SAM Fortez IKR! At first I shipped her with Minho (MinStal!!) - which actually got me into k-pop and loving Krys - but then her with Taemin seems so cute because they're nearly the same age and then L comes in. Though I keep telling myself that "No! I ship Minstal" i can't anymore.....
It's not that I don't like Kai for Krystal (they look cute tho) BUT I'VE BEEN SHPPING THESE TWO SINCE THEIR DEBUT LIKE WTF Never thought that Temin's BFF would get the girl 😂 I'm pretty sure krys and tae had a thing before. Still shipping them but I hope krys and kai lasts 😊
They were so adorable together, it's pretty damn obvious Taemin was crushing on her circa 2012, given a few of their SMT interactions too. It's still a great visual ship, I'm still on it tbh.
I wish Taemin and Krystal would always go to loud places like this one when they talk so they have to whisper into each other's ears all the time. Hahahaha :D BTW, during the first few seconds, Taemin stroked Baby Jung's hair and immediately hid his hand. Kekekeke ^_^
TBH, after watching some parts of taemin and naeun on we got married. I found that taemin is more comfortable with krystal. I don't ship them two but I just think that their chemistry is something.
kryscat xo I'm not an anti fan of Krystal or something ( I LOVE HER), but I just want to make a statement. Taemin and Krystal have probably known each other since they were trainees, so of course they would be close together. Taemin and Naeun are two people who have barely seen each other before. So of course the two would be a little shy and uneasy around each other at first.
+Aileen Chang srsly tho, why did you suddenly talked about taemin x naeun here. she only say taestal has chemistry. what a fuckin insecurities taeun shipper -_-
+SHINee World do yo know that +aileen chang is so pathetic with taeun all the comment of her said all about tauen gosh read more and you find ot that person is out of her mind. +aileen chang if you want someone join you for shipping taeun go to their website say all you want about them how you love them and how you feel for them go ahead.but you are so much yeah you can say all your opinion but not the fact that you are breaking some people here that want taestal.+shinee world is correct you are inturderer
Mariel Englis i knw it. and i swear its the most disgusting, gross, annoying and funny reading her comments. smh... you are right. why dont she just go to their websites and saying these kind of things. she should accept tht fact tht taeun is fuckin dead now. when will she wake up frm her "wonderful" taeun's dream and face the reality.
+Mariel Englis Wow you say that lady's pathetic and here you are commenting on a post about something you didn't like written in August when it's the middle of November. If you're trying to make a statement at least do it at the time and not do it long after the discussion has past. If you're saying she's pathetic, then you're just a childish little kid waiting to make someone's day feel worse. Mann all you people just hiding behind social media just to bash out at others. It's disgusting, especially you.
IKR? TaeStal is sooo much better and more comfy with each other w/o pretending. They always interact whenever they perform in one event too so they're really close ^_^
8luvbug Taemin and Naeun is obviously the better choice. If it were Krystal and Taemin, and WGM ended, it would be so awkward with them to be together. Plus, Taemin and Naeun were so cute since they were both so pure and innocent. I really like Krystal, but I still don't get why people ship Taemin with her, when everyone knows that Taemin and Naeun had true feelings for each other.
unknown anonymous of course they're fake af because wgm is 99% scripted and they haven't known each other that well while soojung and taemin have been friends since ages ago. p.s krystal looks good with anyone i'm dying i don't know who to ship anymore
eulalia florence I agree with sen chi, Taeun still floats, just no one knows about it. Plus, WGM isn't 99% scripted, only the missions. TBH, Taemin and Naeun really showed feelings to eachother, and you can tell that they're not lying. (compare it to their acting in dramas).
It's sad that these kinds of stages are kind of impossible now because of all the dating scandals and hate that will be directed....not saying it wasn't there then too but nowadays it's been almost impossible to get any proper bg and gg interactions without someone making a HUGE deal out of it when things like this happened all the time just a few years ago. kpop used to be fun....what happened now......
Cant get enough of these 2, only if there's another collaboration for TaeStal. Taemin n Naeun r cute together but I really CANT ship them neither Krys n Minhyuk. Tbh I only obsess over f(SHINee), they already admitted honestly how closed they're. And that's it, no other groups can beat their closed relationship, to me. I passionately inlove with them esp my best fav OTPs.
