I wish this had a million views instead of one thousand . This is so important . Regenerative agriculture with both vegetables and live stock working in synchronicity just as they do in Nature is the way toward to sustainable food supply and indeed a healthier soil and Mother Nature across the globe
Sunbeams are not "esoteric", they are electromagnetic and can be absorbed with solar panels. I like chicken somewhat and I don't eat beef very much anymore.
@@alexd3693 sunbeams are not just electromagnetic. You can't capture the feeling of their warmth on your face with a solar panel. You can't bottle the lift it gives someone's spirits to see them after a week of gray skies. Diminishing things to just one aspect of them misses everything else and wastes our ability to see the big picture. Take time to appreciate the whole, and you'll start to feel the beauty whether it ever comes to actual poetry or not, you'll even see the beauty in the electromagnetic quality of sunbeams.
When the headlines started beefing about beef, I told my wife, “A bunch of city slickers equating grass fed beef with feed lot beef”. For years, we raised cattle using multiple cross fencing. I’d laid out the pastures of our hundred acres so that they intersected in the middle where the corral and windmill were. Changing pastures was easy. There’s not a prettier sight than cows in belly high grass.
And let’s not forget that the original cow-ness and bull-ness was the ancient aurochs of Eurasia, and they’re living relatives that are bison, and Afro-Asiatic buffalo.
it's amazing that it was done by our ancestors for years and years, many still does it because they were taught by their fathers and grandfathers, but many stopped because all they cared about was profit, so mny peopl now rediscover it as if it was something new....
Joel Salatin is such an impressive human! We met him this Summer at his farm and it was like talking to an old friend. He is definitely our first go to whenever we start thinking about, anything really, with our new farm!
The best concept I have seen so far in sustainable farming. The "cowness of a cow" was sometimes seen as a problem in climate change but could be the solution to sequest carbon by pruning grass. After all, they are one of nature's gardeners. Can't wait to apply this in my farm. Thank you sir.
Unfortunately swapping wildlife for livestock doesn't work. This man is neither ecologist, nor agriculturist and shouldn't be regarded as an expert, as his views are ideology-driven.
@@TomHaws For the most part livestock takes up different ecological niches than wildlife (nutritional habits, migrational patterns, symbiotic circles, predatory pressure...) - without going into too much detail.
@@strauchdieb7628 your what are your alternative solutions? As the ipcc has the petty much back his ideas and recommendations integration of grass and live in arable rotoation to mitigate climate change and soil degradation.
@@robinlecocq7065 Can you provide a source for that claim? I doubt they even know of him. The IPCC presents several ways for combating climate change, which I won't go into detail about, because they are widely available. In short, we have to "clean up our act". There is no one-size-fits-all formula and especially no magic pill as Salatin claims. As I said, he's mostly ideology driven and possibly also a grifter.
Salatin only briefly mentioned it, but the secret to all of this is solar powered lightweight mobile electric fencing. It could go down as the most important agricultural invention in a century. The ability to move herds daily makes this all possible.
Electric fences are important for rotating small herds, but you can still do it with large groups of cattle and large pastures. You can even simulate migratory grazing without fences. Look up Bud Williams. His goal was to utilize the entirety of pastures by keeping cattle more tightly grouped and moving and settling them on less desirable parts of large pastures. The cattle will do it almost naturally if you handle the right. It's in their nature to be gregarious and have a tight herd!
@@ianbatey3425 fences are certainly important for goats and pigs and poultry. As one travelling goat herder said that used to raise cattle in his former stationary life. When i leave a herd of cows in one place and come 5 days later I will find them. Goats cover a LOT of ground, I'll probably get a phone call from the Canadian mounties. ** that was a PBS Wyoming documentary about goats and their short term grazing of weeds and undergrowth. To restore pasture or to help with fire hazards. Highly recommeded to watch btw.
@@ianbatey3425 Cattle may have had the instinct to stay together when they knew to be afraid of predators, but I think they unlearned that instinct. So without at least a pair of good dogs ..... (Will check out Bud Williams, sounds interesting).
He talks about nature's choreography and presents solutions which are so simple but exactly exactly exact, only wisdom and experience can make such solutions possible. He not just saw but noticed the most obvious things that are very Easy to be ignored.
Je découvre Joël Salatin, il est passionné et, de fait, passionnant ! Son approche écologique et économique de l'élevage est une véritable école pour qui s'intéresse à l'autonomie alimentaire.
Cattle is a marvel of nature. Put grass and water in one end, and fertilizer comes out the other. Then after a couple of years, you can dress out 300 kg of the world’s favorite meat! It’s almost a miracle ...
Joel made a excellent speech! Can you please turn on the community contribution? I would like to submit a subtitle (traditional Chinese) so that more people in my country can better understand this video.
Very interesting. I often find that people who put science into practice have a much better grasp of the subject & can explain complex systems far better than academics as this lecture demonstrates.
Dr. Savory did this "cow talk" back in 2013. It sure has been slow catching on. Excellent science. Question everything. Ruminants are the savior of the environment not the destroyer. Pass the word. Study, so you will know the facts. Joel Salatin did an excellent job of spreading the word and sharing his results. We need to learn how to apply this in the west where there is little, and seasonal rain.
Everyone needs to visit Ireland and New Zealand to see optimum grassland management for dairy cows, beef cattle and sheep. The top farmers can produce up to 17 tonnes per hectare or 15,000 lbs per acre.
In NZ we call it rotational grazing. When low impedance electric fence technology developed in NZ during the 1970s it became possible to economically move livestock to a new area each day. Most NZ farms have used this farming system for 30 or more years. What beggars belief is our own government doesn't recognise or understand these natural principles and want us to follow a flawed regrenerative farming practice that doesn't include grazing ruminants. The lack of scientific reason from our politicians in the bid to be realected will be the down fall of us all. . Z
I'm not a scientist but it's interesting how small animals like squirrels and rodents are ending up in the attics of many homes in my area. So the home owners have to get exterminators to put a product to get rid of the rodents. I noticed that they're cutting down trees to build more and more of these homes. Less trees and grass for these rodents to live. The asphalt and concrete are heating up the ground making them look for shelter. So inadvertently they become pests, voila, the need for pest control and pesticides. These animals aren't trying to become pests on purpose for sure. Thanks for the information.
The funny part is he didn't even mention all the health benefits that come along with eating grass fed animals they are the ultimate alchemists turning undigestible, to humans, grass into the most nutrient dense food on the planet, and as he did say nurturing the planet and the animals, so they don't have to live a terrible life.
I have watched this video several times throughout the years and each time, I always click "like" but for some reason it goes away, every year, I have to re-click.... interesting....
