I remember when this happened and being absolutely appalled. There's a factor of 7.5 between 80m and 600m. The entire crew was full of shit and lying. We should have let the Italians handle them.
It is my impression as well. Besides, if trained airmen cannot tell the difference between 80 and 600 metres, they definitely should not be flying. Or be sent to gliding school... maybe they could handle a 80 metres tow... :)
These clowns were 100% goofing off and recording their "fun". I guarantee that they saw the gondola and dared each other to fly below it. How infuriating that they suffered no consequences for taking so many lives AND denying and culpability.
@@mr.snippy exactly this. And that was why they burned the tapes because they could fully redact anything visual and claim military intelligence, so the excuse of their smiling faces being why they destroyed evidence is B.S. ....they would however have a harder time explaining away editing the audio, and I fully believe that the audio would have them bragging they can fly under the line. (And I have the s on tapes intentionally because they probably have past footage of them or others doing that same thing more than once)
I was stationed at Aviano in the US Air Force when this all went down. I was horrified, and incredulous those men got off so light. Not only did they get away with killing people, but they deliberately destroyed pertinent evidence! Those images I saw of smashed bodies laying in the snow. The Italian people had every right to be angry.
@@Cykotyk not dying on any hill. But they didn’t murder those people. Murder is a deliberate act with intent to kill. They caused their deaths. That’s manslaughter.
@@GenXfrom75 That's negligent homicide, not manslaughter. Manslaughter would mean they did not mean to fly that low, but they did mean to fly that low, and the negligence led them to murder 20 people.
I'm a pilot myself and have seen very detailed breakdowns of the disaster. The fact is, this crew was very well known for hotdogging and they took an LAS mission to mean "fly as low as you like and pretend you're in a Top Gun movie." Even the act of *taping* themselves should have got them court-martialed. Burning the tape afterward would have been taken in near any court as "consciousness of guilt" and absolutely as obstruction of justice and destroying evidence. It didn't take very much time at all for the crew to put two and two together while airborne and realize they'd hit a cable - and exactly what that meant. By the time they landed, they already had all their false alibis prepared and their stories straight. And the US military *always* covers for its own. Because of UA-cam limitations the OP couldn't show most of the photos taken of the destroyed gondola, but I've seen the real pictures the Italians took. The snow was covered in blood and body parts. The impact force was estimated to be 250+gs - far more than any human body can remain intact through. And those pictures were published throughout the Italian media. I would have been baying for their blood too, if it was my relative that got killed like that.
Quite so - and the American military and diplomatic departments have plenty of form for this behaviour. Plenty. The Americans think they can act with impunity anywhere in the world they choose and by and large that is exactly what they do. Is it any wonder half the planet detests the US...
Blaming the altimeter is BS. Any pilot can tell the difference between 260 and 2000 feet and certainly their airspeed indicator was working. They were hotdogging and should have been prosecuted as such.
@coconutsmarties ah, someone who is less smart than their handle. They could see the mountain but couldn't see the cables for the cable cars. Many pilots over the years have come cropper because they never saw the wires across a gap. One glider pilot I knew was hospitalised by a single cable he never saw as the poles holding it up were covered by trees.
As an American and a veteran, I am ashamed that more was not done to make amends to the families of the victims and that the two men were acquitted. They should have paid for their negligence. This disaster should never have happened. RIP all of you poor souls. 💔
It was Newt Gingrich and his Republican House that voted against it just because Bill Clinton wanted it. The GOP has always been the party of deliberate cruelty.
NO WONDER THE ITALIANS ( and other Europians call us " THE UGLY AMERICANS!!!) If that was an Italian plane, flying over the rockies, and hit a gondola cable , killing 20 Americans while HOT DOGGING!!, BET THE CREW WOULD STILL BE IN PRISON!!! ( RULES FOR THEE BUT NOT FOR ME!!! typical!!!)
"I burned the tape because people would get mad at me." *literally just was part of causing an accident that killed 20 people* I hate to break it to you dude, but people will be mad at you no matter what because of what you did
"I don't want people to think I committed the crime I accidentally committed on purpose" does not equal "I didn't want people mad at me" pretty clear he understood people were going to mad at him. he didn't want to spit on the corpses of the victims he just killed by having a tape of him smiling and enjoying the view immediately before the accident. considering the media's love affair with tabloid reporting, it's not an unfounded fear. Besides, he probably didn't need to even burn the tape. If he cried to his superiors in the military, they probably would have covered it up. It's not like the crash was his fault - he was just the navigator, after all, and that's shown by the fact that he escaped receiving a prison sentence. Also, just so you both understand, you *do* know that a navigator of the plane isn't the one who is flying the plane, right? If the two fratboy flightboy military cowboy jackasses wanted to fuck around, horse about, and fly their plane lower than they are supposed to, you do understand that the navigator really can't do much other than say mean words to them, right? He's not even in the same room, really - they communicate via intercom. It amazes me that people can pay half attention to a ten minute video on a topic and pretend like they're experts on the topic
@@lillyclarity9699 While it isn't normally the navigator actually flying the plane, he can do so, since he is in a front seat, with flight controls at his disposal. IOW, he is one of the two cowboy fratboy flyboys.
I remember watching the "Seconds from Disaster" epidode about thus tragedy where they interviewed obe or two of the pilots. He had no remorse at all and in fact was still mad that they got court marshalled. That interview convinced me 100% the crew is guilty as sin and were flying low on purpose and videotaping it to feed their egos.
I must've missed that episode of "SFD." I loved that show, it reminds me a lot of this channel. Still, I don't think I would try to find that one and watch it. Hearing one or more of the pilots try to defend themselves would make my blood boil. Some people wrap themselves in their own lies like a comfort blanket. Eventually they start to believe it wholeheartedly; it's a defense mechanism. Or they're just a sociopath and utterly lack compassion.
@@Unownshipper it's season 4 episode 8 I'm pretty sure. If you look up "seconds from disaster cable car collision" you'll find a few reuploads. I really like the show as well.
El toro poopoo. 'We didn't know we were so low.' (basically 1,700 ft. below legal flight limits). That would be like saying, "I looked out the window of a glass elevator and I didn't know if I was on the 4th or 40th floor because the indicator light didn't work.'
I used to know one of the young Belgian who died in that accident. She was 23 and just finished her law studies. I can not describe how devastated her parents were during years after that. The trial was a real violence for this family, the never really recovered. 😢
My dad who is in the Italian airforce told me about this and I was so angry. He told me that allegedly pilots tend to fly that low and that fast for fun, as sort of a thrill. I really hate how the people responsible didn't get punished in a meaningful way. But hey, its not surprising, given the countries involved.
During the 80s I was learning to ski at Occlini pass, in south Tyrol. Multiple times I saw Italian and American planes flying past at no more than 40m above parked cars and restaurants.
I'm Italian and I was 6 when this disaster occurred. I still remember the newspapers, the outrage, the television news, and the anger and disappointment after they all got to walk free in the end. I don't think I've ever met an Italian (of about my age or older) that _didn't_ believe it all happened due to a deliberate choice in unprofessional conduct
As an American who's learning about this event for the first time, I'm appalled. There aren't adequate words. The loss of innocent lives is horrifying, the blatant misconduct of the crew both during the event and afterwards is sickening, and the reluctance of our government to provide compensation is shameful. They were clearly hotdogging, and when they got caught, they lied and destroyed evidence of their crime. It's unfathomable they weren't suitably punished.
Destroying anything that could be considered evidence is a crime in itself. They should have been arrested just for that alone. But ofcourse the US military gets away with everything. Laos, Afghanistan, Korea, Vietnam, iraq, iran… they all remember
given that the cable car was operating for several decades (even before the 1976 disaster) how 'outdated' were those maps ? were they drawn from reconnaissance photos of WW 2 ?
I find it incredibly hard to believe that tape was burned because a smiling face on camera might have become bad optics in the media. I think it more likely held evidence of just how reckless they were actually being.
