I was born in 1945. This film is near and dear to my heart. It's the best version. It has the feeling and soul of the old Hollywood. Sat in many a darkened theatre and watched the best movies ever made on the big screen. It was magical. I lived across the street from the cinema. Would sometimes spend the entire day watching a film over and over. My mother would sometimes have to drag me out.
Aber haben nicht bemerkt wie gemein diese " Atmosphäre " war! Ich habe in Opera gearbeitet wo auch verschiedenes passiert aber so was doch nie..Es ist furchtbar!
Still the best of the bunch. Janet Gaynor's career at Fox was built on roles like this. She gets excellent support from Fredric March, Adolphe Menjou, Andy Devine and especially May Robson. With Wild Bill Wellman directing and writing and Max Steiner's music, it is one of the best tear-jerkers. The movie's success helped pave the way for "Gone With the Wind" two years later.
You're not far off the truth; The story was actually based on the careers of Greta Garbo & John Gilbert [He taught her a lot about film acting.] It is also rumoured that the failed [due to his declining career & alcoholism] marriage of Mary Pickford & Owen Moore was also sourced.
Still the best version. A lot of the scenarios in this film still ring true in 2023. The ocean scene is tragic and Fredric March is criminally underrated as an actor.
Excellent movie, thank you for sharing it with us! I was captivated, don't allow the age of the movie to keep you from watching this 5-star movie. It's in color as well. Rotten Tomatoes gave it 100% and that never happens.
Она - предатель , фильм ужасный! Даже к бабушке не разу не приехала..а мужа нарочно отпустила" погулять "хотя было видно зачем он гулять пошёл..полное лицемерие и фальсита! Неужели вы совсем этого не видите!
'Gramdma' was 'Aunt Polly' in the 1938 film Tom Sawyer. That movie was made by Selznick Studios as well. The background score is so similar in both these films. I love both these films and never tire of watching them. Thank you for sharing this movie. 🙏🏻
Lei e molto falsa..peccato per il Marito..e poi che mondo terribile di cinema!!!.E un Film come una furba diventa famosa e buona anche usando la morte di proprio Marito, che aveva usato e buttato via anche se molto intelligente in che modo comunque lo fatto, che sembra proprio alcontrario 😮, La gente però sembra non si e accorta di niente..già!
grandiosa Excelente pelicula me imprecioso saver como se travaja en Hollywood Norman se Enamoro Dev esa Injenua chica y la LLevo Al Estrellato fue bello ver Ese Amor De los dos desgrasiadamente el alkol fue su caida de seguir su carrera y su Esposa Fue grande Lo hermoso de esta historia que nunca se divorsiaron fue um amor Bello❤❤ grasias por compartirlo las peliczlas de los 40 50 60 Deverdad FUERON FANTASTICO❤🙏🏻👌👏👏👏👏💗💗💗
Really great point made on how UGLY the press & propaganda mill makers are made in this movie that may be overlooked among the other points of this movie. Grandma could be looked at as a great pioneer women OR one of the worst stage mothers ever too. It's all how you look at it. Norman chose career over his health. Wife was willing to chose him & his health over career to save his life - after all they certainly had the wealth by then anyway. Interesting perspectives depending on where you are in your own life on how you look at this story.
Я в захваті від цього фільма. Актори чудові, не тількі в головних ролях, а й другого плану. Неймовірні таланти! А головна зірка дуже схожа на мою бабцю в юності. 🤗
Странно,почему то никто ищ комментрв не написал о кошмарных порядках в Голливуде тех времён.да и сейчас,наверное не лучше.Сначала ищут индивидуальность,а потом ....Чтобы выжить нужны яйца страусинные.Иначе!?Прекрасный фильм.Оригинал-всегла лучше.
1) check the channel homepage for upcoming live premieres 3 days in advance. 2) Check stories for the next upcoming live stream 3) Or members only playlist for films that will eventually published Hope that helps
No cóż,nie podoba mi się jak zachowywały się kobiety w tamtych czasach.Zbyt uległe,podporządkowane męższczyznom,pełne poświęceń dla nich,słabe.To nie są takie kobiety jak w roku 2023,o nie.Dzieli nas bardzo dużo.
Then you no nothing of women and how they lived or were treated !!!! Maybe do a little research !!!! Not so long ago you were the property of your father then when you married you were the property of your husband !!!! It’s still like that in many countries !!!!
