So many years later and this part still gets to me. It truly was a great show. Florence and the Machine's Shake it Out was a great pick for this scene.
This scene makes me cry every time. My heart breaks for Ted. And Jason’s (Marshall) acting is SO GOOD. Marshall is the best friend anybody could ask for. And it killed him to tell Robin that on Ted’s behalf. As for the song playing and Ted standing on the roof... wow. Perfect combination. HIMYM was always so perfect with the small details that are a huge part to the show.
I wish I could say the same. I have put up with so much shit in my life my ex faked her own death and made me feel terrible. I then got lucky with my fiancee now next month will be our ten years.
The gradually rising shot of a broken Ted on the roof, the increasing tempo of the organ, Robin giving back her keys and hugging Ted behind the scene.... one of the most painfully wholesome scenes of HIMYM. The ending was crap, but for some scenes like this, I watch this show again and again. So many life changing moments!
the point is that robin loves him but feels he is better off without her so she painfully says no, the ending is kinda bad because they didn't take much time to show us how these characters really felt. Honestly the deleted scene where ted and robin have lunch on some random restaurant while ted is married makes the ending better
But you can see that Robin does love Ted in her expressions. Also Marshall‘s „not yet“ proves that the ending works. Moreover there are so many hints throughout the whole series that Ted and Robin will end up together.
@@moonlightcaroline2423 but Ted clearly asked her, wether Robin would somewhen love Ted at any day in her life, and wanted to have that final and ultimate answer (it's right in the dialogue before this video). And Robins answer is "no". So if she said "no" in that second, it should also count in 20 years or so, as this was the final answer Ted wanted in this scene.
The way Jason pursed his lips and tried to force a comforting smile at 1:38 …there’s more emotion in just his facial movement there than a lot of actors can muster in an entire series. He really made Marshall look like he was completely broken-hearted for his best friend in that moment. Absolutely fantastic acting
This scene along with this song makes it so strong that it just leaves you thinking how we have to move on, no matter how hard it is. That 'No' and then Ted's response which he was muttering earlier in a funny way just made this scene perfect. Ted's getting out alone with a the street full of women carrying yellow umbrella shows how brilliant and creative this show is....I love this show!
Marshall had to tell robin Ted couldnt tell her n plus robin bringing other guys over it was goin to kill Ted n he break off the deal they had wen there 40 they will get married that was never gonna happen
After watching this series 3/4 times Everytime I run into this scene i just take one of the biggest advices this show can tell you: don't be afraid to fall in love, don't be afraid to admit it and if it doesn't work out that is just a bump on the road and at the end of the day that road will take to your rest of your life
bro when I tell that this is, like, the FIFTH song that I discovered randomly, absolutely loved it and became obssesed with only to find out later that it was already in the how i met your mother soundtrack. this show OWNS me at this point. years go by and I still discover new things to love about this story and production.
It really is. Clear, honest, and kind. It allows the other person to understand the situation clearly, move on, and find what they’ve been looking for their whole lives. ❤
Isn't another example... When you feel this type of feeling like what ted felt.. You always have to move alone.. You can't explain what you feel.. That's why this song fits perfects here. " I like to keep some things to myself I like to keep my issues strong It's always darkest before the dawn"
I've watched this show way too many times, but man it hits different after falling in love for the first time. I once blamed ted for the crazy things he did for Robin, now I cry when i see him tearing himself in order to make her happy, cause i freaking know the feeling. We need more shows like this.
Marshall the best friend ever. He just tells her straight you've gotten everything from him and he's still to crazy about you to let it go even when he's getting nothing in return, it's not fair. The later seasons really made Robin a villain completely selfish and unforgivable and she never really got a scene were one of the group pulled her up about being so selfish.
Here after my breakup. It was a mutual breakup both of us were crying and emotional. Reminded me of this scene. I wish things did not have to be this way.
I feel like standing on the roof of Ted's apartment sometimes because. Back in may of this year my fiancée broke up with me. After we had been together for over 12 and a half years. I am never gonna give up on her because I love her still so much.
Listen, i know i dont know you. But i just want you to know. However hard it seems it will be okqy. Ive been in your situation more times then i can count. It'll be hard at first. For a while maybe. But it will grt easier. Heartbreak is never easy but it gets easier with time.
