It required an Engineer turned a dedicated Dharmic 🕉️ devotee to explain in such beautiful detail to make what our Rishis did for us ages ago. Pranams to you Sinju Joseph ji🙏🏼 May the Bhagavan bless you with long and healthy life🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼
आज से हजारों सालों पहले विशाल भारतवर्ष में सामान्य वर्ग को धर्म और शास्त्र समजाने और कायम याद रखने की एक विशिष्ट रीत थी और ऐसी प्रणाली में लीखे हूये पुराणों और शास्त्रों को ऐसी द्रष्टि चाहिए। सनातन के विरोधी लोगों को गुमराह कर ते है। ऐसी मानवतावादी सोच कोई विशेष वर्ग विरोधी कैसे हों सकतीं हैं????? बहन जी आपको लाख लाख वंदन। आप मानवता की सही सेवा करतीं हैं।
Ms Sinu Joseph, your knowledge is profound, your dedication to understand and explain shastras and especially varnas are simply amazing - Thank you so much. Please keep up the great work to spread the truth. I heard and, to some extent, agree that classification of people were there long before even Vedas were revealed to the rishis. Vedas gave clarity about these classifications of people with varnas. In Gita, even Lord Krishna, clearly said varnas are not by birth but by their Gunas. Bottom line - foreigners exploited the varnas to divide and break Hinduism while Indians fell for it and got destroyed them selves. I hope people, instead of wasting their time in varnas, caste, and creed, in these times, lead to Athma Jnana and realize the beauty of Vedas and Upanishads.
Namaste, Knowing that the provided explanations are aiding those seeking to enrich their understanding of their culture is truly rewarding. The recognition of this endeavour is deeply valued. Thank you once more.
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫 Don’t be misled just because someone is wearing a saree and bindi. 🔴 Here’s the truth: • Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth. • Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪 • Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa. Historical Examples: • Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑 • Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a Brahmin sage and is revered in the Vedic tradition. 🧘♂️ Reference from the Gita (4.13): “Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.” The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚 In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫 Here’s the truth: • Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth. • Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪 • Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa. Historical Examples: • Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑 • Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a sage. 🧘♂️ Reference from the Gita (4.13): “Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.” The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚 In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
@@prasenjeetrathore My friend may be she was unable to make u understand what she means. U r quoting from Shree Bhagavath Geeta..but u r not accepting the other verses of the same divine book, where Lord Shri Krishna says..birth is based on previous karma to realise Supreme Brahman(ultimate consciousness)through birth position(that said it doesn’t mean that Brahman born will easily attain ultimate consciousness easily or vice-versa)…Bhagwat Gita. Verse 6.37- 6.47
Amazing work and brilliant explanations. Thank you Ms. Joseph. Have followed your work extraordinary work on educating young women about their own bodies and the rather ill informed and hence, nonsensical taboos that still exists. You may not agree, but your knowledge and effort to spread it, you certainly are a Brahmana, perhaps even more than any of us who claim to be.
Thanks Ojashvi ji for presenting such a learned personality sinu Joseph ji possessed with comprehensive profound knowledge of our sacred vedas & shastras with exceptional analytical skills. Indeed, the presentation was a marvelous and authentic description of contents contained in our ancient scriptures.
Outstanding Madam When the most important point of eligibility of Moksha in this Janma itself was explained irrespective of Varanas... I was only looking at this point
Simply profound! Few of us Indians are aware that the interpretations of many of the primary Indian scriptural texts have been given to us by western scholars who translated them or reinterpreted available translations. Very few of these studied Sanskrit for scholarly undertakings of such magnitude, filled with nuances and subtleties that revealed themselves only to those who were able to touch the soul of dharmic thought and experience. Unfortunately for us, these rank cultural outsiders have set the template and tone for our understanding of these supreme concepts that were transmitted over vast spans of time through an unbroken chain of realised - revealed spiritual knowledge of the highest order. Thanks to the colonial project, these profound truths were mangled and grossly distorted when forced to fit into the constraining conceptual vessels of western polemical thought like post modernism , marxism, scientific materialism and rational secularism. Many Indians, young and old alike, prefer to view India's civilisational legacy and, in particular, it's sacred texts through this lens of western literary scholarship and critical thinking, allowing no space for a different (more culturally appropriate) perception and understanding of these ancient writings. We need more Indians like Sinu who can interpret these ancient and forgotten texts for us using the unique markers - language and symbols - of our own civilizational culture and context. Once we understand the operating principles behind Varna Vidya as Sinu outlines it, we can see how they impact our lives at so many fundamental levels, from communal unrest to caste politics and woke thinking as a social trend rapidly gaining ground in India today. I have often wondered why many Government servants (at various levels) who came to their jobs through reservation quotas are incompetent or corrupt, sometimes both. I think varna vidya offers some answers to this painful as it is for us to acknowledge.
