Response to LDS Prepper on Berkey water filters: David, the evidence does not support your claims

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 216

  • @anamericanlife9907
    @anamericanlife9907 2 роки тому +84

    if they can't legitimately refute you, they attack you to try and demean what you are sharing. You are being honest and it is up to the rest of us to educate ourselves. Don't give those types of persons rent space. keep up the good work!

  • @leesasees
    @leesasees 2 роки тому +43

    I spent extra money for the berkey flouride filters and you best believe I want my money back if they don't work. I'm sick and tired of all these money, money, money businesses. At 71 I've never seen such hatred for people by those who supposedly want to make our lives better.

    • @007bird
      @007bird 2 роки тому +3

      only R/O will strip fluoride. get a 5 stage or larger.

    • @michellemata2269
      @michellemata2269 2 роки тому +3

      Test your berkey water system for all the chemicals you are concerned about and decide for yourself.

    • @sixpackbinky
      @sixpackbinky 2 роки тому +2

      @@007bird and many other chemicals that Berkey cannot remove, in my area I have 6 dangerous chemicals in our water that Berkey is only able to remove 1 out of those 6… no where good enough , I have to have Reverse osmosis and even then RO won’t take out one of those, it would take a full house filter to take out one of the chemicals out of the six.

    • @edstar83
      @edstar83 2 роки тому

      @@007bird Water distillers also remove fluoride.
      ua-cam.com/video/0d6XnaCMvA8/v-deo.html

  • @jojow8416
    @jojow8416 2 роки тому +48

    it is so sad when people on social media feel so brave with their insults. They are rarely held accountable and I am so inspired to see you addressing such a socially dysfunctional person. I do not know you but feel that you are incredibly articulate. You dealt with this man with such grace, a great example to all of us.
    You either had an exemplary education, or you are wisely self taught. Either way, you are an outstanding young man.
    THANK YOU for sharing your knowledge and God Bless. 🙏

    • @pamelaremme38
      @pamelaremme38 2 роки тому

      Fluoride has not damaged his brain. Fluoride is a neurotoxin and it affects peoples ability to use COMMON SENSE and LOGIC. It is a neurotoxin (brain toxin) The more water you drink, beverages you drink, food you cook with it, dentist visits....depends on the amount of fluoride you consume.

  • @GarlandFarms
    @GarlandFarms 2 роки тому +13

    I made a water distiller out of an old pressure cooker and copper tubing. No filter in the world is going to perform as well as distillation. I also have an electric distiller that we use on the daily, but the homemade version will come in handy in a survival situation.

    • @karendaniels862
      @karendaniels862 2 роки тому +2

      how much fuel/wood would you use for 2 gallons of distilled water. we also have electric distiller for daily. wondering if solar would be best.

    • @GarlandFarms
      @GarlandFarms 2 роки тому

      @@karendaniels862 Not sure. We have over 200 acres and a tornado that ripped through here about 2 years ago left us with more firewood than we can burn in a lifetime. Can't always rely on the sun, either. Nothing is 100 percent, but the fact remains...no filter will do what a distiller will do.

  • @alexrodgers9247
    @alexrodgers9247 2 роки тому +21

    As for LDS prepper…it’s all about the $$$$$$. He just doesn’t want to lose the sales. So, I wouldn’t trust him as far as I can spit! The 3000 gallon lie and their prices are evil! Yes, I bought one years ago just so I could (if need be) filter my pond water. Now I realize the labeling is a lie, and I’m cheesed off!

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +4

      However, if I'm looking at it positively, the more LSD puts up a fight, he's sending views this way. Good for Robert, if he's monetized🤗

    • @alexrodgers9247
      @alexrodgers9247 2 роки тому +3

      @@flowerchild777 light and truth are the best disinfectant. Cheers Angela!

  • @TheTexasBoys
    @TheTexasBoys 2 роки тому +11

    I appreciate your response. We shared your video on our channel and the negative comments are kinda bizarre considering there is stone cold proof they lied and are misleading. The brand loyalty is awkward. People kept making claims that you and we were selling an opposing brand. Lots of hyperbole and zero facts.

    • @TheTexasBoys
      @TheTexasBoys 2 роки тому +5

      Interestingly enough is LDS Prepper does sell Berkey so he obviously has monetary motivation to make hyperbolic statements.

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +1

      @@TheTexasBoys I'm praying for you guys along the border (assuming you or any family members are anywhere near the border)

  • @hmoser6416
    @hmoser6416 2 роки тому +21

    Some people just will not accept anything that goes against what they have accepted no matter HOW many links supporting information. It's like talking to a wall with some people with closed minds. Sadly for some people when the truth is right in front of them, even after they read it will NOT accept, then they have to make the other person look wrong which is what you're experiencing. Then there are others who won't even read the facts and just claim you're wrong. I thank you for sharing the information you have shared

  • @premadimauro2691
    @premadimauro2691 2 роки тому +22

    He wants to save his wallet

    • @UnschoolingCOM
      @UnschoolingCOM 2 роки тому +7

      And his reputation is destroyed so it's his last ditch effort to save his reputation. Not the best move, but it exposes his true colors.

