Library Chat #19: The Karrāmīs & The Miḥna of The Ash'arites of Nishāpur in 445 AH/1054 CE

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 жов 2024
  • Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Credits:
    Intro Nasheed:
    Link: tiny.cc/oornlz​​​
    Outro Nasheed:
    Link: tiny.cc/outro2​​​
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
    Facebook: yasirqadhi
    Instagram: yasir.qadhi
    Twitter: yasirQadhi
    Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    © Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official UA-cam Channel

КОМЕНТАРІ • 406

  • @alib7489
    @alib7489 3 роки тому +260

    Sheikh I have immensely benefited from your lectures for so many years. My humble request you don't withdraw from at the very least, releasing regular lectures on UA-cam. Jazakallah.

    • @alib7489
      @alib7489 3 роки тому +25

      And if you do decide to release a private portal I will subscribe Inshaa Allah.

    • @user-kl1on3nw7y
      @user-kl1on3nw7y 3 роки тому +5

      I agree

    • @R7m_frz
      @R7m_frz 3 роки тому +5

      Yes i agree he is my all time favourite

    • @mnizam84
      @mnizam84 3 роки тому +1

      Yes of course

    • @Esplayn
      @Esplayn 3 роки тому +1

      He’s not a sheikh. He’s a reformist.

  • @jawaahiri
    @jawaahiri 3 роки тому +142

    I would say UA-cam is the most suitable place because imagine the seerah you recorded before almost 10 years ago is still fresh and fascinating, likewise this library chat will help the umah for the coming decades. And your views will influence and cause average Muslims not to hate eachother.
    Jazaakallahu kheyran yaa shaykh yasir qadhi 🥰🥰🥰

    • @Shabq20
      @Shabq20 3 роки тому +6

      I totally agree ....seerah that was recorded 10 years ago I was able to listen to it a week ago.. Alhamdulillah for DR Sheikh YQ....

    • @a.a5589
      @a.a5589 3 роки тому +1

      love the somali translations you're doing, brother! very benenficial mashallah

    • @khorosh12
      @khorosh12 3 роки тому +2

      True indeed

    • @zakariasalah1595
      @zakariasalah1595 3 роки тому +1

      @@a.a5589 sorry who is doing somali translations?

    • @a.a5589
      @a.a5589 3 роки тому

      @@zakariasalah1595 @ma ognahay id making Somali translations of the seereah series dr. yasir qhadhi did amongst other videos :)

  • @omz20091
    @omz20091 3 роки тому +89

    Your private platform will not be as far out reaching, your work is amazing let your speech be heard across the globe, Sheikh I urge you to continue your interaction regardless of those that criticise and bring you down. You don't know how much you are helping others.

  • @Yazan61
    @Yazan61 3 роки тому +57

    I can respect and understand the desire to withdraw from the internet, the anonymity in particular breeds a level of toxicity that anyone could benefit from removing from their life. I kindly suggest that if you do withdraw from twitter and facebook, that you simply continue uploading to UA-cam while removing the comment section from your videos, and then if you do a private forum type of thing, then people would be able to discuss and comment there. I have benefited greatly from your UA-cam videos, and these library chats are one of the few places I can trust to get a non-orientalist take/explanation of historical events in Muslim lands.

  • @usmanhannan5675
    @usmanhannan5675 3 роки тому +34

    I had an undergrad in Near and Middle East Studies, and from there I know how the western intellect imbibes. The way you have been teaching is nothing short of paradigm shift, because I do not know of anyone who has done it at this level. No wonder you will raise many internal eyebrows, but why back off? Backing off will only make them clap, but the mass will miss the paradigm shift. I truly think Islam is true and at a very critical juncture right now. Basically all other religions have become pawns of time, while Islam stands tall. One way or other the paradigm shift will happen simply because Islam is true. But you should take active open part in it because that's your golden opportunity.

    • @chehrazadeesmey8399
      @chehrazadeesmey8399 3 роки тому

      A pleasure to read your comment, thank you ❤

    • @samirahmujahid5999
      @samirahmujahid5999 3 роки тому +2

      AS-saalamualaikum wa-Rahmah-tullahi-barraktu. Please do not stop teaching on UA-cam. You have give me so much knowledge. I took shahada in Huston masjid in the 70's 6 moths after Elijah Muhammad died.

    • @alib7489
      @alib7489 3 роки тому

      Brilliant point! Well said brother.

  • @SammyAgon
    @SammyAgon 3 роки тому +58

    Wallahi I love these library chats!

  • @paradelic
    @paradelic 3 роки тому +31

    Sheikh, I listen to you every day on my way to work and home on Spotify. I’m so busy at work and with life, this is the only time I am able to listen. I benefit immensely. You reach a wide audience, for better or for worse. Instead of finding a completely different platform, I would ask you consider turning off the comments on your UA-cam and Twitter posts. ‏بارك الله فيك وأحسن إليك

    • @saracentiano
      @saracentiano 3 роки тому

      Yeah. Good suggestion.

