Arab Israelis: Are things different for you since October 7th?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
Can we push this channel to go more mainstream? This level of Journalism is what's missing in today's world. We ask the outside world of their opinions more than the ones that see the conflict on the ground through their eyes.
1:31 Wrong translation: She said:"Ezrahim"= citizens, and not "mizrahim"= Mizrahi.
As an armed Israeli citizen it's surprising to me that she thinks armed citizens would do something to Israeli Arabs on a nature reserve in the south. WTF? Where does this concept comes from?
@@karapuzo1 They are intimidating - you speak the language of "the enemy", you look like "the enemy", your cousins are "the enemy" because of where they live. These people who view you as "the enemy" are armed with guns and are willing to use them. So, what reason doesn't she have to fear such things? You would only understand if you were a member of a marginalized group in a society.
@@rajm2626 so fantasy and projections from their own culture, I got you.
@@karapuzo1 They speak the same language as the people whom Israel have declared "the enemy", follow the same religion, look the same, and generally identify with them as well. They are well within reason to think that they could be shot if they go near armed Jewish Israelis. There is no fantasy or projection there.
@@karapuzo1the unfortunate reality is that their fear is well founded, I had friends in a trip in the south a month or two ago (they were Jewish), and all of the sudden some Naari Gvaot comes at them out of a car and point a gun at them thinking they are Beduin, they were shouting to them "we are jews dont shoot"
for me it was a wakeup call of the direction this country and society is going to, it is looking very grim.
Amazing video as always, Corey, but please try to interrupt less and just let the people speak like you used to. I understand that times are tense in Israel right now, but videos like yours are incredibly valuable to understanding the viewpoints of the people.
Yes, I'll second this. In fact I would say you don't even have to ask them such a specific question. Just ask them to describe how they honestly feel about everything that is going on right now and then just be quiet and let them say whatever they want to say. You can always edit it down later.
I second that. Avoid questions with cues and let them give their true opinion
Who’s that stupid woman with you asking leading questions? Get rid of her
yah that women was giving full anxiety vibes, with her questions, and interrupting people. The irony, the colonizers always the ones on the stressed anxious vibes.
@@marcella9324 I think she is a tourist
@6:40 "The song of peace begins in the home". A beautiful line that is so important to embody, and I hope is ultimately the reason why we are here and watching Corey's amazing videos. There will only be peace when we can see each other and love/respect each other. Amen.
Totally agree with you 100% problem is there is a minority that are greedy and seem to be able to pull the strings and the majority seem to believe them and follow blindly
we need more arab israeli content! great stuff!
Their perspective is extremely important. It's also often one of the most complex perspectives in this conflict
@@RobespierreThePoofIt’s extreme, for sure. And rarely accurate
I didn’t realize how high the tensions between ourselves are.
I’m sorry that you are scared arab Israelis 😢
We are also scared. Everyone is on high alert.
Stay safe ❤
Yah the most afraid are the children in Gaza. Hopefully you’re praying for them to? Or do you also support your government carpet bombing babies in the name of ‘Hamas’
they are not israelis, they are palestinians
@@yansideabacoa6257they are Israeli citizens. I don’t understand your point? Can’t they be both Israeli citizens while simultaneously have their Palestinian identity? As the third man said, even if Palestine will be an independent country we won’t move there, because Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East
The man is unrealistic, the Minister of Homeland Security gave gun licenses only because the Arabs kill Jews at every opportunity, Israeli Arabs with Israeli ID cards also kill Jews, and it turned out that when this happens, God forbid, then in the end a citizen with a licensed gun is the one who saves lives and shoots a terrorist. And it is not true that the minister For internal security he said to shoot the Arabs, but he said to shoot the terrorists, and there have already been Arab victims who were killed by terrorists. As a Jew, I don't think that an Israeli Arab can't walk around a Jewish city, there are Arab policemen, doctors, pharmacists, mechanics, and others who work everywhere and no one attacked them, this is a fact, most Israeli Arabs realized that they were in danger from Hamas terrorists just like the Jews, they murdered On October 7 Arabs, even though they said "We are Muslim Arabs.
@@PhoenixL0vee Citizenship was imposed on them in 1966 after 18 years of segregation and military rule. They had no choice. 3/4ths of all Palestinians were expelled, they either refused to leave or managed to hide and avoid being expelled. Why would they ever leave their ancestral homelands? They know what happens when Palestinians leave their land for even a second, they aren’t allowed to return because Israel is an ethnic cleansing settler colonial society trying to establish an artificial demographic majority. Israel is not a democracy, it militarily occupies over 5 million people who have no legal rights in the country that has occupied them for over half a century. Is that democracy?
But most Arab Israelis and Jewish Israelis look alike and most times, it is not easy to distinguish between them.
Cousins be fighting
We can distinguish mostly
@@maleyalove3447 in which way do you distinguish them?
Most of the time that's the outfit @@farsalami8605
No, it's hard if you haven't lived there. If you live there for a while you'll start noticing the difference. It can still be hard in some cases but usually you are able to tell.
‘I don’t know what is Hamas’. What the hell
Right really horrible comment sounds like Germans after WW2 say they never met or knew a Nazi
Lying to non belivers is a religious duty
Well, he lives in Tira, which has no connection to Hamas, and, for sure he has never even been to Gaza.
You clearly missed his point.
That guy is living in a fantasy world. Talking peace with Hamas or Palestinians is a no no..
Who feels more scared? Arab who walks in Tel Aviv or Jew who walks in Umm el-Fahem? It's tough now. But people still work and live together.
Who feels more scared? An Arab who lives in Masafer Yatta terrorised by settlers or an Israeli who has a passport to flee Hamas’s rockets when they feel like it?
@@MacrobianNomadthats one of those 22 arnab mizlamic nation states? Those that are completly cleansed of jooose?
@@MacrobianNomad mate i didnt understand a word of what you said, sorry
Ok, leave arab-Israelis, what about the palestinians who everyday are threatened by the settelers who rob their land and staff everyday? Are they safe? Oh I forgot that the settelers have lots of weapons that can kill the poor palestinians so easily while they are trying to live a normal life.
@@MacrobianNomadthe guy from yatta can fly too
Every one is on their tip toes
Walking on eggshells
Yes. But did you see how it is easy at 5:10 to blame the government but to "dont know" who Hamas is...
It tells a lot about the democracy and freedom of speech in Israel versus the same in muslim society.
@@DIY-MechanicI wouldn’t say “Muslim society.” But I had the same impression I think you had, namely, of course he knows very well who Hamas is, but is afraid to criticize them.
Welcome to the middle east 😂
@@DIY-Mechanic In general Arabs are liars, they will blame everyone else but themselves.
I always watch your content and find it very interesting, but I think sometimes you cut people off in a bit of a rude manner, then when you don’t end up fully understanding their point, they have to go back to where they were cut off but now their train of thought is all out of whack. Just let the guy give his answer in full. Again, what you are doing is fascinating and I’m a subscriber.
Part of its weird charm is that he has identified a super important project and followed it through consistently for so long... but he could get a lot better at it haha
This is a great question, as a Jewish Israeli that's living in Hod Hasharon, I don't really feel the impact on how we see Israeli Arabs differently since the start of the war, but I have heard things from people and it's good to see all point of view.
i agree its good to see as many points of view as possible, these are only 3, not all.
as we saw after oct 7, the Israeli Arab community in our great country ranges from patriotic Israeli Arabs with great moral compass, to ones still consider themselves Plastelinians and continue spewing the same idiotic rhetoric as the PA.
they are in a very weird social position.
but after oct 7, i do believe they need to sharpen their position, because sitting on the fence is no longer beneficial to them.
@@ct5965 It seems there's a segment of Jewish Israeli society that doesn't want them around, no matter how they think or act.
@@ct5965
lol...Patriotic you say 🤣
More like a coerced acceptance.