28.50 In this context, the characteristics of a Sudra are linked to the Earth element (Prithvi). People with a dominant Earth element are believed to possess qualities such as: 1. Stability and grounding 2. Practicality and hard work 3. Loyalty and dedication 4. Simplicity and humility 5. Physical strength and endurance These qualities are considered essential for individuals in the Sudra varna, who traditionally engaged in manual labor, craftsmanship, and service-oriented professions.
But there will always be an explanation. But we have to dig deep. But what? We don't understand is that when we dig deep we find that we are in a deeper hole than we were. As Hindus we look at the hole only after we have dug the entire way.
@@venkateshprabhu7027u did not answer my question just like Muslim don't make jalebi I can do whatever becoz ishwar made me complete and without flaws for that I don't need permission of Brahmin
Madam Unlike abrahamical religions one lifetime theory, in Sanathana we have cyclic Life and death i.e. Reincarnation theory. That means, a man born in brahmana Varna, if strays in his conduct as defined in shastras can take birth in any other Verna, and a Pious Shudra this life , if live in Pious ways, will certainly take birth as brahmin or other varnas. For one life theorists, this doesn't go in their understandings.
Not the britishers exactly. Why didn't Hindus acknowledge that anybody who happens to be born in a brahman's house is a Brahmin. Most of them are sudras. It is from this acknowledgment that we start building back the science. Otherwise all this lecture is just hogwash.
52:20 A peon today should not sit tomorrow in the Chairman’s chair; because if done so, the organization will fall. However if the Chairman goes to the photostat machine and takes a copy of a document, the organization would still survive😂😂😂
The 3&4th Varna has to directly participate in the production for society like reproductive system 2nd has to Protect the produce distribute and nourish all 1 at verna has to be innovative judgemental coordinator for the full function of the body called society It's simple
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫 Don’t be misled just because someone is wearing a saree and bindi. 🔴 Here’s the truth: • Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth. • Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪 • Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa. Historical Examples: • Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑 • Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a Brahmin sage and is revered in the Vedic tradition. 🧘♂️ Reference from the Gita (4.13): “Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.” The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚 In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
I am studying geeta and started taking pride in my culture and u just ruined it... Can u tell someone that ur child born in low frequency and he is born to serve others..
Whether you like to tell your child or not, that is reality of world, people are born with different qualities. We can argue if Varna was meant to be birth based or not, but every society needs mainly these 4 types of people to work properly. If your society has less of any one of these that society will have to import it from other societies. Varna vyavashtha are just the rules described to limit each varna's power.
Please never get discouraged by any one's lecture, no matter what. Carry on with gaining knowledge, how can one deny your vibration to learn and grow. Possibly you have brahmana Vibration. How can one say you are not being guided by supreme conscious?
Society is filled with categorization. If you had a person in ur family who is not able to come up with decisions, u would never include that person for decision making thus categorizing that person is a different way. There is nothing called equality and it is never possible. Even a Husband and Wife never treat each other equally. Behavior and capability plays a big role.
