THE HOSTAGE DEAL - with Nadav Eyal

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 80

  • @jammintoast1
    @jammintoast1 13 годин тому +37

    By far the best source for information on the Israel conflict. Dan and his guests speak the truth, regardless of whether the narrative aligns with left or right.

  • @lesleybergman3067
    @lesleybergman3067 13 годин тому +16

    Three podcasts in one week. My head is spinning. Thanks so much to both of you!

  • @jurirabiner8654
    @jurirabiner8654 13 годин тому +18

    Best source for the Israel conflict. Listen to every podcast. Greetings from Germany

    • @ahrazathar
      @ahrazathar 5 годин тому

      Best sourve If you are a zionist...

  • @raeli731
    @raeli731 7 годин тому +4

    I needed this conversation. Thank you 🙏🏻

  • @anitamurkes9511
    @anitamurkes9511 7 годин тому +4

    This show supports our mental health in these crazy times !

  • @irisbristow2977
    @irisbristow2977 5 годин тому +5

    Terrible deal. No other country in the whole wide world would be pressured to even talk to terrorist, let alone have to release murderers etc in exchange for babies, children, young people old people unarmed people take in extreme violence as hostages. We pray all will be well and stand with Israel and any palestians who truly want to live in peace with their neighbour Israel.

  • @MenD-e7i
    @MenD-e7i 14 годин тому +9

    Listening to this here on UA-cam a second time!!! Having already listened to the Podcast version!
    It’s so informative and well delivered!
    It’s incredible to me that this is not yet on the top of the trending lists!!!

  • @yosefelishevitz457
    @yosefelishevitz457 13 годин тому +17

    No stupid deals with terrorists

  • @persimmon3458
    @persimmon3458 7 годин тому +6

    As Churchill said, we Israelis had a choice between dishonor and war. We just chose dishonor, and we will get war. This hostage deal is horrific.

  • @gershonportnoy5589
    @gershonportnoy5589 8 годин тому +3

    Excellent podcast🙏

  • @pamelaleibowitz3019
    @pamelaleibowitz3019 Годину тому +2

    We need to learn from History! Otherwise we will continue to repeat those mistakes !!!!!

  • @purpleflame334
    @purpleflame334 10 годин тому +4

    Thank you! ❤

  • @JM.5387
    @JM.5387 10 годин тому +4

    Terrific analysis. Thank you.

  • @sherylkruger3344
    @sherylkruger3344 2 години тому

    Great. Thank you so much

  • @activistmalpractice
    @activistmalpractice 14 годин тому +14

    Short term gain resulting in long term pain?

    • @jacqueslevy340
      @jacqueslevy340 4 години тому

      Enormous pain but long term gain….

  • @gedaliaw
    @gedaliaw 4 години тому +2

    Thank you Dan and Nadav. You've helped reframe the deal in a more positive light. I'm still not convinced it's a good deal, at all, but I understand the nuance and political necessity better.

    • @jacqueslevy340
      @jacqueslevy340 4 години тому

      Deal is not a political necessity but of standing by the Jewish soul….

    • @gedaliaw
      @gedaliaw 4 години тому

      @@jacqueslevy340 There absolutely is incredible international and internal political pressure to agree to this deal. Saving Jewish lives is of course paramount, but the cost needs to be weighed up carefully.

  • @megantaylor4189
    @megantaylor4189 10 годин тому +2

    Thanks.

  • @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla
    @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla 9 годин тому +3

    why why bow down? no list of alive hostage? why ceasefire? why exchange future hostages for current hostages? how many sin wars released? why?

    • @jacqueslevy340
      @jacqueslevy340 4 години тому

      Reason ‘why’ clearly explained in this podcast….

  • @geekwithabs
    @geekwithabs 11 годин тому +7

    I'm so sorry y'all have radical muslims surrounding you.

  • @ilana
    @ilana 3 години тому

    Literally insight i could never ever get anywhere else. Thank you.

  • @jerzywieckowski7610
    @jerzywieckowski7610 9 годин тому +5

    You are wrong. You wont see 98 hostages back home but hamas will get stronger and " starving people of gaza" are dancing on the streets. 900 IDF soldiers died for nothing. Jews are stabbed in the back. Again.

    • @ahrazathar
      @ahrazathar 5 годин тому

      This will continue as long as you occupy land which doesn't belong to you

  • @stansaks3704
    @stansaks3704 5 годин тому +1

    It’s truly excruciating and beggars belief this is our reality in 2025. Another version of freeing our Jewish Survivors out of the gates of hell. 🇮🇱

  • @yosefelishevitz457
    @yosefelishevitz457 13 годин тому +10

    2 million refugees cannot survive in such a tiny place
    One million should be relocated to Sudan

    • @kiswindsidaguigma9261
      @kiswindsidaguigma9261 10 годин тому

      This sound like a genocidal thought

    • @curioushuman4896
      @curioushuman4896 10 годин тому

      Christopher Hitchens said Zionism is a stupid idea silly superstitious waste of Judaism if a Jew in Brooklyn has a right to a state in Palestine then Palestinians born in Palestine have a right a state in Palestine, anyone who disagrees is suspect ( Charlie rose replies I think most people do agree with it and Hitchens retorts well in that case why do we have one and not the other ) it guaranteed a quarrel with Arabs the interview is on UA-cam as is Paul newsman’s

    • @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla
      @RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla 9 годин тому

      @@curioushuman4896 where is the source for Christophers' quote. dont fool yourself

    • @curioushuman4896
      @curioushuman4896 8 годин тому

      @ the source is on UA-cam search Christopher Hitchens Palestine or Paul Newman Israel

    • @ahrazathar
      @ahrazathar 5 годин тому

      You are telling as if its your land..