All here say that Krystal is very shiptable and Taemin is very shiptable too but Taemin is very shiptable with men and it is true I know few Taemin x women ships but I know many Taemin x men ships (kkkk~this are my favorites). Personally i don't ship him with women but Krystal is a strong girl and it makes me like see her with Taemin. She isn't a girl with princess complex. SHE IS JUST LIKE TAEMIN.
The one that was aired on tv was pre-recorded. This one was the one they performed for the live audience at the show while the pre-recorded version was aired for home viewers. They do this a lot for music programs too.
From 0:14 to 0:21 Krystal is jumping up and down and saying "Oppa, I'm so nervous!" and then Taemin smiles and says "Yeah, me too!!" hahah! Honestly, I'm a huge Shawol and loved SHINee since their debut but I personally don't mind if they date and what not. But TaeStal looks like really close friends in my eyes, or maybe have feelings for each other but aren't dating yet? I don't know, their interactions are more fun and goofy than lovey dovey~~ I'm just so happy seeing Taemin's manly side :P
Bridal stye!! You're the man taeminnie~ i was so shocked when taemin carried krystal. so cute! can't help noticing that minho went beside taestal during the live, resulting no bridal style minho is keeping an eye on you two :3
Lol WGM is scripted guys. If Taemin really likes Naeun then we'll never know... same with Krystal. What i'm saying is, stop acting like you own Taemin or something lol
I KEPT GRINNING SO WIDE OMG THEY ARE SO CUTE AND SWEET!! Thats why f(shinee) is family ♡♡ Guys they dont have any chemistry as a couple. They are the cutest sibling otp ever ♡♡♡♡ Like AWWWWW ♡♡♡♡
@beatrice dartn nope i agree with, its actually pretty obvious how he's teasing her like a lil sis, Krystal is close with most of SHINee boys, there are fancams of Taemin laughing with krystal and Minho came along all touchy and nice to krystal, Krystal and Minho walked away and taemin went to another direction, im not saying Minho is dating her, all of this shows that SHINee treat fx like their lil sisters ^.^
I think its because Taemin sees Krystal as a good friend (platonic), so he feels comfortable doing it with her but with Naeun, it seems as if he really likes her as more than a friend, so he feels nervous doing skinship with naeun
let me tell you this: this was before wgm aired but y'all so bitter and bashing naeun lmao if you ship taestal then so be it but y'all can ship them without bragging naeun's name tbh. and well naeun can stand on her own so she don't need anyone else tho
He rehearses at 00:11 minutes. Oh God, Taemin, baby …. he rehearsed his hug with Boa, kisses with Krystal …. and he was so worried. Taemin you are very nice, you know. And in 01:48 he teases her or people on the stage, I gues. :D For me they look like really close dorky friends, nothing more. So sweet
lol i like your comment :)) but Minho's already seen it. And it's the reason for Minho stand next to Taestal when they're performing (this vid is rehearsal)
I love how they are at easy with each other, they are very close friends and what we see in this fancam is true! It's not fake like in wgm! Wgm is just like any other drama or sitcom, it's all about acting...wake up guys
i think it's because he and Krystal is close friends so he isn't too shy to do skinship.. Taemin is usually okay w/ skinship to the people he is close with he is only shy when he doesn't know the person or he isn't so close to that person yet..
Krystal is my bias. she is shipable with other guys like Krystal with Myungsoo,MinHyuk, MinHo,Rain, and Taemin... but i ship MinStal and Myungstal moreee
Of course they would be comfortable with each other they are like "IN THE SAME COMPANY" so more chances of both of them talking duh. MyGosh and they are like sibling groups SHINee and F(x). That is why they are close -.- sorry just kinda annoyed cuz yah know HARD SHIPPER OF TAEUN if you will ask me if why i even watch this even though i am not a shipper it is so that i can analyze why people ship them.
![[MPD직캠] 에프엑스 1위 앵콜 직캠 4 Walls Fancam No.1 Encore full ver. MNET MCOUNTDOWN 151105](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ETX-RyhbIO4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[C.C.] SHINee Taemin and F(X) Crystal are dating in a cute way #SHINEE #TAEMIN #FX #CRYSTAL #K-DRAMA](/img/n.gif)
KRYSTAL is a woman who is SHIPTABLE! HAHAHA. She can be shipped with anyone!