Disappointed! Appalled! Earlier I had such great respect for this author, for her general concerns, as a woman speaking aloud about menstruation and so on. Now, I'm deeply disappointed.. I do respect, but can't stand this misleading. The explanations strung together are wrong and inconsistent in so many ways.. Not an expert, but a student of physics will find this BS. Some mention is made about "resonant frequency", and something is said that when a lady shouts in a shrill voice the glass breaks... Does the author even understand that the glass is breaking *at the resonant frequency / its harmonic? Then, suddenly jumps into electron getting some energy, falling off an orbit releasing light (EM wave), electron losing atom (or was it atom losing electron?) and free radicals... What's all this she's cooking up? First, if the author deliberates to study physics (without any prejudice), and understand the basic concepts, she will herself find out that her stringing of all these is totally inconsistent! I don't see the host being competent either... Viewers? देवानां प्रियाः 😢... Varna being color, varna being sound of the alphabet, varna being emotion/explanation - all that is OK, we may agree or disagree. But to tell that we are made up of *certain atoms from birth to death - and the same atoms remain! What! Every moment millions of cells undergo death(and are thrown out of the body, with the billions of constituent atoms), millions more are born(from the new food intake, with fully new atoms) ; speaking biologically all atoms within a living body get replaced completely in a duration of about few years. Only in a dead body the atoms (most, not all) remain as is. So, as all atoms get replaced(even as you do every single breathe out), where is the "atoms at birth" leading to varna at birth - remains till death ? Many such inconsistent concepts have been just stuck together, sounding to make it look like a "theory". The target audience is more captivated merely by the way of presentation.. Unfortunate!
Can i read and understand ved and upnishad if am not brahmin/answer is yes Can u distinguished people in jatis in this modern world..then what's the point of this misguided lecture ..
Anyone who submits to the knowledge will understand. What i mean when i say submit is... if you are trying to understand by yourself, (I don't believe anyone to teach me what my ancestors have written Thousands of years ago... because humans/gurus these days have their own biases. It is next to impossible for many to find unbiased gurus in present times. As a Hindu everyone is having their own moral compass. Which when we tune based on our ancestors way of thinking, it will always guide us towards the truth even without gurus. But one should not become delusional in the learning process. That is the only requirement. From childhood you might have come across few children who no matter how someone teaches them, they will not understand anything. only 2 possible explanations for it, either teaching process is wrong or Child's is not able to learn because of his brain's ability. Maybe over time he might or might not learn.) remove all influences you might have till this point. Allow your mind to think from their perspective, till you finish learning and understanding. Keep connecting the dots. I hope you have enough understanding of our ancestors unbiased, unrestricted ways of thinking and approaching a problem to solve. If you are sincerely and genuinely trying to learn and understand, keep anger aside and allow your eye of wisdom to reach... that level of understand and world view. You will find your peace at some point. As our ancestors said, "Question and that is the way to the truth." But i will add... at the same time invest enough time to find and understand the answer. Our Culture is not for lazy minds, its dynamic nature humbles anyone, when they understand it.
Anyone can read and learn Vedas. There is no stopping. If you are serious to learn full-time, TTD(Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanam) us running a college in Vijayawada where anyone can learn these subjects and post completion you will also be given some job as per availability.
Read about who NammaAzhwar was before he started learning Sanskrit/Tamil literatures and . Learn who Lord Ram, Shri Krishna were. Were they all Brahmins?? Find the answer which will in turn answer ur queries.
I think knowing and practicing is different. We can know all about the Vedas, what it is and what it says etc. if we read books, especially the books that are the lectures of Acharya of Kanchi Mutt i.e. Mahaperiyava. In fact, Sinu Joseph quotes and takes support for her work from what Mahaperiyava has said. If we strictly go by what she is saying, that women cannot learn the Vedas, then she couldn't have written this book without knowing what the various Vedas and Samhitas contain. You can read the 'Voice of God' book which contains all of Mahaperiyava's teachings. He says everything one needs to know to get an understanding of the Vedas. But knowing doesn't mean one can practice it. That is what Sinu Joseph wants to tell us. She has written even more elaborately what is the path that is prescribed for women, because that is her research interest. What does spirituality mean for women. So there