I don’t know how to react to it...but as I said in “The History Of BaekYeon” if they are happy,I am happy...I hope they can be friends someday...❣️ #BaekYeon #KaiStal
now kai and jennie is dating and everyone is accepting. i just felt sad for kaistal and baekyeon because they never experience that kind of acceptance.
Agree base on all their moments, kai defenitely had a crush on her since trainee and when the pink tape photos with kai happened and f(x) had an interview on a radio show and the members called him “jonginnie” while krystal called him “this kid” made it seem like kai has already confessed to her and that they were close and 2015 was the year they probably dated
Amine Sinan It’s funny how we assume that they’ve grown up. For the most part that’s true but there are still a lot of delusion fans that protest and boycott against them when they announce they’re in a relationship. Like the “scandal” about Chen for instance. He’s getting married to a woman whom he really loves and is going to become a father. It’s the greatest thing a human can experience and people are bashing for having a regular, normal life.
kaistal's relationship was beautiful and it was clear that kai genuinely had feelings for her. but krystal said that when they break up, theyre done and that makes me so sad because they couldve made more history together and prove to everyone that a female idol and a male idol can last more than one year
I broke my heart when the news of their break up came out. I really love their love story and them for each other. I hope they both believe in second chances. ♥
I feel bad but i´m not gonna lie I was glad that they broke up if they really dated. Exo is really popular so they have a lot of saesang fans and obsessive fans specially from China. Everyday in instagram they left mean and rude comments to krystal and the articules about going to an hotel or shopping condoms without real proofs. It was too much. I feel sorry for the guys because I can´t see them dating at least for the next 5 years.
andrea Ramos Your last sentence is the complete opposite of you “feeling bad” because they broke up. You also can’t “feel sorry for the guys” if you’re one of those who are against them being in a relationship. I feel more sorry for them because they can’t be in a happy relationship because of their butt hurt fans. I hope fans will accept the fact that the day will come where these idols will get married with someone they love-whether it will be 5 years from now or tomorrow, even today-because they are humans too. And I’m pretty sure they dated for real especially after their escape room date pictures got leaked.
English isn´t my first language so I don´t know if I express myself. When I say I feel bad it´s because I don´t want to feel relieved that they are not dating anymore because break ups sucks but krystal always recieve so much hate from her resting face since her debut. And exo is too popular and I can´t imagine Kai defend his relationship because fans pull the "fans card" . It´s too much for both.
jennie and kai broke up because so many people hate jennie and called her lazy scandals😭 i feel bad for kyrstal and jennie,jennie had a bad day after they announce the couple, she really happy before 😟
It seems that Kai already had a crush on Krystal since the first day... such a cutie pie love..and seeing how bad EXO have been through all this years.I really want them all to have a beautiful relationship with someone like Krystal.They deserves to be happy...
@Alpaca Young no, im not. I know they are best friend before but his expression when krystal around her is so different with the other girls. And it reminds me with some my friends when they are around their crush. Its normal i think.
I don’t know about you guys but in my opinion Kaistal seemed like one of the realest and most genuine Kpop relationships. I loved them together so much
KAISTAL AKA THE MOST SUPERIOR COUPLE. Idk about yall but kaistal literally gives off such a powerful vibe, chic, hot, sexy, models and etc. cant change my mind
soojung(krystal) has said many times that she feels uncomfortable when people bring up her past relationships, please respect her decisions and leave them alone.
sone彡 i dont think commenting under an old kaistal video, that krystal probably wont even see or search up, bc for obvious reasons wont see my comment. 💀💀stop reachin, only would be uncomfy for her if they comment it on her post or say it to her
Seems like Krystal is a jongin’s first love and crush. His love evaluation looks so heart touching. same time when two friends getting into a relationship is a big decision and when broke up happens it’s really hitting harder and hope they both get good partners in future.
I will always prefer Krystal with Kai over Jennie with Kai because this relationship actually seemed genuine. They were best friends who fell in love with each other and it was obvious how comfortable they were with each other. its a shame things didn't work out but they're still young and sure they may seem a bit distant now but you never know. Either way I'll support both of them and wish them both true happiness and love whether thats with each other or with someone else.
Mengapa sampai saat ini aku pun merasa sedih,, tapi aku yakin kai dan kristal pasti bahagia,, berjodoh maupun sebaiknya, aku harap mereka slalu bahagia 😭😭😭😭😍😍😍
i feel so bad for SM couples since they have so much high expectations and some of their fans are so immature, biased, and controlling. it upsetting to see KaiStal and BaekYeon were separated due to fans affecting their careers and HAPPINESS. some fans can’t see that they are human and human fall in love they aren’t robots. it annoys me cuz some fans ship them but when reality hits they want them to separate or criticize them only some of them but wtf! i shipped KaiStal and BaekYeon ever since their first interaction and i was happy to see them dating or were but i wish exo fans can treat them like they are humans that is ok to date someone they love. also that some exol to not criticize Taeyeon, Krystal, or anyone they date like they have a heart that is the same as we do so stop hating and hurting them
Yehet Sweg I feel the same. I've been seeing them working so hard and I really think they deserve all the happiness and love in the world. It's just sad that some fans can't even support them with the thing that make them happy, it's the least that they can do actually😪
They were sooo cute together but I guess they had a bad breakup.Judging from how Krystal commented on how she’ll never get back w the same guy after a breakup in her interview,And also how Kai strongly agreed when one of the Knowing Brother members said ‘There’s no such thing as true love’ 😭😭 I hope they’ll get back together if they were meant to be together
Now that I think about it Kaistal seem like the popular couple during high school (that everyone finds super cool), like the popular good liking jock, and the pretty cheerleader/ sports girl! Idk why they just gave that feel to me
Whoever said that idols in the same entertainment should not date, start praying, cause I'll remove every single limb of your body. You ruined such beautiful relationships such as KaiStal and BaekYeon
Honestly I just wish for their happiness but TO ME I feel that Kaistal feels a bit more... genuine? The timing of Jenkai felt too suspicious -- and they dated for like what 1 month (publicly)?? There were rumours flying around that Jennie was "dating" the CEO of YG (like wth who came up with these strange rumours???!!) and thus Jennie and Kai had to divert attention away and kind of "prove" that Jennie was NOT dating her CEO. Personally I think it's more of a "business deal" but if they were genuinely in love then I hope they will find happiness again.
