How was the ACEH Conflict Resolved? | How INDONESIA'S 30-Year Separatist Dispute Came to an End

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 309

  • @JamesKerLindsay
    @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +54

    Indonesia is a huge and diverse country that offers so many interesting lessons for those interested in statehood and secession. In this video, I wanted to take a look at one of the rare examples of a secessionist dispute that was successfully resolved by integrating separatist forces back into the parent state. As ever, do let me know in the comments below if there are any other cases that you would like me to look at.
    Thanks for watching. If you found this video useful, please do consider giving it a 'Like' and sharing it with others who might be interested. And do all consider subscribing. It helps the channel to grow! Much appreciated!

    • @alsuvarnadvipadanargentum1743
      @alsuvarnadvipadanargentum1743 4 роки тому +2

      Finally ☺️☺️☺️☺️☺️ it’s about time that you’re covering the Southeast Asian region (you do recognize me right?)
      If you have more time, can you please cover the other secessionist groups from the region (per country of course) and the history behind their desire to separate itself from their parent state?
      Their many reasons usually goes along by saying-that they don’t have or were not given a VOICE for their concerns to be heard because capital’s wants (representatives from the separatist region are lacking even in my home country) in the central government (their concerns/needs are being swept aside or treated as an afterthought) Or that when it comes to the separatist region’s very basic needs, the response from the central government is too slow
      The point is, is that the secessionist problems of every country have to be resolved peacefully (even if I am not from the secessionist region I understand that they mostly wanted a better life for their families and children 👶) including my own country’s secessionist problem which is in the form of the Moro Conflict in Mindanao that President Duterte is trying to resolve (the first Philippine President from Mindanao-Davao region)

    • @jamalacheh2929
      @jamalacheh2929 4 роки тому +3

      @@Rizalmercado #Merdeka #Referendum not Indonesian

    • @autolinearchanel2785
      @autolinearchanel2785 3 роки тому +3

      The royal kingdom at ACEH
      1. KINGDOM OF JEUMPA
      This kingdom was founded in 719 AD (141H), its first king was named MALIK SAID ABDULLAH (the forerunner of the kingdom in Aceh) his son Said almusanna his son Saidina hasan his son fatimah zuhra his son muhammad S.A.W
      2. KINGDOM OF PEUREULAK /ferlec
      Maharaj Syahriar Salman (son-in-law of MALIK SAID ABDULLAH) is one of the descendants of the Imam Musa Al Kazhim great-grandson Saidana Hussein binti fatimah zahra bin rasulillah S.A.W, ..
      Maharaj Syahriansyah Salman has adopted his children to become the new Meurah. To the east, he appointed his son Syahr Nuwi as Meurah in a new city called ferlec. However, in its development, Ferlec Kingdom grew rapidly into a new port city, especially after the arrival of a group of descendants of the Prophet led by Maulana Muhammad al-Diba'i who had the title of Nakhoda Khalifah. Syahr Nuwi married his younger brother Makhdum Tansyuri with one of the figures in the group named Maulana Ali his son Muhammad his son Jafar Sadik, great-grandson of the Prophet Muhammad. From this marriage a son named Maulana Sayed Abdul Aziz was born, and on 1 Muharram (225 H) or year (840 AD), he was appointed King of the Perlak Islamic Kingdom.
      the names of the sultan are as follows:
      - SULTAN SAYED MAULANA ABDUL AZIS SYAH bin Maulana Ali his son Muhammad his son Jafar Sadik, his son Hussein his son fatimah zahra his son Prophet Muhammad. (840M-864M)
      - Sultan Alaidin sayed Maulana Abdul rahim Shah (864 M-888M)
      - Sultan Alaidin Sayed Maulana Abbas Shah (888 M-913M)
      In 913 AD there was turmoil in the ferlec sultanate until 915 AD, then the sultan continued as follows:
      - Sultan Alaidin sayed maulana sayed mughayat syah
      But after that there was another upheaval from 918 AD - 928 AD
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Khadir Shah (928 AD - 932 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Muhammad Amen Shah (932 AD- 956 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Abdul Malik Shah Johan Sovereign (916 AD - 983 AD)
      Then in 983 AD
      - 986 AD, the ferlec was split intowas split into 2, namely, the inner ferlec and the coastal ferlec.
      a. Ferlec deepens Inland
      Ferlec was founded in 986 AD- 988 AD, and who led at that time were: -sultan makhdum alaidin malik ibrahim syah johan sovereign
      b. Coastal Ferlec
      Coastal Ferlec was founded from 986 AD - 1023 AD And those who led at that time were: - Sultan Alaidin Syed Maulana Shah.
      In 1006 AD, ferlec reunited and raised his king again in 1023 AD, who led the following:
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mahmud Shah Johan Sovereign (1023 AD - 1059 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mansyur Shah Johan Sovereign (1059 AD - 1078 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Shah Johan Sovereign (1078 AD - 1109 AD)
      -sultan makhdum alaidin malik ahmad syah johan sovereign (1009 AD - 1135 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mahmud Shah Johan Sovereign (1135 AD - 1160 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Ustad Shah Johan Sovereign (1160 AD - 1173 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Shah Johan Sovereign (1173 AD - 1200 AD)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Jalil Shah Johan Sovereign (1200 M - 1230 M)
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Amin Shah Johan II Sovereign (1230 AD - 1267 AD)
      Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Amin Shah Johan has 2 daughters
      1. Named Putri Ganggang Sari, who later married the Sultan Malikul shaleh
      2. Her name is Putri Ratna Kumala, who will later marry the Sultan Muhammad iskandar syah (Parameswara), the King of the Malacca kingdom
      - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Aziz Shah, son of Malik Muhammad Shah, is the last generation of the Ferlec Sultanate.
      And the ferlec kingdom ended in 1267 AD, so that it finally joined the work of SAMUDRA PASEE which was led by the sultan Malikul shaleh ...
      The story of ferlek (perlak) can be checked in Marcopolo's book entitled Imago Mundi.
      3. SAMUDERA PASEE
      Founded by SULTAN MALIKUL SHALEH or MEURAH SILU his son meurah makhdum malik abdullah, his son meurah ahmad, his son meurah makhdum malik ibrahim, his son meurah malik masir (to meurah mersa), his son meurah makhdum malik ishak, his son sultan makhdum alaidin abdul malik syah, his son sultan makhdum alaidin muhammad amin syah, his son sultan makhdum alaidin abdul khadir syah, his son meurah ahmad, his son meurah bahrun, his son syahir nuwi (the forerunner of the Peureulak/Ferlec kingdom), his son Maharaj syahriar salman (SON IN LAW KING OF JEUMPA) researchers estimate Maharaj Syahriar Salman is one of the descendants of Imam Musa al-Kazhim, great-grandson Saidana Hussein binti Fatimah Zahra bin Rasulillah SAW ,.
      Syahir Nuwi (forerunner to the kingdom of Peureulak / ferlec) his son Mayang seuladang (REAL SON OF KING JEUMPA) his son Malik said Abdullah his son Said almusanna his son Saidina Hasan his son fatimah zuhra his son muhammad S.A.W.
      in 1267 AD after the collapse of the Ferlec kingdom, there was the Samudera Pasai kingdom, the kings who had ruled the Pasee Ocean were as follows
      - Sultan Malikul Pious (1267 AD-1297 AD) - Sultan Muhammad Malikul Dhahir (1297 AD-1326M)
      - Sultan Malik Mahmud ad dhahir (1326 AD - 1345 AD)
      - Sultan Mansur Malik ad dhahir (1345 AD - 1346 AD)
      - Sultan Ahmad Malik Ad Dhahir (1346 AD - 1383 AD)
      - Sultan Zainal Abidin Malik ad dhahir (1383 AD - 1405 AD)
      Ibn Battuta came to the Pasai Ocean in 1345 AD during the time of the Sultan Muhammad Malik ad Dhahir ..
      And during the time of sultan Zainal Abidin, Sultan Zainal Abidin sent ulama to the island of Java in the year 1400 ± AD, one of the most sent scholars was brothers, namely maulana malik ibrahim and maulana ishaq and with their entourage, Maulana Ishq is a scholar of the LINGE kingdom in Takengon Central Aceh. And sending scholars throughout Southeast Asia, especially the archipelago to strengthen Islam.
      4. KESULTAN ACEH DARUSSALAM
      Founded in 1496 AD, and the first sultan was Sultan Ali Mughayat Shah, then reached his heyday during the young Sultan Iskandar in (1607-1636 AD) The following is the name of the work sultan Aceh Darussalam.
      - Sultan Ali Mughayat Shah (1496-1528M)
      - Sultan Salahuddin (1528-1537 AD)
      - sultan ala 'al din al kahhar (1537-1568M)
      - Sultan Hussein Ali Riayat Syah (1568-1575 AD) - young sultan (1575) - Natural Sri Sultan (1575-1576)
      - Sultan Zainal Abidin (1576-1577)
      - Sultan ala 'al din Mansur Shah (1577-1589)
      - sultan buyong (1589-1596)
      - Sultan ala 'al din riayat syah (1596-1604)
      - Sultan Ali Riayat Syah (1604-1607)
      - Sultan Iskandar Muda, Johan, Hero Meukuta Alam (1607-1636)
      - iskandar tsani (1636-1641)
      - Sri Ratu Safi 'Al Din Taj Alam (1641-1675)
      - Sri Ratu Naqi 'Al Din Nur Alam (1678-1678)
      - sri queen zaqi 'al din inayat syah (1678-1688)
      - Sri Ratu Kamalat Syah (1688-1699)
      - Sultan Badr Al Alam Syarif Hashim Jamal 'Al Din (1699-1702)
      - the mighty sultan of nature syarif lamtui (1702-1703)
      - sultan jamal al alam badr al munir (1703-1726) - Sultan Jauhar Al Alam Amin 'Al Din (1726)
      - sultan syam al alam (1726-1727)
      - Sultan ala 'al din ahmad syah (1727-1735)
      - Sultan ala 'al din johan Shah (1735-1760)
      - Sultan Mahmud Shah (1760-1781)
      - Sultan Badr Al Din (1781-1785)
      - Sultan Solomon Shah (1785-1790)
      - Sultan Alaudin Muhammad Daud Shah (1790-1795)
      - Sultan ala 'al din Jauhar al alam (1795-1815) and (1818-1824)
      - sultan syarif saif al alam (1815-1818)
      - Sultan Muhammad Shah (1824-1838)
      - Sultan Solomon Shah (1838--1857)
      - Sultan Mansur Shah (1857-1870)
      - Sultan Mahmud Shah (1870-1874)
      - Sultan Muhammad Daud Shah (1874-1903) ..

