Kazakhstan eruption, why Russia is rushing troops & why it matters for the world
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 січ 2022
- #CutTheClutter #KazakhstanProtests #Russia
Kazakhstan has erupted in violent protests throughout the country. Shekhar Gupta traces the reasons behind these protests, which are a product of anger over the years. And why does it concern Putin's Russia more than any other country. Episode 913 of CutTheClutter
Brought to you by @KiaInd
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
13:18 "Remember Lord Tennyson's 'The Brook' ?"
"For men may come and men may go,
But I go on forever."
Only SG treats us all to a cultural interlude.
Until 1936 Kazakhstan was an autonomy within Russian Federation. Stalin made Kazakhstan a Soviet Republic with the right to leave Soviet Union. By the way, the territory of an other autonomy within Russian Federation - Yakutia, is bigger than the territory of Kazakhstan, and also rich and with even smaller population.
@@viaceslavmikhailovich9825 "An estimated 38 to 42 percent of all Kazakhs died, the highest percentage of any ethnic group killed by the Soviet famine of 1932-1933. Other sources state that as many as 2.0 to 2.3 million died."
I wonder whether they knew they had 'the right to leave the Soviet Union' ?
They should've asked Stalin.
Then taken a one-way trip to the Gulags.
@@vinm300 Bolshevism was an anti-Russian organisation. Most of the territory of modern Kazakhstan was the territory of Russian Ural Kazaks. Bolsheviks exterminated Russian Kazaks and introduced the word Kazakhs to describe the nomad people who earlier were known as Kirgiz.
@@vinm300 In 19 century Romanov Empire moved to Central Asia and took Kirgiz nomads, which were at the time under the threat of extermination by Dzunghar tribes, under Russian protection. Since that time Kazakhs were living in this territory under Russian rule and protection.
As ex-Russian citizen, now German, I am astonished with the level of understanding and analysis you have about exUSSR countries. Spot on, great job.
Indian education system is such[a British creation] that an educated Indian, like Sekhar is will know more about Europe than his own country.
@@pijushghosh4191 he knows about India more than the losers in BJP.
@@yj9032 One of the reason could be the amount of data tracked in the rest of the world. For India we don't even have accurate number on how many died due to oxygen shortage. We don't track accurate unemployment numbers, real estate housing numbers, etc... Thus educated indians have to guess what's happening in India by looking at the examples in other countries.
@@pijushghosh4191 he’s a learned journalist. Put some respect on his name brother.
Last week Russian Forces invaded the Kazakhstan. By the agreement the CSTO help can come only if there is outside invasion of foreign nation, and not when Peaceful Citizens have demands to their own Government. 2. Your “Peaceful” Russian Forces kill our children like bloody Mercenaries and indeed Kazakhstanis people have their own Constitutional Rights as citizens of Kazakhstan.
Russia - please leave Kazakhstan along we don’t need you and your Russian Army Mercenaries to kill our children. Kazakhs can figure out themselves without Putin and his bloody army.
Since I first read a news report about the clashes in Kazakhstan, I was looking forward to a cut the clutter episode on this. Thanks, Sir
First time viewer here. This channel provides insights for sure! :-)
A thousand times more informing than any news media in Europe ! 👍
I am from Kazakhstan. Main thing that you are missing in this video is the fact that Nazarbayev's and his clan's power diminished after protests (Nazarbayev is no longer head of the army, pro-Nazarbayev people in security and government are being replaced, his clan lost business). Some say that it was main factor in outbreak of violence during otherwise peacefull protests. Good job, thnak you!
I think erdogan is behind this
Thank you for great coverage and accurate explanations. As someone who lived in Kz for 25 years, I appreciate you spreading good quality insights. Only one correction: these video and pictures of demonstrations were from the most populated city of Almaty and not from the new capital (Astana). For the rest, you’ve covered this story well. It is a shame that the dictators never resign willingly
I have worked in KZ for 3 years.... Lack of knowledge of Indian outside UK US is bad
It a proper moment for putin to occupy this part of the world, pity for the population!!! Do not allow putinism to dictate their politic in Kazakhstan!!!