    • @maymah
      @maymah 3 роки тому +2

      Same with me! Driving to work and back. My private time for learning and broadening my Islamic knowledge

  • @OpinionatedOnion
    @OpinionatedOnion 3 роки тому +17

    My humble suggestion is to stay on UA-cam. There is no need for any of the other social media platforms. In fact - staying off of them will encourage others not to waste their time there. Releasing content to UA-cam can ensure access is maintained for those who benefit from your material. A separate, private, (Udemy style) classroom for more advanced students offering more interaction is also an interesting concept.

  • @hassanabdaladl
    @hassanabdaladl 3 роки тому +43

    Whether you keep doing public videos or you do talks in private, I'm fine with either. As long as I'm invited, ya shaykh! May Allah preserve you. Jazakallah khair

    • @sherifayantayo2873
      @sherifayantayo2873 3 роки тому +1

      Same akh , Assalamu aleikum akh I see you everywhere from bro hajji

    • @hassanabdaladl
      @hassanabdaladl 3 роки тому

      @@sherifayantayo2873 lol walaykum asalaam akhi

  • @jubayerrahman35
    @jubayerrahman35 3 роки тому +18

    Ustad, please Don't leave UA-cam.
    You have empowered many young Muslim all over the world via UA-cam.

  • @Mek7699
    @Mek7699 3 роки тому +40

    These muslim history library chats are brilliant as they are rare in english language.
    More history please jazakallahu khair

  • @gairoonishaboolay4331
    @gairoonishaboolay4331 3 роки тому +35

    There's the sincere the insincere , the knowledgeable and the normal people who loves to hear you . I enjoy every lecture of yours. And I wait with much excitement for the latest release as they come out. May Allah reward you endlessly in both worlds. Ameen

  • @yedum321
    @yedum321 3 роки тому +9

    My eyes lit up like a little boy on eid morning. I'll most certainly enjoy this. Thank you sheikh for sharing your knowledge.

  • @mhasanali01
    @mhasanali01 3 роки тому +7

    I cannot explain how excited I get whenever one of your Library Chats pop up on my feed. I always appreciate your content Shaykh! I don’t mind if you keep things on UA-cam or some other platform, just want to hear more from you.
    Much love from Ireland ☘️

  • @widisiraf
    @widisiraf 3 роки тому +26

    Sheikh, I've received possibly 80-90% of my deen from you. And I'm sure the case is similar for most people out here.

    • @sisterfleur7523
      @sisterfleur7523 2 роки тому

      Study tafseer, Hadith (with Mufti Menk) , Seerah, Fiqh, Tajweed etc online AT EMAN-ACADEMY ! Salam

    • @amerbinjarrah4427
      @amerbinjarrah4427 2 роки тому

      me too

  • @slivercopper32
    @slivercopper32 3 роки тому +8

    Dear Sheikh yasir qadhi,,
    Pls pls don't withdraw from social media.. u are a wonderful professor of Islamic studies..
    We keep on waiting to hear from you on lot of topics which other fellow sheikh's don't address..
    Pls continue with your youtube channel and lectures on different topic of Islam.

  • @farabisalauddin6049
    @farabisalauddin6049 3 роки тому +8

    Dear teacher I am from Bangladesh and despite being born a Muslim I knew very little of my deen , pls keep up the uploads in UA-cam, I spend most of my free time listening to u and if Allah wishes I shall continue, but please do not abandon youtube completely.

  • @jaadullaali98
    @jaadullaali98 3 роки тому +7

    Sheikh you have benefited immensely for people like me who can't attend your lectures physically . Please don't stop Social media Dawa

  • @osamasayed5929
    @osamasayed5929 3 роки тому +17

    Sheikh no-body has benefited me as a Muslim as much as you have done may Allah bless you and you can ignore those who criticise.

    • @أبوشغل
      @أبوشغل 3 роки тому

      Ignore those who criticize even if they are correct?

  • @randomzz3394
    @randomzz3394 3 роки тому +3

    Asalamualaikum my dear Shaykh. I just wanted to say that my family and I benefit from you immensely. It's tough for the younger generation but my little sisters watch your videos and like the way you deliver your talks. Please do not leave this public platform because this Ummah needs you. May Allah bless you.

  • @shine07031990
    @shine07031990 3 роки тому +2

    Sheikh, I have benefited very well from this platform and have learned a lot just from your refutation series. UA-cam I suggest would be the best as long as you may want to stop the comments

  • @kazirx1
    @kazirx1 3 роки тому +13

    السَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ
    We need you, please don’t leave the platform
    I am listening you last 15 years and I can raise my hand that you are one of the best, again we need you for average Muslims like me

  • @tariqkhalil7401
    @tariqkhalil7401 3 роки тому +4

    Wallah hee Sheikh you have been a blessing for us. Me and my son listen to every single word you say. Allah has not only blessed with knowledge but also the power to convey message. Whatever you decide we will InshaAllah make an effort to listen but youtube is a powerful tool , don't leave it for useless people. Ignore them and continue to do whatever you are passionate about. May Allah bless your parents who have raised a man like you Ameen

  • @muntasifsusmit
    @muntasifsusmit 3 роки тому +3

    Sheikh u really helped a lot of us. Plz stay in UA-cam. Ur seerah and lectures and library chats really enlightened many.may be share ur advance opinions in a different exclusive platform. And also keep Facebook and Twitter. But use them only for official announcements.

