Our apologies for the audio quality with this episode. We discovered the technical issue, took down the video and reloaded it with whatever correction was possible. It was a mess we failed to control. We will be more careful going ahead..thanks for your patience…Shekhar
SG, the audio quality is okay we can always increase our own devices volume. Thank you for clarification. PS - Can we have a cut the clutter on UPSC coaching issues in Delhi
I appreciate the effort you have made. Couple of pointers if you wouldn't mind indulging me; - The volume is generally low on all the videos you guys post. I wouldn't know the exact reason behind it, could be the distance of the mike from source or the mike that you guys are using. If you wanted to use another type of mike and check the difference, it might help. - The sound echo in this video is quite bad, and it is generally decent in one person videos that you guys post. Maybe try using the same studio or the same setup for discussion pieces too. - Love the detailed analysis of things you guys do. If possible, link the sources you mention in the description. Really great source of information you guys have. Please keep up the good work. 😊
Why is Rahul and Akhilesh offended when Rahul’s religion/caste is asked; whereas they want to do caste census and ask the same question of every citizen
@@xxyz2023 Understand your perspective. But people who want to talk this in public can’t be secretive of their own religion/caste. The purposes of INDI is to divide Hindus for their votes. They have no intentions beyond it. It’s all lip service like the ‘garibi hatao’ campaign
Both these two jokers are offended when they are asked to declare their caste in public. But advocate CASTE CENSUS NATION WIDE. IF THEY ARE INTERESTED IN CASTE UPLIFTMENT THEY SHOULD MAKE THE DALIITS BACKWARD CASTES AND MINORITIES IN CHIEF POSTS IN THEIR PARTY LEADERSHIP AND MAKE THEM AS HEAD OF THEIR OWN PARTIES AND SET AN EXAMPLE AND ADVISE OTHERS TO FOLLOW. BUT THEY CLING TO THEIR LEADERSHIP IN THEIR OWN PARTIES. HYPOCRISY AT THE HIGHEST. BJP EXPOSED THIS. THIS IS AN IRRITANT TO THEM TO LUTYENS LIKE THESES PEOPLE.
@@xxyz2023A Person who lives in that area conducts a survey and will get to know your caste and religion. How are you sure that others on that team do not have access to the data the survey person has collected? Does it mean the entire team has easy access to my caste religion data? The local ruling party corporator is going to keep copies of those surveys. How is that even called a secret survey?
Whatever happens, legal MSP should never be given. It will destroy the finances of the country. Crop diversification must encouraged as much as possible. More avenues to sell, and improved storage should be created, which is what the reforms were about. The reform were deliberately opposed, to put blame on BJP, as it was forced to do export bans, to protect middle class consumers, while hurting farmers whose votes were lost in Maharashtra.
Say the same when loans of major industrialists is written off // you have a problem with MSP, work 2 hours in the field and see how it feels // or better go and grow your own 🥦🥕🌽 veggies..
@@faradmodi9197 First, learn difference between write-off and waive-off, and then talk. In write-off banks got money to save them. Not Corporates. They still had to pay the loans, and recovery done under IBC, by selling their assets. And please ask who gave the loans, in the first place. UPA did, and kept hiding them. MSP is wrong policy. Causing wastage.
@@rajx7120 - make a list of companies since 2004 and show much was recovered by selling their assets against what they owed.. Easy to pass generic statements. And the money which bank got is our hard earned tax money, not from anyones personal account..
I like the direction Indian democracy is headed...i had almost lost faith...what a fierce battle. I don't remember the last time I enjoyed the parliament session so much.... but definitely room for improvement..
DiK Sings for BJ Party 😂.. Malviya or Joshi (media calls them sources) have told them bedroom details of Gandhis.😂 If not for ECI adding 5 crore votes BJP would have been at less than 180 seats. DK Sings got it wrong in ELECTION & now
During upa time Capex increased from 90000cr to 2lakh crore. But we also should remember, the inflation is much higher during upa, which makes this so called increase is actually a decrease when adjusted to inflation.
UPA GAVE GDP GROWTH, JOBS GROWTH & RURAL INCOME GROWTH. BJP GAVE SLOWER GDP GROWTH, FAKE JOB GROWTH CLAIMS & GROWING INCOME INEQUALITY. EVEN ON THE INFRA FRONT, LUXURY TRAINS FOR THE RICH ARE TAKING AWAY ALL THE BUDGETARY ALLOCATIONS, LEAVING THE GENERAL BOGEYS DILAPIDATED & OVERCROWDED. AIRPORTS FOR THE RICH ARE TAKING AWAY ALL THE MONEY & LEAVING SOCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE LIKE HOSPITALS & SCHOOLS FOR THE POOR IN SHAKY CONDITIONS.