In the USA, pastures used to mean large fenced areas, and paddocks were smaller, sometimes divisions of pastures. But Americans seem to be using any word to mean 'whatever'...
Anne Hurly And with the rising rate of droughts and higher corn prices, some farmers in America have been feeding their cows more of other grains, and even sugar cookies, gummy bears, and ice cream sprinkles mixed in. Dunno how common that is elsewhere.
Yes, NZ does raise it's beef on pasture, but it is not mob grazing, so we here have the same problem of over grazing, not allowing enough time for grass to regenerate. Our dairy herds, would come closer to what could be described as mob grazing, but are grazed on younger grass than beef cattle for milk fat. Mono-culture type farming is also the norm here. NZ farmers are also farming with chemicals, which kill soil life, so are in this nasty cycle of having to add fertility in an ever degrading system. Everything a plant needs to grow is already in the soil, and if we would just nurture our soil life, and actually get off our backsides and manage our animals, we would have a healthy regenerative system. Another thing NZ does badly, is a dehydrating infrastructure, in which our plentiful rainfall, is directed to the nearest drain, stream, river and out to sea. Every year farmers will moan about drought in summer, yet make no attempt to keep that rainfall on the land longer, to absorb into the soil. It is true, that us New Zealanders find cattle lots abhorrent, hence they are rare here, but we as a nation, still have a long way to go, to overcome the chemical corporations influence on our farming practices.
Its not titled that because that is just a byproduct of following the process. Those pesky morals don't get in everyone's way so the title is about more about carbon. 😁
this stuff is so simple is astonishing people dont understand that all that grass eaten turns into more fertilizer and then the grass grows back fixing more carbon and the world goes round, pruning almost any plant will result in increased growth, wonder why? because the plant assumes it was just eaten completely above ground so wants to bounce back to maintain its own existence, and we can take advantage of this . I blame the fertilizer industries for disconnecting farmers from the land
Please come to Guelph, Ontario- They have one of the largest agricultural colleges in North America! They just built a multi-million Dollar research facility for dairy and beef. Conentration-camp style and pasture is only used to park cars on it.... Researching for the future of agriculture/livestock and not a single animal in their research facility ever sees the light of day. except the horses of course....
employ a scientific mind - sceptically interrogate until you've distilled to the Truth ... I wonder about the ultimate source(s) of the funding for such a massive project, and - further - for the department that administers it.
The current world power structure is built on petroleum and petrochemicals. Since WWII, the push in America and Canada has been toward industrialization of what is a biological process: the production of food. This industrialization benefits the petrochemical industry almost exclusively.
Nonsense. Look at all the good union brothers and sisters at Dow and Monsanto(fertilizer, pesticides and herbicides) , John Deere and Case (machinery) and the ethanol producers plus their shareholders. Don't forget the trucking companies that haul all the above plus the produce and animals. You salad fixing might well be more widely traveled than you. Likewise your steak may have been born in Texas moved to a feed operation in Georgia to graze and be backgrounded on grain and then sent to an Iowa feedlot for finishing and finished off at a nearby packing operation.
you are right John. There is just more money to be made of a centralized, industrialized agriculture with high tech and science to it than from someone like Salatin who simlply produces food from soil. Even a single concentration camp farm enterprize that displaces 100 small scale farmers moves more bucks around than these 100 small scale farms would have. But, fortunately in a democracy the ultimate power comes with numbers and I know for sure that more people are unhappy with concentration camp farming than are happy with it. Joel Salatins popularity confirms that.
Facts? Fine, but Monsanto will not let go of the profits. That's where we, the Peeps need to put the pressure by not buying any corn or soy products. But this is all wonderfully exciting and so logical. Gives us all hope for the future and we can all contribute even if we don't have acreage, doing kitchen composting.
👩🌾 s need to money up and double pay for seed to get off contracts Can’t afford it? Ive never met a rich farmer 😂 I kid of course most of them are big enough they can afford it I will do it on family farm eventually
I can't believe it. TED actually had a meat favorable presentation. They have plenty of vegan and vegetarian propaganda. I've read of paleo/primal heavy hitters trying to get an audience and they were ignored.
@@kellymcgowan3547 "livestock activity being literally the first enviromental issue" also livestock culture "we gonna keep on but now is gonna be diferent, we promese"
@@strauchdieb7628 well I would disagree but that's not the point of my argument but if you could explain how eating less meat helps I might be open to understanding your points and the facts about health are still debatable and might have to do more with vegans being more focused on what they eat rather than the fact that they aren't eating meat.
@@strauchdieb7628 also over farming is a serious problem and cattle can help restore nutrients back to the soil avoiding soil erosion and increasing crop yield.
@@thatoneguyc8312 just read any article about the environmental impact of the meat industry. Consumption by far exceeds health experts´ recommendations, ergo not debatable.
Dan Reinhard that is your full right to do so. I am totally not against farming. But chemical industry and the fertiliser industry are doing the damage. If you listen properly what this man has to say. Grass in nz doesn’t come out of the diaper stage as he calls it.
Dan Reinhard if you look at episode 7 2020 on country calendar you see a very interesting way of holistic farming where carbon is put back to the soil.
+brendon smith where do you think the water goes? If a cow is on pasture and urinates, that water is put back into the natural cycle. just like when you pee out side
His process for raising animals is actually very water efficient. The largest waste of water in traditional livestock raising is to hose down and clean the shit off the floor (and other uses) in containment housing. Salatin's ways don't require all that water use. He also uses automatic waterers and other technology to be extremely efficient in the water use.
Actually, Salatin relies mostly on spring-fed ponds to water his livestock. Under this style of management, his land and the land he leases from others has been building soil, increasing in organic matter, with deep roots, and layers of vegetation- which all help that soil to absorb rainfall, and to soak it in, replenishing groundwater, springs, and deeper aquifers. Do people ever stop to think how much water is soaked into their urban or suburban yards? Or on their favorite shopping mall and parking lot? Industrial agriculture, including CAFOs, is not a good idea for many reasons, but when talking about water waste (lawns?) and the broken water cycle, why do people point their fingers at ag, instead of urban sprawl?
People forget that before settlement by Europeans, North American Bison numbers were almost as high as the current number of cattle we now have in this country. As we were killing off the bison (to near extinction), we were in effect replacing them with cattle. Bison also produce more greenhouse gasses than cattle. Cattle are not the problem.
As we approach this time in history there will be people that are set aside merely for drawing back to the land and reactivating their innate system that has been dead for years. The good news is there is still the opportunity to do this for yourself and start your journey. I see it happening to people from all backgrounds living in both city and country.
