Why does everyone say he's schizophrenic, I've never seen this confirmed by any member of tally hall, or joe himself. all tally hall said was joe was mentally unwell.
"Because good & evil as a concept is a good thing, whereas binary opposition as a concept is ignorant, destructive, counter-productive, & stupid" This hits so hard & is probably my favorite thing someone has said in ages
@@tallyballYT I find the fact that they're short oddly comforting, I have ADHD so I dont normally watch long videos and being able to understand what I like in a short time and in a fun and actually interesting way is very appreciated:3
I disagree that Good & Evil is supposed to be only the good side because calling something purely good is the exact opposite of what the album’s message is. I believe that it’s more likely that Black People, White People was removed from the album because the song was considered to be a little bit too silly when compared to the other more serious songs. Other than this one point this is a great and well made video.
That’s totally fair. I probably should’ve made it more clear that my point wasn’t just that that’s the reason it wasn’t on Good & Evil, but more so that that’s one of the reasons Joe Hawley eventually did release it (along with the fact that it’s just a good song) and why it’s cool that they aren’t on the same album, because it wouldn’t make sense if they were :)
Also the first half of the album Good & Evil has multiple of Rob’s break up songs. This establishes the idea that love is a strictly bad thing. Later in the album, in the songs A Lady and You we see that love shown as something that isn’t necessarily bad (“I know a lady good & evil”) and can even be a good thing (Rob’s song being “You & Me” while Andrew’s is “You” thus implying that in Andrew’s song their relationship isn’t evil). The album’s beliefs contradict each other here which again shows that the album isn’t meant to show only good. Also, I know “A Lady” was originally about Joe’s grandma but I think that it’s meant to be a love song in this album.
thanks! i always get worried that i don’t go in detail enough because it’s so short, but i think it’s just because i don’t pad my videos with unimportant stuff 👀
i absolutely love how the two live next to eachother because if you think about it, bpwp and & are also opposites, because their message is the opposite
Me trying to understand the whole video because I don't know how to speak English and I only speak Spanish: 🕴 but jokes aside, I loved the analysis and as you explain during the video lol
I think that the message of & is more that nothing are perfect opposites. Like in every “duality” mentioned there is always a grey area where one thing can be both. Idk man
wow this is insanely good! i never would have sat down and looked more into the meanings of these songs, but this is so interesting and makes total sense. how do you find these seemingly minor details and flesh them out into something so deep? (also you’re voice is really nice👍)
Just found your channel today and subscribed and watched every video! I always love finding more Tally Hall related content and I’m happy to have crossed some more off the list. I make short piano covers and I did one of & a while ago. Keep up the good work!😁
A song vs an entire album? Are you sure? I think Black People White People is just meant to counter &, not the whole Good & Evil. Black People White People is only *one* song.
also, silly little thing i noticed, both black people white people and & are the second songs on their respective albums, maybe its a coincidence? maybe not?
No I think Black People White People is actually for the same themes of Good & Evil because of that final breakdown after "Single Indonesian Mothers Born in 1967" (or whatever...), there's no 'opposite' of that.
Tally hall isnt just a conincidence and contradiction Tally hall is a band that consists of funny people and 1 proud loud serious person only some adore. And Fabloo
Honestly, I'm liking the new content but I would appreciate if you could still at least MAKE content similar to the short tally hall clips you used to make
kind of funny how this channel went from random tally hall clips to joe hawley song explanations in the matter of like 7 months
i hope it wasn’t a downgrade
@@tallyballYT NAHHH I'm so happy to have a channel like this as a new tally hall fan
@@tallyballYTmassive upgrade
you're like vsauce of tally hall on x1,5 speed but comprehensible and meaningful
this is the best compliment i’ve ever received
i find vsauce very meaningful. but yeah he can be very hard to follow sometimes (or maybe you're just not smart enough to get it) no jk
This further proves that joe hawley is an absolute genius corrupted by the horrible ilness that is schizophrenia :(
Why does everyone say he's schizophrenic, I've never seen this confirmed by any member of tally hall, or joe himself. all tally hall said was joe was mentally unwell.
I agree, and I hope he gets the help he needs
I do hope Joe and all the other Tally Hall members are okay!
"Because good & evil as a concept is a good thing, whereas binary opposition as a concept is ignorant, destructive, counter-productive, & stupid"
This hits so hard & is probably my favorite thing someone has said in ages
thanks so much!