@Harsh-rf9k then add to it the unemployment rate. And you will see inflation balancing out. If the increase in income is equal or greater than the increase in inflation, then it becomes much easier to understand how during UPA people would have still afforded inflation.
India is an anarchy where people vote every 5 years to choose who will be at the top to be the lesser evil at the center, state and local government. This is the reason both local and overseas businesses don't invest to the extent that a country of India's potential deserves. It should be characterized as an anarchy because the simplest business dispute - say a bounced cheque, violating the terms of a contract takes years to resolve. The law and order and justice system is so utterly broken. We cannot take care of such routine stuff like China, because we are supposedly a democracy, and we cannot resolve them like Europe/South Korea/Taiwan/Japan, because in reality India is an Anarchy. And the problems have to be solved at the State and Municipal level, so there's no quick fix solution that any government at the center can apply. The political class, the bureaucracy, the law and order mafia, and the established business class benefit from this anarchy, so there's no incentive to change. The voting public is not demanding such changes either. The Punjabis/Sikhs are smart, they are voting with their feet to leave for Canada or wherever else it makes sense to
Punjabis have screwed the nation by protesting the farm laws. The 3rd generation ot Modi govt should focus on bring justice to door. Grow the social security net to include medical care for old especially considering the taxes are so high. Also reduce burden of education
@@postwala2667I don't get the anti Punjabi hatred. They are one of the most prosperous regions in the country and they contribute more than they take. Blame the centre for pushing through laws with no debate and resulting in the protestors being called khalistanis.
Horrible audio. Don't you guys do any sound test? Please stop taking the audience for granted. I was one of the earliest member but didn't renew the membership due to this indifference towards your audience.
Don't understand the point of Shekar Gupta and DK Singh repeating the whataboutery (which BJP is known for) instead of questioning the budgetary allocations of the ruling party and the growth in capex at the cost of mnrega allocations and other important social programs
Apart from audio quality this kind of episodes r good to watch specially when shekhar ji and dk talk about indian politics, always treat to watch and listen
This format is great -- DK SIngh is very dynamic pragmatic and unbiased as always -- He analyses always to the point .. This format with Seniors where you can get perspective of what happened in 1991 liberalization , Bombay Club etc.. and DK Singh latest fine analysis -- This is beautiful combination -- Kindly continue with this format -- Technical issue of mic can be sorted out by your team .. Thanks a lot
@@archiem9926 I wish opposition were talking of enterpreneurship. They are focused on caste census and reservations in private sector. Basically, when somebody becomes an enterpreneur, he must hire from specific castes, and not on basis of skills he requires.
@@rajx7120No one is saying that and no one is going to implement reservations in private sector. You should learn first how Big tent left parties like Congress function within Congress's bit tent you have parties like CPI and Bhim Army who are extreme left then you have SP and Congress itself all of this make the whole INDIA alliance position moderate on reservation.
@@DataCrusade1999 And what use is caste census? What will it be used for? I don't think the left has any good ideas. I think we need to focus on mandatory school education to all, which is responsibility of states. More manufacturing jobs. Energy independence to save money for freebies. One idea, I just got is, give some reservations to people who have worked in blue-collar infrastructure jobs, for 5-6 years, to help them move up the value chain.
N R Narayana Murthy cautioned against using grandiose terms like "hub" and "global leader" prematurely. "China has already become the factory of the world. Around 90% of things in supermarkets and home depots in other countries are manufactured in China. They have six times the GDP of India. It is too audacious of us to say India will become the manufacturing hub," he stated. This stark comparison underscores the significant gap India needs to bridge to rival China's manufacturing capabilities.
TATA Motors was founded in 1945 and Hyundai Motors in 1967. But today Hyundai motors is a world class brand and almost everyone in the western developed world knows about Hyundai. However baring some middle east and India's neighborhood countries, nobody knows about TATA vehicles. If this is how Indian companies are going to compete - then God save The Great Indian Dream! Now don't come with your Jaguar theory. It is NOT a homegrown TATA product. They just purchased it.
Our people lack research and development.and also marketing.Govt s of both khangress and BJP failed to integrate Educational institutes and commercial industries
Yes. But remember Tatas had to work in the extreme socialist, rather, communist environment for all these years. Only now (let me be fair, since 1991) they have been getting the freedom to do their business freely. Hyundai got the opportunity right from the start. Besides, when there is still a huge local market why should the Tatas go outside at this juncture? Besides, they are at the top with regards to the safety aspects in cars, way beyond Hyundai. So that _is_ an achievement I would say! By the way, I own a Hyundai car and both my children Tata!😜
@@niceguy3099you guys need to shut up about Ambadani as you call them. They are not just wealth creators but _job creators_ more, can't you see that? You can tolerate Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and the like who are the real 'money hoarders' I would say. There you only consider the jobs they generate because our 'intelligent youth' get employed there and go abroad. But Ambadani are creating jobs here, in India!! And now they are also becoming MNC!!