I was watching a Wyoming channel on UA-cam. I loved it, took such great care of their cattle, mowed their own hay when they could, help with birthing when needed, grew the babies all grass fed... then they sold to feed lots. I gave them a piece of my mind then quit the channel. Its so sad, all that great work and I'll never see it on my table.
Can we grow wild grass, plants and weeds in the forest in between trees? He was saying that grass captures the most CO2. Or do the trees stop the sun from reaching the grass on the ground??
Managed forestry does just that. It looks horrid at the end and beginning. But the cycles between are beautiful to watch. However, we need both wild and managed forests to keep the balance between human needs/safety and environmental replenishment in check. Money and greed is where it all falls apart.
Listen to his videos because they make a better place for us in this world and for our food or animal or livestock rather he is the most valid points I've seen out of anyone I don't think I believe much anyone besides him I've looked at many different kinds of data on what he's talking about and even in South America they're starting to do this in their own countries and they know of him even in Colombia and Ecuador Peru all these countries there are we doing when he's talking about they're talking about feeding their own people first we used to be the breadbasket of the world why we not that again.... we do these simple things like he's saying in this video it would make a difference in the world....
We have known this so long ago, in this light how ridiculous are the modern attempts to reduce the carbon and methane emissions by reducing the numbers of cows... Look at Netherlands these days, in 2022 it is a tragedy...
Grass grow into stage one(20 days) Grass grows into stage two(10 days) Grass stops growing and starts oxydating Or Grass grow into stage one Grass grows into stage two Cow eat the grass back into stage 0-1 Grass regrows to stage two while the cow is away. Basically, if the herbivore do not consume the biomass that the plant has made from atmosféric carbon and UV rays the plant stops growing and oxidizes. And without large mammals to fertilize the soil with their waste and to soften the soil with their weight, the soil will degrade and became infertile. Then the grass will stop being able do grow and will start to desertifie
1:30 - When I hear "GRASS", being a 70 yr old California hippy, I think nickel-bag mexi-green. A minute in and I'm already disconnected. But really - Joel is right and we need a RUMINANT REVOLUTION!!
Now I'm not exactly sure how the chemistry works out, but I've heard that grass fed cows produce less greenhouse gasses than grain fed cows. My logic is that since the cow's stomach is meant to ferment the grass so that it can be broken down easier, when you give it grain you get a higher concentration of methane, or methanol. Think about it, grain is very easily fermented into alcohol (beer), but have you ever heard of a grass alcohol? I'm assuming that since the grass is easier to digest for the cow they don't end up burping up as much methane as they do when eating grain. Again, I'm not sure on how the chemistry works out.
Methane eating bacteria emerge in soil once organic matter gets up to certain level. Pastures build soil carbon faster than forests. Intensive grazing builds soil which creates sequestered carbon and digested methane via soil biology.
...and feeding cows corn is like feeding them junk food - apparently, it burns holes in their stomach... don't know about you but I would suggest that would affect their digestion... I think that the idea of corn beer sounds pretty accurate.
Agree with David, but apparently its the other way round. Corn fed cows produce less methane - probably because it buggers their natural digestion process, which has now become a key argument against roaming cows 😪
Why does no one ever talk about composting? If you composted the richest 1000 people you’d sink literally tons of carbon and create a rich soil amendment, which can go on crops, meanwhile you’ve saved all the carbon from the global economy because now everyone only has to do 1/100th of the amount of labor they had to before (to subsidize the ultra-rich). A real positive feedback loop!!!
I've just chatted with the farmer's curious and friendly cows across the fence as part of my evening ritual only to come back inside and find this video among the recommended )) Last week I was standing on my elevated decking and watched how the local vet was performing a C-section on a pregnant cow in the field. These cows greet me when I leave for college in the morning and they gather by the gates when they see me pulling down my driveway. We chat and they lick my hands. And still, I continue to eat beef. I feel like one big selfish parasite, secretly admiring and envying the willpower of vegetarians and especially vegans. These are the people who delay our civilization from extinction as a result of our self-indulgence and inability to face uncomfortable truths about the climate crisis.
I was a vegetarian for 40+ years We were lied to in the 70s when they told us that wheat/corn/soy etc was better than meat. Telling us that cheese and eggs are bad. Well the science has been out now for a while that these crops have been genetically modified and hybridized to the point that they transfer glyphosphate directly into our bodies causing harmful reactions. And the meat industry pumped more hormones and antibiotics into the animals that it also caused health issues. Grass fed cows and free range chickens are way more happy animals than those in cramped cages and feed lots. We must be kind to animals so they be sustainable for the environment. Ecology teaches these things. Mandatory study for the world. ♻️🌱💚
Dear world. We need the cow. Without the cow we would all starve. Grazing animals like cows do NOT accelerate climate change. Cows (and other grazing animals) encourage grasslands. Grasslands capture carbon far faster than forests do and they keep that carbon in the ground. This effect far out ways the negative effect of cow burbs. Furthermore, cows feeding on fallow fields accelerate nutrient recycling. This is because grazing favors faster growing plants. Without grazers crop yields would suffer as soil recovery would degrade. Finally 70% of the world's argracultural land is not fit for raising crops. If the world tommorow stopped eating meat we would go from using %11 of the earth to produce food to using %4. Complex systems are not toys. Changing them always has unintended consequences.
"Cow burbs"... really? Cow farts and poop rather. Also you should explain that to the million of species being lost in the rain forest fires, not to mention the harm those fires do and that they are being created to make space for grazing cattle, which then not just expunge a huge amount of methane, but in addition exasperate the situation also because of the trees that were cut down and are missing now to convert co2 into oxygen.... that's adding insult to injury, and thus making your comment and advocating animal agriculture an insult to everyone.
@@themax2go one half of the planet's land mass is covered in grass. The fact that some people are grazing cattle in the wrong place doesn't change the facts.
@@dudleyhaines9826 Well one half of lands being covered in grass does not make any difference since you also need to own that land or need it to be inside the border of your country lol and yes need important resources such as water and electricity to set the farms. Also Raising cows takes more water than growing any food crops, where is that gonna come from? And how is it expected of countries such as India which does not the space to keep even human population to make space for grazing animals? And not to forget how we going to cope up with the pressure of feeding increasingly world population of additional 2 billion people in coming years.
@@themax2go You are missing the bigger picture here. The rain forest is being burnt because overgrazing ruined the previous pastures. So if the cattle herders actually managed their land properly, nobody would need to burn down any forest.