@@mianilsson3550 , so are you ready to welcome US hegemony in Kazakhistan ?
@@anjanayadav5320 Let the will of people in Kazakhstan to decide their destiny, not dictators or someone else!!!!
@@mianilsson3550 , so why US and Russia are interfering ?
Hello there. As a Finn I need to make a mention about the fact that majority of Finnish people are against joining Nato at the moment.
Percentage of people wanting Finland to stay out of Nato have been ranging at around 54-66%.
Finland has thrived by following what the west contemptuously called for many years 'finlandisation', in effect neutrality. This is the correct way for the Finns to go forward.
how many russians you have in your country? this is the question finland need to ask itself. if there is a 100.000 russian then finland will have second winter war
@@siyeci I understand your point well. Yes, we have around 70.000-100.000 Russians living here but this isn't the same case than for example in Eastern Ukraine. Vast majority of these Russian immigrants are from either former Finland's Karelia region or Russia' Karelia region. Russians who come from this region often have Finnish roots (quite a lot of people from Finland and Finnish immigrants from USA moved to Soviet Union 1920-1930).
The second thing is that 99% of Russians living in Finland I've met have VERY VERY negative attitude towards their home country. The way they speak about their country is sometimes even strange and a bit sad to hear since it's still their country of birth. But anyway the point here is that most of these people have moved here because they've wanted to leave their country and have a "new" life here.
I speak Russian since I learned it in school and been using it in my work so I've talked to many Russians living here so these things aren't made up in my head.
And yes, I know that these facts don't take the threat away. The threat is real and our government realizes it. At the moment, Russia could by no means invade Finland since it would cause absolutely massive losses since Russia hasn't been in REAL war after ww2 and Finnish army is one of the most capable in Europe. Even though we aren't officially part of Nato, US would 100% sure send its troops since it would be against its interests should Russia attack Finland. And then you have the economical side. Russian economy would collapse causing turmoil inside country and eventually lead to collapse of whole Russia since economically Russia is very very very vulnerable.
@@Byrzzaa You're delusional. Russian military and technology could turn Finland into dust in a week. Your only valid argument is that the USA wouldn't allow it which is true. Russian troops were literally fighting all over Asia for the past half a century. And their hypersonic missile technology means they could eradicate Finland with missiles fired from central Russia, thousands of KM away. They don't even need to use nukes.
@@Byrzzaa you dont understand what a say. when a say russians I dont say ethnicity but citizenship.russia giving free citizenship to everyone who have same kind of soviet root.ethnicity doesnt care even political opinion doesnt care by russia. %100 of the russians living in kazakhstan have VERY VERY negative attitude towards to PUTIN.life in kazakhstan definity more good then russia '''''because they've wanted to leave their country and have a "new" life here.'''''' you dont understand the russians any russian want to start a new life first thing they do find a country far away from homeland russia ''''' I speak Russian since I learned it in school ''''' so finns start to get influence by russia. political disaster.
Sir kindly present your analysis on the security lapse during PM Modi's visit to Punjab yesterday! Your analysis always gives us a better insight. Thanks 🙏🏼
I guess, pm stopped farmers from entering capital. He got back in return, it means people aren't happy
@@rammohan5110 yeah meaning those bigots were BJP Stooges, proven fact. But heck, post truth era isn't it, who cares for fact.
Farmers are khalistani sounds more sexy'and exciting, isn't it?
Nothing much happened..just a political move like pulwama to win elections
I think SG will cover it in this week's National Interest!!
@@TheOpposition Which proven fact are you talking about?
Hello from Kazakhstan. Was there 4-5th of Jan 22 in the middle of that unrests. My apartment is close to the Square of Independence in Almaty, where this all happened. Elbasy(Nazarbayev's title) means same as Mahatma (Father of Nation). We're more or less have same situation as India had first decade after Independence reached from GB. Your 😭 bloody experience is what we hope to avoid. But same, to free from Imperialist slavery, which is a long way...