  • @diddydum
    @diddydum 3 роки тому +12

    I think many people would agree that not making public videos wouldn't stop fitna makers from making fitna.
    Your videos are some of the most beneficial out there. Please don't restrict them on account of people who will find a problem everywhere except within themselves

  • @mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141
    @mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141 3 роки тому +8

    Ya sheikh I think you should have a two tier groups of students; The private, high level above intermediate classes and us laymans... low level normal lectures and chats where we will continue to benefit from your chats sermons and all these evolution of ideas within Islam... don't quit on us non students of knowledge but yet are still vying one day to be among those who can handle top research and academic lectures. Please don't leave sheikh.

  • @Pain-jw3uu
    @Pain-jw3uu 3 роки тому +3

    Sheikh Social media is great for dawah. I think you have done more than enough to make people think critically. I don't see any point in continuing the lectures in public on topics that have debates. You should open a private portal so that only those who are serious in seeking knowledge benefit from you. and it will frankly make things easy for us to interact with you too.
    but for general topics or khutbahs I think you should continue to do that on social media. Jazakallahu Khayran

  • @WeFreedoomFighters
    @WeFreedoomFighters 3 роки тому +4

    I have been benefited enormously by your lectures. It’s provided me very fundamental in-depth knowledge of our Islamic history & theology. There are few things I may not agree with your opinions; however, I believe you have the utmost right to have the opinion with regards to the Islamic theology and it’s a blessing for the Ummah.
    My humble request please do not stop your lectures on Social media platform (specially Library Chat) due to haters; they will never stop until Angel of death touch them. A large number of Ummah like me not have Islamic educational background would miss your blessed knowledge & thought!

  • @saidohn8126
    @saidohn8126 3 роки тому +8

    Plz sheikh wherever you go , I will go with you meaning ur teaching because I learn a lot from you and I'm really want to be ur students. I'm sister from UK and wants to learn my Deen inshallah, I understand Arabic but not fluently but want to learn Arabic as well

  • @franklopez861
    @franklopez861 3 роки тому +5

    Please don't leave us sheikh. You don't understand how much you have brought me closer to my Lord Allah the only one! And I'm pretty sure you've inspired millions of other people to get closer to their Deen as well. At least stay on UA-cam and turn the comment section off.
    Don't worry about these haters man. Don't worry I'll make Dua tonight to Allah so he can freeze their mouths and hands when they want to refute you or say something bad. Please stay with us. You don't understand how dear you are to us. Wala fakhr! I'm not trying to bost about you but alot of people need you in this day and age. There's only 0.000000001% of the world population that say bad stuff about you. Forget them man. You're bigger than that! Don't let anyone stop you from doing what you're doing please!

    • @chehrazadeesmey8399
      @chehrazadeesmey8399 3 роки тому +1

      Pffff why do you make me cry...❤❤❤🌹

    • @franklopez861
      @franklopez861 3 роки тому

      @@chehrazadeesmey8399 you don't understand how upset I've been. He really can't leave us. He is an asset to us! Ya Allah please let him change his mind and stay on UA-cam only!

    • @chehrazadeesmey8399
      @chehrazadeesmey8399 3 роки тому +1

      @@franklopez861 Oh yes i do understand, and you explained very well why. Ameen for your duas brother. Take care !

  • @itz_abada19
    @itz_abada19 3 роки тому +1

    Sheikh , please don't leave UA-cam... we can't stop benefiting from your khatirahs and library chats....

  • @diddydum
    @diddydum 3 роки тому +7

    May Allah reward you. You have brough immense benefit to many people.

  • @anahaki7262
    @anahaki7262 Місяць тому

    You are an amazing person and very knowledgeable! I learnt so much from you throughout the years and May God bless you for spreading NOOR OF FAITH around ! Your Seerah, Quran 30/30 and the library chat is my all time favorite lessons to listen to 🙌🏻 you helped me so much from And your always in my prayers ❤

  • @b.i.n.a2959
    @b.i.n.a2959 3 роки тому +1

    Ohhh noooo Shaykh Dr.Yasir...please please please don't stop on UA-cam..from 1st lockdown i followed you closely..I listened to almost all your talks khudba & other programs..we need you to boost up our Emaan with your fabulous knowledge of our Deen..May Allah protect you from all evils in this world..Ameen 🤲💯🌹

  • @saadmansakib1410
    @saadmansakib1410 3 роки тому +4

    Shaykh, you're like a lighthouse for our Muslim teens and young people. I belong to a practicing muslim family, but as I was away from home for my higher education I detached from Islam. In this pandemic period I have listened to your lectures almost every single day. I learned a lot about my deen and started practicing as much as I can Alhamdulillah. Of course Allah is the one who guides our souls, but there's always a medium who plays vital role. Regular reminders keep us in check and balance. I believe You're the reason for thousands of youngsters like me to return to their faith. If you want to retire from social media you may leave facebook and twitter. But please keep posting videos on UA-cam.
    May Allah rewards you in this world and the next. Ameen.
    PS: Private portal can be a good medium. Please make sure people over the globe can reach out.

