Roundtable: West Asia And The War Of Narratives |

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 20

  • @JBC100
    @JBC100 4 дні тому +6

    This forum should have included a Isreli person as well...That Arab guy was given free ride...

  • @samuelross9884
    @samuelross9884 4 дні тому +1

    The term “West Bank” is a modern designation that lacks historical precedent or validity. This region is historically known as Judea, a name deeply rooted in Jewish history and heritage. The name “West Bank” was coined by Jordan following its armed and hostile invasion of the area in 1948 until the end of its occupation in 1967. However, this land has been intrinsically linked to the Jewish people for millennia.
    Judea is the land from which the Jews (i.e. Judeans) originate, a region where the Judean mountains form the backbone of the landscape. It is the territory historically allotted to the Tribe of Judah, one of the twelve tribes of Israel. The Judeans, or Jews, have lived in this area for many centuries, establishing a rich historical legacy. The cultural significance of Judea to the Jewish people cannot be overstated, making the term “West Bank” a misnomer that overlooks the profound connection between the land and its ancient inhabitants.

    • @Knowmore55555
      @Knowmore55555 3 дні тому

      The modern days Jews are not original Jews, they are from Europe. That’s why dna test is not allowed in Israel. The Palestinians has the genes of Jews , just converted to Islam

  • @samuelross9884
    @samuelross9884 4 дні тому +2

    It's completely dishonest to consider only 2% of history.
    Frustrated by confusing & contradictory information, I researched the history of the land we call Israel and Palestine today. Who lived on it first?
    Israelites lived in this land 1,658 years before the ancestors of Palestinians. Palestinian ancestral land is the Arabian Peninsula. ‘Palestinian’ is a modern word from the 20th century.
    "Syria Palaestina” was the name given by the Romans to Judea after the Bar Kochba revolt, although the name's origins go back even further, being based on the term 'Philistine', the name for a land that at the time belonged to a people who were no longer extant, not as a people nor a political entity
    Only the Canaanites and Philistine predate the Israelites. The descendants of Canaanites and Philistine is complex and not entirely resolved
    The Israelites arrived C1300 BCE and established the Israelite Kingdoms of Israel and Judah. The Kingdom of Israel fell to the Assyrians in 722 BC, while the Kingdom of Judah was conquered by the Babylonians in 586 BCE.
    Next the land changed hands many times, until Arab Muslims conquered it in 638 CE and established an Islamic Caliphate. The Arab population, increasingly identifying as Palestinian particularly in the 20th century, has been a significant part of the social and cultural fabric of the area, especially during the periods of Islamic rule and the Ottoman Empire.
    A timeline:
    Canaanite Period (c. 3000 - 1200 BCE): The earliest known inhabitants were Canaanites, a Semitic-speaking people.
    Philistine Period (c. 1175 - 604 BCE): Philistines settled along the coastal areas, mostly in the Gaza Strip.
    Israelite Kingdoms (c. 1020 - 586 BCE): The Israelites, also a Semitic-speaking people, established the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah.
    Assyrian and Babylonian Periods (722 - 539 BCE): Assyrians and Babylonians conquered the region.
    Persian Period (539 - 332 BCE): Persia conquered the Babylonian empire, including this area. The Persians later reinstated Israel as a country.
    Hellenistic Period (332 - 167 BCE): Conquest by Alexander the Great, followed by the Ptolemaic and Seleucid rules.
    Hasmonean Kingdom (167 - 37 BCE): Jewish rule restored after the Maccabean Revolt against the Seleucids.
    Roman Period (63 BCE - 324 CE): The area became a part of the Roman Empire, with Israel remaining a kingdom within that empire, with Rome appointing the king, until AD 44.
    Bar Kochba Period (132 CE - 136 CE): Simon bar Kochba let a Jewish revolt and for a short time revived Jewish sovereignty over land, until it was brutally crushed by the Roman Emperor Hadrian, who renamed Judea as Syria Palaestina to remove any trace of Jewish connection to the land.
    Byzantine Period (324 - 638 CE): Christian rule under the Byzantine Empire.
    Islamic Caliphate Era (638 CE - 1099 CE): Arab Muslims conquered Jerusalem in 638 CE, introducing Arab rule and Islamic culture to the region. Arabic gradually replaced Aramaic and Greek as the dominant language.
    Crusader Period (1099 - 1187 CE): European Christians captured Jerusalem and established the Kingdom of Jerusalem.
    Ayyubid and Mamluk Periods (1187 - 1516 CE): Saladin, a Kurdish Muslim leader, defeated the Crusaders. The Mamluks, who were of various ethnicities including Turkic and Circassian, succeeded the Ayyubids.
    Ottoman Period (1516 - 1917 CE): The Ottoman Turks controlled the region, and the Arab populace lived under Ottoman rule.
    British Mandate (1917 - 1948 CE): British control after World War I. Increased Jewish immigration leads to tensions between Jews and Arabs.
    State of Israel (1948 - Present): Established in 1948, leading to ongoing conflicts with Arab Palestinians.
    The ‘West Bank' is in fact ancient Judea, the land of the Jews. The 'Philistines' lived along the southwest coastline, nowhere near the Judean hills.
    But with all this, there has never been a Palestinian state.

    • @Knowmore55555
      @Knowmore55555 3 дні тому

      The modern day Jews are not the real Jews, they are from Europe. that’s why dna testing is not allowed in Israel. In fact Palestinians have the Jewish genes, many Jews converted to Islam.

    • @CaptainArdalas
      @CaptainArdalas 3 дні тому

      totally agree these muslims always play victims

  • @mdavidasingh
    @mdavidasingh 2 дні тому

    The forum would have been more balanced if it included an Israeli representative. BTW one of the members' views is skewed and factually incorrect.

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    Particle displacement

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    In india butter fly uses as bond.

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    Ours is oval table not round.

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    Hum deresrt ism nahi chahte hain

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    Its not like military social 😮
    Oum praja patayenamah

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 День тому

    History vs science via earth.
    Its not to me earth is going to venus or sun.