SAM Fortez IKR! At first I shipped her with Minho (MinStal!!) - which actually got me into k-pop and loving Krys - but then her with Taemin seems so cute because they're nearly the same age and then L comes in. Though I keep telling myself that "No! I ship Minstal" i can't anymore.....
+Vanessa Chirayus same!!! Now I ship her with lay😫😂
Nattharika thongthep Yeah but still my OTP with Krystal is either Kai or Myungsoo. #KaiStal or #MyungStal
+Zoe Fortez I ship her with Minhyuk(CNBLUE) , L, Taemin, Kai, Lay, Minho(Shinee), ...
+Zoe Fortez and now Kaistal is real 😏❤️
idk anymore... Krystal with Taemin or with Minhyuk or with Kai or with Ahn Jae Hyun... She's very shipable omg:")
SHIP THROUGH THIS NAMES:
Taemin and Krystal
Taemin and Naeun
Krystal and Minhyuk
Krystal and Kai
Krystal and Jaehyun
Naeun and Jaehyun
It's not that I don't like Kai for Krystal (they look cute tho) BUT I'VE BEEN SHPPING THESE TWO SINCE THEIR DEBUT LIKE WTF Never thought that Temin's BFF would get the girl 😂 I'm pretty sure krys and tae had a thing before. Still shipping them but I hope krys and kai lasts 😊
Ikr, same here!
MM Iral Same here! I don't know much about Kai and I don't like/hate him but I still ship TaeStal even until now, 2017! F(SHINee)! 💕
once you taemin you can't taemout Kai and Krystal are not dating anymore.
Me too
I hope they still keep in touch 🥺 they're friendship is so beautiful.
They were so adorable together, it's pretty damn obvious Taemin was crushing on her circa 2012, given a few of their SMT interactions too. It's still a great visual ship, I'm still on it tbh.
Kai will be jealous that his best friend Taemin kissed his girlfriend in the past.
hahaha yaa
same
No he won't lol
Yay
Girlfriend ni kai si jennie duh jennie and kai saying dating
kai be like: "damnnn taemin-ah you kissed my girl" LOL
They're more look like a friends than a lovers. Cuz, TBH Taemin is just like a teenager who's having fun while Krystal is truely a lady type. :)
Did you know that taemin is actually older than krystal
Taemin is cute here
@@howelljenkins97By a year only
@@howelljenkins97By a year only
luna's reaction to taemin carrying krystal though hahahh
KRYSTAL IS REALLY VERY SHIPTABLE !!! I Always ship her with Sehun, Taemin, or any other maknae of all the groups XD!!!!
I wish Taemin and Krystal would always go to loud places like this one when they talk so they have to whisper into each other's ears all the time. Hahahaha :D BTW, during the first few seconds, Taemin stroked Baby Jung's hair and immediately hid his hand. Kekekeke ^_^
When taemin carry her luna was like aww OMO So Cute
I keep replaying from 0:52 to 1:02! SO CUTE!
Same as me 😂👍🏻
they are such good friends, happy to see my two bias interacting like this ^^
TBH, after watching some parts of taemin and naeun on we got married. I found that taemin is more comfortable with krystal. I don't ship them two but I just think that their chemistry is something.
kryscat xo I'm not an anti fan of Krystal or something ( I LOVE HER), but I just want to make a statement.
Taemin and Krystal have probably known each other since they were trainees, so of course they would be close together. Taemin and Naeun are two people who have barely seen each other before. So of course the two would be a little shy and uneasy around each other at first.
+Aileen Chang srsly tho, why did you suddenly talked about taemin x naeun here. she only say taestal has chemistry. what a fuckin insecurities taeun shipper -_-
+SHINee World do yo know that +aileen chang is so pathetic with taeun all the comment of her said all about tauen gosh read more and you find ot that person is out of her mind. +aileen chang if you want someone join you for shipping taeun go to their website say all you want about them how you love them and how you feel for them go ahead.but you are so much yeah you can say all your opinion but not the fact that you are breaking some people here that want taestal.+shinee world is correct you are inturderer
Mariel Englis i knw it. and i swear its the most disgusting, gross, annoying and funny reading her comments. smh... you are right. why dont she just go to their websites and saying these kind of things. she should accept tht fact tht taeun is fuckin dead now. when will she wake up frm her "wonderful" taeun's dream and face the reality.