  • @ahmetgokdemir5846
    @ahmetgokdemir5846 Рік тому +1

    Amazing!!!! May Allah reward you! What a lecture. The best on UA-cam. subhanAllahi wa bihamdihi, that Allah let me to this lectures.

  • @ji.s9434
    @ji.s9434 3 роки тому +2

    Asc Shiekh, جزاك الله خيرًا, i said this from the bottom of my heart, i'm learning alot and learnt more from you, and please keep bringing this lectures more and more, thank you again.

  • @abdulsalad7509
    @abdulsalad7509 Рік тому

    Please dr yasir qadhi, we benefitted from your youtube lectures, I have watched all 104 séries of sira of profit Mohamed alayhi salatu wasalaam and 78 lectures of sahaba and 15 lectures of wives of prophet Mohamed alahi salatu wasalaam many times repeatedly, please don't stop. This has benefited many muslims, my allah bless you and Grant you jannatul fardawsa.

  • @abdulsalad7509
    @abdulsalad7509 Рік тому

    Dr sheekh yasir qadhi, I am always checking new videos of your youtube lectures to watch please keep going. God bless you.

  • @kakhorovj
    @kakhorovj 3 роки тому +1

    Dear Shaikh YQ! Assalamu aleikum wr wb! I am your close follower for many years and I can't even estimate how much you helped me to explore my Deen! Allah is my witness for all love and respect towards you and I ask you to keep posting and spread knowledge that so many people benefit from. There will be always people that won't agree or try to hurt but that what will raise your ranks inshaAllah! Just turn off comments and keep posting,whoever wants will watch. May Allah reward you and your family for all you do to spread our beautiful Deen in the World, ameen

  • @tia8721
    @tia8721 3 роки тому +4

    The benefit of UA-cam is that those just connecting with their faith can learn about their deen in an accessible way. Particularly, in the West we need knowledgeable Sheikhs like you with a real understanding of the current challenges facing Muslims in the West and who are comfortable tackling the tough questions as they come up. Very few of us in the West have access to knowledgeable Sheikhs who can help us navigate contemporary issues and teach us broad scholarly opinions of the various madhabs on issues. I understand and support however, for your mental health your desire to withdraw. It would be a real shame and huge loss to ummah however, if you were to withdraw. Whatever your decision, may Allah bless you abundantly for your service to the ummah!

  • @amiin-shakuradan9923
    @amiin-shakuradan9923 3 роки тому +2

    Assalaamu aleikum Wa rahmatul’lahi wa barakaatum dear Sheikh .
    I met you in Denmark Copenhagen once. I was attending with my brothers whome I was involved in dawah with. We traveled from 3 hours city 7-8 of us just to attend your lecture and lo and behold, we just happend to meet you in a restaurent. Being the one who use to listen to your seerah (and i’ve watched every single episode 5-6 time each) I was kinda star strucked and surprised (Allahs qadr) that you just happend to havde your lunch same place as we did. Our dawah in Denmark was primaraly for converts, and I Walked up to you, and I’ve must have mispronounced the Word. You thought I Said Our dawah was for convicted. Anyhow. I humbly asked you if you could give us a short khatirah, and you did. We all loved it.
    Dear Sheikh . We all enjoy your lectures, and benifits formidably and enormesly a lot. Allah has guided me through your lecthures. And being a farther now, who works a lot to feed my fam, my only time to listen is watching your UA-cam videos. Not only do I benifit. But I truely try my best to implement your teachings.
    Therefor my beloved Sheikh. I personally would be sad, if you leave this platform.
    But if you truely do. I’ll gladly pay the fee to benifit.
    And if I cannot acces your lectures, in sha Allah, as Abu bakr RA Said to Omar RA. So. Allah is ever Living, never dying, I’ll find some Way to feed my islamic knowlegde and find other great shuyuukh to benifit from

  • @susandevy
    @susandevy 3 роки тому +1

    I've been following you for more than 10 years and MashaAllah your knowledge is beyond comparison, I have benefited many great lesson from you.
    whether you choose to withdraw from social media or not, I believe that your followers will keep following you wherever you go, May Allah make everything easy for you

  • @user-kl1on3nw7y
    @user-kl1on3nw7y 3 роки тому +4

    Please don't stop releasing videos on you tube I have learned so much from u Masha'Allah!!!

