No end to avoidable deaths in Mumbai | Faye D'Souza

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 тра 2024
  • As the financial capital is all set to vote against the backdrop of the hoarding collapse that left 16 dead, Faye D'Souza highlights how deaths due to administrative and civic negligence are not only increasing but those responsible for it are getting away with murder, literally.
    #Mumbai #Mumbaivotes #2024elections #hoardingcollapse #Ghatkopar #Beatroot #FayeD'Souza
    Join my channel to get access to perks:
    / @fayedsouza
    For more news and updates, download the Beatroot News App:
    www.beatrootnews.com/download
    Follow Faye D’Souza on Social Media
    Instagram: / fayedsouza
    Twitter: / fayedsouza
    Facebook: / fayedsouzaofficial

КОМЕНТАРІ • 429

  • @scarescore
    @scarescore 23 дні тому +118

    Exactly.. It's never been the spirit of Mumbai but the lack of choice.. No value for human life in India !

    • @msdadsfsx
      @msdadsfsx 22 дні тому +4

      whenever there are 100s of death in mumbai, people say spirit of mumbai, city never sleeps etc whatever that means

    • @wilsoncoelho1963
      @wilsoncoelho1963 22 дні тому +2

      Yeah man.. I feel like I made a mistake buying a house in Mumbai man!

    • @msdadsfsx
      @msdadsfsx 22 дні тому +2

      @@wilsoncoelho1963 how much money?

  • @peterdsouza1259
    @peterdsouza1259 23 дні тому +93

    I am so proud of you Faye you doing a marvelous job

  • @monalisahota
    @monalisahota 23 дні тому +41

    Having always seen you calm through all kinds of coveage, this emotional pitch was hard hitting. Hope people of Mumbai vote against corruption..

  • @anitafernandes807
    @anitafernandes807 22 дні тому +23

    I remember many years ago, this 60 year old widow died in Colaba because of a tree falling on her. She had brought up her children with great difficulty and was about to retire from her government job. It still moves me to tears when I think about it.

  • @rachelduncan1501
    @rachelduncan1501 23 дні тому +28

    This story just says it all - everything that is wrong... Faye, you're compassion shines through.

  • @mohit9206
    @mohit9206 23 дні тому +30

    Thank You for making this much needed video. Hopefully people demand accountability and make their vote count.

  • @faf27
    @faf27 23 дні тому +34

    No value of life be it mumbai, kashmir or Kanyakumari 😥

  • @RaviR-xr2uo
    @RaviR-xr2uo 23 дні тому +44

    the road-show by the supreme leader in the same area of the billboard crash ...just days after the mass-murder ...is like adding insult to injury of the victims !!

    • @NevilleAnandNaik
      @NevilleAnandNaik 22 дні тому +6

      It says something about the desperation to cling on to power...

    • @morenmorefoodflavours
      @morenmorefoodflavours 20 днів тому +2

      ..yes yes ..I live in Bengaluru and I read about the incident there.15th I came to Mumbai and later read that this PM is right in that same area of incident and not a word about the families who lost everything.Such a shame.

  • @divyeshkotekar
    @divyeshkotekar 23 дні тому +41

    You are our hero Fay, bringing out the issues which really matter.

  • @maryanneekka5792
    @maryanneekka5792 23 дні тому +56

    These politicians dont care!!!😢😢

    • @mohit13reddy
      @mohit13reddy 22 дні тому

      Why would they? they can win elections without caring.

  • @manragha
    @manragha 23 дні тому +93

    After this ghastly incident, our politicians will have roadshows to gather votes!! Ashamed to have such immoral and spineless leaders who rule this country. 5 lakhs is the price for life in the new India. Vishwaguru, my foot.

    • @mohit13reddy
      @mohit13reddy 22 дні тому

      Indian voters continue to vote for these crooks, so nothing will change.

    • @sagek7949
      @sagek7949 22 дні тому +4

      Ikr ! People are so blind 😢

    • @tosushil
      @tosushil 22 дні тому +5

      Can't expect much from politicians

  • @user-bl1hi2vj1v
    @user-bl1hi2vj1v 22 дні тому +24

    Hats off dear Faye Dsouza for exposing corrupt politicians and goons. Certainly you are a gutsy woman God will give you a strength to fight against odds.God bless R.H lewis mumbai

  • @Nick-dz9ef
    @Nick-dz9ef 22 дні тому +9

    It's so important to highlight such incidents and give them a voice. Thanks for doing this amazing job Faye!

