They went full out with the storyline in this MV, from props to clothes, to even hand gestures (Also recreations of MV scenes like the beginning was a reference to Just One Day) this was such a masterpiece TT
@@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971 they might say that because they don't know the story of the song conveys...maybe their own music choice is just the beat and not the whole songs itself.
So... that 9 years was their Chapter 1 only, brace yourselves ARMY, we are in this Bangtan sh*t for life! 😌💜 Thank you Rosan for another best theory. You're theories helped me get through the storyline from HYYH era. Thank you for loving BTS. Borahae 💜
YES! I'm ready for chapter 2 and can't wait to see what's in store. I'm so glad my theories were of help! I know things could get confusing lol Thank you so much for the love! 💜
Nobody has mentioned the bit where Jin lifts his head and opens his eyes. In Life Goes On he says. 'Close your eyes for a moment, hold my hand, to that future let's run away. The fact he's lifting his head and opening his eyes, means he seeing the future and we (Army) are with him because he's holding our hand and we are running with him. Well that's my bit of theory lol. 💜
I'm a mots:7 era ARMY. Your explanation helped me figure out the HYYH era. Which is probably the most complicated era. And now everything again reuniting. But it's not that hard for me now. Thank you 💜
@@r_e_e_m3035 Thanks! It's the way RM does it when he wrote on that white t shirt once...remember? with the tree? He's my bias and I'm loyal to him so why not do it! :D
Suuch a great video as always! One thing I theorized is that the train is "abandoned", the reference of snowpierce in spring day, in the end they "leave" the train, "abandoned" the system. And J-Hope sing "The World's Expectations, We ain't about it". Which may simbolize that they got "out" of the system... may be also that they may abandom a little the "idol" rules?!? (Just expeculating) Another thing that I found interesting, when j-hope referenced sea in las vegas saying "It's true, when BTS meets ARMY, the desert becomes an ocean", the memories of past videos are now buried in the sand, and will be part of bts and army forever. But they are in the bus, crossing the desert to new dreams. Well... lets see what deams comes next. I look foward to that!
I love the ending on the bus, and the ON ending , running up the mountain. BTS is always voyaging, and running into their future, and creating their future. I’m here for it all.
Great analysis, thank you! 👍 An ARMY also noticed that, at the end, instead of turning away like in Spring Day, when hobi pats Jimin, Jimin turns to him and smiles. So more hope, joy and optimism than in Spring Day or Sea.
7:28 and Jungkook references it again in "My You" when he sings, "Summer has already spread in the air, breeze is already blowing. The last cold snap is going out." Such a beautiful song!
This mv is a total masterpiece cuz it collects all the flashback of BTS for 9 years!!! Really loved it 🌼💜they proved that there songs have deep meaningss
In Film out, after I saw the video, I noticed the switch between Jin and Taehyung. But basically when Jin goes back from opening the door, he ends up switching places with Taehyung.
I also liked that RM referred to Young Forever when he said "Dream &Hope &Moving Foreward" followed by "we so about it", as it was what they told themselves during the chorus with "kkum huimang jjeonjin jjeonjin", kind of like they reached their dreams and hopes. That all goes with the theme of the desert and the sea.
I also want to say that most artists just put songs out just to put out a song but not BTS their songs tell a story wow these boys blew me away more than usual with this. They are truly amazing artists! I can’t wait for the next chapter. It’s like reading a book through music! Wow
I thought it was interesting that when the guys were on the bus, the camera picked up Jungkook's hand. I would love to think it reflects that Army is going on this next chapter journey right along with BTS.
thank you rosan, you did it again!! tied everything together very beautifully im all emotional again. the contrast between spring day's ending with a snow covered land and ytc ending with a hot desert do support the theory about winter ending and spring finally being here i didn't catched that before
This was absolutely the best and most accurate interpretation of the music video...so many gems you made me see, I hope this gets millions of views, you told the darn story.
I've missed the BU content. This MV was such an emotional roller coaster with all these references from their earlier MVs!! Thank you so much Rosan, for your in-depth explaination and theories!💜💜
In the ending bus scene, the boys seemed to be sitting in the same positions as they were on the train in Spring Day. And when Hobi touches Jimin, he was looking up and forward, not down and covered like in Spring Day. The MV was a visual walk down memory lane and I love it!!
Hi! I`m Nikole. I`m from Ukraine. Now when we have a war BTS supports me with songs every day. And now I`m crying `cause they have a break in music. Thank you, Army for your support in the last concerts. We never forget you
I not only enjoyed it, my tears enjoyed it too. This was so emotional I don't know why. Great job Rosan/XCeleste. You never disappoint. And thank you. Borahae
Yet to come is them moving forward to become solo artists. End of the chapter of BtS at the end of the scene while they are at the bus, meaning their journey has ended as BTS. And now the best is yet to come will be their future individual endeavors.