Sir, Kindly do a CTC on constantly falling Lira and it's impact on middle East and sub Continent.
ua-cam.com/video/zvgs0ie0IYs/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/AZacGzzsrj8/v-deo.html
@@a-woke5283 he's already spoken against erdogan multiple times in the past
This man right here, speaks about the situation better than anyone in my country!
Your research is on point!! And 100 points for the way you present it and connect with the audience. Wish there were more of you or you live eternally! 😀
Thank you Mr.Gupta for explaining these complex matters in very interesting way. Whenever I want to understand what's going on across the globe I always check for a cut the clutter video first. (Even to understand matters in my own country)
Much love from Sri Lanka.
Things are getting out of hand. Soviet Union must rise again.
But President Putin. You are a critic of the USSR.
Comrade Putin 😍
As a Syrian I don't have any difficulty understanding what's happening in Kazakhstan. It's just very similar to what happened there.
@@sanjaymandal6572 to where there is oil ... Comes democracy 😅
@@sanjaymandal6572 don't blame west for every ill in the Middle East. They are fighting for more than 3000 years. It's on the crossroads of Asia, Europe and Africa and it has no natural barriers to protect. Levant was fought over by Egyptians, Hettites, Jews, Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, Crusaders, Mongols, Mamluks and Turks. I would blame Levants prime location and inabilities to defend it as root cause of the problem.
You see it's easy to win that piece of Earth, but it's difficult to defend it. A rag tag group of religious extremists who blow themselves on purpose can conquer vast swaths of land there.
@@hasanx8317 I think it's more than oil when it comes to Syria. Turkey, Europe, Egypt and Iran have historically been interested in your country they have always fought for the control of the region where your country is situated. Honestly if you ask me Syria shouldn't exist as a country, it has never existed as a country in its really ancient history. It's a totally manufactured and artificial country made by drunken diplomats.
@@elhombredeoro955 You're right. Unfortunately the land which we call Syria today has always been a subject of conflict between the ruling powers of the era. However, oil and gas has been playing a major role in the conflicts in the middle east since after WWII.
It's true also that a big part of the conflict is due to the strategic location of the land. The military major intervention of Russia and Iran in the Syrian conflict indicates that at one point the course of events on land was posing a "vital danger" to both of them, as Syrian see ports to the Mediterranean are highly important to them.
Please do a CTC on the PM's Punjab visit and Congress sabotage!!!
Russia is not rushing troops,they have an agreement just like NATO. It doesn't have to make sense to anyone else other than the countries that are members of the treaty.
sorry that is elephant poop. Russia is sending in Troops as fast as they can.
Sir, l looked up all global media outlests but l found the more than needed info from you. Thanks for so much work to provide us necessary background and unbiased report on world affairs.
He copy's CNN, BBC analysis.
Unbiased! ? There r only two version of the incident and both r completely biased. One is russian and the other is western version. There is no 3rd option of unbiased.
Kazak is a country which after formation in 1990's was forced to Destroy nuclear weapons by USA 's command. USA's energy companies entered kazak and bled dry every oil fields present there. These facts do not prove Russian dominance in kazaks political sphere. Rather its opossite.
The western media is master in controlling narrative and disinformation. The print should realize that.
@@sg4250 25% of population of Kazakhstan are Russian only, so definitely Russia will have influence, But your point also correct.
@@homosapien5140 Yes you have pointed in the correct direction. Since there r so many Russians so Russia has influence in the general public and population. This protest for example are influenced by Russia. While the dictatorial Govt is controlled by USA. USA knew that if democracy was allowed here it would be easier for Russia to influence politically and a pro-Russian govt would be elected. So as long autocracy thrives there USA controls there to some extent.
Sorry for being totally off topic, but I so love to hear the dogs barking in the background.