Estudei num colégio católico de freiras... e por um lado foi bom. Porém em outra, me levou a rejeitar a Deus e a biblia e caminhei na tilha da nova era, esoterismo... e quase afundei. Após anos de enganos e desvios sem consciência como universalista, Me converti e venho aprofundando e renovando minha aliança c Deus verdadeiro. E conhecer o sobre o plano de salvação, o verdadeiro sentido da cruz, os planos do inimigo de Deus.. e as escamas cada vez mais caem dos meus olhos.
Gréât lesson in this film how this man take care of her and after the death. The place on the road seem’s good luck 👍🏻🍀 it’s for her before she now him . All the life was right!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌍
_Wow, my dearest Helen! Look to the screen: "A Star is Born"! Well, this star is 86 years old nowadays, but still shines like as on those Good Old Days! Janet Gaynor & Frederic March have glow enough to much more than a century on Cinema! That's why this old amazing movie worthwhile indeed to be seen here on CCC movie chat at live! I hope that you enjoy it, my Sweet Helen from my heart! God bless you always, Forever and Ever!_ 🤩🤩🤗🤗❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@helenpoornima5126 _Hi, my dearest Helen! I hope that everything is going very well with you in the Enchanted Kingdom of Tamil Nadu! God bless you always!_ 🤩🤩🤗🤗❤❤❤❤❤❤
Warner Bros. acquired the rights to the 1937 version just before making the 1954 version. Although it was a pre-1950 film under WB ownership, it was not part of the package of films sold to Associated Artists Productions (a.a.p.) in 1956. Ironically, two years later a.a.p. was bought by United Artists, the original distributor of the 1937 version. This version ended up entering the public domain in 1966 after WB did not renew the copyright in time.
BEAUTIFUL MOVIE WITH TRUE LIFE DIFFICULT PROBLEMS OF LIFE. THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR. HAPPY HOLIDAYS . GOD BLESS AMERICA AND MAY HE PROTECT OUR NATION AND FREEDOM. WWGOWGA NCSWIC ✝️ ✝️
E interesante de sabe que as pessoas gostem de filmes classicos e documentarios em gerais e um senalizador para nos fazermos mais e melhor sempre ? 👍👍👍👍👍🌏🌏🌏🌏🌏
Nunca assisti esse filme,apesar que gosto de clássicos , os diálogos eram poesias, nem sem comparam com os diálogos dos filmes atuais pobres em palavras, frases sem emoção nenhuma.
Janet Gaynor was more homely than pretty, and not a great actress so I’m baffled as to how she became a star. As for this movie, her character pines over movie star Norman Maine all her life, tries out his footprints at Grauman’s, goes nuts when she sees him at the H’wood Bowl, but when she finally finagles a face-to-face with him at the cocktail party, she shows zero interest to the point of rebuffing him. I don’t know if it was the writer or director who was to blame for such lame story telling.
What do you consider as a great actress? Does winning an Oscar for 3 movies count ??? Also it was a totally different era this was 1937 after all !!! And just because you do not rate her means absolutely nothing …
@@Dcs.234 I don’t gauge talent based on Oscars, which are popularity contests more than anything. If you aren’t well liked in Hellywood you won’t get awards even if you’re the most talented; conversely, if you lack talent but kiss the right behinds (so to speak) you’ll be richly rewarded. Don’t be naive.
I was born in 1945. This film is near and dear to my heart. It's the best version. It has the feeling and soul of the old Hollywood. Sat in many a darkened theatre and watched the best movies ever made on the big screen. It was magical. I lived across the street from the cinema. Would sometimes spend the entire day watching a film over and over. My mother would sometimes have to drag me out.
bless you!
😊😊
God bless!❤
Aber haben nicht bemerkt wie gemein diese " Atmosphäre " war! Ich habe in Opera gearbeitet wo auch verschiedenes passiert aber so was doch nie..Es ist furchtbar!
I love this version always have.
Still the best of the bunch. Janet Gaynor's career at Fox was built on roles like this. She gets excellent support from Fredric March, Adolphe Menjou, Andy Devine and especially May Robson. With Wild Bill Wellman directing and writing and Max Steiner's music, it is one of the best tear-jerkers. The movie's success helped pave the way for "Gone With the Wind" two years later.
"A Star is Born" is a great classic! Based on the true life story of Helen Poornima! ♥✔👍⬆😎
Hahahahaha! Fantastic Big John! I like ur sense of humour. ! 👸❤❤❤❤❤❤💃
@@helenpoornima5126😂
You're not far off the truth; The story was actually based on the careers of Greta Garbo & John Gilbert [He taught her a lot about film acting.] It is also rumoured that the failed [due to his declining career & alcoholism] marriage of Mary Pickford & Owen Moore was also sourced.
