Schönberg - Pelleas and Melisande, Op. 5 (Claudio Abbado & Gustav Mahler Youth Orchestra)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @EpikPataTo
    @EpikPataTo День тому

    Just discovered this recently....indescribably moving...finale takes away my breath and tears flow!

  • @jakeplonk888
    @jakeplonk888 Рік тому +10

    Abbado was a genius. A true prince, irreplaceable

  • @kazmcokogullu9945
    @kazmcokogullu9945 2 роки тому +13

    beautiful young artists came together under the guidence of one of the best conductors of our time. Youth energy and pureness come together with old and wise. Schoenberg would be so happy if he could have listened to this

  • @lionelthiebaud7081
    @lionelthiebaud7081 9 місяців тому +1

    Quelle est l'année de ce merveilleux concert sous la direction de sublime Claudio Abbado

  • @bateriaeletronica
    @bateriaeletronica Рік тому +2

    This is the best and most emotional version of this song.

  • @matthewwarren1189
    @matthewwarren1189 Місяць тому

    18:20 the love and farewell scene is so heartbreakingly beautiful

  • @bkkershner
    @bkkershner 5 років тому +21

    The playing is simply beyond belief, and at that age...Must have been life-changing to play it with Claudio Abbado.

  • @Yannoux3000
    @Yannoux3000 6 місяців тому +1

    I really appreciate that the production highlighted the themes and their meaning in the program. Pelleas is such the perfect musical subject... Great great piece

  • @angelosilva4051
    @angelosilva4051 3 роки тому +3

    Grande capolavoro di Schonberg strepitosi orchestra e direttore.

  • @MGHTYPIETYOSRS
    @MGHTYPIETYOSRS 9 днів тому

    Magnifico

  • @zcde345
    @zcde345 4 роки тому +6

    Incredible playing from this magnificent youth orchestra! Maestro Abbado in top form.

  • @benjaminsim5233
    @benjaminsim5233 4 роки тому +28

    The very same hall which the piece was premiered in 1905

  • @64214Jose
    @64214Jose 3 роки тому +3

    Maravillosa obra maestra excelentemente interpretada. Genial. Mi versión favorita, por cierto.

  • @ingamoss-jones6838
    @ingamoss-jones6838 2 роки тому +1

    Beauty and romance well played by young people

  • @bateriaeletronica
    @bateriaeletronica Рік тому

    This is the most beautiful song I have ever heard.

    • @badhairdye
      @badhairdye Рік тому +2

      Unfortunately, it isn't a song. It's a piece, specifically a tone poem, in this case a piece of programme music. Not that it isn't songful! It's more motivic perhaps than melodious. Just some observations. It's good to find someone who at least appreciates it.

  • @lorenzoalessi8953
    @lorenzoalessi8953 4 роки тому +2

    Grande Abbado per questi meravigliosi giovani

  • @alanmofticomposer
    @alanmofticomposer Рік тому

    This is genuinely mind-blowing.

  • @afbf6522
    @afbf6522 Рік тому

    Quin poema tan intrigant. Schönberg va posar-se el barret impressionista, i tant.

  • @borisbrinkmann
    @borisbrinkmann Рік тому

    Bester Fin de siecle-Dirigent.

  • @vaughanosgan2623
    @vaughanosgan2623 Рік тому

    Superb presentation

  • @kwiingina4375
    @kwiingina4375 2 роки тому

    He literally make a story through opera amazing👌

    • @badhairdye
      @badhairdye Рік тому

      Maeterlinclk's Pelleas et Melisande is a drama, set to music by amongst others Debussy. Schoenberg created a tone poem from the original drama -- a piece of programme music.

  • @isabelhuszka1321
    @isabelhuszka1321 3 роки тому +1

    Szép volt, köszönöm!

  • @anonym0usplatypus
    @anonym0usplatypus 7 років тому +7

    These young musicians understand Schoenberg so well

  • @arquelesestrada7918
    @arquelesestrada7918 5 років тому +2

    Estupenda ejecucion de la Orquesta juvenil Gustav Mahler.

  • @AlamannoCapecchi
    @AlamannoCapecchi 7 років тому +8

    Magnifico.

  • @ilmusicofilo
    @ilmusicofilo 3 роки тому

    madonna mia che bordello suonare sta roba

  • @georgeholloway3981
    @georgeholloway3981 2 роки тому +1

    Why is the audience so subdued at the end? That was simply out of this world! Do they know what they just witnessed?!