@@lachlansanders9821 thank you so much ! I actually did manage to move on just a few weeks after writing that comment ! Going no contact helped a lot and I'm now with a wondeful new partner that treats me so much better !I feel very lucky
Hmmm gona see Florence and the machine next week in Madison Square Garden and I didt realize I heard of her years ago because of this scene. I just started listening to Florence 3 months ago.
And this proves you can't listen past words. Look at robin right before she says no, looks like she wanted to say yes. She just can't because she won't be able to give ted his dream of having a family. Kevin couldn't give away his dream but just because ted could doesn't mean she would let him do so. This series is a drama in comedy disguise. Two people who loved each other but couldn't be together because of their differences and add infertility on top of that and consciously decide they have to go different ways. People don't understand the series as much as they like to claim.
@@oceanlegends1533 word my friend. I think the same.. People always criticise this scene that if they are saying No now.. Thn why they ended up together.. People don't understand time change people.. Experiences change people.. People don't understand that the ending is not bad... It just not perfect 😊
@@oceanlegends1533 maybe she wanted to say yes, but relationships are more than just loving, I can love someone but we are just not meant to be. And seeing ted moving out from her is great, clinging to the idea of robin was destroying him, he says it himself in the episode "sunrise", he gives a definition of love and at the begining of the episode older ted admits that he was mistaken, with robin he had to destroy himself, with Tracy (even though he probably was disposed to) he didn't had to.
@@tomasrodriguez827 I'm not arguing the fact that they weren't meant to be together, in the end both had their own universal karma, the things that they were supposed to learn. Ted had to let go and find tracy, and robin, well, she had to choose barney to learn that chemistry and logic isn't everything, she had to go through divorce and end up alone to finally understand that living a life trying to prove yourself to be worthy of your father's aproval is something that simply leads to emptyness. Life is more than success and money.
How on earth did a sitcom turn out to become such a moving romantic comedy? By the end i hated Robin! How on earth does a sitcom KILL OFF THE MOTHER in the Finale!?!?!?! Cristin Milioti was the perfect fit for Ted....he deserved a happy ending with Tracy!
This is like my unofficial end to this show. No Ted clinging to robin and a statement of hope moving into the future that he will meet the mother. I wish they had stuck with this idea of Ted moving on till the end Bc it would truly keep the weight of this scene and help round out teds growth
I'm honestly in a similar situation and I haven't got the rejection yet but I'm pretty sure it's coming in a few weeks but when it does it's going to hurt for a couple days maybe weeks but then I will be free
You know that with this final you dislearnt what you learned. Ted let go Robin but Marshall makes us think the opposite. And not mention it the series finale
Whoever chose this song for the scene should get a raise
The show ended
@@goodftoest that’s not what he meant
Yes! He should be ceo.
@@themysteriousredwarriorblo1662 The show is over dumbass.
Okay they should have gotten a raise, that better
Marshal is simply the greatest friends that has ever been in a comedy show. period.
Joey is great as Marshall
@@aldodeluca7715 Who tf is Joey? Lol
@@camm7985 joey tribiani from friends
@@aldodeluca7715 not even close
@@aldodeluca7715 Marshall is not a playboy like him
HIMYM is a show for people who really know how it hurts to love
I love the show before being in love, and now all these scenes hurt on a personal level.
@@thire10 absolutely
Sandman feeling it rn
This whole scene changed my life
Agreed bro
Hope is all well with you
Yes for me too
Agree bro one of the most underrated scenes in TV History
@Ella Fisher It stopped me living in the past of things that aren't ever going to happen
Just lived this scene this week. Told her I loved her she said she didn’t anymore. It hurt but in a crazy way this scene makes it feel better
So many years later and this part still gets to me. It truly was a great show. Florence and the Machine's Shake it Out was a great pick for this scene.
Yess!!
1:43 ted standing there alone with that organ playing is just pure heartwrenching..