    • @syedrahim6889
      @syedrahim6889 3 роки тому +3

      Free aceh
      Free west papua
      Free maluku

    • @ahmadaraselena1936
      @ahmadaraselena1936 3 роки тому +2

      ❤❤salem aneuk nanggrau❤❤
      The Kingdom of Aceh on the northern tip of Sumatra has always been a very strong and influential sultanate in Southeast Asia since the world has known Aceh. The golden peak of Aceh was under the rule of Sultan Iskandar Muda in the 17th century where, the Kingdom of Aceh expanded its influence almost throughout the whole of Southeast Asia.
      Aceh had strong diplomatic and trading relations with the international world, including the Kingdom of Holland way before the bloody colonial war broke out between the two nations. The Sultan of Aceh sent an Acehnese ambassador Tuanku Abdul Hamid, who died in Holland and was begraved at the church premise in Middlesburg, in the Netherlands.
      On 26 March 1873, the Kingdom of Holland officially declared war upon the Kingdom of Aceh. The aftermath of this declaration was widely reported around the globe by international newspapers and even created debates in government parliaments both in Holland and Great Britain that had diplomatic relations with the Sultan of Aceh.
      Today, after 148 years, the Free Aceh Movement (GAM) and the loyal Acehnese community commemorate this historic and glamourous day. The declaration of war is an official recognition of sovereignty and independence of Aceh. It was on this legal basis that GAM started their liberation struggle on 4 December 1976, whereby more than 30,000 innocent Acehenese and som 200 000 died during the tsunami. In the process, GAM and the Acehnese have always maintained our committment until today.
      The catastrophe was a catalyst that started the peace talks between GAM and GoI that ended the 30 years armed conflict with the signing of the peace accord, The Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), signed on 15 August 2005 in Helsinki, Finland. Since then, GAM has adhered and respect the MoU but unfortunately, most of the points agreed have not been fully implemented while some crucial points are still on paper. In fact new regulations have been passed to decapitate the MoU. Many Acehnese are losing their patience and confidence of the peace process.
      The main issue of conflict in Aceh is political, a decolonization process that has never been done and the status of Aceh that was never part of the Netherlands East Indies. It is also the struggle for the right of determinantion of a decolonised people under international law.
      We strongly believe and call upon the Kingdom of Netherlands, with the support of the international community, to sign an end to the Declaration of War upon Aceh, as has been praticed after the Second World War. Thus eternal peace and stability is maintained in Aceh and the region of Southeast Asia.

  • @ilminoriswandi1171
    @ilminoriswandi1171 2 роки тому +34

    Salam dari Aceh terimakasih telah menayangkan siaran untuk Aceh, agar dunia tau bahwa kesepakatan MOU Helsinki antara gam dan RI begitu banyak yg blum dipenuhi dari pihak pemerintah RI, saya sebagai rakyat aceh sangat khawatir akan terulang nya konflik lagi diaceh

    • @indorailfans2532
      @indorailfans2532 Рік тому +1

      Sangat mungkin hal itu terjadi

    • @trist1302
      @trist1302 9 місяців тому

      Aceh mesti dimekarkan menjadi bbrapa provinsi bro, watak manusia pasti haus kekuasaan

    • @hahahah17114
      @hahahah17114 8 місяців тому +2

      @@trist1302 terbentuk nya Indonesia benar benar menguntungkan jawa

    • @bakuhamtam303
      @bakuhamtam303 7 місяців тому

      @@hahahah17114 bukan Jawa tapi pemerintahannya yang bisa dari luar jawa maupun jawa itu korupsi

    • @putra4101
      @putra4101 4 місяці тому

      @@hahahah17114 "Jawa" mana yg dimaksud? 😅
      Orang kalangan pekerja "jawa" yang tidak merasa mendapatkan apa-apa 🤦‍♂️.
      Dan juga sama bencinya dgn pemerintahan dinasti 😒.

  • @AyedYoutube
    @AyedYoutube 4 роки тому +31

    Thank you for making this video! As an Acehnese i can appreciate the effort in making this video about one of the darkest chapters of Indonesian and Acehnese history. Although a lot of the MoU agreements has not yet been realized, the peace that exist today has allowed for extensive rebuilding efforts following the insurgency and the natural disasters. I look forward for the future!