+Mariel Englis Wow you say that lady's pathetic and here you are commenting on a post about something you didn't like written in August when it's the middle of November. If you're trying to make a statement at least do it at the time and not do it long after the discussion has past. If you're saying she's pathetic, then you're just a childish little kid waiting to make someone's day feel worse. Mann all you people just hiding behind social media just to bash out at others. It's disgusting, especially you.
Taemin looks happy here and not awkward at all. Love this couple
Taemin watch out for Kai!!!
Aww Taestal are so cute together :3
Oh gosh, the explosion of feels.
0.12 he kisses her hand and pats her head lool
I love it when they keep saying they're nervous and jumps up and down and then when the music started they start dancing to the beat :D
I SHIP THESE TWO SOO MUCH!!!!
Krystal and Taemin should've been on WGM instead of Taemin and Naeun. Taestal has more chemistry.
IKR? TaeStal is sooo much better and more comfy with each other w/o pretending. They always interact whenever they perform in one event too so they're really close ^_^
8luvbug Taemin and Naeun is obviously the better choice. If it were Krystal and Taemin, and WGM ended, it would be so awkward with them to be together. Plus, Taemin and Naeun were so cute since they were both so pure and innocent. I really like Krystal, but I still don't get why people ship Taemin with her, when everyone knows that Taemin and Naeun had true feelings for each other.
Agree
Aileen Chang Did you just see what Taemin did to Krystal on this vid? He NEVER did that with Naeun.
Uhhhh... Excuse me? This is a performance. THIS WAS ALL STAGED. Taemin's action's all have to do with the song their singing and SM's choreographer.
I just want Crystal and taemin can always together,because I love them so much 💚💚
Her name doesn’t start with a c her name starts with a k
Taeun just for drama....but taestal for real...tsemin always vote for krystal
I like TaeStal more than TaEun
Ariza Dnielle 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Kai and Krystal are good together but Taemin and Krystal they are perfect for each other
>_< this is the most complete fancam i've seen! thank you very much!
Imagine if idols could do this nowadays
Taeun sunk long ago taestal still floats lmao
unknown anonymous no no Taeun still floats and floats very well. you just dont know it :)))
sen chi nah i aint delusional, taeun was fake af lol even taemin himself said theyre divorced
he just said what he wanted and what the fan want to hear, we dont know what truly inside
so just believe what you want to belive anyway
unknown anonymous of course they're fake af because wgm is 99% scripted and they haven't known each other that well while soojung and taemin have been friends since ages ago.
p.s krystal looks good with anyone i'm dying i don't know who to ship anymore
eulalia florence I agree with sen chi, Taeun still floats, just no one knows about it. Plus, WGM isn't 99% scripted, only the missions. TBH, Taemin and Naeun really showed feelings to eachother, and you can tell that they're not lying. (compare it to their acting in dramas).
Taeminnie look so happy here.
I like Taemin-Krystal T.T *cry*
2015 before 2016 still watching this and some how i still ship these two, they look so cute #taestal❤️💕
And i thought taemin was biting his bottom lip while looking at krystal. 😆
Same!!!
same!! gosh~
+Pi ka Chu its so funny that she is dating Kai now, Taemin is like a third wheel all along
blackblue0613 lol right
It's sad that these kinds of stages are kind of impossible now because of all the dating scandals and hate that will be directed....not saying it wasn't there then too but nowadays it's been almost impossible to get any proper bg and gg interactions without someone making a HUGE deal out of it when things like this happened all the time just a few years ago. kpop used to be fun....what happened now......
Cant get enough of these 2, only if there's another collaboration for TaeStal. Taemin n Naeun r cute together but I really CANT ship them neither Krys n Minhyuk. Tbh I only obsess over f(SHINee), they already admitted honestly how closed they're. And that's it, no other groups can beat their closed relationship, to me. I passionately inlove with them esp my best fav OTPs.