  • @uchoo786
    @uchoo786 3 роки тому +3

    I’ve been listening since 2005, you’ve been an immense source of knowledge and guidance. InshAllah hope you set up something like the portal at least so that I can continue to benefit since I live no where near EPIC.

  • @asmakhalid4562
    @asmakhalid4562 3 роки тому +1

    Salam Dear Brother,
    Your lectures and Library chats have benefitted me immensely and I have passionately recommend them to my family and friends. Allah SWT has blessed you with sincereity of heart, remarkable gift of gab, eloquence and numerable knowledge and you should continue using these gifts to the fullest.
    Having a private portal is a good idea too but please don't take this pleasure of listening to these lectures on UA-cam away from us.
    They're an irreplaceable source of knowledge and learning.
    جزاك اللله خيرا كثيرا

  • @TruthSeeker446
    @TruthSeeker446 3 роки тому +2

    May Allah swt bless you. I benefit so much from your lectures, al hamdoulilah.

  • @badalrana10
    @badalrana10 3 роки тому +7

    Indeed social media is toxic
    Inshallah you keep doing these library chats though
    I would love a lecture on Ibn Hazm (rh)

  • @tauseefahmedwahdat7174
    @tauseefahmedwahdat7174 3 роки тому +15

    The issue with going behind a paywall and private space is that the benefit to the people is reduced as it just disappears from the www. Like your Seerah is of great Benefit to the people since it is on youtube. I would suggest that even your facebook and twitter posts are beneficial but not as much as your detailed lectures, Q&A and library chats. I You should not worry about what your opponents say. May Allah help us all

  • @zaramabrook8313
    @zaramabrook8313 Рік тому

    Your UA-cam lectures are very helpful to us. I have learnt a lot and I look out for all your videos to watch. Please give us continuously the UA-cam lectures.

  • @mydmmydm3984
    @mydmmydm3984 3 роки тому +3

    Alhamdullilah Shaikh Yasir you are doing great and all the best wishes and prayers for you. Library chats are the best please do continue it.

  • @Albert_Hall
    @Albert_Hall Рік тому +1

    Great Great Great 👍🏼
    May Allah سبحانه و تعالى bless your job

  • @adilelhadioui9523
    @adilelhadioui9523 3 роки тому +1

    Ya sheikh. Baraka Allahoe fiek. Like you said at the end of your seerah lessons. There is no one who does what you do. I don't follow you blindly but as for many mini studentes of knowledge in the West you are in my dreamteam. Maybe less controverse and more general topics. Khair in sha Allah. Salamoe 3alaikom from the Netherlands.

  • @faisalaminu78
    @faisalaminu78 3 роки тому +2

    May Allah reward your efforts Sheikh. On the issue of the private portal I think a combination of your social media presence and the portal will help. There are many like me on social media who would want to continue benefiting from the regular lectures you deliver and release on social mefia.
    And yes if there are advanced topics you would want to cover via a private portal... why not. But please dont allow the negativity of your opponents to interfere with the good work you are doing for the Umma. I am in Ghana and i get 99% of my islamic knowledge from your work. May Allah bless us all.

  • @sammu
    @sammu 3 роки тому +14

    I fully support a private paid channel. It’s only logical especially if you plan to cover complex topics that the general public cannot handle/will misinterpret. This will be good for not only your sake but the ignorant masses too.

    • @zakariab9591
      @zakariab9591 3 роки тому

      Yes and I believe most of us who are waiting for new lectures and have benefited a lot, it can even give the feeling of really being the student of sheikh Yasir Qadhi. But it's still heart breaking to hear that the sheikh wants to quit his massive contribution for the English speaking world via social media, but I understand and respect it. May Allah bless our sheikh and every sincere student of his. (Btw: yes I'm definitely willing to pay for the private platform)

  • @nosheenahmed6816
    @nosheenahmed6816 3 роки тому +5

    Assalamualaikum, I really value your chats/ lectures, and especially the islamic history you provide! I will be looking forward to your new private platform, but will be sad to see you go from social media, as it’s so easy to access. Jazakumuallah khair for all you do, May Allah accept your efforts!

  • @adm7812
    @adm7812 3 роки тому +12

    I like the idea sheikh. patreon is another thing that you can look at. people who are interested will subscribe for a nominal fee removing the spammers and insincere people.

  • @SanaullahGh
    @SanaullahGh 3 роки тому +15

    It's very unfortunate for me to hear this. Sheikh never knows how beneficial he is to those abroad. Although hearing "اللغو" from critics is very painful and can affect even the strongest heart. But Sheikh please you have to realize that, it's only in Aljanna that, we won't hear اللغو ill talks. So don't let these critics make you deprive us from benefitting from ur Knowledge.

  • @ziaulujjal1
    @ziaulujjal1 3 роки тому +2

    Love you brother for all the effort you made to spread the knowledge of this beautiful religion, for sure you are well ahead of your time. If you open the portal for sure we will join you. We just want our daily dose of knowledge from you.