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +4

      Thank you so much for the extremely kind comment. (And my sincerest apologies for the delay in replying.) It is always wonderful to hear from people in the countries I cover. It was certainly a dark time. Needless to say, I wish you all the very best for the future. Very best regards from London.

  • @Veterant99
    @Veterant99 Рік тому +13

    actual facts that happened in aceh, very useful videos. I am a GAM fighter who is directly involved as discussed in the video.
    Thank you, greetings from Aceh 🙏🇹🇷

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  Рік тому +3

      Thank you so much. How is the situation over there at the moment?

    • @rafiqirafiqi6423
      @rafiqirafiqi6423 Рік тому +1

      @@JamesKerLindsay very safe

    • @tajulalfarlaki8966
      @tajulalfarlaki8966 Рік тому

      @@JamesKerLindsay kau harus segera mendengar lagu acehnese turbofolk

    • @OtenBenaluIndonesia
      @OtenBenaluIndonesia 9 місяців тому +1

      Berhenti berbicara omong kosong. Aceh memiliki muslim yang setia. Kita sudah makmur tidak ada diskriminasi jangan jadi timur tengah. Tidak ada perang saudara sesama muslim

    • @Apasihacehhhh
      @Apasihacehhhh 8 місяців тому

      Dimana gam saat rakyat Aceh sedang kesusahan waktu tsunami??

  • @pbyt3869
    @pbyt3869 3 роки тому +57

    Interesting video, I’m part Indonesian from North Sulawesi province and we have a small but sizable separatist movement. This is actually for the exact opposite of Aceh, as North Sulawesi is a largely Christian and wants to separate if Indonesia becomes a Islamist nation. Anyway this video is very interesting! 👍

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  3 роки тому +23

      Thank you so much. That is fascinating. I must look into it. Indonesia is such an interesting country in so many ways. Funnily enough, when I originally went to university I applied to do Politics with Indonesian (seriously), but then became fascinated in SE Europe when my family moved to Cyprus. But I’ve always maintained an interest in SE Asia.

    • @mdsabahuddin8251
      @mdsabahuddin8251 3 роки тому

      And your plan will never come to pass

    • @andygian5523
      @andygian5523 2 роки тому +9

      That's quite Impossible, even the largest Muslim organization like NU, refused the idea Indonesia becoming Muslim nations. Becose the priority is making Indonesia Darussalam (peaceful) country. Because only in peaceful countries you can practice your religion freely and safely.

    • @mcchonky5709
      @mcchonky5709 Рік тому +1

      @@andygian5523 Indonesia is alerady a Muslim nation

    • @shaniagunasekara8345
      @shaniagunasekara8345 Рік тому +2

      Indonesia is an Islamic nation

  • @carakayuma8875
    @carakayuma8875 4 роки тому +52

    Indonesia is a multi-culture country with many religion, race, ethnic, and of course armed insurgency, like Soviet or Yugoslav :)
    But Thank God, our country still shine and stand until now 🙌 btw thank you sir, your channel is really help me to know more about international situation

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +5

      Thank you so much for your kind message. I am so glad you find the channel interesting and useful. Indonesia is indeed an incredible country with so much diversity. But, as you note, there are also serious issues. I would really love to be able to visit someday.

    • @anwarklinkanwar5851
      @anwarklinkanwar5851 2 роки тому +1

      Bumoe aceh tetap bumoe aceh,, tanpa bumoe aceh tidak ada Indonesia

    • @haba4696
      @haba4696 2 роки тому +1

      Free acheh

    • @haba4696
      @haba4696 2 роки тому +1

      Freedom acheh

  • @briancops3798
    @briancops3798 4 роки тому +16

    Amzing vid! I must admit I kinda forgot about ACEH!

  • @stadra2160
    @stadra2160 7 місяців тому +3

    Of the 38 provinces in Indonesia, Aceh is considered the most autonomous province. Aceh has a devolved parliament with its own local political parties (no other province in Indonesia has its own political party). Aceh is also the only province in Indonesia that applies sharia law, such as caning for unmarried couples, alcohol, etc.
    One of my teachers at my school back then was Acehnese and he was very happy to live in my province in South Kalimantan because he said we had cinemas. There were no cinemas in Aceh, the existing cinemas were burned to the ground after the peace agreement because they were considered satanic and contrary to Islamic laws.

  • @mukhlisrachman3908
    @mukhlisrachman3908 5 місяців тому +2

    Aceh was a long lasting Independent country before Dutch aggression at end of 19 century. So much different from other parts of which now Indonesia which had been under Dutch’s Indian iIndies for centuries.

  • @arrancaal
    @arrancaal 3 роки тому +14

    Born and raised in Aceh, your video is on point.
    part of the reason dispute came to an end was after the tsunami, international starting to recognizing Aceh problem and it became mainstream? there were lots of international aids and media came here.
    I remember back then, thousands of United states navy and marines pouring my city to help.
    with that, international community starting to pressurize Indonesian government to end the dispute. and finally we come to a long awaited peace.
    sadly, although peace has arrive, there are still many unresolved human rights-crime.
    i saw Indonesian military cut a boys head because the military were looking for his father and couldnt find him, so they killed his son instead.
    atlease we live in peace now.
    great video anyway. love it from Aceh.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you so much. It is always really great to hear from people directly involved in the cases I explore. It is often the case that once the peace agreement has been done and the world’s media go home there are elements of the agreement that don’t get implemented and aspects of the conflict that get quietly pushed away from public view. I really should look at this aspect of conflict. In the meantime, thanks for the comment and very best regards from London.

  • @OnionIlan
    @OnionIlan 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks for talking about this conflict, not many people know about this conflict

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  2 роки тому +2

      Thank you very much. Agreed. It really should be better known internationally.

  • @wenderis
    @wenderis Рік тому +2

    Thx for doing this. 13 mins seems too quick but you manage to distilled a lot of things in a very approachable way.
    Aceh right now is supersafe.. I hiked the Leuser highlands (the traditional hideout for the insurgency back in the day) with ex-GAM fighters as my guides a few times already. The ex fighters are just like any other human, few are corrupt but most are humble yet proud people.
    And Acehnese cuisines...wow.. Hands down one of the best in the world. I sometime joke that it would be a massive loss for Indonesia just because they would lose an array of delicious foods, from the coast to Tano Gayo and Alas-Kluet.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  Рік тому +1

      Thanks so much. It’s so interesting to hear a perspective from on the ground. I really appreciate it.

  • @glevt
    @glevt 4 роки тому +8

    I think we can discuss about this now. There is unfinished business here on the Helsinki peace agreement after 15 years in peace between Aceh and Indonesia. It can triggers new conflict again if the both sides have no sincere intention. The worst happened in the past in the same situation after MoU Lamtéh in 1957.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +2

      Thanks a lot for the comment. I really appreciate it. It does seem that various elements of the agreement have not been implemented. There is always a worry in these situations that the conflict can resume. Hopefully, this won’t happen.

  • @awesomeboy4353
    @awesomeboy4353 4 роки тому +7

    A great video i did not know much about the aceh conflict

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +1

      Thank a lot. Yes, it’s strange but Aceh is largely forgotten; even though it has only (!?) been 15 years since it was brought to an end. At one point, it was very prominent.