It pissed a lot of us off here in America as well. IIRC, the story was that it was a rite of passage for pilots from that base to fly under the cables.
@@delorbb2298 I am willing to bet money that they would do that...which is why the tape was burned....because anything visual could be redacted for "security reasons", I am willing to be it was the audio of that recording they feared.
@@SoManyRandomRamblings After it happened, the people who lived there said pilots did this all the time. That they knew the cables were there and were actively trying to buzz through it.
The pilot should be held responsible for. He ultimately made the decisions to operate that craft. We all know that tape had all the details we needed to show negligence.
Two "experienced" pilots, flying a plane, couldn't tell the difference between 80 meters and 610 meters. They had been reprimanded for flying too low and fast before this disaster. So why were they allowed to keep flying? The captain's sentence for the death of 20 people was ridiculous, and the navigator should have been jailed for destruction of evidence. And even though compensation was promised by the US, it had to be enforced and paid through treaty laws. Utterly shocking and shameful. RIP to the 20 victims
As an American I'm so sorry to the families of the victims, I 100% believe they were acting carelessly and our disgusting response as a country to not help those effected or hold these men accountable
I call BS all day on the sticking gauge. I was an Aviation Electricians Mate in the Navy. I worked on the altitude systems. The age of the aircraft wouldn't have anything to do with the altimeter sticking. That isn't something that would be a fixed piece of equipment. Gauges get swapped out as needed. Then they are put through a complete altitude simulation. I hated that test set. That also wouldn't be the only altitude reference they would have to go by. That was complete deflection trying to blame the maintainers.
You covered this incident in one of your first videos. UA-cam age restricted the video making it harder to find. I'm glad you redid this. The American government acted so horribly in this case. Truly an injustice to the victims and families involved.
The US government always gets their military off with no consequences. Real "fuck the foreigners" vibes. The US military personnel from Abu Ghraib are out and about, living happy lives, with no consequences for what they did and that wasn't just negligence and reckless endangerment of others. It was actual torture and murder. Photographs smiling with decaying corpses. Disgusting organisation.
The EA-6B was a heavily modified version of the A-6 Intruder attack jet. It carried a very extensive EW radar detection and jamming system, a very precise navigation system, superb low level flight characteristics, and with a crew of 4, a heightened level of situational awareness in the cockpit. Jamming and mapping enemy radar emitters was it's job. That mapping had to be precise, so that the intel could be passed on to the Wild Weasels, who could then destroy the emitters with ARMs or some other appropriate ordnance. What I'm leading up to is that the pilot and crew knew exactly where they were, and the cable as well, but the pilot was hot dogging the plane and misjudged how close he was to the cable. He saw it and intended to cut it close, but ended up hitting it. Pure pilot error and poor judgement. IMHO.
I believe everything you said to be true, up until "He saw it". Cables slung across valleys are nearly invisible. I frequently fly in mountainous terrain. Cables slung across valleys have huge orange balls hung from the middle of them. Without the warning balls the cables are invisible in most conditions. The slightest haze, the sun in your eyes, the cable(s) disappear, and I'm only flying at 80-90 knots. An EA-6B can fly over 550 knots, as it was noted the pilot was flying too fast, there's no way he saw that cable.
From an American, I am appalled at this and have been ever since I stumbled across the story one night in college when I was surfing Wikipedia. Deliberately destroying evidence and misleading investigators after accidentally killing almost 2 dozen people, and they walked away free…we should’ve either thrown them in prison ourselves or let them try to figure out a way to get themselves proven innocent in an Italian court of law (which, spoiler, they probably wouldn’t have done). It’s a travesty, and my heart breaks for the families of those who perished because a couple of U.S Marine pilots decided to be stupid.
US soldiers don't ever face consequences, even when it's entirely intentional and not just gross negligence and a disregard for others. It's disgusting. The monsters behind the torture and murders at Abu Ghraib were out, free of consequences, living their lives, right after what they did. Literal photographic evidence of them smiling and laughing over the decaying corpses of their victims and *nothing* happened. People on the other side of the world two decades on are still struggling with mental health after being subjected to torture. Innocent people, who were children at the time, now unable to move due to the conditions and treatment there permanently destroying their ability to walk. Seeing people they knew murdered, being sexually abused, and so much more - all while these US soldiers are off raising happy little families.
The story of the "faulty altitude dial" doesnt wash. There is a barometric altimeter in front of each of the two pilots, and a third one in between them. And there is a radar altimeter. Are we to believe that all four were faulty AND that all four showed the SAME incorrect altitude? That stretches credibility beyond elastic limit.
Not only that, but that difference between lowest allowed height and their actual height is HUGE, you can't tell me that even IF (and I agree that that's more than unlikely) all altimeters didn't work correctly, they weren't able to tell that they were flying significantly lower. I'd maybe get that with being 50 m too low, but over 500 m??
@@vicvega3614 The two men in the back can't see out the front, have no altimeters, and can't do anything to adjust the altitude of the aircraft in any case. Yet you want to put them in prison for 10 years? Care to explain why?
@@fantabuloussnuffaluffagus if you were in the back seat egging your friend on to drive like a lunatic and he ran over some kids i 100% promise you there would be charges against you.
Also, they had been already reprimanded several times for flying too low in the same area. So, unless that few is veeeery unlucky with the altimeters of their aircraft, they were clearly unrepentant hotdoggers…
Insane. The fact that this crew got away with killing 20 ppl; it is obvious they were well aware of what they were doing. And destroying the evidence?! C’mon. Anyone can see through their bs. This case should be brought forward to the public eye, again, and have some proper justice served this time round.
I hate coverups. They KNEW they were too low. Even if the dial was faulty they knew it and they didn't gain altitude. The military should NOT have aided a coverup. And Italy should not have had to use treaties to ensure compensation was paid out.
It would have been an accident, if they had not lived, worked, and flown there for 2 years. Even without maps, they knew there were skilifts in the area. Most likely looking at the pretty tourist girls skiing on the mountain.
The fact that a country worth literal trillions of dollars.. having to be _forced_ to pay compensation after "accidentally" killing 20 innocent people is utterly abhorrent. USA should be ashamed of itself.... AGAIN.
If the pilot was willing to burn the tape and suffer the consequences, it must've been really bad. I wouldn't be surprised if the officer bet or challenged the pilot to fly under that wire.
Showboating murderers. People like that are still around too - I've seen several air force pilots from Travis flying irresponsibly low over the college campus in my area to show off.
How odd a synchronicity that the part-time cable car operator in the first disaster and the navigator of the flight in the second had the same last name, Schweitzer.
Sometimes I wonder what people like this are doing now. Ashby, for instance. Is he working a regular job? Do his coworkers know he's a killer? Is he using an assumed name?
If he hasn’t changed his name, it’s almost guaranteed that his coworkers know. Someone always googles the new guy’s name, and a juicy bit of gossip like that would make its way around an office at warp speed!
Thank you for covering this. I've been fascinated by this case ever since I was a child and it dominated the news for weeks, because it happened very close. The images of the smashed cable car and blood covered snow are seared into my memory.
He forgot to mention that the first responders to this disaster discovered that all of the victims' faces were contorted in fear and terror. Several of them hugging each other trying to comfort themselves in their last moments. Truly horrifying and heartbreaking 😱
If that's true then they most likely saw the jet flying in their direction. Truly appalling that they had no real consequences for their reckless behavior.
Man. This just keeps getting worse for those marines. Absolute idiots. You can very easily tell the difference between 200 and 2,000 feet. They should be serving life in prison.
That may be a bit too harsh, but should definitely be set to work day and night until they pay off the gondola and abut a billion usd per victim. If they are as clever as they thought they are it would be paid off in no time.
When your last video popped up about the cable car accident, I immediately thought you were going to talk about this incident, I had no idea both happened in the same place. I feel so sorry for all the families.