  • @BWSaks
    @BWSaks 2 роки тому +41

    So many people bought into and publicly recommended Berkey, it’s hard for them to admit they didn’t do the research, they believed the hype and were duped - so…they attack you instead of continuing to NOT do the research. Thank you VERY MUCH for your research and making it public for us.

    • @katrinagarland5219
      @katrinagarland5219 2 роки тому

      The Berkeys work just fine... this guy is just a kook.

    • @knothead35
      @knothead35 2 роки тому +1

      Absolutely. I stated on LDS prepper's channel that all Berkey had to do to make this go away is test the filters to the stated capacity and release the results. It's not that hard. David's video is laced with nothing but emotion. Look, not to besmirch the LDS, but they don't believe the same gospel or even the same Bible that most Christians believe. Seems a little narcissistic to say he's "saving lives" by telling people to use Berkey.

    • @theta799
      @theta799 2 роки тому +2

      Guys, i ran a test - ran 1 G of tap water thru a distiller and 1 G of Berkey water thru a distiller. Then I compared what's left after a full stop of the distiller: tap water leftover had beige particles in it and it smelled gross, very chemical. Berkey leftover had a little less of the beige particles and the smell was almost gone (it was still there but it was faint).
      I was not impressed by how much stuff I had left from Berkey.
      I documented everything (have pics and videos) but when I tried to pt it all together in one video I wasn't able to - it did not accept stills and I don't now how to add short movies into one video.

    • @pamelaremme38
      @pamelaremme38 2 роки тому

      It's called Cognitive Dissonance. The same thing happens when you try and tell someone that the earth is FLAT. We are in a circle with a 300 ft icewall around us. We have been indoctrinated (brainwashed) since kindergarten. The spinning ball on the desk. The spinning ball at the beginning of any movie you watch. It's a Masonic fraud.

    • @pamelaremme38
      @pamelaremme38 2 роки тому +2

      Truth is too PAINFUL and EGO gets in the way.

  • @joyful_tanya
    @joyful_tanya 2 роки тому +17

    I don't think dude read the PDFs of the lawsuits. It made me furious to read them. Especially the "nano tech" filtration layer. Ummm, what?! Like graphene maybe??

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому

      Exactly😒 They've been thinking about this for quite awhile😒

  • @calisingh7978
    @calisingh7978 2 роки тому +18

    This is one of the first videos I have seen of yours. You seem really well spoken, I wouldn’t address the drama people or you will be in a drama loop that never ends. Just keep putting out great content. 🎉

  • @chiefonelung9415
    @chiefonelung9415 2 роки тому +19

    I love your honesty. And I believe you and trust you with all of your incredible work and research. I have watched a couple of LDS prepper videos in the past and I cannot deal with his arrogance. So he has never been someone I would subscribe to. Right now he is puckering tight because he's afraid he will lose subscribers and support for his channel for not having as good facts as you do. Thanks for your hard work I hope your channel grows and grows. Go ahead and plan on monetizing. Peace, health, and love to you and your family from East Tennessee.

  • @mariannawilk7260
    @mariannawilk7260 2 роки тому +3

    Thank you for your work!! As ignorant as I was until this very day, I ordered my first Berkey some days ago as part of my healing from 13 years of illness due to toxicity, and will receive it probably today, maybe tomorrow. Because of your hard and, dare I say, frustrating work, and the fact that I, by pure chance, came across your videos, I will be able and in time to return it right back to where it came from without having used it with a great chance of getting my money back, and will spread the word to the retailer hoping the shop will be open enough to scrutinize its provider as well and cease to cooperate. Karma is fair and truth will surface sooner or later. Kindest regards and gratefulness from Denmark!

  • @FORUIDIG
    @FORUIDIG 2 роки тому +13

    I bought my Berkey before I knew this. I appreciate you bringing this up. I found you from The Texas Boys. I myself, I know there’s more like me, don’t have money to just throw away!! These ARE NOT CHEAP!! Many people do not have either the means or Know-how to do this in depth research. I “thought” I did my research reading the info from Berkey. I’ve got more SHTF portable filtration systems. The biggest issue here is the saying truth in advertising is a JOKE. As if I didn’t NOT trust Government and companies enough I truly don’t now! You offered your opinion, you said if I recall it was your opinion. It seems to me if he’s not tied to Berkey in someway he should at least be curious enough to turn his accusations on you to towards the subject here…BERKEY!! Bottom line they are EXPENSIVE!! They should at least be interested in their reputation and truth in advertising! Yep I’d jump on this train if only to get integrity back into the basic research we’ve done on the Berkey website!! I trying to keep my family healthy. I DO NOT have disposable income to just card deal out there for these companies!! Step up to the plate BERKEY!! Be upfront, no half truths, no smoke and mirrors just old fashioned good TRUTHFUL business practices.

  • @premadimauro2691
    @premadimauro2691 2 роки тому +11

    It’s all about money

  • @phototristan
    @phototristan 2 роки тому +2

    I got rid of my Berkey mainly because of the rubber taste it gave and the hassle knowing when the filters need replacing and how slow it is. I got an AquaTru (which is third party tested to NSF standards) and am very happy with it.