  • @swadhamishraa
    @swadhamishraa 22 дні тому +9

    This is such a sad reality not only of Mumbai but of India

  • @isaldanha1
    @isaldanha1 22 дні тому +19

    Absolutely agree Faye the BMC Commissioner should pull up the ward officers in charge suspend them & file a criminal case against them. The government & police have an apathy towards citizens. When will we get responsible politicians. In a country like South Africa the citizens have enacted & passed a law holding the local politicians responsible for any man-made public mishap. when we have public servants that take responsibility for their jobs & are held accountable then alone can we aim to become a developed nation. We citizens cannot file a case against a BMC staff member. WHY?

    • @anujaagrawal9958
      @anujaagrawal9958 20 днів тому

      Well put. The people to be questioned and held accountable are the immediate parties responsible for this act and get answers from them and not stir the conversation about election. @faye I really want to understand what did you expect from PM to be done when he took a rally in Ghatkopar?

  • @AdityaAserkar
    @AdityaAserkar 22 дні тому +9

    Mumbai's budget is many times larger than many European nations combined, and yet this incredibly abysmal state of what we get in return. Cost of life is so incredibly low plus is this superiority of spirit of Mumbai being chanted right under the untimely and avoidable deaths. Never ending. Demand more.

    • @MrDevansh23
      @MrDevansh23 20 днів тому +1

      Yeah BMC is apparently the world’s richest Municipal Corporation

  • @Nemisha17
    @Nemisha17 23 дні тому +17

    I could feel your anger Faye. The value of human life is next to nothing in the city of Mumbai. Truth be told, every time we step outside this city, there is no surety you will come back home safely.

  • @mamamia8511
    @mamamia8511 22 дні тому +6

    Apart from the naked corruption, further what's abhorrent is that viksit Bharat doesn't have a crane or infra to pick up this hoarding for more than 50 hrs!!

  • @arjunarora9177
    @arjunarora9177 23 дні тому +21

    Salute to you faye , Thanks , one of your best videos for all

  • @ashwinirajput07
    @ashwinirajput07 23 дні тому +12

    Thank you so much for sharing and presenting the stats... Everything you said just to the point which no one can question... Vote ! Vote carefully..

  • @goddessvibes08
    @goddessvibes08 23 дні тому +15

    We need proper infra development in India

  • @adhirajacharya2997
    @adhirajacharya2997 23 дні тому +10

    Housing is such a big problem in mumbai and this is not taken seriously by the government. The PM held a roadshow but situation of roads is so bad. Mumbai people are incredible but they are victims of persecution because of no choice

  • @somnathsen2142
    @somnathsen2142 23 дні тому +13

    The known firebrand style. The presentation, the pauses, the care for humanity , the responsibility....everything is great. One can't do anything but to praise her .

  • @ParveenKumar-ek7uf
    @ParveenKumar-ek7uf 23 дні тому +12

    Very nice serious episode concering innocent lives lost in Mumbai. Thank you for raising issue regarding humanity and politics of indifference.👍🙏😍

  • @nikhilshrishrimal4822
    @nikhilshrishrimal4822 23 дні тому +30

    BMC’s Motto “We don’t care , Kindly Adjust .”

    • @morenmorefoodflavours
      @morenmorefoodflavours 20 днів тому

      ..not bmc the vishwaguru and this present govt in maharashtra that only licks is the culprit.

  • @PrabhakarS-ej4cy
    @PrabhakarS-ej4cy 23 дні тому +12

    I’m watching Faye since from Mirror news channel we require more TV news anchor like her.

    • @dianadsouza7003
      @dianadsouza7003 22 дні тому +3

      Yesss, Very bold and brazen lady. Faye is never known to shy away from calling 'Spade a spade.'

  • @lancypinto4719
    @lancypinto4719 22 дні тому +5

    Shame on government

  • @patriciapavey898
    @patriciapavey898 23 дні тому +20

    Life is India is cheap.

