How To Know If It's Aliens
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 тра 2021
- Sign Up on Patreon to get access to the Space Time Discord!
/ pbsspacetime
There’s one rule on Space Time: It’s never Aliens. But every rule has an exception and this rule is no exception because: It’s never aliens, until it is. So is it aliens yet? And on today’s Space Time we’re going to examine all the best case scenarios for life beyond Earth.
If you want more alien content, check out the ALIENS! Playlist
• Aliens!
Check out the Space Time Merch Store
www.pbsspacetime.com/shop
Sign up for the mailing list to get episode notifications and hear special announcements!
mailchi.mp/1a6eb8f2717d/space...
Hosted by Matt O'Dowd
Written by Matt Caplan & Matt O'Dowd
Graphics by Leonardo Scholzer, Yago Ballarini, Pedro Osinski, Adriano Leal & Stephanie Faria
GFX Visualizations: Katherine Kornei
Directed by Andrew Kornhaber
Assistant Producer: Setare Gholipour
Executive Producers: Eric Brown & Andrew Kornhaber
End Credits Music by J.R.S. Schattenberg: / @jrsschattenberg
Special Thanks to Our Patreon Supporters
Big Bang Supporters
Leo Koguan
Matthew Miller
Scott Gray
Ahmad Jodeh
Radu Negulescu
Alexander Tamas
Morgan Hough
Juan Benet
Vinnie Falco
Fabrice Eap
Mark Rosenthal
David Nicklas
Quasar Supporters
Stephen Wilcox
Christina Oegren
Mark Heising
Hank S
Hypernova
william bryan
Marc Armstrong
Scott Gorlick
Nick Berard
Paul Stehr-Green
MuOn Marketing
Russell Pope
Ben Delo
L. Wayne Ausbrooks
Nicholas Newlin
Adrian Posor
Антон Кочков
John R. Slavik
Mathew
Danton Spivey
Donal Botkin
John Pollock
Edmund Fokschaner
Joseph Salomone
Matthew O'Connor
chuck zegar
Jordan Young
m0nk
Julien Dubois
John Hofmann
Daniel Muzquiz
Timothy McCulloch
Gamma Ray Burst
Scott R Calkins
Carl Scaggs
Joshua Helms
G Mack
The Mad Mechanic
Ellis Hall
John H. Austin, Jr.
Ben Campbell
Lawrence Tholl, DVM
Faraz Khan
Almog Cohen
Alex Edwards
Nick
Ádám Kettinger
Sylvain Leduc
MD3
Endre Pech
Daniel Jennings
Cameron Sampson
Pratik Mukherjee
Geoffrey Clarion
Nate
Darren Duncan
Russ Creech
Jeremy Reed
Derek Davis
Eric Webster
Steven Sartore
David Johnston
J. King
Michael Barton
Christopher Barron
James Ramsey
Drew Hart
Justin Jermyn
Mr T
Andrew Mann
Jeremiah Johnson
fieldsa eleanory
Peter Mertz
Kevin O'Connell
Isaac Suttell
Devon Rosenthal
Oliver Flanagan
Dawn M Fink
Bleys Goodson
Darryl J Lyle
Robert Walter
Bruce B
Ismael Montecel
Simon Oliphant
Mirik Gogri
Mark Daniel Cohen
Brandon Lattin
Nickolas Andrew Freeman
Shane Calimlim
Tybie Fitzhugh
Robert Ilardi
Astaurus
Eric Kiebler
Craig Stonaha
Martin Skans
Michael Conroy
Graydon Goss
Frederic Simon
Tonyface
John Robinson
A G
Kevin Lee
Adrian Hatch
Yurii Konovaliuk
John Funai
Cass Costello
Tristan Deloche
Bradley Jenkins
Kyle Hofer
Daniel Stříbrný
Luaan
AlecZero
Vlad Shipulin
Cody
Malte Ubl
King Zeckendorff
Nick Virtue
Scott Gossett
Dan Warren
Patrick Sutton
John Griffith
Daniel Lyons
DFaulk
GrowingViolet
Kevin Warne
Andreas Nautsch
Brandon labonte
8:38 I know that guy!
He seems like a wonderful person
I am really happy they gave you a shoutout Anton.
You’re the best Anton!
😀
Top 10 anime crossovers.