is a two volume book detailing it called Sthree Dharma Paddatihi. It is huge and detailed. But before she released this work, she wanted to clarify why the Vedas take this stance of excluding the Sudra Varna and women from learning Vedas. So for that purpose she released the Varna Vidya. I can understand how it must feel to hear what she says for I also felt upset and let down. But all she is saying is to follow the path that is most apt for us to get the best results in this spiritual life. And for women and Sudra Varna, it is Saranagati or surrender to the Lord. Of course, one may debate how many of the Brahmins are actually Brahmins when they don't even do the basic Sandhyavandhana. In fact Mahaperiyava also says, if Sandhyavandhanam has not been performed for three consecutive generations, then they lose the brahminhood status. There are lot of technicalities involved in how one may lose the tri-varnika status and become a sudra. However, this doesn't affect what Sinu Joseph is saying which is that one can never ascend to a higher Varna in this birth. He may exhibit qualities of a Brahmana Varna, but the biological reality doesn't change and he remains a Sudra. Whereas, the opposite is definitely possible i.e. a brahmana becoming a sudra because of not following his austerities. So there is much sense to what she is saying. Don't they say that in Kali Yuga, it is bhakti yoga alone which will take us close to God, and there is no need for any tough austerities like in the other yugas? I think it is in line with this biological reality of Varna Dharma that Sinu Joseph is saying. Brahmins don't follow their Kula dharma, instead take up material occupations and go after money, and thereby they lose the status of Brahmin. So in the Kali Yuga, we will see mostly only the Sudra Varna as time progresses. And for Sudra Varna, the prescribed path is Saranagathi (Nyasa Vidya). This is not Bhakthi Yoga like Sinu Joseph is saying. I think she has got the names confused here about Nyasa Vidya/Saranagathi being Bhakthi Yoga. Actually Bhakthi Yoga is for the tri-varnika. It is Nyasa Vidya that is for Sudra and Women. And as Kali Yuga progresses, human kind will only deteriorate further. So falling from the higher Varna to a lower Varna in the same birth will happen. But ascending to a higher Varna will never happen in this birth! So we see things getting worse and worse in Kali, before Kalki comes and brings us back to Satya Yuga.
@@thiruvetti u read and understand before defending a Christian teaching hindu scriptures....I know u have problem...but in north we don't study hindu granth from christian and Muslim...
It required an Engineer turned a dedicated Dharmic 🕉️ devotee to explain in such beautiful detail to make what our Rishis did for us ages ago. Pranams to you Sinju Joseph ji🙏🏼 May the Bhagavan bless you with long and healthy life🙏🏼🕉️🙏🏼
आज से हजारों सालों पहले विशाल भारतवर्ष में सामान्य वर्ग को धर्म और शास्त्र समजाने और कायम याद रखने की एक विशिष्ट रीत थी और ऐसी प्रणाली में लीखे हूये पुराणों और शास्त्रों को ऐसी द्रष्टि चाहिए।
सनातन के विरोधी लोगों को गुमराह कर ते है।
ऐसी मानवतावादी सोच कोई विशेष वर्ग विरोधी कैसे हों सकतीं हैं?????
बहन जी
आपको लाख लाख वंदन।
आप मानवता की सही सेवा करतीं हैं।
Namaste Sinu Josephji. Salute you for your service to humanity and ultimately to Sanatana Dharma.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Ms Sinu Joseph, your knowledge is profound, your dedication to understand and explain shastras and especially varnas are simply amazing - Thank you so much.
Please keep up the great work to spread the truth.
I heard and, to some extent, agree that classification of people were there long before even Vedas were revealed to the rishis. Vedas gave clarity about these classifications of people with varnas. In Gita, even Lord Krishna, clearly said varnas are not by birth but by their Gunas.
Bottom line - foreigners exploited the varnas to divide and break Hinduism while Indians fell for it and got destroyed them selves.
I hope people, instead of wasting their time in varnas, caste, and creed, in these times, lead to Athma Jnana and realize the beauty of Vedas and Upanishads.
Namaste,
Knowing that the provided explanations are aiding those seeking to enrich their understanding of their culture is truly rewarding. The recognition of this endeavour is deeply valued. Thank you once more.
You are the one among very few who understands why Varna is by birth and not by karma.
Very clear understanding
Excellent work
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫
Don’t be misled just because someone is wearing a saree and bindi. 🔴
Here’s the truth:
• Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth.
• Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪
• Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa.
Historical Examples:
• Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑
• Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a Brahmin sage and is revered in the Vedic tradition. 🧘♂️
Reference from the Gita (4.13):
“Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.”
The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚
In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
Very good presentation. I felt very happy to have listened to a meaningful talk after a long time. Thank you.
