So when Martin made his D-41 signature model they only made 91, and he got the first two. They sold out immediately at their list price of $17,500, and now - if you can find one - they go for $25K - $30K.

  • @simonpickles6811
    @simonpickles6811 3 роки тому +8

    Interesting that the version by Dylan & Cash changes the chords to a simple G, Bminor, C, G all through. I think this excellent version uses same chords as Dylan's original. Also Dylan & Cash's harmonies are less "conventional" let's say, but wonderful none the less.

  • @jarrowmarrow
    @jarrowmarrow 10 місяців тому

    These guys adapted their own take on Dylans beautifully adapted Parsley sage Rosemary and thyme. The oldest anti war song in the English language.You gotta love how art evolves.

  • @cliffsandifer3877
    @cliffsandifer3877 Рік тому

    Grahms animations are so divine

  • @musicola7371
    @musicola7371 Рік тому

    "Freewheelin" - The original is still the greatest.

  • @fms3696
    @fms3696 Рік тому

    The most beutiful love son ever wtitten ......
    An they do it exceptcionally ....

  • @venetia6296
    @venetia6296 4 роки тому

    Life is so weirdly awesome

  • @1992Maton
    @1992Maton 2 роки тому

    I like the way they sing "shield her from the howling wind"

  • @jogirl770
    @jogirl770 11 років тому +1

    I liked it! They are true

  • @situpfrontful
    @situpfrontful 11 років тому

    You really should look over to the right and click on the Black Crowes version.

  • @michaelbuckland2819
    @michaelbuckland2819 10 років тому +9

    This is a nice version. But Bob's original on Freewheelin' is hand's down the best. Yes many have cited Johnny and Bob's classic version from Nashville Skyline. Here's the problem with that one: For some unknown reason, they left out the verse that makes the whole song. I'm a wondering if she remembers me at all. Many times I've often prayed, in the darkness of my night in the brightness of my day. This verse takes the song from a nice simple ballad and makes it a masterpiece.

    • @rattleshakti
      @rattleshakti 10 років тому +1

      Yes I noticed that too, I've been singing this song for 40 odd years without knowing of this verse -Doh-. I don't know why they left out such a lovely lyric. I like CS&N but this version seems a bit overdone IMHO. Best regard from the UK

    • @tonyschram1260
      @tonyschram1260 6 років тому +1

      Check out Altan, they do a great cover of this song

  • @mrjodel
    @mrjodel 9 років тому +3

    Check out Leon Russell Lockin' 2015. He and Claudia Lennar do a haunting time stopping version.

  • @MaggieJean
    @MaggieJean 5 місяців тому

    Dylan's version is unbeatable.

  • @MrRhmccabe
    @MrRhmccabe 2 роки тому

    Pete Townsend at Woodstock in 1998 does the ultimate rendition of this song.

  • @JDD1733
    @JDD1733 11 років тому +5

    Reminds me a little of Burl Ives... fantastic

  • @lutang15
    @lutang15 10 років тому +7

    ...nice.... but the best version is from Cash/Dylan

  • @Thundergod129
    @Thundergod129 11 років тому +2

    I love CSN and have seen them a number of times. It's reality that as one ages the vocal range is becomes limited. I just think they shouldn't do songs that challenge that too much, Peace....

    • @GGT950
      @GGT950 2 роки тому

      I agree.

  • @G0K3001
    @G0K3001 7 років тому +2

    Older CSN is better than no CSN .

  • @Conurelover1
    @Conurelover1 11 років тому +3

    To: C S N...World Class Gentlemen!!!

    • @debrahubbard763
      @debrahubbard763 4 роки тому

      C.S.N beats Dylan/Cash and that's not easy to do

  • @petervanmegen394
    @petervanmegen394 11 років тому +1

    What is that great Martin Stephen is playing on?

  • @ajahnpadawan8812
    @ajahnpadawan8812 9 років тому +1

    Surely the sound could be synced

  • @keepgoing1973
    @keepgoing1973 4 роки тому +1

    Nice version
    Chris Robinson is my fav. Just saying

  • @mikelheron20
    @mikelheron20 2 роки тому

    Why do they have to change the words?