“The first principle is that you must not fool yourself - and you are the easiest person to fool.” Richard Feynman
This is why i could never be a scientist. Im way too excitable/biased. Every new discovery would just be me going "Aw its DEFINITELY aliens THIS time guys!"
Unfortunately everyone thinks this applies to everyone but themselves
@@dessertstorm7476 Clearly not everyone thinks that.
@@brettvv7475 clearly
@tommy poop ...
wut?
“Your idea is so good that some very smart people have already thought of it” one of the greatest compliments ever
I love hearing that Anton is being mentioned by PBS Space Time! He is most definitely my favorite science creator and he gets way too little recognition for how much work he does
He’s made the big leagues
Mother EARTH is not a spaceship, she is a TIMESHIP!
they its def not aliens then link a video and saw that kinda makes snse but also isnt 100% but its def not aliens cause we dont understand stuff but its def not aliens we understand enough to say it isnt aliens we cant say why we know that but its def not
@@sergioindigo6072 huh? 👀.... Hmmmm
Anton Petrov is the always anti-alien guy LMAO. He explains that aliens are not real but he can’t even prove scientifically how aliens can’t be real. He always use human knowledge on physics and chemistry but alien technology is far much more superior than us LMAO
It’s awesome that Matt gives wonderful person Anton Petrov a shout out...what’s equally or more awesome is how many people in the comments know who he is and are all happy he got the call out from a bigger channel.
Matt, Anton and all the rest here are truly wonderful people!
"HELLO WONDERFUL PERSON 👋!" I love it.....
It’s almost like we are a community! Double awesome.
The dude is a wonderful person...
Ah Anton Petrov...stumbled across his content one late night recently & gave a thumbs up & a well deserved sub. Salute. Thanks again too Matt
Well if its a duck or an commercial airplane THATS ALIEN SPACESHIP! according to the alien conspiracy nutters! Who clearly dont understand physics or even logic!
Once you eliminate the impossible, you are left with all the things you didn't think about.
Uh. You mean the possible? There are infinite possible worlds.
@@ignotumperignotius630 the infinite possibilities aren’t unbounded though, we don’t live in rick and morty
im stealing this quote, thx:)
There's a t-shirt here. :)
That's poetic. Worth being a movie line.
"Is it aliens yet?" No
"Is it aliens yet?" No
"Is it aliens yet?" Look, if you keep asking I'm going to turn this universe around!
"And it'll be NO Ancient Astronauts for a week!"
Dbz Abridged Napa: hey vegeta, Is it aliens yet?
Sounds like Nappa from TFS Dragon Ball!! .... Woah and even Nappa was technically an alien!! Lol! 😅🤷🏻♂️
HAHA.
Yes!
"When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, is all the things you didn't think about."
- youtube-comment that I read somewhere else at some point in spacetime
Yep
Genius.
excellent, I love it, thank you for sharing
I can't help but think about my religious pastor parents whenever I hear this "argument"...
That’s a Sherlock Holmes quote. It’s also not good reasoning when dealing with astrophysics.
Edit: never mind I misread the quote, it’s an adaptation of a Holmes quote. And it’s not bad reasoning, just circular.
You know you succeeded in life when pbs cites you. Congratulations to Anton
I was about to say the same thing on one of his videos
Sike
Nice shout out for The Wonderful Person, Anton Petrov. He will be so excited!
I haven't checked his videos out but they are recommend to me. Are they worth watching?
@@bane4743 very much. Clear explanations and breakdowns. Not sensational, but always interesting and based on recent research. Also admits when he makes mistakes.
He uploads daily too
@@MapleYum thanks for the reply I'll have to check him out later tonight.
Yeah, SpaceTime is always very careful about what they reference, as they have quite the reputation. It's been a while since they've shouted out a UA-camr, so I'm pretty satisfied with Anton being shouted out, I've been watching him for longer than I've been watching SpaceTime.
That should be the next t-shirt: "Is it aliens yet?"
I feel like I speak for most people when I say I want it to be aliens, but only if it's actually aliens. Great video, guys
Yep
Thanks for mentioning Mr Petrov and his channel. He totally deserves the recognition. And it makes you a wonderful person too :)
How am I not seeing this mention? Could I trouble you for a time stamp good sir.