    • @paulybarr
      @paulybarr 2 роки тому +1

      Sometimes people are struck dumb with admiration. It can also mean that they are so involved with the music, especially such a tragic piece as this, that they don't want to break the spell immediately- it can feel uncouth. Did you not listen to how the applause grows to cheering and foot stopping after 30 seconds?

    • @badhairdye
      @badhairdye Рік тому

      Of course they did. That's why they weren't deirious with applause. It's not Phantom of the Opera. It was a powerfully emotional wallop. As a mode of witness: in classical performances, typically -- I say typically -- the audience waits for a sign from the conductor that the piece is over and the emotional bond between him and the orchestra can be broken. He will often simply lowers his hands or put the baton at his side, or nod his head. Then the audience may break loose. Mahler asked for silence of five minutes after the first movement of the Resurrection Symphony. Afte the first act of Parsifal, there is typically no applause at all.

  • @alessandrolombardi5339
    @alessandrolombardi5339 4 роки тому +3

    he had an incredible memory

  • @pietrogulyaev
    @pietrogulyaev 3 роки тому +2

    dude thank god for this evil grampa looking genius of a conductor

  • @TheGranGuardian
    @TheGranGuardian 5 років тому +1

    Si. gracias por compartir

    • @TheGranGuardian
      @TheGranGuardian 5 років тому

      Mahler me eriza los pelos

    • @TheGranGuardian
      @TheGranGuardian 5 років тому

      +Gabriel García Es el Poder de la Música

    • @TheGranGuardian
      @TheGranGuardian 5 років тому

      +Gabriel García mi Euterpe nunca te has alejado, has alumbrado mi camino.

  • @yaelpalombo4093
    @yaelpalombo4093 4 місяці тому

    ♥️😍😍😍

  • @JohnWilmot1179
    @JohnWilmot1179 7 років тому +3

    Stupendo

  • @nojin57
    @nojin57 6 років тому +3

    Claudio Abbado의 생생한 지휘모습을 볼 수 없음이 너무 안타깝다. 고인의 평안한 안식을 기원한다.

  • @docbailey3265
    @docbailey3265 4 роки тому +2

    This is way way way more interesting than the Debussy and Faure versions, except for the Sicilliene which is pretty perfect.

  • @virtualpilgrim8645
    @virtualpilgrim8645 3 роки тому +1

    Claudio Abbado died after this at the age of 80

  • @muslit
    @muslit 5 років тому +9

    Bernard Herrmann must have been aware of this work. I'm thinking of 'Vertigo'.

    • @andreapandypetrapan
      @andreapandypetrapan Рік тому +1

      Bang on the money. BH was a keen student, and unashamed borrower.

  • @sumperk_is_best
    @sumperk_is_best Рік тому

    Schonberg is name of city in Czech republic

  • @faustinebm5431
    @faustinebm5431 3 роки тому +1

    30:24 english horn solo 7 avant chiffre 59

  • @giorgiomacchioni7822
    @giorgiomacchioni7822 7 років тому +3

    "La purezza del sentimento nasce dall'oscurità dell'impulso erotico" Vito Mancuso.

  • @Altonahh10
    @Altonahh10 4 роки тому +5

    I only wish Schönberg had done the opera instead of Debussy whose version always makes me fall asleep after 15 minutes ;-)

    • @edwardtodd9734
      @edwardtodd9734 2 роки тому +1

      Once I didn't fall asleep, them I realised that on the previous occasions when I did, I hadn't missed anything

    • @nicholasmorgan8881
      @nicholasmorgan8881 2 роки тому

      Have grown to appreciate the Schoenberg... in many performances it can sound very muddy, but not in this video - fabulous. But I do LOVE the Debussy... always makes me cry...

  • @SeanPi314
    @SeanPi314 4 роки тому +6

    The crux of the whole piece is 32:56

  • @PentameronSV
    @PentameronSV 6 років тому +5

    Music starts at 0:31

  • @retf054ewte3
    @retf054ewte3 2 роки тому +2

    conducting Schonberg from memory is not everybody's job.

  • @OdinWormcake
    @OdinWormcake 7 років тому +13

    Glitch at 22:54

    • @bryangl1
      @bryangl1 5 років тому

      @OdinWormcake. Poor editing.

  • @nicolasbruant1312
    @nicolasbruant1312 2 роки тому

    22,55mn ?

