ik how oversimplified the tactics were so I made a part 2 Using Realistic Napoleanic Tactics in Guts and Blackpowder Part 2 ua-cam.com/video/nx8golrE3KY/v-deo.html it’s not perfect but way better than this
Did you know that you’re a sinner? But did you know that Jesus loves you and He can change that, all you have to do is believe that He died on the cross and rose from the grave 3 days later, repent, and accept God into your life, it’s your choice, Jesus loves you.
Did you know that you’re a sinner? But did you know that Jesus loves you and He can change that, all you have to do is believe that He died on the cross and rose from the grave 3 days later, repent, and accept God into your life, it’s your choice, Jesus loves you.
@@MostrandomM_toexisttoday im aithiest but i respect your religon but can you stop spamming comments with this? its actually just annoying and it hides all of the good replies
the fact that some of them were letting the zombies get close while reloading, was actually mostly what they actually did😭 edit: there’s a split community in the replies
First of all firing by ranks only works when you like 20 people to work since players in this game have a brain cell of a seagull they don't know how to build a perfect defense against bombers
@@natospysanchez8938 Skirmish Formations consist of gaps. Which is only used against ranged combatants minimizing casualties by spreading everyone out. So if your saying this.
you need to try this again, but with more people. im sure youll be able to get more people. i enjoyed the video and only see potential in this content!
@@rtgjhtyTank fish was able to make the bunch of brainless people that the Chaos Legion is to actually beat Paris Catacombs using line infantry tactucs
The video is great a few suggestions if you're planning to a video liek this again tho. 1. Use cycle firing or platoon firing you'd need a fair amount of people to do this, divide the group into platoons and order each platoon to fire at turns, make sure each platoon fires between intervals so the when the last platoon fires the first platoon would have already loaded their guns and allow for a constant rate of fire. 2. make use of pikemen/seargants, line formations had seargants/NCOs who used halberds/pikes to signify their rank, they could be used to protect the line from zombies. 3. if youre doing ranks, make sure there is gaps between the shoulders so the rank behind can actually see infront.
In the lore the armies practiced shooting, withdrawing a bit to reload, all while staying formation. This was done to combat the hordes on a larger scale and help mitigate their number advantages. If you check the notes and articles it shows the armies were caught off guard and on the backfoot. However as the numbers of the dead began to swell and more were lost the armies broke into smaller groups. So it is likely that fighting as a group without a particular formation became the norm. As the officers fell and the others were left to their own devices. Normally the levels we fight on are set after the local army has been all but annihilated. With endless being the designated holdouts to buy time for others to retreat. So it is logical to assume that the soldiers would largely drop the large formation tactics. Instead opting for a more indiviualized approach to situations. As they are the survivors who SAW these tactics not work.
The Accuracy of the game is decent. Since your fighting in close quarters and tight spaces. Line Infanry is permitted to skirmish tactics. Meaning Fire, Advance, and Hold. Sabers can be used as of that moment. Bayonets are only effective because its easier to equip.
I have an idea, Have 8 line infantry of 2 different nations, 4 per nation, 2 officers, same nation rule, 2 sappers, same nation rule, 2 fifers, nation rule, 2 seamen, nation rule and split them into two groups, A team of each, and you and one of your friends be the officer, commanding your side and hed command his, and play through any map. I wish i could do this myself but i dont have a server with fans. I enjoy your vids thank u for entertaining us❤ edit: 2 medics with the nation rule aswell, idk about priests
I remember that after watching this video, i wanted to do this with my friends on private server, i becomed officer, but my friend become officer and said "he impostor" , i leaved, after 5 minutes i joined him and screamed on him "IM NOT IMPOSTOR"
Even if this was accurate, it wouldn't work against zombies because this was used against humans, who were following rules and trying to stay alive, zombies are rogue and wouldn't care Love the vid though
I think y'all would do better if you had more people. Like a priest, a few seamen, surgeons, and musicians too. Than just line infantry, you have access to all those classes use them to their fullest abilities.
G&B wasn't that all realistic but some and even fewer details can tone your experience, also military tactics nor formations were pointless in the G&B universe since everyone is fighting for their survival in an explicable way as possible.
We would do line battles though in most parts like the one you get the explosive barrels and hay stacks but would ditch the tactic to effectively finish the map its fun to do it and its pretty useful on concentrated funnels like Tyrol or La Fern
Coordinating a small group of minimally experienced people is already difficult, imagine a group of 20 people with mixed skills and no central coordination trying to collaborate with each other, not to mention the poor communication.