  • @johndsousa6744
    @johndsousa6744 23 дні тому +11

    Very very sad and this is common in Mumbai. We have so many open manholes which are open and waiting for an accident to happen. Only then will the authorities start taking action and that too for a short period.

  • @bhinoyj
    @bhinoyj 23 дні тому +11

    I could feel it in your voice. You holding back emotions. And I feel the same. Lack of choice.... Well said. Thank you. The hoardings mafia is a strong lobby. I am sceptical about any change. I hope I am wrong

  • @alancardoz3577
    @alancardoz3577 23 дні тому +10

    There is a huge hoarding at the Eastern Express Highway end of the bridge which crosses the railway track in between Mulund and Nahur railway stations ... god forbid ... but imagine the lives of thousands of innocent citizens travelling by trains under that huge hoarding if anything unfortunate happens

  • @theseasonstylebyjannat
    @theseasonstylebyjannat 22 дні тому +6

    My brother died in train accident. He was only eighteen years old & it has been twenty years still it haunts us. 😢

  • @sajiabraham
    @sajiabraham 22 дні тому +7

    Thank you Fay ,that was well and powerful ..i will forward to my own circle of influence let's vote for change .let us me the change .let me be the first change

  • @ankh2695
    @ankh2695 23 дні тому +10

    Govt body sucks. They don't have any empathy or sympathy to its citizens. They just need power even on dead bodies of its own citizens 😢.

  • @maryanneekka5792
    @maryanneekka5792 23 дні тому +19

    This is too too sad... yes, innocent citizens.

  • @deepanshmehra9885
    @deepanshmehra9885 23 дні тому +10

    Wow. This was powerful. Very very powerful. Suggestion: Have a Hindi version of it too. Please. Most commoners might not get the message due to language barriers. Please. 🙏🏻

  • @nicksonpinto2074
    @nicksonpinto2074 23 дні тому +9

    That's why Mumbai life is overrated. One must ask, what considerations we put forth when we choose to live in an area, neighbourhood, city etc. To me it sounds too pricey for too less.

  • @cherylfernandes5537
    @cherylfernandes5537 23 дні тому +24

    Absolutely true. Thank you for saying this out loud Faye. While Mumbai offers many fascinating things, there is no quality life for the poor and middle class. People should stop glorifying crowded local train journeys. It's not at cool. Nothing to be proud of. Not the spirit of Mumbai.

    • @CW-rx2js
      @CW-rx2js 22 дні тому +1

      While you're right, I must say that Mumbai definitely has spirit. I think what do we mean when we say spirit is the ability to be strong and deal with any setback in life. This actually proves your point that it is a struggle and that is what makes people strong. That is the spirit apart from also people being helpful to each other.
      all the problems of the city are created by the BMC and politicians. The BMC is the richest corporation in India but the most corrupt

    • @morenmorefoodflavours
      @morenmorefoodflavours 20 днів тому

      Yes I agree we shouldn't glorify the crowded train rides but who will explain to these who take vedios.Spirit of Mumbai is best.❤❤

  • @savioryan
    @savioryan 23 дні тому +11

    This is Bharat... Btw... Aren't most hoardings illegal

  • @victoriesthopil1547
    @victoriesthopil1547 22 дні тому +5

    Faye D'souza. Great work indeed. I think what you said is right. They did not deserve. Innocent people. You have raised your voice. I salute you.

  • @alkapradhan806
    @alkapradhan806 22 дні тому +5

    We the public should be aware from this incident. If we see such big hoardings, we must contact the authorities to check if they are legal.

  • @cynthiaaguiar4267
    @cynthiaaguiar4267 22 дні тому +5

    A very sad case of the couple who passed away under the illegal hoarding,the people responsible for this tragedy are going to pay compensation to the victims.

  • @user-wk3ih3zu5o
    @user-wk3ih3zu5o 22 дні тому +5

    Dear Faye
    Inspiring as ever
    Wish this video was longer to make all stand up and take notice

  • @RaviR-xr2uo
    @RaviR-xr2uo 23 дні тому +6

    that stat of railway deaths in mumbai.... well...2500-3000 p.a. has been the average figure for the last 20 years and more..