  • @timsav
    @timsav 4 роки тому +8

    I'm extremely happy that I've found your channel!!! Thank you for your work!
    I'm a master student researching conflict resolution in different regions (especially EU and OSCE involvement in cases of Abkhazia and South Ossetia), so these themes are very interesting for me! :)

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому

      Thanks so much for the really kind message! I am really delighted you found the channel! I actually studied conflict for my MA and PhD (over at Kent) and I remember doing various case studies. I really hoped that the channel would be useful to students. As you can see, I often try to weave in ‘bigger’ issues and concepts into the videos. Do let me know if there are any topics you would like to see me cover. I am always keen to hear good ideas. And perhaps you could recommend the channel to others on your course or anyone else who might be interested. All support is most appreciated!

  • @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr
    @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr 8 місяців тому +1

    Aku rakyat yang mewakili rakyat aceh semua

  • @marioalegalle
    @marioalegalle 4 роки тому +3

    The video is great! I will spend all night watching all the videos on your channel! Thanks for the help in my International Negotiation paper Mr Ker-Lindsay, excellent video! You just gained one more subscriber! cheers from Ecuador!

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому

      Mario G Cevallos Hi Mario, thank you so much. I am so glad the video was helpful! And thanks for the subscribe. Really appreciated. (You might well be the first from Ecuador 🇪🇨!) Do let me know if you have any ideas for subjects you would like to see me cover. I’m always keen to hear ideas.

  • @matthewa.whiting719
    @matthewa.whiting719 3 роки тому +4

    Thank you for this informative video. I'm trying to learn about every nation/"de facto" nation in the world, and was curious about Aceh, since it's a place I've never heard of before.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  3 роки тому

      Thanks. Aceh really is a fascinating case. In fact, Indonesia as a whole is one of the most interesting countries in the world for anyone interested in secession.

  • @hantulaut8817
    @hantulaut8817 2 роки тому +4

    Tank you brother i from Aceh merdeka 😭❤️

  • @hadisaputra7291
    @hadisaputra7291 3 роки тому +3

    Amazing
    hadir dari Aceh

  • @sirepbegonondo2612
    @sirepbegonondo2612 3 роки тому +9

    jika terjadi perang saudara di indonesia pasti orang luar akan senang, karena itu cara licik mereka dari dulu politik adu domba

    • @halimhalim730
      @halimhalim730 3 роки тому +3

      Sapa yng adu domba

    • @BudiRisdiyanto
      @BudiRisdiyanto 8 місяців тому

      Karna kolinial baru itu bernama indonesia , bagus semua merdeka buat apa cuma di manfaatin dan di keruk sumber daya alam nya , bodoh kamu

    • @bakuhamtam303
      @bakuhamtam303 7 місяців тому

      @@halimhalim730 apalagi kalo bukan Amerika salah satu nya

  • @GeographyWorld
    @GeographyWorld 4 роки тому +4

    Very interesting video. Learned a lot about a place I haven't heard much about before.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому

      Thanks. It is interesting how it seems to have completely dropped off the international radar. It was quite a big story at one point. However, these days most people seem to know little about it. (By contrast, East Timor has remained relatively well know.) In any case, I hope you’re doing well. Looking forward to your next offering!

  • @chanchaltayal3687
    @chanchaltayal3687 4 роки тому +14

    Can you do a video explaining the constituent countries of the UK? I have never understood how the UK is even a country. And being a British yourself, what do you think about Scottish independence and Irish unification?

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +3

      Thanks so much. Great suggestion! I’ve already done one video on Scotland. ua-cam.com/video/sDJTQoLH66w/v-deo.html I am certainly hoping to do more on the UK. But a general explainer is an excellent idea. For example, many people don’t understand the relationship between the Isle of Man and the UK or between the UK and the Channel Islands.

  • @rijal916
    @rijal916 4 роки тому +5

    Thank you for your caring about Aceh, i hope you follow as well about advance stuation of MOU Helsinki nowadays.. 😇🙏

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +1

      Thank you. I would really like to do a follow up on Aceh at some point. What is your view of the situation?

    • @rijal916
      @rijal916 4 роки тому

      If i had to say, what's happening right now, it's complicated to explain and perhaps there are sensitive issues among indonesian goverment and GAM such as Aceh's flag, symbol and etc.
      Therefore, i would like you please do your own research to find the solve issues...
      Thank you so much your kind, God bless you are 😊🙏🙏

    • @muakhirakhir.4866
      @muakhirakhir.4866 2 роки тому +1

      ​@@JamesKerLindsay merdeka kan Aceh dari Indonesia

  • @lanaindralak4898
    @lanaindralak4898 Рік тому +1

    Very thoughtful sir

  • @rafsanjani3975
    @rafsanjani3975 3 роки тому +1

    Greeting From ACHEH COUNTRY

  • @monkeytime9851
    @monkeytime9851 10 місяців тому +3

    Little known fact: Aceh is one of the very few homes for wild Orangutan in the world.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  10 місяців тому +1

      Amazing creatures. My father grew up in Borneo. He always said they were incredible. Truly, ‘Jungle People’.