I love the sound of ocean wave, first thing come to my mind was ‘Sea’ my favorite track! I’m so happy that they included this hidden track into the song💜
I hope you read this😭 I went back and watched Film Out after hearing your explanation (which is always spectacular). At 6:57 in Film Out we always thought Jin and Tae looked like they could see each other in the different timelines but girl....... I zoomed in and they are actually talking. Omg GOOSEBUMPS!!! As jin and Tae are walking up to the glass their lips are moving.Does this change anything in the storyline??????
I noticed that too. In "film out" tae was in every room where jin was (not physically but symbolically. like watching him). specially After tae's first singing part room went blackout and jin enters that room when it was dark. when jin's room began to explode he runs and we can see behind him the parallel room's door is open. But jin couldn't go there and when jin again come back to the window tae was there in the parallel room looking at jin but at that time tae's room door is closed. ( thats why i thought jin couldn't go there ). And after they saw eachother from parallel rooms tae's hand reached out to jin but jin was not there anymore. Also in storyline (right here 10:38) tae send messages to everyone they received it saw it and ignored. After that tae went to help jin but he refused (when tae put his hand around jin jin pushed it away 12:17 ). Anyways tae helped him secretly 12:07 . So i think after everything (after film out) jin realized tae wants to help so may be gives his role to him and decided to help him.
@@ferrida7707 omg when I saw film out I said the same thing. Like it looked like they switched places because Taehyung was where Jin was standing at the end when everything exploded.
I can't find a reactor that mentions this. As many times as I've watched FILM OUT I didn't even notice them talking until xcelste brings up this scene again. I believe this would answer alot of questions ARMY has. That's why I hope she reads my comment cuz I trust her opinion. I'm 53 and feel like a 🤡🤡
ARMY is so spoiled by you! I’m one of your subscribers 4 yrs now. Thank you once again for your incredible insight, hard work, clear, concise & well edited vid!! Bravo!! You really knocked it out of the park! Borahae!!
WOW. SO informative. I've yet to grasp everything as an Army of 9 month old, I got som references, but what got me the most is your theory V/Jin !! You're the best !
Rosan, excellent job as usual! I always enjoy your explanation vids because they're so thorough and clear. You're really good at tying in all the resources! In SUGA's scene with the piano (along with Stay Gold and First Love), I got PTD vibes too. Anyone else? I think because of the colors especially of the orange/red piano even though he played a brown piano in the MV. I love that the butterflies were purple too! You may think this is a stretch, but the blue flowers also brought Smeraldo flowers to my mind. About the train representing Spring Day, the condition of it reminded me of when V put his ear to the tracks of the decommissioned train station. I also got Snowpiercer vibes indicating that the snow all melted, Spring arrived, people were able to live freely, and the train was no longer needed and thus abandoned. I love BTS's MVs because they are always so much more than what you see on the surface! Thanks again Rosan for another great explanation vid! 보라해 아미! Borahae ARMY!💜
Thank you so very much for this. In the last 9 months Ive ried to consume as much content I could but have still a lot to catch up on. Tears from start to the end 😢 . You are awesome Rosan 😍💜💜💜 thank you for the detailed explanation
Aww no problem! I'm glad you enjoyed it and I hope it helps! Don't feel rushed to catch up cause I know it's a lot. Take your time and enjoy your journey! 💜
About the exchange of Jin with V, I remembered that in one of the concept photos, the V has a silver rose in his mouth and many said it was the emerald, remembering that the emerald has always been associated only with Jin. UB is very complex I gave up trying to understand, but I want to congratulate the BTS team is not just any company that can always keep the parts so fitted. About this new phase, I feel that Disband is near, they want their personal lives, wife and children. But I also want them to return to their essence, songs in Korean, because they are Korean. And I hope that’s the best that’s to come
guys I'm 110% sure that the whole hybe universe is connected especially BTS's and TXT universe. The dream chapter and the chaos chapter are connected and show a lot of resemblance to the hhyh era mainly TXT's new concept dealing with youth issues and the odd-eyed cat, I feel like he's the real antagonist of the universe because he manipulates the desperate characters who need help like jin and yeonjun. idk but I can see these universes getting connected soon after all this 9yrs is just a 1 chapter of BU and notice how BU started in year 19 march 2nd (year 19 is equal to 2013) and TXT debut in 2019 march 4th.
Hi Celeste! Fist of all I love your videos, theories, and explanations alot. One thing that I honestly thought was that it would be so much for better not only for me but for other viewers is if you can add have subtitles in your theories/explanation videos. I have a hearing problem so sometimes I can't hear well or understand what you were trying to explain. It would also be nice for viewers who likes reading subtitles to better help understand the video. This is only a suggestion, I still love your videos regardless. I just wish there can be subtitles so that I can read them whenever I'm in a loud place and still want to watch your videos
I love your theories! You make very strong points and also helps me remember little details I had forgotten. I’m so excited to see what their next chapter will be!