Greetings from Germany, thank you for the profound information
When you are quoting your figures please remember you have audience outside of India. When saying "lakh" or "crore" please put the Western equivalent on the screen. And yes I know the whole numeric system is Hindu-Arabic originated.
1 lakh= 100k
1 crore= 10 million
Democracy doesn't mean prosperity, people should understand that majority of the time it only makes things worse
It is about how much control government has, not about democracy
True. Fruits are the products of farming. You cannot vote the fruits to magically appear.
Democracy is the rule of the faceless beings with unknown interests guided by the devil and oppression to serve a select few. It's a disease to humanity but also to God .
@@baruasafi5880 every country is ruled by faceless beings,its a question of how many powers they have and in democracies they are curtailed
Shekhar Gupta sir's CTC is by far the best YT source for IR. This coming from a UPSC aspirant who has been following SG sir for many years now.
Thank you from Canada!
If you watch this video for 18.29 minutes, you will learn history, geography and world politics. This gentleman simply gives you the 'facts' and speak very eloquently and always gives you a very unbiased analysis. If you watch WION with Palki Sharma, you hear never-ending whining and also you will be bombarded with all kinds of rotten BS.
True WION has become a whiny cry baby which keeps crying on China this China that, like everyone knows now. There is no news in their reporting
Stopped watching it in 2020 itself. Ridiculous channel
Hi Sanath, do keep tuning in, daily.
Very true. Glad to see that I am not the only Sri Lankan here. Keep up the good work
@@priyanks91
Me too stopped watching WION as it is biased and has become a crybaby.
Happy new year SG sir, I wish you and entire print team a safe year. Thank you for all the journalism services.
A remark regarding 8:15 : Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are integral member states of NATO, both de facto and de jure.
And also very far from Europe in sence of values and politic.
Very nice and detailed analysis. Shared the video with a Kazakh colleague who confirmed that the video is very very accurate.
I would like to correct your misunderstanding about Saudi sending "their version" of Quran to Kazakhstan some 30-35 years ago, which you had stated. In fact Saudis were sending copies of Quran in those days as gift to countries all over the world, after they had installed a modern Quran printing press and printed Quran. They had also employed many Europeans (Christians) experts to train Saudi machine operators. I as an engineer was employed in a Saudi company and I had installed there some German machines sold by our company in those days. So your assumption on gift of Quran copies in particular to Kazakhstan is incorrect.
Secondly, there is no special "version" of Quran gifted by Saudis as stated by you. In Islam there is only one version of Quran since 1400 years. There is already a copy of 1400 year-old Quran present in Tashkent museum, close to Kazakhstan and confirmed by international organizations about the age of that Quran.
By the way I am your fan and enjoy listening to your clips which are highly informative & my best regards to you.
MashAllah brother.
Hi Sir, I am kind of busy and little lazy to read news as a whole and understand the same. But your videos on various burning topics helps me to know the actual news and also what's it's impact on us. So really thank you for this. I am big fan of your narration ans background details you give for every news or story you cover.
Pushpendra Pant sir and Shekhar Gupta sir are extremely gifted and passionate storytellers 🙏🏻
This channel and the “caspian report” are some of the two best information channels I know of. 👍👍
Clearly Borat needs to take the reins of the glorious nation of Kazakhstan.
Borat is a globalist invention. Kazakhstan's leader said no to western oligarchs. So they demonize him. The same people who want to demonize Modi. But we people of India understand these ill desire.
Sir Thank you so much for this highly informative ,accurate account delivered with such good humour.India seems to be preserving the journalism the West has given up on.
ua-cam.com/video/898vWSJlf0Y/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/nT_oR5zJgP8/v-deo.html
Oh, we have many copies of fox news & north korean media here.