  • @AcehPeople
    @AcehPeople 2 роки тому +2

    great explanation prof. God Bless U

  • @autolinearchanel2785
    @autolinearchanel2785 3 роки тому +10

    The royal kingdom at ACEH
    1. KINGDOM OF JEUMPA
    This kingdom was founded in 719 AD (141H), its first king was named MALIK SAID ABDULLAH (the forerunner of the kingdom in Aceh) his son Said almusanna his son Saidina hasan his son fatimah zuhra his son muhammad S.A.W
    2. KINGDOM OF PEUREULAK /ferlec
    Maharaj Syahriar Salman (son-in-law of MALIK SAID ABDULLAH) is one of the descendants of the Imam Musa Al Kazhim great-grandson Saidana Hussein binti fatimah zahra bin rasulillah S.A.W, ..
    Maharaj Syahriansyah Salman has adopted his children to become the new Meurah. To the east, he appointed his son Syahr Nuwi as Meurah in a new city called ferlec. However, in its development, Ferlec Kingdom grew rapidly into a new port city, especially after the arrival of a group of descendants of the Prophet led by Maulana Muhammad al-Diba'i who had the title of Nakhoda Khalifah. Syahr Nuwi married his younger brother Makhdum Tansyuri with one of the figures in the group named Maulana Ali his son Muhammad his son Jafar Sadik, great-grandson of the Prophet Muhammad. From this marriage a son named Maulana Sayed Abdul Aziz was born, and on 1 Muharram (225 H) or year (840 AD), he was appointed King of the Perlak Islamic Kingdom.
    the names of the sultan are as follows:
    - SULTAN SAYED MAULANA ABDUL AZIS SYAH bin Maulana Ali his son Muhammad his son Jafar Sadik, his son Hussein his son fatimah zahra his son Prophet Muhammad. (840M-864M)
    - Sultan Alaidin sayed Maulana Abdul rahim Shah (864 M-888M)
    - Sultan Alaidin Sayed Maulana Abbas Shah (888 M-913M)
    In 913 AD there was turmoil in the ferlec sultanate until 915 AD, then the sultan continued as follows:
    - Sultan Alaidin sayed maulana sayed mughayat syah
    But after that there was another upheaval from 918 AD - 928 AD
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Khadir Shah (928 AD - 932 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Muhammad Amen Shah (932 AD- 956 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Abdul Malik Shah Johan Sovereign (916 AD - 983 AD)
    Then in 983 AD
    - 986 AD, the ferlec was split intowas split into 2, namely, the inner ferlec and the coastal ferlec.
    a. Ferlec deepens Inland
    Ferlec was founded in 986 AD- 988 AD, and who led at that time were: -sultan makhdum alaidin malik ibrahim syah johan sovereign
    b. Coastal Ferlec
    Coastal Ferlec was founded from 986 AD - 1023 AD And those who led at that time were: - Sultan Alaidin Syed Maulana Shah.
    In 1006 AD, ferlec reunited and raised his king again in 1023 AD, who led the following:
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mahmud Shah Johan Sovereign (1023 AD - 1059 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mansyur Shah Johan Sovereign (1059 AD - 1078 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Shah Johan Sovereign (1078 AD - 1109 AD)
    -sultan makhdum alaidin malik ahmad syah johan sovereign (1009 AD - 1135 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Mahmud Shah Johan Sovereign (1135 AD - 1160 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Ustad Shah Johan Sovereign (1160 AD - 1173 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Shah Johan Sovereign (1173 AD - 1200 AD)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Jalil Shah Johan Sovereign (1200 M - 1230 M)
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Amin Shah Johan II Sovereign (1230 AD - 1267 AD)
    Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Muhammad Amin Shah Johan has 2 daughters
    1. Named Putri Ganggang Sari, who later married the Sultan Malikul shaleh
    2. Her name is Putri Ratna Kumala, who will later marry the Sultan Muhammad iskandar syah (Parameswara), the King of the Malacca kingdom
    - Sultan Makhdum Alaidin Malik Abdul Aziz Shah, son of Malik Muhammad Shah, is the last generation of the Ferlec Sultanate.
    And the ferlec kingdom ended in 1267 AD, so that it finally joined the work of SAMUDRA PASEE which was led by the sultan Malikul shaleh ...
    The story of ferlek (perlak) can be checked in Marcopolo's book entitled Imago Mundi.
    3. SAMUDERA PASEE Founded by SULTAN MALIKUL SHALEH or MEURAH SILU his son meurah makhdum malik abdullah, his son meurah ahmad, his son meurah makhdum malik ibrahim, his son meurah malik masir (to meurah mersa), his son meurah makhdum malik ishak, his son sultan makhdum alaidin abdul malik syah, his son sultan makhdum alaidin muhammad amin syah, his son sultan makhdum alaidin abdul khadir syah, his son meurah ahmad, his son meurah bahrun, his son syahir nuwi (the forerunner of the Peureulak/Ferlec kingdom), his son Maharaj syahriar salman (SON IN LAW KING OF JEUMPA) researchers estimate Maharaj Syahriar Salman is one of the descendants of Imam Musa al-Kazhim, great-grandson Saidana Hussein binti Fatimah Zahra bin Rasulillah SAW ,.
    Syahir Nuwi (forerunner to the kingdom of Peureulak / ferlec) his son Mayang seuladang (REAL SON OF KING JEUMPA) his son Malik said Abdullah his son Said almusanna his son Saidina Hasan his son fatimah zuhra his son muhammad S.A.W.
    in 1267 AD after the collapse of the Ferlec kingdom, there was the Samudera Pasai kingdom, the kings who had ruled the Pasee Ocean were as follows
    - Sultan Malikul Pious (1267 AD-1297 AD) - Sultan Muhammad Malikul Dhahir (1297 AD-1326M)
    - Sultan Malik Mahmud ad dhahir (1326 AD - 1345 AD)
    - Sultan Mansur Malik ad dhahir (1345 AD - 1346 AD)
    - Sultan Ahmad Malik Ad Dhahir (1346 AD - 1383 AD)
    - Sultan Zainal Abidin Malik ad dhahir (1383 AD - 1405 AD)
    Ibn Battuta came to the Pasai Ocean in 1345 AD during the time of the Sultan Muhammad Malik ad Dhahir ..
    And during the time of sultan Zainal Abidin, Sultan Zainal Abidin sent ulama to the island of Java in the year 1400 ± AD, one of the most sent scholars was brothers, namely maulana malik ibrahim and maulana ishaq and with their entourage, Maulana Ishq is a scholar of the LINGE kingdom in Takengon Central Aceh. And sending scholars throughout Southeast Asia, especially the archipelago to strengthen Islam.
    4. KESULTAN ACEH DARUSSALAM
    Founded in 1496 AD, and the first sultan was Sultan Ali Mughayat Shah, then reached his heyday during the young Sultan Iskandar in (1607-1636 AD) The following is the name of the work sultan Aceh Darussalam.
    - Sultan Ali Mughayat Shah (1496-1528M)
    - Sultan Salahuddin (1528-1537 AD)
    - sultan ala 'al din al kahhar (1537-1568M)
    - Sultan Hussein Ali Riayat Syah (1568-1575 AD) - young sultan (1575) - Natural Sri Sultan (1575-1576)
    - Sultan Zainal Abidin (1576-1577)
    - Sultan ala 'al din Mansur Shah (1577-1589)
    - sultan buyong (1589-1596)
    - Sultan ala 'al din riayat syah (1596-1604)
    - Sultan Ali Riayat Syah (1604-1607)
    - Sultan Iskandar Muda, Johan, Hero Meukuta Alam (1607-1636)
    - iskandar tsani (1636-1641)
    - Sri Ratu Safi 'Al Din Taj Alam (1641-1675)
    - Sri Ratu Naqi 'Al Din Nur Alam (1678-1678)
    - sri queen zaqi 'al din inayat syah (1678-1688)
    - Sri Ratu Kamalat Syah (1688-1699)
    - Sultan Badr Al Alam Syarif Hashim Jamal 'Al Din (1699-1702)
    - the mighty sultan of nature syarif lamtui (1702-1703)
    - sultan jamal al alam badr al munir (1703-1726) - Sultan Jauhar Al Alam Amin 'Al Din (1726)
    - sultan syam al alam (1726-1727)
    - Sultan ala 'al din ahmad syah (1727-1735)
    - Sultan ala 'al din johan Shah (1735-1760)
    - Sultan Mahmud Shah (1760-1781)
    - Sultan Badr Al Din (1781-1785)
    - Sultan Solomon Shah (1785-1790)
    - Sultan Alaudin Muhammad Daud Shah (1790-1795)
    - Sultan ala 'al din Jauhar al alam (1795-1815) and (1818-1824)
    - sultan syarif saif al alam (1815-1818)
    - Sultan Muhammad Shah (1824-1838)
    - Sultan Solomon Shah (1838--1857)
    - Sultan Mansur Shah (1857-1870)
    - Sultan Mahmud Shah (1870-1874)
    - Sultan Muhammad Daud Shah (1874-1903) ..

  • @ikmalm.1324
    @ikmalm.1324 4 роки тому

    Great video. Thanks again

  • @misbahchannel3501
    @misbahchannel3501 2 роки тому +1

    We hope that the United Nations and the international community will revisit the form of the Helsinki MOU that has been mutually agreed upon between GAM and Indonesia.

  • @zein-vLoG
    @zein-vLoG Рік тому +2

    ACEH❤

  • @kamalynwa8020
    @kamalynwa8020 3 роки тому +1

    thank you brother..info aceh freedom..

  • @mcchonky5709
    @mcchonky5709 4 роки тому +15

    hope we can do the same with West Papua!

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +5

      Thanks. Sadly not a situation that gets nearly enough attention. I actually included it in my recent video on the World’s leading independence movements ua-cam.com/video/JumFpE9D610/v-deo.html I hope to do a longer video on it at some point.