2:03 not to mention *_that drop_* ! that was awesome
probably the most relatable scene of himym ... at least to me
We all wish, we had a Friend like Marshall
Or you can be a friend like Marshall to your friends
@@hajirahazher1091 this one. I want to be the Marshall to my friends.....that's not to say I need a Marshall in my life
This scene makes me cry every time. My heart breaks for Ted. And Jason’s (Marshall) acting is SO GOOD. Marshall is the best friend anybody could ask for. And it killed him to tell Robin that on Ted’s behalf. As for the song playing and Ted standing on the roof... wow. Perfect combination. HIMYM was always so perfect with the small details that are a huge part to the show.
That no, is the most painful no I ever experienced in my life!
AJ Orsini same here. that was heartbreaking
Then you're lucky
Yeah I felt worst on that no than I did when my dad left me at Walmart
I wish I could say the same. I have put up with so much shit in my life my ex faked her own death and made me feel terrible. I then got lucky with my fiancee now next month will be our ten years.
@@DerekBoldiene360 is it real.faked death..🙄😳
"not yet."
We all have that "not yet" in our lives.
Hell yeah not yet. Never give up
The gradually rising shot of a broken Ted on the roof, the increasing tempo of the organ, Robin giving back her keys and hugging Ted behind the scene.... one of the most painfully wholesome scenes of HIMYM. The ending was crap, but for some scenes like this, I watch this show again and again. So many life changing moments!
i agree scenes like this just make it seem like something epic was about to happen.
When all the umbrellas showed up, this was it: HOPE!!!!
yes i agree its like even though robin is moving out its like now things can start to get better for him.
When people ask why I don't think the ending works, I show them this scene.
True ♥️
Then you're forgetting the carousel scene
the point is that robin loves him but feels he is better off without her so she painfully says no, the ending is kinda bad because they didn't take much time to show us how these characters really felt. Honestly the deleted scene where ted and robin have lunch on some random restaurant while ted is married makes the ending better
But you can see that Robin does love Ted in her expressions. Also Marshall‘s „not yet“ proves that the ending works. Moreover there are so many hints throughout the whole series that Ted and Robin will end up together.
@@moonlightcaroline2423 but Ted clearly asked her, wether Robin would somewhen love Ted at any day in her life, and wanted to have that final and ultimate answer (it's right in the dialogue before this video).
And Robins answer is "no". So if she said "no" in that second, it should also count in 20 years or so, as this was the final answer Ted wanted in this scene.
Rest in power, Bob Saget. For my money, many of the best lines of the series were delivered through his narration.
The way Jason pursed his lips and tried to force a comforting smile at 1:38 …there’s more emotion in just his facial movement there than a lot of actors can muster in an entire series. He really made Marshall look like he was completely broken-hearted for his best friend in that moment. Absolutely fantastic acting
The symbolism in this show is insane, huge props to the writers
Marshall was always right.
Except for when he was either drunk or a kid. 🤔
Marshall is such a good friend.
Yep. After she fucked half the town ted eventually got his princess
@@Bripy in your opinion robin should be with barney ?
If you think so the barney f*ck the whole town
Well, yes. Because the ending was decided during season 2 or 3. It was always going to end with Robin.
This will forever be one of my favorite scenes. And I’m so thankful that HIMYM introduced me to this song.
This scene along with this song makes it so strong that it just leaves you thinking how we have to move on, no matter how hard it is. That 'No' and then Ted's response which he was muttering earlier in a funny way just made this scene perfect. Ted's getting out alone with a the street full of women carrying yellow umbrella shows how brilliant and creative this show is....I love this show!
What the scene with the umbrellas mean im only watching a few eps can you explain thank u
@@hanhoang7883 I'd recommend to keep watching the show to find it out for yourself. You'll love it.
@@hanhoang7883 keep watching
HIMYM fans are the best, not spoiling anything for anyone
That scene where marshall tells robin she has to move out is so underrated
Marshall had to tell robin Ted couldnt tell her n plus robin bringing other guys over it was goin to kill Ted n he break off the deal they had wen there 40 they will get married that was never gonna happen
This scene is living proof why everyone needs a friend like Marshall Erickson.
It breaks my heart this scene. Is not only how the acting is done by all three actors here, but also because I see myself in there.
After watching this series 3/4 times Everytime I run into this scene i just take one of the biggest advices this show can tell you: don't be afraid to fall in love, don't be afraid to admit it and if it doesn't work out that is just a bump on the road and at the end of the day that road will take to your rest of your life
I know how it feels when you love someone and they don't love you back 😔
I will never not cry in the scene.