  • @juanadrianarquinegogomez3610

    13:18 this makes my life easier

  • @yusukeundisolde
    @yusukeundisolde 2 роки тому

    恵まれた環境だな。

  • @TheMightyFork_
    @TheMightyFork_ 7 років тому +3

    Spa music 🎶

  • @倉科徹-k5m
    @倉科徹-k5m 5 років тому

    アバドがアグレッシブな指揮で若いオーケストラを鼓舞してます。若い奏者の挑戦として燃焼の演奏です。

  • @jazzsmells9341
    @jazzsmells9341 3 роки тому +2

    Diese Musik ist unglaublich einfallsreich und komplex - soetwas zu performen ist bewundernswert

  • @Dieubussy
    @Dieubussy 2 роки тому +1

    Oeuvre somptueuse, magique, débordante de musique mais Schoenberg a dû jeter son porte-plume à l'autre bout de la pièce quand il a su que Debussy était déjà passé par là.

    • @alleespach
      @alleespach Рік тому

      Et puis aussi Jean Sibelius et Gabriel Fauré !

  • @bryangl1
    @bryangl1 5 років тому +5

    First impressions. The music is intriguing rather than captivating. Whilst I sense an underlying structure, the immediate impression is of an episodic nature more like a movie score than a work for concert hall. And while the musical language is more easily approachable than much of the composer's later work it still lacks beauty of tone ─ the different sections of the orchestra don't seem to blend (not due to the players, they are superb, but due somehow to the orchestration). Of course, beauty is in the ear of the beholder! One person's view, but it's interesting to note that the work is far from being a concert repertoire staple.

    • @ameliawright6947
      @ameliawright6947 5 років тому +8

      Keep in mind that this is Schoenberg's fifth piece written and the first for a large orchestra. Its also a tone-poem; its supposed to shift along episodically. Each movement is a scene.

    • @badhairdye
      @badhairdye Рік тому

      Huh? Who are you? Who cares? Beauty of tone? Movie score! Good God! Save us from You Tubbies! Whilst you sense! Whilst you sense! No wonder Wolf ended up in a madhouse -- he was anticipating You Tube and the 21st century. And so you measure the worth of a piece of music by how much of a 'staple' it is. Aren't you original and thought-provoking. You must be very glad you're you. Well, ignorance proliferates while knowledge watches and worries.

  • @nathanhol42001
    @nathanhol42001 5 років тому

    FOUR harps?!

  • @albertoaguiardacruz7047
    @albertoaguiardacruz7047 3 роки тому

    PELLÉAS ET MELISANDE DE DEBUSSY, NÃO É UMA ÓPERA NO SENTIDO VERDADEIRO, É UMA DETURPAÇÃO DE ÓPERA QUE DEBUSSY INFELIZMENTE CRIOU. SUA MELODIA É POBRE, SUA HARMONIA NÃO TEM GENUÍNO NEXO. BASTA LER A BIOGRAFIA DE DEBUSSY, ONDE NOS INFORMAMOS QUE ÊLE FOI REPROVADO EM HARMONIA NO CONSERVATÓRIO DE PARIS. É PRECISO DIZER MAIS?

  • @stevehinnenkamp5625
    @stevehinnenkamp5625 7 років тому +1

    Gee., more interested in the beautiful horn player in an early shot, than the dreary music which follows.

    • @Zyborggian
      @Zyborggian 6 років тому +1

      Steve Hinnenkamp gaaaaaaaay :P

    • @Zyborggian
      @Zyborggian 6 років тому +2

      Steve Hinnenkamp I find both equally interesting tho hehe

  • @christianalejo7655
    @christianalejo7655 5 років тому

    I don't think there was a single person of color in that room. Good music though.

    • @nathanhol42001
      @nathanhol42001 5 років тому +7

      I don’t think there are very many people of color in Vienna

    • @christianalejo7655
      @christianalejo7655 5 років тому

      Nathan Hollis True 😅

    • @robinblankenship9234
      @robinblankenship9234 4 роки тому +7

      Christian Alejo The only real people who are not "of color" are albinos. There are multitudes of events online at which "white" people are not seen. What is your point? If people "of color" were interested, they could take up the music of Western Civilization and, I'm sure, excel at it. It DOES happen, btw. Awadagin Pratt, of Ghanian ancestry and definitely a man "of color" happens to be one of the best classical pianists alive. Beethoven had a "swarthy" look and has been speculated as perhaps having some African ancestry. If skin color is so important to you, you are not very much into the music.

    • @leocadieux6781
      @leocadieux6781 3 роки тому

      Let’s boycott classical music then 🙄

    • @dergeradeweg1413
      @dergeradeweg1413 3 роки тому

      Shut up

  • @jeannotdenimes158
    @jeannotdenimes158 3 роки тому +2

    Oh nice, Tristan und Isol... oh wait

  • @jeannotdenimes158
    @jeannotdenimes158 2 роки тому

    Début 00:32