  • @victoriesthopil1547
    @victoriesthopil1547 22 дні тому +3

    Really it was I who was present in that incident of 2005 cloud burst. Month of July. I was on my vacation to Mumbai. Yes no body talked about it. I really sometime think is this the value of our lives.I was only praying when will I go back to Dubai. The government takes care for us. Any Nationality. They are always there for helping the needy.

  • @h___p___2036
    @h___p___2036 22 дні тому +3

    Thank you for doing your work honestly

  • @kussh100
    @kussh100 22 дні тому +8

    If bombayites had any sense, they would have supported activists like kamlakar shenoy, a retired hotelier who is fighting against corruption by the municipal commrs and politicians of mumbai. But bombayites are too hard pressed in their daily life struggles. From being packed like sardines into the locals to turning a blind eye to all the corruption around them. From the dumping of effluents by factories in laxmi industrial area, oshiwara, andheri west or the sitting time bombs of the huge petroleum and chemical storage dumps in the chembur, sion area of the rashtriya chemicals factory, industrial disasters are just waiting to happen some day.

  • @mohammedmurtaza3257
    @mohammedmurtaza3257 23 дні тому +5

    I'm sorry for all the loss...very sad....

  • @mg.f.9023
    @mg.f.9023 23 дні тому +5

    Excellent points raised.

  • @Abhi-now
    @Abhi-now 22 дні тому +5

    "Bhavesh Bhinde, the billboard owner is a rape accused and has been penalised at least 21 times in the past for putting up illegal hoardings. As per the civic body, Bhinde's agency did not have a permit from the BMC to put up the hoarding."
    Ghatkopar West MLA: Ram Kadam, BJP.

  • @tinklingcrystals6489
    @tinklingcrystals6489 22 дні тому +5

    Common man also dont care.. that's why ppl are treated like bugs

  • @errolsaldanha2070
    @errolsaldanha2070 22 дні тому +4

    We can do all the hand wringing and tich tiching possible. As long as WE THE PEOPLE allow ourselves to be influenced and divided by Religion, Cast, Creed and Money when we cast our votes and as long as WE THE PEOPLE do not encourage and support our own brothers and sisters who are less fortunate, and WE THE PEOPLE forget that we are citizens of this great nation. We would continue to encourage this behavior from our politicians and have to keep enduring it as Citizens of this our Nation Jai Hind. Well done Faye for highlighting it so well.

  • @sebastianmascarenhas4231
    @sebastianmascarenhas4231 22 дні тому +4

    These incidents will keep on happening, as long as there is no accountability in Our Country. Bridge collapses, Train accidents, etc for a few days there will be discussions. The rot starts from the TOP

  • @sukhvindersinghnagi9752
    @sukhvindersinghnagi9752 22 дні тому +4

    Very shameful and painful

  • @shalinivaz2783
    @shalinivaz2783 22 дні тому +4

    I agree with you Faye😢

  • @tosushil
    @tosushil 22 дні тому +3

    As far as corruption is there it will remain DANGEROUS.....

  • @glendacardoza432
    @glendacardoza432 22 дні тому +2

    It is so serious, Faye. I must say you are so factually correct, we pay so much even as employees working sometimes more than required. Is anything happening in Mumbai?

  • @tarunagarwal7623
    @tarunagarwal7623 22 дні тому +3

    When you can't change the country, change the country. Fortunate to have left the city now.
    Condolences to those who lost their loved ones.

  • @maryconnor6499
    @maryconnor6499 22 дні тому +3

    Extremely well articulated. An eye opener for things brought to light. Thank you. God bless🙏🙏🙏

  • @jacobcheriyan
    @jacobcheriyan 22 дні тому +2

    Illegal hoardings are there all over the country. Unless government of the day is made accountable, nothing can be done. My heart goes for the families wherein they lost their loved ones.

  • @fatemasavliwala9927
    @fatemasavliwala9927 22 дні тому +2

    Very true..vote carefully

  • @Splash-nr8ot
    @Splash-nr8ot 23 дні тому +5

    Faye, I can't agree with you more. But this begs the question--whom do you vote for? They're all the same!!!

  • @sayantanibera6128
    @sayantanibera6128 22 дні тому +10

    Mumbai is an epitome of social injustice and wealth inequality. Having lived there for 7 years, it's not difficult to believe that how Mumbai is projected is very different from how pathetic it is, especially for people who have to struggle for survival everyday. The city of dreams is a farce unless you belong to a privileged social class. It's enraging to see that common people, who make this city what it is, have no value of their lives. The government simply doesn't care, and has zero accountability.