    • @syedrahim6889
      @syedrahim6889 3 роки тому +2

      Aceh papua maluku! Independent

    • @mcchonky5709
      @mcchonky5709 3 роки тому +7

      @@syedrahim6889 no

    • @Fylnnn
      @Fylnnn 3 роки тому +3

      @@syedrahim6889 in your dream kiddo 🤣

    • @pbyt3869
      @pbyt3869 3 роки тому

      @@syedrahim6889 and North Sulawesi or Minahasa

  • @kelvinflychtsundberg1861
    @kelvinflychtsundberg1861 4 роки тому +7

    Could you do a video on Königsberg? And how it became Russian? I really don't understand how the founding city of Prussia then later Germany became a part of the Russian Federation.

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +3

      Thanks so much for a great suggestion! I have noted it down. It certainly is a fascinating situation. A strange enclave of Russia that, as you say, was once part of Prussia.

    • @雷-t3j
      @雷-t3j 2 роки тому

      Basically the Germans(who were NAZI's at that point) left at the end of the second world war, and Stalin made sure they left. Whilst it was part of the Soviet Union it was offered to the Lithuanian SSR, but they declined in a display of foresight.

    • @soberman1520
      @soberman1520 Рік тому +1

      It can be called force relocation

  • @satyawirasenajaputra9888
    @satyawirasenajaputra9888 3 роки тому +3

    " How Aceh Separatist movement just gone "
    Simple. A big big blue sea wave make it gone.

    • @josephextrada1207
      @josephextrada1207 2 роки тому

      Bangsa pengemis gak tau diri tanpa aceh indomi lapar

    • @bgdidi8679
      @bgdidi8679 2 роки тому

      dasar indomi lapar tak tau malu

  • @ry1786
    @ry1786 6 місяців тому

    jaya indonesia!!!!!!

  • @DD-pw3cu
    @DD-pw3cu 4 роки тому +11

    Didn't expect this to be the topic of the video, I have never even heard of Aceh! Indonesia seems to have had a lot of disputes in its history.
    Thank you for a video about yet another lesser known topic!
    I find the pronounciation of Aceh odd 🤔

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +3

      Thanks. Yes, when one thinks of Indonesia it tends to be in the context of East Timor or West Papua. Aceh already seems to be fading from memory; a mere 15 years after it was resolved. However, in its day, it was often reported in the international press.

  • @nasruddin3027
    @nasruddin3027 2 роки тому

    greetings from Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam

  • @faz2604
    @faz2604 4 роки тому +4

    But now tensions have returned between Indonesia and Aceh .. because the points of the Helsinki MOU were not implemented by Indonesia such as the flag, human rights court, distribution of natural products and others. it cannot be guaranteed that the conflict will reoccur.

    • @pandepanda31
      @pandepanda31 4 роки тому +5

      To be honest, the Aceh government had been consistent in their failures to deliver net positive development despite the trillions given by the central government. There are two possible causes: either the local government is corrupt as hell, or the money is syphoned into...another part of the world, the middle east- for example

    • @fajaradi1223
      @fajaradi1223 3 роки тому

      @@pandepanda31
      Agreed
      But let's just hope that the future generation will be more educated and well informed about this issue.

    • @protocetus499
      @protocetus499 2 роки тому +1

      @@pandepanda31 yeah blame the Aceh, you are so genius.

    • @CharDhue
      @CharDhue Рік тому

      @@protocetus499 it's just like Papua, surely Indonesia as a whole is corrupt but local governments will likely become more corrupt if given free rein (including Jakarta)
      It's because we have bad law and procedure regarding how to supervise our own local ruler

    • @protocetus499
      @protocetus499 Рік тому +1

      @@CharDhue How about the cultural aspect then? from the beginning, unitary system is not suited for Indonesia. You guys just shove and force that unitary "is So GoOd" "BeST..." bla bla bla. While Indonesia is undeniably better with Federation system, you think those in West Sumatra want to accept Javanese style of governance

  • @imsouw5342
    @imsouw5342 3 роки тому +4

    It would be interesting to see this type of video about the possible unification of Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei Darussalam, Philippines, South Thailand, Timor Leste, and Papua New Guinea to be Nusantara Empire.

    • @glevt
      @glevt 2 роки тому +4

      disgusting idea.

  • @muhammadharithjohari6855
    @muhammadharithjohari6855 4 роки тому +4

    Can you make about Southern Thai ?

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +4

      Thanks a lot for such a great suggestion. I will certainly look into it. There are some issues in SE Asia that receive barely any international attention!

    • @muhammadharithjohari6855
      @muhammadharithjohari6855 4 роки тому

      @@JamesKerLindsay hope you can studies the conflict at there. I have relationship with there as my ancestors came from this region before it was separated long ago.

  • @bentarasumatra223
    @bentarasumatra223 8 місяців тому +1

    Free Aceh 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷

  • @sayutisayuti767
    @sayutisayuti767 3 роки тому +4

    i from aceh, indonesia kolonial ..

  • @andygian5523
    @andygian5523 2 роки тому

    Now Aceh is the only province in Indonesia with Syariah law, yes it's was part of the deal. I'm not saying is good or bad thing, Just so you guys know.

  • @OtenBenaluIndonesia
    @OtenBenaluIndonesia 9 місяців тому +1

    Aceh, jogjakarta sudah menjadi daerah istimewa di Indonesia. Kita tidak perlu perang saudara. Ulama" besar Aceh berdiskusilah dengan NU. Lihat saudara kita di Gaza. Musuh kita sama zionis. Lebih baik kita berperang melawan zionis dari pada perang saudara

  • @Ani60-f4g
    @Ani60-f4g Рік тому

    Yes good

  • @Dai_Abdurrahman
    @Dai_Abdurrahman 3 роки тому +2

    Crazy good

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  3 роки тому

      Thank you!

    • @abcddef2112
      @abcddef2112 3 роки тому

      @@JamesKerLindsay Not really you did not cover darul islam and its direct relation to aceh separatist movement. That explain the key point of the peace agreement the instatement of shariah law in Aceh.
      Of course then Indonesia government get the periodic flak from western media each time theres public caning by Aceh (formerly separatist) government.
      Kinda funny of course EU support the implementation of shariah law in foreign country.

  • @israruddin8816
    @israruddin8816 4 роки тому +1

    30years of political instability and civil unrest has cause Aceh fair struggle to recover economically and socially. In addition, the newly elected govt seems to be so disruptive and bring Aceh Development nowhere.
    As an Acehnese who were born and grew up in Aceh, I feel like at the end the citizens are the one who pay all the cost. Even after the conflict it seems like it never end. Despite Aceh is rangked as the 5th highest provincial budget but the poverty and unemployment still on the button 6th among other Indonesian provinces. There might lots of variables to be solved in order to make Aceh great again. But I don’t see that will happen even after more than 15 years of peace.
    Thanks for the review tho it’s for the academic purpose. 13 minutes seems not enough to highlight the 30years of civil unrest in Aceh.
    My suggestion maybe you can make video about any other part of the world that recover and gain their economic prosperity after the civil war. So, we can learn from those best practices.