US soldiers never facing consequences is always so disgusting. They just didn't for a moment stop to consider the danger they were putting others in. They refused to accept any responsibility when they did it. I wouldn't be nearly as mad if they had just said "Yes. This was my fault". But they went out of their way to come u with a story and blame literally anything else they could. This isn't even near the worst the US gets up to overseas without consequences though. Boils my blood every day that people like the monsters behind Abu Ghraib are out, free, without consequences, enjoying life, after torturing, murdering, and sexually abusing tens of thousands of people. We have actual photographs, taken by the US soldiers themselves, in uniform, of them smiling over the decaying corpses of the people they murdered, and they are now free to go about their lives and raise families. Meanwhile the victims, two decades on, continue to live in poverty, struggling with the torture they were subjected to, some who were only children at the time, who are still even now unable to walk or exist as functional people due to the damage they suffered due to treatment or conditions there.
Ashby and Schweitzer should've been forced to help clean up their mess as punishment. This was hugely embarrassing, and I was angry at the hubris these US Airmen had.
Easily the most enraging example, but certainly not the only one, of how US units in Italy treat our country as their playground, certain that they will never be persecuted for it. Disgusting.
@@robertcox1835 Yup, there was a case in the UK last year where the wife of a US serviceman killed a teenager on a moped by driving on the wrong side of the road at speed. They flew her back to America and she has faced no charges and of course the US govt wont extradite her back to the UK, they never do (see also, IRA terrorists and fundraisers}.
@@chaminadecrew79 nice rage bait buddy. I personally know the grandchildren of immigrants from Laos that came to Europe because their whole country was carpetbombed by the US. Laos didnt even partake in the Vietnam war, nor were they harboring Viet Cong. The Viet Cong simply retreated into Laos and the US saw that as a good opportunity to kill 200K civilians. Thats more casualties than the 2 nuclear bombs on japan.
@@clray123 no because there was no investigation into was Covid real. And nobody found themselves innocent. Who found themselves innocent the Chinese take a dump on some other post. 💩
I just love this channel. As soon as I hear those chords, I settle in for a bloody good story. And I love your voice, and accent. Who knew, horror stories could be my happy place...😏👍🏽💯🔥🌹
I can't tell you how many times I'll be in traffic on a bridge (for example), and start hearing his voice: "On the second of July, two thousand and twenty-four, traffic was moving at a slow, but steady eight kilometers (or five miles) per hour on the X Freeway interchange, with drivers unaware of the tragedy about to strike."
Even if their altimeter was faulty, which was clearly a lie, any pilot could tell the difference between the 80 metres they were flying and the minimum permitted 610 metres. They should all be serving life sentences but of course the US military acquitted their own.
@@GenXfrom75 that's the exception rather than the rule. You are either being deliberately obtuse or you are clueless about what your country does.. Either way, putting down that star spangled banner for a bit might help you see more clearly if you want to see the truth that is 🤷
You just wouldn't believe it would you? Two accidents on the same cable car line. They should never have been flying there!! There is plenty of room in other places to fly low.
In 2013 six Russians were killed in a snowmobile crash at Cavalese. They were descending an illuminated piste at night when the driver switched to an unlit black run, lost control and crashed into a ravine. The area is a disaster magnet. Great skiing, though.
@@rachaelcourtnell7275 I think they destroyed the tape cuz the audio would reveal that they intended to fly below the wire, fully knowing how risky it was.
I lived in the Po Valley in the 80's. One afternoon a fighter jet from Aviano flew over my house at an altitude of no more than 300 feet. It was deafening. Most of these pilots were hot-doggers without supervision. The supervisors (or lack of them) needed to be scrutinized too! I'm still mad about this.
I was in the brig at Camp LeJeune when these guys were in there. Needless to say, they were in solitary and no one could look at them when they were being transported around.
Your lost cable car video had me searching up related incidents. The amount of times the government has killed people with low flying planes or plane related incidents like this, and got away with it with little to no repercussion is disgusting...
This event outrages me on so many levels. Such a needless loss of lives. Thank you for sharing it though. Many things can be learnt from it in order to prevent it in the future 👍
As an American, I feel disgusted by this. My sympathies & condolences go out to all of those poor people who were murdered -- Yes, I said that right -- by such irresponsible & reckless marines, as well as to their families & friends for this horrible tragedy. It breaks my heart to know that my countrymen did something like that to 20 innocent civilians & escaped justice for their crimes.
US soldiers never face consequences for their actions. This isn't a one-off. It's so disgusting. They just didn't for a moment stop to consider the danger they were putting others in. They refused to accept any responsibility when they did it. I wouldn't be nearly as mad if they had just said "Yes. This was my fault". But they went out of their way to come up with a story and blame literally anything else they could. This isn't even near the worst the US gets up to overseas without consequences though. Boils my blood every day that people like the monsters behind Abu Ghraib are out, free, without consequences, enjoying life, after torturing, murdering, and sexually abusing tens of thousands of people. We have actual photographs, taken by the US soldiers themselves, in uniform, of them smiling over the decaying corpses of the people they murdered, and they are now free to go about their lives and raise families. Meanwhile the victims, two decades on, continue to live in poverty, struggling with the torture they were subjected to, some who were only children at the time, who are still even now unable to walk or exist as functional people due to the damage they suffered due to treatment or conditions there.
@@SNMG7664 Yes, you are correct about that; & it is appalling. It’s easy to understand why they hate us - Americans - so much for doing such awful things. I just hope they understand that it’s mostly our government & military to blame for it & not its people. I’m just as disgusted & outraged, as most of my fellow American civilians, just as much as you & they are about these despicable actions. Most of us are truly not like that; we’re mostly all good, honest, hardworking people who love our families & just wish to live our lives in peace with others, just like the rest of you.
This was not the first time a Marine EA6B squadron’s negligence and recklessness has caused death and destruction of innocent lives. In 1981 a Marine EA6B crashed on board the USS Nimitz due to overindulging in cold medicine. 14 were killed and 45 seriously wounded.
As PIC, you are responsible for the operation of the craft. Low-level flight? Eyes better be OUTSIDE the cockpit. 300+ knots at 200 ft? Eyes are definitely outside.
It’s 5am here in America. I’ve tossed and turned all night, opening UA-cam to try and get some relief, and I’m reminded how nice it is to follow content-makers in the UK - 6 hours ahead.
There is no possible way a trained pilot could not visually tell the difference between 260ft and 2000+ ft without having to rely on instruments. These men are lying
Hello! It would be great if you made a video about the Torre del Bierzo accident, one of the worst railway disasters in history. I love your content, greetings from Spain!
Not sure which is scarier, negligence from the company running the cable car, or negligence from an air crew that you got no clue was even in the area EDIT: THe negligence part was in reference to the first disaster in 1976, to clear that up
They were definitely showing off.. I'm not a pilot but I love roller-coasters. 200ft is quite different than 2,000ft by eye sight!! This was human error and highly infuriating. Thanks again FH, you did a great job breaking this one down.
I'm a pilot. I love our Naval aviators and did everything I could to see this incident impartially as it was unfolding in front of the world at that time. These guys screwed the pooch and got off easy. But for the grace God, there go I. Tragic, horrific, embarrassing, and sad.
Wow! What a story! You never fail to make me thankful for finding your content and learning of new things. It makes my walk through life more circumspect. Thank you for your work, Sir!
The suggestion they tried to fly under the wire is a compelling one. It’s a shame they couldn’t or were prevented from concluding that. Brilliant video packed with detail. Thanks.
Those pilots were monkeying around, flew far too low and fast, caused a serious accident/tragedy that was avoidable, and destroyed evidence…it’s a poor craftsman who blames the tools, and a poor pilot and navigator who blames the aircraft/equipment.
thanks for the follow up video. I know I probably wasnt the only one to ask for it or you were going to do the second anyways but it feels good that our brainwaves connected in some way lol. best horror channel i watch brother. Keep up the fantastic work.
Most military aircraft of that time and many of today do not have FDR's , because they are a security risk if the plane crashes and then found by an enemy.