I have waited for this explanation for years. My mind is in subtle ananda while listening to this masterpiece.
She is one in a million. Great understanding of ancient knowledge and modern science.👌👌👏👏💐💐
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫
Here’s the truth:
• Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth.
• Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪
• Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa.
Historical Examples:
• Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑
• Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a sage. 🧘♂️
Reference from the Gita (4.13):
“Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.”
The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚
In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
@@prasenjeetrathore My friend may be she was unable to make u understand what she means.
U r quoting from Shree Bhagavath Geeta..but u r not accepting the other verses of the same divine book, where Lord Shri Krishna says..birth is based on previous karma to realise Supreme Brahman(ultimate consciousness)through birth position(that said it doesn’t mean that Brahman born will easily attain ultimate consciousness easily or vice-versa)…Bhagwat Gita. Verse 6.37- 6.47
Brilliantly explained 🙏
Salute to your profound knowledge
Simply wonderful and eye-opening. Many thanks to Sinu akka for sharing these insights.
Amazing work and brilliant explanations. Thank you Ms. Joseph. Have followed your work extraordinary work on educating young women about their own bodies and the rather ill informed and hence, nonsensical taboos that still exists. You may not agree, but your knowledge and effort to spread it, you certainly are a Brahmana, perhaps even more than any of us who claim to be.
I am going to buy Mam’s book( this is the way I can contribute her…Please support such people in what way possible).🙏
It’s always a pleasure to hear SINU JOSEPH all set to dive deep into her Research thank you “ Centre for Indic Studies “ for this Upload👍❤️
Quantum biology explained in layman’s language! Great!!!
Thanks Ojashvi ji for presenting such a learned personality sinu Joseph ji possessed with comprehensive profound knowledge of our sacred vedas & shastras with exceptional analytical skills. Indeed, the presentation was a marvelous and authentic description of contents contained in our ancient scriptures.
Madame, this is one of the best descriptions I have ever heard. Fabulous.
Wonderful maam, delightful
Wow so much research and such clarity. One of the best videos I have seen. Hats off to Ms Sinu Joseph
Your research is amazing as always mam. So facinating just listening to your understanding of Shastras...And I just ordered the book Sinu Joseph ji.
Excellent & well researched presentation. Congratulations
Ms Sinu Joseph. This work is very Excellent.
Now I am understaning theosophical occult science 👍 thank you very much 🙏
Outstanding Madam
When the most important point of eligibility of Moksha in this Janma itself was explained irrespective of Varanas... I was only looking at this point
Pranam to you Pujya Sinu Joeph.❤❤❤❤
Such thorough knowledge...! Thank you madam, very enlightening. ❤😊
Great, this may we call the exact Bhashya (भाष्यम्) of Shastras
Great 👍🙏
U are wonderful mam pranam
Simply profound!
Few of us Indians are aware that the interpretations of many of the primary Indian scriptural texts have been given to us by western scholars who translated them or reinterpreted available translations.
Very few of these studied Sanskrit for scholarly undertakings of such magnitude, filled with nuances and subtleties that revealed themselves only to those who were able to touch the soul of dharmic thought and experience.
Unfortunately for us, these rank cultural outsiders have set the template and tone for our understanding of these supreme concepts that were transmitted over vast spans of time through an unbroken chain of realised - revealed spiritual knowledge of the highest order.
Thanks to the colonial project, these profound truths were mangled and grossly distorted when forced to fit into the constraining conceptual vessels of western polemical thought like post modernism , marxism, scientific materialism and rational secularism.
Many Indians, young and old alike, prefer to view India's civilisational legacy and, in particular, it's sacred texts through this lens of western literary scholarship and critical thinking, allowing no space for a different (more culturally appropriate) perception and understanding of these ancient writings.
We need more Indians like Sinu who can interpret these ancient and forgotten texts for us using the unique markers - language and symbols - of our own civilizational culture and context.
Once we understand the operating principles behind Varna Vidya as Sinu outlines it, we can see how they impact our lives at so many fundamental levels, from communal unrest to caste politics and woke thinking as a social trend rapidly gaining ground in India today.
I have often wondered why many Government servants (at various levels) who came to their jobs through reservation quotas are incompetent or corrupt, sometimes both. I think varna vidya offers some answers to this painful as it is for us to acknowledge.