What is the problem?? Soldiers form a line, france vs prussia they are in a line, prussia vs zombies, soldiers uses a line zombies divide and move a lot and they arent in line they uses instinct
This is so unrealistic napoleon and other officers would drive a Dodge Challenger into battle while using the double pump tactic (commonly also used by king karl the 12th of sweden when fighting against russia due to the high damage). Smh my head get your facts straight.
I think each rank is supposed to fire separately for example: rank one will fire then after they fire rank two will reload then after rank one will fire once more kinda like a continuous barrage of balls
ik how oversimplified the tactics were so I made a part 2 Using Realistic Napoleanic Tactics in Guts and Blackpowder Part 2
ua-cam.com/video/nx8golrE3KY/v-deo.html it’s not perfect but way better than this
Yes
No
Yes
yes but use scout tac
Needs friendly fire for extra realism
“We need to know how to form a line, line -“
nice pfp
@@strumjack you too
@@EngineerTeamFortress2 thanks
Did you know that you’re a sinner? But did you know that Jesus loves you and He can change that, all you have to do is believe that He died on the cross and rose from the grave 3 days later, repent, and accept God into your life, it’s your choice, Jesus loves you.
@@MostrandomM_toexisttoday nuh uh.
spam pike and officer charge for the true "BANZAI!!!" experience
Wouldn't it be more faithful to the "BANZAI!!!" experience to use the bayonet
@@Svegga nah, we are going in bushi style. (Or you could say samurai style)
@@Sveggaconsidering melees in every game are basically just HP trading (both you and enemy get damaged) thats the true experience.
Did you know that you’re a sinner? But did you know that Jesus loves you and He can change that, all you have to do is believe that He died on the cross and rose from the grave 3 days later, repent, and accept God into your life, it’s your choice, Jesus loves you.
@@MostrandomM_toexisttoday im aithiest but i respect your religon but can you stop spamming comments with this? its actually just annoying and it hides all of the good replies
the fact that some of them were letting the zombies get close while reloading, was actually mostly what they actually did😭 edit: there’s a split community in the replies
bud they didnt ac tually have zombs during that time
@@dacowfamilyofficial7550he’s talk about like letting soldiers with guns
@@dacowfamilyofficial7550 bro mixed reality and fiction together
thats why rankers had bayonets
They really did that in the Zulu war aswell..
First of all firing by ranks only works when you like 20 people to work since players in this game have a brain cell of a seagull they don't know how to build a perfect defense against bombers
Yea it would have been better if they formed in skirmish formation.
Nah bro Their brain cells are equivalent to room temperature
@@natospysanchez8938 Skirmish Formations consist of gaps. Which is only used against ranged combatants minimizing casualties by spreading everyone out. So if your saying this.
for the longest time i've wanted someone to do this. thank you
Tank fish did it and they won, but they had numbers.
@@octopus3582 Yea, And two Cannons
Yea, that strategy only works if you work together.
Hey it’s Isaac boi from the server! What’s up?
Did you know the firing line was mostly because the muskets were inaccurate
yeah and also because the soldiers could stick together so no friendly fire
@@spongebakesquarepansgaming yeah ig
@@Tatical141 it helped a little
Because it was easier to command groups of infantry if they were in formation rather than being spread out and it also helped against cavalry
Breaking news : Firing lines strategies are effective with weapons made for firing lines
Bro's squad was had more braincells than an average G&B server I join dang
most people werent in the vc
@@Rap4po3 pleople winning kaub with no vc only using chat
@@joyelluke9880 so.. whats ur point? we were supposed to listen to ooz in vc this is not a trio run in kaub
bro definitely has old guard
Just be lucky tbh i got old guard because my team never left@@poorlydrawnlordsinister1849
I saw Tankfishes Firing line in Catacombs de Paris
The tactic of a LINE formation works
I watched that too😂 they were sos surprised that it worked
you need to try this again, but with more people. im sure youll be able to get more people.
i enjoyed the video and only see potential in this content!
It will be hell training 19 people
@@rtgjhty it’s all content in the the end though.
@@rtgjhty real
@@ooz2841 ClIcKkK ATESHHHH
@@rtgjhtyTank fish was able to make the bunch of brainless people that the Chaos Legion is to actually beat Paris Catacombs using line infantry tactucs
The video is great a few suggestions if you're planning to a video liek this again tho.