Remember it like yesterday this tragedy was about the most serious and preventable international incident within my life time the scars simply will not and should not ever go away . 😢🕊
Compared to your first video my friend you really have gone into more detail in this case, such a travesty of justice >< I still don't believe he burned the video because of him smiling but that it had the evidence of them showing off but of course we will never know.
Blaming the altimeter on you flying WAYYY lower is such BS. They clearly didn't care about the flying rules and immediately wanted to cover it up. Them all getting off essentially free after killing 20 people is such a classic .ove of both the US and specifically the military.
The one in the first disaster was a scapegoat, though. (If it was the operator that was called that) He asked his coworkers what to do and was told to override. The company was at fault for their lack of training and running the cars too fast.
That's so upsetting. They killed 20 people and walked away free. This is ridiculous. They should have all been charged and sentence to life. It was so clear they were just messing around and killed so many people as a result.
As a former member of the Armed Forces, USAF, this makes me mad that the USMC would give their soldiers such leniency in a case involving the deaths of over 20 people. Just because they are US servicemen, doesn't excuse their behavior or their actions, and they should have been held accountable for everything that happened on that day. And as officers in the military, they should be setting the example of how an officer is supposed to behave, to their subordinates and to the people of Italy. Not messing around and acting like jackasses, thinking that they are some sort of "TOP GUN" characters showing off to each other.
I own a bakery and Tuesdays are our prep day. You always upload just as I am alone in the basement making croissants. Thank you for always giving me something good to watch 🫶
Just think. There are some Americans so brainwashed by the 'cult of military' that they would "thank" these men for their "service" and buy them a beer. Not everybody in a uniform is a hero. Some are just horrible people. Yet they get endless praise and admiration.
Ooooh, I remember how we used the cable cars for a school trip and someone told me, that there had been an incident. I apparently forgot that it was in italy, but I remember imagining how it was to fall down and got scared from cable cars because of that
"On 4 March 1999, a U.S Marine Corps court-martial at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, found Marine Captain Richard J. Ashby-who on 3 February 1998 had been flying an EA-6B Prowler lower and faster than rules permitted when it severed gondola cables in Italy and sent 20 people to their deaths-**not guilty of involuntary manslaughter and homicide.** It also found him without negligence, thereby creating an uproar in Italy that threatened both Italian-American relations and the fabric of NATO's forces in that country." From the us naval board site
"After a year of painful recriminations on both sides of the Atlantic and a three-week trial, the verdict came with stunning finality this morning at the end of seven hours of deliberation over two days: "Captain Richard J. Ashby, this court finds you, of all the specifications and charges, not guilty," said Col. William T. Snow, president of the jury." Washington post, Steve Vogel
For the full story of the First Cavalese Cable Car Disaster in 1976, you can watch this video: ua-cam.com/video/kuZvOJ1EYuI/v-deo.html
The bhola cyclone
Weird how one person from each incident had the same surname and both caused it.
I remember when this happened and being absolutely appalled. There's a factor of 7.5 between 80m and 600m. The entire crew was full of shit and lying. We should have let the Italians handle them.
Absolutely
I agree. I remember this accident and they should have had the book thrown at them and be in Leavenworth prison today.
It is my impression as well. Besides, if trained airmen cannot tell the difference between 80 and 600 metres, they definitely should not be flying. Or be sent to gliding school... maybe they could handle a 80 metres tow... :)
Italy does send people to jail for things like this, see the video about the first disaster.
@@Ozymandias1 You mean the case where the wrong people were sent to prison while the actual perpetrators, the administration, walked free?
These clowns were 100% goofing off and recording their "fun". I guarantee that they saw the gondola and dared each other to fly below it. How infuriating that they suffered no consequences for taking so many lives AND denying and culpability.
@@mr.snippy exactly this. And that was why they burned the tapes because they could fully redact anything visual and claim military intelligence, so the excuse of their smiling faces being why they destroyed evidence is B.S. ....they would however have a harder time explaining away editing the audio, and I fully believe that the audio would have them bragging they can fly under the line. (And I have the s on tapes intentionally because they probably have past footage of them or others doing that same thing more than once)
Absolutely! Exactly he felt the need to burn the film! Coward! He was being a sloppy idiot. They all were.
YOU cannot guarantee ANYTHING
This is exactly what I suspect as well. Even if your altimeter is broken, you can tell the difference between 200 ft and 2000 ft.
@@arnenelson4495 Agreed but I think it is possible this tragedy resulted from a bet or dare or show off stunt.
I was stationed at Aviano in the US Air Force when this all went down. I was horrified, and incredulous those men got off so light. Not only did they get away with killing people, but they deliberately destroyed pertinent evidence! Those images I saw of smashed bodies laying in the snow. The Italian people had every right to be angry.
It was manslaughter. Not murder.
@@GenXfrom75that's an odd hill to die on.
@@Cykotyk not dying on any hill. But they didn’t murder those people. Murder is a deliberate act with intent to kill. They caused their deaths. That’s manslaughter.
@@GenXfrom75 I was speaking figuratively, not by the legal definition.
@@GenXfrom75 That's negligent homicide, not manslaughter. Manslaughter would mean they did not mean to fly that low, but they did mean to fly that low, and the negligence led them to murder 20 people.
I'm a pilot myself and have seen very detailed breakdowns of the disaster. The fact is, this crew was very well known for hotdogging and they took an LAS mission to mean "fly as low as you like and pretend you're in a Top Gun movie." Even the act of *taping* themselves should have got them court-martialed. Burning the tape afterward would have been taken in near any court as "consciousness of guilt" and absolutely as obstruction of justice and destroying evidence.
It didn't take very much time at all for the crew to put two and two together while airborne and realize they'd hit a cable - and exactly what that meant. By the time they landed, they already had all their false alibis prepared and their stories straight. And the US military *always* covers for its own.
Because of UA-cam limitations the OP couldn't show most of the photos taken of the destroyed gondola, but I've seen the real pictures the Italians took. The snow was covered in blood and body parts. The impact force was estimated to be 250+gs - far more than any human body can remain intact through. And those pictures were published throughout the Italian media. I would have been baying for their blood too, if it was my relative that got killed like that.
Quite so - and the American military and diplomatic departments have plenty of form for this behaviour. Plenty. The Americans think they can act with impunity anywhere in the world they choose and by and large that is exactly what they do.
Is it any wonder half the planet detests the US...
Well said.
Thank you for sharing this.
They did get court martialed, twice
This.
Blaming the altimeter is BS. Any pilot can tell the difference between 260 and 2000 feet and certainly their airspeed indicator was working. They were hotdogging and should have been prosecuted as such.
Spoken like a non-pilot. It is easy to misread an altimeter. Been there, done that, and got away with it without incident.
Checked and found to be working perfectly then the report gets buried. Smacks of a cover up
@@neiloflongbeck5705 Spoken like someone who can't see a freaking mountain 80 metres away in clear conditions.
@@neiloflongbeck5705
It's amazing that you can still get people simping for those obviously in the wrong even in situations like this.
@coconutsmarties ah, someone who is less smart than their handle. They could see the mountain but couldn't see the cables for the cable cars. Many pilots over the years have come cropper because they never saw the wires across a gap. One glider pilot I knew was hospitalised by a single cable he never saw as the poles holding it up were covered by trees.
As an American and a veteran, I am ashamed that more was not done to make amends to the families of the victims and that the two men were acquitted. They should have paid for their negligence. This disaster should never have happened. RIP all of you poor souls. 💔
From someone in Italy I thank you for this comment, your much better pilot than the four baboons In that prowler.
Add it to an enormous list
As an enlisted marine I am said to say tI am not surprised this is how my officers could have acted.
It was Newt Gingrich and his Republican House that voted against it just because Bill Clinton wanted it. The GOP has always been the party of deliberate cruelty.