With all the spring day references they could also be saying that the are all soon going to the military at the same time and for army there will be waiting and loss, but Jungkook has a line where he says they promise to come back again.
I was so excited to watch your reaction because I knew you would catch so many references that other reactors were missing. I admit I definitely missed a few, but caught most of them. I’m not as familiar with the full BU storyline so I missed those. I love how they put small but significant movements from their videos almost more than the more obvious props. It felt like finding a million Easter eggs. Lol. 💜
After watching the Mv my theory, BTS story - Jin's story loop ended, Jungkook's story loop will be continuing now, And Taehyung is the one who will be stuck again as he will remember both Jin and now Jungkook's every story loop unable to move forward. (Guessing this specially after the way Taehyung did that hand sign of Jin from Spring Day)
Do you think the oasis/island of multi-colored flowers around Yoongi's piano represents the various awards received? Also, Yoongi is standing on top of his first love...the piano. He has achieved King status.
It's insane how they work on their lyrics like it's a pure work of intelligence how they connect everything and make it sound so perfect everytime and it takes observation to understand the real meaning. These guys are amazing 💜
In the train, with all seated in the back, J-Hope touches Jimin's arm and Jimin looks away and both of them look hurt and sad. In YTC, they are now in the bus and sitting in the middle not the back (and also not in the front) J-Hope touches Jimin's arm and they look each other in the eyes and smile.
I new you’d have the best breakdown! You have been the only one to notice the vase on the table next to V mimicked the same scene with Jin. One thing I did notice was that Jungkook running with his arms out like an aeroplane was straight out of the Euphoria MV. I think even the camera angle is the same. One last thing. The flowers around the piano reminded me of Stay Gold as well but also I think some of the Japanese MVs of HYYH era have a lot of flowers too. I’m not as familiar with those MVs though so could be wrong.
Just One Day lyrics are also very important as they reiterate that BTS just wants to spend time with ARMY. I also love the lyrics that stress they're not about awards and trophies...they just love music.
In my thinking if V is replacing from Jin then what should we understand that the incidents happened with each member who travelled in time or who is going to travel from now onwards... another thing is that it doesn't more says about jimin I mean about his story in the storyline... please have a look at these concepts.
At the beginning.. I felt the desert is grey in color making me think of blue & grey ( as the sky is blue and the desert is grey ) 😭 and the lyrics of blue and grey is deeppp 😭
I wish I could like this video a million times, so amazing I have been an army for 5 years now but I had no idea about many of this, thx so much celeste , we really appreciate the work you put in for us, borahae 💜
I just got curious yesterday after seeing a pinterest post realizing that all the theories of their MV's that were all over the place for me before were now making sense, so I today I searched and found your channel and I swear your explanations were the best. I understood every bit of it. Also, I did notice the similarities between the scenes from the spring day MV but it didn't make sense before, but now I'm aware about the whole story. Thankuu 🥰
❣️Thank you so much! Your analogies are always done with respect and in good taste. You hold a plethora of information that you don’t mind sharing, which is so great for us. We can tell you enjoy and take pride in creating videos about these fine young men whom we all adore ! Much respect to you. Again… a HUGE THANKS for all you do! 😊💜
You know what, I was eager and so excited for the Yet To Come music video but i had to rewatch it a few times because I couldn't see a thing through my tears. How can a music video turn into an emotional experience! How creative and talented, to have the vision and concepts to create such masterpieces. They mentioned many times about a 'new chapter' and i was waiting to see what that meant. The mv and the storytelling, is always a brilliant way to combine everything together. They really outdo themselves every time. Thank you for this.
What I noticed in no more dreams and yet to come by myself "They are 7 boys come from a bus to complete their dreams and now they are going back from the same bus because their first chapter is complet and I think there going towards 2 chapter"
A friend noticed that the statue is not androgyne, as in BST, but male. Since I was reading Demian, I could think of the androgyne figure of Eva vs. Demian, who finally gives Sinclair her kiss, in the chapter "the beginning of the end", when Demian says that he will leave, but Sinclair will be able to find him inside himself...
You have explained and connected everything so well! Cannot thank you enough for your intense research and knowledge of the boys and their works. I can understand this incredible music video so much better now - they always astound me with their depth and intelligence. They are definitely not just pretty faces, as we are all aware. Thank you.
So I was right about Just One Day MV 😂 Your theory about TaeJin's role in BU story vs YTC mv is putting my mind in a spin. What if we hv been led to believe that Jin is the one who saved the boys but in reality Tae helped Jin in saving them because he remembers all the past timelines. But Jin doesn't remember the past timeline so that was nvr included in story in the first place cos that was said from Jins POV. Sounds ridiculous right? Never mind. I feel like I am going mad 😂 BTS sure knows how to keep our mind working 😂 Anyways loved ur explain video 😍 always a pleasure to watch it
Do you think that Jungkook running alone in YTC has any correlation to the suspicion he has about his accident/ how alone or left out he felt? I could be wrong but he’s the only one who was running by himself. For some reason that scene really stood out to me.