  • @adityavikramdas6116
    @adityavikramdas6116 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you very much, Shaykh, for yet another highly enlightening lecture.
    The sub-text in this library chat was quite clear, and I could tell which contemporary movement you were indirectly comparing the Karramis with.
    Some suggestions with regard to your proposal to withdraw from social media -
    1. Whilst I understand that social media can be highly toxic, there are alternatives to a full-fledged withdrawal. If you deliver your lectures only through a private forum (on a subscription basis) then you will be addressing a fundamentally different audience. You will confine your audience, should you choose this option, to a largely scholarly circle. Whilst this may improve the quality of debates and discussions, it will reduce the accessibility of your lectures.
    2. I think there is something to be said, in general, about the maslaha of the global ummah in preserving diverse critical voices. Your complete withdrawal from social media will in general not be a welcome development, because there is a great deal of khayr that the average Muslim derives from your commentary. Leaving the field open to other, less critical voices will have consequences that we all know and fear.
    3. Think of how the vast majority of your listeners (your consumers) engage with your lectures (your product). The average listener is engaging with your lectures in the evening after work, or late at night before heading off to sleep (like your Seerah lectures), or early in the morning before work, or during the day on a weekend. These are not necessarily the listeners that you will carry over to your new private forum, which will attract a more scholarly circle like yourself. You will lose the vast majority of your listeners who actually GAIN from your lectures the most. Please consider this while making your decision.
    I suggest a two-tiered approach, wherein you keep most of your content online, but reserve the higher-level scholarly talks for your new private forum. This ensures that whilst the vast majority of the ummah continues to gain from your presence online, you can have higher quality debates with your more dedicated students on a separate forum. Thank you very much for reading this long comment.

  • @JosefTheMuslim
    @JosefTheMuslim 3 роки тому

    Ya habib, please please do not stop your lessons on UA-cam. I have benefited so much from your lessons. We are so many that need your guiding. Hafidaka Allah!

  • @monaa.6148
    @monaa.6148 3 роки тому +2

    Shaykh I benefit immensely from your talks and lectures. I especially benefited from the Prophet's seerah, Barzakh, Day of Judgement, Jannah/Jahannam and currently from the Stories of the Prophets series and etc. Just some years back I didn't really know much about the deen nor was I practicing but Allah guided me back and taught me a lot about the deen through your lectures. May Allah bless you for this. You taught us all so much. What I especially like about you Shaykh is that you always state all opinions about a topic not just your own opinion which you personally follow and of course your tangents and detailed and sometimes a bit critical lectures.
    So please don't stop giving lectures online, at least keep your UA-cam. It would be a great loss if you would stop giving lectures online. Personally, I was a bit shocked when you said that at the beginning of the video.
    Don't think about all the haters but think about all the people who benefited from you.
    May Allah (swt) bless you for your efforts and grant you Jannatul Firdaus🤲.

  • @walidahmed286
    @walidahmed286 2 роки тому

    Man This sheikh is so much knowledgable. I love u Shaikh from Houston Bangladesh

  • @mdharis
    @mdharis 3 роки тому

    Please DO NOT move away from social media. English-speaking scholars like you are SO NEEDED to educate us. There is such a dearth of English-speaking advanced students. Most of us are fed the Sunday-school, hunky-dory, sanitized & convenient kumbaya versions of incidents and rulings. We need you Dr. Yasir Qadhi. The ummah needs teachers like you. May Allah grant you the highest maqam in Jannah.

  • @slivercopper32
    @slivercopper32 3 роки тому +6

    No no no
    Pls don't leave social platform,, if you were not there,, whoelse was there to teach us the GRAND Seerah of our beloved Rasool Allah sallallahu alaihi wasalam 🌹.
    IAM ur student through internet. And the topics you cover ,, dare others have so much guts..
    May Allah bless you immensely..

  • @Yoromo77
    @Yoromo77 3 роки тому

    As a convert and ignorant in many things, from the biography to our beloved prophet to simple daily actions, you had been my guide and I think many mire will loose if you leave social media than benefit (please don’t let shaitan win) there will always be people who will try to take away scholars like you who are very knowledgeable, elocuente and neutral. You always make sure to give the facts and the sources, may Aláh reward you, give you more knowledge and wisdom to do what you think will make this world a better place. I won’t mind paying for your own channel, but I’m afraid you won’t be accessible to many, specially the ones new to Islam.

  • @aatifhashmi3804
    @aatifhashmi3804 3 роки тому +1

    With The blessing of Allah SWT you have changed my way of thinking and understanding of islam. The haters will always hate. Let them do what they will always do and please continue to make your amazing videos.

  • @farahrashid4768
    @farahrashid4768 3 роки тому +2

    Assalam O Aleikum bhai, as your lectures are really interesting and very informative as well your tangents, seriously I really enjoy and learn from your tangents, continue doing that. May Allah bless you and your family, Ameen

  • @shafnasameen
    @shafnasameen 3 роки тому

    Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, your videos are the most in-depth, most informative Islamic videos on UA-cam. I've benefited immensely I can't even say how much. Please keep making these extremely helpful videos.

