Ceasefire or Not, Palestinian Liberation is Inevitable w/ Ali Abunimah

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 248

  • @mirandaaskew
    @mirandaaskew 21 годину тому +74

    In the midst of all this horror, I feel like I just spent time with the most intelligent and compassionate friends. Thank you both.

  • @claudemagnan4043
    @claudemagnan4043 День тому +66

    Thank you Rania and Ali.

  • @monakalamouni2881
    @monakalamouni2881 18 годин тому +21

    Thank you for a great discussion and your tireless work and commitment. Free free Palestine 🇵🇸🇱🇧

  • @Nina-q9y4p
    @Nina-q9y4p 23 години тому +30

    Rania and Ali are phenomenal journalists. I trust them more than most journalists out there.

  • @rosedandaro1761
    @rosedandaro1761 23 години тому +37

    Thanks for this amazing interview! Free Palestine!

  • @PerceivedREALITY999
    @PerceivedREALITY999 19 годин тому +41

    Thank you Rania and Ali. Independent journalists with journalistic integrity are the heroes of our time.

    • @bluestar6879
      @bluestar6879 12 годин тому

      "independent journalists" = far leftist, reytaarded cuckoos who live in a parallel universe.

  • @hg5054
    @hg5054 День тому +55

    Thanks for this important discussion Rania & Ali. Solidarity with the Resistance. Free Palestine. End the occupation. Stop the genocide. Justice will prevail! 🙏🏽💕✊🏽🇵🇸 🇱🇧 🇮🇳 🇾🇪 🇸🇾

    • @farsheedyas697
      @farsheedyas697 17 годин тому

      Without 🇮🇷, there would have been no resistance.

  • @orooropaa1846
    @orooropaa1846 День тому +36

    Thank you, Rania & Ali, for sharing your analysis

    • @ITStudion
      @ITStudion День тому +7

      Absolutely
      Palastine will be FREE
      Palastine will be FREE
      Palastine will be FREE

  • @DanaDoe
    @DanaDoe 23 години тому +23

    Ali Abuminah! Thankyou one of few people who have kept me sanely insane in this society and time 🙏

  • @zebedasharif
    @zebedasharif День тому +44

    We pray for peace for Palestine. Lebanon abd Aameen and that the genocide stops Aameen

    • @Mohammed-f8h9j
      @Mohammed-f8h9j 21 хвилина тому

      There is no Palestine. I’m a Muslim and I admit this. Why do we perpetuate this lie without ever taking responsibility for our actions??

  • @irjajohansson4650
    @irjajohansson4650 День тому +32

    Thank you for your bright dialougue - always you present light for humanity. Irja - Denmark.

  • @EileenHildaWright
    @EileenHildaWright День тому +32

    Great thank you both for your incredible journalism ❤❤

  • @MikeElissen
    @MikeElissen День тому +37

    The ignoring of the Genocide we support by Western people in general is shameful and disgusting. ´Human Rights´...Western people should NEVER bring that issue to any table again. Free Palestine!

    • @robertdiscipio243
      @robertdiscipio243 День тому

      Western countries. ?Geopolitical analyst Dario Fabbri said The Americans flatter us when they call us allies .We are satellites."The neocon regime bullies their vassal states and the mainstream media in all these countries obfuscates what both the US and Israel does.They abide by their godfathers dictates.Italy doesn't have any enemies yet it has 47 bases that serve the empire.Are they there to protect Italy from Switzerland Tunisia or San Marino?

    • @IlMondoRosa
      @IlMondoRosa 22 години тому +6

      So true

    • @robertdiscipio243
      @robertdiscipio243 22 години тому

      @MikeElissen I don't think western people are on board with the policies of the neocon regimes in London and DC but they are systematically brainwashed by the corporate media which obfuscates what is going on.When students in Italy are beaten and gassed by the police and musicians denounced at the San Remo festival for daring to call an end to genocide the ruling elites are responsible for their enforced hypocrisy.If the people more generally knew the truth they would be incensed.The oligarchies are total hypocrites and pontificate about freedom and human rights but only if they subscribe to Washington mandates.