  • @christianstoffler7673
    @christianstoffler7673 2 роки тому

    Les contre voix étaient parfaites !

  • @Droopydog79
    @Droopydog79 5 років тому

    whats the guitar model he playing?? nice cover.

  • @thegratefulbrad3072
    @thegratefulbrad3072 8 років тому +4

    That's about the purdiest old Martin that I've ever seen.

  • @adapotato53
    @adapotato53 5 років тому +1

    I'm from the north.

  • @timothyflyte9443
    @timothyflyte9443 5 років тому +3

    Beautiful version when the harmonies come in. This is one of my favorite Dylan songs. I recorded a version and I've posted it at reverbnation,com..if you'd like hear just Google
    TimothyFlyte'66 at reverbnation.com. I hope you like it .

    • @mrbobevans
      @mrbobevans 5 років тому +2

      Love "Girl From the North Country." I love Marty Robbins' "Girl From Spanish Town" even more. This version is a little too slow.

  • @Thundergod129
    @Thundergod129 12 років тому +3

    Stephen crooning like Dylan. Interesting choice. I'd of liked to hear them do this one 25 yrs. ago
    Their voices seem strained now. I guess the harmonies have lost a little something. This one just doesn't quite work.

  • @writereducator
    @writereducator 4 роки тому

    Every guy was thinking of some special girl . . .

  • @GGT950
    @GGT950 2 роки тому

    Im not sure their doing it justice here. See Bob live in 86 ( there’s a clip) it alone. Its a lot better. (Nice licks by Stills of course )

  • @macnificobis
    @macnificobis 5 років тому

    Sound is low, I can hardly hear anything.

  • @benmeltzer
    @benmeltzer 2 роки тому

    Song stars at 0:39.

  • @davidmurray2539
    @davidmurray2539 5 років тому +1

    Some songs are simply allergic to three part harmonies. Sounds like the church choir stepping out of their non-secular safe zone.

  • @ludmilalazareva6287
    @ludmilalazareva6287 9 місяців тому

    Beautiful! P.S. Пожалуйста закрой мою страницу на "f", возникла проблема с телефоном.

  • @carmenandthedevil2804
    @carmenandthedevil2804 2 роки тому

    Big CSN fan but the other two versions are better. Russell/Cocker and Dylan/Cash.

  • @ahmetberkayezgu8457
    @ahmetberkayezgu8457 7 років тому +3

    With Young, it would be better I think.

    • @David-D-Pyrénées
      @David-D-Pyrénées 5 років тому +1

      Neil Young are from the north country

    • @bendream544
      @bendream544 4 роки тому +1

      @@David-D-Pyrénées there is a video of Neil singing this song on UA-cam recorded in one of those booths that they have in truck stops etc. It's very good, he plays it quite up-tempo and kickin, search it out.

  • @collinbutt8741
    @collinbutt8741 9 років тому +1

    you know what ? Rattle is right. Cant improve on the original. I love CSN almost as much as the great Zimbo but they shld just hv left this one for private viewing. To give u an idea my first ever 7" (remember those !!!) was Rainy Day women - 1964 !! Don't even try to work out my frixking age !!

  • @levistubbs8949
    @levistubbs8949 5 років тому +1

    Is Nash in his bare feet ??

  • @robshore1574
    @robshore1574 11 років тому

    A touching tribute but I hate to say that C,S & N are well past their best

  • @GGT950
    @GGT950 2 роки тому

    Dylan & Cash on Nashville Skyline. Big CSN fan but this pales by comparison

  • @nickyl9040
    @nickyl9040 9 років тому +2

    Roseanne Cash does the truest version of this

  • @misshavisham3220
    @misshavisham3220 2 місяці тому

    Tough to see Stephen Stills struggle with his hearing loss.

  • @CKANE1952
    @CKANE1952 2 роки тому +3

    Great song. Graham Nash: please don't look so ridiculous