Solar has improved in her musical thingy now she restrains her voice a bit more and now is better than wheein in terms of technique, they've always been kind of the same ranking, wheein never had a better technique. Wheein is more head voice focused and solar is more chest voice focused but now solar has improved
Actually most parts are unnessessary in dance moonbyul and wheein have very similar skillset and so do hwasa and solar. Stage presence is fire for each of them and for vocals wheein and solar are practically same level
I kinda wished you didn't do the visual ranking part :( Since you rated them equally at the end, it means it possible and you just chose to include it :(
I'd put wheein first in vocals, everyone knows she has the best technique, her belts might be not as powerful as solar's but she easily belts high notes, not including other aspects of singing like riffs, low singing, whistle notes etc agree about her stage presence tho, she gets lost a lil bit compared to other members but like.. she is a beast of stage presence actually and other members being higher just shows how superior is mamamoo's stage presence
I think the only category I agree with is the rap. Dance too now that I think it. Hwasa and Moonbyul have top stage presence for sure. Vocals (keep in mind I also love them all equally) Solar, Byuli, Wheein, Hwasa. MoonByul is BY FAR the most underrated singer in Mamamoo. Check out some of her solo songs. There's a cover she recently did that displays a range in her voice RBW can't appreciate enough. Like HOLY MOLY. I was taken aback for sure. I just wish I could remember the name of that song. 😅
This is honestly pretty accurate IMO (except the visual part, why add that? 🥲) I feel like if Moonbyul received proper vocal training as the rest of the group like she was supposed to, she would be higher on the ranking. Nevertheless, she's an amazing vocalist 💗
Moonbyul did received proper vocal training tho ? She attended sm academy before and she was a main vocalist there (she got a lot of bad comments while she's there)
she actually gonna be a vocalist too in group, but when she realize the group didnt had any rapper, i forgot she decide to become a rapper or the comapany ask her to be a rapper, but yeah she became a rapper after that, and fun fact if im not wrong the one who teach moonbyul how to rap is solar
Even if solar is my biais I think hasard is n1 in visual, solar is second or 3rd moonbyul is really beautiful her style make her unique and does not fit any runs, also wheehin is really charming and beautiful, think she is more shy in term of styling, well this is if I have to rank But for a moo I would say they are all n1 Almost forget, for dance just go see all weehin dance video, I was amazed when I first discover her
Dance: 1. Wheein 2. Solar 3. Moonbyul 4. Hwasa Moonbyul is stiff af and dances small. She’s not bad by any means, but I never got why people think she’s the best
True, she just gets shadowed by the agency. She trained a lot to be a vocalist and dancer, just because she raps it doesn't mean she isn't good at singing Plus, she's giving amazing vocals proofs in second world which rbw never let her do, so I agree w you :)
@@flomary2085 being good and being THE best is a whole other dimension. Vocally she doesn’t hold a candle to the other vocalist in Mamamoo, still she is super good compared to other idols. The level in Mamamoo is just really high. As a dancer I think she lacks versatility. She is good with the tomboyish dance but looks kind of ackward with other dance styles. Still she has better technique than solar and hwasa. Wheein is the best dancer tho, just like most professional dancers say about Mamamoo. I’m not saying Moon is in any way not talented. She is mar talented (-> best rapper, best lyricist, best visuals (my opinion), really good stage presence, second best dancer, good vocalist).
@@pollop2311 I agree with you, I just think she's much more versatile than what we see (sorry for any error english is not my first language c":) and that her solo performances are very versatile in dance and vocals, she just doesn't do all genre because she isn't comfortable in them, I think her performances when she's not with mamamoo show much more. It's enough looking at her solos and stuff. I just think she's pretty underrated and that she can do much more than what we usually see in shows, and that in single performances she can express it more
Solar best Vocalist in Mamamoo especially after the Mata Hari. Wheein using to many head voice, falsetto to much for her Solo album. I prefer Hwasa's Voice and Technic compare to Wheeinie but Hwasa is mezzosopran so many people still think Wheeinie is better
@@mooblink4ever899 Yeah, Solar has the best technique now🧐. It's sad some people can't see that Solar is so much improved and Wheein is regressed badly.😔😔
I would disagree with the visual and dance. Based on their solo dance pieces, Wheein has the best technique. Best technical dancer and her expressions are great. Her movements are clean and precise. Hwasa has excellent technique, facial expression, and presence. I would go Wheein, Hwasa, Solar, Moonbyul. For visuals, they're all gorgeous in a variety of looks. Ranking visuals is too subjective. You know what they say. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
I don't understand ranking stage presence, they all have energy, aura, emotions, and I don't see any difference between members in that category. Like, I would rank them all on number 1. I know it's your opinion, but I just don't understand that.