  • @baneverything5580
    @baneverything5580 2 роки тому +7

    I saw some convincing info on much less expensive pitcher filters under 30 bucks. The guy used a large collection of them and sent water he filtered through each from one bucket full of tap water for testing. The Waterdrop pitcher removed even the fluoride. I`m on SSI with no transportation in a very rural secluded area far from stores. I have to drink a lot of water or I get kidney infections. The water here is truly gag inducing. But I can`t afford to keep buying bottled water. After my last electric bill shocker I don`t think using the electric distiller I got for water is a great idea unless I use it with my solar which isn`t completed in a safe way for daily use yet. So I`m trying the pitcher next month. It claims it can do 200 gallons. I suppose that`s the least expensive route I can take right now. Taste test will tell I guess.

    • @annahgibbus8
      @annahgibbus8 2 роки тому +2

      Hi, I live rural also, but at least my water tastes great. I don't know what's in it, but it tastes great.
      I am on widow's benefits. Unfortunately I bought a Berkey a year ago & can't afford anything else. Could you tell me the name of the pitcher you plan to get? I'd appreciate it. Thanks!

    • @baneverything5580
      @baneverything5580 2 роки тому +3

      @@annahgibbus8 Waterdrop. Here`s the description> Waterdrop 200-Gallon Long-Life Elfin 5-Cup Water Filter Pitcher with 1 Filter, NSF Certified, 5X Times Lifetime, Reduces Fluoride, Chlorine and More, BPA Free, Blue

    • @annahgibbus8
      @annahgibbus8 2 роки тому +1

      @@baneverything5580 Thank You ☺️👍

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +1

      Thanks for the heads-up👍You are much appreciated.

    • @theta799
      @theta799 2 роки тому +1

      Guys, i ran a test - ran 1 G of tap water thru a distiller and 1 G of Berkey water thru a distiller. Then I compared what's left after a full stop of the distiller: tap water leftover had beige particles in it and it smelled gross, very chemical. Berkey leftover had a little less of the beige particles and the smell was almost gone (it was still there but it was faint).
      I was not impressed by how much stuff I had left from Berkey.
      I documented everything (have pics and videos) but when I tried to pt it all together in one video I wasn't able to - it did not accept stills and I don't now how to add short movies into one video.

  • @juliobetancourt5025
    @juliobetancourt5025 2 роки тому +11

    I saw David's post. I noticed immediately that he was under some type of emotional distress.

    • @TheMaddVanner
      @TheMaddVanner 2 роки тому +2

      Right! It almost sounded like he was about to cry!

  • @HadasahB
    @HadasahB 2 роки тому +7

    Thank you, thank you for all you've done, and DO!

  • @Silenceisconsent
    @Silenceisconsent 2 роки тому +2

    You replying to him , is human nature…. A natural response we have ALL been programmed to FEEL we should do .
    But lately, as I spend more and more time with The Lord , I felt lead to share to you ….
    The Lord says , we will be mocked , falsely accused, cast down , and laughed at . And The Lord says to The Body - Let them BE , Keep on your mission. Do not allow the tactics of the enemy to slow you down.
    When YOU KNOW, the Truth that The Spirit of Truth has lead you to - speak that Truth BOLDLY. It will uphold Itself.
    Let those that refuse to accept it , be .
    Dust off the dirt and keep on YOUR PATH .
    Be strong 💪 ! And DO NOT BE OFFENDED with the enemies tactics.
    💗

  • @pattiannepascual
    @pattiannepascual 2 роки тому +25

    A few people got upset when all I said was "there seems to be some sort of Berkey cult".This LDS guy is a perfect example,as are several people and customers I noticed had berkeys.I mentioned what's going on and that they might want to get their water tested,especially those using the water to make formula for little babies.I came under attack simply for advising them of this issue.i am appalled at how human behavior has become lately.In this case,they will defend a product to the end that they themselves didn't even test.If I were using a product,you noticed it and informed me there's controversy about the product, I would thank you immensely and research it,especially if I was giving it to kids,seniors or pets. What in the world is wrong with humans these days???

    • @elwingw4321
      @elwingw4321 2 роки тому +6

      I believe you Robert. The LDS prepper shouldn’t have used his faith in God as his credential of integrity. I believe Jesus is the water of life. But not to sell Berkey water filters. He is defending his own reputation and ability to be a distributor.

    • @pamelaremme38
      @pamelaremme38 2 роки тому +6

      You are so correct!!!! Same goes with when you try to ask people "WHY WOULD YOU ALLOW SOMEONE TO INJECT you with something that no one knows what it is? The shot!!! I have recently learned that is the role of FLUORIDE.

    • @pamelaremme38
      @pamelaremme38 2 роки тому

      @@elwingw4321 Alex the FRAUD Jones same thing. He peddled this product also. Then come to find out Jones is controlled opposition. 80% Truth mixed with 20% LIES or distraction tactics.

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому

      Pattianne, you're being reasonable. We can no longer expect everyone else to be reasonable as well, now can we?😒 Maybe it's in the water they've been drinking their whole lives. Maybe the food, vax, chemtrails. I believe it's all of the above. If a doctor puts you on anti-anxiety meds and you miss a couple days, your body responds very negatively. I'm not knowledgeable about every med used for that purpose, but absolutely believe they're spraying and withholding types from the skies.