Vsauce ahh quote
I HAVE TWO SIDES
black people || white people
im still waiting for the mutha clucka analysis and how its about the extended laws of the universe
you’ll get it… eventually
WE GOT IT!¡!
@@tallyballYT You son a bitch, you were right. Thank god, it was beautiful.
This man really made a poll asking if people think his next video would be about & or black people white people then made it about both
i love how you explain everything in less than 5 minutes, not like that people that make 30 min long vids and dont explain it 😭😭
thanks! i always worry it’s too short and not explained enough, but comments like this definitely make me feel better about it
@@tallyballYT I find the fact that they're short oddly comforting, I have ADHD so I dont normally watch long videos and being able to understand what I like in a short time and in a fun and actually interesting way is very appreciated:3
@@kassdred ADHD buds 🤝
I did not need to spend 5 minutes on that one poll just to have both answers be correct
😈
WE'VE BEEN BAMBOOZLED AND WE GOT BOTH
😈
Good & Evil being the good part of good & evil is funny considering there's no "Hawaii: Part I" :)
The missing duo: Evil G&E and Hawaii: Part I
vsauce: tally hall edition
Also good and evil album cover is black and white
I disagree that Good & Evil is supposed to be only the good side because calling something purely good is the exact opposite of what the album’s message is. I believe that it’s more likely that Black People, White People was removed from the album because the song was considered to be a little bit too silly when compared to the other more serious songs. Other than this one point this is a great and well made video.
That’s totally fair. I probably should’ve made it more clear that my point wasn’t just that that’s the reason it wasn’t on Good & Evil, but more so that that’s one of the reasons Joe Hawley eventually did release it (along with the fact that it’s just a good song) and why it’s cool that they aren’t on the same album, because it wouldn’t make sense if they were :)
Also the first half of the album Good & Evil has multiple of Rob’s break up songs. This establishes the idea that love is a strictly bad thing. Later in the album, in the songs A Lady and You we see that love shown as something that isn’t necessarily bad (“I know a lady good & evil”) and can even be a good thing (Rob’s song being “You & Me” while Andrew’s is “You” thus implying that in Andrew’s song their relationship isn’t evil). The album’s beliefs contradict each other here which again shows that the album isn’t meant to show only good. Also, I know “A Lady” was originally about Joe’s grandma but I think that it’s meant to be a love song in this album.
As someone who native language is spanish I can say this video is perfect to practice my english listening
i love these analysis videos so much 😭 Such a deep dive in 4 minutes!
thanks! i always get worried that i don’t go in detail enough because it’s so short, but i think it’s just because i don’t pad my videos with unimportant stuff 👀
I wait for the day this man makes a Hawaii Part: II or Candle On The Water video
Candle on the water is just a cover of a Disney song...
@@andistansbury4366 Still a good song
The list of albums abbreviated could've been MMMM COC
COC???
Is that the... Is that the VSauce background song...
yes
@@tallyballYT😮
Straight to the point no beating around the bush and if you want more depth the creator suggests dropping a comment, this is why tallyball is za goat
Black and white ppl good and evil album TALLY HALL WHCHA TRYING TO SAY 💀💀💀💀💀
& it one of my top songs
this was explained so well in under 5 minutes lol well done
thank you!
i absolutely love how the two live next to eachother because if you think about it, bpwp and & are also opposites, because their message is the opposite
the vsauce music and the topic being tally hall basically sums up this entire channel
First!!! YESSSS!!! Westhatch?
Tally ball you're the coolest tally hall youtuber (i totally did not say this to project letters before...)
The wooden spoon is back let’s goooo 🎉
THIS IS AMAZING, YOU TRICKED US‼️‼️‼️‼️🔥🔥🔥🗣️🗣️
id honestly love you see you try and analyze bring her along, its one of my favorite songs in the tallyverse and i still dont understand what it means
it’s 100% on my list! i have a couple more vids planned before it though :)
So then where does the album yelwah eoj yelwah eoj fit in in all of this?