@@NoExitLoveNow His methods are being used to great success by farmers and you can go and see what he does at his farm. Its basic biology of plants and grasses that have a symbiotic relationship to the animals that live on them and with them
See vegans .... here is the solution, the solution is not abstaining from meat and deteriorating your body. Instead of growing 100s acres of soy and depleting the soil we should let the natural cycle of herbivores take place
Think again. Most soy is grown for cattle. Most crops are fed to cattle. If something sounds too good to be true - it usually isn't, and I´m no vegan...
@@strauchdieb7628 Most of the crop has to be fed to cattle. The amount of biomass humans can really consume from either corn or soy crops is very small in comparison so the rest is fed as forage to cattle.
Leave ethics a side for a moment.We don't have enough land for grass fed animals.Not only that but will raise the price of meat and will become extremely expensive and exclusive
Merle Marie Multi adaptive paddock grazing produces 3 to 5 times enough yield using the same amount of land as traditional ranching. It also is carbon negative as it mimics the millions of ruminants that use to roam the planet and somehow never never raised the carbon dioxide levels......
@@gabrielwilson6484 Double the yield would be a VERY ambitious claim. 3 - 5 times ? compared to completely degraded land ? maybe. - Ratio of fodder input to meat output 7 : 1 for beef. (4 : 1 for pork and still 3.5 : 1 for poultry. But that is big ag standard. You cannot raise pork only on grass, certainly not if you want to fatten them up for a crowd and fast. I know he has his pasture pigs but they do not have the stomach to handle grass in the most efficient way, they are getting other food. Pigs are good to keep down pests (like snails etc). So even your wild ! claims of 3 to 5 times the yields do not add up. When the production of beef is super costly. Of course if land can ONLY produce grass ... then sheep, cattle and goats would be better. The nomads of Lappland need reindeer herds they cannot grow grains or veggies. But not where he lives in the temperate climate zone, there he could grow some grains, food trees, oil plants, mushrooms. And of course veggies like kale, or potatoes. If you feed the potatoes (or topinanmbur which grows like weed) to the pigs or feed the potatoes directly to humans ? What do you think is more EFFICIENT when it comes to use of land (the feces of the humans can also be returned to the land). But almost everywhere you can grow potatoes, hardy veggies, some fruit trees that can deal with short growing seasons and lots of rain, and lower temps. Wheat will not grow, but rye, barley oats, lensseed (higher quality even, if it is cool), and then there are other root vegetables. Some berries. asparagus. One could also cultivate fish, ducks, rabbits, ....
@@gabrielwilson6484 FDR made a campaign promise: A chicken in the pot in every home on Sunday. Note how this was a _Sunday_ treat, and a chicken in the pot is usually a laying hen that has gotten too old and now is used as soup chicken. it is not the best quality meat. Your can still make tasty food from it (lots of poor immigrant housewives knew how to put it to good use), but for a roasted chicken in the stove you need a younger chicken that never served double duty as egg producer. The chicken in the _pot_ was a nod to the frugal housewives that could not even go crazy with the food expenses for the Sunday meal.
As a way to stop desertification, it could work. But what if you start taking beef off the land and eating it a 1000 km further down. It would break the cycle. Nutrients would leak out of the system and would have to be replenished somehow.
I wish this had a million views instead of one thousand . This is so important . Regenerative agriculture with both vegetables and live stock working in synchronicity just as they do in Nature is the way toward to sustainable food supply and indeed a healthier soil and Mother Nature across the globe
It probably did but has been downplayed censored etc... Google and UA-cam are Global Elite mechanisms of manipulation...
Joel expresses the most basic concepts of land and animal husbandry in ways that everyone can appreciate.
Sunbeams are not "esoteric", they are electromagnetic and can be absorbed with solar panels.
I like chicken somewhat and I don't eat beef very much anymore.
Number File y
Number File hi
@@alexd3693 sunbeams are not just electromagnetic. You can't capture the feeling of their warmth on your face with a solar panel. You can't bottle the lift it gives someone's spirits to see them after a week of gray skies. Diminishing things to just one aspect of them misses everything else and wastes our ability to see the big picture. Take time to appreciate the whole, and you'll start to feel the beauty whether it ever comes to actual poetry or not, you'll even see the beauty in the electromagnetic quality of sunbeams.
@@alexd3693 Why not to eat grass-fed beef, raised as Salatin teaches?
When the headlines started beefing about beef, I told my wife, “A bunch of city slickers equating grass fed beef with feed lot beef”. For years, we raised cattle using multiple cross fencing. I’d laid out the pastures of our hundred acres so that they intersected in the middle where the corral and windmill were. Changing pastures was easy. There’s not a prettier sight than cows in belly high grass.
Yes
Once the grass has reached belly height. the nutritional value is way past optional. ME value has dropped markedly
And what the cows don't eat (weeds), sheep will.
Agree! Weary of the move to force us to be vegans...
@@alexandrawhitelock6195 you know than you can pasturise animals without eating them
A society that doesn't respect the cow-ness of the cow will soon lose respect for the human-ness of you.
Excellent
And let’s not forget that the original cow-ness and bull-ness was the ancient aurochs of Eurasia, and they’re living relatives that are bison, and Afro-Asiatic buffalo.
it’s amazing how simple something like this could have such a big impact. simply amazing.
it's amazing that it was done by our ancestors for years and years, many still does it because they were taught by their fathers and grandfathers, but many stopped because all they cared about was profit, so mny peopl now rediscover it as if it was something new....
Love Joel.
The most passionate man I’ve ever heard speak.
He is amazing!!!!
Joel Salatin is such an impressive human! We met him this Summer at his farm and it was like talking to an old friend. He is definitely our first go to whenever we start thinking about, anything really, with our new farm!
The best concept I have seen so far in sustainable farming. The "cowness of a cow" was sometimes seen as a problem in climate change but could be the solution to sequest carbon by pruning grass. After all, they are one of nature's gardeners. Can't wait to apply this in my farm. Thank you sir.
I'm impressed! Not a big meat eater but now I want a cow. He is so right. Let the herbivore do its job and build the soil.
Unfortunately swapping wildlife for livestock doesn't work. This man is neither ecologist, nor agriculturist and shouldn't be regarded as an expert, as his views are ideology-driven.
@@strauchdieb7628 Can you explain what you mean by "doesn't work"?
@@TomHaws For the most part livestock takes up different ecological niches than wildlife (nutritional habits, migrational patterns, symbiotic circles, predatory pressure...) - without going into too much detail.
@@strauchdieb7628 your what are your alternative solutions? As the ipcc has the petty much back his ideas and recommendations integration of grass and live in arable rotoation to mitigate climate change and soil degradation.