NO WONDER THE ITALIANS ( and other Europians call us " THE UGLY AMERICANS!!!) If that was an Italian plane, flying over the rockies, and hit a gondola cable , killing 20 Americans while HOT DOGGING!!, BET THE CREW WOULD STILL BE IN PRISON!!! ( RULES FOR THEE BUT NOT FOR ME!!! typical!!!)
"I burned the tape because people would get mad at me." *literally just was part of causing an accident that killed 20 people*
I hate to break it to you dude, but people will be mad at you no matter what because of what you did
It's pretty obvious that they knew the tape would incriminate them, knowingly flying extra low and showing off.
@@zorfmorf2414 At the very least he should have been convicted for destruction of evidence.
Edit: Nevermind, he got obstruction.
"I don't want people to think I committed the crime I accidentally committed on purpose"
does not equal
"I didn't want people mad at me"
pretty clear he understood people were going to mad at him. he didn't want to spit on the corpses of the victims he just killed by having a tape of him smiling and enjoying the view immediately before the accident. considering the media's love affair with tabloid reporting, it's not an unfounded fear.
Besides, he probably didn't need to even burn the tape. If he cried to his superiors in the military, they probably would have covered it up. It's not like the crash was his fault - he was just the navigator, after all, and that's shown by the fact that he escaped receiving a prison sentence.
Also, just so you both understand, you *do* know that a navigator of the plane isn't the one who is flying the plane, right? If the two fratboy flightboy military cowboy jackasses wanted to fuck around, horse about, and fly their plane lower than they are supposed to, you do understand that the navigator really can't do much other than say mean words to them, right? He's not even in the same room, really - they communicate via intercom.
It amazes me that people can pay half attention to a ten minute video on a topic and pretend like they're experts on the topic
@@lillyclarity9699
Who's job would it be to look at the envelope marked "new map"?
@@lillyclarity9699 While it isn't normally the navigator actually flying the plane, he can do so, since he is in a front seat, with flight controls at his disposal. IOW, he is one of the two cowboy fratboy flyboys.
I remember watching the "Seconds from Disaster" epidode about thus tragedy where they interviewed obe or two of the pilots. He had no remorse at all and in fact was still mad that they got court marshalled. That interview convinced me 100% the crew is guilty as sin and were flying low on purpose and videotaping it to feed their egos.
It's a scary thought that he may now be flying airliners.
@@Ozymandias1 That's what I was wondering. Freedom of information and all that. Someone must know.
I must've missed that episode of "SFD." I loved that show, it reminds me a lot of this channel. Still, I don't think I would try to find that one and watch it. Hearing one or more of the pilots try to defend themselves would make my blood boil.
Some people wrap themselves in their own lies like a comfort blanket. Eventually they start to believe it wholeheartedly; it's a defense mechanism. Or they're just a sociopath and utterly lack compassion.
@@Unownshipper it's season 4 episode 8 I'm pretty sure. If you look up "seconds from disaster cable car collision" you'll find a few reuploads. I really like the show as well.
El toro poopoo. 'We didn't know we were so low.' (basically 1,700 ft. below legal flight limits). That would be like saying, "I looked out the window of a glass elevator and I didn't know if I was on the 4th or 40th floor because the indicator light didn't work.'
@@craigpridemore7566 perfect analogy. Lol
A window in a glass elevator would be quiet the waste of handy man work time.
If you can't tell the difference between 80m and 600m, you have absolutely no business piloting a plane.
Not saying I disagree with you,
BUT maybe he didn't know the relative size of the cable car?
Absolutely ridiculous excuse. .."We got confused"
So because they do know the difference, but wanted to play games, then they should be pilots? WOW
@@MrE-y7v That is absolutely not what the OG comment meant....
No question…They were hot dogging. Knowing full well they were below minimums. 😢
The fact that they were acquitted was a huge travesty of justice
No its really not
"Semper fi" taking care.
@chaminadecrew79 Yes, it is you absolute melt.
Welcome to the modern american military 🙃🙃
Welcome to the military where they'll move mountains to protect their officers from murder but will brig a private in a heartbeat for touching a joint
I used to know one of the young Belgian who died in that accident. She was 23 and just finished her law studies. I can not describe how devastated her parents were during years after that. The trial was a real violence for this family, the never really recovered. 😢
I'm so sorry for your loss and for her family. No one should be made to endure this
I couldn’t imagine the anger and devastation they must have felt
My dad who is in the Italian airforce told me about this and I was so angry. He told me that allegedly pilots tend to fly that low and that fast for fun, as sort of a thrill. I really hate how the people responsible didn't get punished in a meaningful way. But hey, its not surprising, given the countries involved.
The actions of America's military and congress were insufficient, arrogant and shameful.
During the 80s I was learning to ski at Occlini pass, in south Tyrol. Multiple times I saw Italian and American planes flying past at no more than 40m above parked cars and restaurants.
@@paulcooper8818 You could say that about their entire history. Not just this occassion.
@@itchyshizle I wouldn't say the entire history, but certainly there are more examples than this one instance.
You’re all welcome for your freedom.
I'm Italian and I was 6 when this disaster occurred.
I still remember the newspapers, the outrage, the television news, and the anger and disappointment after they all got to walk free in the end.
I don't think I've ever met an Italian (of about my age or older) that _didn't_ believe it all happened due to a deliberate choice in unprofessional conduct
As an American who's learning about this event for the first time, I'm appalled. There aren't adequate words. The loss of innocent lives is horrifying, the blatant misconduct of the crew both during the event and afterwards is sickening, and the reluctance of our government to provide compensation is shameful. They were clearly hotdogging, and when they got caught, they lied and destroyed evidence of their crime. It's unfathomable they weren't suitably punished.
I was deployed to Aviano at that time. I had bricks thrown through my windshield and/or eggs thrown at my car every time I left the base.
The anger towards the Americans even appeared in a sopranos episode, during filming an old man shouts at Paulie 'you cut our ski-lift cable”
I remember that line! I always wondered what he meant by that. Thanks.
@@jonusjonus9271 Is that the episode where he goes to Italy and hates it? So funny.
@@thingywotsit9246 yes !
He burnt the tape because he didn't want it to be used as evidence thats an admission of guilt right there
Yup.
Nah, that's called "Pleading the 5th", as he made a Tape that was self-incriminating.
Oh wow, you’re the first person to realize that! Surely justice will be served this time!
@@ligmasack9038no, its called “tampering with evidence” and its a crime in almost all western countries.
Destroying anything that could be considered evidence is a crime in itself. They should have been arrested just for that alone.
But ofcourse the US military gets away with everything. Laos, Afghanistan, Korea, Vietnam, iraq, iran… they all remember
Arguing the maps were outdated when they didnt even unpack the new map is huge 🤣
given that the cable car was operating for several decades (even before the 1976 disaster) how 'outdated' were those maps ? were they drawn from reconnaissance photos of WW 2 ?
@@Rumpel-r4d Taken from Mussolini´s own hands back in ´45 probably :D
Also, I don't know how the cable car lines were ignored in their pre-flight preparations.
I find it incredibly hard to believe that tape was burned because a smiling face on camera might have become bad optics in the media. I think it more likely held evidence of just how reckless they were actually being.
It's sad, but one can easily imagine some "bro" spouting nonsense akin to,
"HaHa, bet you can't fly under that gondola."
"Oh yea? WATCH ME!"
It pissed a lot of us off here in America as well. IIRC, the story was that it was a rite of passage for pilots from that base to fly under the cables.
@@delorbb2298 I am willing to bet money that they would do that...which is why the tape was burned....because anything visual could be redacted for "security reasons", I am willing to be it was the audio of that recording they feared.
@@SoManyRandomRamblings After it happened, the people who lived there said pilots did this all the time. That they knew the cables were there and were actively trying to buzz through it.
@@delorbb2298 not surprised, disgusted by them, but sadly not surprised
The pilot should be held responsible for. He ultimately made the decisions to operate that craft. We all know that tape had all the details we needed to show negligence.
