Shay really underestimates how much Randy is loved and has a huge fan base - so being critical of Randy is just going to make him extremely unpopular. Wrong move.
why are they making up this beef all of a sudden? i have never heard any consultant, shay included, speak to randy that way before. they clearly scripted this for the episode but it doesn't make any sense. i guess a surprise proposal wasn't dramatic enough for the producers?
The Shaye and Randy thing is bizarrely funny! Randy wants to assert his expertise and position and Shaye wants to be left to do his job! I don’t think either of them is right or wrong but, I do think both their egos clash!! I think Randy should back off a little, I believe Shaye gets great feedback and if that’s true, he’s doing his job, no need for Randy to get bent out of shape if someone doesn’t need his input.
Y'all are SO funny acting like this show isn't EXTREMELY scripted. Shay and Randy are fine y'all that interaction was written by the producers. Randy probably didn't want to waste his time but still contacted to make an appearance. Chill out y'all are wildin
@@jessicakorban7980I dunno. I'm thinking about it, and I figure, if I were her young age and had never been to NYC, let alone a store like Kleinfeld's, I'd be ready to believe cameras were rolling on someone at any point. Maybe they convinced her they were giving Jonathan some camera time as a form of on-the-job training. I'd be completely prepared to believe, "Yeah, this is about a training film, not about me."
she most likely had an idea but she was not about to ruin her own proposal and there are actually quite a few women who are cool to just try on the dresses for fun
what a sweet event for a cute couple, and that is NOT her dress. Shay's arrogance stops all he could learn from a seasoned bridal agent, Randy. Ridiculous.
Jonathan might be good at his job. But he acts like such a real jerk, particularly with Randy. His jealousy comes screaming out and it’s very unprofessional and childish‼️
Totally agree. He's rude and disrespectful. He has fail to realize that it is not weak to work together with a co-worker. Come on now. He is acting as if he is in kindergarten. He could have share the moment with Randy. If I ever do get married and go to the store to get a dress, I would specifically ask for Randy. He is the BEST.
Shay really thinks Randy is jealous of him, get a grip ABSOLUTELY nothing to be jealous about. Randy is awesome very professional and knows all about team work. Randy tries to help everyone that's why he's loved. Shay get over yourself ❤❤
Yea guys who are ego divas have all the answers but fail to realize Randy Fenoli is the man with dress selections and is wedding dress line is amazing. She is just another worker, easily replaceable
WTH is up with Shay's jacket?? 1 button done, up around his sternum, leaving his belly sticking out all obvious. What a horrible look for someone that's supposed to be a "fashion person". Oooh, just got to the part where he basically evicted Randy from the stock room. WOW! Arrogant much?
I love that beautiful proposal. Hope they keep this love till death do them apart. Shay and Randy's spat was a production setup to make it interesting.
2:40 My bros are in a nasty cat fight over fit-&-flare dresses 😹 I’m always gonna honor Randy’s expertise tho 🙌🏻 2 gay retail coworkers fightin’ like cats & dogs
What is Randy's problem? Shay is consistently capable of handling his work. Randy is used to stepping in when the women consultants need him. This guy threatens him is what I think. Or at least that's what the producers are trying to create cos they are also equally not great actors.
oh where to start... didnt she wonder why cameras were filming her? or why she's trying on dresses if theyre not even engaged? and that dress was ill-fitting, her dark underwear showed through. i wouldnt want a proposal like this. but they are a very sweet couple and I wish them well.
Shay is a fool to turn down the help of Randy who not only has excellent taste but knows exactly how to behave!. Shay is also creepy "beautiful girlfriend" as he strokes her hair -ugh! .🌈🙄🙏
The proposal and dress are beautiful❤...her not knowing about it? I'm not buying that part...when she comes out wearing the dress she already has on heels but those weren't the original shoes she had on...unless Kleinfield let's you borrow shoes
women look at wedding dresses before they're engaged and sometimes even before they're in a serious relationship. it's nice to just daydream and get an idea of what you like for when the time comes.
This is honestly really weird. If my partner was like hmm we’re not even engaged but want to wear some dresses? I’d be like uh piss off man don’t mess with me let’s go😂 feels like a shut up ring to me if she’s that desperate to try on dresses
Wondering if Jonathan is still there. His ego takes up the whole room and there's no space for anybody else. He could learn from Randy. I'd ask for another consultant myself. Ego is like sandpaper to my soul.
OK, the last dress. A good salesperson would not have let her bring that into the room. That "friend" is no friend. :( So, which dress did she end up with after three appointments?