DK Singh, how long have you been following politics?! Nirmala Sitaraman was spokesperson for BJP during UPA regime and I have heard her speak in person. The clarity of her expressions and her sharpness is something I held my breath. The Print needs to get a better political editor.😊
As if you keep selling and buying propertoes every day. There are ao many people in india that are left behind. It’s our reaponsibility. Nobody is takkng ur money to swiss bank anymore
I think we Indians should appreciate the fact that the Ambani wedding happened in India. Look at how much employment and revenue that wedding created. Look at how many eyeballs it grabbed throughout the world as world leaders and world artists came to perform or attend. Look at the amount of soft power it increased for India. We should encourage all our billionaires to celebrate their weddings the same way in India instead of making a devil out of Mukesh Ambani and guilt tripping him for doing so.
I like not only this format but also the more neutral comments of you both (these days). It was a fair and objective discussion. Pl keep more of these coming the same way. Thanks
India's $ 50+ Billion USD(& Rising fast) Trade Surplus with The US & EU is Totally in Merchandise sectors and If you include services, It will rise to 180+ Billion USD and Mr Gupta doesn't know that and Indian Airlines currently have more than 1700+ Planes on order NOT 1100 as Mr Gupta said and India's nominal per capita is 100% higher or double that of paxtan and not 35%
So the FM thinks that having concentration of wealth in 2 families is the spirit of entrepreneurship? I think the opposition leader mentioned small to midscale business owners and their plight in his speech. How about privatisation???How has that gone for the current govt? During the speech she has played BJP as a victim too....what about when they suspend MPs during sessions and divide the country based on religion, and what they eat and what their names are? It must be a case of selective amnesia.
You and opposition are cherry picking. So many new unicorns and billionaires created in the last 5 years. First woman billionaire Falguni Nayyar of Nayka. Don't get tunnel vision from opposition propaganda.
Education is primarily a state subject. Have you met your MLA and asked how much he spends on education within his constituency? Do you even know that data? Misplaced activism?
Spending is not the issue in Education. Just throwing money at the problem doesn't solve it. System is the issue. Examinations and continuous evaluation of outcomes, teacher quality, research and development in academia. Moreover, state Govts have to step up.
The format makes CTC a bit non coherent sometimes, particularly when topics are jumped horizontally, the beauty of CTC is its 'one at a time' vertical depth closure on topics. Just a point to consider
The Print, has its political affiliation clearly worn on its sleeve, whatever Gupta's pretension. BJP is not fighting back. It is lashing out in frustration.
Great video sir, but sorry to say crappy audio, I like to hear your voice but this was very frustrating like trying to attend a virtual meeting in silk board signal in Bengaluru. Thanks again sir, keep up the great work!
Extremely beautiful and insightful discussions, audio needs a bit of attention and video grab changes too frequently. Sitting in different time zones, it’s so healthy to listen out to you guys. The Print is really becoming a major mark in news analysis.
Yes, I do like. But how it is that i can hear Shekhar so clearly but not so DK. Indeed, I like DK's most presentations, his probing analysis, his insight but sometimes regret missing out a few important points that he makes. Today, his voice was echoing on occasions- dont know if it appears to me ONLY because of my advancing age. I didn't find Shekhar's voice echoing but. Overall, I love "The Print".
Sinister campaign by DK to malign Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman Madam didn’t defend Adanis or Ambanis. she merely spoke about Adanis being given by a port to manage (by Congress state government). DK’s propensity to subtly run down NDA is despicable
Chinese investment should not be treated as a pariah. India has suffered significantly in the past by adopting an anti-American stance for an extended period. Although we have disputes with China, we cannot ignore that it is the second-largest economy and significantly larger than India’s economy. The Chinese have mastered manufacturing, a skill we still need to develop. The U.S. policy of “China plus one” and India’s openness to Chinese manufacturing and investment are crucial to overcoming the manufacturing challenges we face. One positive aspect of this budget is the government’s acknowledgment of our need for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), employment opportunities for our youth, and investment in manufacturing from both China and the U.S. Recognizing and diagnosing our problems is the first step toward resolving them. We are on the right track this time.
There’s no meaning in making high quality content if the audio is difficult to hear. There is a lot of echoing. Please make a cushioned room and try recording there.
Indian private sector is still to get out of the conservative socialist hangover inspite of the government giving all assurances I think. With the turncoat opposition pilloring the government on all issues that itself had rejected and supporting all kinds of agitations and protests (farmers, CAA, etc) and playing caste politics, it is scared.