Who in their right mind would want to live in a fascist country like Israel, let alone Palestinians robbed from their land.
@@ct5965youre a fascist settler
@@ct5965yes everyone should get off the fence and call Israel for what it is. An apartheid. A racist state. Occupying state. Committing gen0cide.
חבל שראיינת רק 3 אנשים. הייתי סקרנית לשמוע עוד. אני חיה בגליל וזה כנראה האזור הכי ידידותי בארץ מבחינת יחסי שכנות טובים בין יהודים וערבים. אז אני יכולה גם לשאול בעצמי:) יכולה להגיד מהחוויה שלי שהערבים בגליל היו כואבים מאד אחרי ה 7.10 והייתה בהתחלה מתיחות. ראיתי את הפחד אצלם שהיחסים יושפעו ויתקלקלו. וגם ראיתי את ההקלה אצלם שאחרי כמה שבועות שכולנו היינו בהלם ומפוחדים, אז הייתה הקלה כששני הצדדים הבינו שאנחנו ממשיכים הלאה כמו קודם, ולא יקרה משהו רע ביננו. (שני הצדדים, גם אנחנו פחדנו שפתאום תתגלה עוינות בכפרים שחשבנו שהם ידידותיים, ויתחיל פתאום בלגן גם אצלנו- בהתחלה היה פחד ותחושת ערעור באמון בהכל וכולם)
עצוב לשמוע שערבים בארץ התחילו לפחד מזה שאנשים התחילו לקבל נשק ולהסתובב עם נשק ברחובות… אנשים בעולם לא מבינים כמה פחד היה בארץ בשבועות הראשונים אחרי ה 7.10 שיתחילו עוד מתקפות עלינו מעוד כיוונים, וכולם התחילו להסתובב עם נשק שזה באמת מטורף…! ברוך השם ערביי ישראל בטח ראו שאף אחד לא השתמש בנשק כלפי ערבים במטרה לתקוף, אלא רק מתוך כוונה להיות מוכנים למקרה של התקפה. ואני מקווה שכבר פחות מרגישים סכנה או איום.
אלוהים איזה מצב מטורף זה כשכולם חיים בפחד אחד מהשני
you don’t belong in their land, go back to your countries of origin
Hamas ruined life for everyone! Too bad the Arabs can't or won't speak out against terrorism.
מרגיש לי שטיפה שכחנו את הפרעות שהיו בערים המעורבות במלחמה הקודמת. היה פחד מוצדק לגמרי, אני זוכר טוב מאוד כמה פחדתי לסבתא שלי שגרה בלוד.
היי, את מעדכנת על המצב באינסטגרם? אם כן, אשמח לעקוב
its a english site please use english
i feel like we might need another video on the same topic
this subject is so damn important right now
The 2nd guy is very funny… “The Israel govt is preventing us from having peace”. What about Hamas ? “Hamas I don’t know what is Hamas”
He just doesn't want to go into that subject
Bibi the crime sinister of this big mess paid hamas so to divide them with fatah , the carrots are cooked 🥕🥕
Yes! The utter blindness...
It's not being delusional anymore, it's being a retard
2nd guy trully lives in denial
No, he is not in denial or living in blindness. What concerns him is his Israeli government and the racism he's facing because of its members and Israeli politicians.
Listen to the 3rd guy, he prefers to live in Israel than any other Arab state including a potential Palestinian one... how does that fit with the suffering of Israeli Arabs?
The real reason in the back mind of most arab israeli, that they will never leave this part of palestine for the jews. Its their land.
@@mnlamraj9744 So you arrogantly and hilariously give a completely different reason to what the ACTUAL PERSON says. How rude some people are.
Hey, its his country too. He is a citizen, has his life there, his rights. Why would he leave a democratic state, that has democratic values, for a country that does not? He understands the grass isn't greener.
@@happinin07lol
You admit every ar ab country is a horror show
And in all liklihood, like most Palestinians, his family has lived in that land continuously for countless generations pre-dating 1948, often tracing back a millenia or more. His roots are Palestinian before Israel even existed, so why on earth should he leave the land where he is from even if Israel allows a a truncated, less than-soveriegn set of bantustans next door? He also, as self-professed, believes strongly in coexistance - which is the only lasting way forward for all.
Fantastic videos man. Thank you for delivering the rawness of it all.
Yeah, he does important work. Been following for a while. Asking the real questions. 🙏🏻 Free Palestine 🇵🇸❤
Absolutely
@@JaseekaRawryou know what it means? This slogan?
@@JaseekaRawr no, thank you.
@@JaseekaRawr Watching for a while and still use that stupid "free palestine" buzzword? I call bullshit.
This is a horrible situation. Every time there is a terror attack or worse an intifada, people get hurt and the Arabs in the country seem to "take the heat" for that. It's not right and shouldn't be like that. We are a small country and even if you don't know someone that was affected, you know someone who does. So it affects almost everyone in one way or another especially now. The worse the attacks are the worse it is.
The massacre that happened was unimaginably horrific and brutal. Our hostages are still there. People are still mourning and in shock at this whole thing.
Btw, there are some Israeli Arab hostages there as well.
I really hope the hostages will be released soon and come back home and Hamas won't be a threat anymore. That the terror attacks will stop and the war will end. There was enough death from all sides.
And to the Arabs in our country (from this Israeli Jew), I hope this whole thing calms down soon and that we can live together as we used to. I'm sorry we have a couple of radical hotheads in the government and even more sorry that some people still haven't let go of the racism. (on both sides)
If I may say, I think part of all of this is also the fact that we have seen some support from the Arab community on Oct-7, and while I have seen Arabs saying they don't agree with what happened, and some that even came and helped, as a community you seem to be quite silent. Perhaps if people have seen more support coming from the Arab side as well things will be able to change faster. That is just my opinion of course.
Right now a lot of people are just scared (on both sides) and are just looking for people to blame.
Regardless, this is still an ongoing horrible situation (to say the least) :(
I hope it will end soon and we can go back to at least how things were, if not better.
America took Japanese citizens and put them in prison camps, they took American Natives, stole their lands and put them on Reservations. In Israel after October 7th, some Arab communities inside Israel were celebrating.
No offense but Jews never help non Jews in other wars also, everyone sticks to their own ,Israeli Arabs are just trying to live normally
@Eidelmania Apparently there were less than 20% of the IDF troops in the South, 80% were in the West Bank because of terror. By the time they were gathered and moved South was hours
cause theysupport it. similar to how most palestinians cheered oct 7 then cry on oct 8 when israel attacked back.l
@@MrSandman96 Some of them do, they weren't shy about it. But a lot didn't. Don't forget that some of them did volunteer and did help.
We shouldn't generalize and treat them all the same. Just like we don't want to be treated the same.
One gentleman did not knew what hamas was, the last gentleman, very educated, believed Saudi are occupied by USA. Extreme opinions
.
Since October 7th I make it a point to call my Arab friends more often and meet up with our kids. October 7th happened to all of us.
5:00 look how he "doesn't know Hamas", a well known name in the area especially after Oct'7 - It just screams FEAR.
and how he criticize Israel's government so freely- he knows he lives in a democracy that will never target him for these words, but with Hamas, HE'S AFRAID FOR HIS LIFE.
He knows the face of Hamas but makes sure not to say it out loud cause he wants his family alive.
That might be a very good explanation for his ridiculous claim to not know what Hamas is
To be charitable, I think what he meant was that he does not recognize Hamas, that is- that they don't represent the Arabs (Palestinians) from his perspective.
I wouldn't have read it that way. Yours is just an opinion, as valid as other interpretations. But not a fact.
@@FirsToStrikeof course, I very much doubt he was saying he literally did not know what hamas is
Taqqyia
Kitman
Tahadia
Etc etc
Some cultures have so many names to lies, just like some cultures have many words for types of snow.....