🙏🙏🙏 Dhanyavada Mata ji.🙏🙏🙏
🙏🙏 Jay shree ram 🙏🙏
28.50
In this context, the characteristics of a Sudra are linked to the Earth element (Prithvi). People with a dominant Earth element are believed to possess qualities such as:
1. Stability and grounding
2. Practicality and hard work
3. Loyalty and dedication
4. Simplicity and humility
5. Physical strength and endurance
These qualities are considered essential for individuals in the Sudra varna, who traditionally engaged in manual labor, craftsmanship, and service-oriented professions.
Vidushi of the highest order 🙏👏👏
नमोनमः
Great discussion!🙏🙏🙏
We should normalise Varna vyavastha again!
Wonderful!!!
Bahenji
Keep on writing.
How can I procure this book.??
Book ordered!!!
Chhandas have rashmi like string theory tell 64 vibration but in physical all will be lessed. Very well explained 🙏🙏
40.08
If Rishi's could see the colors emitted by their varnas, why Parushuram could not see the light from Karna, who was a kshtria by birth?
But there will always be an explanation. But we have to dig deep. But what? We don't understand is that when we dig deep we find that we are in a deeper hole than we were. As Hindus we look at the hole only after we have dug the entire way.
जय श्री कृष्ण ❤
Is Shambu"s episode mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana,the original Ramayana.
It's there in the gitapress edition
Namaskaram Sinu ji
Very well.explained. thanks 🙏🙏
I admire your work madam.
So do u think I am not allowed to read ved ...if u am not brahmin by birth.
@@madhavrekwar3552 ofcourse you can do whatever you want to meet your needs.
Forget about the VARNA. All human beings are one.
@@venkateshprabhu7027u did not answer my question just like Muslim don't make jalebi
I can do whatever becoz ishwar made me complete and without flaws for that I don't need permission of Brahmin
@@venkateshprabhu7027than what were u admiring in this lecture... Casteism
R u from south part of india
What is Sinu Joseph's Varna
Thank you
Namaskaram Sinuji
💯🙏🏾🙏🏾
The problem is many and more are not made accessible to such things
In the name of their religion
Ammaaa 🙏🙏🙏
🙏
Madam
Unlike abrahamical religions one lifetime theory, in Sanathana we have cyclic Life and death i.e. Reincarnation theory.
That means, a man born in brahmana Varna, if strays in his conduct as defined in shastras can take birth in any other Verna, and a Pious Shudra this life , if live in Pious ways, will certainly take birth as brahmin or other varnas.
For one life theorists, this doesn't go in their understandings.
Namaste
56:00
Sri Rama wore white and red.
Sri Krishna wore yellow and blue/black
After a long long time Sinu ji 🙏
U people are casteist..
🙏
🙏🙏
For what .. misguiding u😂😂😂
👍🙏
🙏💪🚩🔱🚩💪🙏
❤
Very interesting.
Sinu ji please 🙏 make video in hindi
Britishers and missionaries have done so much injustice to varna system with their own caste system.
Not the britishers exactly. Why didn't Hindus acknowledge that anybody who happens to be born in a brahman's house is a Brahmin. Most of them are sudras. It is from this acknowledgment that we start building back the science. Otherwise all this lecture is just hogwash.
@nehrumantri830 it seems that you are brainwashed...
52:20
A peon today should not sit tomorrow in the Chairman’s chair; because if done so, the organization will fall. However if the Chairman goes to the photostat machine and takes a copy of a document, the organization would still survive😂😂😂
The 3&4th Varna has to directly participate in the production for
society like reproductive system
2nd has to Protect the produce distribute and nourish all
1 at verna has to be innovative judgemental coordinator
for the full function of the body called society
It's simple
Interesting. But you are beating around the bush.
Explain how??
🚫 Incorrect Explanation Alert! 🚫
Don’t be misled just because someone is wearing a saree and bindi. 🔴
Here’s the truth:
• Varna is determined by skills and qualities, not birth.
• Everyone starts as a Shudra (labourer) and can shift their Varna based on their abilities. 💪
• Varna is fluid: Throughout history, many who were once considered Shudras became Kings/Kshatriyas, and vice versa.