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +3

      @@pamelaremme38 YESSS! Why would anyone "physician" fire you as a client when you reject them? I read the insert THEY gave me and said, "no thanks" and the pediatrician says we can't have you as a client any longer. Wonder why that is? Have you read them? Many MANY times over the limit they themselves recommend. It's not just the "stuff" that's supposed to help, it's the adjuvants, too.

  • @rjahn3000
    @rjahn3000 2 роки тому +8

    There is only one reason Berkey will not get proper NSF certification, they won't pass!

    • @chewbacca5986
      @chewbacca5986 2 роки тому +3

      That's right, if they stand behind their claims they would at minimum obtain the 3rd party certification. Berkey/Millenium can certainly afford 3rd party trusted testing/certification with as expensive as Berkeys are. Without the 3rd party certification the company seems sheisty snake oil sales people. Mama always says 'trust' AND 'verify'. I believe in certification verification that backs up claims.

  • @deborahhopkinson5243
    @deborahhopkinson5243 2 роки тому +6

    I'm upset that I wasted a heck of a lot of money on a Berkey system, but I thank you for your honesty and links to back it up. I've done more research, and you are certainly not alone in revealing the Berkey fraud. It's amazing that so many people have their income tied to this product, but this is not the first time in the history of the United States that this has happened.

  • @Clynn57
    @Clynn57 2 роки тому +1

    He’s a distributor so that’s gives him an agenda, immediately. There is something in it for HIM.
    I’m so glad you have countered his comments.

  • @premadimauro2691
    @premadimauro2691 2 роки тому +17

    Great response

  • @ghoulgoil5029
    @ghoulgoil5029 2 роки тому +8

    It’s probably a bot slave. Pay them no mind! You are trying to get the truth out there, they hate that!

  • @bonbons6860
    @bonbons6860 2 роки тому +7

    You are doing an amazing job, thanks for staying calm and following the evidence.

  • @OllieSoul
    @OllieSoul 2 роки тому +21

    I saw that video. Whatta you know... a Berkey distributor doesn't want the truth being exposed about Berkey filters 🤔🤔. All because he's trying to "save lives".

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +2

      Not just save lives, it's the first, #1 thing he'd take before his firearm, (did he say Bible? Idk) or anything above his Berkey😒

  • @ozzieosawamick1712
    @ozzieosawamick1712 2 роки тому +2

    Have you heard of the doulton water filter? If so, would it be any better than the phoney berkey filters?

  • @c.Lo_Vee
    @c.Lo_Vee 2 роки тому +7

    Annnd the negative side of this platform. Someone will always have something to say. Dont let it get to you. You have great information

  • @foxyauragems6146
    @foxyauragems6146 2 роки тому +6

    All of these Prepper push Berkey ! With a discount code 😊to make a commission

  • @Sanwizard1
    @Sanwizard1 2 роки тому +4

    I left a comment on his upload. LDS seems to be making money off Berkey, so he is NOT a disinterested third party. I also said to leave God out of it.

  • @markh9653
    @markh9653 2 роки тому +17

    Excellent detailed response. The truth and prepper community tend to seek truth no matter where it takes us.

  • @arkansasboy45
    @arkansasboy45 2 роки тому +3

    He replied to a comment that I had made and placed all blame on the filter manufacturers even though Berkey puts the data in question on their website.

  • @mzimmerman12
    @mzimmerman12 2 роки тому +1

    So what are the options for replacing the Berkey Filters?

  • @everythingmatters6308
    @everythingmatters6308 2 роки тому +8

    He's attacking you because your claims threaten his livelihood and reputation. I am a prepper and hadn't heard of either one of you. Lots of prepper channels have recommended Berkey. How they respond to you will reveal their character. I will start watching your videos. I won't watch his considering his response.

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +2

      I was thinking the same thing. I know of a couple of "preppers" who suggest them too. I now wonder if they've got skin in the game🙁😒 I'll be on the lookout as well. After Robert's third video, I thought about bringing it up on one guy's channel, but decided to wait for the court's decision. Now I'm wondering if he'll bring it up🤔 Certainly at least 1 of his many subscribers has seen these already.

  • @silverclouds3725
    @silverclouds3725 Рік тому +1

    The longer I live the more I understand the depth of the statement "buyer beware". We all think that because we wouldn't attack, lie and steal posing as a person trying to help others that nobody would... But, sadly, we must research our purchases as though we presume every claim is false and every salesman a liar.

  • @melvinajessop696
    @melvinajessop696 2 роки тому +3

    Can we get other filters. Put them in the berkey

    • @flowerchild777
      @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +1

      I saw an Aussie rig one with ceramic pots on a bin. I'll try and link it here.

    • @cjdflkj
      @cjdflkj 2 роки тому

      Yes, you can.