Still the best version. A lot of the scenarios in this film still ring true in 2023. The ocean scene is tragic and Fredric March is criminally underrated as an actor.
"Underrated" is criminally overused by people today just because these are STARS from bygone eras.
@@kaydee4296 tradus in romana,te rog.
Mlñ
Q❤😢 PP ña😊😊😊
Mlñ
Q❤😢 PP ña😊😊😊
One should be reminded that March was also a great Broadway actor. How many stars have won multiple Oscars AND Tony's? March did.
Excelente 👏👏👏
Amo las películas de esos años 30, 40 y 50 ❤
Me too, though I wasn't even born until 1961.
Thank you! Janet Gaynor was so beautiful
The recipient of the first Best Leading Actress Oscar. That Oscar was for silent films. But I don't think she made that many talkies.
😂😂 só consigo pensar em lady gaga hahahah esse filme é original e o outro cópia. Nada se cria tudo se cópia
There have been a few versions of this movie ..
Frederick March (R.I.P.)was a beautiful man, and a wonderful actor.
I think everybody is RIP in this one.
12/7/2023 Mais alguém vendo esse clássico lindo?
2.0 horas da madrugada.
Yo!!
Excellent movie, thank you for sharing it with us! I was captivated, don't allow the age of the movie to keep you from watching this 5-star movie. It's in color as well. Rotten Tomatoes gave it 100% and that never happens.
Она - предатель , фильм ужасный! Даже к бабушке не разу не приехала..а мужа нарочно отпустила" погулять "хотя было видно зачем он гулять пошёл..полное лицемерие и фальсита! Неужели вы совсем этого не видите!
'Gramdma' was 'Aunt Polly' in the 1938 film Tom Sawyer. That movie was made by Selznick Studios as well. The background score is so similar in both these films. I love both these films and never tire of watching them. Thank you for sharing this movie. 🙏🏻
Maravillosa película!!! GRACIAS! 💯👏👏👏🥰
Her impressions were stellar!
Je n avais pas encore vu cette version merci de m avoir permis de découvrir ce magnifique film
The original one
Que bonita película que grata sorpresa gracias por subirla ❤
Lei e molto falsa..peccato per il Marito..e poi che mondo terribile di cinema!!!.E un Film come una furba diventa famosa e buona anche usando la morte di proprio Marito, che aveva usato e buttato via anche se molto intelligente in che modo comunque lo fatto, che sembra proprio alcontrario 😮, La gente però sembra non si e accorta di niente..già!
They should have gone with Licky Vester.
?????
Judy Garland James Mason
Barbra Streisand Chris Christopherson
Wie können die Menschen so böse zu sein, ich verstehe das nicht..Böse und gemein, verstehe nur nicht warum? Unglaublich!! Wir sind doch Menschen!...
Que gran película que buenas son las de antaño ❤❤❤❤
Deus abençoe ricamente todos vcs que ler essa msg 🙏🍃🙌🍃
grandiosa Excelente pelicula me imprecioso saver como se travaja en Hollywood Norman se Enamoro Dev esa Injenua chica y la LLevo Al Estrellato fue bello ver Ese Amor De los dos desgrasiadamente el alkol fue su caida de seguir su carrera y su Esposa Fue grande Lo hermoso de esta historia que nunca se divorsiaron fue um amor Bello❤❤ grasias por compartirlo las peliczlas de los 40 50 60 Deverdad FUERON FANTASTICO❤🙏🏻👌👏👏👏👏💗💗💗
Ativei a legenda em português, amo este filme ❤
Wonderful portrayal and telling of this sadly too-real story.
Both Actors were brilliant; I especially love her personality!
The last version was a disappointment. Lady gaga.
I agree … I have like the Judy Garland one and Barbra Streisand one
I miss the few minutes of film that captured the essence of Judy Garland singing “The Man That Got Away” from the 1954 version.
Brilliant movie. Great acting that had me crying at the end.
VIVE LA FRANCE! GOD BLESS YOU ALL!! FROM ROMÂNIA! 🙏❤️😘🕊️🇲🇫🇷🇴😘🌹🌹🌹🥂🍾🌹🌹💕🌟
DZIEŃ DOBRY ❤
PRZEPIĘKNIE DZIĘKUJĘ
❤ZA BARDZO PIĘKNY FILM
NAJPIĘKNIEJ POZDRAWIAM ❤
Really great point made on how UGLY the press & propaganda mill makers are made in this movie that may be overlooked among the other points of this movie. Grandma could be looked at as a great pioneer women OR one of the worst stage mothers ever too. It's all how you look at it. Norman chose career over his health. Wife was willing to chose him & his health over career to save his life - after all they certainly had the wealth by then anyway. Interesting perspectives depending on where you are in your own life on how you look at this story.