@@robinlecocq7065 Can you provide a source for that claim? I doubt they even know of him. The IPCC presents several ways for combating climate change, which I won't go into detail about, because they are widely available. In short, we have to "clean up our act". There is no one-size-fits-all formula and especially no magic pill as Salatin claims. As I said, he's mostly ideology driven and possibly also a grifter.
Salatin only briefly mentioned it, but the secret to all of this is solar powered lightweight mobile electric fencing. It could go down as the most important agricultural invention in a century. The ability to move herds daily makes this all possible.
Electric fences are important for rotating small herds, but you can still do it with large groups of cattle and large pastures.
You can even simulate migratory grazing without fences. Look up Bud Williams. His goal was to utilize the entirety of pastures by keeping cattle more tightly grouped and moving and settling them on less desirable parts of large pastures. The cattle will do it almost naturally if you handle the right. It's in their nature to be gregarious and have a tight herd!
@@ianbatey3425 fences are certainly important for goats and pigs and poultry. As one travelling goat herder said that used to raise cattle in his former stationary life. When i leave a herd of cows in one place and come 5 days later I will find them. Goats cover a LOT of ground, I'll probably get a phone call from the Canadian mounties.
** that was a PBS Wyoming documentary about goats and their short term grazing of weeds and undergrowth. To restore pasture or to help with fire hazards. Highly recommeded to watch btw.
@@ianbatey3425 Cattle may have had the instinct to stay together when they knew to be afraid of predators, but I think they unlearned that instinct. So without at least a pair of good dogs ..... (Will check out Bud Williams, sounds interesting).
Great presentation sir. If we don’t go back to the old ways humanity will pay dearly!!!
'Concentration Camp Meat' - That's the best way of putting it.
Grass has become a useful source of nutrition, shade, moisture and tool for helping build my farm.
He talks about nature's choreography and presents solutions which are so simple but exactly exactly exact, only wisdom and experience can make such solutions possible. He not just saw but noticed the most obvious things that are very Easy to be ignored.
My man, Joel, pulls through again. Keep up the good work
Who would have thought that we needed taught how grass works and what God's intent for it was.
this guy is brilliant
Je découvre Joël Salatin, il est passionné et, de fait, passionnant ! Son approche écologique et économique de l'élevage est une véritable école pour qui s'intéresse à l'autonomie alimentaire.
Best presentation about grass ive ever seen, and ive seen documentaries about weed.
Cattle is a marvel of nature. Put grass and water in one end, and fertilizer comes out the other.
Then after a couple of years, you can dress out 300 kg of the world’s favorite meat!
It’s almost a miracle ...
I am super happy that Joel was around on the day of the youtube and free information
Joel made a excellent speech! Can you please turn on the community contribution? I would like to submit a subtitle (traditional Chinese) so that more people in my country can better understand this video.
I’m actually thinking of the same thing!
I LOVE THIS MAN
Farmers are the best!!
His is an amazing individual, I just hope big corporations will learn something from him...
what a go ahead I've leant so much today thank you
Very interesting. I often find that people who put science into practice have a much better grasp of the subject & can explain complex systems far better than academics as this lecture demonstrates.
Dr. Savory did this "cow talk" back in 2013. It sure has been slow catching on. Excellent science. Question everything. Ruminants are the savior of the environment not the destroyer. Pass the word. Study, so you will know the facts. Joel Salatin did an excellent job of spreading the word and sharing his results. We need to learn how to apply this in the west where there is little, and seasonal rain.
This guy is really good at talking
What a great presentation!
Joel is da man.
Love this guy! Sorry I missed this presentation knowing now that it was just across the mountains from me.
Thats awesome 👌, i never thought id find a Joel ted talk
Amazing MAN! Thank you 🙏 Mr. Salatin.
Everyone needs to visit Ireland and New Zealand to see optimum grassland management for dairy cows, beef cattle and sheep. The top farmers can produce up to 17 tonnes per hectare or 15,000 lbs per acre.
Likely the higher rainfall (also during the warm season summer) makes that possible.
In NZ we call it rotational grazing. When low impedance electric fence technology developed in NZ during the 1970s it became possible to economically move livestock to a new area each day. Most NZ farms have used this farming system for 30 or more years. What beggars belief is our own government doesn't recognise or understand these natural principles and want us to follow a flawed regrenerative farming practice that doesn't include grazing ruminants. The lack of scientific reason from our politicians in the bid to be realected will be the down fall of us all.
.
Z
I'm not a scientist but it's interesting how small animals like squirrels and rodents are ending up in the attics of many homes in my area. So the home owners have to get exterminators to put a product to get rid of the rodents. I noticed that they're cutting down trees to build more and more of these homes. Less trees and grass for these rodents to live. The asphalt and concrete are heating up the ground making them look for shelter. So inadvertently they become pests, voila, the need for pest control and pesticides. These animals aren't trying to become pests on purpose for sure. Thanks for the information.
The funny part is he didn't even mention all the health benefits that come along with eating grass fed animals they are the ultimate alchemists turning undigestible, to humans, grass into the most nutrient dense food on the planet, and as he did say nurturing the planet and the animals, so they don't have to live a terrible life.
I've already commented that grass fed cows etc. produce vitamin K2-7 in their meat... which is essential to every cell in the human body !
11:30
@pawsscience1020 that's a dangerous misinformation.
One correction on grass production, the spanish lang subtitles reads "hectares", when actually Salatin says "acres". 1ha = 2.47 acres
Fantastic!
iLOVE Joel Salatin!!! "The Blessed Way!" Inspiring/informative! #genius #SuperFan
Excellent Analysis, Deployed Worldwide Through My Deep Learning AI Research Library…Thank You
He's a mad farm scientist
I have watched this video several times throughout the years and each time, I always click "like" but for some reason it goes away, every year, I have to re-click.... interesting....
New Zealand still grows all its beef on pastures (we call them paddocks here).
In the USA, pastures used to mean large fenced areas, and paddocks were smaller, sometimes divisions of pastures. But Americans seem to be using any word to mean 'whatever'...
Anne Hurly And with the rising rate of droughts and higher corn prices, some farmers in America have been feeding their cows more of other grains, and even sugar cookies, gummy bears, and ice cream sprinkles mixed in. Dunno how common that is elsewhere.
Yes, NZ does raise it's beef on pasture, but it is not mob grazing, so we here have the same problem of over grazing, not allowing enough time for grass to regenerate. Our dairy herds, would come closer to what could be described as mob grazing, but are grazed on younger grass than beef cattle for milk fat. Mono-culture type farming is also the norm here.
NZ farmers are also farming with chemicals, which kill soil life, so are in this nasty cycle of having to add fertility in an ever degrading system.