Tbh I didn't really jump on board with this whole connecting to the BU thing and just took it as them reflecting on the past discography and journey as a whole, but it's fun watching these
One of the best n detailed explanation of the MV. x Celeste has put in her entire ( not sure of many years)of journey with BTS to the fullest..Am not an ARMY yet but an ardent fan of everything BTS..so this anthology album is a must purchase item for me to know them even more ...truly appreciate her effort..I did watch a lot of other reaction..if they r ARMY ..they reacted with a lot of emotions..but not so well dissected like x Celeste...
Amazing in depth tribute knowledge, down to shots from previous MV, to moments from MV and live concert, to philosophy reference to BTS' songs and lyrics. Thank you for making me a better ARMY.
Hey Rosan👋🏻 ! New army here. I just finished reading the HYYH notes 1 & 2. I had many confusions but I cleared that from your videos. I'm really greatful to u❤.
Thank You!! My dear . ALREADY SAW EVERY ONE OF THE references .....from THE BEGINNING TO THE END in this break down ..long before many of you - did. LOVE OUR BOYS but am honestly way too damm lazy!! 😂 Was just waiting for you and others to SEE and INCOROPORATE it into the BTS Story Line. I knew you would. How could we not??🤣 we Saw TOO MANY REFERENCES to SO MANY OF THEIR VIDEOS in that one clip. Amusing how many.. never even saw or ( acknowledged) when Jin raised his hand in an homage to 'Fake Love.. for eg. Saw it INSTANTLY and recognized the other 'homages' paid to their past videos. Thanks for pointing out every..single...thing. There was so much that the General Public (yet call them themselves 'New Army' or .....100% fans) missed in this video. Such a pity, really. This is not the first song by BTS that Has been broken down AND SPOKEN THE TRUTH, WHILE holding a torch.. or putting it under a loving, BTS microscope. As an Army Mom.....X. C'est Pourquoi on t'amour...tellement 💜💜 You always speak your truth on BTS. Merci, ma Belle 🥰
Once again Thank you Rosan for this beautiful explanation video. Feels like an end of a chapter and a big era in our lives but it also inspires new beginnings. I can't wait to see what videos you do and what BTS does next. 💜
![[EPISODE] BTS (방탄소년단) ‘Yet To Come (The Most Beautiful Moment)’ MV Shoot Sketch](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5eFOa2hKRwM/mqdefault.jpg)
They went full out with the storyline in this MV, from props to clothes, to even hand gestures (Also recreations of MV scenes like the beginning was a reference to Just One Day) this was such a masterpiece TT
And some armys are saying they are disappointed with these songs
@@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971 they might say that because they don't know the story of the song conveys...maybe their own music choice is just the beat and not the whole songs itself.
So... that 9 years was their Chapter 1 only, brace yourselves ARMY, we are in this Bangtan sh*t for life! 😌💜
Thank you Rosan for another best theory. You're theories helped me get through the storyline from HYYH era. Thank you for loving BTS. Borahae 💜
YES! I'm ready for chapter 2 and can't wait to see what's in store. I'm so glad my theories were of help! I know things could get confusing lol Thank you so much for the love! 💜
I’m 7 years in and it just gets deeper and more meaningful as the years slip by.
Well..it would be another chapter..but can't forget if it's same book..!!
im ready
i feel soo nostalgic
I was just thinking this .. 9 years and only chp 1 lol - what are gonna do next!?
Nobody has mentioned the bit where Jin lifts his head and opens his eyes. In Life Goes On he says. 'Close your eyes for a moment, hold my hand, to that future let's run away. The fact he's lifting his head and opening his eyes, means he seeing the future and we (Army) are with him because he's holding our hand and we are running with him. Well that's my bit of theory lol. 💜
It’s the same look as from one of their btsu videos too
I'm a mots:7 era ARMY. Your explanation helped me figure out the HYYH era. Which is probably the most complicated era. And now everything again reuniting. But it's not that hard for me now. Thank you 💜
same! Im a 2020 aRMy too! :D I can't wait for what's to come!
I'm so happy to hear that!!! Yess, for sure HYYH-Wings was A LOT but now this MV is filled with so much nostalgia. Thank you for watching my videos~ 💜
Thanks for replying 💜 always with you. Thanks for supporting Bangtan. Old ARMY's are so special.
@@popicalbubbles I like the way you spell aRMy💜It can be another way arMY(Min Yoongi).
@@r_e_e_m3035 Thanks! It's the way RM does it when he wrote on that white t shirt once...remember? with the tree? He's my bias and I'm loyal to him so why not do it! :D
Suuch a great video as always!