Всем привет из Харькова ! Мирного неба !
Love Fredrick March, spellcheck.
Danke schön so wunder schöne Energie . ich möchte auch Heimkommen.💚💙💜💛
Ein schöner Film 🎥🌟Danke dafür 👏👏
This is the best color for A STAR IS BORN that I've every seen.
O filme da Lady Gaga foi baseado nesse filme.Mais o original é muito melhor.
Я в захваті від цього фільма. Актори чудові, не тількі в головних ролях, а й другого плану. Неймовірні таланти! А головна зірка дуже схожа на мою бабцю в юності. 🤗
Mon dieu quel superbe film. 💙💙💙
Lembro desse filme, assisti a mais de 20 anos e gostei muito ❤
Странно,почему то никто ищ комментрв не написал о кошмарных порядках в Голливуде тех времён.да и сейчас,наверное не лучше.Сначала ищут индивидуальность,а потом ....Чтобы выжить нужны яйца страусинные.Иначе!?Прекрасный фильм.Оригинал-всегла лучше.
She reminds me very much of Bette Davis
The granny forshadowing...she lost the man she loved more than anything but still went on.
Hadn't seen this, thank you.. BTW.. is there a way to find out what movies are coming up soon?
1) check the channel homepage for upcoming live premieres 3 days in advance.
2) Check stories for the next upcoming live stream
3) Or members only playlist for films that will eventually published
Hope that helps
@@CultCinemaClassics thank you
No cóż,nie podoba mi się jak zachowywały się kobiety w tamtych czasach.Zbyt uległe,podporządkowane męższczyznom,pełne poświęceń dla nich,słabe.To nie są takie kobiety jak w roku 2023,o nie.Dzieli nas bardzo dużo.
Then you no nothing of women and how they lived or were treated !!!! Maybe do a little research !!!! Not so long ago you were the property of your father then when you married you were the property of your husband !!!! It’s still like that in many countries !!!!
Хороший фильм, бабушка очень боевая, а дедушку значит убил какой то дикарь, индеец значит какой то
❤BRASIL🇧🇷💕💖💗💕💖💗💕💖💗💕💖💗💕💖💗
Estudei num colégio católico de freiras... e por um lado foi bom. Porém em outra, me levou a rejeitar a Deus e a biblia e caminhei na tilha da nova era, esoterismo... e quase afundei. Após anos de enganos e desvios sem consciência como universalista, Me converti e venho aprofundando e renovando minha aliança c Deus verdadeiro. E conhecer o sobre o plano de salvação, o verdadeiro sentido da cruz, os planos do inimigo de Deus.. e as escamas cada vez mais caem dos meus olhos.
Excelente!! 👏👏👏❤
One of the best movies in 1937 excellent 👍👍
WHY in these movies everybody has to complain??? GIVING ME A HEAD ACHE.
@bethlehemeisenhour5807 😅😅 🤐🤐 Ahh... complaints... so tiring indeed!
Love love love this movie!❤️
I love this movie soo much.
Terkadang sulit untuk membuat orng yg kita cintai percaya bahwa kita bisa menerima dia walau apa pun.
😭
Tout à fait vrai. Terima kasih for this thought.
Моя мама родилась в конце 1938 года. Дай ей Бог здоровья! Боже, как это было давно! Я тоже уже давнишняя. 😂
Стилист полина вахитова в своем блоге обсуждает девушку, внешность которой довольно близка монро
Twitcheye, from u can't take it with u
Gréât lesson in this film how this man take care of her and after the death. The place on the road seem’s good luck 👍🏻🍀 it’s for her before she now him . All the life was right!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌍
Danke Dass das diese FILM Zeigen geworden ........