Everything a plant needs to grow is already in the soil, and if we would just nurture our soil life, and actually get off our backsides and manage our animals, we would have a healthy regenerative system.
Another thing NZ does badly, is a dehydrating infrastructure, in which our plentiful rainfall, is directed to the nearest drain, stream, river and out to sea. Every year farmers will moan about drought in summer, yet make no attempt to keep that rainfall on the land longer, to absorb into the soil.
It is true, that us New Zealanders find cattle lots abhorrent, hence they are rare here, but we as a nation, still have a long way to go, to overcome the chemical corporations influence on our farming practices.
Anne Hurly
Here, paddocks could be small spaces also.
@Homie Gibiotch In US, they are called fields, as probably in Europe.
Go Joel!
amazing, thanks for guidiing us back to life cycle
👏👏👏 Great talk. See also Allan Savory ✊👍
It's called holistic management
I seriously cannot believe that this was not titled, Respecting the Cowness of the Cow. Smh!!
Its not titled that because that is just a byproduct of following the process. Those pesky morals don't get in everyone's way so the title is about more about carbon. 😁
Brilliant!
That was brilliant
All you need to do is come to new zealand and see our grass based farming systems
Nz still dosent let the grass get out of diaper stage.
Europe is largely grass fed too. Having said that, it’s often an intensely managed ryegrass monoculture.
Oliver Byrne and also grazed way to short especially when cows are dry in winter time.
Brilliantly presented. Why can't people get this simple idea into their heads?
Beautiful
this stuff is so simple is astonishing people dont understand that all that grass eaten turns into more fertilizer and then the grass grows back fixing more carbon and the world goes round, pruning almost any plant will result in increased growth, wonder why? because the plant assumes it was just eaten completely above ground so wants to bounce back to maintain its own existence, and we can take advantage of this . I blame the fertilizer industries for disconnecting farmers from the land
They missed that part of The Lion King where Mufassa explains the Circle of Life
beautiful!
Please come to Guelph, Ontario- They have one of the largest agricultural colleges in North America! They just built a multi-million Dollar research facility for dairy and beef. Conentration-camp style and pasture is only used to park cars on it.... Researching for the future of agriculture/livestock and not a single animal in their research facility ever sees the light of day. except the horses of course....
+putin88100 sad situation
employ a scientific mind - sceptically interrogate until you've distilled to the Truth ... I wonder about the ultimate source(s) of the funding for such a massive project, and - further - for the department that administers it.
The current world power structure is built on petroleum and petrochemicals. Since WWII, the push in America and Canada has been toward industrialization of what is a biological process: the production of food. This industrialization benefits the petrochemical industry almost exclusively.
Nonsense. Look at all the good union brothers and sisters at Dow and Monsanto(fertilizer, pesticides and herbicides) , John Deere and Case (machinery) and the ethanol producers plus their shareholders. Don't forget the trucking companies that haul all the above plus the produce and animals. You salad fixing might well be more widely traveled than you. Likewise your steak may have been born in Texas moved to a feed operation in Georgia to graze and be backgrounded on grain and then sent to an Iowa feedlot for finishing and finished off at a nearby packing operation.
you are right John. There is just more money to be made of a
centralized, industrialized agriculture with high tech and science to it
than from someone like Salatin who simlply produces food from soil.
Even a single concentration camp farm enterprize that displaces 100
small scale farmers moves more bucks around than these 100 small scale
farms would have. But, fortunately in a democracy the ultimate power
comes with numbers and I know for sure that more people are unhappy with
concentration camp farming than are happy with it. Joel Salatins
popularity confirms that.
“The cowness of the cow” very well put 😂
Facts? Fine, but Monsanto will not let go of the profits. That's where we, the Peeps need to put the pressure by not buying any corn or soy products. But this is all wonderfully exciting and so logical. Gives us all hope for the future and we can all contribute even if we don't have acreage, doing kitchen composting.
Patents grass
👩🌾 s need to money up and double pay for seed to get off contracts
Can’t afford it? Ive never met a rich farmer 😂 I kid of course most of them are big enough they can afford it
I will do it on family farm eventually
excelente sin desperdicios
This great talk from a brilliant systemic mind has waaaay to few views
I can't believe it. TED actually had a meat favorable presentation. They have plenty of vegan and vegetarian propaganda. I've read of paleo/primal heavy hitters trying to get an audience and they were ignored.
@@kellymcgowan3547 They understand alright.... but it goes against the agenda.....Agenda 21 !
I'm a little shocked too! It's rare to hear someone who isn't a neoliberal!
"Propaganda" aka "people with arguments who I don't wanna hear because it put my retrograde behaviours in question"
@@kellymcgowan3547 yeah sure, 1.500 millon cows on the world and all the land deforestation for meat consumtion are super eco-friendly
@@kellymcgowan3547 "livestock activity being literally the first enviromental issue" also livestock culture "we gonna keep on but now is gonna be diferent, we promese"
Im glad we are seeing the other side of the argument I'm for helping the environment but I don't agree with most of the ways people are trying too
No argument. The less meat we consume, the better for our health and the environment.
Strauch Dieb obviously you didn’t understand what he was saying. Sad.
@@strauchdieb7628 well I would disagree but that's not the point of my argument but if you could explain how eating less meat helps I might be open to understanding your points and the facts about health are still debatable and might have to do more with vegans being more focused on what they eat rather than the fact that they aren't eating meat.
@@strauchdieb7628 also over farming is a serious problem and cattle can help restore nutrients back to the soil avoiding soil erosion and increasing crop yield.
@@thatoneguyc8312 just read any article about the environmental impact of the meat industry.
Consumption by far exceeds health experts´ recommendations, ergo not debatable.
We never forget our planet without soil and crops correlation for long term Sustainable Agriculture.
Congrats Joel Salatin to be in USDA in the Trump’s team! Bring the change! MAGA and MAHA!
go to New Zealand and learn about rotational grazing !!
Yep but they don’t grow it long enough to put carbon in the soil and graze it to short often
And often ruin what has been gain with chemical fertilisers
@@frederiksmees5503 Sorry I disagree .....
Dan Reinhard that is your full right to do so. I am totally not against farming. But chemical industry and the fertiliser industry are doing the damage. If you listen properly what this man has to say. Grass in nz doesn’t come out of the diaper stage as he calls it.
Dan Reinhard if you look at episode 7 2020 on country calendar you see a very interesting way of holistic farming where carbon is put back to the soil.
without the grazing herbivores the grasslands would turn into brushland in dry areas or forest in wetter areas. .