  • @nasreenkhan2716
    @nasreenkhan2716 3 роки тому +1

    Dear son, you can decide for yourself. Personally, I have benefited soooooo
    much from all your different Bayans. You unreathed so many gems of Deen for me. Every day I listen to you. My Iman gets a shine. Beta, please give some Bayans for laymen like me. May Allah Tallah reward you immensely for all your hard work. Ameen. Duas from India

  • @akhlakurrahmansadat5636
    @akhlakurrahmansadat5636 3 роки тому +2

    Sheikh I love u for Allah. May Allah protect u. Ameen.

  • @adamlee2506
    @adamlee2506 3 роки тому +4

    Looking foward to the Nizam Mulk Lecture. Have you thought of setting up a Google classroom.
    Or you ask for those who want to subscribe their email to recieve a link of your Library Chats.

  • @cyrtanthuselatus3686
    @cyrtanthuselatus3686 3 роки тому +2

    I like your talks. It is a great solace to me. Truly you do not give the impression that there is judgement.... so rare to non existent in todays talks. It will be a pity if you should leave this platform forever. It would be a sad day.

  • @abdullahlakay8448
    @abdullahlakay8448 3 роки тому +2

    May Allah reward Sheikh Yasir immensely.

  • @ruhaimahamed3705
    @ruhaimahamed3705 3 роки тому

    As salamu alaikum sheikh .iam from srilanka and 21 years old.i have watched your whole seerah series,sahaba series,end of world series and majority of your common lectures. I have benefited immensely from you and those are the light for me in my dark days. Please continue to share your wisdom and inspire us❤

  • @riyadhuk
    @riyadhuk 3 роки тому +4

    ZAZAKALLAH sheikh. I think you can just ignore the trolls and carry on. I like your open sessions like these.

  • @mahmudulislamkhan
    @mahmudulislamkhan 3 роки тому

    No matter what your decision is regarding social media, please keep options for people like us who live in developing countries and love your lectures.

  • @mahmudulislamkhan
    @mahmudulislamkhan 3 роки тому

    JazakAllah Khairan Shaykh.

  • @NafisaLondon
    @NafisaLondon 3 роки тому +6

    I would pay £s for the private platform/forum.

  • @johnsword8954
    @johnsword8954 3 роки тому +2

    Beloved Sheikh, may I suggest something. You can just simply turn off the comment section in every video clip you post to avoid toxic and vulgar comments. You have done a lot of good things for the non arabic speaking muslims. I am pretty sure, you have more supporters than haters. wassalam.

  • @mominahkhan5645
    @mominahkhan5645 3 роки тому +2

    May Allah be with you.

  • @khadaraxmed
    @khadaraxmed 3 роки тому

    I hope you don’t withdraw the social media.yes there are unhealthy sides of it and lot of people are abusing the terms and conditions of the social media.
    I really find your talks and lectures very healthy and really making people love more their Islamic faith.
    I would rather recommend you talk to the management of these social media so they can filter anything deemed hateful toxic comments.
    I find you humble healthy and so educated so jazaakallaahu khayra.🙏❤️🙏❤️🙏

  • @fuaadjafree5395
    @fuaadjafree5395 3 роки тому +4

    Im a simple man....i see a library chat upload, I drop everything and watch

  • @lazershocks4109
    @lazershocks4109 3 роки тому

    Yasir bhai you can’t go anywhere me and kids and whole family are turning to religion via your lectures. After completing seerah , barzakh, Ramadan series we are looking forward to learn much more from you. You are the Ustaz of my children. If you open your institute we will come learn from you directly InshaAllah May Allah keep you safe and keep you with us so we can benefit from your ilm nafe’ . Allah be with you my Sheikh # 1 ❤️❤️❤️

  • @sidyndao1626
    @sidyndao1626 3 роки тому

    Sheikh we have been and have always benefited from your knowledge. Your approaches are unquestionably sincere and rewarding and we need to find alternative to keep you in social media despite ongoing adversities and animosities. We are learning so much about our deen and we are also helping others. May Allah gives you rewards and blesses you in these efforts. We are ready which ever way you go in the near future. 👍🏿

  • @adnankassem8114
    @adnankassem8114 3 роки тому +3

    Once again Sheikh. Excellent lecture may Allah reward you. I'm very interested in the establishment of the Ashari school and how the later Malikis and Shafis were always Ashari but the earlier ones were not necessarily Ashari. Jazakum Allahu Khayran