Did he seriously say, instead of hading out flowers, they hand out guns?
To whom do you want to give flowers? To the guys stabbing and shooting random Israelis in the streets?
Wow, the brass neck of yours. There are plenty aggressions from israeli to Palestinians but the Arabs are stabbing. Brainwashed hasbara goat
A misstatement was that Gaza has been occupied for 75 years. Egypt had it till 67 and Israel left in 2006. As the interviewees stated there is NO apartheid in Israel.
The west bank enclaves are essentially bantustans
@@MohammedAli-hl4mrhow are we supposed to know what is bandustan? I disagree with original comment, but that comparison doesnt help
@@grindingpancake bantustans were a feature of appartheid in South africa and the main thing used to draw parallels between South Africa's appartheid regime and Israel.
@@MohammedAli-hl4mrhopefully israel will complete the population exchange with the 22 giant arnab states.
@@MohammedAli-hl4mrbut when the people living there were Jordanian Arabs as an annex province of the Kingdom of Jordan they didn’t clamor for independence.. interesting
My family left our village (Jish) and are now in Haifa because Hezbollah. There are many Arabs here so I feel safe, I'd probably avoid Jerusalem and other places until it dies down. My brother in army.
Stay safe😊
Stay safe my friend!
Stay safe! Haifa is a great city.
Stay Safe, hello from Yokneam.
Thank you my brothers. God bless you
5:10
Very ignorant of him to talk about the politicians, but when its about the side who started a war he is saying "I dont know what it is"...
I guess you only think about your own safety so yes maybe to YOU there was no war before the 7th of October but to others just miles away it doesn’t seem like it’s the case 😅!
As a Jew I wish it would go back to the way it was, where Israeli Jews and Arabs lived together in peace, inside of Israel, without fear of each other. Everyone who is Israeli and holds Israeli citizenship is equal in Israel.
you must want to return to before 1882 prior to Zionism😂
"...where Israeli Jews and Arabs lived together in peace..."
You mean when it was called Palestine.
You need to advocate the dismantling of this terrorist state, if you are honest about living together in peace.
@@malektahri5590 The Hebron massacre was the killing of sixty-seven or sixty-nine Jews on 24 August 1929 in Hebron, then part of Mandatory Palestine, by Arabs
It was not peaceful. This was under the British. Before that, Jews were dhimmis. They were not assured equal civil rights like all in Israel. Stop spreading propoganda.
@@yansideabacoa62571882 The time everybody in the larger region was occupied by the Ottoman Empire you mean?
@@yansideabacoa6257yup!
This was really amazing to watch (many of your videos) as someone who is just trying to understand this conflict in a deeper meaningful way.
4:45 The man is unrealistic, the Minister of Homeland Security gave gun licenses only because the Arabs kill Jews at every opportunity, Israeli Arabs with Israeli ID cards also kill Jews, and it turned out that when this happens, God forbid, then in the end a citizen with a licensed gun is the one who saves lives and shoots a terrorist. And it is not true that the minister For internal security he said to shoot the Arabs, but he said to shoot the terrorists, and there have already been Arab victims who were killed by terrorists. As a Jew, I don't think that an Israeli Arab can't walk around a Jewish city, there are Arab policemen, doctors, pharmacists, mechanics, and others who work everywhere and no one attacked them, this is a fact, most Israeli Arabs realized that they were in danger from Hamas terrorists just like the Jews, they murdered On October 7 Arabs, even though they said "We are Muslim Arabs.
yeah corey isn't big on fact checking when jews on the right are being lied about
He just praised the murder of a 12-yo boy.
What a bunch of BS
האישה הראשונה אמרה "הם אזרחים" נא לתקן את הכתוביות בטעות כתבתם "מזרחים"
The second guy is a real winner - he doesn't know about Hamas (@5:11)? And then they wonder why Jews are security-conscious, and why Jews aren't optimistic about the chances for peace 🙄
I had similar takeaways from him. But he's the 1st _guy._ The 2nd guy, the older gentleman, seemed to have a bit more perspective.
If folks in the strip desired peace, they would have made different choices in the past rather than continuing to choose violence and celebrate (& make excuses for) violence. Anyone who advocated for peace there (or in the "WB") was attacked, killed, or run out. Kinda got the excuses vibe from all 3 interviewees in this video, but the 1st guy was the most blatantly brainwashed, just repeating the media talking points. (For the record, I'm not siding with these or those, but rather sifting through the rubble for the Truth. Which is often rather complicated.)
The whole situation weighs very heavy on my heart. 💔
Yeah denying hamas’ existence was a total joke. Get real bro!
@@sfrentals4769he's not denying their existence. He is basically saying that he has nothing to do with them. What concerns him is his Israeli government and the racism he's facing because of its members and Israeli politicians.
@@4UnlimitedBEing Israelis are looking for war because they want to take all of Palestine, that's why they have this extreme government, because they are extremists themselves.
@@shaimael-elaimy590 duh, it’s obvs he has nothing to do with hamas. But hamas has a whole lot to do with the situation. So ignoring them completely and just complaining about Israeli Jews is counter productive. Matter of fact, most Arab Israelis support this war and agree that hamas needs to get their asses handed to them. (Yes they are concerned about civilian casualties, but understand the fundamental goal.) perhaps This guy was being “political” because he was being filmed and didn’t want to upset his pan Arab brethren; Image an’ all.
I wish you would interview more people. It would have been interesting to hear also Druze, Bedouin, etc.
Second that ☝️
This is a video about Israeli Arabs. Druze and Bedouin don't often identify as such.
@@hunterfabio
Bedouins do
You have no idea what you are talking about
@@hunterfabioI am Druze, we do identify if asked.
Very illuminating, and sad, that the one gentleman who was asked whether Hamas was a barrier to peace hedged the question and stated he didn’t know what was Hamas. Even Arab Israelis are intimidated by Hamas and its supporters. But he is NOT intimidated by the Israeli government. He felt very comfortable in openly criticising the Israeli government. Hmmm.
you are jumping to conclusions that he is afraid , israel is much much more poweful than hamas and they call the shots
You people are so delusional to the point that you’re literally putting words in peoples mouths that have not a single semblance to what they actually said. The second man specifically said he feels intimidated by the current government and their racist remarks toward Arabs and arming settlers in the West Bank. Yet you’re here stating that he’s actually afraid of Hamas and not the Israeli government? You suffer a special kind of delusional my dear
@@dianalee1589 he didnt even want to mention Hamas by name… did we watch the same video?
He saw 30 thousand of his people killed by his “army” and ur too upset about his statements? Lol
Respect to you. You have to have a lot of confrontations I couldn’t handle, and do a well balance of opinions. Its refreshing
Apart from the first woman, What I’m still hearing is their refusal to say that Hamas caused this, but quick to blame the government. How is October 7 a symbol of peace? Where are the flowers from Hamas? I also don’t feel good that Israeli citizens are being given guns in parts of Judea and Samaria but I can see why they would want to following the attack.
The "action" of October 7, 2023, is natural, according to their Islamic reason and values, while Israel's response to that "action" is unacceptable and a "genocide" for the Islamic world and the useful idiots of the Islamic world.
There are two cultures, Islamic and Judeo-Christian, which have diametrically opposed principles and norms as their foundation. You can never harmonize them.
judea and samaria? just how much are you brainwashed
@@theoutsider078 West Bank is an ancient Palestinian name.
she is scared of hamas
@@wildwomanofthewoods nope and jesus was a jew and bethaham is in west bank ald pals are just ancient tribes that king david fought againt and even today they not all the same tribes in west bank or gaza so they not even ethicly the same people
They all say how they feel AFTER October 7th. But not one of them will tell you what he felt on October 7th. It’s as if there is October 6th and October 8th. And October 7 disappeared somewhere. I would like to ask the Israeli Arabs: how did they feel on October 7?