Won't see this kind of truth on the mass media or making it's way into the class room too much.
+NCIcaucus talking thru his ass........how much water does it take to produce this dairy produce? unsustainable
+brendon smith where do you think the water goes? If a cow is on pasture and urinates, that water is put back into the natural cycle. just like when you pee out side
His process for raising animals is actually very water efficient. The largest waste of water in traditional livestock raising is to hose down and clean the shit off the floor (and other uses) in containment housing. Salatin's ways don't require all that water use. He also uses automatic waterers and other technology to be extremely efficient in the water use.
Actually, Salatin relies mostly on spring-fed ponds to water his livestock. Under this style of management, his land and the land he leases from others has been building soil, increasing in organic matter, with deep roots, and layers of vegetation- which all help that soil to absorb rainfall, and to soak it in, replenishing groundwater, springs, and deeper aquifers.
Do people ever stop to think how much water is soaked into their urban or suburban yards? Or on their favorite shopping mall and parking lot? Industrial agriculture, including CAFOs, is not a good idea for many reasons, but when talking about water waste (lawns?) and the broken water cycle, why do people point their fingers at ag, instead of urban sprawl?
None. He only produces meat and eggs.
People need to quit bagging their grass when mowing also...
John Christiansen for sure and applying fertiliser on top of it contaminating rain water supplies
@@sweetvuvuzela4634 going to try this out… everything seems inverted in this dam world right now.
Just let it sit or?
Whenever someone brings up climate and meat consumption, I have to redirect them to the historical 30 million bison that used to live in the US.
Holy Cow!
People forget that before settlement by Europeans, North American Bison numbers were almost as high as the current number of cattle we now have in this country. As we were killing off the bison (to near extinction), we were in effect replacing them with cattle. Bison also produce more greenhouse gasses than cattle. Cattle are not the problem.
As we approach this time in history there will be people that are set aside merely for drawing back to the land and reactivating their innate system that has been dead for years. The good news is there is still the opportunity to do this for yourself and start your journey. I see it happening to people from all backgrounds living in both city and country.
Isn't life amazing ❤️
Awesome
I was watching a Wyoming channel on UA-cam. I loved it, took such great care of their cattle, mowed their own hay when they could, help with birthing when needed, grew the babies all grass fed... then they sold to feed lots. I gave them a piece of my mind then quit the channel. Its so sad, all that great work and I'll never see it on my table.
Can we grow wild grass, plants and weeds in the forest in between trees? He was saying that grass captures the most CO2.
Or do the trees stop the sun from reaching the grass on the ground??
Managed forestry does just that. It looks horrid at the end and beginning. But the cycles between are beautiful to watch. However, we need both wild and managed forests to keep the balance between human needs/safety and environmental replenishment in check. Money and greed is where it all falls apart.
Finally, a practical solution that does not need congress to spend 30 trillion dollars that they don’t have.
There is a HUGE difference between commercial feed lots and local ranchers giving cattle the best life they could ever have. Don't lump them together
Listen to his videos because they make a better place for us in this world and for our food or animal or livestock rather he is the most valid points I've seen out of anyone I don't think I believe much anyone besides him I've looked at many different kinds of data on what he's talking about and even in South America they're starting to do this in their own countries and they know of him even in Colombia and Ecuador Peru all these countries there are we doing when he's talking about they're talking about feeding their own people first we used to be the breadbasket of the world why we not that again.... we do these simple things like he's saying in this video it would make a difference in the world....
We have known this so long ago, in this light how ridiculous are the modern attempts to reduce the carbon and methane emissions by reducing the numbers of cows... Look at Netherlands these days, in 2022 it is a tragedy...
Could someone please help me summarize this process!!!!
Grass grow into stage one(20 days)
Grass grows into stage two(10 days)
Grass stops growing and starts oxydating
Or
Grass grow into stage one
Grass grows into stage two
Cow eat the grass back into stage 0-1
Grass regrows to stage two while the cow is away.
Basically, if the herbivore do not consume the biomass that the plant has made from atmosféric carbon and UV rays the plant stops growing and oxidizes. And without large mammals to fertilize the soil with their waste and to soften the soil with their weight, the soil will degrade and became infertile. Then the grass will stop being able do grow and will start to desertifie
This talk was okay. I I enjoyed it i guess 🙃🥳🙈🙉🙊
1:30 - When I hear "GRASS", being a 70 yr old California hippy, I think nickel-bag mexi-green. A minute in and I'm already disconnected. But really - Joel is right and we need a RUMINANT REVOLUTION!!
SHAME to all of those who didnt laugh at his wonderful jokes they lack his great humor
I laugh at him constantly :)
Oh....That's Tai Lopez's first mentor❤
Nice
Now I'm not exactly sure how the chemistry works out, but I've heard that grass fed cows produce less greenhouse gasses than grain fed cows. My logic is that since the cow's stomach is meant to ferment the grass so that it can be broken down easier, when you give it grain you get a higher concentration of methane, or methanol. Think about it, grain is very easily fermented into alcohol (beer), but have you ever heard of a grass alcohol? I'm assuming that since the grass is easier to digest for the cow they don't end up burping up as much methane as they do when eating grain. Again, I'm not sure on how the chemistry works out.
Methane eating bacteria emerge in soil once organic matter gets up to certain level. Pastures build soil carbon faster than forests. Intensive grazing builds soil which creates sequestered carbon and digested methane via soil biology.
Good point makes sense !
...and feeding cows corn is like feeding them junk food - apparently, it burns holes in their stomach... don't know about you but I would suggest that would affect their digestion... I think that the idea of corn beer sounds pretty accurate.
Agree with David, but apparently its the other way round. Corn fed cows produce less methane - probably because it buggers their natural digestion process, which has now become a key argument against roaming cows 😪
Do the grass fed cows produce methane?
They do, but a healthy grassland also hosts methanotrophs - a bacteria that feeds off methane. Another beautifully symbiotic relationship in nature.
Why does no one ever talk about composting? If you composted the richest 1000 people you’d sink literally tons of carbon and create a rich soil amendment, which can go on crops, meanwhile you’ve saved all the carbon from the global economy because now everyone only has to do 1/100th of the amount of labor they had to before (to subsidize the ultra-rich). A real positive feedback loop!!!
Why do I feel like his words fall on deaf ears
I've just chatted with the farmer's curious and friendly cows across the fence as part of my evening ritual only to come back inside and find this video among the recommended )) Last week I was standing on my elevated decking and watched how the local vet was performing a C-section on a pregnant cow in the field. These cows greet me when I leave for college in the morning and they gather by the gates when they see me pulling down my driveway. We chat and they lick my hands. And still, I continue to eat beef. I feel like one big selfish parasite, secretly admiring and envying the willpower of vegetarians and especially vegans. These are the people who delay our civilization from extinction as a result of our self-indulgence and inability to face uncomfortable truths about the climate crisis.