@@wannableishere1156 lmao y'all really don't stan f(x) and it shows kaistal didn't seem very genuine, actually seemed like they were close friends that started to like eachother but after some time they fell out of love. i highly doubt soojung and jongin are still friends after this, their relationship didn't work out.
To those people who are worried about Krystal’s statement about her not going back again to her exes, correct me if I’m wrong but when asked if she had experienced on and off relationship, she said: “I’ve never had that situation. I may think this way because I’ve never experienced that situation before. It may happen in the future.” - Krystal She said she doesn’t think about her exes after the relationship ended but she doesn’t rule out the possibility of going back with one again. I agree, the future is uncertain. You cannot speak in a finishing manner. You’ll never know what the future holds.
Yeah ik they are now dating but I used to ship Kaistal I love them both but he's now with Jennie I ship them too Because I ship those who are dating not the one who by the camera angle look like they are staring at each other 🤣🤣
seriously i shipped these two way too long before they start dating and they will always be my favorite couple in kpop bcz their relationship was so good although they don't show it to the public but they were perfect for eachother , i hope they comeback together if they still love eachother
This relationship really made me happy and they are too, before. The way Jong-in looks so happy with Krystal and also in times he was sad you can clearly says he loved her before. I missed them 😐
I totally agree being an EXO-L I'm ashamed by the actions of some of the k-exols why do they have to be so nosy in their idols private lives or am I weird for bring happy when I hear that my idols are dating🙄honestly I just wish that they date peacefully and one day even get married to them I am so happy that Chen is getting married and giving us a beautiful princess to adore and love and I'm proud to say that Exo are not afraid of the responsibility and do not easily give in to some mindless selfish people who just want to ruin their lives .I as long as I'm an EXO-L (that is for the rest of life) will support each member in their love lives and their marriage .
With Kai and Krystal... I just felt bad how their close friendship seem to have ended alongside their relationship. They were close friends since trainee days and remain friends for 10 years then dated and when they break up... not only the relationship ended but the friendship too. That is so sad. 😭
I MEAN W DON’T KNOW DEEP INSIDE THEY LOVE EACH OTHER BUT FOR ME THEIR RELATIONSHIP WAS GOOD I MEAN THEY REALLY FIT TOGETHER YOU KNOW SOMETIMES RELATIONSHIPS ARE MADE TO BE A LESSON TO YOU OR A CAUSE OF BAD TIMING😢😢
Yes, it's true, Krystal does not like Taeyeon, because Jessica made her think that Taeyeon was a bad person, Jessica is very bad sometimes, in predebut she thought Tiffany was annoying and overactive (Sorry for the english i'm japanese)
They looked good together....it's really sad that they broke up but being an idol is very time consuming and not being able to see each other when in a relationship is damaging ....... :I it's hard for all idols to date..... :(
I'm so glad someone has finally done something good regarding KaiStal! No hating, no biasing, no negativity towards them. Thank you so much for doing this, even though I felt sad sometimes because I can't believe such a perfect couple came to an end, I was really happy to see their moments. I also hope they're still good friends, or they could be again in the future; but my illusions go further and I'd like to see them together again :'( Again, thanks for sharing this with us! ♡
@@helenakim9766 lmao i came here because i was watching krystal videos and this came up. if you genuinely like krystal please don't mention her past relationships because she has said that she's uncomfortable. stan f(x).
@@helenakim9766 plus jongin wouldn't appreciate you being stuck on his past relationship. remember how much shit soojung went through? im glad people learnt their mistakes and supported jenkai. soojung and jennie best girls.
@@asmin538 good thing jongin and krystal aren’t lurking in some kaistal youtube video and reading the comments? anyway, i believe i’m entitled to my own opinion and atleast i’m not shoving it to their faces via sns like some fandom out there. and if you think that its not good to rehash past relationships (as per soojung), you shouldn’t be in here as well. you shouldn’t have clicked this video and skimmed thru shippers’ comments then shoved your unsolicited opinion)
I actually think that Kai was so lucky to have her. She's amazing. She's kind, beautiful, and talented. She was admired by many celebrities, not only because of her visual, but also her attitude in performing. Some Exo-L's might not know this but she have many videos of her fainting while performing. She once fainted while performing and still holding her mic. She also finished her performance first and fainted right after. That's how professional she is. She barely think about herself and still think about their performance and would be thinking she would ruined it if she prioritized her health first. Despite of that netizens still called her a lazy performer. Now think on how she survived with haters being doubled because of her dating Kai. This what I hate about the fans, if they hear their bias dating someone they immediately think it was the girl who flirted with their bias. So, yeah Krystal deserved better.
Yall better protect Jennie now that she’s dating Kai. I do not want to see the same type of hatred from toxic fans when Krystal dated him. She didn’t deserve any of the toxicity. I’m happy that Krystal moved on and is living her best life💜💜
Natalia Carrion i mean even if they do break up eventually, what’s the point of hating on the couple? They’re happy together right now so we shouldn’t disturb that.
Natalia Carrion Commenting “idk” when I said hating an idol is unnecessary makes it seem that maybe you did intend hate. If have trouble being nice to idols, then you should really change your attitude.
it's sad idols have to be scared and worried if they are in a relationship. I wish people would support them, they are humans it's normal that we fall in love.
Well, I still support Kai & Krystal and still believe that they are still friends or maybe more than friends til now coz for how many years they've known each other, and it is not easy to break it PS. Nice history :) keep it up
kai deserves the best, he is the best person I know and anyone, whether male or female, who is his partner will be very lucky, he is such a kind, sweet, handsome and pleasant boy, he deserves the best
I still think these two are perfect for each other. yoooo been here since their interaction at sm town in LA, until their dating news came out and still here after years of their break up.