    • @robertdiscipio243
      @robertdiscipio243 17 годин тому

      @MikeElissen The imperialists in London and Washington are the ones pontificating about human rights and freedom and demand the rest of the world to acquiesce to their agenda but the whole world is finally waking up to their deceit thanks to people like Rania Ali Francesca Albanese Alessandro di Battista Max Blumenthal Jeffrey Sachs who are exposing the corporate propagandists.

    • @urbansetter1
      @urbansetter1 16 годин тому +2

      I agree

  • @rodcarlson9505
    @rodcarlson9505 18 годин тому +13

    Thank you both REAL NEWS

  • @joelquaintance9025
    @joelquaintance9025 21 годину тому +13

    Excellent discussion. Both of you are a blessing to everyone seeking THE TRUTH ABOUT GAZA.

  • @crackthefoundation_
    @crackthefoundation_ 22 години тому +12

    Thank you Rania and Ali.
    That Madeline Albright clip was absolutely wild..
    🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸

  • @Officiallyamber-rose
    @Officiallyamber-rose День тому +32

    Two of my very favorite people. Thank you.❤️🤍💚🖤❤️🤍💚🖤

    • @MalcolmMacPhail-mt1gt
      @MalcolmMacPhail-mt1gt День тому +5

      My too. Two of the best independent journalists around.

    • @ITStudion
      @ITStudion День тому +5

      💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯

  • @kittysawtelle5552
    @kittysawtelle5552 День тому +21

    I loooove always to hear Mr Ali..thx u

  • @barbiedesoto7054
    @barbiedesoto7054 16 годин тому +12

    “The people of Lebanon gave more than anyone else in the world, and that cannot be repaid.” 😭 beautiful.

  • @monicaarmanino7013
    @monicaarmanino7013 23 години тому +18

    It's like the Great Oz's curtains being drawn back. I love it. Ceasefire NOW, and Free Palestine!

  • @Christy-et8ib
    @Christy-et8ib День тому +17

    Excellent interview thank you for this

  • @TheDharma2009
    @TheDharma2009 16 годин тому +12

    Thank you both. Your comments & perceptions are much appreciated.

  • @mydog8ball
    @mydog8ball День тому +39

    ❤ free Palestine ❤

    • @ITStudion
      @ITStudion День тому +6

      Absolutely.
      Palastine will be FREE
      Palastine will be FREE
      Palastine will be FREE

    • @bluestar6879
      @bluestar6879 12 годин тому

      @@ITStudion
      .................................of Jihadis.

  • @hnnssy
    @hnnssy 21 годину тому +9

    You are all great. Thank you for this discussion.

  • @jilj1948
    @jilj1948 17 годин тому +4

    A huge thanks to both of you for all you do to inform the un-informed..
    May God bless, greetings from Danmark also wishing you a happy new year.

  • @Sylvia-u7g
    @Sylvia-u7g 23 години тому +22

    One state....................Palestine

  • @fariyaali2445
    @fariyaali2445 6 годин тому +2

    Thank you Raina and Ali this interview was like a breath of fresh air

  • @AliMalikAsthar-z1q
    @AliMalikAsthar-z1q День тому +16

    30 min. Ali, you are a gem.

  • @ms9771
    @ms9771 16 годин тому +3

    Honest report, thank you

  • @lewisstreet7266
    @lewisstreet7266 4 години тому +2

    Rania you are great and thanks for having Ali in your Chanel: he is awesome!

  • @pawancheekmarican320
    @pawancheekmarican320 7 годин тому +2

    great interview, rania and ali.

  • @mamdougindo
    @mamdougindo День тому +10

    Thanks!

  • @faroukyoussef6190
    @faroukyoussef6190 День тому +6

    43:06 hi emily xD thank u guys for your work ❤

  • @Joh61241
    @Joh61241 День тому +11

    Thank you

  • @faridakhalifa1939
    @faridakhalifa1939 17 годин тому +3

    Well spoken.

  • @jamesw.6207
    @jamesw.6207 17 годин тому +4

    I'm currently reading "The Gun and the Olive Branch" by David Hirst based on a recommendation by Electronic Intifada. Thank you Ali and company.