Well I am an arab and I felt disgusted by what happened on oct 7. Are you happy ?
@@lollmao249 I cannot be happy about anything related to October 7th. However, words of sympathy are a little comforting. It's a pity that you did not participate in this survey.
@@user-hc9qg5ib3v I am a human with a lot of empathy and my empathy isn't for one groupe of people it's for everybody. I cry every innocent life be it israeli arab chinese whatever. I doubt you would do the same. The audacity of you to want to label us arabs as people without empathy is mindblowing. You seriously need to go and question yourself. For real
@@lollmao249 Where did you read that I branded all Arabs, Chinese, Russians or anyone else as people without empathy? I watched the video and my reaction concerns the people in this video. But I didn’t even say about them that they lack empathy. I said that not one of them spoke about what happened on October 7 and did not express sympathy out loud about it. Perhaps I missed something, name a minute in this video where this is not the case.
@@user-hc9qg5ib3v the question that was directed to them is how THEY feel AFTER oct 7th not what they felt watching what happened to innocent lifes during oct 7th. And by the way oct 7th is still going until this minute right now, except that the people involved aren't israelis but palestinians. Sad
The Arab Israeli at the end- “I rather live in Israel than in an Arab country” that should tell you everything!
At 4:31 He said the people of Gaza live under occupation for 75 years. First of all, Egypt controlled Gaza from 1948 to 1967, then Israel regained controll in 1967 and left in 2005, even taking their dead with them.
Gaza was NEVER occupied by Israel. It became Israeli land on May 14th, 1948 under the International Law of Uti Possidetis Juris. This states that a new country takes the borders of the last top-level political entity that was in that land, in the case of Israel, that was the Mandate of Palestine. The Mandate of Palestine include the lands of Gaza as well as the West Bank.
There has been no Israeli presence inside Gaza from 2005. There was never any occupation.
"It became Israeli land on May 14th, 1948"
And the people living there became Israeli citizens (like the people in this video), right? Right?
are u there inside gaza? to say that?
It’s not 75 of occupation in Gaza but it’s , 57 years , from 1967 until now it’s occupied, yes Israel left it in 2005 but there is still a control of everything literally , Israel didn’t allow us to build port or airport , or benefit from the gaz in Gaza sea , and during every war siege and collective punishment for all my people
@ahmadhusam6078
Take some responsibility for what you have done there!
Hamas was voted in. They walked away from the peace process. Sanctions from EU.
Turned it into a missile launching ground. Built tunnels instead of an economy
Billions wasted, global welfare for generations that other refugees dont get.
Squandered the opportunity to govern yourselves and still pointing the finger.
@@silentiumestaureum1Gaza was then colonized by Egypt, but it was still legally Israeli land. There was no claim by Egypt for this land other than a colony. Israel reclaimed the land in 1967 and considered it as "Disputed Territories". Israel settled no land claims for the Disputed Territories and made nobody citizens.
The man stood there and said he doesn't know Hamas. What a gaslighter. All of these people claim they are scared of Jews. But seems to me they are more scared of being seen speaking honestly about Hamas and what they did on October 7 which sparked this present round of war.
I suspect he was afraid to criticize Hamas. He wasn’t trying to gaslight anyone, he just didn’t want to endanger his life or his family.
I have personally seen videos on social media of IDF soldiers storming into arab businesses and demanding to search through their phones, searching for any sort of evidence of sympathy towards Gazans.
Have also heard of other reports of Palestinians outside of Gaza getting into trouble for showing any sympathy towards what’s happening in Gaza.
So I am not at all surprised that this guy isn’t displaying too much of an opinion on Hamas because there’s a huge chance he or his family could
Get into trouble by the spawns of satan that are the IOF.
The IDF killed 17k people in Lebanon and 14k children in Gaza. Only a fool wouldnt fear them. They killed their own hostages and over 100 journalists. Nurses, newsreporters, children, women, Aid workers, disabled, babies, elderly, foreigners have all been killed by the IDF. Most rational people will fear them.
After October 7th, he don't know what is Hamas 5:15
He defends Hamas
For all of those who feel bad, it happens few times before, when there is tension between Palestinians and Israelis, there is tension between Arab Israelis and Jewish Israelis, but after things chill a bit, life becomes normal again, i think that Arab Israelis doing great mistake that through out the years, they many of them don’t stand 100% by Israel, because id they will, the Jewish population won’t be afraid of them, and the relations will be better, like the Arab Druze Israelis, and Jewish Israelis are very good friends and have 0 tensions, because the Druze community shows that they stand by Israel.
It's hard for them to stand by Israel when people like Ben-Gvir and Smotrich are in the government.
Y should they stand 100% with Israel when Israel has never stood 100% with them? U expel my family and expect me to stand with u? LOL!
@@deficrypto1234 the state of Israel did stand 100% if them, in terms of opportunity security and education, that’s what a state should provide to its citizens, and we didn’t ”expelled” your family, it’s estimated that around 50,000-70,000 Palestinians were actively expelled in the Nakba, the rest fled in fear of have been told by invading Arab armies to leave, the issue of the Palestinian refugee problem is because Israel refused to take all the refugees back when the war ended, and justifiably so, if the Israel would take back all the refugees, Israel was not a state today, I will add that Israel did a mistake that it didn’t expelled all the Palestinians from Gaza and the West Bank back then, because if all of them were expelled, today i can say that it will be the moral choice to do, because they could have a better life and die less, and many many wars would have been avoided, of course today i am not in favor of expelling them, but if they did it in 48, our situation would be much much much better, for the Palestinians, for Israeli Arabs, and for Israeli Jews.
@@deficrypto1234 as i Jewish Israeli, we would never understand Arab grievances over land, you care enormously about land, a million Jews were expelled from Middle Eastern countries and nobody cares, we care for people, Arabs care for land, that’s how i feel.
Their total LACK of accountability for hamas speaks volumes, I see why Ben Gvir says the stuff he says.
They’re already designated by the world as a terrorist organization and criminals but no accountability for the Israeli government which by records and for decades did waaaaaaaay worse
What occupation existed before Hamas. Look up the nakba. Ben gvir idolized a serial killer that killed 29 Muslim worshippers in 1994. Biggot
@@KK-up2rmnakba is when all arab countries attacked israel on its first day and told the people to leave so they get rid of the je ws and it backfired?
@@viosh7137 Small-scale local skirmishes began on 30 November and gradually escalated until March 1948. The war started may 1948. Damn you are autistic
The arab israeli know that they are safe in Israel and have equality. They cannot admit it for fear of being treated as a traitor by their brothers in Palestine.
If Israel were to fall, those Israeli Arabs would turn on the Jews to prove to their brothers, their solidarity to save themselves and even turn on their fellow Arabs who collaborated with the Jews.
there is a big difference with those who live in israel and those who live in gaza
i watched a video last year where a israel arab said her uncle in west bank threatened to kill her and her mother because they did something he didnt like
israeli arabs are free while in gaza or west bank they not in a country of free thought
Cant admit it = maybe they do quietly support october 7th.
@@dogbert52not all but I'm sure there is.Jews must have eyes everywhere. What a life
So you basically don’t believe them even when they literally say “we are not equals”. What a shame.
Why is that none of them acknowledged what happened on Oct 7?
Oct 7? Isn't that a shawarma place in Jordan? Hamas, what is Hamas? You mean hummus?
Most of them support the attacks. Just because they are Israeli citizens doesn’t mean they care about Israel or Israeli Jews.
@@poppothepug2211what the F are you talking about
Because that wasn't the question.
@@Amygdala233 Haven't we been watching the same clip?
"There must be peace, peace is only 5 letters. It's not difficult to do peace."
Strong point, however, Hamas has only 4 letters.
War has only 3.
Maybe the background is a bit more complex.