All here say that Krystal is very shiptable and Taemin is very shiptable too but Taemin is very shiptable with men and it is true I know few Taemin x women ships but I know many Taemin x men ships (kkkk~this are my favorites).
Personally i don't ship him with women but Krystal is a strong girl and it makes me like see her with Taemin.
She isn't a girl with princess complex.
SHE IS JUST LIKE TAEMIN.
+Nightmare jongtae taekai 2min.... and some I don't ship but I found cute and funny ontae, taekey XDD ohhhhh taemin
+aNiMeAddiCtZ26 and Taekai and now TaeminxJimin 😉
I KNEW IT THERE R 2DIFFERENT ONES THIS IS EITHER THE REHERSAL OR THE ACTUAL THING BUT IT IS DIFFERENT THEN THE PREFOANCE ON MBC KPOP
The one that was aired on tv was pre-recorded. This one was the one they performed for the live audience at the show while the pre-recorded version was aired for home viewers. They do this a lot for music programs too.
bLESS YOU FOR THE ANSWER BLESS
I used to be taeun shipper buy not anymore. Ugh. Taestal just-- god. They're so cute.
I like also Krystal for Taemin....they are also matched.
Taestal!
omg! they are so sweet together
they're so cute, i love krystal and i like taemin too, if they're a real couple, it's great!
From 0:14 to 0:21 Krystal is jumping up and down and saying "Oppa, I'm so nervous!" and then Taemin smiles and says "Yeah, me too!!" hahah! Honestly, I'm a huge Shawol and loved SHINee since their debut but I personally don't mind if they date and what not. But TaeStal looks like really close friends in my eyes, or maybe have feelings for each other but aren't dating yet? I don't know, their interactions are more fun and goofy than lovey dovey~~ I'm just so happy seeing Taemin's manly side :P
Bridal stye!! You're the man taeminnie~
i was so shocked when taemin carried krystal. so cute!
can't help noticing that minho went beside taestal during the live, resulting no bridal style
minho is keeping an eye on you two :3
Usually I'm not into shipping idols, but these two I can ship
I love amber’s singing voice
I like they're comfortable each other and having fun in the stage. Something that we can't see in idol right now
I SHIP IT FORGET KAISTAL OR WHATEVER
Lovely Me
yeah! let's forget it 😀😂
Tarmin looks happy here and not awkward. Loove this couple
they look so comfortable with each other! :)
and taemin is so grown up now omg
they're too cute for words.
the broadcasted version was actually pre-recorded. this is the live version for that day when minho and sulli went to sbs for their new comer awards.
Lol WGM is scripted guys. If Taemin really likes Naeun then we'll never know... same with Krystal. What i'm saying is, stop acting like you own Taemin or something lol
everytime i watch it,i always smile
lol at the end where Jonghyun stares a bit at Krystal
that lip bite and smile tho :55 to :57 .! like omg my feels lol they seems really cute together tbh
I KEPT GRINNING SO WIDE OMG THEY ARE SO CUTE AND SWEET!! Thats why f(shinee) is family ♡♡ Guys they dont have any chemistry as a couple. They are the cutest sibling otp ever ♡♡♡♡ Like AWWWWW ♡♡♡♡
They are so cute!! Really ^^You could see he was really having fun here ^^
this is pre recording i guess because in the live show the ending wasn't like that plus krystal wore black socks
TAESTAL so cute >
Too much chemistry!! It hurts!! >.< Seriously though, they are so cute together!!
i love both! And this two are so sweet to be together! i'll support you!!! :D
They are too cute
And after everything, just look at his smile @ 3:06-3:07-ish
The lights are dim
He's off the stage
No fans to smile to
He is happy :)
I love them so much
Aww so cute when the puts his hand on his chest at the beginning like he's nervous or something
TAESTAL IS THE BEST! (y)
@beatrice dartn nope i agree with, its actually pretty obvious how he's teasing her like a lil sis, Krystal is close with most of SHINee boys, there are fancams of Taemin laughing with krystal and Minho came along all touchy and nice to krystal, Krystal and Minho walked away and taemin went to another direction, im not saying Minho is dating her, all of this shows that SHINee treat fx like their lil sisters ^.^
that's because they both went back to mbc after receiving the sbs awards.
