I enjoy the game and I understand it well enough to see the strategy in it, but Tom is completely right about the rule book and components. It has some big issues.
I agree baseball highlights is much easier to get into and enjoy right away, but football also is a good game. Football needs several games to understand and implement the strategies - app is a great help here. I see a critical error play in this video causing too much safety points, defensive minus yard has to be subtracted from the offensive yard - not from current position. With this error fixed, i say this game grasps good feeling of football for its weight
I only partially agree here. I do believe that Baseball Highlights is a better game. However Football highlights is a good game...just different. The key here is that you really have to use your audibles well. If one of the cards you drafted at half time is not in your hand, you use the audibles to get them into your hand. Add to this the fact that it is a drafting game instead of a deckbuilder and you get something interesting. Note there is an app for this one too. Both this app and the Baseball Highlights apps are not the prettiest but they do get the job done (especially during COVID).
Sorry but I disagree. This game is a lot of fun. The more you play it you understand the strategy of deciding when to give and take. On the surface you just try to win every turn but that won’t win you the game. Sometimes it’s better to give up a 25 yard gain to be able to shut down the drive or to counter perfectly. Play the app and you’ll see.
wow - that's too bad this didn't click with Tom. I own this game and really enjoy playing it with others and solo. Skip the rulebook, there are some very good how to play videos on you tube. I also enjoy Baseball Highlights.
The gameplay becomes better the more you know the teams and the cards. The strategy DOES get deeper. I'd say it is good, but it does not reach the heights of Baseball Highlights. The rules - yes, I concede that they are structured poorly. And for first plays, yes, I concede that it would appear as though you're just "reacting" to the cards as they are put down - but their are more choices to make than appear to you on those first few games. I call this one good, but not great.
I loved Baseball Highlights so much and was pumped for the Kickstarter, but watching the videos and rules on it during that time, I did not end up backing it. To be honest, I kind of forgot about it since then. Baseball Highlights is amazing, stick with that, folks.
While I agree that BH is a better game I really really like this one too. But I’m also a huge football fan, followed the development closely, and watched a lot of videos before I played it. So I totally get where Tom is coming from.
I completely agree Tom! I backed this on Kickstarter and feel ripped off. I love football, board games and baseball highlights and I can’t even figure out how to play this game. This is the worst rule book I’ve ever struggled through and there isn’t a how to play video online. It gameplay creates lots of edge cases and those are impossible to resolve with this rule book too.
I've played the app version of both games, Baseball Highlights is the far better game. Football Highlights just feels too random and the graphic design is a mess.
I enjoy the game and I understand it well enough to see the strategy in it, but Tom is completely right about the rule book and components. It has some big issues.
I agree baseball highlights is much easier to get into and enjoy right away, but football also is a good game. Football needs several games to understand and implement the strategies - app is a great help here.
I see a critical error play in this video causing too much safety points, defensive minus yard has to be subtracted from the offensive yard - not from current position. With this error fixed, i say this game grasps good feeling of football for its weight
I haven't even played mine yet with how confusing and convoluted it was to figure it out. Glad to hear I'm not the only one struggling.
If anyone ever doubted if Tom's reviews are impartial, this answers it. Him and his crew get put into the game and he still slammed it. Wow.
Lmao
I only partially agree here. I do believe that Baseball Highlights is a better game. However Football highlights is a good game...just different. The key here is that you really have to use your audibles well. If one of the cards you drafted at half time is not in your hand, you use the audibles to get them into your hand. Add to this the fact that it is a drafting game instead of a deckbuilder and you get something interesting.
Note there is an app for this one too. Both this app and the Baseball Highlights apps are not the prettiest but they do get the job done (especially during COVID).
This was I was hoping would be good, but sounds like its baseball highlights is the way to go.
Sorry but I disagree. This game is a lot of fun. The more you play it you understand the strategy of deciding when to give and take. On the surface you just try to win every turn but that won’t win you the game. Sometimes it’s better to give up a 25 yard gain to be able to shut down the drive or to counter perfectly. Play the app and you’ll see.
Great review Tom! Keep up the good work!
wow - that's too bad this didn't click with Tom. I own this game and really enjoy playing it with others and solo. Skip the rulebook, there are some very good how to play videos on you tube. I also enjoy Baseball Highlights.
The gameplay becomes better the more you know the teams and the cards. The strategy DOES get deeper. I'd say it is good, but it does not reach the heights of Baseball Highlights. The rules - yes, I concede that they are structured poorly. And for first plays, yes, I concede that it would appear as though you're just "reacting" to the cards as they are put down - but their are more choices to make than appear to you on those first few games. I call this one good, but not great.
I loved Baseball Highlights so much and was pumped for the Kickstarter, but watching the videos and rules on it during that time, I did not end up backing it. To be honest, I kind of forgot about it since then. Baseball Highlights is amazing, stick with that, folks.
While I agree that BH is a better game I really really like this one too. But I’m also a huge football fan, followed the development closely, and watched a lot of videos before I played it. So I totally get where Tom is coming from.
I love baseball highlights, and probably one day will get football highlights. Am looking forward to it.
I completely agree Tom! I backed this on Kickstarter and feel ripped off. I love football, board games and baseball highlights and I can’t even figure out how to play this game. This is the worst rule book I’ve ever struggled through and there isn’t a how to play video online. It gameplay creates lots of edge cases and those are impossible to resolve with this rule book too.
Final judgment -fumble
Dang, was hoping this was a bit better. I like the Football theme better than baseball...but I may try Baseball highlights now
Can we add this game to the list of worst box art of all time list? Why do we need three images of the same dude?
Game boy geek said its the best game he played all year. Funny how opinions differ so much
So maul is double-edged?
Yes. Maul cards are great for defense but terrible for offense.
Could have been an opportunity to iterate on the baseball game both visually and gameplay wise...it just looks like a HUGE turn off
Hockey Highlights... Slapshot/Phantoms of the Ice.
I've played the app version of both games, Baseball Highlights is the far better game. Football Highlights just feels too random and the graphic design is a mess.
I have the game, and I was wondering if I was crazy because I could not figure out how to play it--even when I watched videos. Disappointing.
Game boy geek gave this game a glowing review. Love the Dice Tower, but this review was unfair to what is otherwise a solid game.
Unfair how? Dan I just disagree on this one, that's all.
Totally agree. I played this as a prototype and didn't like it.
Not surprised it's an EGG with a really horrible rulebook.
Hello
Rulebook is really bad....