The last guy should check how the Saudis raged the oil war against the US. Didn't seem very "under the shoe".
I am an Ashkenazi Jew. The last interview the old man looks like my grandfather's twin. I've watched it many times. Jews are native to Israel and it may be that some Palestinians have a lot of Jewish blood.
Same. And the second man looks like my dad’s twin
And vice versa
I was thinking the same thing! He looks so much like my own Jewish grandfather.
Then you are Khazarian.
The irony is both are like cousins. Many Palestinians were actually Jewish who converted long ago. Genetic studies even stated Jews and Palestinians are closer to each other than diaspora Jews to their host countries. I'm just an outsider but it truly saddens me to see both sides keep fighting when you should be getting along. I pray for peace will come soon.
Great video. Make more about arab israeli. Very interessting
They are afraid of Hamas and the opinion of the Arabs in the world, they are in a very difficult place.
Nah more like the Israeli government that hates Arabs
Should they fear the IDF who killed 17k people in Lebanon, who killed 14k people in Gaza and over 100 Journalists?
He blames the government but can’t say anything about Hamas. He hasn’t heard of it.
lol
Excatly, and Gazans want peace!!
who has all the power? who has all the weapons? who controls all the borders, the comms, the airspace, the waters, the electromagnetic sphere?
@@yansideabacoa6257
i wonder why? 🤔
Gaza actually had a better standard of living than many nearby Arab cities.
Gazans should have had Chinese neighbours. Started five wars.... billions in welfare. Build infrastructure for war instead of developing an economy.
@@yansideabacoa6257 if Hamas controlled it there would not be one Jew alive.
So better Israel as they acted much more responsibly
But the borders are controlled by Egypt and Jordan too
@@aupti Europeans and North Africans don’t belong in Palestine
I feel so awful for the average Arab Israelis, because this is real how Jewish Israelis are now scared of their Arab neighbors. I talked to a Jew who had been in Israel during October 7th and they said that they had an Arab who helped with a family member who was disabled, and they had been fine with them. But then after October 7th, they're now scared of this Arab who they had known for so long. And honestly? I'm not Israeli, I'm American, but I openly admit that I've become scared of Arabs here in the US since October 7th, too...I hate to say it, but it's true. And I can imagine it's so much worse in Israel. Fear is a powerful and dangerous thing. I pray for a day when that fear is gone and we can all just live in peace together.
U talk to much
Just come visit and see for your self
So if 1200 people are killed and Israeli Jews are scare, should Israeli Arabs be scared of Israeli Jews who have killed 100k Arabs since 48?
Ameen but God-fearing Arab will not harrass you - in fact, they will protect you
The problem is not knowing which is which
@@merouby The ones to fear are Isreali Jews who recently killed 14k children.
Really, after Oct 7th. I view Jews very differently. I should say Zionists. Israel is populated by the most vile and hateful people on earth. They are truly frightening. Lying about rapes and beheaded babies to gin up support. Wasn’t the attack on those young concert goers enough? That was horrific. What is happening to Palestinians is genocide. I’m an American and would never visit Israel out of fear of great bodily harm.
It hasn't even been a year since October 7th. We don't know the longterm effects that the Simcha Torah Massacre will have on either Israeli society or Palestinian society.
what lies Israeli arabs can go anywhwere they want unharmed, its the israeli Jews who risk their life if they go to arab villages and neighborhoods. Never miss the chance to play the victim
What do you mean? Thirteen thousand children have been murdered, a genocide is taking place, what's to understand?
@@vanessac1965there’s no genocide
@vanessac1965 what do u consider a genocide, concentration camps cause Gaza has been cut off from the rest of the world
@@Jessman15 go cry to Egypt.
You should just ask in Hebrew and add the subtitles. Even when the person you are interviewing can understand and speak some English, the answers are much less articulate when they are using a foreign language
Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, it is a lie to suggest Gaza was under occupation on 7th October in 2023.
It was under a siege
That's worse than occupation
The gaza strip was described as unlivable by the UN nd that's way before the war.
If Israel didn't control everything in Gaza, there wouldnt have been a revolution. Blame it on your self.
The guy with glasses said: "we are not leaving...we are almost equal...it is a democracy". Things do not add up.. 🤔
only to people that dont live in the middle east..
Why does it not add up. Equal under the law, and equal in society are two different things. There is discrimination. Its not legal. Like sexism, ageism, etc. It exists.
@@happinin07
Israeli Arabs have better benefits than Israeli Jews. They get an advantage when in School they are admitted to colleges and get Scholarships that Jews don’t and they don’t have to serve in the Army if they don’t want to. And edit he says that he can’t write what he wants. Neither can you or I. Canada just implemented a law saying they can lock you up for life for something that you said.
@@happinin07 Arabs are not equal under the law. Israel's Basic Law states that only Jews have the right to self-determination. Israel's Law of Return only grants the right of return to Jews. Those are just 2 examples where Arabs, or any gentiles for that matter, are not equal under the law. Israel is an ethnocracy not a democracy.
@@tellthetruthna8523 Basic Law States are the same for Arabs and Jews, law of return is something else that's for sure, but I'd love to see a single Jewish Doctor, University teacher or Politician in any arab country. Just one of each.
It’s interesting to me that an Arab woman in Israel traveling freely says she’s concerned of her safety. She’s driving around by herself, obviously not as scared as she vocalizes. Also, in Gaza she wouldn’t be able to drive around freely, as women have travel restrictions and need a male chaperone to travel.
You don't understand if you are Jewish ,Jews can be very extreme also in their behavior toward arabs
It is a reasonable concern given the events that happened back in 2020.
Yeah i know all Palestinian have travel restrictions under tge occupation. You the checkpoints…
Starting around 5:36 the subtitles say "Lufti Tira." Is that the author's name? Is there anyway to link to a public profile/website of his writings? I think his view is very interesting and would love to read more.
Lufti is his name, Tira is the name of the town where he was interviewed.
Quote of senior PLO Leader Zuheir Mohsen:
"The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians, and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct “Palestinian people” to oppose Zionism.
Once we have acquired all our rights in all of Palestine, we must not delay for a moment the reunification of Jordan and Palestine.
Zuheir Mohsen (1936 - 25 July 1979) Palestinian leader of the Syria-controlled as-Sa'iqa faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization
Opposing Zionism sounds like a great cause to follow ;-)
That's standard Pan-Arabist boilerplate. It's really not helping your case.
And you really think if Israel was destroyed and a "palestinian" state would be established as the Arabs wish, Jordan and "palestine" won't unite?@@brianhanssens7996
You lack the context of panarabism and how politics were for decades in the middle east.
If I said I'm Tunisian and feel like I am close to other north africans and that our identity is made up post colonialism, does that mean I should give up my homeland to foreigners and just go live in Algeria? This is so stupid
If the land you are sitting on was stolen in the first place (even the Quran acknowledges the LAND OF ISRAEL to belong to the Jews and not to the Arabs)
and you start a war trying to kill others, don't cry after you lose lands @@Youssef0120
To all the al Jazeera fans in here...if only you wouldn't take democracy and freedom for granted...
today double antisemitic standards are trend
today double antisemitic standards is trendy
Driving a 300k$ car and wears closes she can only wear in Israel in the middle east, says she feels unsafe
Racism is rampant in Israel. I've heard Israelis say the Arab Israelis better not make a wrong move or else. What kind of threat is that?? Who cares what she wears or drives. Israel isn't the only one who allows clothes and nice cars.
You look jealous
I didn't notice her clothing in particular but was thinking the same thing about the car.
“Closes she can only wear in Israel”, are you living under a rock?
I advise you check out countries like Lebanon and the UAE and you can have a good look at how the women dress there 🤣
how the f*k do you know how much her car worth? lol are you jealous of her hard earned car? or you think she stole it like your grandfathers stole the land?