@@ryanjude1290 sure, no problem! here you are:
ua-cam.com/video/3sq658Okvao/v-deo.html
@@ryanjude1290 around 830
He's such a great science educator. He doesn't have the flashy graphics of PBS Spacetime or Kurzgeasdubguagaht, but he puts out videos way more often which is impressive in its own right. Although Spacetime does deeper dives so they're both great in different ways. Spacetime and Anton are the top 2 science channels imho.
Or according to youtube auto subtitle : "wall of a person" 😄
I Love Antón Petrov!
He’s a wonderful person!
That's so cool that PBS shouted him out! Great channel!
Anton is a wonderful person
Yea he is!
He tells me that i am wonderful too
Dr. Becky gave him a shout-out recently as well. He's getting to be a very popular wonderful person.
Once you've ruled out the impossible, what ever remains could be something unknown to you or a great many things that are known to you. Therefor, ruling out the impossible is a single step, not a deciding factor.
So, what have they ruled out ?
@@MrSummitville I'm commenting on a line used in the video, not necessarily stating that I know what has or has not been ruled out.
I'm an optimistic skeptic. I do believe we are not alone in the universe. Unfortunately, I don't think we will ever find out in the time we have left as a species. But I would like UAP's to be concretely explained to not be aliens before I give up. And loved the shoutout to Anton. He's the man.
I also believe that humans will never meet these aliens.
Our genetically modified cyborgs and AIs probably will though.
Event Hoizon Sometimes taking a look at the sky and moon for yourself, can reveal more than what the powers that be, or NASA will ever reveal. Do we have the technology to have over ten objects/UFOs at the same time to the right of the moon? or a spacecraft in the direction of the Hercules constellation? If not, who has?
@@GenUineUFOs6833yes, we have thousands of objects to the right of the moon at any given time, they're called "satellites".
A better question is, are you personally capable of distinguishing between natural phenomena, man made phenomena, hallucinations/tricks of the mind, and aliens?
The answer would seem to be no.
@@DBZHGWgamerPhotos / videos speak for themselves.
@@GenUineUFOs6833 Shakycam footage of a blurry dot doesn't speak to anything.
Aye the call out for Anton was great! Seems we have a lot of wonderful people here too!
Yeah Anton is such a wonderful person with a brilliant channel.
PBS working for the Men In Black
His videos are like precious candy i get almost every morning
Love his videos, but I don't understand the people he gets in his comments section. Seems like 1/3 of his viewer base are just people who watch the videos to feel smarter and pretend they learned something before spouting off some nonsense about aliens living among us or angels/demons.
@@ossiehalvorson7702 haha if the aliens saw what we put in youtube comments, then no wonder they are avoiding us like the plague
A shout out for Anton! I think that makes Matt a wonderful person 👍
Could you do an analysis of the flying objects disclosed by the Pentagon? Maybe you have an idea on how their physics could work and what they maybe are, if not aliens
Fuzzy Dots on a computer display? No, real images.
@@smokedmessias1607 Aliens? From where? How did they get to Earth without being seen or detected?
Thunderfoot has a UA-cam channel of the same name that debunks them all.
These guys are science communicators, not scientists. They have to wait for scientists to develop an hypothesis, before they have anything they can communicate to us about this.
Infrared blobs, no visual spectrum, appearing on the small territory of usa, which is notoriously famous for nuttjobs looking for bigfoots and alien abductions stories. Kek
I never feel more smart than when I understand and laugh at one of Matt's dry humor jokes.
Shout out to Anton Petrov, the hardest working man on the tube. Nice one Matt!
Also the sharpest jawline on UA-cam.
@Sean g 137 you realize this is like the worst place on the whole of the internet to try and sell your new age Woo trash right? Like the people who come here to watch these tend to at least have a highschool level understanding of physics, which is all it really takes to make you immune to that level of low effort bullshit.
Until Anton says it’s aliens, it’s not aliens
Is that the mukbang channel guy?.... lol JK
The amount of love for Anton in this entire comment section is wonderful.
Nice of you to give a shout-out to Anton Petrov! :)
He covers a wide range of space and science topics, and he's not afraid to admit if he makes a mistake. A truly wonderful person :P
Yeah I'm subscribed too him amazing down to earth guy! Its nice that Space time shouted him out!