Historical Examples:
• Shudra to King: Raja Bhoj, a notable king of the Paramara dynasty. 👑
• Kshatriya to Brahmin: Vishwamitra, initially a Kshatriya, transformed into a Brahmin sage and is revered in the Vedic tradition. 🧘♂️
Reference from the Gita (4.13):
“Chaturvarnyam maya srishtam guna-karma-vibhagashah.”
The Vedas don’t prescribe fixed Varna roles. Instead, Varna describes the different professions in society and how they fit together. 📚
In addition, various smriti’s have different take on varnas and are in general more flexible. Hence throughout India the practice of Varna varied from one place to another.
I am studying geeta and started taking pride in my culture and u just ruined it...
Can u tell someone that ur child born in low frequency and he is born to serve others..
Whether you like to tell your child or not, that is reality of world, people are born with different qualities.
We can argue if Varna was meant to be birth based or not, but every society needs mainly these 4 types of people to work properly. If your society has less of any one of these that society will have to import it from other societies.
Varna vyavashtha are just the rules described to limit each varna's power.
Please never get discouraged by any one's lecture, no matter what. Carry on with gaining knowledge, how can one deny your vibration to learn and grow. Possibly you have brahmana Vibration. How can one say you are not being guided by supreme conscious?
Society is filled with categorization. If you had a person in ur family who is not able to come up with decisions, u would never include that person for decision making thus categorizing that person is a different way.
There is nothing called equality and it is never possible. Even a Husband and Wife never treat each other equally. Behavior and capability plays a big role.
@@thiruvetti u must be from Brahmin or rich person.... A family can't be happy and grow if they don't have consensus..
Disappointed! Appalled! Earlier I had such great respect for this author, for her general concerns, as a woman speaking aloud about menstruation and so on. Now, I'm deeply disappointed.. I do respect, but can't stand this misleading.
The explanations strung together are wrong and inconsistent in so many ways.. Not an expert, but a student of physics will find this BS.
Some mention is made about "resonant frequency", and something is said that when a lady shouts in a shrill voice the glass breaks... Does the author even understand that the glass is breaking *at the resonant frequency / its harmonic?
Then, suddenly jumps into electron getting some energy, falling off an orbit releasing light (EM wave), electron losing atom (or was it atom losing electron?) and free radicals... What's all this she's cooking up?
First, if the author deliberates to study physics (without any prejudice), and understand the basic concepts, she will herself find out that her stringing of all these is totally inconsistent!
I don't see the host being competent either... Viewers? देवानां प्रियाः 😢...
Varna being color, varna being sound of the alphabet, varna being emotion/explanation - all that is OK, we may agree or disagree. But to tell that we are made up of *certain atoms from birth to death - and the same atoms remain! What! Every moment millions of cells undergo death(and are thrown out of the body, with the billions of constituent atoms), millions more are born(from the new food intake, with fully new atoms) ; speaking biologically all atoms within a living body get replaced completely in a duration of about few years. Only in a dead body the atoms (most, not all) remain as is. So, as all atoms get replaced(even as you do every single breathe out), where is the "atoms at birth" leading to varna at birth - remains till death ?
Many such inconsistent concepts have been just stuck together, sounding to make it look like a "theory". The target audience is more captivated merely by the way of presentation..
Unfortunate!
Can i read and understand ved and upnishad if am not brahmin/answer is yes
Can u distinguished people in jatis in this modern world..then what's the point of this misguided lecture ..
Anyone who submits to the knowledge will understand. What i mean when i say submit is... if you are trying to understand by yourself, (I don't believe anyone to teach me what my ancestors have written Thousands of years ago... because humans/gurus these days have their own biases. It is next to impossible for many to find unbiased gurus in present times. As a Hindu everyone is having their own moral compass. Which when we tune based on our ancestors way of thinking, it will always guide us towards the truth even without gurus. But one should not become delusional in the learning process. That is the only requirement. From childhood you might have come across few children who no matter how someone teaches them, they will not understand anything. only 2 possible explanations for it, either teaching process is wrong or Child's is not able to learn because of his brain's ability. Maybe over time he might or might not learn.) remove all influences you might have till this point. Allow your mind to think from their perspective, till you finish learning and understanding. Keep connecting the dots. I hope you have enough understanding of our ancestors unbiased, unrestricted ways of thinking and approaching a problem to solve. If you are sincerely and genuinely trying to learn and understand, keep anger aside and allow your eye of wisdom to reach... that level of understand and world view. You will find your peace at some point. As our ancestors said, "Question and that is the way to the truth." But i will add... at the same time invest enough time to find and understand the answer. Our Culture is not for lazy minds, its dynamic nature humbles anyone, when they understand it.