![[KPOP IN SCHOOL/PUBLIC] KISS OF LIFE (키스오브라이프) - Igloo | STELLARIS Dance Cover](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/otFjs7_afwM/mqdefault.jpg)
Have a nice day~
(please check the description)
Solar has the most powerful voice, wheein has the best technique
Wheein's technique regressed and Solar's improved. Solar is now better than her technique wise.
and hwasa has unique voice, never get tired listening to her.
@@pennymikk literally absolutely yes
@@pennymikk It’s the truth… wheein has regressed badly she’s only a little better than hwasa
Solar has improved in her musical thingy now she restrains her voice a bit more and now is better than wheein in terms of technique, they've always been kind of the same ranking, wheein never had a better technique. Wheein is more head voice focused and solar is more chest voice focused but now solar has improved
Solar got good at rapping by always singing Byulie's lines lmao
Solar actually taught our Byul how to rap 🤭
i agree completely except for the visual part
Wheein ❤❤
I also think that Solar has improve so much (thanks to Mata Hari)that deserves the recognition of main vocalist
When you see WheeIn in 4th place for stage presence but you know she already that good… Mamamoo is a full package group! STAN QUEEN
Visual part is unnecessary they all are pretty but for me hwasa is most pretty in mamamoo
Actually most parts are unnessessary in dance moonbyul and wheein have very similar skillset and so do hwasa and solar. Stage presence is fire for each of them and for vocals wheein and solar are practically same level
Exactly for me Hwasa is so gorgeous
Me too think hwasa most pretty because she different
@@libijones its her charisma for me 😔👌
@@quuenbanaana8425 no... Technically Solar is better than Wheein. Wheein badly regressed.
actually mamamoo mebers all good at everything
How can you put them in visual rank like this? All their songs and yet you learned nothing from it THEY ARE ALL VISUALS
Yes, wheeiniee is all around
I really like how you coordinated the rankings with the song!
(Also for visual, I think it's according to kbs so it seems accurate)
Moon Byul is the prettiest and coolest member of MAMAMOOMoon
1.Moon Byul.
2.Wheein.
3.Solar.
4.Hwasa.
All r amezing vocalist and verstile artist
I honestly believe they are equals in all aspects. They are all, all rounders and showcase different styles and skills within each category.
Beautiful ❤️
vocal
1. wheein
2. solar
3. hwasa
4. moonbyul
dance
1. wheein
2. moonbyul
3. solar
4. hwasa
rap
1. moonbyul
2. hwasa
3. wheein
4. solar
stage presence
1. hwasa
2. solar
3. wheein
4. moonbyul
visual (kbs)
1. solar
2. wheein
3. moonbyul
4. hwasa
popularity (most biased)
1. moonbyul
2. hwasa
3. solar
4. wheein
What? 😐💀 It's clear that the most popular one is Hwasa.
@@mooblink4ever899 my bad, moonbyul is the most biased among moomoos but hwasa is actually the most known/popular member
Reality: Mamamoo only have 2 official positions (Leader & main rapper). 😂
별언니 너무 예뻐❤😍❤🥰
I kinda wished you didn't do the visual ranking part :(
Since you rated them equally at the end, it means it possible and you just chose to include it :(
I'd put wheein first in vocals, everyone knows she has the best technique, her belts might be not as powerful as solar's but she easily belts high notes, not including other aspects of singing like riffs, low singing, whistle notes etc
agree about her stage presence tho, she gets lost a lil bit compared to other members but like.. she is a beast of stage presence actually and other members being higher just shows how superior is mamamoo's stage presence
I think the only category I agree with is the rap. Dance too now that I think it. Hwasa and Moonbyul have top stage presence for sure. Vocals (keep in mind I also love them all equally) Solar, Byuli, Wheein, Hwasa. MoonByul is BY FAR the most underrated singer in Mamamoo. Check out some of her solo songs. There's a cover she recently did that displays a range in her voice RBW can't appreciate enough. Like HOLY MOLY. I was taken aback for sure. I just wish I could remember the name of that song. 😅
VISUAL MOONBYUL!??? I THINK YES
Hwasa is the best dancer
My opinion.
Vocals:
Wheein
Solar
Hwasa
Moonstar
Dance:
Moonstar
Hwasa
Wheein
Solar
Rap
Moonstar
Hwasa
Solar/wheein
Stage presence:
Hwasa
Solar
Moonstar
Wheein
This is honestly pretty accurate IMO (except the visual part, why add that? 🥲)
I feel like if Moonbyul received proper vocal training as the rest of the group like she was supposed to, she would be higher on the ranking. Nevertheless, she's an amazing vocalist 💗
Isn’t moonbyul a trained vocalist? Like she trained FOR YEARS…. Or am I confused?
yeah Moonbyul has the best voice to me after Wheein 😭😭
Moonbyul did received proper vocal training tho ? She attended sm academy before and she was a main vocalist there (she got a lot of bad comments while she's there)
she actually gonna be a vocalist too in group, but when she realize the group didnt had any rapper, i forgot she decide to become a rapper or the comapany ask her to be a rapper, but yeah she became a rapper after that, and fun fact if im not wrong the one who teach moonbyul how to rap is solar
She is an insane vocalist. She was in singing competitions. Watch it
Don't judge
Visual part was kind of really unnecessary I feel like they all should be number ones in their own ways but I get you have your own opinion
Wheein is actually a better singer at least technique wise than Solar but other than that this is pretty accurate
You stuck in the past. Wheein regressed. Solar now is much better technically.