  • @EDasouza916
    @EDasouza916 22 дні тому +2

    Thank you very much sister for bringing this in public notice.God bless you 😢😢😢

  • @michaelmanickam1735
    @michaelmanickam1735 22 дні тому +2

    thanks Faye for that presentation, but one question will still be left unanswered,
    1)who is responsible ?
    2)does the word ACCOUNTABILITY exist.
    3) can we have some strict criteria in place for people standing for election.

  • @CasiaPereira-rj4md
    @CasiaPereira-rj4md 21 день тому

    Thanks Fay for talking on the real and painful issues of Mumbai and making the citizens to think before voting.

  • @darreldsouza5200
    @darreldsouza5200 22 дні тому +4

    Mumbai is one of the worst cities to habitat. 😮😮

  • @glendadesylva6189
    @glendadesylva6189 22 дні тому +2

    Faye u r just amazing. Hats off to a frank n feeling media person who speaks d truth. 2day morn itself l was shocked to see d Times of India promoting d wrong doers. Dont care of d people who laugh at u, as mostly people cant understand women like u n r always hiding behind d truth. U r a true pillar of genuineness n truth. Wish l could join u. Just luv u❤❤❤1❤

  • @ThePremanand711
    @ThePremanand711 22 дні тому +2

    "We will not go without a fight,
    We will not go silently into the night"

  • @ShivamVashishtOfficial
    @ShivamVashishtOfficial 22 дні тому +3

    I remember an incident from last year where I had asked my casting agent to reschedule our meeting due to heavy rains in Mumbai, he then laughed at me and said “Vapas chala jaa tu bhai Dilli, Mumbai tere jaison ke lie nahi hai”
    I questioned my integrity of being an artist so much so that the first opportunity I had received in a year didn’t come from Mumbai despite running around in the street carrying my guitar in heavy rains.
    Is it even worth calling it a “sapnon ki nagri, agar sapne jeene wale hi na rahen?”

  • @bhumaiyer5362
    @bhumaiyer5362 22 дні тому +3

    This is a very sad occurrence 😢 Human callousness caused this 😡 Unforgivable 🤬 No 5 lakhs of compensation can make up for this tragic loss 😭

  • @reshmadhingra8691
    @reshmadhingra8691 22 дні тому +3

    This so true , am glad some spoke about this. No one cares

  • @darshanamhatre7827
    @darshanamhatre7827 22 дні тому +2

    Thankyou Faye for addressing this..

  • @carmen3808
    @carmen3808 22 дні тому +1

    Faye you have always been the best till date. Hats off to you. What is the Government doing for us tax paying citizens 😢

  • @nancyfdes7971
    @nancyfdes7971 22 дні тому +3

    I salute you for your courageous advice 👍

  • @lynnetteremedios6659
    @lynnetteremedios6659 21 день тому +1

    Faye hats off to you. Goa is so bad corruption everywhere. We the people of Goa who have our roots here are so ashamed of what is happening. Goa was peaceful but now m sorry to say it's not the same anymore

  • @zitacrasto2497
    @zitacrasto2497 21 день тому

    You are absolutely right 👍Proud of you atleast someone raised the voice.
    Take your own decision before voting choose a right candidate 🙏

  • @henriettasaldanha2178
    @henriettasaldanha2178 22 дні тому +2

    Such callousness from the business community.. Very sad indeed.

  • @shraddhakale7779
    @shraddhakale7779 22 дні тому +2

    Thanks to her, she is voicing out the actual issues, the issues which affect my life and thousands of lives on a daily basis.

  • @jessyfernandes4315
    @jessyfernandes4315 18 днів тому +1

    Faye your doing a marvelous job keep going 👍

  • @benitachoytooa3872
    @benitachoytooa3872 22 дні тому +2

    The day and the moment this happened and was posted online....I remember saying thank God the petrol pump didn't blow up and the innumerable extent of risk involved. Mumbai is tough to live in and there's way too much risk involved. All said and done, what is being done to change the situation and how many alert citizens voices are valued in Mumbai or anywhere else in India. It's sad.