Something I think is interesting is how the album covers also play with the same idea
hits harder after the joe hawley lore drop
Me trying to understand the whole video because I don't know how to speak English and I only speak Spanish: 🕴
but jokes aside, I loved the analysis and as you explain during the video lol
I think that the message of & is more that nothing are perfect opposites. Like in every “duality” mentioned there is always a grey area where one thing can be both. Idk man
The transitions are sooooooooooo nice
wow this is insanely good! i never would have sat down and looked more into the meanings of these songs, but this is so interesting and makes total sense. how do you find these seemingly minor details and flesh them out into something so deep? (also you’re voice is really nice👍)
the editing is so good
thank you!
marvelous
un-marvelous
Mechanical
Non mechanical
Museum
Non Museum
Was that a potato vs spoon reference at the end?
this is really cool!!!! never thought about it and both those songs never made so much sense
bro got betrayed by his own song 💀
Maybe it was supposed to be the first song of the album and "&" would be later in order to show some sort of development/revelation
As an Indonesian single mom that gave birth in 1957, I approve of this video
the real reason it wasnt used is because of the use of the fuck word several times
When are we gonna get a zubin sedghi out of context
This makes so much sense… yet none at all… bravo
0:17
17 seconds in and bro is Vsauce
Wow I love how black people white people connect with &, And you explain so I can understand it lol
OMG I LOVE THE OUTRO TO!!!
bpwp people is how the taijitu is viewed at a surface level but & is what the taijitu actually symbolizes
Amazing analysis
Tallyball uploads, I click.
I loved hearing the vsauce music coming in at the end LMAO
Bold of you to assume I think people are sexy
Just found your channel today and subscribed and watched every video! I always love finding more Tally Hall related content and I’m happy to have crossed some more off the list. I make short piano covers and I did one of & a while ago. Keep up the good work!😁
Joe Hawley Joe Hawley is the evil in good & evil
i love your videos so much
thanks!!
A song vs an entire album? Are you sure? I think Black People White People is just meant to counter &, not the whole Good & Evil. Black People White People is only *one* song.
I liked this video :)
also, silly little thing i noticed, both black people white people and & are the second songs on their respective albums, maybe its a coincidence? maybe not?
Great video! Also I just noticed the name changed lmao
This guy is the Vsauce of tally hall
bro forgot the entire second half of BPWP
help my brain hurt
IS THE TITLE CARD A CHONNY JASH REFERE-
Idk if you answered this in another video and ik Im a year late but the ending to & never made sense to me
Why didn't you talk about the latter part of Black People White People ?
I stopped trying to understand it as the lyrics just seem like nonsense to me
Cool!
the comment i put on one of the joe hawley videos of your that was before the doc man I’m sorry that if very embarrassing for mehelp😢😢😢🙏
I see you with the vsauce music
Awesome video! Please remember to drink water and get at least a little bit of sunlight
Why did this Tally ball guy become V-sause?
THE TIP OF THE HAT TO YOU SIR I SHOULD SPOUT!
the part after the indonesian moms thing is just so divine i literally ascend to the heavens every time i hear “never gonna stop me”
Theres a new joe hawley piece of music out, what does it mean? Its called i am confessing and its on joe hawley-topic.
fake
@@gooseguts I commented this literally 40 minutes after the fake song came out. /:
@@uhigldasdtyuiosagjk wakwkakaka 🔳🔲🔳🔳🔳🔳
No I think Black People White People is actually for the same themes of Good & Evil because of that final breakdown after "Single Indonesian Mothers Born in 1967" (or whatever...), there's no 'opposite' of that.
i like your hair, also why do you have a spoon?
thanks! also yes
good video omg
Ok, &?
Is this like Hegelian dialectic?
Basically
Black People White People=,
And=&
Tally hall isnt just a conincidence and contradiction Tally hall is a band that consists of funny people and 1 proud loud serious person only some adore.
And Fabloo
oh
Why'd the thumbnail change?
funsies
i dont have enough money to have a membership
that’s ok! i appreciate you just watching what i’ve created :)
very cool video tbh :) btw i make music as a side hobby if you ever need anybody to compose something for a video at any point!
when new meme video 🤯🤯
Joe Bawley
YIPPE YOYRE BAKC 🎉
yes! sorry for the late upload, been super busy with school :)
@@tallyballYT its fine!! u can take as much time off as u need ^^
@@tallyballYT no biggie shits getting wild in school now adays
Get a better video schedule please I love your videos 😭
sorry! i’ve been really busy with school recently :)
Honestly, I'm liking the new content but I would appreciate if you could still at least MAKE content similar to the short tally hall clips you used to make
why do you have a wooden spoon in your hand
you kinda look like paul dano
i get this a lot 😭
Bro is not vsauce 😭
🫂
I was right?!
Why are you holding a wooden spoon?
I was right
fuck yeah
that song is catchy even though it’s racist
the world isn't black and white the world is grey