I think its because Taemin sees Krystal as a good friend (platonic), so he feels comfortable doing it with her but with Naeun, it seems as if he really likes her as more than a friend, so he feels nervous doing skinship with naeun
Taemin said his heart is 100% leaning towards Naeun now
Cynthia Plata HAHAHAHAHAHA EW
@@danielaahumada214 😂😂😂😭
let me tell you this: this was before wgm aired but y'all so bitter and bashing naeun lmao if you ship taestal then so be it but y'all can ship them without bragging naeun's name tbh. and well naeun can stand on her own so she don't need anyone else tho
Do not mention Taemin and naeun in this video. Their WGM program is finished. Let's face it. 내 새끼들 건들지 마. 태민이 수정이 파이팅, 사랑해.
박유빈 ok but you can forbid everybody not to talk about them, Taeun's so cute anyway
sen chi This video is only for Taemin and Sujeong, Please tell on their channel if they are cute.
sen chi And sorry for my bad English
got it. sorry
He rehearses at 00:11 minutes. Oh God, Taemin, baby …. he rehearsed his hug with Boa, kisses with Krystal …. and he was so worried. Taemin you are very nice, you know.
And in 01:48 he teases her or people on the stage, I gues. :D
For me they look like really close dorky friends, nothing more. So sweet
@musiclover4ever2000 yep it was planed and he didnt actually kiss her, he came close to her hand first then her head as a part of the performance ^^
lol i like your comment :))
but Minho's already seen it. And it's the reason for Minho stand next to Taestal when they're performing (this vid is rehearsal)
yes~ i think so too.. they work together for many times ~ how come didn't have a number!
actually idk what to say..just he's so gorgeous Q_Q
i don't wanna say anything else,i just love taemin+krystal this pair
I'm still watching this video to now 2022
why is this diff than the one that i watched on tv? the tv one theres no taemin holding krystal? why is different?
2nd gen is the best era of kpop tbh. New fans nowadays are too jealous and immature
I love how they are at easy with each other, they are very close friends and what we see in this fancam is true! It's not fake like in wgm! Wgm is just like any other drama or sitcom, it's all about acting...wake up guys
I had a smile on my face all the video, i don't actually ship these two, but they'so so cute! *.*
The maknaes.. CUTE !!!!
even im shipping Minhyuk&Krystal and Taemin&Naeun..
this looks more real, comfortable and lovely kekekee
Is this a dress rehearsal? Krystal and Taemin were doing a lot more pointing at the camera in the official performance
Yes, bcs after that, krystal used stocking
The other one was a recording, because minho and sulli have to attend another award on that day
Taestal ! Hwaiting!!!!!!
Karen Lacson yessss
At the end he leaves like he don't give two cents of what just had happened Lol
the only time i saw taemin manly with a girl...hahahaha...well it's what i think...
this why i love taestal 😆
how come they didnt out this in the original clip?
+ohaika _exoahgasae this is only prerecording session :D
i think it's because he and Krystal is close friends so he isn't too shy to do skinship.. Taemin is usually okay w/ skinship to the people he is close with he is only shy when he doesn't know the person or he isn't so close to that person yet..
Krystal is my bias. she is shipable with other guys like Krystal with Myungsoo,MinHyuk, MinHo,Rain, and Taemin... but i ship MinStal and Myungstal moreee
Of course they would be comfortable with each other they are like "IN THE SAME COMPANY" so more chances of both of them talking duh. MyGosh and they are like sibling groups SHINee and F(x). That is why they are close -.- sorry just kinda annoyed cuz yah know HARD SHIPPER OF TAEUN if you will ask me if why i even watch this even though i am not a shipper it is so that i can analyze why people ship them.
if this isnt the cutest idk what is
I miss this..
Missing taestal again. ❤
i think it was the rehearsal
haha taemin is soo cute ^^ it's nice to see krystal an taemin together they seem like good friends :D
They're just rehearsing :))
You are really 100% taestal shipper ;D
why is it different from the one we saw on tv ?
I think taemin and naeun is really good
Yoyo Bui yes they're. love them ^^