One thing I theorized is that the train is "abandoned", the reference of snowpierce in spring day, in the end they "leave" the train, "abandoned" the system. And J-Hope sing "The World's Expectations, We ain't about it". Which may simbolize that they got "out" of the system... may be also that they may abandom a little the "idol" rules?!? (Just expeculating)
Another thing that I found interesting, when j-hope referenced sea in las vegas saying "It's true, when BTS meets ARMY, the desert becomes an ocean", the memories of past videos are now buried in the sand, and will be part of bts and army forever. But they are in the bus, crossing the desert to new dreams.
Well... lets see what deams comes next. I look foward to that!
I love the ending on the bus, and the ON ending , running up the mountain. BTS is always voyaging, and running into their future, and creating their future. I’m here for it all.
Great analysis, thank you! 👍 An ARMY also noticed that, at the end, instead of turning away like in Spring Day, when hobi pats Jimin, Jimin turns to him and smiles. So more hope, joy and optimism than in Spring Day or Sea.
Who is here after their hiatus announcement and understanding so much more now? Sorry I'm just over here bawling my eyes out.
Same. Same.
7:28 and Jungkook references it again in "My You" when he sings, "Summer has already spread in the air, breeze is already blowing. The last cold snap is going out." Such a beautiful song!
This mv is a total masterpiece cuz it collects all the flashback of BTS for 9 years!!! Really loved it 🌼💜they proved that there songs have deep meaningss
In Film out, after I saw the video, I noticed the switch between Jin and Taehyung. But basically when Jin goes back from opening the door, he ends up switching places with Taehyung.
I also liked that RM referred to Young Forever when he said "Dream &Hope &Moving Foreward" followed by "we so about it", as it was what they told themselves during the chorus with "kkum huimang jjeonjin jjeonjin", kind of like they reached their dreams and hopes. That all goes with the theme of the desert and the sea.
I keep on looking at the "EMERGENCY EXIT" written in the Bus, both inside and outside of it.
I also want to say that most artists just put songs out just to put out a song but not BTS their songs tell a story wow these boys blew me away more than usual with this. They are truly amazing artists! I can’t wait for the next chapter. It’s like reading a book through music! Wow
I thought it was interesting that when the guys were on the bus, the camera picked up Jungkook's hand. I would love to think it reflects that Army is going on this next chapter journey right along with BTS.
thank you rosan, you did it again!! tied everything together very beautifully im all emotional again. the contrast between spring day's ending with a snow covered land and ytc ending with a hot desert do support the theory about winter ending and spring finally being here i didn't catched that before
This was absolutely the best and most accurate interpretation of the music video...so many gems you made me see, I hope this gets millions of views, you told the darn story.
After their announcement during Festa video, I am so excited to see their chapter 2. And it makes the Yet to Come music video so much more meaningful
I've missed the BU content. This MV was such an emotional roller coaster with all these references from their earlier MVs!! Thank you so much Rosan, for your in-depth explaination and theories!💜💜
In the ending bus scene, the boys seemed to be sitting in the same positions as they were on the train in Spring Day. And when Hobi touches Jimin, he was looking up and forward, not down and covered like in Spring Day.
The MV was a visual walk down memory lane and I love it!!
Rosan, you always knock it out of the park. ARMY is indebted to you. HYBE should have you on their payroll. Thank you for everything you do!
Hi! I`m Nikole.
I`m from Ukraine. Now when we have a war BTS supports me with songs every day. And now I`m crying `cause they have a break in music. Thank you, Army for your support in the last concerts. We never forget you
I not only enjoyed it, my tears enjoyed it too. This was so emotional I don't know why. Great job Rosan/XCeleste. You never disappoint. And thank you. Borahae
Yet to come is them moving forward to become solo artists. End of the chapter of BtS at the end of the scene while they are at the bus, meaning their journey has ended as BTS. And now the best is yet to come will be their future individual endeavors.
I love the sound of ocean wave, first thing come to my mind was ‘Sea’ my favorite track! I’m so happy that they included this hidden track into the song💜
I hope you read this😭 I went back and watched Film Out after hearing your explanation (which is always spectacular). At 6:57 in Film Out we always thought Jin and Tae looked like they could see each other in the different timelines but girl....... I zoomed in and they are actually talking. Omg GOOSEBUMPS!!! As jin and Tae are walking up to the glass their lips are moving.Does this change anything in the storyline??????
I noticed that too. In "film out" tae was in every room where jin was (not physically but symbolically. like watching him). specially After tae's first singing part room went blackout and jin enters that room when it was dark. when jin's room began to explode he runs and we can see behind him the parallel room's door is open. But jin couldn't go there and when jin again come back to the window tae was there in the parallel room looking at jin but at that time tae's room door is closed. ( thats why i thought jin couldn't go there ). And after they saw eachother from parallel rooms tae's hand reached out to jin but jin was not there anymore. Also in storyline (right here 10:38) tae send messages to everyone they received it saw it and ignored. After that tae went to help jin but he refused (when tae put his hand around jin jin pushed it away 12:17 ). Anyways tae helped him secretly 12:07 . So i think after everything (after film out) jin realized tae wants to help so may be gives his role to him and decided to help him.