1. Use cycle firing or platoon firing you'd need a fair amount of people to do this, divide the group into platoons and order each platoon to fire at turns, make sure each platoon fires between intervals so the when the last platoon fires the first platoon would have already loaded their guns and allow for a constant rate of fire.
2. make use of pikemen/seargants, line formations had seargants/NCOs who used halberds/pikes to signify their rank, they could be used to protect the line from zombies.
3. if youre doing ranks, make sure there is gaps between the shoulders so the rank behind can actually see infront.
You should try Catacombes de Paris with these tactics. It's the most effective map to use these, especially the final part
In the lore the armies practiced shooting, withdrawing a bit to reload, all while staying formation. This was done to combat the hordes on a larger scale and help mitigate their number advantages. If you check the notes and articles it shows the armies were caught off guard and on the backfoot.
However as the numbers of the dead began to swell and more were lost the armies broke into smaller groups.
So it is likely that fighting as a group without a particular formation became the norm. As the officers fell and the others were left to their own devices.
Normally the levels we fight on are set after the local army has been all but annihilated. With endless being the designated holdouts to buy time for others to retreat.
So it is logical to assume that the soldiers would largely drop the large formation tactics. Instead opting for a more indiviualized approach to situations.
As they are the survivors who SAW these tactics not work.
4:01 - 4:04 that scream is killed me💀💀💀💀
Tf2 spy scream
glad to help a lot in recordings :)
Just joined the discord great videos dude I love em keep going!!!
under rated guts and blackpowder youtuber
Using realistic napoleon tactics and using British
ermm so?
Plot twist: все это время он разговаривал сам с собой не включая микрофон и его коллеги даже его не слышали
POV you make a plan that you make even though you know damn well no one gonna listen
The Accuracy of the game is decent. Since your fighting in close quarters and tight spaces. Line Infanry is permitted to skirmish tactics. Meaning Fire, Advance, and Hold. Sabers can be used as of that moment. Bayonets are only effective because its easier to equip.
Bayonets are one of the best single target melee weapons
Guts and Blackpowder is the type of game where your teammates are a higher threat than the zombies themselves.
As a new player, I completely agree.
I have an idea, Have 8 line infantry of 2 different nations, 4 per nation, 2 officers, same nation rule, 2 sappers, same nation rule, 2 fifers, nation rule, 2 seamen, nation rule and split them into two groups, A team of each, and you and one of your friends be the officer, commanding your side and hed command his, and play through any map. I wish i could do this myself but i dont have a server with fans. I enjoy your vids thank u for entertaining us❤
edit: 2 medics with the nation rule aswell, idk about priests
I remember that after watching this video, i wanted to do this with my friends on private server, i becomed officer, but my friend become officer and said "he impostor" , i leaved, after 5 minutes i joined him and screamed on him "IM NOT IMPOSTOR"
When they charge, most officers in the 1800's screamed "FIXED BAYONETS!"
Even if this was accurate, it wouldn't work against zombies because this was used against humans, who were following rules and trying to stay alive, zombies are rogue and wouldn't care
Love the vid though
20:36 old man is only survivor 😢
" I seen gay parades more straighter than this line "
- RichardExitium
"Chrrge! Tally o' ladsss" 💀
💀
I think y'all would do better if you had more people. Like a priest, a few seamen, surgeons, and musicians too. Than just line infantry, you have access to all those classes use them to their fullest abilities.
Awesome video, this looks like a nightmare to attempt lol
7:49 the best player of G&B
Hey ooz, i was in the video. I was merlin
nice
Cool
nice
NOOOO YOU WERE SO CLOSE BUT YOU DIED RIGTH WHEN THE BIAT SHOWED UP
8:06 cannon blows up
This was an amazing video!! Keep it up!!. Side note: I'm just going to ignore the fact that they put Red Dead redemption 2 music in there
Good video but not very accurate.
Loose accuracy for the sake of entertainment lol.
we were lacking people tbh and people werent listening that good
Bro is jack dawn 💀
Lose that “realistic” in the title NOW RAHHHH 😡😡😡😡
Scary Fact No. 100 They are all BRITAIN
G&B wasn't that all realistic but some and even fewer details can tone your experience, also military tactics nor formations were pointless in the G&B universe since everyone is fighting for their survival in an explicable way as possible.