That's an excellent point about sensitivity of oil rich countries' population about a slight increase in prices and also about inequality in rich countries. Completely missed that fact before. Thanks, graet point 👍. It's just struck me from the episode, Nikolai pashiyan might be one of the rarest heads of state especially in today's day and age to have been re-elected after losing a war. A nice analysis on it might be needed
Nikol * pashiyan
A doubling, tripling of LPG prices is NOT a slight increase in prices.
For the ordinary citizen, these expenses are back-breakers.
That's why everyone is suddenly in the streets.
The West had NO influence over the dictator... and you know that HE had to be in the loop over such an epic decision.
Thank you very much for job well done. I love your interpretation.
Number one fan from Australia
Beautifully analysed,i keep looking forward for Shekhar Gupta Sir's view on Various Current Affair Matters..👌👌👌
Sir, please do a video on PM security breach, cause I find you non bias media
@@rajeshswain6137 that's your perception,
Buddy godi media is all over it.. U should check them out
Thank you from TX / US.. Very insightful information to help us understand the truth of events in Central Asia and Europe. May God almighty be on the side of the the average civilian who's government is being hijacked by the elite agendas. God bless you for your service sir.
Thanks SG for this video and this topic. Very interesting and informative. Keep it up. 💖
Lol the dog and ambulance noise preview was amazing
Shekharji, do an episode on Modiji’s security breach and ramification of such practices! Thanks.
There was a security breach of president of india in kerala days ago. But no one talked about it. And it happened again.
Action should be taken on the first instance then same thing will not repeat just like bully-sulli case.
Our police is too political. We need a police reform
It was orchestrated by the PM HIMSELF, in light of the UP election. After this, he will win UP in a landslide. The man's a genius!!!
@@satyannair4837 Oh wowwwwww - you’re genius for propounding that theory.
@@pritesh0117 Sorry, I don't eat dhoklas, fafdas and khakhras the way Feku does. I am a simple man. I don't have the deviant mind of the Godhra Monster.
@@satyannair4837 What does food have anything to do with your preposterous theory? Only simple yet devious mind like yours can only think in this line. I’m not sure who is monster in this case?
Hi sir,
Was hoping for today's CTC to be on what happened in Punjab yesterday. I humbly request one. Even if you were to not add anything factually (which I don't believe), your opinion and perspective is always welcome.
Regards,
@@insearchof9090 he did
Wonderful CTC on a Topic which is Very Important for India. Brilliant Analysis, Looking forward to how the situation will unfold further. Stay Safe, Stay Healthy, SG Sir.
This was very informative! Thank you
Peaceful or even angry demonstrators do not behead police officers. Demonstrators do not use machine guns. This is a "regime change" operation, very similar
to what happened in Syria and later Ukraine.
Exactly
It's very difficult to distinguish between
Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan,
Republic Of Stan
You forgot Turkmenistan.
Also out of all the stans only Tajikistan is racially and linguistically different. Tajik are mostly caucasian racially and speak tajik which is farsi derived hence indo Iranian language family
@@vanderboii2202 thats a false comparison. India itself has many states with its own culture and language. India is a union, similar to EU.
Tajikistan is very different from other four stans in Central Asia, they r totally two different ethnic groups.
Read Oxford blackswain book.
Good overview and update with good perspective on Kazakhstan’s history and internal developments as well the regional dynamic/implications. I will say, however, this guy’s brief soliloquy about his neighbor’s noisy dog (around 5:30) is really really funny!! 😂😂. Added to my enjoyment! I like this guy!
Thanks!
Thank you for the SuperThanks!