  • @harbinger6562
    @harbinger6562 14 годин тому +2

    Good evening Rania and Ali ♥️🇱🇧🇩🇪🇺🇲🌍🌌🦾😇🌹👋🕊️

  • @nathanSWP
    @nathanSWP 23 години тому +9

    Thank you from Wales!

  • @jx7695
    @jx7695 День тому +14

    I’m from turkey where my dads from. Thank you for introducing me to the word neoottomanism

  • @lucyhenery2356
    @lucyhenery2356 7 годин тому +2

    Well said Ali

  • @MarionThi
    @MarionThi 18 годин тому +6

    Dankeschön aus Berlin für dieses Gespäch 🙏🏼
    🇵🇸⚖️🕊☮️✊

  • @toorankhaksari5061
    @toorankhaksari5061 21 годину тому +7

    I am always amazed by your wonderful analysis.
    Thank you both for being there Palestinians, Syrians and all those who are suffering from Amperialism hegemony .
    🙏🙏🙏👏👏👏👍👍👍

  • @OneDeadBird1
    @OneDeadBird1 23 години тому +6

    Important conversation, thank you.

  • @MrMzand
    @MrMzand 11 годин тому +2

    Love you both my two favourites.

  • @GraemeLambert-r6u
    @GraemeLambert-r6u 17 годин тому +4

    Thankyou both bless you ❤

  • @ShaneMuckian
    @ShaneMuckian 11 годин тому +2

    Much love and respect from Ireland, man I would love to have a pint and chat with you both.

  • @MichaelHarding-b9w
    @MichaelHarding-b9w 12 годин тому +2

    Rania &Ali, i thank you both,all the time everytime,Free Palestine

  • @mschickie007
    @mschickie007 День тому +15

    Hey lady ! Free Palestine ! Free the 🌍🌎from Zion is m!

  • @jameeltayyeb584
    @jameeltayyeb584 20 годин тому +3

    Awesome interview. Always enjoy listening to both of you speak.

  • @ananda-b3u
    @ananda-b3u 18 годин тому +4

    Hopes are high 🤞🤞🤞 Thank you Ali and Rania. Looking forward to this week’s ei livestream

  • @taranehahmadi-parker1412
    @taranehahmadi-parker1412 6 годин тому +1

    Thanks

  • @taranehahmadi-parker1412
    @taranehahmadi-parker1412 6 годин тому +1

    Thank you 🙏🏽 for informative discussion 🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️😭🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉

  • @mothompson3437
    @mothompson3437 День тому +7

    A surgeons who has returned to uk from Gaza has said that children are running into vats of bombing water In order to die

    • @mothompson3437
      @mothompson3437 День тому +4

      Boiling water

    • @deedaagenie
      @deedaagenie 21 годину тому +1

      Oh no😱 that's beyond horrific 😢😢 🕊️ 🕊️

    • @evelyncraig7243
      @evelyncraig7243 21 годину тому

      What's Bombing water

    • @evelyncraig7243
      @evelyncraig7243 20 годин тому +2

      How shameful that this was allowed .These poor kids are going to be traumatised for years .West never learns this is how resistance grows

  • @urbansetter1
    @urbansetter1 16 годин тому +5

    From the US im sorry what America does to the Middle East

  • @queenofnothing78
    @queenofnothing78 13 годин тому +4

    Ireland, Colombia, at least they kicked out Israel embassies.Colombia cut off the coal to Israel.

  • @0722zeppa
    @0722zeppa 10 годин тому +3

    Persistence for resistance!
    New merch, Rania! I’d buy a T-shirt!🇵🇸💚

  • @OH-uo3nq
    @OH-uo3nq 22 години тому +6

    Save Gaza

  • @michaeltee4275
    @michaeltee4275 День тому +12

    Teach sister!

  • @jethrondhlovu
    @jethrondhlovu 12 годин тому +4

    More HORRIFIED, than disgusted. Disgust is a bodily or physical reaction. Horror is mental, spiritual, soul-based recoil.
    The world is HORRIFIED!

  • @Robert_Bob_Bobrob
    @Robert_Bob_Bobrob 23 години тому +10

    Free Palestine!