Shay needs a lesson in manners, Randy is epitome of decorum and diplomacy....I doubt Shay will last at Kleinfelds with that attitude towards his colleagues.
I HATED Shay. I felt like his “rivalry” with Randy was manufactured by the show runners. This show doesn’t need fake drama - the real drama from the bridal parties is more than enough!
I usually won’t watch if Jonathan is in video, he is so arrogant and annoying, I watched this for the proposal. Maybe this is an old video and Jonathan is gone I hope
I suspect the producers artificially cultivated this catty tension between Randy and the other consultant. Who could ever be rude to Randy?! But it does make for good TV. That guy's sassiness is fun to hate!!
I can see the look on Shay’s face that he’s totally jealous of Randy he thinks he knows more about dresses then Randy does when he’s the expert on this stuff 😂
Ugly dress, totally wrong for her body. Something that would have covered her more on top, and a looser fit around the belly would have been far more flattering. Randy would have chosen a far nicer gown that would have made the young woman look like a million dollar princess.
Shay really underestimates how much Randy is loved and has a huge fan base - so being critical of Randy is just going to make him extremely unpopular. Wrong move.
Yeah, but he ticks all the right boxes in today's dei world.
Shay is so jealous of Randy. He acts like he knows more than Randy who is the real expert. Beautiful proposal.
I never liked him. Such arrogance, such disrespect.
why are they making up this beef all of a sudden? i have never heard any consultant, shay included, speak to randy that way before. they clearly scripted this for the episode but it doesn't make any sense. i guess a surprise proposal wasn't dramatic enough for the producers?
@@dietotaku he did it in many episodes and there was other beef too.
@@dietotaku Shay has done this before. I've seen it in every episode where he encounters Randy.
The Shaye and Randy thing is bizarrely funny! Randy wants to assert his expertise and position and Shaye wants to be left to do his job! I don’t think either of them is right or wrong but, I do think both their egos clash!! I think Randy should back off a little, I believe Shaye gets great feedback and if that’s true, he’s doing his job, no need for Randy to get bent out of shape if someone doesn’t need his input.
Team Randy!
Y'all are SO funny acting like this show isn't EXTREMELY scripted. Shay and Randy are fine y'all that interaction was written by the producers. Randy probably didn't want to waste his time but still contacted to make an appearance. Chill out y'all are wildin
I know, right? They probably think the Kardashian's aren't scripted either lol
I feel sorry for Jonathan the boyfriend lol. He got so many negative comments because people thought his name is the consultant's 😂
Ahhh okay. This makes a lot more sense 😂
......yea I'm sure she had an idea..you don't just take a girl to a wedding place to try on stuff unless you plan on asking them to marry you
and the cameras? she didn't question why she's being filmed for the show?
Yeah, but maybe not just at that particular time.
@@jessicakorban7980I dunno. I'm thinking about it, and I figure, if I were her young age and had never been to NYC, let alone a store like Kleinfeld's, I'd be ready to believe cameras were rolling on someone at any point. Maybe they convinced her they were giving Jonathan some camera time as a form of on-the-job training. I'd be completely prepared to believe, "Yeah, this is about a training film, not about me."
@@haplessasshole9615Yes, I agree. And the bride blushed so much. She couldn’t fake the surprise that much.
she most likely had an idea but she was not about to ruin her own proposal and there are actually quite a few women who are cool to just try on the dresses for fun
I've watched SO many Yes shows, but that first story brought tears! ❤
The first dress for the second bride was incredible
what a sweet event for a cute couple, and that is NOT her dress. Shay's arrogance stops all he could learn from a seasoned bridal agent, Randy. Ridiculous.
most likely scripted 😀
I thought his name was Shea. Isn't Johnathan the groom?
Yes, it's Shay. His rivalry with Randy is immature. @@deejay136
u r right.@@deejay136
Shay... not Jonathan. But i agree.. wrong dress!
Randy is King of that store , take a step back dude , respect
This is so genuinely thoughtful I’m in love for her
Jonathan might be good at his job. But he acts like such a real jerk, particularly with Randy. His jealousy comes screaming out and it’s very unprofessional and childish‼️
I thought his name was Shea. Isn't Johnathan the groom?
How long did he last at Kleinfelds?
Totally agree. He's rude and disrespectful. He has fail to realize that it is not weak to work together with a co-worker. Come on now. He is acting as if he is in kindergarten. He could have share the moment with Randy. If I ever do get married and go to the store to get a dress, I would specifically ask for Randy. He is the BEST.
@@jcomeau15371 I don't know if he is still there. He is not a team player.
@@jcomeau15371 I think he only lasted one season. I remember him. He was rude to Randy.
the 2nd brides friends were THE BEST.