    • @muhammadsahlan8189
      @muhammadsahlan8189 Рік тому

      Our Aceh has the same fate with Nepal after Maoist insugency. Former Maoists frontman rebels lift to political saga and swept the victory in the first national elections which held after the 2006 peace deal, but soon fell out of favour as former cadres accused rebel leaders of adopting lavish lifestyles and betraying their sacrifices

  • @desthounf8518
    @desthounf8518 7 місяців тому +1

    😊😊❤❤🎉🎉

  • @mustofalionpiranhanilecroc4105
    @mustofalionpiranhanilecroc4105 4 роки тому

    I'm support you always you're do it sir don't worry I'm you're member

  • @rabbaniazzahra1784
    @rabbaniazzahra1784 4 роки тому +7

    ACEH WE LOVE U
    ure indonesian constantinopel :D
    i just wish the goverment do more to you
    u kicked the western powers like a boss
    and u won againts japan
    and the javanese are still sorry because of them u lost your sultan
    but thank you so much and remember
    insha allah
    god bless your lands :D

    • @tsukiyamagaming8178
      @tsukiyamagaming8178 3 роки тому +4

      www u means aceh kick japan imperial army out of aceh??
      yes..
      but if japan focus only attacking aceh, however our kingdom facing big lose after fighting VOC-portoguese in selat malaka...
      that cause ottoman call back 90% his war ship for back up turk-yaman conflict..
      since that kingdom fall and deutch come more-and more till japan come.. but no one of them realy occopasion aceh region without war except japan, japan imperial army asked to leave their military base in (sabang), and japanese imperial army agree to leave without bringing more than one weapon because achenese ask them to leave ASAP that day if they want their life", japan army leave everything excepet one weapon with and bullet to protect their self and they not facing big problem here in aceh because japan only deals with deutch here..
      aceh killed 2 deutch army general and make deutch goverment angry and send the third general and after that japan come, may be japan entering aceh only looking for deutch general because aceh was one of international trade zone that time..

  • @syedrahim6889
    @syedrahim6889 3 роки тому +2

    Go aceh!

  • @famustvofficial
    @famustvofficial 2 роки тому

    The Indonesian side has so far not kept its MoU in Helsinki promise regarding the Aceh flag and the symbols and other MoU in Helsinki items.

  • @mzf11125
    @mzf11125 4 роки тому +2

    Please do the East Timor conflict

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому

      Thanks so much. Great suggestion. I certainly plan to do a video on East Timor. It is a very interesting case that actually has some parallels with Western Sahara. ua-cam.com/video/x7xRduwFNPg/v-deo.html

  • @NASHRUDDINification
    @NASHRUDDINification 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks you very much mr.james
    I am from aceh. We will independen from indonesia.

    • @andriwahyudani1302
      @andriwahyudani1302 3 роки тому +3

      no

    • @mohammadhijirismail
      @mohammadhijirismail 8 місяців тому

      No, that's an idea that could damage Indonesian sovereignty because we have to remember that many of Indonesia's national heroes are from Aceh

  • @Casper56380
    @Casper56380 4 роки тому +3

    Help free country Aceh🇹🇷🇹🇷
    I from acehnese

    • @Rainbow-zz9oi
      @Rainbow-zz9oi 2 роки тому

      Turkey with you bros

    • @joMan1060
      @joMan1060 Рік тому

      aceh is already free,
      aceh now get their freedom and decided to go back to medieval rule..

  • @anupamhasan2687
    @anupamhasan2687 4 роки тому +5

    Video needs related to India's secessionist s

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +1

      Thanks. I certainly hope to do some videos on India. In case you haven’t seen it, I did one on Bangladesh. Obviously, India’s role in that situation was crucial. ua-cam.com/video/Xp2ljnaoaqs/v-deo.html

    • @anupamhasan2687
      @anupamhasan2687 4 роки тому +1

      @@JamesKerLindsay I have seen mentioned video. It was nice one.

  • @edwaredo617
    @edwaredo617 2 місяці тому

    Kenapa MOU Helsinki negara² internasional tidak lagi mengawalnya?
    Kenapa Atjeh dibiarkan sendiri mengawalnya? Sehingga byk poin² yg tertuang dlm perjanjian tersebut dijalankan oleh pemerintah Indonesia, dan sebagian besar pejuang² Atjeh yang berperang dengan pihak Indonesia sekarang malah berkhianat kpd rakyat Atjeh dengan kenikmatan kekuassan yg mereka peroleh, baik di parlemen daerah ( DPRA dan DPRK) maupun sebagai pemimpin daerah (gubernur dan bupati)..
    kami rakyat Atjeh berharap peran pemerintah internasional untuk terus mengawal MOU Helsinki agar kami bisa menikmati kesejahteraan dari kekayaan bumi yang kami miliki, sehingga anak² kami lebih mampu menikmati pendidikan yg lebih tinggi hingga ke berbagai negara..
    Terimakasih..

  • @IslamistSocialist371
    @IslamistSocialist371 Рік тому

    Aceh Province is like a Country within a country, they decided their rules alone mostly. Like integration of Islamic Rules .

  • @PutraPutra-b9q
    @PutraPutra-b9q Рік тому

    From aceh

  • @legoshi7350
    @legoshi7350 4 роки тому +5

    and west papua?

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +4

      Thanks. It’s certainly on my list - along with East Timor.

  • @misa5309
    @misa5309 4 роки тому

    Good

  • @muhammadsyahril8570
    @muhammadsyahril8570 4 роки тому +1

    Amazing video
    I am GAM from aceh

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +1

      Thank you so much. I appreciate it. What is the situation like over there at the moment?

    • @tsukiyamagaming8178
      @tsukiyamagaming8178 3 роки тому

      bereh" kiban keadan wate droe keh GAM masanyan ??itanyeng le jih (le po channel)

    • @azmiulul2975
      @azmiulul2975 2 роки тому

      Situasi nya sangat rumit

  • @mahmudimayoridi6455
    @mahmudimayoridi6455 4 роки тому +10

    Before there was Indonesia, Aceh was sovereign after Aceh helped Java, then Java betrayed Aceh and slaughtered the Acehnese nation until now the natural products of Aceh were in the colonies and the people were colonized by Java,

    • @IcefPr.
      @IcefPr. 3 роки тому +1

      May I ask, how did the Sumatran Sultans vanished?

    • @ichiroyamada1901
      @ichiroyamada1901 3 роки тому

      @@IcefPr. The communist group during the Indonesian Independence time kill all of them. There are only three prominent monarchs that survive until now in Indonesia. The Sultan of Yogyakarta, the King of Cirebon, and 'proclaimed' Sultan of Tidore.

    • @mrj475
      @mrj475 3 роки тому +3

      Transmigrasi javanese to sumatra from colonial and communism ideology by sukarno killed all of them by transmigrasi people.. i heard sumatra sultanate never wanna be part of indonesia, then the killing happened..

    • @Emjazzuli
      @Emjazzuli 3 роки тому +2

      @@mrj475 how could it be when majority of indonesian founding father are sumatrans? Indonesia itself is the idea of sumatran founding fathers.

    • @pramudyaseven5671
      @pramudyaseven5671 2 роки тому +4

      @@mrj475 funny coz Tan malaka and DN Aidit are sumatran

  • @nurdinamin5901
    @nurdinamin5901 3 роки тому

    Love And Darling Aceh

  • @putrakarasa8810
    @putrakarasa8810 Рік тому +1

    Free acheh

  • @cobayoutube3139
    @cobayoutube3139 4 роки тому +4

    I ask for help from you brother. help Aceh for the sovereignty of Aceh Free Aceh for the people of Aceh

  • @merxho95
    @merxho95 4 роки тому +3

    Aceh was Ottoman-Colony in 16th Century during Sultan Suleyman

    • @JamesKerLindsay
      @JamesKerLindsay  4 роки тому +3

      Yes. Amazing to discover the link between Aceh and the Ottoman Empire. It really does show that the Empire’s reach went far further than most people realise.