  • @driankatz
    @driankatz 12 годин тому +1

    great podcast. wished there was some discussion/speculation about the way forward for the remaining hostages...

  • @rachelebgi
    @rachelebgi 13 годин тому +1

    such great info

  • @jewfrombirth
    @jewfrombirth 14 годин тому +6

    Horrible mistake!

  • @robertbollert7375
    @robertbollert7375 7 годин тому +1

    He just had to say "Axis of Resistance" again. Please stop. Great details. Thank Mr. Eyal.

  • @terraloft
    @terraloft Годину тому

    Excruciating, yes. And without being able to lean on the sustaining Grace of Jesus Christ, we will not endure in order to stand in faith in integrity in Hope every soul needs to turn their eyes to Christ. Confess sin except his redemptive blood and call on his name for mercy

  • @sylvialandman3959
    @sylvialandman3959 55 хвилин тому

    What about the rest of the hostages.

  • @Zonno5
    @Zonno5 Годину тому

    It was a good podcast but I couldn't help but giggle about how Dan Senor is wearing two layers of dress shirts.

  • @RachelGild-ep3qt
    @RachelGild-ep3qt 14 годин тому

    ❤ happy about them coming home but I don’t about Hammas

  • @pamelaleibowitz3019
    @pamelaleibowitz3019 59 хвилин тому

    Thank G-D for Benjamin Netanyahu !!

  • @roseblue3368
    @roseblue3368 14 годин тому

    Why cant they give power to the clans in gazs surely they could keep hamas in check?

    • @joge2468
      @joge2468 12 годин тому +1

      It’s possible they will allow them civil control. The last time this idea was floated, though, Hummus targeted their leaders.

    • @stnln2180
      @stnln2180 11 годин тому

      Because Hamas controls humanitarian aid. In order to give power to tribal leaders Hamas should be removed and this could be done only if IDF controls humanitarian distribution.

  • @omarm316
    @omarm316 13 годин тому +3

    Dedicated to all who voted for Trump. There is a sucker born every minute.

    • @aaronrodgers77
      @aaronrodgers77 13 годин тому +1

      The fact that so many people just allowed themselves to believe he would do whatever they wanted is insane. Some Israeli right wingers were straight up delusional. Trump was threatening Israel, not Hamas.

    • @arikkatzenberg582
      @arikkatzenberg582 12 годин тому

      Who’d u vote for? Those Obama-Nazis?

    • @arikkatzenberg582
      @arikkatzenberg582 11 годин тому +1

      Who’s u vote for ? Those Obama-Nazzzzies?

  • @Trenl7
    @Trenl7 13 годин тому +1

    It's strength? Why? Dan keeps bringing this storyweaver and word trickster onto his program

  • @ahrazathar
    @ahrazathar 4 години тому

    Israel is winning😂😂
    No....

    • @jacqueslevy340
      @jacqueslevy340 4 години тому

      Yes, moral win…extremely important!

  • @ahrazathar
    @ahrazathar 4 години тому

    You feel so sad...
    Of a million people returning back to north...
    Palestinians Celebrating...
    I feel happy on your sadness...
    Your occupation will not last this century...

  • @ahrazathar
    @ahrazathar 6 годин тому

    Palestinian resistance will always win .

  • @sfa_2016
    @sfa_2016 12 годин тому

    What Hamas did was a heinous act, and I feel sorry for those killed and kidnapped as a result.
    What Israel has been doing before and since then is way much worse!
    I think Israel should stop playing the victim, realize peace is impossible with their far right fundamentalist politics, and sit on the table to reach a compromise and live as peaceful as possible.
    Foreign funding is not forever, and cannot keep you carry out the status quo. Furthermore, the global sentiment has turned against the state.
    The sooner this reality is realized, the less suffering for the beautiful peace loving people on both sides.

    • @Daniebraids
      @Daniebraids 12 годин тому +1

      The fact that you think Israel is much worse just shows how little you know or how immoral you are

    • @Zonno5
      @Zonno5 Годину тому

      israel tried peace in 2000 and 2006 only have to deal with the second intifada and october 7th. If you listen to Hamas and the PLO you will realize peace is never possible as long as those organizations are kept in power. The sooner the world realizes this reality, the sooner we can actually work towards peace.

  • @monkgroupie
    @monkgroupie 9 годин тому

    what about the Bibas family including 2 small children?