  • @YasirAbbasi84
    @YasirAbbasi84 3 роки тому

    Ya Abu Ammar! Our beloved sheikh !!! my beloved Sheikh .... May Allah increases your darajaats and continue benefiting us Ummah from your knowledge of deen and your eloquent speech which off course are the greatest blessings Allah has given you and through these He is testing you.
    Please do not abandon us. Listening to your lectures are as if we are attending unversity, but we are listening in the comfort of our home, we are listening on the way to work, we are learning deen while driving taxis, while some of us are laying bricks, some doing house chores. and all the others and the list can go on and on.... We need scholars like you in the time of great confusions. We are living in the time where right is becoming wrong and wrong is becoming right.
    Please stay on youtube channel keep posting your lectures, you can perhaps turn off comments. Thousands of us dont comment but doesnt mean we dont like what you preach us. I myself is commenting second time since all those years I have started listening and learning from you. Only because you asked for our opinions.
    I know social media is the greatest fitna of our time. Alot of studies are taking place about its toxic culture. My humble request would be that you can come off all the others media sites if you have made up your mind but stay on this channel. May Allah help you decide your course in the favour of us Ummah. Ameen
    Jazakumullahu khairan

  • @jokermaruf9759
    @jokermaruf9759 3 роки тому +3

    It’s very interesting lecture thank you sheikh

  • @gairoonishaboolay4331
    @gairoonishaboolay4331 3 роки тому

    Sheikh it will be so sad for millions of people that will loose out. May Allah guide you to benefit yourself and us all. Ameen. I'm very grateful that you were available on this platform, I benefited so much. Algamdulila

  • @toufeeqsiddique7520
    @toufeeqsiddique7520 3 роки тому +5

    Plz whatever you do don't leave UA-cam! And if you make a private halaqa ,plz keep an option to pay the payment in taka ( Bangladeshi currency)

  • @SAK1912
    @SAK1912 3 роки тому

    MASHALLAH Tabarakallah Shaikh. You are one of the best lecturers from the West and my family and I have benefited from. I make Doa daily for all our Shaikh,/Shaikha, Ustadh/Ustadha, Imams who gives dakwah for the sake of Allah swt (not humans) save from fitnah and evil eye. I have confidence that Allah protects those who are truelly sincere in their work for the betterment of the ummah. We will follow you in whichever platform that you think is best for your work. Amin.

  • @safiamumin4925
    @safiamumin4925 3 роки тому

    Ya sheikh ma sha Allah I really love ur lectures especially the seerah you dived in without sugar coating and that was amazing I have never heard any Aaleem give such truth and I salute you may Allah bless you

  • @LuqmansReacts
    @LuqmansReacts 3 роки тому +1

    I am 25 years old from Nigeria and I've been listening to your lectures since 2013. You are one of the best and my favourite Islamic aleems. I've learned immensely from your online resources. Alhamdulillah Over the years my iman have grown stronger and stronger listening to you. 😓 I am truly saddened that you're leaving social media. Nevertheless, I pray that Allah swa grant you and your family peace and his blessings. 😔😔 Also, no matter what all these uneducated people keep saying about you, it won't change the fact that you are one of the greatest minds of our time. ❤❤

    • @LuqmansReacts
      @LuqmansReacts 3 роки тому +1

      P.s I can't wait for the private paid platform in sha Allah❤🙏🏿

  • @imranahmed786
    @imranahmed786 3 роки тому

    Dr saab im sorry for your experience with the awaam. May Allah taala give you strength to remain steadfast in your academical life. And your kind nature to engage with those whom are interested.

  • @leemonchoudhury2538
    @leemonchoudhury2538 2 роки тому

    Dear shaykh I have to say that I feel at peace by grown up academic learning. Thank you for sharing your insights. It really does help people like myself.

  • @beyondeyes29th
    @beyondeyes29th 3 роки тому +2

    Dear sheikh please continue your online work through youtube wallahi we're with you. let those ignorants wander in madness. I too abandoned facebook months ago. The social media environment, its effects and outcomes are so much chaotic. It brings nothing but damage to our morale. (Aside from the goods) The most shocking thing I witnessed is that the race of hatred for one another, our society becoming so much chaotic before our own eyes, how evil people can be that's what shocks me. May ALLAH continue guide us throughout our life.
    Dear sheikh Please pray for my Daughter, she's 2 years old. I'm so much worried for her. may ALLAH help us.

  • @thrallingFRglory
    @thrallingFRglory 2 роки тому

    Pease never stop these series o Sheikh!! I have my share of disagreements with you but I absolutely adore these library chats. May Allah keep you safe and in good health

  • @bakti331
    @bakti331 3 роки тому +1

    mashallah..keep on preaching sheikh..love from malaysia

  • @mubarizafzal8296
    @mubarizafzal8296 3 роки тому

    Salaam shaykh. You have spoken much good to us, and perhaps you feel that it is time to shift from speaking to other forms of work for yourself and the ummah that is much needed. I think the library of videos you have left with us is expansive and truly filled with benefit. I ask Allah to make what you have taught/produced beneficial for myself and future generation of Muslims, Ameen.

  • @aviatrixsaba5619
    @aviatrixsaba5619 3 роки тому

    JazaakAllah khairan Kateeran for your work