Thank you for these interviews.
It's really jarring how Israeli Arabs in general and Israeli Muslims in particular are treated. As an Israeli, I can say racism against them is everywhere, and not enough is being done to fight it.
אחי זה שיש אפליה נגד ערבים זה נטו בגלל העניין של ה"לאומנות הפלסטינית",אין בעיה באופן בסיסי עם ערבים,אבל אני אגיד לך ככה שערבים הבעיה שביחס לאוכלוסייה יש הרבה מאוד בעיות שגורמות לאפליה נגדם,וזה שמאשימים כל יהודי שטוען דבר כזה או אחר נגד מגזר מסויים זה לא קורה סתם,הלאומנים שביניהם גורמים נזק לכולם
וגם אגב אין לך מושג בכלל כמה ערבים גזענים יש,לא רק נגדם,יש גם להפך,יש כאלה שיסתכלו עלייך כיהודי לפני שיסתכלו עלייך כבנאדם זה גם חלק מהשורש של הבעיה
Racism abounds world wide no matter what race you are
True. But also there are a lot of groups in Israel that work with kids and adults, in shared activities that help to breakdown stereotypes, and build bonds. You can donate, send your kids, promote them. :)
What i usually hear from Jewish zionists is "arabs and jews in israel have the same rights so theres no problem" but without missing a beat, they go on to talk about the rise of antisemitism in western democracies where jews have the same rights as everybody else and how seriously we must take this issue.
Corey, there is a technology called microphone which I think you should employ.
as we see, Israeli Arabs are strikingly different from the residents of Gaza
and this is probably why they suffer the most mentally, although physically they are safe
Probably, the Israeli government should more actively involve Israeli Arabs in anti-terrorist propaganda among the residents of Gaza, showing what their peaceful life could be like if they abandoned the armed struggle for fictitious goals - terrorism against random civilians actually only delays the creation of a full-fledged Palestinian state
(in my opinion, Arabs, of course, have the right to fight for the creation of their own state or respect for their rights, but using adequate political methods)
Thank you Corey keep it up
Really interesting perspective from the last man at the end
He made zero sense. Establish a Palestinian state, but at the same time he plays victim in Israel, yet he would want to stay in Israel 😂 ZERO sense
Yeah, all arab and muslim countries are occupied 😂
Make it make sense please.
Complete and utter nonsense and i'm not surprised to hear it at all.
He is one of the elites and lives a far better life than most people, including israeli jews, yet he uses a victim card and extends it to all arab and muslim states.
It resembles hearing a 15 year old that hasn't worked a day in his life talk about struggles of humanity.
(Gretta? Hmmmmm....)
Well, what he says is basically that USA and israel are really controlling the whole middle east. Which is evident because what the Arabic governments are doing certainly does not reflect the will of the people. So, for him actually staying in his land and hoping for the best is the best he can do to resist the Z project.
So to him basically the Z project is the problem and when the israelis drop it there will be peace. He didn't say that but I believe this is his opinion.
Love this we need more Palestinians like the first lady
None of the people interviewed blamed Hamas or any terrorists. Very eye opening.
Who killed palestinians Hamas or tsahal ?
Were they asked to Blame Hamas? I blame Israel. No Siege, no Oct 7th.
Did these two interviewed gentlemen have any point of view regarding the "action" of the Palestinians on October 7, 2023?
It would be interesting if they had.
Conveniently not mentioned, very odd
I will tell you my opinion as a Palestinian, and this is the opinion of literally everyone I know. We support any Palestinian resistance that targets Israeli soldiers because there is not a single one of us who has not suffered because of them. I lost my friend and my uncle and they returned my uncle’s body to us after they stole all his organs. He was just a doctor. My friend lost his sons. His two uncles (and this is not in Gaza in the West Bank), my friends in the refugee camp are still suffering due to their grandparents’ loss of their lands, property, and wealth, in 1948. Most of them had their economic conditions improved when they came here, but they will suffer to own the basics of their lives in the future, such as land or a house. Because the salaries are low and they did not receive anything from their families, as happened to me. However, salaries are not a guaranteed thing because the Israeli government controls everything, and now I, as an employee of the Palestinian government, have not received my full salary since the beginning of the war, due to the accumulation of all these circumstances. The desire to join the Palestinian resistance and carry Weapons are increasing among young people, especially in refugee camps, but I can say that more than 80% of us refuse to kill or kidnap any civilian, so I am personally against targeting civilians that happened on October 7, but seeing the crimes of Zionist soldiers makes this situation worse, if it were The Israeli government has a real desire to achieve peace. They must implement all the terms of the Oslo Accords at a minimum. They only took advantage of the stupid concessions made by our government and did not implement anything in our favor in that agreement.
@@ahmadhusam6078 I have all the compassion as a human being for any victim, for any injustice, committed by someone against an innocent person. Not your case. But here are the causes, the data that, for the most part, generated this situation today.
Many Arab leaders had declared, in various circumstances, that their objective was to drive the Jews out of Palestine, but when the Egyptian leader Gamal Abdel al Nasser, with all the prestige he had, declared that his country was aiming for nothing more and nothing less than liquidation to the state of Israel, the impact was quite different. In general, experts appreciate that the outbreak of the Six-Day War, in June 1967, was the result of a long series of mistakes made by Nasser. Two of these in particular were likely to convince the Israelis that Nasser was serious when he referred to the liquidation of Israel.
In early 1967, tensions between Israel and its Arab neighbors were high. Egypt, led by President Gamal Abdel Nasser, closed the Straits of Tiran, thus blocking Israel's access to the Red Sea. Nasser also moved Egyptian troops to the Sinai Peninsula on the border with Israel. These actions created a sense of crisis and imminent threat. The intelligence services have warned of the danger.
On June 5, 1967, Israel launched Operation Focus, a massive air attack on Egyptian air bases. In a matter of hours, almost the entire Egyptian air force was destroyed on its runways. This attack opened the way for a massive land offensive against Egypt in the Sinai Peninsula.
After Jordan began bombing West Jerusalem, Israeli forces counterattacked and initiated a series of operations to capture East Jerusalem and the West Bank. By the end of the war, Israel controlled the entire city of Jerusalem and the West Bank, including the historic city of Hebron.
A large-scale ground operation was initiated by Israel in the Sinai Peninsula immediately after Operation Focus. The Israeli forces advanced quickly, defeating the Egyptian army and reaching the Suez Canal within days.
After Syrian forces bombarded Israeli territory in the Golan Heights, Israel launched a ground offensive to capture this strategic area. Within days, the Golan Heights were under Israeli control, giving Israel a high and lasting strategic position vis-à-vis Syria.
OPERATION PLESHET
This was an operation intended to capture the Gaza Strip from Egypt. It paralleled the advance into the Sinai Peninsula and was successfully completed, adding another disputed territory to Israel's list of territorial gains.
GEOPOLITICAL CONSEQUENCES
At the end of the war, the map of the Middle East changed dramatically. Israel gained control over strategic territories: the Sinai Peninsula, Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights. These gains gave Israel a military and strategic advantage, but also complicated its relations with the Arab community and the Palestinians, intensifying the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that persists to this day. The Six-Day War was a turning point in the history and geopolitics of the East Middle.
In just six days, Israel managed to shift the balance of power in the region in its favor, but at the cost of intensifying tensions and conflicts that persist to this day. Analysis of this war shows the complexity and fragility of relations between states in the Middle East and highlights the long-term impact of military and political decisions in a region marked by instability.
Your Palestinian-Jewish problem, on an interhuman level, will never have a reasonable end as long as the two Semites exist on earth. It is in human nature. You have a vendetta of about 2500 years. Hard to believe that you will ever find a modus vivendi.
Cynical, but fair and realistic, you reap what you sow. Why was that stupid and dishonorable attack needed for honest people? Whose game did you make deliberately or not?