They were a hot and a beautiful couple, it's sad that it has already ended. Well tbh I'm still hoping that these two are in contact, if not more than friends then a friendship is enough. And yes, your last words are right 'individually support' them
im a blink and jennie is my bias wrecker. but kai looks better with krystal. im sad how people didnt support kai and krystal but they did support jennie and kai. im happy for the both of them but i miss kai and krystal 😭😭😭
I didn't know much of it. I think you did such a great job with putting up all the info. More people should watch this. You're right. They were a beautiful couple, and had the time to develop those feelings, and enjoy the time together. But for reasons that only they know, it wasn't meant to be like that, and it's good to see that fans continue to support them, and their work besides all that. I really loved your video. Again, you did such a great job!
If i can say something. In my opinion. This couple broke up not bcz they had their busy schedule. But bcz jongin was worried abt his fans, he's thinking a lot abt his fans. He might confused how to treat his fans after his dating news. Like krystal said that she hate pull and push relationship(?) I think jongin did it which is he was confused what should he do after dating news. Like he affraid to meet krystal after it. Even though he knew that many exol support his dating news. Bcz that they broke up. This is my opinion. Im an exol, and i hope in the future exo member will have a relationship without worrying exol. We, exol have our own life which is have bf and maybe husband so if you want to starting to dating a girl just do it without any hestitate🙏 exol not a teeneger anymore, 75% of us are adult. So dating or marry a girl comfortly. We will happy to see it❤
Milhatin Naimah lmao he didn’t break up with her because he was worried what his fans may think or to make them happy. i’m sorry but that’s the dumbest thing i’ve ever heard, can you imagine a celebrity living their life like that based on what their fans think? you’re delusional.
This is really hard, I am worried for idols, especially with the rumors about red velvet dating scandal in 2019, I want that things will change and idols could dating freely with any fear.
it doesn't matter who's better. Kai wanted to be with Jennie and Jennie wanted to be with Kai. your idol is happy with Jennie so just accept it and suck that up. Support them if you want to, if not, don't go around spreading negativity.
Nora Beckwith so what? what’s important is that they’re both happy. why worry about how long they’re gonna last? lol 😂 also, not to be that kind of person but.. it’s “THEY’RE as in THEY ARE not THEIR” you’re welcome 😊👌
@@norabeckwith446 you are acting like jennie is 18 LOL she's turning 23 in january and kai is 25 in january thats only 2 years Krystal is only 24 as well what you on about child/woman they are literally nearly the same age krystal and kai were younger than that when they started dating
i respect that but i hope you respect their relationship too, you wouldn't be too happy if someone says they like your boyfriend more with his previous girlfriend than you, would you? (just an example).. Kai is happy with Jennie now, he's already moved on so why can't you? if you don't like them together then at least be respectful enough
@@liezelanne777 yeah i know it, we have to respect it all, kai is human too and we know it. thats just my opinion, im glad kai found his new lover, i just dont ship jen-kai, not hate them👌
It's 2020 im still for Kaistal.. i hope they become friends again or even back together. After watching this video my heart 💔 when they ended their relationship.. Kai deserve to be happy.
I wonder why ? For those who now knowing that kai and jennie confirm to be dating came here ,Yall know this is story about KAISTAL,don't bother kaistal shipper bcs we still in dilemma,I'm for sure still can't get over that breathtaking news ,so you guys should has to go Jenkai right ,don't bothering us with that inappropriate comment session views down below by keep saying about Jenkai.I'm frustrated and emo rn yes yes
@@milkbread4691 that's the point ! Until now if I miss them I came here to see those story bout them ,but now looking at the comments all about jenkai.We just need time to accept it ,really real soon.Kaistal just a memories ,kai happy with a new one,pls let our precious girl named krystal happy too ,she deserve more.Thank you for your understanding
the fact that people had a different response to kaistal than they had to baekyeon really breaks my heart. LET THEM BE HAPPY THEY ARE HUMAN TOO LET THEM DO WHATEVER THEY WANT
some of you “fans” dont even understand how serious this is. much love to the fans out their who love and support them regardless of who they date. but hating and breaking people apart, especially a close relationship can tear someone the hell apart and its sad that thats what happened here all because some “fans” didnt approve of it. its honestly really sad and i honestly hope Kai and Jennie have a happy relationship, and i really hope they stay happy and dont get depressed or down if people hate on them. :(
They were the most powerful couple. They really suit each other a lot! My selfish self wish they will still be in the end. If that happens in the future, I will be the happiest 🥺❤️
After everything, I just WOW at the editing!! Superb, almost felt like a movie or something. Loved Kai & Krystal too bad its rly hard to date in that line of work but wish them both happiness ☺️
I have a tear from 11:00 such as a beautiful journey... Thanks for making this pretty video :') May kaistal always happy, stay healthy as our hope.. aameen
Came here after SM released an official statement about the confirmation of the dating rumour Jennie and Kai has. And it breaks my heart xc don't get me wrong, but I'm happy for Jennie because as she stated she is now a happy jennie when she went to Paris with Kai and that makes me greatful but also to be honest, I never thought of them to be a couple so I was shocked xD but yeah, ever since it was confirmed that this two was dating years ago, I was so happy because like ughhh~ They suit each other and I kinda thought they'd get back together y'know? But I'm looking forward for what Jennie and Kai brings. And I am also happy that unlike the oast dating 'scandals' where exo-l's get too much obsessed and posessive, this time both Fandoms swore on protecting the two. A job well done you guys.
ThisIsMyShitue I’m thought I’d just clarify this, Kai and Jennie went to Paris separately. They didn’t have dinner together they just posted around the same time I think. Plus kai had fans following him around (sadly😔) so It’d be impossible for them to have dinner without fans finding out.