Anyone can read and learn Vedas. There is no stopping.
If you are serious to learn full-time, TTD(Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanam) us running a college in Vijayawada where anyone can learn these subjects and post completion you will also be given some job as per availability.
Read about who NammaAzhwar was before he started learning Sanskrit/Tamil literatures and . Learn who Lord Ram, Shri Krishna were. Were they all Brahmins??
Find the answer which will in turn answer ur queries.
I think knowing and practicing is different. We can know all about the Vedas, what it is and what it says etc. if we read books, especially the books that are the lectures of Acharya of Kanchi Mutt i.e. Mahaperiyava. In fact, Sinu Joseph quotes and takes support for her work from what Mahaperiyava has said. If we strictly go by what she is saying, that women cannot learn the Vedas, then she couldn't have written this book without knowing what the various Vedas and Samhitas contain. You can read the 'Voice of God' book which contains all of Mahaperiyava's teachings. He says everything one needs to know to get an understanding of the Vedas. But knowing doesn't mean one can practice it. That is what Sinu Joseph wants to tell us. She has written even more elaborately what is the path that is prescribed for women, because that is her research interest. What does spirituality mean for women. So there is a two volume book detailing it called Sthree Dharma Paddatihi. It is huge and detailed. But before she released this work, she wanted to clarify why the Vedas take this stance of excluding the Sudra Varna and women from learning Vedas. So for that purpose she released the Varna Vidya.
I can understand how it must feel to hear what she says for I also felt upset and let down. But all she is saying is to follow the path that is most apt for us to get the best results in this spiritual life. And for women and Sudra Varna, it is Saranagati or surrender to the Lord.
Of course, one may debate how many of the Brahmins are actually Brahmins when they don't even do the basic Sandhyavandhana. In fact Mahaperiyava also says, if Sandhyavandhanam has not been performed for three consecutive generations, then they lose the brahminhood status. There are lot of technicalities involved in how one may lose the tri-varnika status and become a sudra. However, this doesn't affect what Sinu Joseph is saying which is that one can never ascend to a higher Varna in this birth. He may exhibit qualities of a Brahmana Varna, but the biological reality doesn't change and he remains a Sudra. Whereas, the opposite is definitely possible i.e. a brahmana becoming a sudra because of not following his austerities.
So there is much sense to what she is saying. Don't they say that in Kali Yuga, it is bhakti yoga alone which will take us close to God, and there is no need for any tough austerities like in the other yugas? I think it is in line with this biological reality of Varna Dharma that Sinu Joseph is saying. Brahmins don't follow their Kula dharma, instead take up material occupations and go after money, and thereby they lose the status of Brahmin. So in the Kali Yuga, we will see mostly only the Sudra Varna as time progresses. And for Sudra Varna, the prescribed path is Saranagathi (Nyasa Vidya). This is not Bhakthi Yoga like Sinu Joseph is saying. I think she has got the names confused here about Nyasa Vidya/Saranagathi being Bhakthi Yoga. Actually Bhakthi Yoga is for the tri-varnika. It is Nyasa Vidya that is for Sudra and Women.
And as Kali Yuga progresses, human kind will only deteriorate further. So falling from the higher Varna to a lower Varna in the same birth will happen. But ascending to a higher Varna will never happen in this birth! So we see things getting worse and worse in Kali, before Kalki comes and brings us back to Satya Yuga.
@@thiruvetti u read and understand before defending a Christian teaching hindu scriptures....I know u have problem...but in north we don't study hindu granth from christian and Muslim...
Joseph?¿???
Ammaaa 🙏🙏🙏