Line infantry would not even have sabers in the first place because the bayonet would be much more practical
We would do line battles though in most parts like the one you get the explosive barrels and hay stacks but would ditch the tactic to effectively finish the map its fun to do it and its pretty useful on concentrated funnels like Tyrol or La Fern
Actually during this time period skirmishes were common during city fighting, so uh yeah, normal gameplay is accurate
Great video as always ooz
Also 7:52 mobile player moment
bet he helped zombies fall him down 💀
I wish public servers were cooperative like this
Coordinating a small group of minimally experienced people is already difficult, imagine a group of 20 people with mixed skills and no central coordination trying to collaborate with each other, not to mention the poor communication.
But it would be amazing
this may be the smartest team in guts & blackpowder..
Im think developer of g&b really expectation every player of their game use tactical napoleon strategi
I love how he says charge its so gentle
I really like this but it should be done with a full squad (like Tanfish did it)
tankfish actually did this in catacombs town part and he was so surprised its working (no sh*t it works. its an actual tactic)
bro needs a new army 🙏😭
We are french we charge backwards
Tank fish.
try this in blood and iron
I’m not sure why you were playing rdr2 music while nothing that intense was happening at 3:41
"lads"
"Them being French"
No that's British. The uniforms, Face that's nation specific and especially the unique uniforms for only the British nation
to be more accurate, your supposed to say:”Make ready!” “Present” “Fire!” these three orders
2:50 isn’t there a charge feature for the officer?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA it was so funny how all of them didnt survive at the end
I'm just here for the history nerds nitpicking every little detail
This comment is very accurate and relatable. ☝️🤓
that red dead soundtrack got me high
What is the problem?? Soldiers form a line, france vs prussia they are in a line, prussia vs zombies, soldiers uses a line zombies divide and move a lot and they arent in line they uses instinct
This is so unrealistic napoleon and other officers would drive a Dodge Challenger into battle while using the double pump tactic (commonly also used by king karl the 12th of sweden when fighting against russia due to the high damage). Smh my head get your facts straight.
I think each rank is supposed to fire separately for example: rank one will fire then after they fire rank two will reload then after rank one will fire once more kinda like a continuous barrage of balls
you need to tell them to unequip and then equip to present hte bayonet faster
I try to do this but I have 5 year old children as line infantry.
HE IS BACK!!!!!!
What is the game you do boot camp in?
God some of them need more training
thanks for giving me ideas for me bro
Should you not have the lines firing in cannon not all at the same time
Really good video idea but I think it would be better if there were more men
How do you lock your camera to face forward in 3rd person on PC? I can't figure it out, and no one will tell me how.
Go to settings and set shiftlock to toggle
I can get san sebastian achievements in private servers?
You need a 2nd man for the winch part otherwise ur softlocked
Does g and b have a zombie dead sound as the metal pipe falling meme?
Just editing
@@ooz2841 I hope the devs add it just like the wilhelm scream.
"Free trade and sailors right" 💀💀💀
READY LADS PRESENT AIM *AGH!!!!* gets killed by runner
I think tank fish did this and it worked really well lol
spam pike and officer charge for the true "BANZAI!!!" experience
2:22 should have sea men in rank 2 maybe? maybe? to slow?
First step wash your teeth (also remembers he’s in the British army)
Brush*
One question 7:52 how did he get picked
you have potential to lead a real line some day not irl in a roblox community called nepolionic wars
Takes 100000 years just to get 19 people to form a line
What if in the front there is pikemen and then muskets
I can't join discord it's glitched
i thought the french moved backwards, not forwards.
I know what the Napoleonic wars are but what the hell are the "Napoleanic" wars
Maybe switch to carbines, exchange power and melee for faster reloads and shove ability.
only use line formation when against a horde, bit every possible moment
I'm guts and blackpowdering
Good video most Realistic Napoleonic war game
It's not
@@sok-v6w what's the most then
kind of
it do be like that sometimes 5:48
Legend is back🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
Rdr2 music?
we need an original tactic like 1 shot every second.
Cronin Courts
DONT THINK I DONT KNOW THE RDR2 ONLINE MUSIC WHEN YOU OPEN THE GATE AT THE FIRST TRY ):
IS THAT RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 MUSIC I HEAR!?!?!?!??!!
The british infection💀
mvp irish zapper
If only I was in, this would be so fun
Looks like there was something you could do.