*"Let our idols be happy in their own way, with whoever they want and how they want"* *I THINK IT'S TIME THAT FANS ACCEPT CHEN HAVING HIS OWN FAMILY ALREADY AND I HOPE ALL THE HATES THROWN AT HIM WILL STOP ALREADY. CHEN IS STILL A HUMAN AND HAS HIS OWN FEELINGS AND OPINIONS. IF YOU ARE A TRUE FAN, I HOPE YOU REALIZE THAT WHAT YOU ARE DOING IS HURTING THE ONE YOU LOVE. LET'S SPREAD THE LOVE ♡* PS. I know this is not related to the couple but still hope this reaches out those particular "fans"
Kaistal is just legendary couple just like Baekyeon, YoonA Lee Seunggi, Lee Minho Suzy, Khuntoria, BByu, (even its just wgm couple). Their relationship is just legendary even they're all broke up.
I don’t know how to react to it...but as I said in “The History Of BaekYeon” if they are happy,I am happy...I hope they can be friends someday...❣️
#BaekYeon
#KaiStal
Unicorn Lay Love your words💕,thanks for watching the two videos🙈
well for baek and taeyeon they stopped avoiding eachothers i think they moved on and he even greeted her and she too smiled and greated him
Nicole Loves OhSehun, SAMEE.
Yes were just friends with you guys
Kaistal, maybe. But Baek__yeon? I donths.
Dispatch destroys relationships.
Maria Bn Fans*
Idol life*
Maria Bn faxx
Fans and Dispatch
fans and idol life*
now kai and jennie is dating and everyone is accepting. i just felt sad for kaistal and baekyeon because they never experience that kind of acceptance.
Pritse Qtie what can i say most blink are supportive
people learned from the past that's why..
Kaistal got so much love from fans too. Their love story got happy ending and it left good memories between them.
actually not all exols are accepting
...some of my friends gone mad...and i was like ‘lets just chill’
I agree like fans were telling the girls to go kill themselves and shit like seriously
These two probably dated for a lot longer than what was said and honestly it wouldn't surprise me if they were still dating, statement or otherwise.
same, I think they really dated each other before they we're Dispatch by the media.
Eve Tan I agree that u think they were in a relationship before it was confirmed but I think they really broke up tbh😕
Well, we don't know anything. If they're happy with each other nor with their individual lives, let's just support them
MISS PANDUHK true
Agree base on all their moments, kai defenitely had a crush on her since trainee and when the pink tape photos with kai happened and f(x) had an interview on a radio show and the members called him “jonginnie” while krystal called him “this kid” made it seem like kai has already confessed to her and that they were close and 2015 was the year they probably dated
People didn't even know how precious they're relationship is. They went from bestfriends to lovers.
exols- protecc jennie.
*krystal and taeyeon left the conversation bc they had it worst back then*
Came here after the dating news of jennie and kai.
In terms of dating an exo member, taeyeon had it worst
@@noname-pl5ob yep, krystal and taeyeon, of course
@@j6k122 its not unfair. Yes it was sad for krystal and taeyeon but its good that fans learned their lesson and start to accept idol relationships.
Amine Sinan It’s funny how we assume that they’ve grown up. For the most part that’s true but there are still a lot of delusion fans that protest and boycott against them when they announce they’re in a relationship. Like the “scandal” about Chen for instance. He’s getting married to a woman whom he really loves and is going to become a father. It’s the greatest thing a human can experience and people are bashing for having a regular, normal life.
They aren’t dating. It’s all a hoax and a publicity stunt by SM
kaistal's relationship was beautiful and it was clear that kai genuinely had feelings for her. but krystal said that when they break up, theyre done and that makes me so sad because they couldve made more history together and prove to everyone that a female idol and a male idol can last more than one year
I broke my heart when the news of their break up came out. I really love their love story and them for each other. I hope they both believe in second chances. ♥
I feel bad but i´m not gonna lie I was glad that they broke up if they really dated. Exo is really popular so they have a lot of saesang fans and obsessive fans specially from China. Everyday in instagram they left mean and rude comments to krystal and the articules about going to an hotel or shopping condoms without real proofs. It was too much. I feel sorry for the guys because I can´t see them dating at least for the next 5 years.
andrea Ramos Your last sentence is the complete opposite of you “feeling bad” because they broke up. You also can’t “feel sorry for the guys” if you’re one of those who are against them being in a relationship. I feel more sorry for them because they can’t be in a happy relationship because of their butt hurt fans. I hope fans will accept the fact that the day will come where these idols will get married with someone they love-whether it will be 5 years from now or tomorrow, even today-because they are humans too.
And I’m pretty sure they dated for real especially after their escape room date pictures got leaked.
English isn´t my first language so I don´t know if I express myself. When I say I feel bad it´s because I don´t want to feel relieved that they are not dating anymore because break ups sucks but krystal always recieve so much hate from her resting face since her debut. And exo is too popular and I can´t imagine Kai defend his relationship because fans pull the "fans card" . It´s too much for both.
I agree but I'm hurting myself while shipping them 😂
*jennie enters the chat*
To be honest they can go far, like seriously madly serious about their relationship but the public....stupid
orange Peech ikr
ikr
They have their own reasons too, but if the fans supported their relationship I think Kaistal will lasts longer
So sorry for Krystal, when Kai's fan bullied and hurt her.... And now, they're protecting Jennie... I hope they did it earlier 😭
Coz Jennie has a lot of fans compare to Krystal and I think Jennie met their standards that why most of exo-l ship and support them.
Uhh, Krystal’s fan bullied Kai too.
Even if Krystal didn't meet their supposed standards aa yoy say that isn't an acceptable reason for them to attack her
jennie and kai broke up because so many people hate jennie and called her lazy scandals😭 i feel bad for kyrstal and jennie,jennie had a bad day after they announce the couple, she really happy before 😟
@@rosieposieo0o842 trueeee
It seems that Kai already had a crush on Krystal since the first day... such a cutie pie love..and seeing how bad EXO have been through all this years.I really want them all to have a beautiful relationship with someone like Krystal.They deserves to be happy...