  • @eugenedesanto2797
    @eugenedesanto2797 23 дні тому +5

    Very sad news

  • @anjalinair3788
    @anjalinair3788 22 дні тому +2

    This is just heartbreaking!

  • @rajeshsequeira8381
    @rajeshsequeira8381 21 день тому +1

    Great work Faye.

  • @vilhenadsouza1788
    @vilhenadsouza1788 22 дні тому

    I lived in Mumbai. I have a daughter also called Faye D'souza. Hats off.❤

  • @sheilarebello763
    @sheilarebello763 21 день тому +1

    To add to flouting all norms of size, they bragged about a place in the Limca Book of records as the biggest billboard ever... Disgusting to say the least.

  • @icelinedmello5952
    @icelinedmello5952 22 дні тому +1

    Hats off to you Fay. I admire your courage. People speak about our PM they are targeted through many things one of them is TDS on your FD of senior citizens. Cruel.

  • @ashashivdasani2341
    @ashashivdasani2341 22 дні тому +2

    Faye, So well expressed. Really Sad. Hats off to people like u, who are bold and brave to bring out the truth.

  • @anjalimhapankar7914
    @anjalimhapankar7914 19 днів тому +1

    No value for lives in INDIA , BUT BIIIG VALUE FOR MONEY. Yes Ma'am Faye. You are an Eye Opener for human lives for JUSTICE N HOPE n
    Outspoken for the goodness of humans.
    Yes you said it right. Who care for lives ???? Only can for Our TAXES. Sad very sad. N the destructions been done on so called R........n. numberless. God Bless you Faye n keep you protected. I pray.

  • @DollyAfonso-un9pl
    @DollyAfonso-un9pl 20 днів тому

    Well spoken, Faye.We are proud of you.Happy feast.Happy Voting

  • @robertdsouza477
    @robertdsouza477 19 днів тому

    We miss your reporting on the TV channel but we enjoy your exposures on UA-cam. Please keep going Faye. You are excellent. 👍👌🙏

  • @deepakrebentisch9173
    @deepakrebentisch9173 17 днів тому

    This case is an eye opener for a “national policy” on hoardings in our country

  • @ramzanaliparvana8804
    @ramzanaliparvana8804 22 дні тому +1

    This sad state of affairs has taken more than 75 years to reach to where it is today! The construction company that erected the ill-fated billboard still has its owners and its staff roaming the streets! Those officers who approved the project and issued a license for its erection are not worried in the least. Setting aside the loss of these 16 innocent persons, who can we hold responsible for deaths through poverty, sickness, rapes, robberies, hunger....? Changing faces in leadership is not the full answer because what's needed is a drastic change in the mindset of ALL leaders throughout India and not only Bombay!

  • @judithparnell4029
    @judithparnell4029 21 день тому +1

    Absolutely 💯 right . Your a true journalist who speaks the truth. You hit the nail on the head. So many incidents, which were an eye opener. It made no difference to the government. They are busy with road shows , the Billboard incident makes no difference. They are bothered about the vote bank.

  • @MrDevansh23
    @MrDevansh23 20 днів тому

    Make the govt officials and politicians more accountable

  • @ritafernandes4739
    @ritafernandes4739 21 день тому +1

    What a reporting. Faye you spoke your heart out. Yes we need to choose our govt mindfully and not under any pressure or freebies

  • @JoRash-ct5qk
    @JoRash-ct5qk 18 днів тому

    Thanks for putting this all together. We are just helpless, Faye! We all just do post-mortem analysis nothing we can do. There are countless incidents due to missing basic civic sense and negligence. Processions are taking out with proud feeling making roads jam where not even a bicycle can pass thru and we talk about make way for ambulances. It is all uncertain! - Prem.

  • @sohamdey76
    @sohamdey76 22 дні тому +2

    Make that vote count but vote for who ? Please let us know

  • @lynnetteremedios6659
    @lynnetteremedios6659 21 день тому +1

    My sympathies to all the people who lost their lives due to corruption of our government and failure on their part to provide safety.

  • @user-mb7yw7ww8x
    @user-mb7yw7ww8x 20 днів тому

    You are one of the best because you care. Those in power in this country are callous ashamed of them