*gasp* “Oh my gosh Jamie your BUTT!!!”
would have been hilarious if she had said "oh. my. god. jamie. look. at your. BUTT!"
Shay really thinks Randy is jealous of him, get a grip ABSOLUTELY nothing to be jealous about. Randy is awesome very professional and knows all about team work. Randy tries to help everyone that's why he's loved. Shay get over yourself ❤❤
I honestly dont like Sheas attitude. He needs to be quiet sometimes and listen when people are giving him good advise.
Yes, he needs to LISTEN!!!
I thought he was just playing
Yea guys who are ego divas have all the answers but fail to realize Randy Fenoli is the man with dress selections and is wedding dress line is amazing. She is just another worker, easily replaceable
@tiffanybrown1001 No, he has had some weird one-sided beef with Randy since the first episode he was on, and it's annoying!
Jonathan is the groom y'all. Shae, or whatever the spelling is, is the consultant.
I wouldn’t call him that, he is so full of himself it’s embarrassing.
Aw not playing well with the professionals. Randy rules
Yea Randy rules!!
I love Shay and how he treats the brides to be ❤ but the way he acts around Randy 😢
Wedding shop, CAMERAS..but no clue 😏
Staged AF
Oh my word, I just LOVE Randy. He is so sweet and balanced. Randy is just precious.❤️🥰
I didn’t believe for a second that it was a surprise but I teared up anyway.🤷♀️
WTH is up with Shay's jacket?? 1 button done, up around his sternum, leaving his belly sticking out all obvious. What a horrible look for someone that's supposed to be a "fashion person".
Oooh, just got to the part where he basically evicted Randy from the stock room. WOW! Arrogant much?
“You owe a surprise!”, they’re adorable 💕
I love that beautiful proposal. Hope they keep this love till death do them apart. Shay and Randy's spat was a production setup to make it interesting.
2:40 My bros are in a nasty cat fight over fit-&-flare dresses 😹 I’m always gonna honor Randy’s expertise tho 🙌🏻 2 gay retail coworkers fightin’ like cats & dogs
Congratulations!!! Best wishes. ❤
The dynamic between Randy and Shay reminds me of me and an old coworker 😂 I’m a fan of Randy. ❤
Yeah, the "consultant " was horrible and very rude to Randy.
What an awful dress. At least put something on her that fits better. Team Randy!
“One thing that’s missing” … “A belt?” 🥰🥰🥰
This is the first I've seen of this guy and...nah!!!! I'm team Randy all day!
I'm confused why is she trying on wedding dresses and she's not engaged?
i hope you were able to watch more than 3 seconds of the clip in order to get your answer.
Awwww I cried;-). Sooo sweet 🧁
Yes!
Lol Johnathans proposal was 🥴... I wish he said something sentimental. But congratulations to the couple 🥰🙏🏽
In all honesty the bloke seemed so nervous
Never did like this guy Shae, his behaviour is inappropriate.
Jonathan told her that she owes him a surprise i wonder if it's gonna be pregnancy !! Hahahaha 😅 that would top his surprise 😅
Like shay but love randy! He should open his mind to learning from the best
What is Randy's problem? Shay is consistently capable of handling his work. Randy is used to stepping in when the women consultants need him. This guy threatens him is what I think. Or at least that's what the producers are trying to create cos they are also equally not great actors.
Comes to a wedding shop trying on dresses and has no clue she’s being proposed to? 😂
with cameras.
Are you sure this wasn’t scripted between Randy and Jonathan? Makes for tv drama😂😂
I thought his name was Shea. Isn't Johnathan the groom?
I ❤️ the proposal
Where is the rest of this episode?
yes, I wanna see what dress she picked
Segunda parte porfis!!!😢😢😢
How did he explain the camera crew filming, and didn't the couple have to sign some sort of release for filming?
oh where to start... didnt she wonder why cameras were filming her? or why she's trying on dresses if theyre not even engaged? and that dress was ill-fitting, her dark underwear showed through. i wouldnt want a proposal like this. but they are a very sweet couple and I wish them well.
Great proposal!!! Last one -it's an $8100 fancy Nighty. (ugh) in my opinion.
#1, WRONG dress!
Wow Jonathan.. learn from the best.... xx 😢😂❤
You mean Shae, jonathan is the groom
It's all about Jonathan....
Shay is a fool to turn down the help of Randy who not only has excellent taste but knows exactly how to behave!. Shay is also creepy "beautiful girlfriend" as he strokes her hair -ugh! .🌈🙄🙏
The perfect consultant for a surprise!!! Love me some Shay!!!