    • @ghost-user559
      @ghost-user559 Рік тому

      Yes, almost any meant for a similar unit will fit

  • @whatever833
    @whatever833 2 роки тому +5

    I've commented on his videos and traded a few responses and he is deifinitely in favor of hyperbole and dramatic talk when it comes to defending his beloved Berkey. He makes it sound like water filtration is life or death. People drink the same water we're all filtering straight from the source everyday and they are fine. I pointed it out in my inital response to his video. No one should be listening to or taking advice from anyone who makes money off the thing they are touting. He is not and can not be an unbiased perspective on this matter. I don't know him personally as none of us do but this appears to me at least to be clearly a salesman trying to protect his meal-ticket.

  • @TheMaddVanner
    @TheMaddVanner 2 роки тому +15

    People always say the lord/devil wanted me to do this. Take responsibility for your own crap and leave them out of it.

  • @livingtx
    @livingtx 2 роки тому +1

    Curious what you can find out about Hydroblu (particularly their Jerry Can setup). They offer a package with a "virus" filter. I know it's not really an everyday filter setup, but I'm not a researcher. Would love to know what you find out.

  • @jedi_mapperp4073
    @jedi_mapperp4073 2 роки тому +1

    I’m a water scientist and fell for the Berkey. We did notice our water tasted better and felt softer in our mouths, even the kids noticed - initially. I searched Amazon for whole-house carbon block filters. Turns out a Berkey Black appears to be a modified design inspired by inline whole house filters - which isn’t a bad thing. As for the filter testing and certification, I’d be more interested in the EPA rating. Just like professional organizations that certify skilled ASCE mechanics, or a GISP geographic information systems professional certification, there’s money involved to obtain one. I don’t have either of these certificates (that one must pay for) but I have rebuilt the engine in my Porsche 928 and I teach GIS classes. Companies like testing certifications because they communicate to customers that they are good quality, but that doesn’t mean others without are not good. Certifications become a marketing requirement. Also, I’m sure there are poor ASCE mechanics and I personally know less skilled GIS pros with GISP certifications. Credential requirements and those seeking them are easily corrupted. UL and NSF are not government agencies. They are for profit certifications. Initially, I thought NSF stood for National Science Foundation. So I think the Berkey improves the taste of our already clean well-derived town water supply (I read the test reports) - and because the Berkey is hard to miss and the water tastes good, we drink more water!
    PS: anything made by 3M is excellent.

  • @annahgibbus8
    @annahgibbus8 2 роки тому +12

    LDS? Latter Day Saints? The people who wear magical underwear? He either hasn't researched or is being payed by Berkey.
    Your conscience is clean Sir.

  • @jazzcat1056
    @jazzcat1056 2 роки тому +5

    Posted your video on his site saying he shouldn’t endorse. Also commented all over Berkey FB and people are getting mad. They won’t approve a post on the topic but I add to others comments.

  • @marilynwallace1050
    @marilynwallace1050 2 роки тому +18

    See how popular you are getting? When people begin attacking you, then, you have arrived! Good job!
    By the way this man's poor behavior sheds a very poor light on the LDS
    You handle yourself well. And by the way, my friend just replaced her Berkey system with Zero Water. Keep up the great work.

    • @katrinagarland5219
      @katrinagarland5219 2 роки тому

      Popular? People are just trying to sort out the truth and this guy is a quack.

    • @cjdflkj
      @cjdflkj 2 роки тому +2

      @@katrinagarland5219 lol, a quack who shines the light on Berkey own claims and documents 🤪

    • @marilynwallace1050
      @marilynwallace1050 2 роки тому

      Katrina: You make me smile. You just proved my point. Now go sit down.

    • @webdev-1
      @webdev-1 2 роки тому +1

      He's not an LDS spokesman by any means, despite his UA-cam name. He's just a dude speaking for himself. Don't particularly like his style, I must admit.

    • @theta799
      @theta799 2 роки тому

      Guys, i ran a test - ran 1 G of tap water thru a distiller and 1 G of Berkey water thru a distiller. Then I compared what's left after a full stop of the distiller: tap water leftover had beige particles in it and it smelled gross, very chemical. Berkey leftover had a little less of the beige particles and the smell was almost gone (it was still there but it was faint).
      I was not impressed by how much stuff I had left from Berkey.
      I documented everything (have pics and videos) but when I tried to pt it all together in one video I wasn't able to - it did not accept stills and I don't now how to add short movies into one video.

  • @peony0505
    @peony0505 2 роки тому +1

    Have you tested the Epicwater pour through filter? Very curious. I can't find a parent company to it, and not sure if it's a stand alone being honest with their data or if a dba of Brita, Zero, etc....

  • @urbanfrog1
    @urbanfrog1 2 роки тому +3

    Greetings from New Zealand. I watch a variety of prepper channels, and LDS Prepper shows up on all of them. The strawman and ad hominen attacks he used on you are pretty much the entirety of his repitoire. He seems to spend most of his time running around attacking people in the comments of the various channels. He's gone after me a couple times too. He's like a spoiled 3 year old running around screaming "I'm right you're wrong! I'm right you're wrong!" So take heart, you are just one of thousands of people he has thrown a tantrum at.
    Your information is very interesting, and I look forward to hearing more as you delve further.
    I know UA-cam tells content creators to try to limit their videos to around 5 mins, but that is mostly to cater to Gen Z (appropriate letter designation, Z for zombie, that is about the limit of their attention span). But realistically, most people who would be watching these videos watch a lot of prepper and DIY videos, which often run between 25 mins and just over an hour. So don't be afraid to take the time you need to get your message across. Your videos are great, and you do yourself credit with your research, and linking people to it.
    I wish you and your partner well with the birth of your baby, and congrats 😊 Cheers.