Legal MSP is good with terms and conditions. Ex. Quality of crops must be good in line with international standard. Govt will not buy bad produce on msp. Ensure farmers use environment friendly fertlisers and pesticides. Bring farmers with more than 20 acres under tax regime.
Hi sir, Thank you for the episode. Its been a long time since I commented, but please be rest assured that I watch every edition of CTC. Below is my feedback - Firstly, your team needs to work on the mike. Your mike was just acceptable, but DK sir's was not. Secondly, seeing that we are getting a good parliamentary session after so long, I would like something more than a quick summary of the points made by both sides. So, you both telling us about the subtle changes in the approach of the government towards various issues is a good step in that direction. I would like you to go a couple of steps further. Make it point by point. Tell us that this is what the opposition said. In response, this is what the government replied. Now, comes the most important part. Then, tell us what your opinion is with regards to both the points. I know in CTC you do not state you opinion and stick to facts, but as you are so point out, numbers can lie (absolutes vs percentages) and often do not tell the whole story. Tell us how valid the points made by both the sides were and where either side might not have told us the whole story or tried to misconstrue the facts. If there is no clear winner on that point or if the problem/solution is way too complex to be discussed in just an hour or so, admit and state so. I personally hate it when I would see on tv that a politician would state a fact and then another one would say that that is a complete lie and the real figures were these. I would always wonder if it should not have been the anchor's job to step in and tell us, the viewers, what the real story was and which politician was telling the truth. Regards,
Shekhar ji, this format is fine occasionally. But why are you missing in action in Headlines ke peechhe...? DK is doing well but he is like Gautam Gambhir, who will only bat on political turf and can win man of the match in that too. On the other hand Shekhar Gupta ji is like Kapil Dev, the Allrounder who will take questions on Politics, International affairs, defence, music, cricket, etc. But the most important is the old time stories and mention of Hariyana, ur NE days stories, Saddam, AF-PAK stories ,etc.
Guys work on the mike. Audio is very bad and inconsistent video to video.
Good work otherwise
It's a wonder they haven't noticed this repeated comment on so many videos over the years
You're right.
😅😅 4:39 😅😅😅
I am really amazed. How hard is it to buy proper microphones ?
They might need a studio
Our apologies for the audio quality with this episode. We discovered the technical issue, took down the video and reloaded it with whatever correction was possible. It was a mess we failed to control. We will be more careful going ahead..thanks for your patience…Shekhar
SG, the audio quality is okay we can always increase our own devices volume. Thank you for clarification.
PS - Can we have a cut the clutter on UPSC coaching issues in Delhi
I appreciate the effort you have made. Couple of pointers if you wouldn't mind indulging me;
- The volume is generally low on all the videos you guys post. I wouldn't know the exact reason behind it, could be the distance of the mike from source or the mike that you guys are using. If you wanted to use another type of mike and check the difference, it might help.
- The sound echo in this video is quite bad, and it is generally decent in one person videos that you guys post. Maybe try using the same studio or the same setup for discussion pieces too.
- Love the detailed analysis of things you guys do. If possible, link the sources you mention in the description.
Really great source of information you guys have. Please keep up the good work. 😊
Why is Rahul and Akhilesh offended when Rahul’s religion/caste is asked; whereas they want to do caste census and ask the same question of every citizen
@@xxyz2023 Understand your perspective. But people who want to talk this in public can’t be secretive of their own religion/caste.
The purposes of INDI is to divide Hindus for their votes. They have no intentions beyond it. It’s all lip service like the ‘garibi hatao’ campaign
Both these two jokers are offended when they are asked to declare their caste in public. But advocate CASTE CENSUS NATION WIDE. IF THEY ARE INTERESTED IN CASTE UPLIFTMENT THEY SHOULD MAKE THE DALIITS BACKWARD CASTES AND MINORITIES IN CHIEF POSTS IN THEIR PARTY LEADERSHIP AND MAKE THEM AS HEAD OF THEIR OWN PARTIES AND SET AN EXAMPLE AND ADVISE OTHERS TO FOLLOW. BUT THEY CLING TO THEIR LEADERSHIP IN THEIR OWN PARTIES. HYPOCRISY AT THE HIGHEST. BJP EXPOSED THIS. THIS IS AN IRRITANT TO THEM TO LUTYENS LIKE THESES PEOPLE.
What a BILLION dollar question 😂👍🏻👌🏻
Exactly
@@xxyz2023A Person who lives in that area conducts a survey and will get to know your caste and religion. How are you sure that others on that team do not have access to the data the survey person has collected? Does it mean the entire team has easy access to my caste religion data? The local ruling party corporator is going to keep copies of those surveys. How is that even called a secret survey?
Whatever happens, legal MSP should never be given. It will destroy the finances of the country.
Crop diversification must encouraged as much as possible. More avenues to sell, and improved storage should be created, which is what the reforms were about.