Two "experienced" pilots, flying a plane, couldn't tell the difference between 80 meters and 610 meters. They had been reprimanded for flying too low and fast before this disaster. So why were they allowed to keep flying? The captain's sentence for the death of 20 people was ridiculous, and the navigator should have been jailed for destruction of evidence. And even though compensation was promised by the US, it had to be enforced and paid through treaty laws. Utterly shocking and shameful. RIP to the 20 victims
As an American I'm so sorry to the families of the victims, I 100% believe they were acting carelessly and our disgusting response as a country to not help those effected or hold these men accountable
I 100% believe they were showing off and flying under the cables, the burned tape probably documented all of that.
@@biazacha absolutely 💯
US military personnel face consequences for their horrific actions overseas? Never!
I call BS all day on the sticking gauge. I was an Aviation Electricians Mate in the Navy. I worked on the altitude systems. The age of the aircraft wouldn't have anything to do with the altimeter sticking. That isn't something that would be a fixed piece of equipment. Gauges get swapped out as needed. Then they are put through a complete altitude simulation. I hated that test set. That also wouldn't be the only altitude reference they would have to go by. That was complete deflection trying to blame the maintainers.
You covered this incident in one of your first videos. UA-cam age restricted the video making it harder to find. I'm glad you redid this. The American government acted so horribly in this case. Truly an injustice to the victims and families involved.
The US government always gets their military off with no consequences. Real "fuck the foreigners" vibes. The US military personnel from Abu Ghraib are out and about, living happy lives, with no consequences for what they did and that wasn't just negligence and reckless endangerment of others. It was actual torture and murder. Photographs smiling with decaying corpses. Disgusting organisation.
The EA-6B was a heavily modified version of the A-6 Intruder attack jet. It carried a very extensive EW radar detection and jamming system, a very precise navigation system, superb low level flight characteristics, and with a crew of 4, a heightened level of situational awareness in the cockpit. Jamming and mapping enemy radar emitters was it's job. That mapping had to be precise, so that the intel could be passed on to the Wild Weasels, who could then destroy the emitters with ARMs or some other appropriate ordnance. What I'm leading up to is that the pilot and crew knew exactly where they were, and the cable as well, but the pilot was hot dogging the plane and misjudged how close he was to the cable. He saw it and intended to cut it close, but ended up hitting it. Pure pilot error and poor judgement. IMHO.
I believe everything you said to be true, up until "He saw it". Cables slung across valleys are nearly invisible. I frequently fly in mountainous terrain. Cables slung across valleys have huge orange balls hung from the middle of them. Without the warning balls the cables are invisible in most conditions. The slightest haze, the sun in your eyes, the cable(s) disappear, and I'm only flying at 80-90 knots. An EA-6B can fly over 550 knots, as it was noted the pilot was flying too fast, there's no way he saw that cable.
@@fantabuloussnuffaluffagus "See that cable car packed with Eurotrash?
Let's give them an American fly by!!! YEEHAW"
Could I ask what “hot dogging” means? Second comment I’ve seen mention this and I’m curious!
@@CoreKatalystbasically "showing off", or trying to show how cool they are.
@@CoreKatalystHot-dogging, Flat Hatting, those are terms for flying outside of normal parameters. Thinking buzzing a control tower or hangar.
Genuinely just one of the most disgusting miscarriages of justice in history
Almost as disgusting as siding with Germany in WWII.
@@KSparks80 Yeah that excuses the modern day scumbag behavior of the USA, right? Two wrongs make a right, yeah?
@@KSparks80and that's relevant how?
From an American, I am appalled at this and have been ever since I stumbled across the story one night in college when I was surfing Wikipedia. Deliberately destroying evidence and misleading investigators after accidentally killing almost 2 dozen people, and they walked away free…we should’ve either thrown them in prison ourselves or let them try to figure out a way to get themselves proven innocent in an Italian court of law (which, spoiler, they probably wouldn’t have done). It’s a travesty, and my heart breaks for the families of those who perished because a couple of U.S Marine pilots decided to be stupid.
US soldiers don't ever face consequences, even when it's entirely intentional and not just gross negligence and a disregard for others. It's disgusting. The monsters behind the torture and murders at Abu Ghraib were out, free of consequences, living their lives, right after what they did. Literal photographic evidence of them smiling and laughing over the decaying corpses of their victims and *nothing* happened.
People on the other side of the world two decades on are still struggling with mental health after being subjected to torture. Innocent people, who were children at the time, now unable to move due to the conditions and treatment there permanently destroying their ability to walk. Seeing people they knew murdered, being sexually abused, and so much more - all while these US soldiers are off raising happy little families.
The story of the "faulty altitude dial" doesnt wash. There is a barometric altimeter in front of each of the two pilots, and a third one in between them. And there is a radar altimeter. Are we to believe that all four were faulty AND that all four showed the SAME incorrect altitude? That stretches credibility beyond elastic limit.
Not only that, but that difference between lowest allowed height and their actual height is HUGE, you can't tell me that even IF (and I agree that that's more than unlikely) all altimeters didn't work correctly, they weren't able to tell that they were flying significantly lower. I'd maybe get that with being 50 m too low, but over 500 m??
@@tezzanoia yea all 4 of them should've gone to prison for 10 years or more
@@vicvega3614 The two men in the back can't see out the front, have no altimeters, and can't do anything to adjust the altitude of the aircraft in any case. Yet you want to put them in prison for 10 years? Care to explain why?
@@fantabuloussnuffaluffagus if you were in the back seat egging your friend on to drive like a lunatic and he ran over some kids i 100% promise you there would be charges against you.
Also, they had been already reprimanded several times for flying too low in the same area. So, unless that few is veeeery unlucky with the altimeters of their aircraft, they were clearly unrepentant hotdoggers…
Insane. The fact that this crew got away with killing 20 ppl; it is obvious they were well aware of what they were doing. And destroying the evidence?! C’mon. Anyone can see through their bs. This case should be brought forward to the public eye, again, and have some proper justice served this time round.
Literally nobody believes they weren't showing off. This was shameful.
I hate coverups. They KNEW they were too low. Even if the dial was faulty they knew it and they didn't gain altitude. The military should NOT have aided a coverup. And Italy should not have had to use treaties to ensure compensation was paid out.
It would have been an accident, if they had not lived, worked, and flown there for 2 years.
Even without maps, they knew there were skilifts in the area.
Most likely looking at the pretty tourist girls skiing on the mountain.
also burning the video tape gave him more alibi against him, he did something stupid.
The fact that a country worth literal trillions of dollars.. having to be _forced_ to pay compensation after "accidentally" killing 20 innocent people is utterly abhorrent. USA should be ashamed of itself.... AGAIN.
It appalls me too, but it doesn't surprise me, our congress would do anything to not have to take responsibility for something.
As an American I say “Good luck with that…” though I don’t disagree with you at all.
@@toastoverlord2166 agreed our congress is fully against accountability
What do you mean, "AGAIN"? That was a shame. All countries have reason for shame. Stick to the specific incident.
@@loganmeline9233no no. “America bad!”
If the pilot was willing to burn the tape and suffer the consequences, it must've been really bad. I wouldn't be surprised if the officer bet or challenged the pilot to fly under that wire.
Showboating murderers. People like that are still around too - I've seen several air force pilots from Travis flying irresponsibly low over the college campus in my area to show off.
How odd a synchronicity that the part-time cable car operator in the first disaster and the navigator of the flight in the second had the same last name, Schweitzer.
I know it might be just a common name, but I thought the same thing!
Sometimes I wonder what people like this are doing now. Ashby, for instance. Is he working a regular job? Do his coworkers know he's a killer? Is he using an assumed name?
If he hasn’t changed his name, it’s almost guaranteed that his coworkers know. Someone always googles the new guy’s name, and a juicy bit of gossip like that would make its way around an office at warp speed!
I was wondering the same thing.