  • @rodcarlson9505
    @rodcarlson9505 18 годин тому +4

    Thank goodness there are people like you who inform the western world the truth about this genocide in Gaza, I have learned so much about Palestinians from these sites & the history of their suffering, I donate to Doctors Without Borders & hope they can return to Gaza without being killed in the future

  • @juanitadoe-b8i
    @juanitadoe-b8i 21 годину тому +7

    UK resistance , BDS movement , uni encampments,JC at every London protest elected as independent in 2024 not mild movement. Palestine Action Filton 18 in UK held without trial since last August for action against Elbit UK . We resist and stand in solidarity for as long as it takes. Free Palestine

  • @eman7079
    @eman7079 20 годин тому +5

    The best !!! Both !!

  • @MalcolmMacPhail-mt1gt
    @MalcolmMacPhail-mt1gt 7 годин тому +1

    My two favourite independent Journalists together.

  • @PSmith-f1u
    @PSmith-f1u 11 годин тому +2

    Respect for Ali Abunima and the EI team 🙏 top independent journalists and the EI keep our hopes going even in the darkest of times for the past 15 months. Ali Abunima answered Rania's question so precisely, truthfully and intelligently. It's so infuriating i know, and I'm noticing more independent journalists now crying out in frustration with the blame game. Why didn't and why can't these bigger countries do this , do that? Criticisms flying at Iran, Russia, China, even at Hezbollah. I used to be like that too last year until I educated myself more on our global geopolitics. Not every country support or try to stop something by bombing the daylights out of another, esp when it is not their country, and if their country' security is threatened. Like it or not, every country has to take care of its own people and borders first, as much as they may be aghast at the ongoing Genocide in Gaza. Only USA -West-Israel empire doesn't . They just bomb whomever they like, directly or using proxies. Every country has their own foreign policy as well. Rania, If you check out Ben Norton's coverage on geopolitics economy, Danny Haiphong's interviews with Pepe Escobar, The Cradle and Matt Kennard from the UK you will find it is fully shifting like you wouldn't believe. The multipolar world is fully happening, that's why the US and Israel continues to get increasingly brutal. Only a dying animal behaves like that, the imperial empire. The battle is from all fronts - geoeconomics, financial, shift in alliances - everything weakens the existing empire. Support doesn't have to come in the form of guns and bombs, otherwise we would all be totally nuclear annihilated by now. Definitely more to come, and how it will play, no one can predict, because the whole world are players on different fronts. Hope Gaza hangs on, and a ceasefire happens soon 🇵🇸✌️

  • @PrivateOrdover
    @PrivateOrdover День тому +2

    I am just a man. With one voice with little power, but my potential is off the charts..

  • @taranehahmadi-parker1412
    @taranehahmadi-parker1412 4 години тому +3

    Love EI and Rania

  • @MariamHussein-fb3eg
    @MariamHussein-fb3eg 13 годин тому +2

    Great show always wonderful and informative.

  • @queenofnothing78
    @queenofnothing78 14 годин тому +2

    Thks, Ali I agree 100%, Hi from South America

  • @evelyncraig7243
    @evelyncraig7243 20 годин тому +2

    And we the people also have to keep up our protests and BDS to get gaza free with its own sovereignty and rights .

  • @joanlong4183
    @joanlong4183 16 годин тому +4

    I cant imagine anyone having beach access like Gaza, wanting to give that up.

  • @taranehahmadi-parker1412
    @taranehahmadi-parker1412 4 години тому +1

    They stopped us having our beloveJeremy Corbyn

  • @EileenHildaWright
    @EileenHildaWright День тому +6

  • @cindyrolle6476
    @cindyrolle6476 17 годин тому +5

    My tears can’t stop flowing for the Palestinians. Israel must be stopped!

    • @bluestar6879
      @bluestar6879 12 годин тому

      Fakestinians never existed & never will !