@@ferrida7707 omg when I saw film out I said the same thing. Like it looked like they switched places because Taehyung was where Jin was standing at the end when everything exploded.
I can't find a reactor that mentions this. As many times as I've watched FILM OUT I didn't even notice them talking until xcelste brings up this scene again. I believe this would answer alot of questions ARMY has. That's why I hope she reads my comment cuz I trust her opinion. I'm 53 and feel like a 🤡🤡
ARMY is so spoiled by you! I’m one of your subscribers 4 yrs now. Thank you once again for your incredible insight, hard work, clear, concise & well edited vid!! Bravo!! You really knocked it out of the park! Borahae!!
WOW. SO informative. I've yet to grasp everything as an Army of 9 month old, I got som references, but what got me the most is your theory V/Jin !! You're the best !
As always, xCeleste, love your deep dive into this BTS comeback 'Yet to Come'. Thanks fir putting in all the work for others to understand.
First comment!! I am your big fan! Waiting for your explanations, they are great.. 💜
Thank you for the love!! I appreciate you looking forward to my video hehe
and also RM talking abt new chapters makes sense
Always the go to for the accurate theories! Looking forward to it Rosan!
Rosan, excellent job as usual! I always enjoy your explanation vids because they're so thorough and clear. You're really good at tying in all the resources!
In SUGA's scene with the piano (along with Stay Gold and First Love), I got PTD vibes too. Anyone else? I think because of the colors especially of the orange/red piano even though he played a brown piano in the MV. I love that the butterflies were purple too! You may think this is a stretch, but the blue flowers also brought Smeraldo flowers to my mind.
About the train representing Spring Day, the condition of it reminded me of when V put his ear to the tracks of the decommissioned train station. I also got Snowpiercer vibes indicating that the snow all melted, Spring arrived, people were able to live freely, and the train was no longer needed and thus abandoned.
I love BTS's MVs because they are always so much more than what you see on the surface! Thanks again Rosan for another great explanation vid!
보라해 아미! Borahae ARMY!💜
This song is masterpiece and we all know that
But sadly many people didn't like it I really don't know why
@@inyochayacha548 They're on the bandwagon that BTS somehow lost their artistry due to releasing English songs the last few years..
@@agentapple2674 but they didn't, not everyone will appreciate the real art behind this song
@@inyochayacha548 Of course.. The antis are just using that as an excuse.. This song is amazing..
Thank you so very much for this. In the last 9 months Ive ried to consume as much content I could but have still a lot to catch up on. Tears from start to the end 😢 . You are awesome Rosan 😍💜💜💜 thank you for the detailed explanation
Aww no problem! I'm glad you enjoyed it and I hope it helps! Don't feel rushed to catch up cause I know it's a lot. Take your time and enjoy your journey! 💜
💜💜💜💜🙏
the mv was a masterpiece, all of the references had me screaming.
About the exchange of Jin with V, I remembered that in one of the concept photos, the V has a silver rose in his mouth and many said it was the emerald, remembering that the emerald has always been associated only with Jin.
UB is very complex I gave up trying to understand, but I want to congratulate the BTS team is not just any company that can always keep the parts so fitted.
About this new phase, I feel that Disband is near, they want their personal lives, wife and children. But I also want them to return to their essence, songs in Korean, because they are Korean. And I hope that’s the best that’s to come
Omg I knew this was coming AHHH😆 I’m so excited!
ありがとうございます！
SOMEONE ACTUALLY NOTICED V's connection to BOY IN LUV. THANKGOD
guys I'm 110% sure that the whole hybe universe is connected especially BTS's and TXT universe. The dream chapter and the chaos chapter are connected and show a lot of resemblance to the hhyh era mainly TXT's new concept dealing with youth issues and the odd-eyed cat, I feel like he's the real antagonist of the universe because he manipulates the desperate characters who need help like jin and yeonjun. idk but I can see these universes getting connected soon after all this 9yrs is just a 1 chapter of BU and notice how BU started in year 19 march 2nd (year 19 is equal to 2013) and TXT debut in 2019 march 4th.
That was indeed so indepth. I clearly understand now all the symbolisms presented in the YTC MV.. thanks xceleste👍🏻😊
I 😢 when I saw the mv. The nostalgia and the boys speaking from their 💙. I love hearing others explanations because I might have missed something. 💙
Wow! This is so wonderful!! 😍💜
Hi Celeste! Fist of all I love your videos, theories, and explanations alot. One thing that I honestly thought was that it would be so much for better not only for me but for other viewers is if you can add have subtitles in your theories/explanation videos. I have a hearing problem so sometimes I can't hear well or understand what you were trying to explain. It would also be nice for viewers who likes reading subtitles to better help understand the video. This is only a suggestion, I still love your videos regardless. I just wish there can be subtitles so that I can read them whenever I'm in a loud place and still want to watch your videos
I love your theories! You make very strong points and also helps me remember little details I had forgotten. I’m so excited to see what their next chapter will be!