His co-workers subscribe to Fascinating Horror.... "uhhhhhh hey guy, something you wanna tell us?"
Thank you for covering this. I've been fascinated by this case ever since I was a child and it dominated the news for weeks, because it happened very close. The images of the smashed cable car and blood covered snow are seared into my memory.
He forgot to mention that the first responders to this disaster discovered that all of the victims' faces were contorted in fear and terror. Several of them hugging each other trying to comfort themselves in their last moments. Truly horrifying and heartbreaking 😱
If that's true then they most likely saw the jet flying in their direction. Truly appalling that they had no real consequences for their reckless behavior.
Can you state where you found that information?
Has no one else noticed that both of these disasters (98 & 76) were caused by people with the same surname?? No one else find that strikingly spooky??
Man. This just keeps getting worse for those marines. Absolute idiots. You can very easily tell the difference between 200 and 2,000 feet. They should be serving life in prison.
That may be a bit too harsh, but should definitely be set to work day and night until they pay off the gondola and abut a billion usd per victim. If they are as clever as they thought they are it would be paid off in no time.
@@Commentator54120 people died and you're saying it's too harsh? Tf.
@@PhilipMarcYTlife for an accident? It wasn’t murder.
Life is usually reserved for 1st Degree Murder, not negligence leading to accidental manslaughter.
It's really adorable out the people in this comment section have no idea how the law works lol.
When your last video popped up about the cable car accident, I immediately thought you were going to talk about this incident, I had no idea both happened in the same place. I feel so sorry for all the families.
As an American I am appalled by and deeply ashamed of this incident. I am so sorry for my country's behavior.
US soldiers never facing consequences is always so disgusting. They just didn't for a moment stop to consider the danger they were putting others in. They refused to accept any responsibility when they did it. I wouldn't be nearly as mad if they had just said "Yes. This was my fault". But they went out of their way to come u with a story and blame literally anything else they could.
This isn't even near the worst the US gets up to overseas without consequences though. Boils my blood every day that people like the monsters behind Abu Ghraib are out, free, without consequences, enjoying life, after torturing, murdering, and sexually abusing tens of thousands of people. We have actual photographs, taken by the US soldiers themselves, in uniform, of them smiling over the decaying corpses of the people they murdered, and they are now free to go about their lives and raise families. Meanwhile the victims, two decades on, continue to live in poverty, struggling with the torture they were subjected to, some who were only children at the time, who are still even now unable to walk or exist as functional people due to the damage they suffered due to treatment or conditions there.
Love your content. It's informative and respectful. Keep up the good work!
Ashby and Schweitzer should've been forced to help clean up their mess as punishment.
This was hugely embarrassing, and I was angry at the hubris these US Airmen had.
I'm even angrier at my country for not compensating the families nor disciplining the criminals properly.
No.
Sorry to correct you, but they aren't Airmen. That term is usually reserved for the Air Force, these officers were Marines.
@@michaelkantner6420 No prob.
@@jenniferlonnes7420 I appreciate it very much.
I can't imagine being on one of those clean up crews .
Easily the most enraging example, but certainly not the only one, of how US units in Italy treat our country as their playground, certain that they will never be persecuted for it. Disgusting.
Not just Italy. Wherever th US has bases, personnel are protected by the status of forces agreement which basically puts them above local laws.
@@robertcox1835 Yup, there was a case in the UK last year where the wife of a US serviceman killed a teenager on a moped by driving on the wrong side of the road at speed. They flew her back to America and she has faced no charges and of course the US govt wont extradite her back to the UK, they never do (see also, IRA terrorists and fundraisers}.
They do this in every country. It is disgusting.
A travesty of justice. Absolutely disgusting.
Wow they basically said "We investigated ourselves and found us innocent" huh.
Kinda like those responsible for covid.
Kinda like the US government when any incident happens.
@@axelbrackeniers5488 keep crying about it
@@chaminadecrew79 nice rage bait buddy. I personally know the grandchildren of immigrants from Laos that came to Europe because their whole country was carpetbombed by the US. Laos didnt even partake in the Vietnam war, nor were they harboring Viet Cong. The Viet Cong simply retreated into Laos and the US saw that as a good opportunity to kill 200K civilians.
Thats more casualties than the 2 nuclear bombs on japan.
@@clray123 no because there was no investigation into was Covid real. And nobody found themselves innocent. Who found themselves innocent the Chinese take a dump on some other post. 💩
4 months in prison for murdering 20 innocent people. Disgusting.
I just love this channel. As soon as I hear those chords, I settle in for a bloody good story. And I love your voice, and accent. Who knew, horror stories could be my happy place...😏👍🏽💯🔥🌹
I can't tell you how many times I'll be in traffic on a bridge (for example), and start hearing his voice: "On the second of July, two thousand and twenty-four, traffic was moving at a slow, but steady eight kilometers (or five miles) per hour on the X Freeway interchange, with drivers unaware of the tragedy about to strike."
Even if their altimeter was faulty, which was clearly a lie, any pilot could tell the difference between the 80 metres they were flying and the minimum permitted 610 metres. They should all be serving life sentences but of course the US military acquitted their own.
The US Military doesn’t often acquit “their own.”
Every plane has redundancy in primary flight instruments, the co pilot has his own set, so they knew full well what their altitude was at all times.
@@GenXfrom75 it most certainly does
@@yorgokarna6801 ok. 👌 guess that’s why so many service members are currently serving sentences in places like Leavenworth.
@@GenXfrom75 that's the exception rather than the rule. You are either being deliberately obtuse or you are clueless about what your country does.. Either way, putting down that star spangled banner for a bit might help you see more clearly if you want to see the truth that is 🤷
You just wouldn't believe it would you? Two accidents on the same cable car line. They should never have been flying there!! There is plenty of room in other places to fly low.
Was the second even an accident?
In 2013 six Russians were killed in a snowmobile crash at Cavalese. They were descending an illuminated piste at night when the driver switched to an unlit black run, lost control and crashed into a ravine. The area is a disaster magnet. Great skiing, though.
@@rachaelcourtnell7275 I think they destroyed the tape cuz the audio would reveal that they intended to fly below the wire, fully knowing how risky it was.
Thank you and have a great week.
I lived in the Po Valley in the 80's. One afternoon a fighter jet from Aviano flew over my house at an altitude of no more than 300 feet. It was deafening. Most of these pilots were hot-doggers without supervision. The supervisors (or lack of them) needed to be scrutinized too! I'm still mad about this.
I was in the brig at Camp LeJeune when these guys were in there. Needless to say, they were in solitary and no one could look at them when they were being transported around.
They were horseplaying and filming inside the cockpit with video camera, later burning the tape (destroyed the evidence), got away with it.
Your lost cable car video had me searching up related incidents.
The amount of times the government has killed people with low flying planes or plane related incidents like this, and got away with it with little to no repercussion is disgusting...
Not just American!
@@njwpoo666 I didn't say American!
So much for "Marine Core Honour".
This event outrages me on so many levels. Such a needless loss of lives.
Thank you for sharing it though. Many things can be learnt from it in order to prevent it in the future 👍
RIP to those souls lost in this horrible tragedy, condolences to the families.
Such a shame justice was not served here.
As an American, I feel disgusted by this. My sympathies & condolences go out to all of those poor people who were murdered -- Yes, I said that right -- by such irresponsible & reckless marines, as well as to their families & friends for this horrible tragedy. It breaks my heart to know that my countrymen did something like that to 20 innocent civilians & escaped justice for their crimes.
US soldiers never face consequences for their actions. This isn't a one-off. It's so disgusting. They just didn't for a moment stop to consider the danger they were putting others in. They refused to accept any responsibility when they did it. I wouldn't be nearly as mad if they had just said "Yes. This was my fault". But they went out of their way to come up with a story and blame literally anything else they could.