  • @Reality-50s
    @Reality-50s 2 роки тому +2

    People are just butthurt because they paid large for something they didn't research. Thank you for your honesty 🙏

  • @gisela1074
    @gisela1074 2 роки тому +1

    Have you looked at Aquacera filters or Doulton? They fit Berkey and are Third party tested.

  • @drandadeleon9327
    @drandadeleon9327 2 роки тому +1

    What is your conclusion on the water filters that actually work that fit into the black Berkey Water filler spot in the Berkey? We just bought a Berkey and I'm thinking maybe if it's got a guarantee maybe we should return the Berkey we also have a zero water filter not sure if it makes as many gallons as it claims but it will test out to zero where refrigerator water or sink water does not I have yet to test the Berkey water

  • @yadealone
    @yadealone 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for this. If you hear anything about this, let us know when the lawsuit is complete. I have no idea if I will be notified. The authorized dealer I bought my Berkey 3.25 gal. from also sent me an extra set of filters. The dealer actually sent the Berkey to me in California the which is not allowed. They said that they were going to stop being an authorized dealer and he didn’t care if they send it to me. I tested my filters at about seven months. I had one of my four filters fail the red dye test. Later I noticed a second filter failed the red dye test. I did call Berkey and they said that the company I purchased from was an authorized dealer. They said I could send a copy of my receipt and purchase prorated filters. I decided not to and continued using the two that were still good. I didn’t want to put money out I couldn’t afford on new filters. How many people has this affected especially if the Berkey’s are not doing what they claim to do. I really hope this lawsuit goes through. I just feel like I’m out so much money. I highly doubt that Berkey would’ve reimbursed me for the two bad filters. Please let us know when you find a countertop system that works well. I’m new to your channel. I have watched most of the videos you just came out with regarding Berkey. I thought I would be saving money because why else would I put out so much money. This is affected so many people. You can ignore the truth of the renovations that you’ve been making. It just makes me sick. Thank you so much and all the best to your family.

  • @joytrujillo9447
    @joytrujillo9447 2 роки тому +2

    When Berkey sells its product for $150, or less, I might consider it...oh and have a return or replacement policy that is not so scam obvious.

  • @growinggenerationshomestea516
    @growinggenerationshomestea516 2 роки тому +4

    Yes! I don't usually comment on posts like LDS Prepper but since I watched yours several Berkey videos popped up. I watched two. Both were from people who benefitted from selling them. It's sad when grown people lie, kids too but. I did comment on his video he lied to what you said in your video. The only good advice he gave was be a truth seeker.

  • @carlashuler5004
    @carlashuler5004 2 роки тому +2

    Actually, when you are directly selling a product that you have a stock of inventory to sell, it makes sense to defend your product.

  • @lizhaydon2250
    @lizhaydon2250 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for bringing up this issue. I did not know.

  • @Dr.Gunsmith
    @Dr.Gunsmith Рік тому +1

    So what filters will fit my Berkey and be better.

  • @johnmal5975
    @johnmal5975 Рік тому

    So whats the best filter for rain water?

  • @theta799
    @theta799 2 роки тому +1

    Guys, i ran a test - ran 1 G of tap water thru a distiller and 1 G of Berkey water thru a distiller. Then I compared what's left after a full stop of the distiller: tap water leftover had beige particles in it and it smelled gross, very chemical. Berkey leftover had a little less of the beige particles and the smell was almost gone (it was still there but it was faint).
    I was not impressed by how much stuff I had left from Berkey.
    I documented everything (have pics and videos) but when I tried to pt it all together in one video I wasn't able to - it did not accept stills and I don't now how to add short movies into one video.

  • @shelly8387
    @shelly8387 2 роки тому +1

    Because he admits he sells them. It was quick and brief at the beginning of video.

  • @TheFineLine920
    @TheFineLine920 2 роки тому +6

    Stay strong brother! 💃

  • @knothead35
    @knothead35 2 роки тому +1

    As I said to David...when it comes to the water I put in my body...I want more than an extrapolation

  • @jeffreyrodgers2881
    @jeffreyrodgers2881 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for your suggestions for other filters in this video. I am still a little on the fence about Berkey, but I did just order some additional Seychelle Water filters that I use for day to day to put in my emergency supplies.

  • @Thin447Line
    @Thin447Line 2 роки тому

    The need to filter municipal "tap" water is dubious at best. If people were dying from drinking unfiltered tap water I think we'd have bigger problems to deal with. If municipal water supplies become unreliable or non-existent we would have to resort to natural water sources. Rain catchment, rivers, lakes, ponds, etc. Boiling is pretty much the universally accepted method of making sure water from these sources is safe for consumption. The water filter industry has capitalized on the prepper community and made pretty good bank using sensational scare tactics. I'm 52 years old and have been drinking plain old tap water my whole life and guess what? I'm still alive and very healthy. Water filter systems are a scam. Berkey included.