@Sean g 137 You 100% sound like a kook.
We are certainly fortunate to have access to this level of knowledge.
Re: your point regarding likelihood of two tech civs being so close, and its implications.
Is it possible Proxima and the system came from the same nursery as the Sun? I don't know what their vector through the galaxy is relative to ours, but if they came from the same stellar nursery, one might see why there would be the same elements and time to evolve.
Just a thought
Petrov getting the shout-out is awesome! Dude puts in the work, great to see the recognition.
In the event that aliens do land on Earth, the planet will be gaining some extra terrestrials.
🥁
CAAAAAAARLOS! XD
Caaaaaarlos
Nice
Ahhhhhh snap!
Congratulations for another excellent video. Keep up the good work!
With every new episode, I like this channel more and more.
Thank you for being a wonderful person and giving some love to Anton Petrov.
what are you all, hired bots? Saying the exact same thing
@@AverageAlien you’ve obviously never watched Wonderful Person Anton Petrov. He’s wonderful. But seriously, he is.
@@AverageAlien Anton has an army of followers who all know the "wonderful person" reference.
A SHOUT OUT FOR ANTON? MY BOY!! he deserves it
I gotta say that, i love the last 3 or 4 minutes of this particular episode. Thanks for the brain candy.
Anton Petrov has a wonderful channel for this stuff, that was a great shoutout!
„Hello wonderful person, this is ... PBS Spacetime. ... ahh, what?!“ :D Love Anton! Awesome to see him mentioned here!
Thanks for being wonderful
Just started the vid and paused when I read your comment!
He mentions him?? Can't wait!
@@Mermaider Hope you enjoyed the video! That’s just the perfect combination. Anton and PBS. There is nothing better! :D
@@MauriceM.
Good episode indeed.
I'd add John Michael (event horizon) and Isaac Arthur to the mix.
@@Mermaider I never heard of any of them but I will make sure to check both of them out. It’s just wonderful seeing the community come together.
Anyway. Thank you for the suggestion :)
Holy cow, what a shout out for Anton! Such a wonderful person!
Love that guy
Hello wonderful person 👋
🤦♂️
Love Anton, made me so happy to see my favorite YT channel reference my other favorite YT channel :)
Look forward to hearing Matt’s take on next months report on UAPs
My silly hobby is to ask people
if they want some names of science-channel they may or may not know yet.
May I?
Wooo, Anton Petrov shout-out! I watch his videos every day.
Thanks for the direct to Anton, he is an absolutely amazing presenter and, on top of it, he is a wonderful person.
There is an interesting comment by Sean Carrol when asked about the chances of aliens in our galaxy. I don't remember it clearly but he said something like "no. And if you asked me 20 years ago, I would have said 'yes'".
He went on to explain why. I think it was when he appeared on the podcast the Infinite Monkey Cage.
Six minutes in and you’ve already ripped my heart out three times
This video is exactly what an alien would make if they wanted to throw us off the trail of the real aliens.
EDIT: Really enjoying the replies. Stay crazy, Internet.
Preach!
Amin
Too bad they don't! xD
I think they're waiting for us to settle off Earth
This video is exactly what a alien-nerd don't want to hear, since it puts his religion to a low level.
if there are aliens but they are only plants there is no way to find them without going to planets with FTL travel, so will probably never find them
Most ambitious cross over event ever, Anton and Matt
Both of them are wonderful people!
Nah, what about video-ception, each video is actually just a clip in someone else's video... You could link infinite YT channels together.
Hello wonderful Matt, this is person
I would love it!
Should do a crossover with Physics Girl. She just left PBS and her channel is now unsponsored. That's a tough transition. Would be good to have her back.
16:29 Great, the device for interstellar travel also serves as a doomsday weapon.
Loving the Anton Petrov shout out! That wonderful person makes wonderful content.
Shoutout to Anton, a wonderful person.
Whoaa, PBS shouted out Anton! That's cool!
I think I speak for everyone who read "Rendezvous With Rama" when I say I was really excited about 'Omuamua and even thought I know intellectually it was very probably not aliens, I'm really disappointed we didn't get to see more of it to find out for sure before it left our solar system.
In appearance, it reminded me more of the Whale Probe from "Star Trek IV." But its appearance was quite suggestive, all the same.