Democracy doesn't mean only voting right. If democratic institutions are hampered, any attempt from the ruling or oppositions to keep a reluctance to reflect social contracts isn't pro-democratic. In essence, no check and balance, no democracy. However, where Industrial-revolution took place, we have observed maximum democratic practices. I personally like to address it as a classical democratic society. Another form of democracy is celebrated in former and existing Communist countries, like Russia, China, Kazakhstan, etc. All are under manipulated second-grade democracy. Some of those are better than the second-grade. The Middle Eastern Emirates are declared undemocratic. Most of those are pretty wealthy, but the global people are less interested in settling there due to straight-line state kingship authority. So shiny buildings, bridges, communication, etc., aren't the measuring yards of an advanced society. And the bottom of the list is countries like India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh, where number and faiths are concerned than democratic values. Despite all sorts of mess, India is ahead of the other two. Because still, people can attain in elections. Though Voters aren't agreed to understand, the job of a government isn't to provide heaven or hell to the people. Thank you from Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Honestly amazing to see the tremendous growth, both in terms of Economics and Democracy Bangladesh has taken over thr last decade. Love from India and all the best!
Why there is no video on pm security breach
Amazing Topic, Exceptional Analysis by SG sir....
😎🙏🏻
Thank you for the recap. Very interesting.
Only when America is in Crises... How do Protests start erupting in Various Places... Hong Kong, Ukraine and now Kazakhstan... How fund's these protests...
Enough with your conspiracy theories. This is not your WhatsApp group.
Always happy to see people hitting the street to save country. Hong Kong did the same, so is Kazakhstan 🙏
Yeah? Like they saved the country in Ukraine? In Libya? In Syria? I am from Kazakhstan. And although I don't support the current regime, in this moment when I see the whole city where I was born being looted, my father is stuck there and not reachable and the food at some places is becoming scarce, I kind of wish people would go away from the streets and stop "saving the country".
Beheading people and destroying cities is not "saving" the country.
@@albertdittel8898 is putin trying to make soviet union again?
Yeah be destroyed like Ukraine. Look at Tunisia. Another failed liberal democracy. Are people just stupid or are they paid to destroyed their own country?
additional information.ua-cam.com/video/VHeDGpSz2W4/v-deo.html
Great job sir for highlighting this issue.You are one few journalists who cover relevant topics.
Well collected reporting and to the point. Well done Sir.
I feel like my smart uncle is telling me about the situation in Kazakhstan.
Economy issues result in political issues. It's true for every country.
Many countries are facing economic hardship these days. Are all seeing such violent protests? Does such violent protest do any good? look at Arab spring which happened under similar circumstances a decade ago. Did it do any good?
Economy issues result into social issues also. Syria civil war spark was torture of harsh police torture of few local youth for spray painting anti-bashar slogans. There was already anger of damascus ppl towards bashar for not providing jobs. We see political issue of syria with a social bias.
Actually in syria's case, the core reason was climate change. Failed rains in late 2010s led to migration of villagers to damascus, which led to more crowding & unemployment, & increased anger towards the govt.
THANK YOU SHEKHARJI...!!!
Way to roll with the punches or dogs! Excellent information and indispensable!Great crash course.
Although it seems tantalizing destabilising the eastern borders of Russia while there's a storm brewing in its west but still I dont think that west has anything to do with it because USA and others have a lot of economic interest in Kazakhstan, there is oil and gas and there is also URANIUM. Kazakhstan being the largest exporter of the stuff. And that the west would know that dictatorship is the best form of government in these regions if they want to exploit the resources not an islamist or Taliban form of government.
No More Foreign Interference Needed Any More Kick Them All Out We The People R The Warriors / Qaurdian Of This Planet. Many Govs Around The World will Soon Fall
But US would like to hold a position on the Belt And Road Project in between Russia and China.
Weren't they the number 1 exporter of potassium?
That's because you are Modi bakht and you don't see anything wrong with the West because you are hopping that, one day, you will go there, if not already are there. Typical RSS subserviently to Western ideologies.
@@twatts1523 No U Wrong That Project Has Been Created By The BRIC or Brics If U Know Who The Brics R
it's mainly about economy and income inequality. Wanting Democracy is just a byproduct of government lack of accountability for poor governance. Baltic nation that converted to democracy,, like Ukraine, didn't solve accountability,, corruption, economy, income inequality after the Maiden Protest. In fact, it maybe worse than Lukashenko era.