  • @macik7624
    @macik7624 2 роки тому +1

    First of all, thank you for bringing the Berkey deception to our attention. I've been using a Berkey system for years, and I thought I would be well-prepared when it comes to water with more Berkey filters. It's upsetting to realize I got deceived, but come to think of it, it's not surprising that Berkey is a lying company. Look at their company logo. Second, I've watched your Berkey series videos, and I appreciate your attention to details and all the supporting info. I could tell you are being sincere. I am looking forward to your conclusion for the alternative filter.
    Finally, please don't let anyone get to you emotionally. I want to offer a verse from the Bible... I Corinthian 16:13 God bless.

  • @joannahuntington620
    @joannahuntington620 2 роки тому +5

    Excellent points!!!

  • @cadriver2570
    @cadriver2570 2 роки тому +2

    He deletes critical comments, so reposting my comment here "Berkey is $300+. $10k for a certification is nothing. In independent testing Berkey is average at best. There are so many better (and cheaper) options. You’re not saving lives, much less by recommending a mediocre $300+ water filter."

  • @exemida
    @exemida 2 роки тому +1

    Im no christian but I still believe lying for your own benefit is an awful thing to do especially with a lack of testing when all they want is money. Good on you for the research. And don't let stubborn individuals push you off the path towards the truth because they cant accept that they were wrong.

  • @knothead35
    @knothead35 2 роки тому +1

    Question is, the one tested for the court case...the one that stopped after 100 gallons...were those true Berkey filters? My guess is that it was otherwise it wouldn't have been allowed as evidence. Am I remembering that correctly from one of the last videos?

  • @janridge116
    @janridge116 11 місяців тому

    Doesn't a reverse osmosis take out all of the minerals in the water? If they do is it necessary to supplement with certain mineral? I'm just trying to get informed there is so much out there!

  • @flowerchild777
    @flowerchild777 2 роки тому +3

    Nicely done Robert.

  • @333whiteraven
    @333whiteraven 2 роки тому +5

    I'm hoping you'll do a grand video comparing many water filters, not just countertop products. I have looked into them, and I obviously don't know what I'm doing. Damnit Jim, I'm a writer not a scientist! I have also been looking at GRAYL...but now you make me doubt myself 😭

  • @Coconutoilcrazy
    @Coconutoilcrazy 2 роки тому +1

    So the LDS dude said the Lord told him to help people get ready for his return. then followed with safe water filtration? IS he an affiliate of Berkey? Next, When the Lord returns, why would anyone need safe water and or other preps? Didnt Jesus turn the water into wine? Fedd thoussnds with a loaf of bread and a fish?
    I apologize for the sarcasm, you , Robert are doing a great service to all, The LDS dude is one of the reasons I do not listen to those out to save the world from their sinful life.

  • @flowerpt
    @flowerpt 2 роки тому +2

    It's nice when you can make a commission on the Return of the Lord.

  • @MarcellaSmithVegan
    @MarcellaSmithVegan Рік тому +1

    It sounds like LDS Prepper sells the filters under perhaps another name saying its an authorized dealer, so if people don't buy them then he loses money? MHO

  • @rosemarythyme8595
    @rosemarythyme8595 2 роки тому +7

    David just doesn't want to lose his cash cow by the Berkey truth coming out.

  • @silverclouds3725
    @silverclouds3725 Рік тому +1

    LDSPrepper said, in the comment section of the video in question, that he had reached out to you (for a meeting). Could you comment on the validity of that contact?

    • @ghost-user559
      @ghost-user559 Рік тому

      Why would he want to meet with a guy whose first reaction was to call him uneducated and a liar? Would you feel comfortable with that?

  • @geri-atric1660
    @geri-atric1660 2 роки тому +1

    He has a fridge certification EPA Section 608 Certification
    For working on stationary HVACR equipment
    Section 608 of the Federal Clean Air Act requires that all persons who maintain, service, repair or dispose of appliances that contain ozone depleting refrigerants be certified in proper refrigerant handling techniques. It is a Green Energy wank certification. Just keep on keeping on Robert. You rock mate. I would love you to make a home made Water Filter using a clay pot. There is a kiwi bloke who shows you how and test the water 😀🥰

  • @horvathattila377
    @horvathattila377 2 роки тому +2

    Hi Robert!
    What do you think about Zero Water? They have pretty much good filter system and as far as I have seen, different test results showing their filter system is great.
    I would like to hear what is your opinion and maybe during your search came across some data what prove or deny the results.
    An other question, maybe the Zero Water filter somehow we can fit into Barkley water tank and we could use our investment in a different way?
    Let us know about your thoughts and opinions.
    Attila.

  • @naikrosh
    @naikrosh 2 роки тому +5

    LDS is a Berkeley salesman… don’t take him seriously.

  • @fastrack2170
    @fastrack2170 2 роки тому

    Alexapure I know has done its job though. As a consumer of Nascent Iodine I would feel in my thyroid whenever I consume any halogen besides Iodine. With Alexapure I wouldn't feel any trickling in my thyroid till afte ra year and a half, then I would get a new filter. However, I have received faulty filters from them and had to get a replacement 3 times in the same order.