"I could never leave the past behind"
"Do you love me?" "No" When Ted clear his throat, you know he was hurt.
One of the best scenes in the entire show.... chills every time
bro when I tell that this is, like, the FIFTH song that I discovered randomly, absolutely loved it and became obssesed with only to find out later that it was already in the how i met your mother soundtrack. this show OWNS me at this point. years go by and I still discover new things to love about this story and production.
Goosebumps everywhere, everytime
jan 22’. still love this so much
This scene changed my life man it's so painful
One of the best scenes EVER!
Marshall is really is Ted best friend. Only a true friend would have your back
marshall being such an amazing friends by handling business for ted
Marshall is the friend that always have your back no matter what
With is scene I realised that rejection is also a good thing
It really is. Clear, honest, and kind. It allows the other person to understand the situation clearly, move on, and find what they’ve been looking for their whole lives. ❤
@@InvisibleBlues this
That's why i love the song , perfect scene
funny thing is, robin also have yellow raincoat..
Isn't another example... When you feel this type of feeling like what ted felt.. You always have to move alone.. You can't explain what you feel..
That's why this song fits perfects here.
" I like to keep some things to myself
I like to keep my issues strong
It's always darkest before the dawn"
When he enters the street, the first girl with the yellow umbrella really looks like Tracy 😳
I've always thought this! Notice how he follows her with his eyes for a moment.
Bro...
ted and robin were always better as friends. she has always been way more in love with barney, they’re a great match.
Lmao Ted and Robin end up together in the end...
@UCNthfqRS-O-DNkaW2W__ocw yeah, so? it’s not my fault the writers are dumb as 💩
@@screenshotscenes Ķ!sş mę !! :')
Great scene,this show is so great.
I've watched this show way too many times, but man it hits different after falling in love for the first time.
I once blamed ted for the crazy things he did for Robin, now I cry when i see him tearing himself in order to make her happy, cause i freaking know the feeling.
We need more shows like this.
Instead of saying we all need a friend like Marshall. We should all need strive to be like Marshall.
One of the best scenes. Really love this serie❤
Whoever is still saying Friends was a greater show than HIMYM obviously didn't see this scene
Always makes me tear up. Okay, I’m lying. Makes me sob.
Man
I wish for a friend like Marshall
I saw himym almost 7 years ago, and the first time i listened to this song, i was hooked.
I still listen to it on loop😔😔
Marshall the best friend ever. He just tells her straight you've gotten everything from him and he's still to crazy about you to let it go even when he's getting nothing in return, it's not fair. The later seasons really made Robin a villain completely selfish and unforgivable and she never really got a scene were one of the group pulled her up about being so selfish.
Here after my breakup. It was a mutual breakup both of us were crying and emotional. Reminded me of this scene. I wish things did not have to be this way.
This episode has it's own beauty..❤️
Estou revendo a série. Essa é uma das mais lindas passagens. A dor do Ted, o ótimo amigo que o Marshall é, novas possibilidades. Amo!
One of the saddest scenes ever
oh god the scene with the song oh myyy
When a man ask a woman do she love him and she said no. It is heartbreaking.
this scene is so000 powerful.
I feel like standing on the roof of Ted's apartment sometimes because. Back in may of this year my fiancée broke up with me. After we had been together for over 12 and a half years. I am never gonna give up on her because I love her still so much.
Closure & moving on at its best!
I'm exactly in Ted's shoes right now and I know I need to move on but I'm struggling
Listen, i know i dont know you. But i just want you to know. However hard it seems it will be okqy. Ive been in your situation more times then i can count. It'll be hard at first. For a while maybe. But it will grt easier. Heartbreak is never easy but it gets easier with time.
@@lachlansanders9821 thank you so much ! I actually did manage to move on just a few weeks after writing that comment ! Going no contact helped a lot and I'm now with a wondeful new partner that treats me so much better !I feel very lucky
“I’ve been a fool and I’ve been blind”
Feels.
Poor Ted. He always trying to find love.
i wish i had a friend like marshal,
Hmmm gona see Florence and the machine next week in Madison Square Garden and I didt realize I heard of her years ago because of this scene. I just started listening to Florence 3 months ago.
why for heavens sake do they cut the damn song at the end of the scene.....