  • @AmyBarker-Wilson
    @AmyBarker-Wilson 13 годин тому +2

    Excellent. The only part I questioned the role of Turkiye. I don’t agree about the part blaming Turkey. Turkish is instrumental in supporting and taking in Syrians and the group that finally overthrew Assad. It’s what the US wanted to do didn’t do. Turkiye has supported the starving people i Idlib all these years of being living in the edge.
    The US doesn’t like Turkiye taking a buffer zone of peace to keep the PKK out of invading Turkiye . The US and some Kurdish militants don’t like that because they are there for the oil only as their power position and connection with other points. Also the new government of Syria will need a strong supporter to make its democracy work - else you’ll see Israelis creating upheavals everywhere to create chaos and turn it into a fanatic regime so they fee justified to invade Syria as part of the end goal: Greater Israel.

  • @HTownCharlieBrown
    @HTownCharlieBrown 16 годин тому +3

    This "ceasefire" is just another bait and switch.

  • @RebeccaRBS
    @RebeccaRBS 10 годин тому +2

    thank you

  • @truthseeker-v6c
    @truthseeker-v6c 12 годин тому +2

    Free "palestine" from stupidity.

  • @jennygriffyn1897
    @jennygriffyn1897 12 годин тому +2

    Mine is a somewhat unpopular theory because we all like to hold on to our sense of reality and our personal comforts, privileges, power, status etc but its based on connecting the dots from various disciplines.
    The common denominator is capitalism. Not that I dislike money or have an issue with making profit from skills, trade & commerce, far from it. However, that existed long before the concept of capitalism was thought up by British aristocrats to avoid the guillotine, protect their wealth & privilege & to retain their ‘power over’ the public
    Note the rather grandiose us & them split thinking and consider the subculture that they were born into. It wouldn't have been difficult to sell this narrative to the up and coming merchant class and even the unionised working public because at that stage they were colonising other parts of the world and they needed their labour.
    Capitalism has had to be reiterated upon a few times but at its core is the underdeveloped aspect of a healthy persons humanity.
    This thinking, ideology has been around for so long and have informed western "culture" for so long that it's almost considered a natural law by some. In fact, it's a manufactured "culture", a set of ideas and values that because it is perceived as a culture end up shaping our behaviour.
    For millennia we survived the savanna as prey because we learned to cooperate, rely on & trust each other to put the wellbeing of the collective first. Survival skills & customs were passed down by trusted elder who cared for future generations. Traditional cultures which values & principles were tried and tested over time. We evolved to become Homo Sapiens: The Wise Human
    As story based sentient beings we can be controlled and divided by both weapons and narratives, something that people with damaged and or underdeveloped humanity are willing to exploit
    Surely, we have a critical mass by now, that has evolved enough to understand that unless we prioritise humanitarian values before the value of the capital market, humanity will not survive, that instead we will keep marching towards extinction by either climate catastrophe or nuclear war pockets full of money. In the mean time our mental health is deteriorating at increasing speed.
    Wherever you look, what stands between us and humanity (peace and prosperity for all) is money & unenlightened people who think themselves (& or the tribe they identify themselves with) more valuable than others.
    But we are generations into this debacle so few can see outside the box, we're stuck in an ideological Plato's cave. A lord of the flies society that has now become so precarious even for the privileged middle class that they're becoming reactive.
    Wired as prey and living in a predatory culture in which human trust is slowly but surely is being eroded is leading to regression because we end up reacting from our limbic system instead of operating from our prefrontal cortex.

  • @ShanKing-t8v
    @ShanKing-t8v День тому +6

    I can hear you.

  • @sarashepard7504
    @sarashepard7504 19 годин тому +5

    Free Palestine forever and may they prosper and thrive for all eternity. Reparations and rebuild of all their land needs to be done.

  • @rozalialuks6583
    @rozalialuks6583 19 годин тому +3

    Excelent!
    #LONGLIVERESISTANCE

  • @PrivateOrdover
    @PrivateOrdover День тому +3

    If 41:50 they won’t allow Serra to.become any political power then the sure as hell won’t let Palestine..

    • @Ron841000
      @Ron841000 День тому

      Rania has a major Blind spot as a "closet" Trump supporter. The FOFO phase for he Michigan Arab Muslim community, who supported Fascist Racist White Nationalist Trump, is about to occur.
      The continue death, destruction, and Genocide, may have Rania having second thoughts about her White Racist hero Trump.