The reform were deliberately opposed, to put blame on BJP, as it was forced to do export bans, to protect middle class consumers, while hurting farmers whose votes were lost in Maharashtra.
Say the same when loans of major industrialists is written off // you have a problem with MSP, work 2 hours in the field and see how it feels // or better go and grow your own 🥦🥕🌽 veggies..
@@faradmodi9197 First, learn difference between write-off and waive-off, and then talk. In write-off banks got money to save them. Not Corporates. They still had to pay the loans, and recovery done under IBC, by selling their assets. And please ask who gave the loans, in the first place. UPA did, and kept hiding them. MSP is wrong policy. Causing wastage.
@@rajx7120 True. People are falling for propaganda by some youtubers giving half baked knowledge.
@@rajx7120 - make a list of companies since 2004 and show much was recovered by selling their assets against what they owed.. Easy to pass generic statements. And the money which bank got is our hard earned tax money, not from anyones personal account..
@@rajx7120 and if reforms were soooo gooood, why was it rolled back???
Very poor audio quality; most of it is incomprehensible
I like the direction Indian democracy is headed...i had almost lost faith...what a fierce battle. I don't remember the last time I enjoyed the parliament session so much.... but definitely room for improvement..
DiK Sings for BJ Party 😂.. Malviya or Joshi (media calls them sources) have told them bedroom details of Gandhis.😂
If not for ECI adding 5 crore votes BJP would have been at less than 180 seats. DK Sings got it wrong in ELECTION & now
During upa time
Capex increased from 90000cr to 2lakh crore.
But we also should remember, the inflation is much higher during upa, which makes this so called increase is actually a decrease when adjusted to inflation.
100% inflation?
UPA GAVE GDP GROWTH, JOBS GROWTH & RURAL INCOME GROWTH.
BJP GAVE SLOWER GDP GROWTH, FAKE JOB GROWTH CLAIMS & GROWING INCOME INEQUALITY.
EVEN ON THE INFRA FRONT, LUXURY TRAINS FOR THE RICH ARE TAKING AWAY ALL THE BUDGETARY ALLOCATIONS, LEAVING THE GENERAL BOGEYS DILAPIDATED & OVERCROWDED. AIRPORTS FOR THE RICH ARE TAKING AWAY ALL THE MONEY & LEAVING SOCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE LIKE HOSPITALS & SCHOOLS FOR THE POOR IN SHAKY CONDITIONS.
AGAR BJP NE 12 KAROD ROJGAAR DE DIYA TO UNEMPLOYMENT RATE DOUBLE DIGIT KE DEHLEEZ PE KYON HAIN???
@@abdullahaftab1839 inflation rate during upa time was double digits for several years. If you compound it for 10 years, it is much higher than 100%.
@Harsh-rf9k then add to it the unemployment rate. And you will see inflation balancing out. If the increase in income is equal or greater than the increase in inflation, then it becomes much easier to understand how during UPA people would have still afforded inflation.
India is an anarchy where people vote every 5 years to choose who will be at the top to be the lesser evil at the center, state and local government. This is the reason both local and overseas businesses don't invest to the extent that a country of India's potential deserves. It should be characterized as an anarchy because the simplest business dispute - say a bounced cheque, violating the terms of a contract takes years to resolve. The law and order and justice system is so utterly broken. We cannot take care of such routine stuff like China, because we are supposedly a democracy, and we cannot resolve them like Europe/South Korea/Taiwan/Japan, because in reality India is an Anarchy. And the problems have to be solved at the State and Municipal level, so there's no quick fix solution that any government at the center can apply. The political class, the bureaucracy, the law and order mafia, and the established business class benefit from this anarchy, so there's no incentive to change. The voting public is not demanding such changes either. The Punjabis/Sikhs are smart, they are voting with their feet to leave for Canada or wherever else it makes sense to
They should vote for Mamta Baneerjee😅
Punjabis have screwed the nation by protesting the farm laws.
The 3rd generation ot Modi govt should focus on bring justice to door.
Grow the social security net to include medical care for old especially considering the taxes are so high.
Also reduce burden of education
@@postwala2667I don't get the anti Punjabi hatred. They are one of the most prosperous regions in the country and they contribute more than they take. Blame the centre for pushing through laws with no debate and resulting in the protestors being called khalistanis.
Good, hope pressure from Rahul Gandhi makes Narendra Modi take many right decisions, basically paving way for BJP victory again in 2029!
Greater victory
Please work on mic quality. Atleast we can expect good sound quality from print.
Audio quality is low , please look into this .
Horrible audio. Don't you guys do any sound test?
Please stop taking the audience for granted.
I was one of the earliest member but didn't renew the membership due to this indifference towards your audience.