@Alpaca Young kai looks so.onvious had a crush with krystal around 2012-2013.
@Alpaca Young *obvious
@Alpaca Young no, im not. I know they are best friend before but his expression when krystal around her is so different with the other girls. And it reminds me with some my friends when they are around their crush. Its normal i think.
I don’t know about you guys but in my opinion Kaistal seemed like one of the realest and most genuine Kpop relationships. I loved them together so much
KAISTAL AKA THE MOST SUPERIOR COUPLE.
Idk about yall but kaistal literally gives off such a powerful vibe, chic, hot, sexy, models and etc. cant change my mind
soojung(krystal) has said many times that she feels uncomfortable when people bring up her past relationships, please respect her decisions and leave them alone.
sone彡 i dont think commenting under an old kaistal video, that krystal probably wont even see or search up, bc for obvious reasons wont see my comment. 💀💀stop reachin, only would be uncomfy for her if they comment it on her post or say it to her
Agreed the most amazing couple. I still stan for KAISTAL.
Still kaistal!!!
im still shipping them even though they broke up😂
Trish Amor Same with BaekYeon😭
Was that them who kissed
I feel it’s wrong to do it
@@psssume3626 why?
Trish Amor me as always... Hard shipper of kaistal...
Seems like Krystal is a jongin’s first love and crush. His love evaluation looks so heart touching. same time when two friends getting into a relationship is a big decision and when broke up happens it’s really hitting harder and hope they both get good partners in future.
I will always prefer Krystal with Kai over Jennie with Kai because this relationship actually seemed genuine. They were best friends who fell in love with each other and it was obvious how comfortable they were with each other. its a shame things didn't work out but they're still young and sure they may seem a bit distant now but you never know. Either way I'll support both of them and wish them both true happiness and love whether thats with each other or with someone else.
Mengapa sampai saat ini aku pun merasa sedih,, tapi aku yakin kai dan kristal pasti bahagia,, berjodoh maupun sebaiknya, aku harap mereka slalu bahagia 😭😭😭😭😍😍😍
you act like you know them💀
i feel so bad for SM couples since they have so much high expectations and some of their fans are so immature, biased, and controlling. it upsetting to see KaiStal and BaekYeon were separated due to fans affecting their careers and HAPPINESS. some fans can’t see that they are human and human fall in love they aren’t robots. it annoys me cuz some fans ship them but when reality hits they want them to separate or criticize them only some of them but wtf! i shipped KaiStal and BaekYeon ever since their first interaction and i was happy to see them dating or were but i wish exo fans can treat them like they are humans that is ok to date someone they love. also that some exol to not criticize Taeyeon, Krystal, or anyone they date like they have a heart that is the same as we do so stop hating and hurting them
Yehet Sweg I feel the same. I've been seeing them working so hard and I really think they deserve all the happiness and love in the world. It's just sad that some fans can't even support them with the thing that make them happy, it's the least that they can do actually😪
I like ur pfp
They were sooo cute together but I guess they had a bad breakup.Judging from how Krystal commented on how she’ll never get back w the same guy after a breakup in her interview,And also how Kai strongly agreed when one of the Knowing Brother members said ‘There’s no such thing as true love’ 😭😭 I hope they’ll get back together if they were meant to be together
kpoplover08 the crying man meme is my literal mood rn
NAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHAHAHHAHDHDNFJDHSJJFKD
I think they literally said that bcs they were still broken-hearted
kpoplover08 sm said they're still friends tho I don't think what she said was related to her rs with him
Some fans are just toxic
Now that I think about it Kaistal seem like the popular couple during high school (that everyone finds super cool), like the popular good liking jock, and the pretty cheerleader/ sports girl! Idk why they just gave that feel to me
No hate but, JenKai has nothing to do here, this is KaiStal moment
BITCH IKR
Yes 👍
why are JenKai stans here?? Are they jealous their faves doesn't get much history???
@@Kaye_Gaming1028
Why would they want Kai :/
@@Kaye_Gaming1028 hindi ba pwedeng inaalam lang yung story ng kaistal, anong klaseng mindset yan b tch
OKAY BUT DISPATCH NEEDS TO STOP AND MIND THEIR OWN BUSINESS-
Whoever said that idols in the same entertainment should not date, start praying, cause I'll remove every single limb of your body. You ruined such beautiful relationships such as KaiStal and BaekYeon
I have never been saw Kai super excited and happy and bright after they have broken up. He was really in loved with Krystal
I came after after Kai and Jennie because I’m salty I liked this ship more but some crazy fans ruined it.
Same girl hayss
Sameee
Honestly I just wish for their happiness but TO ME I feel that Kaistal feels a bit more... genuine? The timing of Jenkai felt too suspicious -- and they dated for like what 1 month (publicly)?? There were rumours flying around that Jennie was "dating" the CEO of YG (like wth who came up with these strange rumours???!!) and thus Jennie and Kai had to divert attention away and kind of "prove" that Jennie was NOT dating her CEO. Personally I think it's more of a "business deal" but if they were genuinely in love then I hope they will find happiness again.
@@wannableishere1156 lmao y'all really don't stan f(x) and it shows kaistal didn't seem very genuine, actually seemed like they were close friends that started to like eachother but after some time they fell out of love. i highly doubt soojung and jongin are still friends after this, their relationship didn't work out.
@@asmin538 that just proves even more that their feelings are real and that kaistal was genuine and based on love????? lmfao
who's here after knowing the Kai and Jennie's dating rumor?
Meee
@@respectvips..yahbaekhyun4771 shocking isn't it?
@@winkingucci1487 yep. I cant believe
@@respectvips..yahbaekhyun4771 me too
wink in gucci it’s not a rumor it’s a fact now keke
To those people who are worried about Krystal’s statement about her not going back again to her exes, correct me if I’m wrong but when asked if she had experienced on and off relationship, she said:
“I’ve never had that situation. I may think this way because I’ve never experienced that situation before.