@@ahmadhusam6078i hope israel will learn from its neighbours on how to treat minorities.
@@dogbert52 who do you mean by that??
ask them if they condemn hamas’s actions:)
They just can't trust everybody at this timebof war because you don't know who is who.
I have worked with a lot of Israeli Arabs and a lot of Mizrahi Jews and Spanish Jews. To be honest I could hardly ever point to one and say they were this and another and say they were that. I would have to say that I found the Mizrahim to be far more Nationalistic.
I mean with enemies like Iran you shouldnt be too not nationalistic. Also the holocaust i know its hard to realize what that does with u. And maybe like 10000 wars. Is it still as weird?
@@viosh7137yea it is when nationalism means weaponising one side of civilians only while the other feels terrified for their lives, common sense
@@liaa4172 the one exploding busses and themselves are terrified?
@@viosh7137 the ones legally weaponised and raised with
racism & supremacy are terrified?
Also u just admitted you view ALL arabs even israeli citizens as ur enemy but u wanna talk about being the peaceful side lmfao
@@liaa4172 u havent been there so find someone else to hate israel with
As an Israeli I fell that our hart were broken and most people no longer believe in peace, some are even more right wing and radical because politicians using the fear of the people.. also as a left wing that believes in the 2 state solution I’m feeling that the all world will hate us anyway.. because in October 7 before the war even started people were on the streets shouting against Israel, people say it is justified to ki**and ra**so I feel also betrayed and misunderstood by the world and human rights groups..hope for a better future
Ye well Palestinians has that since 70+ years.. so good that you start to feel something.
@@YTFreePalestine we are not terrorizing. You are part of the problem
@@dolev7839 Yes you are terrorizing you just dont care when it happens to them
I cant see how any Israeli after the 7th of October seeing the west bank videos of Corey can still believes in the 2 state solution.
@flowapowa4307 I can't believe for 70+ years of occupation/ethnic cleaning /apartheid/ racism and some Palestinians still think of peace.. that's amazing.
Israelí soldiers are responsable for their rifles 24 hours. It’s normal in Israel to see a 19 year old woman in a party dress with a rifle strapped on her back.
This video really shows the apartheid. Everyone is a poor citizen which feels unsafe and they have a lot of self criticism about their Arab culture.
Poor? You should definitely watch many more of Corey's interviews.
As they should. If i had that culture i would question everything.
What snakes - especially the second guy. Says peace is being destroyed by two Israeli gov ministers (who are not even in the war cabinet), but when Hamas is brought up? "I don't know what Hamas is". Snake.
God gave us the land, the non Jews can move to Europe, pray for us ♥️🙏
pray for the 1000s of innocent children and women in israeli prisons just as much
@@xxhorrorpunkxx There are no Palestinians under the age of 14 in Israeli prisons and those 14 and up minors are not innocent. They were brainwashed to hate and tried, sometimes even succeeded to kill Jews. Many of those incidents were captured on street cams and such, yet still Qatari funded Al Jazeera and pro Palestinian influencers on social media claimed they were innocent.
Here’s a crazy idea, let’s pray for peace and freedom from oppression and violence for all people.
lmao, there are less than a hundred jailed Palestinians and they are all terrorists@@xxhorrorpunkxx
@@Moss_Pillows true. i agree.
The problem of asking people is, they create their own reality. And put everyones reality together in one context is pure chaos. Thats why facts are better than opinions.
Thank you for this exciting and interesting contribution. I have the uneasy feeling that, especially since the last conflict, a constructive public exchange between the groups involved is not possible or desired. I therefore consider your videos to be useful because at least all groups can express their concerns, fears and wishes in the hope that a positive conversation can arise with one another. That is what I hope...
I’m an Israeli Jew who voted for Ayman Odeh in the previous elections. However, some of the other MPs of that party have disappointed me and I won’t vote for them again, until they unequivocally condemn modern antisemitism, condemn Hamas, and clarify their stance on Jewish sovereign state in 67 borders for-ever.
Only then I will continue to support them. Obviously Ben Gvir and Smotrich are worse but people need to become aware of what they have to change and stop blaming the lunatics from the other side . And there are plenty in both .
Out of curiosity, how are you leaning towards in the next election?
Why on earth did you vote for Ayman Odeh? I'm an Israeli Arab and their politics are horrible, as you've seen.
Unfortunately many Israeli Arabs don't have proper representation, especially secular ones like me.
I usually just vote for one of the left leaning Jewish majority parties.
I'm not the biggest fan of them either. But they're much better than the right like Ben gvir and smotrich.
I am pro-Odeh too, the policy that forced Odeh to coalition with Arab Nationalist parties was horrible. The UAL is a hodge-podge of ideologies at this point.
🤦🏻♀️
אמיתי בן גביר גרוע יותר מבן אדם שרוצה להעיף את כל העם שלך מכאן?
אתה צריך עזרה פסיכיאטרית אם עוד לא קלטת שמי שמהלל שאהידים, לא אכפת לו אם אתה שמאלני או ימני, בהינתן הבחירה הוא מחסל את כולנו.
כל אדם שפוי היה מעדיף פסיכי שרוצה לחסל את האויבים שלו(בן גביר), על פסיכי שרוצה לחסל את העם שלו.
תהיה בריא.
Interested to hear your reasoning for voting for Odeh specifically. As an Israeli Arab, I find Abbas the better option.
I like how the first woman can't specify ANYTHING specific for why she is afraid. No one stopped her, no one did anything to her... she is still driving her car, going to work, getting with her friends, etc... So this is just based on her own feelings. Huh? What is odd is that EVERYONE IGNORES THAT IS IT HAMAS GAZANS WHO DID OCTOBER 7TH. Why do people ignore this????? The second guy literally says "I don't know what is Hamas". ARE YOU KIDDING ME??!!! He's bold-face lying. You CANNOT be living in Israel and not know who Hamas is. That is just plain stupid.
Gurl shut up RESPECTFULLY. IT DIDNT START OCTOBER 7th
If you believe that then you’re plain stupid and dumb.
@@layan808i love how thats the argument u had to add to your og comment.
No one ignores Hamas commited atrocities on October 7th. However, Hamas arose due the to the brutal killings of the IDF.
@@deficrypto1234 egg and chicken
The lady has more knowledge, the other two men live in a different world.
the lady asking the questions seems a bit confused, she keeps asking about peace inside of israel which makes the questions unclear, whether she reffers to israel and gaza or israeli jews and israeli arabs, which in the latter's context the word peace doesn't fit because there's no war.
It upsets me that these people who clearly have good hearts would not say that Hamas is the problemed counter-part in a search for peace.
How about the occupation being the problem? How about the racism, that even a blind person can see, in the Israeli government being the problem?
Maybe they arent good hearted?
Hamas and the Palestinians being carpet bombed and starved don't want peace? What about your fucking right wing ultra racist government?
@@dogbert52 sometimes people come from different backgrounds, or possibly the truth is too hard to bear. Some could say the same about my people too. There are many ways to view the world, but intention is what defines a good heart.
Maybe because Khamas isn’t the problem, the problem is the establishment of the Zionist entity called IsraHell over the Palestinian land? Maybe because those Zionists killed and are still killing the native people of Palestine and steal their lands?
Its amazing each and every arab saying 75 years if occupation forgeting west bank wost jordanian and Gaza was Egyptian for 20 years... 20 years that those govs didn't gave them a state...and then 30 years (Gaza) of "occupation" and 20 years of sovereignty in which the so called victims chose Hamas...
Gaza wasnt Egyptian. Egypt never occupied or annexed Gaza. Stop lying. Give who a state?Wt 20 years of sovereignty? It never happened.
You're a good man, Corey.
I like how the second guy said it was the government and not the Jews. He's absolutely right.