  • @OlivinePhoenix
    @OlivinePhoenix Рік тому +1

    So Berkeys own laboratories test their filters? That seems like a conflict of interest doesn’t it?

  • @brunosco
    @brunosco 2 роки тому

    This “battle” is so personal, emotional, passionate and not factual that it’s a pure waste of time. I’ve watched both videos and I have no clue if I should buy a Berkey or not. Please join forces and seek factual truth together! Or at least calm down and be more objective before talking. I say that with the utmost respect, just that it upsets me to have to go through this when trying to know which filter to buy. All the best with your newborn and family, BTW! 😉 Oh, and I will add I was glad to see from the thumbnail you were practicing the “sleeping-in-the-same-bed” way with your child (forgot the proper term), I did with mine and believe it’s the best way.

  • @jenniferreynolds7082
    @jenniferreynolds7082 2 роки тому

    I am a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latterday Saints as well. I hope you don’t think bad about our church just because of one person’s comments to you. He doesn’t represent all of us. I really appreciate the research you have done to find the truth amidst all the deception of those who want to make money in a business without doing all the hard work of making a quality product and getting it certified. We do value emergency preparedness as a church but we also believe strongly in not attacking others and treating them with respect. I hope you keep on searching for the truth and we can all work together to find the best products out there to protect us and our families. I heard of a company called Seychelle that is supposed to be really good and would like your opinion of their laboratory tested data claims.

  • @Dr.Gunsmith
    @Dr.Gunsmith Рік тому +1

    LifeSaver products are great but expensive.

  • @TheKingsComingAlefTav
    @TheKingsComingAlefTav 2 роки тому +1

    How would fraud filters get into court 🤣🤣🤣

  • @hollyraban
    @hollyraban 2 роки тому +2

    Enjoying your videos so much!

  • @gretchenburton7184
    @gretchenburton7184 2 роки тому

    I have a Berkey. Did not like the taste. Had RO for years but the plumber said it was going to leak so it was disconnected and got the Berkey. An odd smell and taste. Got some 90.10 water bottles, expensive and all 4 have rust arount the necks! But the taste ftom Berkey is better. Still looking for a water filter but kitchen needs work so need a countertop filtration system. Am going to try enviromagnetics soon. Need to get them installed...magnets on pipes.

  • @tan3964
    @tan3964 2 роки тому +1

    You have my support 100%.

  • @clrobinson1776
    @clrobinson1776 2 роки тому +1

    If you can’t attack the augment attack the person. Where are his “facts”? People rarely are willing to admit they put their faith in something that looks to be turning into a lie. It’s why people keep believing in conspiracy theories no matter what the proof is.
    There are water testing kits out there that aren’t trying to sell you anything else. Don’t know anything about ones on Amazon, but you can pick one up @ most hardware stores.
    p.s. My husband’s area of expertise is environmental waste & water systems. His job is helping poorer communities to get grants from the state so they can upgrade their infrastructure to have safe water. He’s been very interested in these lawsuits.

  • @omavicmcmurray2893
    @omavicmcmurray2893 2 роки тому +6

    Robert, don’t go down the rabbit hole with a troll, its not worth it. Anyone can make claims about anything, you do your best, you do good work, you hav a new job and school and a baby soon…don’t continue to put your energy into his claims, your life is too precious. Take care my friend. O

  • @nancysonnier6605
    @nancysonnier6605 2 роки тому +4

    Good video!

  • @jopo6388
    @jopo6388 2 роки тому

    Distillation only way to go!

  • @preppinainteasy9965
    @preppinainteasy9965 2 роки тому

    Piss on the people who refuse too,do there home work.Anyone still pushing a Berkey is flat out in it for nothing but 💰 🤑!!!!Good job....

  • @helensosa3791
    @helensosa3791 2 роки тому +1

    WHY you give that person a minute of your time, your time is precious, don't worry what people saying. We are adults and responsible for what we believe, don't worry, keep trying to be honest with the Lord and don't worry. Only went we bother the devil the devil will bother us. 😉

  • @stacey9003
    @stacey9003 2 роки тому +1

    I just unsubscribed from LDSPrepper's channel. It's a shame he felt threatened by your research and attacked you as he did. He sells Berkey merchandise and has stood behind Berkey for quite some time. Partially due to his endorsement I purchased a Berkey water filter and found it didn't improve the taste of our Southern California water, which indicates to me it isn't filtering as claimed. We should support each other in truth.

  • @04DynaGlyde
    @04DynaGlyde Рік тому

    👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @JudyinAZ3
    @JudyinAZ3 2 роки тому +1

    I believe you

  • @Justno-hm3vk
    @Justno-hm3vk 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you so much for the work you have done on this Berkey subject. I'm just plain embarrassed I bought one last year, but I take full responsibility that I did not do my own research.

  • @stephm.3407
    @stephm.3407 Рік тому

    David sounds like he is grandiose and has a God complex.

  • @stewartrv
    @stewartrv 2 роки тому +1

    Dude I suggest you log a take down request as the dude is harassing you - you have the right of free speech and he is abusing you for it....
    It's all about the money, LDS Prepper sells Berkey stuff... Follow the money.