Baltic nations that converted to democracy are far richer than Russia now,like Estonia
By global standards, the Baltics are 'clean.'
Why? Because the leadership is just down the road from Joe ordinary.
The number one issue in the Baltics: how to get the Russians/Slavs to just leave.
It's a problem: the local (political & economic) environment is so sweet that NO (ethnic) Russian has any motivation to leave.
It's ironic, Baltic Slavs want things just the way they are. (Can anyone get Putin just to go away?)
NATO does deploy jets to the Baltics -- four at a time. (!!!) None of them are American. (Yup)
Instead, they all come from minor NATO powers: Denmark, Norway, Belgium routinely transit through the Baltics.
Every once in a while, the RAF will station (4) four, F-16 fighters there.
All of the above are designed with diplomacy in mind.
Four F-16s can't be any threat to Moscow. They are militarily SYMBOLIC. And that's all.
@@ihavenojawandimustscream4681 None of the other Baltic states had to go through the Maiden protest debacle that teared itself between pro-EU and Pro-Russia.
Excellent sir
Great job on the video!
Kazakhstan is an oil rich nation. How come prices have increased there?
Market price se bhi kam thi pehle abhi subsidy hata di govt ne
If there's unemployment in your country then increase in petrol price can antagonize citizens
Because govt can give only so much of subsidy. As oil prices go up the amount of govt subsidy also increases. And when it reaches breaking point then correction has to happen.
@@ajqkit7gt But Kazakhstan only has 2 crore people. And it doesn't import oil and gas like India. Hence their government should be able to provide subsidy. India is so poor and imports so much from outside, still farmers get all kinds of subsidies.
@@harshb747 As a result of Covid there is now inflation worldwide. Inflation in US has reached 40 year high. Which is affecting prices of everything. including food. Kazakhstan must be importing lot of non oil stuff. Like food etc. May be those are subsidized as well. So the total subsidy burden on the govt has become too high
Sir , seriously CTC is helpful in preparing PSIR optional for CSE 🙏
Exam in a week. One episode won’t save us
@@amogsnair10 I am preparing for 2022🙂
Best of luck for your mains 👍
@@amogsnair10 Essay is tomorrow :) or I should say after 9 hours :P
Fingers crossed bois
Been waiting for this
Thanks for such an insight.
6:55 Russia is reducing its dependence on Baikonur for rocket launches. These days it launches more rockets from Plesetsk and (newly built) Vostochny cosmodrome in far east.
Yes and no. Moscow still loves Baikonur -- and still uses it for ISS oriented launches. The rent is reasonable: One ruble per year.
I find it hard to believe that Moscow will EVER abandon Baikanur. It's just too sweet.
In many ways, Baikanur is the International Gateway to Space -- which is, amazingly, how Moscow pitched it all those decades ago.
Plesetsk is almost wholly oriented towards Moscow's security launches, its version of the USSF's Vandenberg.
Moscow has come around to American thinking: one launch base for wide open civilian operations;
Another base for high security, truly military operations. Cost is no longer a significant consideration.
When NASA proposed using the Space Shuttle for military cargoes, the USAF had a FIT. Ultimately, Moscow came to the same conclusion.
SG often takes two or three semicircles to come to the point
Excellent !!! 💕 ❤ 👌 👍 ✌
Very deep analysis. Before stumbling upon your video I was watching news of KZ on various foreign news channel for more accuracy what went wrong in KZ, and you pacified me. Thank a lot 🙏🏼
Amazing topic!
Today I would be representing Kazakhstan in the MUN in UNSC Committee, and then this shit happened 😭😔
Why you had to represent Kazakhstan, even you are not? just curious.
@@emmiaman my preference was the P5 of course but they were all filled up so the Board gave me this allocation,
ig they did it in a random manner..
I hope Borat Sagidyev , worlds most famous Kazakh is safe !