Buena peli, excepto por la parte de la mala propaganda contra los nativos americanos que hizo la abuela
Good
Ótimo filme 👍
_Wow, my dearest Helen! Look to the screen: "A Star is Born"! Well, this star is 86 years old nowadays, but still shines like as on those Good Old Days! Janet Gaynor & Frederic March have glow enough to much more than a century on Cinema! That's why this old amazing movie worthwhile indeed to be seen here on CCC movie chat at live! I hope that you enjoy it, my Sweet Helen from my heart! God bless you always, Forever and Ever!_ 🤩🤩🤗🤗❤❤❤❤❤❤
Hai my dear Paulo ❤❤❤❤👸
@@helenpoornima5126 _Hi, my dearest Helen! I hope that everything is going very well with you in the Enchanted Kingdom of Tamil Nadu! God bless you always!_ 🤩🤩🤗🤗❤❤❤❤❤❤
Filmes memoráveis ❤❤❤ Eterna saudades 💋💋💋
Those old people are absolutely horrid to her!!!!
She has arrived!
Great movie 😊
Really?!?! 👸❤❤❤❤
@@helenpoornima5126❤yes
Fredric MARCH ...
VICKI LESTER! WHAT A GREAT NAME 😂😂🎉
Got children out. Where we could live snd breathe. Jealousy in this town.
Gracias me gustan mucho los clásicos
Muy linda pelicula gracias
aunt em as mattie
a great film wonderful print
Excelentes actores
Thank you for this film.
It's a fabulous classic... I never get tired of watching it!
Звезда эта фальшивая, раз муж убился.
Warner Bros. acquired the rights to the 1937 version just before making the 1954 version.
Although it was a pre-1950 film under WB ownership, it was not part of the package of films sold to Associated Artists Productions (a.a.p.) in 1956. Ironically, two years later a.a.p. was bought by United Artists, the original distributor of the 1937 version. This version ended up entering the public domain in 1966 after WB did not renew the copyright in time.
Найкращі фільми які дивиться весь світ виготовлені у Голлівуді.Вічна історія кохання.
@user-rv7md5vs5b Так рады, что вам понравилось! Продолжайте смотреть и наслаждаться CCC! Ура!
Beautiful lady !❤❤❤❤❤
Gee, Davey..."😅
@@mikesilva3868 👸❤❤❤
Questo film lo dedico al canale di Mediaset "Rete 4"
I love love more classic love story movie❤❤❤
No, I'm in love.
Perfect Movie Amazing Film
I'm trying to watch this version but it's just not the 1976 movie version. And I'm a 30's-40's movie fan.
Great movie
BEAUTIFUL MOVIE WITH TRUE LIFE DIFFICULT PROBLEMS OF LIFE. THANK YOU AND GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR. HAPPY HOLIDAYS . GOD BLESS AMERICA AND MAY HE PROTECT OUR NATION AND FREEDOM. WWGOWGA NCSWIC ✝️ ✝️
We re not a towns pincushion.
Si pero nadie la ve
Excelente pelicula !
Grazie per questo bellissimo film
Whoever did the subtitles in this film should listen better. They’re very messed up!
That's why I got my year at LSSU. Alpena went into tripple overtime to drag me down.
E interesante de sabe que as pessoas gostem de filmes classicos e documentarios em gerais e um senalizador para nos fazermos mais e melhor sempre ? 👍👍👍👍👍🌏🌏🌏🌏🌏
This is still the best version.
Maldita adiccion al alcohol!!!!!!!!
@user-mt1nq1mm2n 😬 Maldita, si...
Nunca assisti esse filme,apesar que gosto de clássicos , os diálogos eram poesias, nem sem comparam com os diálogos dos filmes atuais pobres em palavras, frases sem emoção nenhuma.
Janet Gaynor was more homely than pretty, and not a great actress so I’m baffled as to how she became a star. As for this movie, her character pines over movie star Norman Maine all her life, tries out his footprints at Grauman’s, goes nuts when she sees him at the H’wood Bowl, but when she finally finagles a face-to-face with him at the cocktail party, she shows zero interest to the point of rebuffing him. I don’t know if it was the writer or director who was to blame for such lame story telling.
What do you consider as a great actress? Does winning an Oscar for 3 movies count ??? Also it was a totally different era this was 1937 after all !!! And just because you do not rate her means absolutely nothing …
@@Dcs.234
I don’t gauge talent based on Oscars, which are popularity contests more than anything. If you aren’t well liked in Hellywood you won’t get awards even if you’re the most talented; conversely, if you lack talent but kiss the right behinds (so to speak) you’ll be richly rewarded. Don’t be naive.
You're not much of a movie critic.
This was an excellent performance. How can you call this woman homely? What a weird thing to say.
Muito obrigado...Parabens...
Preciosa película
No match for the class of James Mason unfortunately. Maine made to be rather a lout in this version.
Creepshow sent me.
🙋🏻♀️💯👏👏👏👏😪❤️