*indifference
@@MichaelEdwards-gc2xx
thanks, that's what I meant, predictive text decided otherwise..😊
Audio is horrible
Don't understand the point of Shekar Gupta and DK Singh repeating the whataboutery (which BJP is known for) instead of questioning the budgetary allocations of the ruling party and the growth in capex at the cost of mnrega allocations and other important social programs
Monolog is boring
I couldn't hear beyond 5 minutes due to the audio issues. Aborting...
Apart from audio quality this kind of episodes r good to watch specially when shekhar ji and dk talk about indian politics, always treat to watch and listen
This format is great -- DK SIngh is very dynamic pragmatic and unbiased as always -- He analyses always to the point .. This format with Seniors where you can get perspective of what happened in 1991 liberalization , Bombay Club etc.. and DK Singh latest fine analysis -- This is beautiful combination -- Kindly continue with this format -- Technical issue of mic can be sorted out by your team .. Thanks a lot
There is a big difference between entrepreneurship and crony capitalism
No every developing country first undergoes chrony capitalism then capitalism then devloped
@@yashdeeppalo8170 South Korea became rich because crony capitalism helped build Samsung, LG etc called Chaebols.
@@archiem9926 I wish opposition were talking of enterpreneurship. They are focused on caste census and reservations in private sector. Basically, when somebody becomes an enterpreneur, he must hire from specific castes, and not on basis of skills he requires.
@@rajx7120No one is saying that and no one is going to implement reservations in private sector.
You should learn first how Big tent left parties like Congress function within Congress's bit tent you have parties like CPI and Bhim Army who are extreme left then you have SP and Congress itself all of this make the whole INDIA alliance position moderate on reservation.
@@DataCrusade1999 And what use is caste census? What will it be used for? I don't think the left has any good ideas. I think we need to focus on mandatory school education to all, which is responsibility of states. More manufacturing jobs. Energy independence to save money for freebies. One idea, I just got is, give some reservations to people who have worked in blue-collar infrastructure jobs, for 5-6 years, to help them move up the value chain.
Very bad audio.
N R Narayana Murthy cautioned against using grandiose terms like "hub" and "global leader" prematurely. "China has already become the factory of the world. Around 90% of things in supermarkets and home depots in other countries are manufactured in China. They have six times the GDP of India. It is too audacious of us to say India will become the manufacturing hub," he stated. This stark comparison underscores the significant gap India needs to bridge to rival China's manufacturing capabilities.
Audio very poor
Dear Print Pls invest in Good mic systems. Your discussions are very difficult to understand with surround sound :-)
Horrible audio, like hearing from a well😂
I love this format of roping in an expert for certain topics. Please continue this!
Wonderful one ❤
Some how not convinced this format. It is always the best to listen to your analogy and analysis.
Yes, I like this format. Let’s have more such conversations with senior experts.
TATA Motors was founded in 1945 and Hyundai Motors in 1967. But today Hyundai motors is a world class brand and almost everyone in the western developed world knows about Hyundai. However baring some middle east and India's neighborhood countries, nobody knows about TATA vehicles. If this is how Indian companies are going to compete - then God save The Great Indian Dream!
Now don't come with your Jaguar theory. It is NOT a homegrown TATA product. They just purchased it.
Worlds all devils know Ambadani
Tata sold its first consumer car in 1998… don’t compare apples and oranges. Our political environment until 1991 made it impossible to do any better.
Our people lack research and development.and also marketing.Govt s of both khangress and BJP failed to integrate Educational institutes and commercial industries
Yes. But remember Tatas had to work in the extreme socialist, rather, communist environment for all these years. Only now (let me be fair, since 1991) they have been getting the freedom to do their business freely. Hyundai got the opportunity right from the start.
Besides, when there is still a huge local market why should the Tatas go outside at this juncture? Besides, they are at the top with regards to the safety aspects in cars, way beyond Hyundai. So that _is_ an achievement I would say!
By the way, I own a Hyundai car and both my children Tata!😜
@@niceguy3099you guys need to shut up about Ambadani as you call them. They are not just wealth creators but _job creators_ more, can't you see that? You can tolerate Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and the like who are the real 'money hoarders' I would say. There you only consider the jobs they generate because our 'intelligent youth' get employed there and go abroad. But Ambadani are creating jobs here, in India!! And now they are also becoming MNC!!
really good discussion guys - Srini
DK Singh, how long have you been following politics?! Nirmala Sitaraman was spokesperson for BJP during UPA regime and I have heard her speak in person. The clarity of her expressions and her sharpness is something I held my breath.
The Print needs to get a better political editor.😊
The sound quality was very poor. Please be careful in future.
Yes sir, we like this format👍
Money compounding and Growth compounding are two different things !
During 2000 - 2012 you could feel the growth compounding!