    • @merxho95
      @merxho95 4 роки тому +1

      @@JamesKerLindsay Thank you very much James for your videos. Its really interesting to discover lot of different geo-political conflicts.

    • @andikafabian
      @andikafabian 4 роки тому +5

      not a colony, but a vassal

    • @carakayuma8875
      @carakayuma8875 4 роки тому +2

      Not colony, but under protectorate

  • @mahmudimayoridi6455
    @mahmudimayoridi6455 4 роки тому +1

    The people of Aceh until now want Aceh to be independent and sovereign as before there was Indonesia

  • @VishnuQM
    @VishnuQM 3 роки тому

    Another example would be the Kurds reintegrating into Iraq

  • @cobayoutube3139
    @cobayoutube3139 4 роки тому +8

    video that is very interesting to all the people of Aceh to see it .ace is not part of Indonesia and Indonesia is not part of Aceh where the people of Aceh have the right to live under the kingdom of their ancestors is not part of the province of Indonesia which is very barbaric towards its people.

  • @khuddahri2232
    @khuddahri2232 3 роки тому

    But why many peace points cannot be realized after the conflict ends.

  • @SapeuePakat
    @SapeuePakat 11 місяців тому +1

    Many of the MoU points are not realized by the indon government, the government are betraying the Achehnese trust as always, and CMI is careless about it. Therefore many more separatists' ideas are sprouting nowadays. Acheh will soon see even more resistance groups fighting for independence, even larger than before.

    • @mohammadhijirismail
      @mohammadhijirismail 8 місяців тому

      Actually, if we talk about the separatist movement in Sarawak and Sabah in Malaysia there is also an independence movement, although it is not widely expressed to the public because it is to maintain the spirit of Malaysian unity.😊

  • @hendratoh9845
    @hendratoh9845 Рік тому

    Tqu for u video.. Aceh is a my country n iam Acehnese.. my people was fighting so long first with Dutch for 70 Years when Aceh is a empire and State Indonesia there not yet in the world... Dutch colonize Netherlands indie/Indonesia now no Aceh because the Acehnese fighting dutch empire.. after WW2 Indonesia is freedom an work together with Acehnese and then the government Indonesia betray Acehnese and we war For 30 years and killing acehnese more milions etc war stopped because natural disaster Tsunami.. and the we peace with MOU Helsinki where the Aceh country will be like federal state.. until now from 2005-2023 the MOU HELSINKI not yet finish because the government Indonesia to paranoid and hypocrite to Aceh.. so iam a Acehnese maybe we will fighting/war with Indonesia again to make Aceh freedom.... Just remember of you to see video by reporter american(Williams nessen)when aceh war with Indonesia the title video The Black Road.. tqu😊😊😊

  • @fahrulselow2382
    @fahrulselow2382 3 роки тому

    aceh champa race, viet china, their custom was introduced by the Persian Arab Turkish nation

  • @kikywang9997
    @kikywang9997 4 роки тому

    Indonesian ppl, r u in here?

  • @muhammadsalehsaleh9940
    @muhammadsalehsaleh9940 3 роки тому

    Klw boleh cpa yg bisa terjemahkan, sya ucap kan sebanyak banyaknya terimakasih kpd yg terjemah kan 👍

  • @Dinulamri
    @Dinulamri 7 місяців тому

    Aceh merdeka pisah dari indonesia.perjanjian MOU helsingki 15 tahun sekarang sudah 17 tahun.pemerintah Indonesia from blem.

  • @jeffbansos8106
    @jeffbansos8106 Рік тому

    Momentum aceh merdeka dan jawa Indonesia keluar dari sumatra adalah perang dunia!
    Jikalau u.s membutuhkan waktu 10 tahun untuk menginvasi irak, maka u.s akan menginvasi china pada tahun 2028, 10 tahun setelah perang dagang di 2018!

  • @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr
    @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr 8 місяців тому +1

    Negara Aceh darusalam merdeka

  • @ibnuasakir7477
    @ibnuasakir7477 2 роки тому

    Please translate Indonesian from Aceh,don't understand

  • @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr
    @SyahwalSyahwal-se1kr 8 місяців тому +1

    Negara aceh darusalam endependem

  • @safuandi0681
    @safuandi0681 4 роки тому

    Aleh peu kakaprak ke meukutupue that..❤️❤️❤️from ACEH

    • @muhammadsalehsaleh9940
      @muhammadsalehsaleh9940 3 роки тому

      Saban bng long rencana neuk komen lage dreoneuh, tapi apalah daya, krn awai dreoneuh yg komen😂😂😂😂😂👍

  • @Kenatokah_
    @Kenatokah_ Місяць тому

    We, the Acehnese people, only want independence because that is the solution to peace. If Indonesia upholds democracy, then let the Acehnese people decide whether to remain with the Republic of Indonesia or choose independence through a referendum.

  • @muhammadfauzan1728
    @muhammadfauzan1728 4 роки тому +2

    Please substile bay Melayu bahasa

  • @kiahrukiah-u7p
    @kiahrukiah-u7p 9 місяців тому

    Ada orang aceh tak kenal yg bernama indonesia sebab tak punya bahasa tak punya tanah

  • @FSS981
    @FSS981 3 роки тому +3

    So sad for Aceh, country that have been colonised by Indonesia until now.. They help Indonesia during independence but been colonised after Indonesia strong.

    • @Ann_niana
      @Ann_niana 3 роки тому +1

      Indonesia shouldn't help Aceh when they got hit by tsunami then. They pour a lot of money to help Aceh recover from that disaster.

    • @bliss6495
      @bliss6495 2 роки тому +1

      All over Indonesia were hand-in-hand spontaneously organizing aid when tsunami struck Aceh. I was one of them coordinating aids to Meulaboh when it was not accesible, one of my friends an anasthesist in Jakarta with his team of doctors voluntarily flew to Aceh the second day of tsunami. I remember how the whole Indonesia acted in many ways to help Aceh at that time. That I think what many Acehneses also saw which made it easier for integration.

  • @kandaralwi
    @kandaralwi Рік тому

    86 yr

  • @lanaindralak4898
    @lanaindralak4898 Рік тому

    🥰

  • @srisri4031
    @srisri4031 4 роки тому +3

    Free acheh.. Free papua,.. Free Maluku.. Best james

  • @mudawalimudawali8668
    @mudawalimudawali8668 3 роки тому +2

    Aceh is not Indonesia

  • @syedrahim6889
    @syedrahim6889 3 роки тому +2

    West papua go!!!

  • @robertdms1639
    @robertdms1639 3 роки тому

    Aceh saboeh nanggroe yg ka gadoeh diateuh rueung donya

  • @muhammadyasirilyasyasir7749
    @muhammadyasirilyasyasir7749 2 роки тому

    Indonesia jawa banyak sekali melakukan pelanggaran Hak asasi manusia terhadap bangsa Aceh dan sekarang melakukan penipuan terhadap MOU helsingky yang telah ditandatangani,,,,

  • @saifulaceh3911
    @saifulaceh3911 3 роки тому +1

    Aceh is not indonesia

  • @adensaputraaden8848
    @adensaputraaden8848 3 роки тому

    aceh empayer of the king

  • @HuaWei-kl8gg
    @HuaWei-kl8gg 3 роки тому

    Free aceh

  • @mawardiabmawardiab5166
    @mawardiabmawardiab5166 4 роки тому +1

    help us in aceh

  • @muhammadnur3583
    @muhammadnur3583 4 роки тому

    idroe kuh hana ku tupeu peu yg jipeugah,meuka kunonton aju