I was a vegetarian for 40+ years
We were lied to in the 70s when they told us that wheat/corn/soy etc was better than meat. Telling us that cheese and eggs are bad. Well the science has been out now for a while that these crops have been genetically modified and hybridized to the point that they transfer glyphosphate directly into our bodies causing harmful reactions. And the meat industry pumped more hormones and antibiotics into the animals that it also caused health issues.
Grass fed cows and free range chickens are way more happy animals than those in cramped cages and feed lots. We must be kind to animals so they be sustainable for the environment. Ecology teaches these things. Mandatory study for the world. ♻️🌱💚
Dear world. We need the cow. Without the cow we would all starve.
Grazing animals like cows do NOT accelerate climate change. Cows (and other grazing animals) encourage grasslands. Grasslands capture carbon far faster than forests do and they keep that carbon in the ground. This effect far out ways the negative effect of cow burbs.
Furthermore, cows feeding on fallow fields accelerate nutrient recycling. This is because grazing favors faster growing plants. Without grazers crop yields would suffer as soil recovery would degrade.
Finally 70% of the world's argracultural land is not fit for raising crops. If the world tommorow stopped eating meat we would go from using %11 of the earth to produce food to using %4.
Complex systems are not toys. Changing them always has unintended consequences.
"Cow burbs"... really? Cow farts and poop rather. Also you should explain that to the million of species being lost in the rain forest fires, not to mention the harm those fires do and that they are being created to make space for grazing cattle, which then not just expunge a huge amount of methane, but in addition exasperate the situation also because of the trees that were cut down and are missing now to convert co2 into oxygen.... that's adding insult to injury, and thus making your comment and advocating animal agriculture an insult to everyone.
@@themax2go Do you have data on forests that are cleared for the sole purpose of grazing? Asking for a friend
@@themax2go one half of the planet's land mass is covered in grass. The fact that some people are grazing cattle in the wrong place doesn't change the facts.
@@dudleyhaines9826 Well one half of lands being covered in grass does not make any difference since you also need to own that land or need it to be inside the border of your country lol and yes need important resources such as water and electricity to set the farms. Also Raising cows takes more water than growing any food crops, where is that gonna come from? And how is it expected of countries such as India which does not the space to keep even human population to make space for grazing animals? And not to forget how we going to cope up with the pressure of feeding increasingly world population of additional 2 billion people in coming years.
@@themax2go You are missing the bigger picture here.
The rain forest is being burnt because overgrazing ruined the previous pastures. So if the cattle herders actually managed their land properly, nobody would need to burn down any forest.
Alan savory gives a much better presentation on a ted talk called holistic animal management.
Alan Savory is a fraudulent crank.
@@NoExitLoveNow His methods are being used to great success by farmers and you can go and see what he does at his farm.
Its basic biology of plants and grasses that have a symbiotic relationship to the animals that live on them and with them
NoExitLoveNow hahah. How can you say such things about Savory when this guy is using the exact same principals of migratory grazing. SMH.
What about natural grazing lawns?
Goats?
See vegans .... here is the solution, the solution is not abstaining from meat and deteriorating your body. Instead of growing 100s acres of soy and depleting the soil we should let the natural cycle of herbivores take place
Think again. Most soy is grown for cattle. Most crops are fed to cattle. If something sounds too good to be true - it usually isn't, and I´m no vegan...
@@strauchdieb7628 Most of the crop has to be fed to cattle. The amount of biomass humans can really consume from either corn or soy crops is very small in comparison so the rest is fed as forage to cattle.
@@u.martin6917 Not really.
He lives "over the mountain" CLEVER
Cows got a bad wrap... until subway came out with chipotle steak wraps
Greta needs a joel salatin scientific education adjustment.
Leave ethics a side for a moment.We don't have enough land for grass fed animals.Not only that but will raise the price of meat and will become extremely expensive and exclusive
Merle Marie Multi adaptive paddock grazing produces 3 to 5 times enough yield using the same amount of land as traditional ranching. It also is carbon negative as it mimics the millions of ruminants that use to roam the planet and somehow never never raised the carbon dioxide levels......
@@gabrielwilson6484 Double the yield would be a VERY ambitious claim. 3 - 5 times ? compared to completely degraded land ? maybe. - Ratio of fodder input to meat output 7 : 1 for beef. (4 : 1 for pork and still 3.5 : 1 for poultry. But that is big ag standard. You cannot raise pork only on grass, certainly not if you want to fatten them up for a crowd and fast. I know he has his pasture pigs but they do not have the stomach to handle grass in the most efficient way, they are getting other food. Pigs are good to keep down pests (like snails etc).
So even your wild ! claims of 3 to 5 times the yields do not add up. When the production of beef is super costly.
Of course if land can ONLY produce grass ... then sheep, cattle and goats would be better. The nomads of Lappland need reindeer herds they cannot grow grains or veggies.
But not where he lives in the temperate climate zone, there he could grow some grains, food trees, oil plants, mushrooms. And of course veggies like kale, or potatoes.
If you feed the potatoes (or topinanmbur which grows like weed) to the pigs or feed the potatoes directly to humans ?
What do you think is more EFFICIENT when it comes to use of land (the feces of the humans can also be returned to the land).
But almost everywhere you can grow potatoes, hardy veggies, some fruit trees that can deal with short growing seasons and lots of rain, and lower temps. Wheat will not grow, but rye, barley oats, lensseed (higher quality even, if it is cool), and then there are other root vegetables. Some berries. asparagus.
One could also cultivate fish, ducks, rabbits, ....
@@gabrielwilson6484 FDR made a campaign promise: A chicken in the pot in every home on Sunday. Note how this was a _Sunday_ treat, and a chicken in the pot is usually a laying hen that has gotten too old and now is used as soup chicken. it is not the best quality meat. Your can still make tasty food from it (lots of poor immigrant housewives knew how to put it to good use), but for a roasted chicken in the stove you need a younger chicken that never served double duty as egg producer.
The chicken in the _pot_ was a nod to the frugal housewives that could not even go crazy with the food expenses for the Sunday meal.
As a way to stop desertification, it could work.
But what if you start taking beef off the land and eating it a 1000 km further down.
It would break the cycle.
Nutrients would leak out of the system and would have to be replenished somehow.
I don't quite understand your point. "eating it 1000km further down" ?
Does that mean transportation of the meat?