Yes this format is great.
Cannot see the links suggested in the podcast
Please more of Shekhar and DK podcast type coverage of events. Great to hear two maestro of Indian politics just chatting.
Nirmala is gifted with a voluble mouth but poor knowledge of economics. Only rhetoric and deflection.
Everyone ignored the middle class again , so did the the print, which really makes me think the biased opinion of these people.
As if you keep selling and buying propertoes every day. There are ao many people in india that are left behind. It’s our reaponsibility. Nobody is takkng ur money to swiss bank anymore
I think we Indians should appreciate the fact that the Ambani wedding happened in India. Look at how much employment and revenue that wedding created. Look at how many eyeballs it grabbed throughout the world as world leaders and world artists came to perform or attend. Look at the amount of soft power it increased for India. We should encourage all our billionaires to celebrate their weddings the same way in India instead of making a devil out of Mukesh Ambani and guilt tripping him for doing so.
@@xxyz2023 Your point being?
brother, now imagine if that same money was actually given to all his employees as a bonus or over their tenure. don't get lost in the sauce
I like not only this format but also the more neutral comments of you both (these days). It was a fair and objective discussion. Pl keep more of these coming the same way. Thanks
Annoying Echo in voice. Can you guys not fix it? When 2 genuine fast bowlers are bowling the pitch should be excellent.
India's $ 50+ Billion USD(& Rising fast) Trade Surplus with The US & EU is Totally in Merchandise sectors and If you include services, It will rise to 180+ Billion USD and Mr Gupta doesn't know that and Indian Airlines currently have more than 1700+ Planes on order NOT 1100 as Mr Gupta said and India's nominal per capita is 100% higher or double that of paxtan and not 35%
This format is great. Able to hear and see your team as well. Making your team brand ambassadors of the print. All the best :)
Yes .. i liked it
Yes the format is good shekhar
love the format...
SG is now reporting that PM and FM said it is raining outside.
There is a lot of echo in the audio
I do like this format. Thank you.
Anuraag Thakur... Intellectually Bankrupt
Getting expert advise is occasionally great but for me, it has to be either Mr Gupta and Mr Singh but separately. Please keep them standalone.
So the FM thinks that having concentration of wealth in 2 families is the spirit of entrepreneurship? I think the opposition leader mentioned small to midscale business owners and their plight in his speech.
How about privatisation???How has that gone for the current govt?
During the speech she has played BJP as a victim too....what about when they suspend MPs during sessions and divide the country based on religion, and what they eat and what their names are? It must be a case of selective amnesia.
You and opposition are cherry picking. So many new unicorns and billionaires created in the last 5 years. First woman billionaire Falguni Nayyar of Nayka. Don't get tunnel vision from opposition propaganda.
But shekhar and team work on good quality mics. Your competitors are doing great here
We should have this format
Great to know that a BJP leader defended JNU.
This was a good discussion. Do have more such sessions
Good morning Sir
The budget is 48 lack crore. But only 2.5% for education.😢😢
Because education is on concurrent list but most of the allocation comes from the states
@@Sandeep-tj7qf 💯
Education is primarily a state subject. Have you met your MLA and asked how much he spends on education within his constituency? Do you even know that data? Misplaced activism?
State governments are free to spend 50% of their budget on education
Spending is not the issue in Education. Just throwing money at the problem doesn't solve it. System is the issue. Examinations and continuous evaluation of outcomes, teacher quality, research and development in academia. Moreover, state Govts have to step up.
How much of the Ambani wedding was sponsored by the Corporate tax cut that happened a few years back?
The format makes CTC a bit non coherent sometimes, particularly when topics are jumped horizontally, the beauty of CTC is its 'one at a time' vertical depth closure on topics. Just a point to consider
The Print, has its political affiliation clearly worn on its sleeve, whatever Gupta's pretension.
BJP is not fighting back. It is lashing out in frustration.
Garbage audio. We expect better quality. This is amateurish.
💕 this format
Our country is supposed to compete with the developed economies, but we are competing with our own economy of a few decades back.😮
2005-2014 is being compared to 2015-2024
Exactly. Because we had been deprived of real development till 1991. And then again between 2004 and 2014!
It's a fabulous format. Please do this more often.
Great video sir, but sorry to say crappy audio, I like to hear your voice but this was very frustrating like trying to attend a virtual meeting in silk board signal in Bengaluru. Thanks again sir, keep up the great work!
This format is good
Extremely beautiful and insightful discussions, audio needs a bit of attention and video grab changes too frequently. Sitting in different time zones, it’s so healthy to listen out to you guys. The Print is really becoming a major mark in news analysis.
Yes, I do like.