Most Jewish Israelis agree with their government with respect to the "war" on Gaza. They can deny it all they like but the Israeli government is a reflection of the people. Netanyahu is the longest serving PM in Israeli history. That is not an accident. That Arab guy knows it too. He was just afraid to say it.
@@tellthetruthna8523 Most is not all.
@@Jotari Which is why I did not write "all." The percentage that doesn't support it is small, however.
@@tellthetruthna8523 Yes, and it's important to not refer to the whole group as unitary in its thinking. He's right. It is the government doing it. It's a democratically elected government, sure, but it is the government and not a one brush all people. Such language and making their cause synonymous with Jews, or even Israelis, is precisely what the Zionists want to drive their ethnocentric philosophy.
@@Jotari Why so triggered? Most Israeli Jews are Zionists.
The second man, doesn't know who Hamas is? Gazans want peace?
Really can someone actually be that genuinely that uniformed? Seems incredibly dishonest.
Hamas what is Hamas? I don't know. You mean hummus? 7 Oct, isn't that a shawarma place in Jordan?
He probably just didn't want to get into a political discussion. A lot of Arabs are questioned about whether they condemn Hamas a lot especially if they wish for an end to the war, so he probably evaded that topic. He seemed to want to stick to the general idea of peace. Of course Gazans want peace. Peace means an end to the occupation/control of their resources. So technically there is never a time of "peace" in the Palestinian territories.
@@LilaFreakkif they want peace they should stop acting as if they want the opposite. Starting this thing was really not peaceful so what you are saying makes absolutely no sense
He's saying what do you *mean* by "Hamas", like some people use the term more loosely than they should, and also "Hamas" is changing as a concept right now. But yes he was dodging the question it's become a common way of weaseling out of talking about Hamas. All the people of Palestine (Jews, Druze, Muslim, Christian, Atheist) have been trained since birth in the art of debate.
@@Amygdala233 The entire population of Gaza was not responsible for the oct 7 attack. Leading up to that point, the state of Israel killed more Palestinians that year that any other year. 2023 was insane. I don't condone it whatsoever it's horrible, but what I'm saying is the state of Israel hasn't acted very peacefully either and they're the one in power and therefore have the power to change things. But nope just same old violent occupation and human rights violations and then a terrible retaliation and now this war. The Palestinians are not solely responsible for this.
The fact that these guys talk about the government but not about hammas is absurd. "Its possible to make peace but the israeli givernment doesnt want peace". Yeah right like hammas marched peacefully into israel to prove that.
The fuck do they have to do with hamas? the Israeli government is the government that they are under.
These people and their families probably never had any encounter with the political entity as eretz israel is the only land they've ever known, not gazq nor thr west Bank.
Weird ass comment, quit trying to put collective guilt on our kind
That uncle rant at the end 😭😭
סליחה? -כן. אני היחיד המומה מהתשובות של הערבים שנשאלו?
הגברת שמסבירה כל כך מפחד כשהיא רואה יהודים עם רובים בצפון?
האם היא אי פעם שאלה את עצמה למה הם צריכים לשאת אקדח?
האיש שאומר שהיהודים לא רוצים שלום?
במקום לתמוך בנו הם מתלוננים על תנאי החיים שלהם שהם מהגבוהים במזרח התיכון.
אתה ממשיך להסתכל על הסכסוך כמו מערביים ,הנאיביות....
How come none of them condemns terrorism?
Now ask the same to any Druze and you will see the great difference in the answers. 🇸🇨🇮🇱🤝
Druze are “loyal to the state” find a Druze in Lebanon and he/she would say free Palestine 🇵🇸. Majority of Druze live in Arab countries like Lebanon and Syria genius
Yes, they are very loyal. But I'm not sure about "Free Palestine". Druze from different countries speak to one another. My understanding is that there isn't strong support for Hezbollah or Hamas in those regions, at least along the border regions. Being patriotic does not automatically mean supporting total Arab control of the region. My two cents. @@KK-up2rm
@@KK-up2rmwow its almost like they wanna ruin more places with that culture not only Libanon and Syria
@@happinin07 Hamas does not represent Palestine. It is the PLO. And free Palestine means freedom and no occupation. I have Druze Lebanese friends
@@viosh7137 what are talking about. Commenting like a fool and nothing to do then watch UA-cam apparently
I think the quality of the video was quite bad and the questions were uncertain.
Politically correct questions. 🤣
The lady needs to make her questions more coherent
Thank you for a different perspective
Important question to ask, but I am always puzzled by his none representative sample of the Palestinians living in Israel. Let along the specific age group he is sampling.
He’s interviewed plenty of young and old people. Living in Israel or West Bank… students… entrepreneurs. Everything.
They're not "palestinians living in Israel". They're Arab-Israelis.
@@shaikatz3816they are Palestinians bc there was no Israel until 1948.
Minute 5:30... He says: I dont know what is Hamas. Really? You dont? You have no idea what they did? Who they are? What thwy stand for?? Really?. In reality this opinion this guy is very key to understand the situation.. which is.. the arabs want peace when they are losing. Shame on this guy shame of everyone like them.
Arabs speaking Hebrew seem to be speaking in Arabic or some kind of ancient Hebrew. For example they use the Arabic pharyngeal letters ح( h'a) and ع ( a'in) and the imala of the أ (alif sounding like ae) which we never hear with other Hebrew speakers which would say ha, a, and aa for these letters.
For anyone who is gonna post something here after me: Can you please make it on the issue of this video and leave your other agendas for one minute! Also, thanks Corey
@@OriginalOogwaythat's sad that you too are being effected by the evil of Hamas
@@SnowsStorm1 Why wouldn’t the Israeli Arabs feel safe? These two interviewed were blaming the Jewish government- which sounded like more of the same. Has any Jew ever attacked them with knives in the street, or shot them while sitting in their cars? No! Now please tell me a nation where a Jew could terrorize a nation and remain untouched.
Sir...have you...like....read your own agenda written by you in your comment? 😅
Say what you want, but you can't try to control an entire comment section just because you are annoyed by what other people might comment that is still relevant to the broader context of the video and the reality we live in. Just saying... 🤷🏻♀️
@@OriginalOogway No he didn't, what's been deleted was deleted by the youtube algorithm. My dude literally posted a video about the subject, and you think he deleted comments that support his video? You're not very sharp, are you?
@@jessicaferrari3987 I am not controlling anyone, just asking
the last elderly person is totally confused... he speaks about discrimination, but he forgot to mention the POSITIVE discrimination. He knows that Israel is the only democratic state in the area, and he is happy to live here (obviously!), but he also believes that the IDF shoots at hungry Gazans...
they literally do
Can't it be both? Can Israel be democratic and yet should at Palestinian kids? Are they mutually exclusive propositions?
It was literally the IDF that shot Palestinians trying to get food.
They said it themselves that they were there with the aid trucks.
Stop bending the truth! It was not Hamas!! You are infuriating. Both of you. One that seems to have missed all the latest news and one that just lies wihout shame. Bravo!
@@jessicaferrari3987most were killed by the stampede and being run over by aid trucks that were NOT driven by Israelis. The IDF shot gunshots into the air to disburse the crowd, and at Gazan who were approaching their tanks. Gazans have affixed explosives to Israeli tanks. Those were the ones who were fired on. I read and watch more than MSM misinformation.
You said democracy??? Killing 31,000 people in Gaza ????
I don't know hamas🤔 so october 7 didn't happen? 75 years, but Smotrich and Ben Gvir are the problem?
I mean both groups are crazy genocidal maniacs the problem is one side is a small group and the other is the fourth biggest army in the world 😅 you’re comparing apples to oranges 😂
@@beleivernew7149haha its almost like one group has 57 lands with their religion and culture and the only one just one haha
@@viosh7137 the day you Learn the difference between Islam and Arab you can argue but you just sound dumb like this!