I’ve been waiting for this…… the very first thing I was so desperate searching for right after viewing the MV yesterday …. Thank you!
As expected your theory never fails to deliver what is best! I’m a new born army… so love it. Love you BTS!
Same. I remember thinking i could not wait for her video to come out, because i knew she would catch all the things i knew i had to have missed
This feels like Endgame 😭😭😭😭
Grammy 2023 nomination DESERVED. Congrats boys! You more than deserve this!
With all the spring day references they could also be saying that the are all soon going to the military at the same time and for army there will be waiting and loss, but Jungkook has a line where he says they promise to come back again.
This also crossed my mind with all the Spring Day references... But if that is the case, we will always wait for them 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
드디어!💜
Others have done a list of references but you did a true analysis
Well done
Thanks for your hard work
I was so excited to watch your reaction because I knew you would catch so many references that other reactors were missing. I admit I definitely missed a few, but caught most of them. I’m not as familiar with the full BU storyline so I missed those. I love how they put small but significant movements from their videos almost more than the more obvious props. It felt like finding a million Easter eggs. Lol. 💜
After watching the Mv my theory, BTS story -
Jin's story loop ended,
Jungkook's story loop will be continuing now,
And Taehyung is the one who will be stuck again as he will remember both Jin and now Jungkook's every story loop unable to move forward. (Guessing this specially after the way Taehyung did that hand sign of Jin from Spring Day)
Do you think the oasis/island of multi-colored flowers around Yoongi's piano represents the various awards received? Also, Yoongi is standing on top of his first love...the piano. He has achieved King status.
It's insane how they work on their lyrics like it's a pure work of intelligence how they connect everything and make it sound so perfect everytime and it takes observation to understand the real meaning. These guys are amazing 💜
In the train, with all seated in the back, J-Hope touches Jimin's arm and Jimin looks away and both of them look hurt and sad. In YTC, they are now in the bus and sitting in the middle not the back (and also not in the front) J-Hope touches Jimin's arm and they look each other in the eyes and smile.
You are amazing Rosan. So talented in putting your theory and explanation together.
I new you’d have the best breakdown! You have been the only one to notice the vase on the table next to V mimicked the same scene with Jin.
One thing I did notice was that Jungkook running with his arms out like an aeroplane was straight out of the Euphoria MV. I think even the camera angle is the same.
One last thing. The flowers around the piano reminded me of Stay Gold as well but also I think some of the Japanese MVs of HYYH era have a lot of flowers too. I’m not as familiar with those MVs though so could be wrong.
this is such a good & throughout video omg, thank you so much! also i kinda forgotten, may i know from where jin scene in 12:22 is from?
Great job ! 👌🏻
I'm already looking forward to this!!! 🥰💜
Just One Day lyrics are also very important as they reiterate that BTS just wants to spend time with ARMY. I also love the lyrics that stress they're not about awards and trophies...they just love music.
There are so many "signs" of their hiatus :
Rosane's theories are the best!!
In my thinking if V is replacing from Jin then what should we understand that the incidents happened with each member who travelled in time or who is going to travel from now onwards... another thing is that it doesn't more says about jimin I mean about his story in the storyline... please have a look at these concepts.
The BEST explanation that I have seen bar none. All others does not come close. Thank you very much.
At the beginning.. I felt the desert is grey in color making me think of blue & grey ( as the sky is blue and the desert is grey ) 😭 and the lyrics of blue and grey is deeppp 😭
I wish I could like this video a million times, so amazing I have been an army for 5 years now but I had no idea about many of this, thx so much celeste , we really appreciate the work you put in for us, borahae 💜
Literally ur the only one I trust with analyzing the plot! Thank you ❤️
Okay I'm here for this 😍 WAAAITINGGG
Thanks a lot for such explanation
Well done, as usual. Thank you! There are some drums in the back of the bus. ON?🙂 💜
They really keep me forever young
I just got curious yesterday after seeing a pinterest post realizing that all the theories of their MV's that were all over the place for me before were now making sense, so I today I searched and found your channel and I swear your explanations were the best. I understood every bit of it.
Also, I did notice the similarities between the scenes from the spring day MV but it didn't make sense before, but now I'm aware about the whole story. Thankuu 🥰
❣️Thank you so much! Your analogies are always done with respect and in good taste. You hold a plethora of information that you don’t mind sharing, which is so great for us. We can tell you enjoy and take pride in creating videos about these fine young men whom we all adore ! Much respect to you. Again… a HUGE THANKS for all you do! 😊💜
You know what, I was eager and so excited for the Yet To Come music video but i had to rewatch it a few times because I couldn't see a thing through my tears. How can a music video turn into an emotional experience! How creative and talented, to have the vision and concepts to create such masterpieces. They mentioned many times about a 'new chapter' and i was waiting to see what that meant. The mv and the storytelling, is always a brilliant way to combine everything together. They really outdo themselves every time.