Yep. This is a good thing.
The beauty of this scene is why the ending of HIMYM doesn't make sense
Goated scene goated show
Ted tried to hide his feelings. But Marshall knows that Ted is hurting
With this scene that song changed meanin
THIS SHOULDVE BEEN THE END OF TED AND ROBIN , FUCK THE LAST EPISODE
That song was perfect for that moment
Not yet
Asking a person if they love you and they said no is painful to hear
Done.When I find you my love, I’ll show you this. Till then, I shall be waiting.
25.06.2022
This episode proved why Robin and Ted aren't meant to be together, and yet they decided to go with that ending...
And this proves you can't listen past words. Look at robin right before she says no, looks like she wanted to say yes. She just can't because she won't be able to give ted his dream of having a family. Kevin couldn't give away his dream but just because ted could doesn't mean she would let him do so.
This series is a drama in comedy disguise. Two people who loved each other but couldn't be together because of their differences and add infertility on top of that and consciously decide they have to go different ways. People don't understand the series as much as they like to claim.
@@oceanlegends1533 word my friend.
I think the same.. People always criticise this scene that if they are saying No now.. Thn why they ended up together..
People don't understand time change people.. Experiences change people..
People don't understand that the ending is not bad... It just not perfect 😊
@@abheethakker ending is not bad its HORRIBLE.
the character growth of barney robin just thrown away in just last 5min of show.
@@oceanlegends1533 maybe she wanted to say yes, but relationships are more than just loving, I can love someone but we are just not meant to be. And seeing ted moving out from her is great, clinging to the idea of robin was destroying him, he says it himself in the episode "sunrise", he gives a definition of love and at the begining of the episode older ted admits that he was mistaken, with robin he had to destroy himself, with Tracy (even though he probably was disposed to) he didn't had to.
@@tomasrodriguez827 I'm not arguing the fact that they weren't meant to be together, in the end both had their own universal karma, the things that they were supposed to learn. Ted had to let go and find tracy, and robin, well, she had to choose barney to learn that chemistry and logic isn't everything, she had to go through divorce and end up alone to finally understand that living a life trying to prove yourself to be worthy of your father's aproval is something that simply leads to emptyness. Life is more than success and money.
I wish I had a Marshall 😖
This was so sad
That scene should just mark the End for Ted and Robin! Even if Robin wasn’t supposed to be with Barney, she shouldn’t be with Ted in the End.
How on earth did a sitcom turn out to become such a moving romantic comedy? By the end i hated Robin! How on earth does a sitcom KILL OFF THE MOTHER in the Finale!?!?!?! Cristin Milioti was the perfect fit for Ted....he deserved a happy ending with Tracy!
This was suck an emotional moment
Wait until the last chapter
Not yet for me too. Dated 7th October 2024
This is like my unofficial end to this show. No Ted clinging to robin and a statement of hope moving into the future that he will meet the mother. I wish they had stuck with this idea of Ted moving on till the end Bc it would truly keep the weight of this scene and help round out teds growth
I'm honestly in a similar situation and I haven't got the rejection yet but I'm pretty sure it's coming in a few weeks but when it does it's going to hurt for a couple days maybe weeks but then I will be free
Dammit...you left the part where Marshall and Lily talk afterwards..the BEST part 😂 Thumbs up anyways 🤙
This scene truly hits like a ton of bricks
Ted and Robbin are better off just being friends
And yet they still end up together lmao.
Marshall's the best wingman.
Also it’s been 11 years since this was posted and I’m still heartbroken 💔 don’t judge please
You know that with this final you dislearnt what you learned.
Ted let go Robin but Marshall makes us think the opposite.
And not mention it the series finale
What ever season this was, it would have been a good time to meet the mother and end the show.
I just cried so fucking hard 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
Ted and Robin were never actually meant for each other. They were very different.
It was just Ted who always behaved like a Cinderella.😃
Robin moved out
Que triste
Marshall was the only one who believed in them
that fucking no😢😢
My god imagine how much money they blew on all those umbrellas
This was the second worst moment for Ted, I think.
The first for me was when she got engaged with Barney