Him Paul, yes, I immediatley thought of Arthur C Clarke's classic! It sounded like a perfect description of an alien sublight starship/probe...
LOVE the shout out to Anton! He has a spectacular channel
Antrov is a legend.
Sorry checkmarks dont work here. ^-^
Yeah, I love Antop's videos
DO NOT TRUST PBCPPS - THEY ARE LEFTIST COMMIE SATANISTS! False flag incoming to distract the sHEEPLE! Look up hologram tech and the craft we already have that are not gravitationaly challenged.
@habanerat sus...
@@habanerat You ok hun? X
It feels like someone is fixing the bugs as soon as we discover them. 😂
Darn universe doesn't pay a bug bounty though. :(
I know of one alien,Elon Musk
The Matrix is onto us.
Always interesting, thank you.
No other mission tried an improved labeled release experiment either. It is interesting listening to interviews with the scientists who were responsible for these experiments.
I’m glad Anton got a shoutout I feel like there are a lot of people who might need his incredible positivity, and his content is just as addicting
DO NOT TRUST PBCPPS - THEY ARE LEFTIST COMMIE SATANISTS! False flag incoming to distract the sHEEPLE! Look up hologram tech and the craft we already have that are not gravitationaly challenged.
F Anton's positivity when he can't say a sentence without a major bs!
I've known what dark matter really is for years. I just don't want to show anybody up, so I'm keeping it to myself until after the discovery so I can tell people in the comments of a UA-cam video on the subject. Then they'll know just how smart I am.
XD
I just hope it's not cockroaches. Imagine if 80% of the universe was cockroaches..
@@johnflux1 no the dark matter is carlos
@@johnflux1 its vampires, telescopes use mirrors, thats why we can't see them.
What is it?
Damn the sneak disses at Avi Loeb are pretty funny
So glad Anton got a shout out! I'm a year late to this one but I love it!
Thanks Matt for giving a nod to Anton Petrov. He Rocks!
“Sherlock Holmes observed that once you have eliminated the impossible then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the answer. I, however, do not like to eliminate the impossible.” - Dirk Gently
Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character created by Arthur Conan Doyle shouldn't he get the credit for being the genius to make his character say such a quote ?
Also that logic used by holmes is completely fallacious
@@spaceisalie5451 how it's fallacious?
@@aaronequinoa77 "Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character created by Arthur Conan Doyle shouldn't he get the credit for being the genius to make his character say such a quote ? - Aaron Equinoa" -Baychimo
"An ancestor of mine maintained that if you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains - however improbable - must be the truth." -Spock, descendant of Holmes.
16:20 "... beam of energy, powerful enough to destroy a planet - so yeah, don't pull up right in front of your destination, THAT'S RUDE." I laughed so hard 🤣
Yay Alma mentioned, great lot over there - pleasure to work with
That sounds exactly like something an alien would say.... 🤔
* Searches Matt's face for telltale zipper seams *
😜🤪, silly, they use invisible zippers...
Why do you think he has a beard
Hmm, that chiseled jaw is certainly suspect
Guys guys, chill. The zipper is at the back, we can't see it from this angle. ✂️📎🧷🤐👽
of course there is no zipper that is absurd. aliens would use velcro. where do you think velcro came from?
When the Impossible has been eliminated, and you have nothing left; There is no choice, but to rethink what is in fact possible.
@The Guy You Knew As Mark Omega well that’s kinda boring
@The Guy You Knew As Mark Omega If they only possible answer is the impossible, we should relook at why we threw out the possible. Our understanding of the universe isn't the ultimate truth, and we shouldn't always be insisting our assumptions are correct.
18:00 I was thinking dark matter could be high spin, massive bosonic matter. Hence, it would be hard to detect. I was very happy to see some people had written some papers about it.
Why would high-spin, massive bosons be harder to detect?
@@bigsmall246 It's been my experience that massive bosoms are almost always EASIER to detect. Spinning ones? Probably even more so.
thanks a bunch for putting the old close out theme.it is apart of the channel
Love the Anton shoutout where my wonderful people at?
Both Issac Arthur and Now Anton Petrov have gotten shoutouts on pbs spacetime. Perfection.
Because Matt is a wonderful person.
Which episode was Issac shouted out in?