It may happen in the future.”
- Krystal
She said she doesn’t think about her exes after the relationship ended but she doesn’t rule out the possibility of going back with one again. I agree, the future is uncertain. You cannot speak in a finishing manner. You’ll never know what the future holds.
She broke up with him, ok? Leave her alone now
Kai and jennie lol
Edit: broke up lol
Yeah ik they are now dating but I used to ship Kaistal I love them both but he's now with Jennie I ship them too
Because I ship those who are dating not the one who by the camera angle look like they are staring at each other 🤣🤣
JENKAI
@@jimindepity_7771 Thank you. If those camera-angled looking couples are actually dating, please support them as well :)
lmfao
i could have shipped kaistal if they didnt already confirm jenkai
seriously i shipped these two way too long before they start dating and they will always be my favorite couple in kpop bcz their relationship was so good although they don't show it to the public but they were perfect for eachother , i hope they comeback together if they still love eachother
Nour Chaieb krystal said she doesn't give second chances :(
yeah i read that somewhere but who knows maybe one day she will change her mind (i hope so)
minatozaki sana stole my heart huh? she was talking about her character in the drama not in real life
KaiStal was one of the most beautiful match made kpop couples ive ever known
In my opinion soojung is the most suitable pairing for jongin..
The fact that they had to break up because of the immature fans break my heart into million pieces
I came here after hearing that jennie and kai are dating
I came here after they broke up
Honel fam. Same & cause I miss kaistal
HAHAHAHA damn
Jenkai is media play
@@jenskieeherim4593 nah
He's so in love with her lol.. sadly fans can't accept it
kai really like her
This relationship really made me happy and they are too, before. The way Jong-in looks so happy with Krystal and also in times he was sad you can clearly says he loved her before. I missed them 😐
Just finished reading an article saying Exo kai and black pink Jennie are dating
I don’t care who he dates , I am happy for him
#SupportEXOtoDating ❤
They are handsome and in age for dating, please Aeri ya, let them dating freely❤
@@arin441 4:45
I totally agree being an EXO-L I'm ashamed by the actions of some of the k-exols why do they have to be so nosy in their idols private lives or am I weird for bring happy when I hear that my idols are dating🙄honestly I just wish that they date peacefully and one day even get married to them I am so happy that Chen is getting married and giving us a beautiful princess to adore and love and I'm proud to say that Exo are not afraid of the responsibility and do not easily give in to some mindless selfish people who just want to ruin their lives .I as long as I'm an EXO-L (that is for the rest of life) will support each member in their love lives and their marriage .
Most of international fans are very supportive korean one are just wild
With Kai and Krystal... I just felt bad how their close friendship seem to have ended alongside their relationship. They were close friends since trainee days and remain friends for 10 years then dated and when they break up... not only the relationship ended but the friendship too. That is so sad. 😭
I MEAN W DON’T KNOW DEEP INSIDE THEY LOVE EACH OTHER BUT FOR ME THEIR RELATIONSHIP WAS GOOD I MEAN THEY REALLY FIT TOGETHER YOU KNOW SOMETIMES RELATIONSHIPS ARE MADE TO BE A LESSON TO YOU OR A CAUSE OF BAD TIMING😢😢
Ikr i have a feeling they still love each other
This is probably the cutest and the most genuine relationship kpop had, too bad
I wonder if baekyeon and Kaistal went on double dates LOL (probably not)
chibisue chibisue krystal probably doesn't like taeyeon after what happened with Jessica. (her sister)
Yes, it's true, Krystal does not like Taeyeon, because Jessica made her think that Taeyeon was a bad person, Jessica is very bad sometimes, in predebut she thought Tiffany was annoying and overactive (Sorry for the english i'm japanese)
Umm...Sm ENT didn't confirmed that they are dating
V's wife yes they did, for both couples
V's wife yeh they did
came here after watching the mv of kai's solo debut mmmh bro the lyrics are giving me flashbacks anyways stream mmh
Who’s here after jennie and kai dating
Me
Me
Me...
Changkyun Monsta me
me
They looked good together....it's really sad that they broke up but being an idol is very time consuming and not being able to see each other when in a relationship is damaging ....... :I it's hard for all idols to date..... :(
deff wat I just wish they could be together again, it is just so sad these two just starting and ending it so fast
same :( idky i think kaistal still love each other tho
Kai have dated
SM:Krystal
Now YG:Jennie
Who's next JYP??
😂😂
ãññìě Kpop 😂😂😂
Bighit jk
@@asd-do1xm lol 😂
@@zenntakumi7174 nooo 😀
After jyp, it will be bighit😂 probably jimin😂😂
I'm so glad someone has finally done something good regarding KaiStal! No hating, no biasing, no negativity towards them.
Thank you so much for doing this, even though I felt sad sometimes because I can't believe such a perfect couple came to an end, I was really happy to see their moments.
I also hope they're still good friends, or they could be again in the future; but my illusions go further and I'd like to see them together again :'(
Again, thanks for sharing this with us! ♡
After all these years, I cannot see Jongin with somebody other than Kyungsoo and Krystal. Only those two.
jennie? im a huge kaisoo stan but y'all being a little delusional rn
@@asmin538 i said what i said. find jenkai vids somewhere else to buzz on.
@@helenakim9766 lmao i came here because i was watching krystal videos and this came up. if you genuinely like krystal please don't mention her past relationships because she has said that she's uncomfortable. stan f(x).
@@helenakim9766 plus jongin wouldn't appreciate you being stuck on his past relationship. remember how much shit soojung went through? im glad people learnt their mistakes and supported jenkai. soojung and jennie best girls.