This had to be the best episode I’ve seen. Randy looked smoking hot in his suit!
Shay is intimidated and jealous of Randy.
The proposal and dress are beautiful❤...her not knowing about it? I'm not buying that part...when she comes out wearing the dress she already has on heels but those weren't the original shoes she had on...unless Kleinfield let's you borrow shoes
Ее привели в свадебный салон, а она делает вид, что не понимает, что ей сделают предложение?
If Amanda came to me with a bad fitting jacket over staunch. I’d go the other way.
I’d be like, I’m not tryin’ on wedding dresses. Why would I? I’m not getting married. 🫤
Someone would have to clue me in.
believe me, its always a good thing if he suggests looking at wedding dresses. If it happens to you, just indulge him in that one but expect nothing.
😂😂😂
If she's been looking a dresses then how much of a surprise can this be??
women look at wedding dresses before they're engaged and sometimes even before they're in a serious relationship. it's nice to just daydream and get an idea of what you like for when the time comes.
Randy is so cool patient helpful in a very non pushy way. This is why RF is so loved. SHAY SUCKS. 509 dress is yucky
Did Jamie Lee get a dress?
This is honestly really weird. If my partner was like hmm we’re not even engaged but want to wear some dresses? I’d be like uh piss off man don’t mess with me let’s go😂 feels like a shut up ring to me if she’s that desperate to try on dresses
Wondering if Jonathan is still there. His ego takes up the whole room and there's no space for anybody else. He could learn from Randy.
I'd ask for another consultant myself. Ego is like sandpaper to my soul.
I would like Jonathan a lot more if he was less bitchy.
I wonder if he still works there now?
Jonathan is the groom. The bridal consultant is Shea.
@@dr.emilyacevedo812Ah. I was unclear, too. Shoulda read the on-screen graphics, huh?
What if she said no....😮
OK, the last dress. A good salesperson would not have let her bring that into the room. That "friend" is no friend. :( So, which dress did she end up with after three appointments?
Shay needs a lesson in manners, Randy is epitome of decorum and diplomacy....I doubt Shay will last at Kleinfelds with that attitude towards his colleagues.
Ummm.. insulting Randy is not a good business decision. And that dress was too small.
I HATED Shay. I felt like his “rivalry” with Randy was manufactured by the show runners. This show doesn’t need fake drama - the real drama from the bridal parties is more than enough!
I usually won’t watch if Jonathan is in video, he is so arrogant and annoying, I watched this for the proposal. Maybe this is an old video and Jonathan is gone I hope
Jonathan is the groom. Shea is the consultant.
The consultant Shay didn’t last long. He wasn’t professional.
I suspect the producers artificially cultivated this catty tension between Randy and the other consultant. Who could ever be rude to Randy?! But it does make for good TV. That guy's sassiness is fun to hate!!
No, it wasn’t. Shay didn’t last long .
exactly
I can see the look on Shay’s face that he’s totally jealous of Randy he thinks he knows more about dresses then Randy does when he’s the expert on this stuff 😂
And in a couple years they have kids and happily ever after....
No...they got married but didn't stay together. No kids.
Shay didn't last very long. Haven't seen him in a long long time...........
Y'all going nutsin comments but this shay-Randy thing is just to add some spice or they wouldn't have aired it
The comedian has that typical female comedian voice
Heather's sister looks like Rosamund Pike !
WHAT HAPPENED TO PAULA'S FACE??
Doing it like this was sweet but what if she had said no
Wtf happened to the rest of the show! This is so annoying.
Sure was sweet
I never liked that Shay guy day one. Ruins the show.
Love this consultant, besides Randy, he is awesome!!
Hmmmm
Shay’s jacket doesn’t fit and it’s buttoned wrong, not into him… he should have let Randy help him, dork.
Ugly dress, totally wrong for her body. Something that would have covered her more on top, and a looser fit around the belly would have been far more flattering.
Randy would have chosen a far nicer gown that would have made the young woman look like a million dollar princess.
👍👍👍👍
Randy has an attitude and enlarged ego when it comes to not being needed
Shay should dress better. sorry man, that button did not hide but accentuated your belly,
That is a MAN
Randy has every right to “check on” that poser.
Akward
Does tlc pay extra money to kleinfeld 💍🤍 consultant?
I dont know if its for more views but why is he like that with Randy🫨. Girl!! he is not trying to steal your job just chill the f out. Chilll
Are you sure this wasn’t scripted between Randy and Jonathan? Makes for tv drama😂😂
Jonathan told her that she owes him a surprise i wonder if it's gonna be pregnancy !! Hahahaha 😅 that would top his surprise 😅