This isn't even near the worst the US gets up to overseas without consequences though. Boils my blood every day that people like the monsters behind Abu Ghraib are out, free, without consequences, enjoying life, after torturing, murdering, and sexually abusing tens of thousands of people. We have actual photographs, taken by the US soldiers themselves, in uniform, of them smiling over the decaying corpses of the people they murdered, and they are now free to go about their lives and raise families. Meanwhile the victims, two decades on, continue to live in poverty, struggling with the torture they were subjected to, some who were only children at the time, who are still even now unable to walk or exist as functional people due to the damage they suffered due to treatment or conditions there.
@@SNMG7664 Yes, you are correct about that; & it is appalling. It’s easy to understand why they hate us - Americans - so much for doing such awful things. I just hope they understand that it’s mostly our government & military to blame for it & not its people. I’m just as disgusted & outraged, as most of my fellow American civilians, just as much as you & they are about these despicable actions. Most of us are truly not like that; we’re mostly all good, honest, hardworking people who love our families & just wish to live our lives in peace with others, just like the rest of you.
Wild coincidence that the first accident had an operator named Schweizer and the second a pilot named Schweitzer.
This was not the first time a Marine EA6B squadron’s negligence and recklessness has caused death and destruction of innocent lives. In 1981 a Marine EA6B crashed on board the USS Nimitz due to overindulging in cold medicine. 14 were killed and 45 seriously wounded.
I remember this case. Didn't realize it was the same cable car service as first video. Geez, those Top Gun Maverick types.
As PIC, you are responsible for the operation of the craft.
Low-level flight?
Eyes better be OUTSIDE the cockpit.
300+ knots at 200 ft?
Eyes are definitely outside.
It’s 5am here in America. I’ve tossed and turned all night, opening UA-cam to try and get some relief, and I’m reminded how nice it is to follow content-makers in the UK - 6 hours ahead.
They're 5/6 hours ahead depending if it's DST or not (it is now).
There is no possible way a trained pilot could not visually tell the difference between 260ft and 2000+ ft without having to rely on instruments. These men are lying
Hello! It would be great if you made a video about the Torre del Bierzo accident, one of the worst railway disasters in history.
I love your content, greetings from Spain!
Not sure which is scarier, negligence from the company running the cable car, or negligence from an air crew that you got no clue was even in the area
EDIT: THe negligence part was in reference to the first disaster in 1976, to clear that up
I know the worst part: all the crew members were acquitted of manslaughter.
Where do you find negligence on the part of the cable car company? It's not as if the cable car ran off course.
@@notapplicable531 Negligence in regards to the 1976 disaster, not the 1998 one
They were definitely showing off.. I'm not a pilot but I love roller-coasters. 200ft is quite different than 2,000ft by eye sight!! This was human error and highly infuriating. Thanks again FH, you did a great job breaking this one down.
I'm a pilot. I love our Naval aviators and did everything I could to see this incident impartially as it was unfolding in front of the world at that time. These guys screwed the pooch and got off easy. But for the grace God, there go I. Tragic, horrific, embarrassing, and sad.
Wow! What a story! You never fail to make me thankful for finding your content and learning of new things. It makes my walk through life more circumspect. Thank you for your work, Sir!
I remembered watching this case on Second from disaster
The suggestion they tried to fly under the wire is a compelling one. It’s a shame they couldn’t or were prevented from concluding that.
Brilliant video packed with detail. Thanks.
I learned about this disaster at "Seconds from disaster".
Same
same
I learned about "Seconds From Disaster" from this comment.
Me too and I absolutely reccomend it to everybody who is interested in such cases.
Me too
Those pilots were monkeying around, flew far too low and fast, caused a serious accident/tragedy that was avoidable, and destroyed evidence…it’s a poor craftsman who blames the tools, and a poor pilot and navigator who blames the aircraft/equipment.
The American military murdering innocent civilians without any consequence? That tracks.
Imperialism at its finest.
please cry more about it
Well, the classical archetype of a typical American exists for a reason...
@chaminadecrew79
As a Mexican, why should I cry? I'll just laugh as more of my people pour into your country
thanks for the follow up video. I know I probably wasnt the only one to ask for it or you were going to do the second anyways but it feels good that our brainwaves connected in some way lol. best horror channel i watch brother. Keep up the fantastic work.
No cockpit black box audio recorder? Or did they "forget" to pull from the breaker
Most military aircraft of that time and many of today do not have FDR's , because they are a security risk if the plane crashes and then found by an enemy.
That was really interesting. Thank-you for doing the research.
I had a feeling this would be the next video. Send in the Marines.
Remember it like yesterday this tragedy was about the most serious and preventable international incident within my life time the scars simply will not and should not ever go away . 😢🕊
burning the tape is beyond suss
Aww, but he got six whole-, sorry....FOUR whole months prison /sarcasm
Compared to your first video my friend you really have gone into more detail in this case, such a travesty of justice >< I still don't believe he burned the video because of him smiling but that it had the evidence of them showing off but of course we will never know.
Blaming the altimeter on you flying WAYYY lower is such BS. They clearly didn't care about the flying rules and immediately wanted to cover it up. Them all getting off essentially free after killing 20 people is such a classic .ove of both the US and specifically the military.
Stunning that such a strong cable didn't shred the aircraft,,,
Basically, never get on a cable car is what I'm gathering
Never do anything. There might American military staff nearby waiting to take your life and never face any consequences
They are quite safe, actually. Accidents are very rare.
especially after that accident in Italy in 2021. video footage of it and everything.
@@paninipaninior wives of US military attaches might drive on the wrong side of the road, kill someone and also get away with it
@@paninipanini please please keep crying
Ok I gotta admit I was NOT expecting you to so casually make this a two parter. The title got me. Damn guys.
Both people responsible for the two disasters are called "Schweitzer". Weird coincidence?
The one in the first disaster was a scapegoat, though. (If it was the operator that was called that) He asked his coworkers what to do and was told to override. The company was at fault for their lack of training and running the cars too fast.
That's so upsetting. They killed 20 people and walked away free. This is ridiculous. They should have all been charged and sentence to life. It was so clear they were just messing around and killed so many people as a result.
As a former member of the Armed Forces, USAF, this makes me mad that the USMC would give their soldiers such leniency in a case involving the deaths of over 20 people. Just because they are US servicemen, doesn't excuse their behavior or their actions, and they should have been held accountable for everything that happened on that day. And as officers in the military, they should be setting the example of how an officer is supposed to behave, to their subordinates and to the people of Italy. Not messing around and acting like jackasses, thinking that they are some sort of "TOP GUN" characters showing off to each other.
I own a bakery and Tuesdays are our prep day. You always upload just as I am alone in the basement making croissants. Thank you for always giving me something good to watch 🫶
Seconds from disaster did a fantastic job covering this. If you get a chance, watch it (this is also fascinating).
Just think. There are some Americans so brainwashed by the 'cult of military' that they would "thank" these men for their "service" and buy them a beer.
Not everybody in a uniform is a hero. Some are just horrible people. Yet they get endless praise and admiration.
Lmao such ridiculously binary thoughts
Ooooh, I remember how we used the cable cars for a school trip and someone told me, that there had been an incident. I apparently forgot that it was in italy, but I remember imagining how it was to fall down and got scared from cable cars because of that
"On 4 March 1999, a U.S Marine Corps court-martial at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, found Marine Captain Richard J. Ashby-who on 3 February 1998 had been flying an EA-6B Prowler lower and faster than rules permitted when it severed gondola cables in Italy and sent 20 people to their deaths-**not guilty of involuntary manslaughter and homicide.** It also found him without negligence, thereby creating an uproar in Italy that threatened both Italian-American relations and the fabric of NATO's forces in that country."
From the us naval board site
"After a year of painful recriminations on both sides of the Atlantic and a three-week trial, the verdict came with stunning finality this morning at the end of seven hours of deliberation over two days: "Captain Richard J. Ashby, this court finds you, of all the specifications and charges, not guilty," said Col. William T. Snow, president of the jury."
Washington post, Steve Vogel
I remember this and it was truly shocking and appalling.