@@asmin538 good thing jongin and krystal aren’t lurking in some kaistal youtube video and reading the comments? anyway, i believe i’m entitled to my own opinion and atleast i’m not shoving it to their faces via sns like some fandom out there. and if you think that its not good to rehash past relationships (as per soojung), you shouldn’t be in here as well. you shouldn’t have clicked this video and skimmed thru shippers’ comments then shoved your unsolicited opinion)
"they broke up doe their busy schedule"
I don't know but I'm tired of hearing that... That's so unfair :(
I actually think that Kai was so lucky to have her. She's amazing. She's kind, beautiful, and talented. She was admired by many celebrities, not
only because of her visual, but also her attitude in performing. Some Exo-L's might not know this but she have many videos of her fainting while
performing. She once fainted while performing and still holding her mic. She also finished her performance first and fainted right after. That's how professional she is. She barely think about herself and still think about their performance and would be thinking she would ruined it if she
prioritized her health first. Despite of that netizens still called her a lazy performer. Now think on how she survived with haters being doubled
because of her dating Kai. This what I hate about the fans, if they hear their bias dating someone they immediately think it was the girl who flirted
with their bias. So, yeah Krystal deserved better.
As much as I respect JenKai, my love for Kaistal will never end 😔👊🏻
Yall better protect Jennie now that she’s dating Kai. I do not want to see the same type of hatred from toxic fans when Krystal dated him. She didn’t deserve any of the toxicity. I’m happy that Krystal moved on and is living her best life💜💜
Kpop Llama no hate intended but like it seems they'll break up by 2020
LMAO
Natalia Carrion i mean even if they do break up eventually, what’s the point of hating on the couple? They’re happy together right now so we shouldn’t disturb that.
Kpop Llama idk
Natalia Carrion Commenting “idk” when I said hating an idol is unnecessary makes it seem that maybe you did intend hate. If have trouble being nice to idols, then you should really change your attitude.
it's sad idols have to be scared and worried if they are in a relationship. I wish people would support them, they are humans it's normal that we fall in love.
This is so sad. I’m literally cryin rn.
I love how sm is so cool about their artists dating thing
Well, I still support Kai & Krystal and still believe that they are still friends or maybe more than friends til now coz for how many years they've known each other, and it is not easy to break it
PS. Nice history :) keep it up
ITS 2020 AND IM STILL HERE BECAUSE THEIR GODDAMN RELATABLE TO EACH OTHER UGHHHH WHYYYYYY I NEED KAISTAL COMEBACK
STILL ICONIC COUPLE IN THE KPOP INDUSTRY.
media destroy many relationships, anyway they looks really good together
kai deserves the best, he is the best person I know and anyone, whether male or female, who is his partner will be very lucky, he is such a kind, sweet, handsome and pleasant boy, he deserves the best
they were such powerful couple. too bad toxic fans and the media destroyed the rights of idols to be happy as well ~
my heart felt so heavy... I have shipped them since the day Jongin's first teaser came out. I knew he was the perfect pair for Soojung...
Today's Kai dating news broke my heart T_T I really wanted him to go back to Krys T_T but as long as Kai's happy, well, we can do nothing about it :")
I still think these two are perfect for each other. yoooo been here since their interaction at sm town in LA, until their dating news came out and still here after years of their break up.
They were a hot and a beautiful couple, it's sad that it has already ended. Well tbh I'm still hoping that these two are in contact, if not more than friends then a friendship is enough. And yes, your last words are right 'individually support' them
im a blink and jennie is my bias wrecker.
but kai looks better with krystal.
im sad how people didnt support kai and krystal but they did support jennie and kai.
im happy for the both of them but i miss kai and krystal 😭😭😭
@ankita sinha exactly like girl have you not seen how much hate jennie was getting
I didn't know much of it. I think you did such a great job with putting up all the info. More people should watch this.
You're right. They were a beautiful couple, and had the time to develop those feelings, and enjoy the time together. But for reasons that only they know, it wasn't meant to be like that, and it's good to see that fans continue to support them, and their work besides all that.
I really loved your video. Again, you did such a great job!
He likes her so much. If it wasn't for his fans objecting his relationship they're probably still together (I think?)
If i can say something. In my opinion. This couple broke up not bcz they had their busy schedule. But bcz jongin was worried abt his fans, he's thinking a lot abt his fans. He might confused how to treat his fans after his dating news. Like krystal said that she hate pull and push relationship(?) I think jongin did it which is he was confused what should he do after dating news. Like he affraid to meet krystal after it. Even though he knew that many exol support his dating news. Bcz that they broke up. This is my opinion. Im an exol, and i hope in the future exo member will have a relationship without worrying exol. We, exol have our own life which is have bf and maybe husband so if you want to starting to dating a girl just do it without any hestitate🙏 exol not a teeneger anymore, 75% of us are adult. So dating or marry a girl comfortly. We will happy to see it❤
Milhatin Naimah i agreed with you..
Ikr
I agree with you. Kai :( couldn't blame him , he's sucha softie
Milhatin Naimah lmao he didn’t break up with her because he was worried what his fans may think or to make them happy. i’m sorry but that’s the dumbest thing i’ve ever heard, can you imagine a celebrity living their life like that based on what their fans think? you’re delusional.
Wow
kaistal shouldn't end:(
Oh god they really suit each other well, be happy KaiStal.
I don't believe they break seriously 😭😭😭😭 i still believe kaistal real 😭😭😭
This is really hard, I am worried for idols, especially with the rumors about red velvet dating scandal in 2019, I want that things will change and idols could dating freely with any fear.
It think KaiStal is better than JenKai
_hmmm_
it doesn't matter who's better. Kai wanted to be with Jennie and Jennie wanted to be with Kai. your idol is happy with Jennie so just accept it and suck that up. Support them if you want to, if not, don't go around spreading negativity.