@@alvinnobody788 I'll be honest I put playlists on and listen to them while I'm going to bed.. but just like this video I shot up like "YEAH!" As soon as I heard the name mentioned... I went back through my history but I cant seem to find the video just check the ones with Issac type of content. Wish I could have came across which one to link it for you ♡
That's awesome!
I just discovered Anton Petrov’s channel last month. Great channel.
Really enjoyed that and allmost understood some of it lol:)
Anton , Sabine and yuo are really great channels , very good work 😊
Nice shoutout Antón Petrov!
He's a wonderful person!
are you by any chance a vinesauce enjoyer
"Once you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains is still less likely than an error in your impossibility proof"
I guess it depends on what you're trying to proof. If it's very unlikely, then yes
@@martiddy Arthur C Clark may have put it better, "When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong"
Once you eliminate the impossible, you are left with all the things you didn't think about.
The logical part of me understands these new discoveries are because of advancements in technology.
But seeing all of them debunked at once makes the imaginative part of me go "Yeah...right... sure totally not aliens, just a weather balloon right?".
Nice video top marks great stuff
Very happy to see Anton being mentioned here. Following both these channels for quite some time now.
I need a tee-shirt with Matt's face and the quote "It's not aliens until it is"
Matt’s face on a Wonderful Person t-shirt!
Or "Nothing in physics is alien to us!"
Meanwhile Michael from Vsauce, "Or is it?"
I would buy that shirt :)
And on the back needs to be the dude from ancient aliens going "Aliens!"
OMG ANTON PETROV IS SO GOOD! Thank you for shouting him out
I love that wonderful persons videos. Good to see Anton get mentioned.
I'm so happy for Anton to get this shout out. Had to immediately pause the video to check out all the comments! What a wonderful person.
When it comes to quotes about aliens, I subscribe to Bill Watterson: "Sometimes I think the surest sign that intelligent life exists elsewhere in the universe is that none of it has tried to contact us."
It can only be, microbial alien life
Besides, to the highly advanced 👽 👽 👽 👽 ALIENS, we are like ANTS, comparable to.
The main reasons for, no contacts with us.
Wow, PBS linking to Anton Petrov? You people are awesome!
Haha glad to see Leo is supporting the channel!
Yes Yes Yes. My Mind has been longing for such a subject by PBS.
And they've covered it many times...
Shout out to wonderful persons everywhere!
Thank you for the video 👽
As much as i love imagining alien life, i favor truth more. whats true outweighs my wishes.
They shouted out UA-cam's most Wonderful Person: Anton Petrov!
I think one possible future hurdle in identifying life is defining what is alive. We still don’t have consensus on whether a virus is alive or not. What if we discover something that behaves life like but somehow isn’t at the same time?
A great point, and one that astronomers actively pursue.
"It's never aliens until it is..." Soon I hope!
gonna be a truly enlightening decade
That shout out to Anton's channel! Wonderful person indeed
Whoo hoo! Anton shoutout. You're a true Man of Culture, Matt.
5:07 Even if the red lines on Europa are rust, I thought that was still a pretty good indicator of sub-surface life considering it indicates the presence of O2 in the water which is typically created by cyanobacteria (at least on earth).
Mars is also red due to iron oxide. It may indicate that all the free oxygen once present in Europa is already bound and used up, and natural processes are somehow pushing the ancient iron oxide onto the surface.
"at least on earth" is the problem, though. We've got a pretty specific and therefore limited sandbox on our planet - there could be millions of life-free ways to induce O2 in water, we just haven't observed them, because those circumstances can't occur in our specific sandbox.
excellent video including the quote from shakespeare
Whoaaaa
YES ANTON!!! my two fav youtube channels 😭
Snarky Matt is the best Matt! :)))
Important to practice this thought process
Oumuamua was clearly a silicon based space whale, nobody can convince me otherwise
Early comments are always the best
That actually sounds awesome 😎 🪐🐋
Yay! Anton's channel get's a shout out from Eons! He works really hard putting out a quality video every day.
I love when my favorite UA-camrs name drop each other
Thank you! I remember reading about the meteorite story when I was little. I was so excited! Then, I became annoyed when I didn't hear anything else about it. I've been wondering what happened since that discovery and why no one spoke about it since then. Thank you very much for talking about that story.