I felt so dumb when I was informed it's not a film about Kazakhstan -.-
Crow too added to Music🥰
Loved the way you explain topic with ease and utmost knowledge
As the saying goes-"The more it changes ,the more it remains same.". The Kazaks and the people of other 'stans' , freed from the dictatorship of Communist Party, have fallen into the dictatorship of an individual. The fallen statue of Nazarbaev is foreboding and reminds me of fallen statues of the great comrade Lenin and Saddam Hussein.
And falling statues in the USA. Meaning this is a foreign (Western) sponsored unrest.
@@SportZFan4L1fe That makes no sense.
@@SportZFan4L1fe I dnt see the comparison
The world is upside down look at the US fake election fixed by its own cia
@@richardhenry371 Where's the evidence?
Tanpura and Kazakhstan - A heady mix. There is a world out there outside India and it’s politics. Helps perceptions.
Tailpiece: A wholesome channel - ThePrint.
Great video as usual shekhar sir👏🤝👍
Well presented and enlightening piece, indeed.
Buddhism had some influence in Kazakhstan 1000 years ago. In that sense Indian philosophy had reached there at one point. But yes sadly not any more.
Just not Indian influence they are the same people as that of India and it is named on an Jat gottar called kaswan from Russian language word kosa ke /kasa ke has become kajak/Kazakh and Kazakhstan in English language
Islam reached this central Asian country 1400 years ago and deep into southern Russia......Islam is deeply entrenched in central Asia and southern Russia.
I guess all these analyses are fine on face value, but the real summary is that since they have oil and gas Uncle Sam will want to bring the ‘democracy’ to kazak people!!
Many Americans are not paying attention to this. This reporter is very well informed, I appreciate his work and his personality. We, as a world, must keep our minds open and our senses tuned for cases such as this. I pray for Kazakhstan, I pray for Ukraine. May these countries find peace, may tyranny be quashed under the boots of millions of hard working, tired, and desperate people
Shekhar, nice topic, some refreshing change!
This is somewhat sad. Only on 19 Dec Kazakhstan’s Kassandra-Jomart was in Dehlli with Mr Jay. Shankar discussion peace and aid for Afghanistan
So, just as Russia was getting belligerent on its western border, troubles erupts on its southern border.
International politics is full of such coincidences. Uncanny!
fuzzed, idiot. (no, you think everyone else is an idiot)
I love your video great work as
always.
Better to watch and hear news here than what is there in the telly. Thank you for your summary. I may not agree with you always, but want to hear your point of view.
You forgot about Georgia.. (Abkhazia & South Ossetia territories under Putin control). Russian Putin has a lot on it's hands atm..
Pls do CTC for our PM security breach
There is no clutter there, except the PM’s mind.
Watch any tv channel
Sir
Thanks
I love this guy. Great explanation!
Yeessssssss shekhar foreign affairs is back. Thank you. It's a relief after a defeat in Joburg today.
Where is video on security breach?
Ok, I changed my mind about Russian and US. Actually, US Army has done great jobs in these 10 years for not interfering anymore with foreign nation as it did in 2000s. Meanwhile, Russia actively done so in 20 years. (20 years of observation because I'm born in 90s).
US Army is/was bombing up to 8 (eight) countries in the last decades and still illegally occupying parts of Iraq, Syria and other regions.
Great coverage
Indian Media- whether Print, Electronic, or Web pays very little attention to International News. We Indians miss it, since it's just not available unless one tunes BBC , CNN or Al Jazeera. Shekhar, if you recall, Prannoy Roy became a TV star long before he started his own channel, because of the weekly show- The World This Week -TWTW, much before Star News. We need that kind of a show, all that it needs an Anchor like you to present a cm0lilation of videos freely available on net & International TV channels & their websites. Pls start a weekly show on International affairs.
Watch wion
So this is what kejriwal want in delhi after couple of years, if someone hikes rate later 😬
As usual very clear and comprehensive
Sir, Can we get pdf of the yellow pages you were reading from. That would be really helpful for making notes. Thank you.
Is it for upsc ??😄