@@liezelanne777 bro their not gonna last long like kyrstal and kai Jennie is just a child kyrstal is a women theirs a difference
Nora Beckwith so what? what’s important is that they’re both happy. why worry about how long they’re gonna last? lol 😂 also, not to be that kind of person but.. it’s “THEY’RE as in THEY ARE not THEIR” you’re welcome 😊👌
@@norabeckwith446 you are acting like jennie is 18 LOL she's turning 23 in january and kai is 25 in january thats only 2 years Krystal is only 24 as well what you on about child/woman they are literally nearly the same age krystal and kai were younger than that when they started dating
I came here bcs i miss kaistal so much, skip me but i prefer kaistal more than jenkai or those shippers called them
i respect that but i hope you respect their relationship too, you wouldn't be too happy if someone says they like your boyfriend more with his previous girlfriend than you, would you? (just an example).. Kai is happy with Jennie now, he's already moved on so why can't you? if you don't like them together then at least be respectful enough
@@liezelanne777 she dont have to respect it dont force her
Nora Beckwith lol watttt??? how old are you even? and do you go to school because ftw?
@@liezelanne777 yeah i know it, we have to respect it all, kai is human too and we know it. thats just my opinion, im glad kai found his new lover, i just dont ship jen-kai, not hate them👌
van nia i respect your side and opinion😊👌
It's 2020 im still for Kaistal.. i hope they become friends again or even back together. After watching this video my heart 💔 when they ended their relationship.. Kai deserve to be happy.
THEY WERE SO CUTE TOGETHER WTF
I wonder why ? For those who now knowing that kai and jennie confirm to be dating came here ,Yall know this is story about KAISTAL,don't bother kaistal shipper bcs we still in dilemma,I'm for sure still can't get over that breathtaking news ,so you guys should has to go Jenkai right ,don't bothering us with that inappropriate comment session views down below by keep saying about Jenkai.I'm frustrated and emo rn yes yes
Quirky alone IKR! So annoying. I support jenkai but what’s the purpose of them commenting here?
@@milkbread4691 that's the point ! Until now if I miss them I came here to see those story bout them ,but now looking at the comments all about jenkai.We just need time to accept it ,really real soon.Kaistal just a memories ,kai happy with a new one,pls let our precious girl named krystal happy too ,she deserve more.Thank you for your understanding
Quirky alone agreeeeee
Not only here....those comments are everywhere and it's getting annoying
SAY THIS TO THOSE PEOPLE AT THE BACK
Dispatch destroys relationships
This was in my recommendation after Jennie kai dating news. 😅
I needed this.. the whole video was so beautiful.. great effort
I'm still shipping them hard
literally one of my favorite couples i’m so sad to see kaistal breakup ;-;
the fact that people had a different response to kaistal than they had to baekyeon really breaks my heart. LET THEM BE HAPPY THEY ARE HUMAN TOO LET THEM DO WHATEVER THEY WANT
Why is everyone keep bringing in Jenkai? Why can’t we just talk about Kaistal, Jenkai always doesn’t have to be involved.
it's 2021 and here i am still sailing this ship!
KaiStal never ended i swear it 😿
some of you “fans” dont even understand how serious this is. much love to the fans out their who love and support them regardless of who they date. but hating and breaking people apart, especially a close relationship can tear someone the hell apart and its sad that thats what happened here all because some “fans” didnt approve of it. its honestly really sad and i honestly hope Kai and Jennie have a happy relationship, and i really hope they stay happy and dont get depressed or down if people hate on them. :(
They were the most powerful couple. They really suit each other a lot! My selfish self wish they will still be in the end. If that happens in the future, I will be the happiest 🥺❤️
After everything, I just WOW at the editing!! Superb, almost felt like a movie or something. Loved Kai & Krystal too bad its rly hard to date in that line of work but wish them both happiness ☺️
still shipping them in 2023😭😭😭 my heart is for kaistal
I don’t care about who he is with , I just love Nini and I’ll support and love him unconditionally forever💙
i came here because i miss kaistal.
I have a tear from 11:00 such as a beautiful journey... Thanks for making this pretty video :')
May kaistal always happy, stay healthy as our hope.. aameen
Came here after SM released an official statement about the confirmation of the dating rumour Jennie and Kai has. And it breaks my heart xc don't get me wrong, but I'm happy for Jennie because as she stated she is now a happy jennie when she went to Paris with Kai and that makes me greatful but also to be honest, I never thought of them to be a couple so I was shocked xD but yeah, ever since it was confirmed that this two was dating years ago, I was so happy because like ughhh~ They suit each other and I kinda thought they'd get back together y'know? But I'm looking forward for what Jennie and Kai brings. And I am also happy that unlike the oast dating 'scandals' where exo-l's get too much obsessed and posessive, this time both Fandoms swore on protecting the two. A job well done you guys.
ThisIsMyShitue I’m thought I’d just clarify this, Kai and Jennie went to Paris separately. They didn’t have dinner together they just posted around the same time I think. Plus kai had fans following him around (sadly😔) so It’d be impossible for them to have dinner without fans finding out.
ThisIsMyShitue can I just now why everyone thinks that they went to Paris together? They only posted at the same time lmao
today is their day, and i come back here, i miss them
*"Let our idols be happy in their own way, with whoever they want and how they want"*
*I THINK IT'S TIME THAT FANS ACCEPT CHEN HAVING HIS OWN FAMILY ALREADY AND I HOPE ALL THE HATES THROWN AT HIM WILL STOP ALREADY. CHEN IS STILL A HUMAN AND HAS HIS OWN FEELINGS AND OPINIONS. IF YOU ARE A TRUE FAN, I HOPE YOU REALIZE THAT WHAT YOU ARE DOING IS HURTING THE ONE YOU LOVE. LET'S SPREAD THE LOVE ♡*
PS. I know this is not related to the couple but still hope this reaches out those particular "fans"
This couple is really POWERFUL! Hope they go back to each other.
Kai real and first love is Krystal, my baby was so happy nervous feeling all these emotions 🐻😭
i came back here cause i miss my kaistal interactions so bad, 2012-2016 were the good old days for krystal and kai, wish i can turn back time
Kaistal is just legendary couple just like Baekyeon, YoonA Lee Seunggi, Lee Minho Suzy, Khuntoria, BByu, (even its just wgm couple). Their relationship is just legendary even they're all broke up.
OMG you made me cry...in the end with the music...
You'R really great!