But how it is that i can hear Shekhar so clearly but not so DK. Indeed, I like DK's most presentations, his probing analysis, his insight but sometimes regret missing out a few important points that he makes. Today, his voice was echoing on occasions- dont know if it appears to me ONLY because of my advancing age. I didn't find Shekhar's voice echoing but.
Overall, I love "The Print".
I like this format
Good format. Pl continue.
Very good discussion
Sinister campaign by DK to malign Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman
Madam didn’t defend Adanis or Ambanis. she merely spoke about Adanis being given by a port to manage (by Congress state government).
DK’s propensity to subtly run down NDA is despicable
Opposition: sell everything and giving freebies is how you grow economy
Love the format. Very analytical and informative with broader context. But the audio quality is poor, especially with DK.
Chinese investment should not be treated as a pariah. India has suffered significantly in the past by adopting an anti-American stance for an extended period. Although we have disputes with China, we cannot ignore that it is the second-largest economy and significantly larger than India’s economy. The Chinese have mastered manufacturing, a skill we still need to develop. The U.S. policy of “China plus one” and India’s openness to Chinese manufacturing and investment are crucial to overcoming the manufacturing challenges we face.
One positive aspect of this budget is the government’s acknowledgment of our need for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), employment opportunities for our youth, and investment in manufacturing from both China and the U.S. Recognizing and diagnosing our problems is the first step toward resolving them. We are on the right track this time.
The print..... Audio quality is poor....DK' was sort of echoing
Dropping off....🙄
Shekhar ji, please make a ctc video on the Mullaperiyar dam issue. this issue pops up in the radar, during every heavy monsoon rains in kerala
+1 on the new format where more than one team member is part of the CTC
Great format but the audio quality could be better
Yes this format is better
There’s no meaning in making high quality content if the audio is difficult to hear. There is a lot of echoing. Please make a cushioned room and try recording there.
Indian private sector is still to get out of the conservative socialist hangover inspite of the government giving all assurances I think. With the turncoat opposition pilloring the government on all issues that itself had rejected and supporting all kinds of agitations and protests (farmers, CAA, etc) and playing caste politics, it is scared.
Shekhar Sir Am Regular Viewer from Past 4 Years, Today's Sound Quality is a bit not Tuned
Legal MSP is good with terms and conditions. Ex. Quality of crops must be good in line with international standard. Govt will not buy bad produce on msp. Ensure farmers use environment friendly fertlisers and pesticides. Bring farmers with more than 20 acres under tax regime.
Can you pls fix mike. Its very difficult to understand.
Nice episode, i liked it.
But audio issue
Your mike was not turned on, very irritating to hear
Hi sir,
Thank you for the episode. Its been a long time since I commented, but please be rest assured that I watch every edition of CTC. Below is my feedback -
Firstly, your team needs to work on the mike. Your mike was just acceptable, but DK sir's was not.
Secondly, seeing that we are getting a good parliamentary session after so long, I would like something more than a quick summary of the points made by both sides. So, you both telling us about the subtle changes in the approach of the government towards various issues is a good step in that direction. I would like you to go a couple of steps further. Make it point by point. Tell us that this is what the opposition said. In response, this is what the government replied. Now, comes the most important part. Then, tell us what your opinion is with regards to both the points. I know in CTC you do not state you opinion and stick to facts, but as you are so point out, numbers can lie (absolutes vs percentages) and often do not tell the whole story. Tell us how valid the points made by both the sides were and where either side might not have told us the whole story or tried to misconstrue the facts. If there is no clear winner on that point or if the problem/solution is way too complex to be discussed in just an hour or so, admit and state so.
I personally hate it when I would see on tv that a politician would state a fact and then another one would say that that is a complete lie and the real figures were these. I would always wonder if it should not have been the anchor's job to step in and tell us, the viewers, what the real story was and which politician was telling the truth.
Regards,
I just hope this political battle leads to better infrastructure and public services rather than appeasement and freebies and massive fiscal deficits.
No one is attacking entrepreneurship. So it need not be defended by NS. So the praise of SG is misplaced, if unintended.
We like this format, but please invest on good acoustics
You have to do something to do a better audio level . We are hardly able to hear what you two discussed. Audio is very poor.
Mic quality is very bad in this episode.
good discussion but shekhar voice volume was less
Not an acceptable audio from a media platform.
Shekhar ji, this format is fine occasionally. But why are you missing in action in Headlines ke peechhe...?
DK is doing well but he is like Gautam Gambhir, who will only bat on political turf and can win man of the match in that too.
On the other hand Shekhar Gupta ji is like Kapil Dev, the Allrounder who will take questions on Politics, International affairs, defence, music, cricket, etc.
But the most important is the old time stories and mention of Hariyana, ur NE days stories, Saddam, AF-PAK stories ,etc.
Audio is absolutely terrible.. not expected from The Print
good format if only allow DK to speak