Even if solar is my biais I think hasard is n1 in visual, solar is second or 3rd moonbyul is really beautiful her style make her unique and does not fit any runs, also wheehin is really charming and beautiful, think she is more shy in term of styling, well this is if I have to rank
But for a moo I would say they are all n1
Almost forget, for dance just go see all weehin dance video, I was amazed when I first discover her
Mc Duk & Mc Dak be like 👁️👄👁️
my favorite voice is Hwasa, the best voice is Wheein, the powerful voice is Solar
Dance: 1. Wheein 2. Solar 3. Moonbyul 4. Hwasa
Moonbyul is stiff af and dances small. She’s not bad by any means, but I never got why people think she’s the best
OT4 IN ALL CATEGORIES. NO COMPETITION IN ALL MMM MEMBERS
monbyul is the best dancer and vocalist
??
No she isn't
True, she just gets shadowed by the agency. She trained a lot to be a vocalist and dancer, just because she raps it doesn't mean she isn't good at singing
Plus, she's giving amazing vocals proofs in second world which rbw never let her do, so I agree w you :)
@@flomary2085 being good and being THE best is a whole other dimension.
Vocally she doesn’t hold a candle to the other vocalist in Mamamoo, still she is super good compared to other idols. The level in Mamamoo is just really high.
As a dancer I think she lacks versatility. She is good with the tomboyish dance but looks kind of ackward with other dance styles. Still she has better technique than solar and hwasa. Wheein is the best dancer tho, just like most professional dancers say about Mamamoo.
I’m not saying Moon is in any way not talented. She is mar talented (-> best rapper, best lyricist, best visuals (my opinion), really good stage presence, second best dancer, good vocalist).
@@pollop2311 I agree with you, I just think she's much more versatile than what we see (sorry for any error english is not my first language c":) and that her solo performances are very versatile in dance and vocals, she just doesn't do all genre because she isn't comfortable in them, I think her performances when she's not with mamamoo show much more. It's enough looking at her solos and stuff. I just think she's pretty underrated and that she can do much more than what we usually see in shows, and that in single performances she can express it more
You forgot:
"Gayest: mamamoo"
(Don't take it too seriously)
My op...
Voice
Wheein/Solar/Hwasa/Moonbyul
Dance
Wheein/Hwasa/Moonbyul/Solar
Stage Prescence
Hwasa/Wheein/Solar/Moonbyul
Beauty
Hwasa/Moonbyul/Wheein/Solar
I agree with this list
I think the page has korean standard Hahahaha
Gayest: 1. Moonbyul 2. Wheein 3. Solar 4. Hwasa
👌👌😂
you are just have derty mind bruh stop talking nonesense😒
Oye en dance va primero moonbyul no
don't rank them okay ?
they can be the lowest ranked in their group, but i think they are better than most
I thought it was solar visual!!!
VISUAL SOLAR AND HWASA
Solar best Vocalist in Mamamoo especially after the Mata Hari. Wheein using to many head voice, falsetto to much for her Solo album. I prefer Hwasa's Voice and Technic compare to Wheeinie but Hwasa is mezzosopran so many people still think Wheeinie is better
Wheein has a better technique
It's ur opinion anyway
Stop spreading wrong information. Wheein regressed badly.
@@mooblink4ever899 Yeah, Solar has the best technique now🧐. It's sad some people can't see that Solar is so much improved and Wheein is regressed badly.😔😔
Moonbyul on Tcchandler??????? No SOLAR AND HWASA FOR VISUAL
No hwasa dance is the best tho
I would disagree with the visual and dance. Based on their solo dance pieces, Wheein has the best technique. Best technical dancer and her expressions are great. Her movements are clean and precise. Hwasa has excellent technique, facial expression, and presence. I would go Wheein, Hwasa, Solar, Moonbyul.
For visuals, they're all gorgeous in a variety of looks. Ranking visuals is too subjective. You know what they say. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
I don't understand ranking stage presence, they all have energy, aura, emotions, and I don't see any difference between members in that category. Like, I would rank them all on number 1. I know it's your opinion, but I just don't understand that.
Gurl no 👎