Thank you for this.
What I noticed in no more dreams and yet to come by myself
"They are 7 boys come from a bus to complete their dreams and now they are going back from the same bus because their first chapter is complet and I think there going towards 2 chapter"
I thought the same like they were running towards new beginning
@@moon-nu8mx yeah you're right 😁
I have so been waiting for you to drop something like this. Thanks for all your hard work so glad I sub your channel. 💜💜
A friend noticed that the statue is not androgyne, as in BST, but male. Since I was reading Demian, I could think of the androgyne figure of Eva vs. Demian, who finally gives Sinclair her kiss, in the chapter "the beginning of the end", when Demian says that he will leave, but Sinclair will be able to find him inside himself...
This is beautiful🥺
I love BTS so much💜💜💜
You have explained and connected everything so well! Cannot thank you enough for your intense research and knowledge of the boys and their works. I can understand this incredible music video so much better now - they always astound me with their depth and intelligence. They are definitely not just pretty faces, as we are all aware. Thank you.
So I was right about Just One Day MV 😂
Your theory about TaeJin's role in BU story vs YTC mv is putting my mind in a spin. What if we hv been led to believe that Jin is the one who saved the boys but in reality Tae helped Jin in saving them because he remembers all the past timelines. But Jin doesn't remember the past timeline so that was nvr included in story in the first place cos that was said from Jins POV. Sounds ridiculous right? Never mind. I feel like I am going mad 😂 BTS sure knows how to keep our mind working 😂
Anyways loved ur explain video 😍 always a pleasure to watch it
🌈Seems like they recreated the past and moving towards the future🌈
Do you think that Jungkook running alone in YTC has any correlation to the suspicion he has about his accident/ how alone or left out he felt? I could be wrong but he’s the only one who was running by himself. For some reason that scene really stood out to me.
Hi! The channel Bookish Theories explain a bit this her explanatory video, may be useful for you
Tbh I didn't really jump on board with this whole connecting to the BU thing and just took it as them reflecting on the past discography and journey as a whole, but it's fun watching these
Im bawling my eyes out😭 This video hit me with so much nostalgia😭 Thank you for this beautiful video💜
One of the best n detailed explanation of the MV. x Celeste has put in her entire ( not sure of many years)of journey with BTS to the fullest..Am not an ARMY yet but an ardent fan of everything BTS..so this anthology album is a must purchase item for me to know them even more ...truly appreciate her effort..I did watch a lot of other reaction..if they r ARMY ..they reacted with a lot of emotions..but not so well dissected like x Celeste...
as much Proof is a musical anthology, YTC's MV is a visual anthology as well
Am I the only one who wants this 13 min video to be another 1-hour one?🤧🤧😥
Amazing in depth tribute knowledge, down to shots from previous MV, to moments from MV and live concert, to philosophy reference to BTS' songs and lyrics. Thank you for making me a better ARMY.
giiiiirl🙌🙌🙌 this was perfect👌 thank you sis, I'll recommend it to all new army and reactors forever😎🙌
Hey Rosan👋🏻 ! New army here. I just finished reading the HYYH notes 1 & 2. I had many confusions but I cleared that from your videos. I'm really greatful to u❤.
Thank You!! My dear . ALREADY SAW EVERY ONE OF THE references .....from THE BEGINNING TO THE END in this break down ..long before many of you - did. LOVE OUR BOYS but am honestly way too damm lazy!! 😂 Was just waiting for you and others to SEE and INCOROPORATE it into the BTS Story Line. I knew you would. How could we not??🤣 we Saw TOO MANY REFERENCES to SO MANY OF THEIR VIDEOS in that one clip. Amusing how many.. never even saw or ( acknowledged) when Jin raised his hand in an homage to 'Fake Love.. for eg. Saw it INSTANTLY and recognized the other 'homages' paid to their past videos. Thanks for pointing out every..single...thing. There was so much that the General Public (yet call them themselves 'New Army' or .....100% fans) missed in this video. Such a pity, really. This is not the first song by BTS that Has been broken down AND SPOKEN THE TRUTH, WHILE holding a torch.. or putting it under a loving, BTS microscope. As an Army Mom.....X. C'est Pourquoi on t'amour...tellement 💜💜 You always speak your truth on BTS. Merci, ma Belle 🥰
My heart is full. Crying happy tears of joy and gratitude. Thank you for this. Forever grateful 🥹
I'm crying..... this is so beautiful
Once again Thank you Rosan for this beautiful explanation video. Feels like an end of a chapter and a big era in our lives but it also inspires new beginnings. I can't wait to see what videos you do and what BTS does next. 💜
Finally! Thanks so much Rosan. I've been waiting for this. Thank you ILU 💜
Thank you Rosan! I've been waiting for this explanation video from you because you are so thorough! Keep on doing what you do! You are awesome!