  • @Shadow_Archivist_Forever
    @Shadow_Archivist_Forever День тому +2

    🌐 The United Nations (UN) 🌐
    Organized into 6 Principal Organs
    1. The General Assembly (GA)
    2. The Security Council (SC)
    3. The Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC)
    4. The Trusteeship Council
    5. The International Court of Justice (ICJ)
    6. UN Secretariat

  • @cyberseklep1
    @cyberseklep1 8 годин тому +1

    From the occupied territories of the Secwepemc Nation, south central British Columbia clanada...
    What effect does a permanent ceasefire deal have on the South African ICC court proceedings against the blue star?

  • @KimberlyJones-bf5wd
    @KimberlyJones-bf5wd 23 години тому +2

    1:12:20 I think the world deserves to vote on this since we inhabit it. Why can’t we vote? 😤

  • @am9116
    @am9116 22 години тому +3

    Doesn't anyone remember that Trump and Netanyahu had it pre-planned to accept ceasefire when he was coming into office

  • @charlesewillmore5252
    @charlesewillmore5252 13 годин тому +1

    9:39 😂agricltral advanced vocabiolzrtt❤😅😅

  • @suhaillegend9081
    @suhaillegend9081 День тому +7

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @PSmith-f1u
    @PSmith-f1u 20 годин тому +2

    I think Trump wants to wrap things up and focus on the bigger players eg Iran, Russia and China. Gaza has been through more than enough! please let there be a permanent ceasefire, then end of occupation 🙏🇵🇸✌️

  • @maryannechilds6459
    @maryannechilds6459 16 годин тому +2

    Thanks ali the resistance has done an awesome job . Perhaps trumps as sick of bibi as the rest of us r ?

  • @supralapsarian-cb9ig
    @supralapsarian-cb9ig 19 годин тому +1

    Ceasefire will not last,🤠

  • @zebedasharif
    @zebedasharif День тому +3

    Yes

  • @juanitadoe-b8i
    @juanitadoe-b8i 22 години тому +2

    jumping ship hold them accountable. anti zionist movement keep up resistance Free Palestine

  • @brucebruchelle3980
    @brucebruchelle3980 18 годин тому +2

    Israel doesn’t do ceasefires

  • @mothompson3437
    @mothompson3437 День тому +2

    Regarding who steps up to support Gaza..i think it relates to having been OPPRESSED by a powerful neighbour eg Ireland and or having been colonized brutality eg local people In america etc

  • @jennyrokeach1958
    @jennyrokeach1958 23 години тому +1

    Hello Rania and Ali❤

  • @DanaDoe
    @DanaDoe 21 годину тому +2

    Raytheon in US cities.

  • @farsheedyas697
    @farsheedyas697 16 годин тому +1

    The difference between Biden or Trump is insignificant. Same shit but different smell 😂.
    Long live the axises of residence ❤️ from 🇮🇷

  • @abrambadal8997
    @abrambadal8997 13 годин тому +1

    In order to STOP Palestinian Genocide , respecting International Law & respecting UN Charter , we need to see this : Each Government taking these position and '' two state solution '' should give up some 5, to 10 to 20 Km2 of their own territory , given up to Palestinian joint leadership, with lending it freely with contract , in order for Palestinian people to use that parcel in all those countries as their own and under protectorate of those states , to be run temporarily as their State of Palestine , and those state take part actively in Liberation of Palestine completely with borders drawn by UN in 1967 , before the conflict ! This act of joining actively with Palestinian people , as official member of UN , until Palestinian State becomes fully a material reality , those states will actively put all kinds of pressure on Israel until UN Charter is fully respected , and under conditions that Veto powers are temporarily NUL and None Existent until and for Solving The Genocide Question to the completely satisfaction of all parties and G.A. resolutions since 1948 ! NO VETO Powers against Palestine's vote could be used until stopping all risks of Genocide ; If not blabla bla bla bla is just a wind to say '' I support Palestinians to oppose Genocidal Israel '' , with no action taken materially behind is an indirect helping and complicity with the Genocide crime !